lucaslazarus 1 month ago

I don’t entirely understand the war-gaming aspect here. Is this just Model UN for adults?

  • NDlurker 1 month ago

    Yeah like d&d, I think

beloch 1 month ago

"Simulations like this one are not supposed to predict the future. The outcomes depend on the design of the game and the relative personalities and experience of the players. Many of those in the room lacked first-hand diplomatic and national security experience. The UN forum, which organizers selected as the game’s setting, may also not be as effective as talks between smaller groups of major countries."

------------

This paragraph deserves emphasis to balance out the doomer linkbait headline.

The players of this game largely ignored scientific opinions and played politics like it was a fun board-game. Presumably, they did have fun. Notably missing from this wargame was the kind of pressure that real leaders and diplomats would face to swallow their pride, eschew fun, understand the science, and get the solution right. It's just our planet and civilization on the line, right?

It would be deeply foolish to use this wargame to discount or disparage the UN. Under more realistic conditions they could get it right, and they might be our best hope for preventing one or a small number of governments from acting unilaterally and getting it tragically wrong.

  • oefrha 1 month ago

    I don’t take these war games seriously myself, but have you been living under a rock? This U.S. administration and many an ally they’re trying to install elsewhere are in open denial about climate change. Pretending that scientific opinions aren’t often ignored in the real world especially when there’s both strategic interests and powerful industry groups meddling in it is patently absurd. Not to mention the “science” is heavily influenced by politics and industry money to begin with. The NGO secretly owned by fossil fuel lobby funding the scientist is a nice touch in this one.

Liftyee 1 month ago

What other options are on the table if we REALLY want to limit warming below the 2 deg C target? It's already 1.5+, and control systems theory says that the inertia of various mechanisms (ocean warming, ice/permafrost melt, ...) will cause a lag between the emissions being produced and the actual warming happening. So even if we immediately switch off all human sources NOW, everything that's already in the air will stay there, and the temperature will keep increasing for some time. Under the assumption that the "residual warming" will overshoot 2 C, aerosols are the only industrially feasible way I know of. Mass production of engineered particles certainly sounds more reasonable than mass producing carbon capture machines in the volumes required.

Of course, we are too busy arguing about how important it is to fully commit to any path.

dustractor 1 month ago

There was an old lady who swallowed a fly. I don't know why she swallowed the fly. I guess she'll die.

AuthAuth 1 month ago

Those dam solar panels are sucking up all the sun rays and theres gonna be none left for YOU - Oil and Gas company

ErroneousBosh 1 month ago

The past couple of years the Sun has been low-single-digit-percent amounts brighter because it's the first actual solar maximum that's done anything for 40 years.

It's been heatwaves and droughts and stuff unlike anything we've seen since I was in primary school.

So yeah any attempt by us to dick about with the Sun's output is going to be utterly catastrophic, because it's not going to be even as small as a 3% increase or decrease.

  • rootusrootus 1 month ago

    > The past couple of years the Sun has been low-single-digit-percent amounts brighter

    Say what? Isn't that off by 1 or 2 orders of magnitude? [0] 1% would be enormous.

    [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Solar_irradiance

    • ErroneousBosh 1 month ago

      It might well be. Tiny tiny amount, either way.

      And yet, with similar numbers of sunspots, the weather is identical to the early 80s which was the last time the Sun did anything.

      Radio propagation right now is absolutely mental, which is directly correlated.

      • rootusrootus 1 month ago

        > the last time the Sun did anything

        What about cycle 22 or 23?

  • AnimalMuppet 1 month ago

    I think you're overly worried.

    Almost any attempt to change the sun's output is going to have a 0.000% change. It is very much not easy to affect something that size.

    • mattkrause 1 month ago

      You don’t actually have to change the sun, “just” the earth’s atmosphere (or surface or anything in between).

    • eqvinox 1 month ago

      It would help if you (and the GP) actually read the article

      > These technologies promise to reverse global warming by reflecting away a portion of the sunlight reaching Earth, for example by spraying particles of sulphur dioxide or some other manufactured substance into the atmosphere.

      The global maritime shipping industry has already been doing this, by accident, and their stopping (going to better fuel oil with less sulfur in it) has detectably raised global temperatures. [https://cpo.noaa.gov/the-unintended-consequences-of-reducing...]

      • AnimalMuppet 1 month ago

        Well, first, I can't read the article.

        But, second, yes, I know what they're talking about. I also know about the shipping thing. So (honest question), while that was happening, did it reduce the sun's radiation to the ground by 1%? 0.1? 0.01?

        But it was enough to make a measurable difference in temperature. To make a meaningful difference in temperature is going to take, say, 10 times as much sulphur as the ships were putting out, or else putting it at more strategic layers of the atmosphere. So "most attempts" (most people who say "let's do this") aren't going to get anything like the scale that is needed.

  • jxcole 1 month ago

    It's probably caused more by anthropogenic climate change than sun luminosity.

  • OgsyedIE 1 month ago

    Wouldn't this be attributable to the change in international agreements about bunker fuel composition to have massively less sulfur?