Zigurd 1 day ago

I've been a frequent critic of starship. But the significance of this milestone is clear: it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.

Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive. It required a lot of expensive refurbishment between missions. Launch cadence had a fairly low upper bound. And it wasn't safe enough.

The true believers will claim that catching a starship upper stage marks a new era. It marks the possibility of a new era. It proves it is plausible that a vertical landing upper stage could possibly be a better approach than a space plane. But it hasn't proven any of that. There are about a dozen major milestones between here and actually having a rocket system that meets all of its claimed specifications, both technical and financial. Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

In my estimation, it will take at least another five years to know what starship really can do and what it will cost.

  • pfdietz 1 day ago

    > it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle.

    And even Space Shuttle wasn't a demonstration of that, since the propellant tankage (the largest volume of any stage) wasn't reusable.

    SpaceX has pretty conclusively shown the Shuttle architecture (stage and a half, using LH2 at launch) was not the right choice.

    • DennisP 1 day ago

      And the Shuttle's escape system wasn't for use during launch. It was only usable in controlled flight, if they couldn't reach a runway. It was added after Challenger.

    • bumby 1 day ago

      Yes, but broadly speaking that has been known pre-SpaceX. The DC-X was the first proof of concept, and SpaceX's wonderful engineering is another evolutionary step in that direction. In Musk's words, SpaceX is "Just continuing the great work of the DC-X program"

      [1] https://www.space.com/22432-reusable-dc-x-rocket-space-hall-...

    • hvb2 1 day ago

      > SpaceX has pretty conclusively shown the Shuttle architecture (stage and a half, using LH2 at launch) was not the right choice.

      The space shuttle was retired for a reason? This was already known. The only thing it shows is that with that knowledge, you can design something better. Hindsight 20/20 etc

      • pfdietz 1 day ago

        It was well known even before Shuttle's retirement that expendable launchers would have been cheaper. The alternative avenue of cost minimizing expendables dates back at least to the 1960s, from a guy named Arthur Schnitt. Expendable Falcon 9 can be considered a later day embodiment of those ideas.

    • dreamcompiler 1 day ago

      NASA knew the shuttle was not the right technical choice before it ever flew. But it was the only political choice they could get funded at the time.

  • locknitpicker 1 day ago

    > Part of the importance is due to the fact that while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive.

    This is a complete apples to oranges comparison.

    A more apt comparison would be the space shuttle being a kin to Vasco da Gama's discovery of the sea route to India. After that point, the concept was demonstrated and the challenge was in optimizing cost-savings of commercial endeavours.

    I mean, orbital lift services have been a thing for how many decades?

  • bumby 1 day ago

    >And it wasn't safe enough.

    How are you measuring "safe enough" in this context? My understanding is that the Shuttle didn't have programmatic probabilistic requirements for mission safety. Ie, they didn't use overall reliability estimates and instead relied on engineering judgement (which the Challenger report showed varied widely depending on who you interviewed). It's hard to make a claim on whether it was safe enough without explicitly defining the safety goal.

    Early 1970s documents were given safety requirements of 1:20 flights being successful. [1] That's the closest I've found to an actual requirement, and the shuttle record falls well within that requirement. I do think such an early spec is not a good basis for final performance, though.

    [1] page 326: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/19700005884/downloads/19...

    • jpablo 1 day ago

      It wasn't safe enough to keep using it.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        So I ask again, what is safe enough for continued use?

        • wolf550e 1 day ago

          See page 17 here: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20110004917/downloads/20...

          Shuttle started at 1:10 and ended with 1:90 chance of loss of crew. That was bad and got it canceled as soon as the station was built, and supposedly ISS was finished only because international obligations. The last mission to extend Hubble's life was almost canceled because the NASA admin thought it was too dangerous.

          NASA wanted 1:270 (so just "3 times safer than shuttle at the end of the shuttle program") from commercial crew (i.e. SpaceX Crew Dragon and Boeing Starliner).

          Current US law for commercial space works on consent: passengers sign a waiver saying they know it's dangerous, and then the company doesn't have to promise safety the way an airline does. The company is on the hook for debris and innocent bystanaders on the ground though.

          SpaceX plan to fly Starship a lot and gain so much experience they can find and fix all problems and reach airline safety. At least private jet level of safety, at a start.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            Right, those are historical numbers, not design specs. I was asking for the design spec. Ie, in order to say whether it was “safe enough” the historical numbers either exceed the requirement spec (or not), like what exists for CCP.

            There are multiple layers of risk consent, from engineering, safety, medical, and crew, for NASA. Of those, I think crew are the least likely to say no because they tend to come from a very risk tolerant population.

            • labcomputer 1 day ago

              Obviously it wasn’t “safe enough” because congress declined to continue funding it, and there was very little pushback from anyone when that happened.

              Whatever official spec that did or did not exist is irrelevant.

              • bumby 2 hours ago

                That’s an odd take that the requirement is irrelevant. At the very least it’s exhibiting hindsight bias.

                If you hire a contractor to build a 2000 sqft house and then after it’s built complain to them that it’s not big enough, the problem is literally the requirement you gave them.

    • goodmythical 1 day ago

      >It's hard to make a claim on whether it was safe enough without explicitly defining the safety goal.

      I don't think it's that hard. "We're not sure exactly how safe it is, and do not have any actual requirement that it meet any specific level of safety" is clearly not safe enough for manned flight. (At least not outside of war-time or other such times we're willing to take on extra risks)

      Would you get on an elevator that has a weight limit listed as "hasn't fallen yet", "has only fallen that one time", or "did fall that one time, but not since the redesign". Would you trust millions of dollars of human training and several lives to such an elevator?

      • bumby 1 day ago

        Vibes-based requirements seldom work out well. It lays the groundwork for all kinds of human biases.

    • dghlsakjg 1 day ago

      3.9% of space shuttle crew died on missions. That’s a much higher fatality rate than d-day participants.

      I think we can say that it wasn’t safe.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        The question was what is “safe enough” threshold. If you say 3.9% isn’t, you need to define what is. The better way to count isn’t “what percent of crew” but “What percent of crew-events” because astronauts were often on multiple missions. That number is 1.64% (14 fatalities over 852 crew events) Maybe that meets your threshold, maybe not.

        The point was that wasn’t explicitly defined up front…they seemed to have fallen into the same trap you did of “we’ll know it when we see it”. CCP has a loss of crew threshold requirement of 0.37%.

        • dghlsakjg 1 day ago

          Fine. If you want an acceptable design parameter for expected deaths: 0%.

          We do not design civilian, optional, exploratory space missions with a threshold for acceptable fatalities. There is no number of dead astronauts that we can accept as a design goal.

          Unforeseeable fatalities can happen, but death rate should not be a predetermined design parameter.

          For the record, at the start of the shuttle program engineers warned of a 1 in 100 failure rate implying an expected death rate.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            That is a common knee-jerk reaction of people who have no domain experience. 0% is functionally impractical; if that is your spec you won’t have an aerospace program. It’s the same reason the FDA allowable amount of insects in your food is non-zero.

            • dghlsakjg 1 day ago

              That’s crap.

              My comment is that a predetermined fatality rate is unacceptable. Not that unforeseen fatalities are unacceptable. Space programs playing Russian roulette is NOT the same thing as letting a few beetle parts into the Rice Krispies. If you can reasonably foresee that people WILL die (as happened on the space shuttle) you fix it.

              EDIT: 1 in 270 (.37%) isn’t a design parameter from SpaceX. That’s a NASA number for the upper bound of risk for entire mission success. That covers, again, unforeseeable issues. The design number for foreseeable issues is 0. They do not intentionally design fatal hazards into the spacecraft.

              • bumby 1 day ago

                I get that’s not the world you want, but that’s how these projects run in real life. E.g. SpaceX specs define a loss of crew rate of 0.37% as the upper threshold that is acceptable. 100% reliability is not a realistic goal in a world full of uncertainties. SpaceX would be out of business in a world that accepts zero risk.

                EDIT: 0.37% is not a mission success spec, it is a loss of crew spec. Acceptable mission failure is ~2%. I can guarantee you SpaceX specs for safety critical components is not 100% reliability because those components do not exist. They know they can fail, but try to mitigate it to a reasonable level. “Intentional” is not the same as “acceptable”.

                As an example, they originally designed a copv system with a check valve. All competent engineers know check valves leak. That ultimately caused the system to fail.

                • dghlsakjg 23 hours ago

                  Then this is just a phrasing/terminology misunderstanding.

                  I thought you were claiming that they were designing for an intentional failure rate when you said this

                  > The point was that wasn’t explicitly defined up front…they seemed to have fallen into the same trap you did of “we’ll know it when we see it”. CCP has a loss of crew threshold requirement of 0.37%.

                  I read your statement of a “requirement” of a crew loss threshold as being required losses. You seem to keep ignoring that I’m saying that no one is designing for intentional losses, and asserting that they are designing to hit a certain number of failures as a “requirement”

                  • bumby 22 hours ago

                    From a reliability standpoint they are describing the same phenomenon. Failure = 1-reliability.

                    Ie, a reliability (survivability) requirement is functionally the same as an acceptable failure requirement. The confusion seems to be around whether that defines a maximum or a minimum.

            • senordevnyc 1 day ago

              What rate of commercial air travel fatalities does the FAA and NTSB consider acceptable?

              • bumby 1 day ago

                I don’t know for over road vehicles. FAA seems much more stringent [1] as would be expected with public systems but it’s non zero.

                [1] https://www.faa.gov/documentLibrary/media/Advisory_Circular/...

                • senordevnyc 17 hours ago

                  I didn’t ask about over road vehicles. I specifically asked about commercial air travel. You’ll note that every time there’s a plane crash, the NTSB investigates it and issues recommendations on how to avoid it in the future. That’s why commercial air travel is so safe today. They don’t just write off some percentage as the cost of doing business.

                  That said, I do understand what you’re saying, that we can’t insist that we never start human commercial space travel unless it can be perfectly safe, and we can’t stop it every time there’s an accident. But that’s not quite the same thing as having an expected fatality rate that we find acceptable.

                  • bumby 10 hours ago

                    Ok, I misunderstood your question and was trying to explicitly acknowledge NTSB covers more than air travel.

                    The linked reference does indeed give an acceptable rate. This doesn’t seem to be a curious discussion if you’re jumping to argue instead of engaging the answer provided.

                    • senordevnyc 6 hours ago

                      You linked to a 75 page PDF with a vague reference to a non-zero number.

                      It’s cool man, I think you’re wrong in your overall approach here, but it’s not worth arguing, agreed.

                      • bumby 4 hours ago

                        Check the appendix. There an example table with the exact same method if you don’t want to read the pdf. Those probabilities are comparing the engineering reliability calcs to acceptable thresholds. That’s the method used in industry. If you want, I can also link you to NASA docs with similar methodology, but you specifically asked about commercial aircraft.

                        If you ask a question and are literally given the authoritative source but are too lazy to read it, maybe feed it into AI or something if you actually want the answer. But at least temper your confidence if don’t have domain experience and are just going off what you think the process is.

        • tekla 1 day ago

          The Space shuttle was expected to have a failure rate of 1/100,000 flights

          It had a failure rate of 2/135. Doing quick math its actual failure rate was about 1500/100,00 flights

          • bumby 22 hours ago

            Are you citing Feinmen? Those were not true reliability estimates, they were opinions of various levels of management/engineering.

