by Kwpolska 2 days ago

Where's the good faith in demanding a non-profit buys a $10k+ HSM just to get a gold star from an OpenAI employee?

woodruffw 2 days ago

I don't think we require a Trusted Publishing provider to use a physical HSM. As I've said in other venues, even a self-hosted Vault instance would almost certainly be fine. But storing private keys on disk is not, and we owe PyPI's users a higher standard of care than saying otherwise.

(I also don't hand out gold stars, and my employer does not direct my work on PyPI.)

  • zmgsabst 1 day ago

    Your posts about how you’re restricting people for their own good make a lot more sense knowing you’re funded by OpenAI.

    I think you should be more upfront about that funding — because while you may not perceive yourself as biased by that, others do.

    • woodruffw 1 day ago

      My employer is a matter of public record, as is the fact that I’ve worked in PyPI for years on both my own time and at other jobs. You’re letting the tail wag the dog.

      (Note also that none of the work being talked about right now was paid for by my current employer. I wasn’t even involved in it. I’m only familiar with it circa 2022-24, when I had a different employer.)

ghosty141 2 days ago

A yubikey is cheap and is good enough for that... No 10k jam necessary