points by sanity 1 year ago

I'm sorry to hear that you feel this way, but I need to correct some inaccuracies in your comment.

The decision to rebrand Locutus as Freenet 2023 was not made lightly or without discussion. On the contrary, I had an extensive discussion with the lead maintainer of the original codebase starting over a year before the decision was announced.

The primary reason for the redesign was to address the significant changes in technology and the web since the original Freenet was first designed in 1999 and underwent its last major redesign in 2005. These different eras brought different technologies and problems. To effectively address today's challenges, a comprehensive redesign was necessary.

As the architect of Freenet, it was my responsibility to make this decision based on what would lead to the best end result, even if it wasn't the most popular choice. The goal was to create software that could gain sufficient adoption to tackle the serious problems we're seeing with centralization today.

I understand that this decision was controversial and not everyone agreed with it. However, it was made to ensure that Freenet could continue to innovate and adapt in the face of modern challenges. Mistakes can happen, but in this case, the decision was made with careful consideration and a focus on the long-term goals of the project. I stand by my decision.

I appreciate the contributions of all volunteers and maintainers, and I deeply respect their work. The goal was never to overshadow their efforts but to build on the legacy of Freenet in a way that meets current and future needs.

I hope this clarifies the situation and provides some context for the decision.

ArneBab 1 year ago

And from the start the maintainer objected strongly to your idea.

As did the whole core development team once this was announced. And most users.

I warned you that this would cause massive problems.

And I am still cleaning up the mess it created.

  • sanity 1 year ago

    Yes, I didn't expect you to change your mind, and I haven't changed mine either.