            • tekla 12 hours ago

              You seem to have missed the word "expected"

              • bumby 11 hours ago

                No, I caught it. But since you didn’t answer the question I’ll assume that’s where you got the information. The problem is the “expected” rate differed depending on who was asked. Managers had a different expected failure rate than engineers. The latter point being, there wasn’t a rigorous reliability based probabilistic calculation everyone could agree on, so they all just had their own biased context.

                • tekla 9 hours ago

                  And was any of them anywhere near the actual failure rate?

                  • bumby 9 hours ago

                    It depends on whether you mean the full program or not. The engineer “expected” failure rate was 1/100. The post challenger failure rate was 1/110. Full program was about 1/70.

                    But those “expected” rates are just guesstimates and not scientific. Feynman put it at about 1% given the engineering data available in 1986.

    • wat10000 1 day ago

      We can at least compare with more modern numbers. The commercial crew program (Dragon 2 and Starliner) specced a maximum of 1/270 loss of crew probability. Shuttle managed about 1/70 by the end of the program.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        Point being? How does that relate to question about whether a historical shuttle reliability spec existed? The question was not about how the performance stack up.

        • wat10000 1 day ago

          You’re the only one talking about a historical spec. The comment you replied to just said “it wasn't safe enough” with no mention of what “safe enough” would have entailed. So I’m contributing a specific reference point from a subsequent program that can be used to compare.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            >The comment you replied to just said “it wasn't safe enough” with no mention of what “safe enough” would have entailed.

            Yes. That’s why I asked for clarification. It’s like someone saying, “That costs too much“ And someone else asking “How much can you afford?” They are logically sequential statements.

            You responding with “this other thing has a different price” doesn’t answer how much they can afford.

            • wat10000 23 hours ago

              It’s a figure from the same organization that shows you what kind of numbers they might consider. I thought it would be relevant as something at least in the general ballpark.

              I’m sorry this so offended your delicate sensibilities. I suggest you append “do not reply with anything that isn’t exactly what I’ve asked for” to all of your future comments to avoid any more misunderstandings.

  • sneak 1 day ago

    > Here's just one big hairy example: to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    I bet there are lots of people willing to fly on Starship even if it had Falcon 9’s level of reliability even without an escape system.

    • Zigurd 1 day ago

      I bet hundreds of people would volunteer. Look at the number of fatalities and non-fatal crashes involving FSD attention detection defeat devices. Brave test pilots every one of them.

      • sneak 1 day ago

        F9’s escape system has never been needed thus far. It’s possible it’s a lot more reliable than we know.

        Current (2026-11) FSD in “sloth” mode requires less attention (in software), and, having used it a fair bit myself, I would probably ride in it unsupervised. The Cybercab customers do.

        • senordevnyc 1 day ago

          Allegedly.

          • sneak 19 hours ago

            I’m sorry, I understand every sentence I wrote to be an objective statement of fact. What part is alleged?

            • senordevnyc 17 hours ago

              There’s a non-trivial chance they are remotely operating the cybercabs a non-trivial fraction of the time.

              Maybe it’s exactly as you say, maybe they have finally figured this out, but Tesla / Elon have blatantly lied, manipulated data, faked capabilities, and overpromised way too many times over the last decade for me to take them at their word. We’ll see.

              • sneak 2 hours ago

                Ahh, my assumption is based on a fair number of hours using the current FSD release in maximum-caution/slow mode. The software actually significantly relaxes the driver attention requirements in that mode, and I haven’t seen it do anything mega stupid yet, but my sample size is a few hundred hours in non-rain non-snow.

                It is a joy to use. It drives the way I wish Uber and taxi drivers would drive; it goes exactly the speed limit. A cop drove behind me for like five minutes straight the other day and I turned on FSD in sloth mode and knew it would be unimpeachable, and he left me alone.

                …but we both know anecdotes are not data. Tesla has a tremendous amount of data and while I don’t trust the things Musk says, I do trust that Tesla is not trying to kill their customers en masse.

  • izend 1 day ago

    I think it is obvious by now that Starship was not designed for manned missions and that it was designed to provide cheap launch capabilities for very large payload capacity.

    Flight 13 launched 20 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 34,100 kg.

    Flight 14 launched 26 Starlink v3 sats for a total payload of 44,330 kg.

    The Space Shuttle's max payload capacity was only 22,780kg (https://i.redd.it/8t8j1n4032lh1.png)

    • bunderbunder 1 day ago

      It was originally designed for manned interplanetary missions, but then they (wisely) decided to pivot when it became clear that that wasn’t going to happen.

      I have yet to be convinced that Starship’s payload capacity is actually a good thing, from a big picture perspective. It looks to me like a possible case of shouting, “I meant to do that!” after a pratfall. On a months-long trip to Mars, you need a vehicle that big for the sake of the human occupants. For launching Starlink, it’s less clear whether the ability to deploy so many satellites at once was worth the vehicle’s development costs. Perhaps it’s just inherited from an earlier iteration of the program that had different goals, and a more modest design would have been more economical. Worse, so far it seems like Starlink might be it. Most other use cases people have proposed for putting 40 tonnes in orbit on a regular cadence are the kind of highly speculative grasping at straws that accompanies any technically impressive solution in search of a problem.

      • jordanb 1 day ago

        Shuttle was supposed to be two different vehicles: a potentially reusable but a cheap unmanned heavy lift vehicle plus a small reusable manned shuttle.

        A lot of the vision was actually around building orbital solar arrays (remember the microwave power plant from sim city 2000?) to resolve the oil crisis.

        The oil crisis went away and the microwave arrays idea didn't make much progress and shuttle' budget got cut until they could only do one vehicle, so they tried to combine both and have a reusable heavy lift manned space glider.

        But because the microwave arrays weren't going to happen nor was the earlier L1 space station idea (and skylab deorbited before shuttle's first launch) they had nowhere to shuttle anything to, so instead they just ended up with a heavy lift LEO launcher that had people onboard for some reason.

        Ofc they eventually got the ISS as a destination, much later.

      • engineer_22 1 day ago

        Just speculating, but the US Military has money burning a hole in their pocket and could be interested in putting 40 tons to orbit several times a month.

      • pigpop 1 day ago

        I'm not convinced it's a permanent pivot. An opportunity to generate revenue immediately instead of much later presented itself, anyone with business sense would do the same. Manned flights are a long way off and commercial satellite launches can't happen until they achieve enough reliability. Launching their own satellites lets them use their prototype and test flights to accomplish something that saves+earns them money and they don't care too much if they lose the occasional batch of satellites since they're mass produced. It's also great PR for when they do want to sell launch services since they'll have an established flight record with real operational payloads that say "we trust our own business to this so you can trust us with your business".

        There are many valid points about the difficulties they'll need to overcome for manned flights but there are likely many solutions as well. I wonder if it could be as simple as making a really big crew capsule capable of launch abort with its own thrusters? It would make the second stage partially single use but the capsule itself could be reused like they reuse the Dragon crew capsule.

        As for large satellite launches, there's an obvious need for a larger faring volume when you look at the lengths we've had to go to in order to make payloads fit into the tiny ones currently available. Being able to launch a large telescope or solar array that needs minimal folding would be a huge cost and time saver. Having more and cheaper tonnage also saves money on materials used for manufacturing satellites, you can use less expensive metals/alloys and components if you have more weight budget. You can add more fuel to extend operational lifespan. It's also big enough that launching habitat modules becomes much more attractive. There's a lot we didn't do just because it was too expensive or simply impossible with the launch capability we had.

      • maccam94 1 day ago

        They haven't pivoted from the original Mars goal, they're just iterating on the path to reach it. The Moon lander is a bit of a diversion, but it funds some of the same development milestones and builds credibility for the manned Starship program. Space investments are relatively conservative, taking years to get funded and developed with a specific launcher in mind. It's very uncommon for them to be designed to ride on an unproven launch vehicle. SpaceX has been trying to push the industry to plan for Starship for years already, and now they're announcing their plans to phase out Falcon years in advance to really drive the point home that Starship is coming and they're not going to continue maintaining an outdated and more expensive launch platform.

    • jfengel 1 day ago

      Aren't manned missions a particularly large payload?

      • hvb2 1 day ago

        Manned missions have totally required an escape system of some sort. So when you know the rocket isn't going to make it, you can let the crew escape.

        In it's current design, there's no way to do that. Which is also why starship can be a lander on the moon, but it's crew will board after it gets to orbit (for now, at least).

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          The Shuttle didn’t have an escape system.

          • voidUpdate 14 hours ago

            and in two missions, everybody on board was killed

        • nout 1 day ago

          If there are multiple startships in orbit, that can provide redundancy for manned flights.

      • wat10000 1 day ago

        Not really. Dragon 2 is about 13 tons fully loaded, for example. It doesn’t come close to maxing out its launch vehicle.

    • asadotzler 1 day ago

      It was designed for human trips to and from Mars, redesigned for satellite launch, and a variant is currently being designed for long-signed NASA contracts for human flights to and from the Moon.

  • gadders 1 day ago

    I still feel like I am living in the future when I see these catches, but that last flip to vertical it does as it decelerates looks like everyone would be leaving their lunch all round the inside of the rocket.

  • fnord77 1 day ago

    Ironically I think it's going to take as long as the Space Shuttle did to get to first orbital flight. And be less safe.

    • asadotzler 1 day ago

      It's had orbital flights, more than one.

      • fnord77 1 day ago

        Still, I'm right - space shuttle took 12 years from concept to first flight

        Starship took 14 years

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          Starship was essentially in orbit two years ago - they chose not to do the additional orbital and circularization burns because of safety.

    • engineer_22 1 day ago

      This was an orbital test, it circled the earth for almost 24 hours and returned to base.

  • MattDamonSpace 1 day ago

    Idk imo the hard part is catching the giant rocket, everything else is “known”

    • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

      exactly! They've demonstrated all of those problems already in both the falcon 9 and falcon heavy. They are planning 5+ variants of starship as i'm aware.

      The reason the shuttle was so expensive and costly was because they used ablative cooling. SpaceX came up with some novel material produced entirely in house to make the heat shield hot swappable. They new this was a problem from the start and specifically designed this thing to be rapidly reusable, not just reusable in namesake.

      Atleast, on elon time it's super easy to get these haters to eat their words. They are producing one of these every month, so he will see how fast they scale from here. Even if it takes a month to referb and put back on the pad, they are scaling exponetially pretty fast.

      • avmich 1 day ago

        Shuttle didn't use ablative heatshields. They had to check - that is, detach, disassemble etc. - engines, which added to delays and costs.

        • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

          They used ablative materials at multiple spots on the shuttle, mainly in the a elevon gaps and around the nose. They also used carbon on carbon on all the wing edges, which is super expensive, but lasts a long time in theory but you have to scrap the whole section if it cracks.

          • avmich 1 day ago

            It's not the reason to say Shuttle was expensive because ablative cooling. For that scale ablative cooling was not used.

      • Recurecur 1 day ago

        SpaceX has already demonstrated completely refurbishing the tiles on the Ship stage in two days.

        Even if they have to do that every flight, which I doubt, SpaceX can achieve a very high flight rate with relatively few Ships.

    • 7952 1 day ago

      Surely the heat shield still needs to be proven on multiple flights.

