points by jvandonsel 21 hours ago

Despite reading the entire series twice, I never understood the porcupine line. Can someone ELI5?

tclancy 20 hours ago

It’s Jack talking through his hat again. I think he’s trying to determine if a woman is married or not and when it turns out they having a roving eye, he conflates “porcupine” (no idea what a porcupine-lay might be) with “concubine”.

  • BLKNSLVR 17 hours ago

    I think "lay" might be as literal as we would use it now.

    • js2 16 hours ago

      It's probably slang for "line of work: occupation":

      https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/lay

      See 3b under its noun definition.

      So: “Why, sir, in a manner of speaking: but some might say more on the porcupine-lay, the roving-line, if you understand me.”

      Translates to: “Why, sir, in a manner of speaking: but some might say more on the concubine-occupation, the roving-line [of work], if you understand me.”

      Then Jack, not wanting to embarrass Heaven for his malapropism, intentionaly reuses "porcupine" incorrectly.