      • consensus1 1 day ago

        Yes, but even if the whole thing needs to be replaced each flight the economics are still great.

      • MattDamonSpace 1 day ago

        Yes but that’s in the “what form should it take” category, heat shields are a proven thing

        The whole “catch the giant rocket” thing is (was?) the hard part

      • Zigurd 1 day ago

        Engines, too. One reason that catching the starship upper stage is very impressive is that, unlike a booster, it has to come down from orbital velocity through the atmosphere at much higher temperatures and much more buffeting. There is no heat shield covering the engines. Turning around a starship upper stage without replacing significant parts of the engines, or significant numbers of the entire engine, is a much more difficult chain of dependencies than anyone on this thread seems to appreciate.

        Starship has taken this long because of over optimistic project management. Elon doesn't like bad news about difficult issues. He's run a massive rocket project like a mobile app development run with an agile task board. In contrast, Apollo was a triumph of conventional systems analysis style project management.

        • ggreer 1 day ago

          What? The engines are shielded by the aft skirt. Otherwise they'd risk damage during reentry and wouldn't be able to perform the landing burn.

  • breakyerself 1 day ago

    I wouldn't fly on one for a very long time. They aren't close to being reliable.

    • dotancohen 1 day ago

      I'd fly one to Mars tomorrow morning. I'm going to die some time, might as well conquer a dream.

      Now, would I let my children fly on one? I'm hesitant now, and I'd like to see how they handle the flip maneuver with humans aboard. But no hard yes or no yet. Let's see how long it takes to become as reliable as the Falcon family - or the 747 family even as that is SpaceX's stated goal.

    • shytey 1 day ago

      Yes, this is a test program, it's obvious that they are not reliable yet.

  • oconnor663 1 day ago

    > to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    I assume they'll do the latter. If the vehicle is truly rapidly reusable, that's less crazy than it sounds. Just fly it 10,000 times and fix all the problems you find :) Escape systems are only really useful during launch anyway. The only way to protect the crew from a failure during reentry is reliability.

    • samcheng 1 day ago

      People are relatively small and precious. Why not keep Falcon 9 / Dragon for human-rated space flight, and rendezvous with the rest of the system in orbit?

      • smotched 1 day ago

        that's not feasible for a mars trip or even a trip to the moon and back with real cargo. Even with starship you need many refueling flights for it to be possible. Not to mention the cost.

        • DennisP 1 day ago

          You could use Dragon to lift humans to LEO and transfer to Starship, and vice versa for the trip back down. They're already adding docking capability for Artemis. It'd cost more but it could be a useful transitional phase.

      • Alive-in-2025 1 day ago

        Besides the fact that they're going to do a lot of those Falcon missions with the Starship, I think they actually are pulling the rug up behind them. They don't want to give a lot of launch capability to their future competitors.

      • nick486 15 hours ago

        Because it would take take mission support people away from the starship program, and those people are a limited resource. Also, being the "low volume secondary project" tends to negatively impact reliability too, in many ways. So its not even certain, that there is a crew safety benefit here, compared to a hypothetical Starship program safely flying hundreds of missions a year.

    • wat10000 1 day ago

      An escape system could also be useful for a failure during landing. If I were flying on Starship, that’s what would worry me the most. Incredibly slim margins and no room for delays. If the engines look wonky on launch, you can stop and try again later. On landing, better hope the issue isn’t a big deal because you’re making a crater if it is.

  • NitpickLawyer 1 day ago

    > what starship really can do and what it will cost.

    The previous flight launched 20 sats and that is the equivalent (in Starlink bandwidth) to 10x F9 launches.

    This one launched 26 sats. That'd be 13x F9 launches in Starlink bw.

    F9 internal cost is 20M$.

    Starship stack is rumoured to cost ~100M$ to build.

    If they can launch a stack once every month, they've already achieved more "capacity" for Starlink than their best year using F9s (last year). At half the price.

    So that's already proven, even if nothing else works (i.e. reusability, etc). But of course they'll keep working the problem and make it work. They're also scaling at a crazy pace (3 more pads in various stages of readiness, plus even more planned in the next ~5 years). They've just finished the gigabay and they're planning even more in Louisiana.

    Anything they do from here on out is "the cherry on top".

    • jvanderbot 1 day ago

      There's different levels of proof being discussed here.

      Are we ready to put passengers and NASA interplanetary missions on Starship? No.

      Is SpaceX ready to count on Starship for replenishing or expanding their main moneymaking satellite fleet? Yes.

      • ericd 1 day ago

        Are manned missions commercially relevant? They have NASA contracts, but they seem like small potatoes compared to bulk mass to orbit.

        • lokimedes 1 day ago

          It has to hinge on opening up an entirely new economy in space. I certainly see the potential for mass-human spaceflight when access to space crosses the threshold prices that made commercial air travel possible.

        • tsimionescu 1 day ago

          Currently the only major clients for space flight are NASA and similar space research agencies, and Starlink. Everything else is a minor addition. It's not at all clear this will ever change.

          • ericd 1 day ago

            Don’t forget every other nation’s sovereign equivalent of Starlink. And there are obviously a bunch of speculative ideas. Seems like dropping military hardware anywhere in the world in an hour will probably be interesting at some point (Starfall being v0 of this).

            If you just look at incentives combined with the large change in the underlying assumptions of space flight, it’s quite clear that customer base will expand if SpaceX wants it to.

            • tsimionescu 1 day ago

              What every other nation's sovereign equivalent of Starlink? No other nation is currently attempting anything of similar scale. China and the EU might at some point, Russia would probably want to as well, and that's about it. Do you really think that Moldova or Barbados would consider having their own fleet of worldwide satellites? And none of these are likely to use SpaceX, so they're not a real market (well, maybe the EU might).

              And about the "dropping military equipment in 1h" thing, I'll believe it when I see it. Rockets are so easy to track and intercept that I'm not sure I see the plausibility of this.

              • ericd 23 hours ago

                Heh obviously I don’t mean the tiny ones. Good point about maybe not wanting to ride up with SpaceX, tho. Starshield is a pod that can deorbit arbitrarily, it’s not a rocket to be tracked, and I think ballistic missiles in terminal phase are famously hard to intercept?

              • autuni 15 hours ago

                I think it's worth pointing out 2 things here:

                a) EU and China both are actively working on it and

                b) > No other nation

                Starlink also doesn't belong to a nation, it's owned and run by a private company, which will probably cause issues for the US government at some point in the future

          • cryptonector 1 day ago

            And Starlink is the lion's share of that, is it not?

          • hammock 11 hours ago

            What are you defining as “space research agencies”? Because in my mind starlinks major client has an annual budget of $961B…and directly related to why other clients have not appeared (not allowed)…

    • nick_ 1 day ago

      Just curious if that math includes a brand new starship upper stage for each launch?

      • NitpickLawyer 1 day ago

        Yes, the estimate is for the entire stack. But it's rumoured so take it with a pinch of salt. The internal cost for F9 is from their IPO I think.

        • ericd 1 day ago

          Absolutely crazy that F9 with reuse is more expensive per sat capacity than a disposable starship, incredible what Raptor mass manufacturing has done to costs.

          • DennisP 1 day ago

            Also the main structure of the F9 is made of an aluminum-lithium alloy that costs about ten times as much as the steel used for Starship.

            • ericd 1 day ago

              Ha cool detail, thanks!

    • jmyeet 1 day ago

      You're not the first person on this thread to claim a Starship stack cost $100M and the internal F9 cost was $20M so I went looking for the source of this and the source seems to be... Elon himself. That's... not reliable. Consider [1]:

      > An insider source told Bloomberg that each fully stacked Starship actually costs hundreds of millions of dollars. How many hundreds of millions? They didn’t say, but this is more evidence to support my estimated build cost of a fully stacked Starship at $500 million. This figure didn’t come out of thin air. It was derived by scaling up Falcon 9 build costs to Starship’s weight to obtain a rough estimate and then verifying it against SpaceX’s Starship expenditure, minus overheads, and dividing it by the number of launches (read more here). This suggested a build cost of $500 million. Now, this is still a very rough estimate, but the fact that it aligns with this SpaceX insider’s statement suggests we are at the very least close.

      The Starship program cost is $15B and counting. It will like get to $20-30B+, particularly when you start factoring in aspects like crewed missions, in-orbit refueling and lunar landing and takeoff. You don't have to do all of these capabilities but any you drop remove certain markets.

      Likewise, any production line needs to be scaled. There is a cost to that too.

      All of which to say is that $500M/launch currently I find entirely plausible.

      But what's the market? Because AFAICT it's basically "Starlink". How many launches will that sustain? Well, that depends on the market for Starlink. Starlink receivers obviously have uses for mobile broadband, particularly on planes and ships. But th ereceivers are expensive. How many people will be able to and willing to pay $100/month for mobile broadband?

      I was curious about the possibility for a Starlink based phone communication networks and the prospects are... not good. Because physics. 5G phones typically have to communicate only a few miles. Depending on the altitude and it's overhead, a Starlink phone has to communicate with something 300-1000km+ away. You'll lose service indoors. The signal just isn't powerful enough. Raise the power and the phone gets bigger, hotter and more expensive with worse battery life.

      It's like SpaceX has decided to keep throwing more and more balls in the air and the solution thus far has been to throw them really hard so they don't come down for awhile. But, given there's a limited return because force is geometric, eventually it's not going to end well. Even the whole Ai angle was Elon using SpaceX to rescue himself and his "investors" from xAI, which itself was used to rescue Elon from paying $44B for Twitter.

      EDIT: Original Bloomberg report [2].

      [1]: https://wlockett.medium.com/things-arent-adding-up-145732c9c...

      [2]: https://archive.ph/TWIQi

      • szundi 1 day ago

        Cost versus marginal cost. You should not mix them up. The lower number can the marginal cost, what means how much more would it cost to produce just one more of the last one. No jon-recurring engineering, nothing else.

      • ggreer 1 day ago

        Scaling up Falcon 9 costs by mass will lead to extremely pessimistic estimates for Starship because Falcon 9 uses lighter, more expensive materials and fabrication methods. For example: Falcon 9 is made from Aluminum-Lithium alloy that is friction stir welded. It uses carbon fiber fairings that are designed to survive landing in salt water. Starship uses low carbon stainless steel and normal welding methods. Also Raptor engines cost less to manufacture (<$1M) than Merlin engines ($1-2M). I don't know how accurate $100M is for an expendable Starship launch, but I seriously doubt that it would be anywhere close to $500M.

        I can't read that article, but I've seen some of the author's other stuff and he gets basic facts wrong. For example, he claims that Starlink is unprofitable, and that higher RAM & fuel prices will make it moreso.[1] But he's ignoring that SpaceX's financial filings already account for depreciation, and that propellant & RAM are a tiny fraction of costs. Both could double and only increase SpaceX's costs per satellite by a few percent. He also claims that, "...a large portion of the Starlink constellation consists of V1 and V1.5 satellites..." but they're less than 15% of the bandwidth of the constellation. Over half of the v1 & v1.5 satellites have been deorbited.

        As far as I can tell, he's throwing as many criticisms at SpaceX & Tesla as he can think of and hoping some will stick. He's arguing like a lawyer, not a researcher. That's not a good way to figure out what is true or what is likely to happen in the future.

        1. https://archive.is/eKCJu

        • benj111 1 day ago

          To me, the issue is that space X are developing a rocket, flying that rocket, are its own customer for that rocket.

          Ultimately spaceX aren't profitable. That's about the best we can say, because the other numbers can be fudged

      • stevage 1 day ago

        Presumably the market also includes competitors to StarLink, which one imagines they wouldn't take.

      • tristanj 1 day ago

        The article you are citing as "evidence" is garbage - he added up cumulative Starship program spending and divided it by the number of launches and called that the "build cost". That's how he reached $500m per vehicle. That is an insane way to measure a vehicle still in development. Every vehicle has astronomical unit costs at some point during its development. For example, my old Toyota probably cost more than $10 million per unit at some point. But I still managed to buy one for less than $20k, and I don't go around telling people my car used to cost millions of dollars.

        What matters is the marginal cost of building a new Starship, which is (currently) around $80-100m. This number is still high, and will drop when Starship is mass manufactured.

        There are also glaring errors - it claims the $70m Falcon 9 customer price actually costs SpaceX $67m internally, implying a 3% profit margin - which is absurd and fiscally impossible given SpaceX's Q3 2026 SEC filings. The internal launch cost is closer to $15m.

    • ActorNightly 19 hours ago

      Falcon 9 launches are heavily subsidized. No reason to think this is any different.

      • jve 17 hours ago

        Subsidized by whom? The company that launches satellites? That cost of doing business and not a subsidy.

        I'm not aware of government subsidizing starlink. They do pay for starshield tho which is another revenue stream from constellation.

        • ActorNightly 7 hours ago

          Subsidized by taxpayers.

          In the IPO, it was clear that the launches were not profitable.

          Once Musk established DOGE, SpaceX basically started getting a shitload of contracts, as well as enjoyed the ability to operate with way less regulation.

  • willmadden 1 day ago

    >to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    Starship doesn’t need a 1960's style launch escape system. The whole ship is the crew vehicle. If the booster fails, Starship separates and flies away on its own Raptors. That’s the plan SpaceX has stuck with for years. NASA requires high reliability and failure tolerance for crewed flights, not a regulatorily mandated escape system.

    If you extrapolate the safety record of Falcon onto Starship, which seems conservative given that Starship is going to be their focus, it will be far safer than the Space Shuttle.

    The Space Shuttle blew up 2 out of 135 flights, 1.5%. Falcon has 3 blow-ups out of 720+ flights. That's more than 20x as safe, and includes the aggressive/early R&D.

    Starship is still being developed. Unless they go under somehow, it's going to be safer than the Space Shuttle by similar orders of magnitude.

  • abletonlive 1 day ago

    Blatant moving of the goal posts. HN is so prone to this, that much is clear. Another example of how HN is prone to this is regarding LLM denialists.

  • NooneAtAll5 1 day ago

    > while the space shuttle was a technical success in terms of being able to build and operate a reusable upper stage, it was hella expensive

    stop repeating this lie, please

    shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level

    the only reason for the cost was lack of payloads (!) to spread per-year costs

    there's a reason why spaceX now gets far far FAR largest part of its income from Starlink and most most MOST of its launches are Starlink. It's sattelite company with launch side business

    • jryle70 1 day ago

      > shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level

      Huh, in what world is that true? SpaceX quoted $75 million to external customers per launch according to their IPO.

      Shuttle launch costed $1.0 billion in 1992, or $2.41 billion today, inflation adjusted. That is without R&D cost.

      Thus, average cost per flight including development costs and flights through FY 1993 is $1.6 billion. Average cost per flight not including development costs or flights, up to FY 1992, is close to $1.0 billion. - [0]

      How much was the maintenance, refurbishing cost for each launch? the cost of a new external tank for each launch was $52 million in 1992, or $120 million today - [1].

      How much do you think they could get it down if they could launch more?

      Do you think NASA could fly 150 times annually even if there was demand, when it only flew 135 times in the shuttle's 30 year lifetime?

      [0] - https://sciencepolicy.colorado.edu/admin/publication_files/1...

      [1] - https://www.gao.gov/assets/nsiad-93-115.pdf

      • NooneAtAll5 22 hours ago

        > Do you think NASA could fly 150 times annually even if there was demand, when it only flew 135 times in the shuttle's 30 year lifetime?

        why not? if there was demand, especially internally from the government as planned - it would've been accommodated

        > Huh, in what world is that true?

        in the world where demand for Shuttle was 150 annually and not 135 in 30 years, duh?

        > How much do you think they could get it down if they could launch more?

        my main point is the per-year costs, like all the crew training complexes

        LARGE part of the billon$ number you quote comes from that and would get spread a lot. 50 million$ is a nice floor to exemplify where it would've ended up

        • jryle70 21 hours ago

          > shuttle costs per-launch were on falcon 9 level

          Mind to share how did you get that?

          > why not? if there was demand, especially internally from the government as planned - it would've been accommodated

          Which demand? For how many launches?

          > in the world where demand for Shuttle was 150 annually and not 135 in 30 years, duh?

          So the demand is in your imagination?

          > my main point is the per-year costs, like all the crew training complexes

          You need to be specific. How much did training complexes cost?

          Shuttle maintenance and refurbish were very labor intensive. It took months to get one ready for the next flight. For fewer than 10 flights a year (generously speaking). How do you propose they could scale up to support 150 launches annually? Again, be specific. You can't be hand wavy when you call other people lying.

    • dahinds 1 day ago

      Unfair to call it a "lie", it is objectively true that the program was very expensive. You can argue that in a different reality it might have been cheaper, but the statement is not a lie. The lack of payloads wasn't the only reason for this, the losses of the Columbia and Challenger were a pretty big deal.

      • NooneAtAll5 22 hours ago

        Columbia happened decades afterward, so everyone already knew the internal demand wasn't there

        Challenger is largely true (5 years is about the same as CRS-7), but iirc demand disappeared already at the late development stage

        I do call it a lie because people mix up program running costs and rocket launch costs. If your factory costs bajillion dollars to keep lights on, but nothing extra to increase output 100-fold, then it is expensive only on low demand. Proclaiming that it's always expensive and thus a failure of technology misunderstands how mass production works

  • engineer_22 1 day ago

    > to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    Falcon rockets don't seem to be exploding on ascent anymore, they're doing 2-3 launches per week now, no explosions in a decade.

    Perhaps an escape system could be deployed from the dorsal side of Starship, too.

    Given their track record of achieving the impossible, I wouldn't bet against SpaceX as they head towards commercial deployment of Starship.

  • reedwhistle 1 day ago

    > to fly manned missions, starship either needs to be redesigned to accommodate an escape system, or it needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    What makes you think humans will be the primary passengers? My bet is they will send Optimus for the majority of "manned" missions, especially 5 years from now

  • mattlondon 1 day ago

    > needs to show a level of reliability and safety never previously achieved by a rocket.

    Why does it need to be so much more reliable/safe than any other rocket that's existed before?

    Seems unfair to hold it to a different standard than anything else?

    • ngriffiths 1 day ago

      Because other rockets have an escape system.

      • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

        It will be a while before Starship carries humans.

        • mavhc 13 hours ago

          If they're launching every week they'll have 100s of examples of it working correctly very quickly

  • nlitened 1 day ago

    > I've been a frequent critic of starship

    Sir, you are a programmer of Java applications for mobile phones. You’ve had an impressive career, and are a person I am honored to look up to, but please have some humility

  • hn_submit 1 day ago

    The biggest problem they need to solve at this time is making the thermal tiles more damage resistant. At this time too many ceramic tiles get damaged and need replacement, repair or refurbishment just like with the Space Shuttle. That makes the dream of rapid reuse and lower launch costs unattainable.

    I wonder why SpaceX didn't pioneer metal-ceramic or metallic heat shielding.

  • ggreer 1 day ago

    I'd respect your criticisms much more if they were more accurate, of if when shown to be inaccurate, you acknowledged that. But it seems like you just move from one criticism to another and ignore your mistakes.

    For example, on flight 14 you claimed that SpaceX fudged their payload numbers by not fully fueling the satellites.[1] I pointed out that this must be false for two reasons: 1. Propellant is less than 5% of the mass of the satellites and 2. The FAA requires accurate masses for debris assessments.

    You also suggested that flight 14 wasn't fully fueled to allow for RTLS, but the amount of propellant burned is the same for a water landing and a tower landing. The only difference is when they do the reentry burn.

    Other times you've claimed that Starship hasn't met its payload goals. But Starship currently delivers a half payload because when launching from Texas, it must perform a dogleg maneuver to avoid flying over populated areas (such as Cuba). When they start launching from Florida, they they'll be able to put 100 tons into orbit per launch.[2]

    You've also claimed that Starlink's addressable market is shrinking because terrestrial wireless will expand.[3] But a cell tower costs about 1/3rd as much as a V2 mini and can't serve nearly as many customers in rural areas. So even with Falcon 9, Starlink outcompetes cell towers in areas with low population density. If Starship lowers launch costs more by being reusable, then the tradeoff will favor Starlink in more areas, not fewer. The only way to reduce Starlink's TAM would be if cell towers somehow became much cheaper.

    Even today you've claimed that the ship's engines don't have a heat shield.[4] But if you look at images of Starship or watch videos of reentry, you can see the engines are enclosed by the aft skirt. They already need to shield the engines for reentry because they operate during the landing burn.

    These sorts of mistakes make it much harder to lend credence to your conclusions. Yes the Starship program has taken much longer than SpaceX planned, but if the program is going to be successful in the long term, outcomes like flight 15 are exactly what one should expect to see.

    1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49893773

    2. https://arstechnica.com/space/2026/11/spacex-now-fundamental... "Dontchev said a single Florida Starship launch will be able to carry up to 20 times the bandwidth of a single Falcon 9." SpaceX currently claims that each Starship launch carries 10x the bandwidth of a Falcon 9 launch, so this would put them at around 100 tons of payload.

    3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=45617326

    4. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50510264

  • autuni 15 hours ago

    > it's the first demonstration of a reusable upper stage of a rocket system since the space shuttle

    I'd argue not quite yet. They've shown that they can catch the upper stage and that of course is a big milestone and improves the chances of getting a reusable system tremendously. A demonstration of a reusable upper stage requires them to successfully re-fly a previously used upper stage. The catch demonstration is a very good step in that direction, but not quite yet (in my opinion).

small_model 2 days ago

If the heat shield holds up then this changes everything. Next step is double catch and re-flying the same ships and catching again, then payloads to orbit become significantly cheaper opening a new era in space flight.

  • modeless 2 days ago

    Yeah, I'm eagerly awaiting results from inspection of the heat shield (which hopefully they will disclose). Reflight without refurbishment is the last goal they need to hit before the system can be considered a success. After that, optimizing for increased payload and nailing reliability will be the things to work on. And of course orbital refueling for HLS.

    • ACCount39 2 days ago

      They already recovered a ship from that one time they accidentally landed one in the ocean. SpaceX got to have a lot of heatshield endurance data by now.

      • pettijohn 1 day ago

        And they attached one of those used tiles to the ship that just landed. Second flight tile data is going to be huge.

    • NetMageSCW 23 hours ago

      They don’t need to fly without refurbishing as long as they have minimal refurbishing needed. They are able to get cheaper than F9 per kg by reducing Raptor costs.

  • proxyscore 2 days ago

    This changes nothing, in space fuel transfer between ships is the make it or break it.

    • lfuller 2 days ago

      Even without enabling missions requiring refuelling this is still a huge step change in orbital capabilities.

    • modeless 2 days ago

      Fuel transfer seems like a trivial problem next to the reusable heat shield. And even if for some weird reason it never works, the program could likely pay for itself just launching Starlink/Starshield with full reuse.

      • vl 2 days ago

        Or use SuperHeavy to launch non-reusable second stage and fueled Moon module of different design. After all SuperHeavy doesn’t have to be used exclusively for Starship.

      • lsllc 2 days ago

        I don't know -- that fuel transfer scene in Armageddon was pretty sketchy!

    • ericcumbee 2 days ago

      plenty of use cases were fuel transfer is not needed.

    • Tepix 2 days ago

      Fuel transfer isn't needed to launch to LEO at much lower cost.

      • firesteelrain 2 days ago

        It’s needed to go to the Moon based on the current Artemis design

        • sroussey 2 days ago

          Which is of secondary concern. SpaceX makes money on Starlink, not launches.

          • mathgeek 2 days ago

            This depends on what you're considering to be the main goal of Starship. Both of you are correct that Starship's stated goals included what you're considering the goal.

        • pfdietz 2 days ago

          If the simple industrial process of pumping liquid from one tank to another is too difficult, one wonders exactly what sort of society anyone could imagine building in space.

          The main reason fuel depots and fuel transfer were disparaged was to protect the gravy train of SLS. But that's essentially over.

          • TeMPOraL 2 days ago

            Nothing is simple in zero g. All our industrial processes have baked in assumption about gravity (and most also about the composition and pressure of surrounding air).

    • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

      Only for going to the Moon or Mars. As a launch system, Starship will still be a phenomenal success even if they struggle with fuel transfer, which is really an entirely different problem.

    • matheusmoreira 2 days ago

      Orbital refueling seems like a small problem compared to a reusable starship.

    • small_model 2 days ago

      No really it can now launch 20x the Starlinks per flight and StarMind is possible now economically.

    • kortilla 2 days ago

      It changes cost to put up satellites, which is very significant.

      It might not change much for mars

  • segmondy 2 days ago

    How many payloads are we going to put in the orbit before we end up with a new set of problem?

  • emkoemko 1 day ago

    Falcon9 already made it a lot cheaper but i don't see much market opening up? other then launching their starlink's

    • maxdo 1 day ago

      Space stations , space manufacturing, different kind of payload eg telescopes that are 10x bigger , you name it , oh and yeah mars , moon , asteroids etc . It all depends on how cheaper and bigger payload . 10x or 100x. If 100x this is new era for humanity

    • piloto_ciego 1 day ago

      When I was a kid it was like $50k/lb to send something up? Now it's like $1200? That's a big deal.

      • somenameforme 1 day ago

        And the even more tantalizing thing is what comes next. You're right that that's a big deal, that's near to two orders of magnitude cost reductions! But on the other hand we're still in a scenario where it costs $1200 to send a 16oz bottle of water to space. So that means the amount of infrastructure that can be deployed out there is limited and mostly restricted to governments or small satellites for private usage.

        Now bring it down two more magnitudes, which is the aspirational goal of Starship, and you're talking about a world where regular companies can start to deploy mass infrastructure to space. Suddenly, space as a domain for expansion and development becomes completely viable. That would completely revolutionize space, Earth, and humanity. It would be the official start of the next era of humanity.

        • ExoticPearTree 1 day ago

          Give it time. Maybe in the meantime new chemicals are discovered that make space flight cheaper. And new alloys to make the rocket lighter.

          And who knows, maybe we discover The Expanse like reaction engines in a few decades.

          • somenameforme 1 day ago

            You're speaking of advances well beyond the two magnitudes more we need. This is what I think most people don't get about the concept of full reuse. Those two orders of magnitude are theoretically viable with Starship!

            Starship spends around $1 million fuel to send around 100 tons to orbit. That's a baseline cost of $10/kg. But if we get truly aspirational then fuel costs can be significantly reduced through greater vertical integration, and the later block models already are looking at bumping the payload up to 200 tons.

            You obviously need some margin to account for maintenance after each flight, but the cost of the rocket itself rapidly amortizes to something near $0 with sufficient reuse. So something around $10/kg is a completely viable aspirational goal with current tech.

            And if we get anywhere in the ballpark of that $10 then Starship is going to be at least a big of a revolution in space as LLMs were in the digital/cognitive world. Wild time to be alive!

            • ExoticPearTree 1 day ago

              I was reading in the comments that the rocket itself is made of steel. What if they manage to build it out of a lighter alloy that has the same or better properties when it comes to going and coming back from space?

              What if, considering how SpaceX simplified rocket engine design figures out that, i don't know, adding a little bit of ammonia to the mix, makes the engines perform 10% better? Or 15%? Obviously not a rocket expert, but I don't think we (as a species) experimented with all the possible combinations of chemical compounds to get the best possible output to make a rocket get to space.

              I us a lot of what IFs, because in the past few years we've made technological jumps that prior to that it would have taken us decades.

              Indeed, wild time to be alive.

              • ballooney 1 day ago

                Read “Ignition!” by John D Clark. The field of chemical propulsion is far more mature than you realise, there are no more basic ‘whatifs’ like your hypotheticals.

              • Turneyboy 1 day ago

                > I don't think we (as a species) experimented with all the possible combinations of chemical compounds to get the best possible output to make a rocket get to space.

                What makes you think that? That's a nice thing to think but mostly comes out of ignorance of the field.

                • ExoticPearTree 1 day ago

                  Because we don't know everything. We find out each day new things about chemistry, the universe and so on.

                  When it comes to rockets, yes, I have zero knowledge beyond the basic functioning of one. On the other hand, I look at how the Raptor engines were simplified to make them more reliable, with fewer failures and so on. And my gut says they are not yet with enhancing their performance and reliability.

                  I may not know much about chemistry, but, call me ignorant, I don't think we discovered all the combinations between elements in order to ignite something or make it go boom.

                  Like with fusion reactors, in theory they work, in practice we haven't figured out how to initiate a reaction and keep it stable "forever".

                  More progress will come, at a much faster rate than ever before.

                  • ballooney 1 day ago

                    Yeah that’s just wrong. For chemical propulsion we no exactly what sort of valence arrangement of electrons and mass of combustion exhaust products is optimal for getting the most acceleration for your reaction rate. It’s mostly because simpler is better (eg if pure hydrogen could be a combustion product it would he impossible to improve on that). More complex molecules will be strictly worse than anything we know about already. As you said yourself, you know nothing abour rockets or chemistry. Read the book everyone has been recommending.

                    • ExoticPearTree 20 hours ago

                      That book explains the state of affairs at the time of writing.

                      You did not disprove my assumption we have not tested all the possible chemical combinations to make reaction better.

                      It is a very non-engineer stance of you to assume we now know everything about chemistry and that nothing new can be discovered.

                      Maybe we should ban chemical research going forward since there’s nothing new to learn and discover, no?

              • pfdietz 1 day ago

                What alloy would that be? Aluminum? Doesn't have the temperature tolerance. Titanium? Nightmarish to manufacture and expensive. Composites? Temperature intolerance and they tried it; not robust.

                Stainless steel lets the structure get very hot on entry without failure, beyond the temperature where aluminum alloys would lose substantial strength. This reduces heat shielding requirements.

                • hparadiz 1 day ago

                  The sky is the limit really. The shape and design is sound so now you can test all sorts of options. Internal frames to buttress the structure. Mixed materials. Composites. You name it. Steel is super easy and cheap for prototypes but if you know you can get the ship back you can play with all sorts of variables.

            • jimnotgym 1 day ago

              And then lots of startups will be able to afford to compete with starlink?

          • maxdo 1 day ago

            Starship built with new alloys and promises to deliver everything expected. I’m wondering what’s next for spacex beyond starship . It will take 5 years to squeeze all the possibilities from current design(s). What will be next 10x ?

          • pantalaimon 1 day ago

            Cheaper than methane and oxygen?

        • helterskelter2 1 day ago

          > a world where regular companies can start to deploy mass infrastructure to space

          If we don't start becoming much more careful, I expect we'll live to see the Kessler syndrome, perhaps sooner than we expect.

          • somenameforme 1 day ago

            Well how are we going to have big problems to solve if we don't create them!? Snark aside, Kessler syndrome is probably 100% inevitable. Even ignoring development, there's geopolitics. Modern warfare heavily depends on eyes in the sky, and so on day 1 of direct war between two great powers, stuff in space is going to start going pop.

            Fortunately it's not as bad as most think. You'd still be 100% capable of launching stuff into space, and even orbital rotations would still be viable, even if it would require more active maneuvering. It's not like it creates a giant impassable shield over Earth that'd just blot out the sky, but more like the odds of a collision per year on a given orbit would tend to increase dramatically.

            And the biggest risk would be in stuff quite close to Earth since that's where it'd be the most energetic/fastest, and also where there's the least amount of space meaning the odds of a collision are relatively greatest. Fortunately, that's also the domain where drag is the greatest and where particles would most rapidly end up falling into the atmosphere and burning up, so the worst of it would clean itself up naturally on reasonably short timeframes, like days to months.

          • eru 1 day ago

            Low earth orbit can't sustain a Kessler syndrome for more than a few years. Atmospheric drag is too large. (And it gets proportionally larger for smaller fragments.)

            • defrost 1 day ago

              So just half a decade of LEO's being economically infeasible then?

              I guess that gives the rebels time to organise for the next wave of fragmentation and shrapnel launches.

              • eru 1 day ago

                > So just half a decade of LEO's being economically infeasible then?

                Actually, it depends a bit on how disposable and cheap your satellites are that you want to put there. If you can drop costs enough, even an expected operational time of a few months before they get hit might be worth it.

            • jdb9001 1 day ago

              more worried about the upper range of LEO that'll last a couple hundred to thousand years.

              • eru 1 day ago

                Maybe. But that just makes the orbits unusable for longer term satellites or manned space stations. You can still pass through them with minimal risk (because the dwell time is so short.)

          • scottyah 1 day ago

            Perhaps, but that's country club problems for their lifespan. I think pollution on earth is a much more worthy issue to allocate resources towards. A lot of Earth's problems won't solve themselves with time.

        • oatmeal1 1 day ago

          I would be more excited if the plan to deploy to space didn't involve destroying critically important wetlands on earth.

          • falserum 1 day ago

            Expand a bit please.

          • piloto_ciego 1 day ago

            “Critically important” is a value judgment.

            • oatmeal1 1 day ago

              Do you think it's wrong? Humans are part of the web of life. We need wetlands so we can have clean water and seafood, even if somehow you think any non-human animal is worthless.

    • thinkcontext 1 day ago

      Starlink is a big deal so I wouldn't discount it. It's significantly expanded the satellite networking market. It's also a key military asset.

      Aside from that the F9 rideshare missions have made space accessible to a whole new class of space startup that wouldn't exist otherwise.

      Prior to F9 there was no competition in the US market. The result was government customers paid ULA through the nose. Commercial customers largely used Ariane. F9 saved the government money directly but also forced other launchers to lower their prices.

      • eru 1 day ago

        > Commercial customers largely used Ariane.

        That and the Russians. But SpaceX is cheaper than both of them.

        • fpoling 1 day ago

          The current list price of Falcon-9 flight at 74 millions is a third more than what Russia used to charge for commercial payloads. Production cost of Russian rocket is below 15M USD and probably was below 10M at the peak of Russian comercial services. This is comparable with Falcon-9 amortized cost per flight.

          • scottyah 1 day ago

            Are you adjusting for inflation over the decades between when russia provided these services for financial gain and what falcon does now?

            • fartfeatures 1 day ago

              Also don't forget what a state their launch facilities are in. Just because they could do something before does not mean they can do it now. They haven't invested properly in their infrastructure.

              • bumby 1 day ago

                Wouldn’t this imply the SpaceX costs need to adjust for the infrastructure they didn’t pay for? Not slighting them, just acknowledging an apples to apples comparison is hard

          • panick21_ 1 day ago

            You can't compare rocket vs rocket. Cheap Russian rockets are way smaller. Falcon 9 destroyed their market even before it was reusable.

            You are also missing that Falcon 9 costs as much as costumers pay, SpaceX internal cost are significantly less. They just don't have competition to make it cheaper.

            • eru 1 day ago

              Yeah, I'm a bit confused about how, if Russia was supposed to be cheaper, did SpaceX get all the marketshare.

    • eru 1 day ago

      Starship will make it even cheaper, if it works.

      With price per kg to orbit dropping, you can afford much more off-the-shelf components for satellites and using more cheap and redundant parts, instead of high quality bespoke stuff.

      • jamiek88 1 day ago

        Also, size! The sheer volume of starship would make say, James Webb telescope a lot less complex with a 175x30ft size ship to deploy it.

        • verzali 1 day ago

          Only if SpaceX can work out how to get it out of Starship. It is not as trivial as it sounds, and so far they have shown no inclination to work on the problem.

          • actionfromafar 1 day ago

            They could if they wanted to but for now it seems optimized to poop out little bom... sorry I mean little Starlinks.

          • DennisP 1 day ago

            True, but it seems like the Shuttle proved feasibility.

          • maccam94 1 day ago

            They already have a signed contract for a customer that requires a large payload bay door, they'll get there. They've just been focused on getting proof-of-concept orbital deployments first.

    • azernik 1 day ago

      Part of the problem was that there wasn't a second provider. I think Blue Origin getting into orbit will be a bigger game changer for launch prices than Starship, because it'll introduce competition into the market.

      • oska 20 hours ago

        I think Chinese launchers are a more likely provider of competition than Blue Origin

        (Of course, some USA payloads will never fly on a Chinese rocket but I'm talking about the worldwide market here)

    • daniel_iversen 1 day ago

      Not sure why the parent is being downvoted. Nobody in the comments seem to say anything else than "because Starlink" and a vague "new space startups". I'm a simple retail investor in SpaceX and love it just for Starlink and AI and then it's nice that they'll take humanity to Mars etc, but I was always dubious about how much money and growth would be in generic space cargo business and I fear if NASA stops having big contracts for them then it's a big impact on that side of the business. Would love to hear others' point of view on that! (one angle might be that they can use the current gravy train of NASA and Starlink and what not to invest in rapidly reusable rockets and once they're an order of magnitude cheaper then the future space cargo business doesn't have to be so large?)

    • Prickle 1 day ago

      Well we should be able to get SpaceShuttle size/tonnage cargo into space again, and on a re-usable platform.

      To put it bluntly, rocketry has been stagnant for a while. The spaceshuttle never really got design iterations because politicians wanted prestige more than results.

      We will start to see chinese/european copycats of starship, the same way there are many orgs trying to replicate Falcon 9. That is in my opinion kicking us into a new age. The launch cadence of SpaceX just with Falcon/FalconHeavy is already unprecedented as it is.

      Multiple orgs chasing starship, and starting a new spacerace. That is what I hope for.

      • pfdietz 1 day ago

        The politicians didn't want prestige, they wanted pork barrel spending going to certain voters. Prestige was just the mechanism to keep the pork flowing.

    • sailfast 1 day ago

      Starlink is big enough that the military is now concerned SpaceX and NASA won’t have the capacity to launch their payloads in the coming years - seems like there is enough demand!

    • asadotzler 1 day ago

      Starlink is huge, a market many times larger than Falcon 9 launch and Falcon 9 cannot launch Starlink satellites fast enough to keep up with current demand, build for future demand, and maintain a constellation of (already) over 10,000 satellites.

      SpaceX has contracts with NASA committing SpaceX to manned lunar missions, soon. Falcon 9 cannot do that.

      Long term (5-10 yrs) SpaceX will almost certainly send these to Mars and return them home. Falcon 9 cannot do that.

  • bryanlarsen 1 day ago

    Even if it doesn't meet their goals of rapid reuse, I think we've still joined the new era. Replacing tiles is going to be substantially cheaper than building new upper stages, likely less than the cost of fuel for a launch.

    • haspok 1 day ago

      So what was the problem with the Space Shuttle?

      • WalterBright 1 day ago

        The wings, landing gear, control surfaces, added a great deal of weight.

        • fsh 1 day ago

          Doesn't seem to be that different. Space Shuttle: 27.5t payload/2030t launch weight = 1.4%. Starship: 40t payload/5000t launch weight = 0.8%. For comparison, the Falcon 9 has 17.5t/549t = 3.2%. Bringing back the orbiter appears to still come at a significant cost.

          • nkoren 1 day ago

            The maximum payload of the current configuration is a matter of conjecture, but 40t is considerably lower than the low end. I think 80t-100t is more likely.

            • fsh 1 day ago

              The first stage ran out of fuel in the current configuration with approx. 40t payload. Anything else is conjecture.

              • baq 1 day ago

                Yeah, but still 40t to LEO with cheap rapid reusability (say 60 days, cheap engine replacement, some mass produced tiles) is still revolutionary, just not as revolutionary as Musk’s vision is. Imagine what research packages you can send to the outer planets with 40t budget from the effin LEO. Approximately infinite delta V with ion drives and fat solar cells.

                I’m more concerned with payload bay doors than the spacecraft’s performance tbh.

                • bunderbunder 1 day ago

                  But Starship does not currently seem to be on track to achieve cheap, rapid reusability.

                  I know that is what was promised, but I do wonder how many of Starship’s design goals the program needs to miss on before the general public starts to wonder if maybe goals are not the same thing as guarantees.

                  • JumpCrisscross 1 day ago

                    > Starship does not currently seem to be on track to achieve cheap, rapid reusability

                    What? Based on what? Starship has had two orbital flights ever. And they’ve gone pretty well.

                    • bunderbunder 1 day ago

                      They still don’t seem to have figured out how to reliably recover and reuse Superheavy. They did it a couple times in 2025, but it’s been over a year and quite a few flights since the last time they successfully caught one.

                      Raptor isn’t shaping up to be a sufficiently reliable engine. They are still having shutdowns and failures on every flight. That could be a huge problem for cheap and rapid reuse because it implies that quite a lot of inspection and refurbishment will be needed for every engine they re-fly. This was famously a major impediment to cheap reusability for the RS-25 and Shuttle, and they only had to worry about three of those per flight. Starship has 13 times as many engines to worry about, and those engines have thus far had a much higher failure rate.

                      And then they’ve also been having trouble with the thermal protection system, which seems to require a lot more refurbishment than what they had originally wanted. There have also been some kinks to work out in terms of its actual protection of the vehicle, which is a problem because even minor materials degradation due to thermal stress will limit the reusability of the upper stage.

                      • WalterBright 1 day ago

                        The Me-262's jet engines only had a useful life of 20 hours. Look how far we've come!

                        • cryptonector 1 day ago

                          Ruining naysayers' day is so much fun!

                      • JumpCrisscross 14 hours ago

                        All three of the issues you’ve pointed out are real. But all evidence points to them being engineering issues, requiring refinement. Not design issues, which require rebuilding.

                        In contrast, the propellant-transfer mission is entirely in the design-risk setting. It’s wild NASA is counting on something that risky for missions less than half a decade out.

                        I’d bet on Starship solving recovery refurbishment (they’ve done it before) and refining an engine (they’ve done before). Thermal protection is riskier, but even if that turns out a blocker, Starship still beats Falcon 9 in cost per pound.

                        • bunderbunder 10 hours ago

                          They could only be engineering issues if SpaceX’s management didn’t keep pushing design changes.

                          As it is, Starship is proving to be a fairly straightforward example of a project that’s stuck in development hell due to excessive managerial meddling and unrealistic expectations.

                          It’s only getting this much goodwill because SpaceX also produced Falcon 9, which famously also needed 14 flights to safely reach orbit, and definitely did not get there on the first try and deliver cargo to the ISS by flight 4. /s

              • nkoren 1 day ago

                These are still experimental flights. That could have been a bad procedure or a misconfiguration; we don't know. Claiming it as an upper limit if the design and then comparing it to a fully mature STS (you're quoting Endeavour's payload IIRC; Columbia was heavier and could not match its numbers) is cherry-picking. If you want to organise your claims with "in the absolute worst case..." then that's fine. But this is a subject with a lot of uncertainty around it, and asserting that one end of the error bars is the only one that counts isn't really justified.

              • jryle70 1 day ago

                That doesn't say much without knowing how the fuel was used. They may have pushed it to the max to give Starship more room, therefore didn't save enough fuel for the booster's return. They may have set higher safety margin. They may have used more conservative thrust settings.

                There are so many knobs to turn. Everything is conjecture because it's only the beginning. One thing for sure, Superheavy/Starship in the future -- a year, two years, five years from now, will be very different that what was used for this flight.

              • hparadiz 1 day ago

                These flights use a minimum amount of fuel with a half empty payload.

              • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

                That's not how rocket science works lol. You don't put it up and accidently run out of fuel because it used more fuel than you think. Slosh in the internal tank and a sensor failure is most likely. Second most likely is that engine that went out started spewing fuel. You don't "Run out of fuel", when attempting a tower catch.

                • cryptonector 1 day ago

                  Apparently they had to throttle down during booster ascent and had to burn for longer, and that's why they consumed more fuel than planned.

              • NetMageSCW 23 hours ago

                No. Elon posted that the dogleg required to reach Starlink orbit from Texas lowered the payload by about half, so they could reach 100 ton to LEO from Florida.

          • cryptonector 1 day ago

            Yeah, but those wings and landing gear and what not were not necessary to get anything to orbit. Starship does away with all the deadweight. IIUC this week's mission achieved 52 tons to orbit, and they were flying the booster's raptors are much less than full throttle due to reliability issues, so imagine what the stack could do if they solve those issues. They really might get to 100 tons. The mass percentages you're quoting are not very relevant for other reasons too, since who cares if a non-fully-reusable system is more 'efficient' in this sense if its marginal costs are higher than those of a fully-reusable system that is less 'efficient' in this sense. You're looking at the wrong statistic.

      • KineticLensman 1 day ago

        Massive refurb / rebuild costs between each flight

        • z3t4 1 day ago

          They reassembled and checked everything down to every single bolt. With unmanned missions it does not matter I guess, if a rocket occationally explodes.

          • KlutzySofa 1 day ago

            Reliability is still a huge concern as there is a risk to the public if Starship has issues at the wrong time.

            During launch its relatively fine as you are flying into a designated safe zone, but since its designed to survive re-entry there is a much higher chance of parts surviving and hitting something on the ground. We already saw that with multiple of the Starship V2 flights.

            • cobbzilla 1 day ago

              if your craft is pointed at the “cemetery” when it starts its journey, it’d have to go very off course for anything bad to happen

              https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Spacecraft_cemetery

              were these other craft not headed for Point Nemo? if not then wtf

              • KlutzySofa 1 day ago

                The rocket can still explode while in space and parts of the rocket can reach the ground without burning up. Thats not a big risk with rockets built mainly out of aluminium etc, but Starship with its stainless steel that can handle higher temperatures and its heat shield is more likely to reach the ground.

                The 11 Starships that have gone through re-entry have so far had no issues with reaching their designated landing zone/spot in one piece (except from some minor parts melting off in their earlier V1/V2 flights). So far SpaceX has shown that they are willing to play it very safe, but there is always a risk and their future re-entries will also do go over land like Flight 15 did.

            • consensus1 1 day ago

              The risk is minimal. Out of all the rockets that have exploded there has been exactly one case of a person being hit by debris in the US and it was fiber glass so they weren't even injured.

          • gus_massa 1 day ago

            The reassembled and checked everything down to every single bolt because they were using too much fancy beading edge technology that was not reliable for reuse. Even if they connect the landing gear to the automatic system to make it unnamed, they would have to disassemble and reassemble each time. Reuse was a lie, or at least a poetic licence.

            The motor had like 30 blades and a few of them developed cracks each time, so you have to open it, inspect each blade and replace the bad ones. IIRC Feynman was very afraid one of them would break and cause another crew lost. Luckily it didn't happen, but they have a last chance in Artemis.

            The metal encase of the solid rockets would get deformed in the splash, so they have to make them round again.

            The heat shield has to be completely replaced by design.

            ...

            • NetMageSCW 23 hours ago

              The Shuttle heat shield was completely inspected after every flight but very few tiles were actually replaced.

      • azernik 1 day ago

        The hull shape was very complex. Tiles on Starship are mostly identical; the massive number of SKUs involved in the Shuttle heat shield meant there wasn't a lot of mass production.

        (Starship still has unique tiles near flap joints and edges, but the main hull itself has mass produced tiles.)

        • KlutzySofa 1 day ago

          Didn't help that Shuttles had design differences between them as well due to the lessons learned and new technology developed between when they were built which resulted in having differences both internally and externally. Even the heat shield layouts were different.

        • alcomatt 1 day ago

          Still - it is hardly revolutionary. Evolutionary more like it. Natural conclusion to make it mass producible.

          • jryle70 1 day ago

            Who says anything about heatshield tile being revolutionary? The whole package is, however -- Raptor engine, reusability, refueling, mass production, and so on. Together, they allow low cost, fast turnaround time launch service.

            As for a different approach, try Stoke's active cooling solution:

            https://www.stokespace.com/news/building-rockets-to-fly-and-...

            • DennisP 1 day ago

              Stoke is amazing. SpaceX briefly considered active cooling, but with methane the physics isn't so favorable.

          • azernik 1 day ago

            Taking something handcrafted and making it mass produced is absolutely revolutionary.

      • sneak 1 day ago

        It wasn’t a drone and there weren’t large factories explicitly designed to scale up that could produce new ones in weeks.

        The big one though is that it had schoolteachers inside. The Starship is robot drone. If it blows up on reentry it isn’t a huge deal.

      • tristanj 1 day ago

        The space shuttle program was doomed from the start because it was designed as a manned vehicle. Unlike Starship, it couldn't fly unmanned.

        Shuttle had to fly humans, and had to maintain its human-rated safety certification. This meant that any design change or modification had to be tested extensively to ensure it didn't kill the crew. This took multiple design iterations, took a long time, and was not cheap.

        After the initial design of the ship, it made the program very risk averse. Changing anything required a lot of testing, so it was easier to not change it. Shuttle got stuck because it became too difficult and expensive to iterate; Congress did not give NASA enough funds to overcome this, so the project stagnated.

        Because Starship flies without humans on board, it doesn't have these issues. SpaceX can make radical design changes, perform minimal testing, then put these changes on the next flight and immediately see what happens. Sometimes this fails catastrophically, which is the main reason why Starship keeps blowing up. They can also push the ship close to failure to see how it performs, without worrying about humans on board. This is why Starship burned up multiple times when returning from orbit - SpaceX intentionally ran the ship through excessively steep reentry profiles to measure how the heat shield performed.

        The overall result is that SpaceX can iterate on Starship faster and more cheaply than NASA ever could with Shuttle.

        • pfdietz 1 day ago

          Human rating was more of a PR issue. The value of the human lives on the orbiter was much less than the value of the orbiter itself. So the cost of an accident would not have been significantly reduced by making it unmanned.

          Shuttle's real problem was it was just an uneconomical design. It was foolish to expect government and its cost-plus contractors to be able to optimize for cost.

          (Of course this got downvoted because people are unrealistic about the value of human lives. To pretend they don't have finite value leads to absurd results.)

          • xp84 1 day ago

            I see your point financially, however you’re just undervaluing the cost of highly-public deaths then. If a couple missions in a row for any manned program resulted in astronauts being incinerated, it costs the full future value of whole program, because astronauts won’t go on it anymore and the public will also demand its end.

            • pfdietz 1 day ago

              Right, that's a PR issue. It's ultimately because the space program is not actually producing much of tangible value, but rather a perception of value. A program that is producing airy PR is vulnerable to bad PR.

              The government has no problem with programs producing tangible value that also cost lives. Consider the military, police, search and rescue, and really any activity where people do anything with nonzero risk. The lives lost are part of the cost.

              • true_religion 1 day ago

                Right. If the space shuttle was crucial to national security or even financial success, politicians would spare no expense in telling the public that blood needed be shed to protect the ongoing accumulation of wealth en infinitum.

                But since it's a science project more akin to basic research than anything with a ROI formula attached, then even one death is one death too many.

                • xp84 1 day ago

                  One death isn't too many. It's a matter of too high a probability of general random catastrophe.

                  Example: Astronaut Tim goes on an EVA to perform an emergency repair after a micrometeorite damaged the space station. A malfunction of his space suit kills him. Everyone agrees that Tim died a hero doing a high-risk activity that needed to be done, and almost no one would say it means we can't do spacewalks or can't send astronauts to space anymore.

                  Compare to Challenger or Columbia: The whole crew dies randomly on the way up or down during a routine mission. A program which became known for having like, a 10% chance of that happening would be horrifying (in my opinion).

                  • pfdietz 1 day ago

                    If the Shuttle had been cheap they would have tolerated the losses, refined the design, built more, and kept on chugging.

                    But Shuttle was an economic as well as a safety fiasco. So there was no good motivation to keep using it.

                    The biggest tragedy of the Shuttle program was the 12 figure cumulative budget it consumed, equivalent to many thousands of lives.

          • RhodesianHunter 1 day ago

            I sure hope you never work on anything where human lives are in the balance.

            • pfdietz 1 day ago

              I sure hope you're never involved in any policy decisions, as you are clearly not able to make them rationally.

              Assigning a finite value to human lives (in the US, it's around $12M) is absolutely essential to evaluating policy tradeoffs.

          • PKop 1 day ago

            > the cost of an accident would not have been significantly reduced by making it unmanned

            > people are unrealistic about the value of human lives

            Which one is it?

            Given 2 is true and extreme, politics dominates all, and anyone acting like you would have been thrown out of political power as fast as possible. So no, "the cost of" does not pertain only to materiel and technical development, etc.

            > Human rating was more of a PR issue

            And this was demonstrative in limiting efficiencies and iteration, as OP was explaining. He stated the reasons it failed; you're countering with your idealism around why it shouldn't have failed, while inadvertently confirming the various reasons it did.

            • pfdietz 1 day ago

              Like people are thrown out of political power because of military training accidents? (This is about 400 deaths/year in the US.)

              No, those are just par for the course, a necessary cost for a military that can deliver its intended function.

              Manned space has the problem it was set up as theater, not to deliver value independent of the theatrics.

              If a space program costs billions of dollars a year, but cannot tolerate any deaths, it should just be abandoned, since it clearly isn't delivering enough value to justify those billions of dollars.

        • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

          Oh... you just met a big space shuttle nerd.

          This is not true... The shuttle mission was highly automated. Launch, orbit, reentry was all automated. They only needed human pilots to land on the runway because their algo's weren't good enough. Which, again, was one of many design failures of the shuttle. Having humans on board only slightly increased the chance of success according to nasa. other failures were their ablative heat shield ontop of the ceramica, the carbon-on-carbon plating around the aluminum housing, using aluminum as the body and fins instead of steel, AND DROPPING THEIR BOOSTERS IN THE FUCKING OCEAN.

          • jimmydorry 1 day ago

            >AND DROPPING THEIR BOOSTERS IN THE FUCKING OCEAN

            As opposed to dropping them in the desert or a town? The risk appetite was not there at all to figure out safe capture of the boosters. And if they had the allowance to tackle that problem, it would have been better focussed on improving the shuttle itself, fixing the problems GP has outlined.

            Of all the issues, "dropping their boosters in the fucking ocean" probably doesn't even make top 10.

            • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

              i'm talking about recovery. They couldn't because they caught it with parachutes.

              Again, stage zero is a huge enegineering challange and issue that Nasa didn't even attempt to solve because it was too hard.

          • azernik 1 day ago

            There was no way to Shuttle to land except on a runway. So yes, it did require human pilots.

            • rozab 1 day ago

              Buran proved there was no technical obstacle to uncrewed runway landing, the US could have achieved it a few years earlier if it was a priority. The Buran landing system was more complex than you might expect, and proved to be pretty adaptable in its only orbital flight.

            • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

              no, you missed what i said. Having humans only slightly improved the odds of mission success... Meaning they did have algorithms to autonomously land on a runway.. They chose not to.

              • tekla 1 day ago

                NASA chose not to because of several reasons, but the pilots really really wanted to be able to control the orbiter (probably because many were test pilots and liked the adrenaline). After Columbia, the orbiter was retrofitted to fly itself to the ground just fine.

                • burnerRhodov3 5 hours ago

                  but OP used that as the whole reason it failed... They could have, if they wanted, land it without people. Thus, the "reason" it failed is untrue.

          • voidUpdate 14 hours ago

            I've heard that the only reason it needed humans on board was to lower the landing gear, which was such a critical part of landing that a computer wasn't trusted to lower them at the right time, which seems a bit weird given that a computer could be trusted to do everything else

      • asadotzler 1 day ago

        Every tile on Shuttle was bespoke and had to be carefully hand-glued. Starship depends on heavily uniform tiles that can be robot arm installed, with truly bespoke tiles accounting for a small portion, in ares that are likely to survive well enough to be re-flown. Also, the propellant tanks aren't lost with each flight. That's just a couple of the differences, I think the biggest, but there are many smaller areas that Starship can, if it hasn't yet, dramatically beat Shuttle in refurbishment costs (money, but more importantly, time.)

  • beezlewax 1 day ago

    Why is catching them by better than landling them to the degree that it would open a new space era?

    • apexalpha 1 day ago

      Apparently the engines damage themselves in the last few meters when the energy required to hover / land that gets blasted out is reflected back at the rocket by the launchpad itself.

      • bluecalm 1 day ago

        Also if you can catch it you can save on having landing legs on the ship.

      • stackghost 1 day ago

        Surely the same energy reflection happens on launch.

        I would imagine it’s the weight savings of not having to carry thousands of pounds worth of landing legs onboard the rocket.

        • taneq 1 day ago

          I’d imagine it’s a bit easier to control the positioning of everything at launch.

        • sib 1 day ago

          Yes! Every kg used for legs is a kg not used for cargo... (And worse because the legs have to be carried up and down while the cargo only has to go up.)

        • Aerroon 1 day ago

          >Surely the same energy reflection happens on launch.

          Don't the launchpads have systems in place to prevent that? Eg the sound suppression system where they basically spray water into the air to absorb the sound. Does the landing pad have that?

          • foota 1 day ago

            Something like it, because they destroyed the pad previously.

        • IsTom 1 day ago

          They've got flame deflectors at the launch site so this doesn't happen.

          • peterbecich 1 day ago

            So theoretically the rocket could land on a flame deflector, reversing the process?

            • martyvis 1 day ago

              Not easy the land on a reverse waterfall I think.

              • gattr 1 day ago

                Now that I think about it, why land upright at all? You could do a gentle controlled touchdown in a water pool and slowly tilt to horizontal with a minor splash, like the previous Starship.

                • vardump 1 day ago

                  It'd destroy Starship, not enough structural integrity in that orientation.

        • rplnt 1 day ago

          I do believe it's mostly the legs, but to the first point, on launch you don't have the vacuum engine bells exposed to this. Or second stage at all, where weight matters much more, so any extra shielding you don't need is good.

      • exe34 1 day ago

        If they are as precise as they are now, can't they land on asian latrine type launchpads? Like the ones the shuttle used to take off from, with the guides for the blast to go through.

        • fartfeatures 1 day ago

          That would require landing legs, which would reduce usable payload to orbit significantly, the tyranny of the rocket equation.

        • zardo 1 day ago

          That was the original concept for the booster. You need some sort of giant rocket manipulator at the launch pad no matter what. If you can make it double as an active landing target, you go from needing cm level to m level landing precision.

      • hackrmn 1 day ago

        That's something that's been irking me whenever I watch the booster and now the ship, come crashing down at triple digit MPH speeds then watching it re-light the engines at the now front (aft end of the vehicle but going head first), what with a bunch of non-aerodynamic surfaces there. I am obviously not qualified to assess this, but I wouldn't bet on those engines being reusable more than 2, max 3 times each.

        Then again, I wouldn't know how to solve this better -- if you say, have a cover protecting the engines before re-lighting, you're not shedding speed any better than without it, and after re-entry and when the speeds are relatively modest (only, say, 400mph 2-3km up vs 4000mph at 100+km) the air itself doesn't do anything to the engines anyway.

        The booster has flaps that help it shed speed, but the Starship's flaps are very different, aren't they? And it's not exactly the kind of a flying brick that Space Shuttle was, either -- having it coast longer before it flips to be caught by Mechazilla, isn't a solution then...

        Just ramblings of an amateur :B

        • SirFredman 1 day ago

          What they do with Falcon 9 is insane as well - they have a portable heatshield for re-entry. That is, the heat shield is the exhaust of the engines. Which is absolutely glorious, not only do you brake, but you shield the rest of the ship using the exhaust as well, as a blowtorch burning to the atmosphere.

        • chasd00 1 day ago

          Taking an engine off and putting a replacement on is a fast process. Iirc booster gets all its engines in a day or two. Not quite like changing a lightbulb but I think it’s a fast process.

    • bell-cot 1 day ago

      Not an aerospace engineer, but roughly:

      I don't think catching (vs. landing) is a "new space era" game changer, but it offers several advantages in a game (chemical rocketry) where some margins are very thin -

      - No need for a separate landing pad. Which might need its own flame trench, for reasons others have noted.

      - You already have the chopsticks for pre-launch stacking.

      - Because you're stacking with chopsticks, you already have those hard points on the Starship. (Hard points are spots engineered to bear heavy loads, in contrast to fragile areas. On large aerospace structures, hard points are expensive in engineering, manufacturing, and weight.)

      - Landing legs on a hard surface require larger safety margins. Or a lot of springs, shock absorbers, and such. (Falcon 9's landing legs include those.) That's because the transient loads during an off-by-5-cm landing can be 3X or more the static loads on your landing legs. Vs. if you land on the chopsticks - all the springs and stuff can be built into them. With chemical rocketry's thin margins, not needing to carry that extra weight to space and back is a serious win.

    • MindSpunk 1 day ago

      If you mean why is catching (starship) better than landing (falcon)? The difference is the whole launch platform is reusable, booster and upper stage. Falcon is a reusable booster, the upper stages are always expended. Starship's payload capacity is huge, having that capacity on a fully reusable platform will drastically reduce $/kg to orbit since you aren't building whole new rockets every launch. See Falcon 9 for what a reusable booster can do for cost.

      If you mean why catching is (anything) better than landing (anything)? Landing gear is heavy. All the weight and mechatronics and complexity of the landing gear systems takes mass that could've been payload. Put the "landing gear" on the tower instead and the launch vehicle doesn't eat the cost of the weight. It's an optimization but not an order of magnitude revolution compared to a fully reusable heavy lift platform.

      • jojobas 1 day ago

        The jury is still out on ship reusability, especially fast reusability. If its life is say 5 flights it might well be not worth the hassle.

        Fastest Falcon 9 turnaround was 9 days, I wouldn't expect Musk's 1 hour turnaround target for Starship to ever be reached.

        • panick21_ 1 day ago

          The question for Falcon turnaround is about if this is because of anything related to hardware or logistics and business.

          And even 5 reuses matter if you want to do many launches. Because building them will be slow. So even if financially theoretically its not worth it, if you can increase your launch rate its still worth it.

          And that gives you the time to continue iterating.

          • jojobas 1 day ago

            From SpaceX publicity history, if they could turn one around in a day they absolutely would.

        • bunderbunder 1 day ago

          The jury’s still out on whether Starship needs fast reusability, too. The existing market for heavy lift launches is tiny. Starlink creates some demand, but beyond that SpaceX seems to be placing an incredible amount of faith in the idea that if you build it they will come.

          But what happens if there isn’t actually that much pent-up, latent demand for flinging heavy things into orbit? What happens if people still mostly want to launch the same size stuff they already do? Starship could become the paratransit shuttle of space: inexpensive, yes, but also inconvenient because of having to share the ride with so many other people that all have different destinations and schedules. In that case we might see that demand for Starship remains low due to potential customers deciding the extra cost of a different option is worth the added convenience. Anyone who’s chosen an Uber even though the city bus can get them to their destination for 1/10 the price should be familiar with the principle.

          • gedy 1 day ago

            > The existing market for heavy lift launches is tiny

            I can see the value in this though if we end up developing space and Moon, and a vehicle like this could open the doors for that, unlike now. If China has long term plans for that, it's probably a good indicator of future market.

            • bunderbunder 1 day ago

              That’s such a big if, though. Not just around how long it will take. Around whether it will happen at all. There are still a bunch of unknowns that need to be resolved before we can know whether any such plans are economically viable. What I’ve personally observed is that a lot of these ideas look great when presented as concept art, but iffy at best once you start trying to do any back of the envelope estimates.

              That certainly doesn’t mean it will never happen or that it’s not worth trying. But I’ve noticed that in these online discussions there’s a tendency to treat moonshot programs as if they’re sure bets.

              Also don’t forget social factors. The US had been actively working on establishing more of a presence on the moon, too. But the current administration more-or-less killed it because they didn’t like how much it was costing.

          • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

            You are right, they will repeat what they did with falcon.. They created the demand. They created starlink because they created so much capacity, they needed to put it somewhere. Now they will create Starlink v3 to completely dominate the internet market worldwide. Ontop of starlink V3, they have Starlink V4 in the works which will include direct to cell capability along with building land based towers worldwide. Finally, they have Starmind, for orbital compute.

            They don't need/ want to sell capacity. They want to constrain the capacity for themselves, which is obviously the better business move. Look at falcon 9 launches... It's not like they drastically lowered their pricing, they've been raising there pricing dramatically because they want to phase falcon 9 out.

            • oska 21 hours ago

              > Now they will create Starlink v3 to completely dominate the internet market worldwide.

              What's your business / engineering case for Starlink (i.e. LEO satellites) dominating the internet market worldwide?

              I was an early believer in LEO internet delivery and realise its advantage over terrestrial delivery in some regards, but I haven't seen reason to project its 'dominance'. So I'd be interested to know why you are projecting this. Fibre-optical cable is very hard to beat for bandwidth capacity.

              • jojobas 18 hours ago

                Next you'll say a datacenter in space is a dumb idea for the vast majority of applications, and you'll be correct.

                • oska 18 hours ago

                  Correct

                • burnerRhodov3 5 hours ago

                  once you realise you can expose liquid to the vacuum, and that the energy radiates ^4 around the surface area of the sphere, it makes alot more sense. You have to solve this when designing rocket engines. You "spew" the fuel sprayed into eachother so it splits into a thousand small little droplets. You then ignite these little tiny droplets to get a great mix. So instead of igniting them, you constrain them into a sheet. So now if we apply this to cooling in space, the Thermal radiation follows the Stefan–Boltzmann law P = εσA(T⁴ − T_env⁴).Radiated power increases with the fourth power of absolute temperature, not simply in proportion to temperature.

                  You also have to collect almost every droplet, prevent the spray from drifting, and keep droplets from blocking one another's radiation. These are significant engineering challenges. Which they already use on starlink.

                  Edit: found this from NASA in 1980's https://ntrs.nasa.gov/citations/19810062992

                  • jojobas 1 hour ago

                    Not sure what you point is. A starlink satellite consumes, and therefore needs to radiate, around 100W. A single rack cabinet from a modern data center consumes 1000 times that.

              • pie_flavor 15 hours ago

                Fiber is king at the top end, but Starlink currently only beats garbage low-end providers (or provides signal in previously barren boonies). Upgrades will allow them to beat normal midrange Comcast, especially if you're somewhere that sees outages or is lacking in upgrades. Additionally an increase in launch capacity will allow them to further saturate the sky, lowering the required line-of-sight cone and allowing it to be viable in more forested areas and manage congestion better for urban areas. And I'm just talking about America. 'Worldwide' is a statement that includes e.g. Namibia, whose 200Mbps+ solutions are much more expensive than ours.

              • burnerRhodov3 5 hours ago

                Business case is that they can scale capacity infinte, vs. the constrained nature of fiber? It's really, really, really, expensive to add capacity using fiber in cities. but adding more starlinks is trivial. The v3 capacity is insane.

                • jojobas 1 hour ago

                  >can scale capacity infinite

                  Claude Shannon would disagree.

                  With fiber you can cheaply add capacity by upgrading terminal hardware where needed. With Starlink you can only add capacity to the whole world at once, and it's mostly seas and woods.

                  It would appear that every commercial ship and every RV has a starlink already, this is perfect application for starlink. Competing with city ISPs would require thousands times the bandwidth at lower prices, it's a non-starter.

            • jojobas 19 hours ago

              They'd be hard-pressed to dominate land-based cables and antenna towers in cities, where 80% of people are. The only defensible application for orbital compute is military.

          • UltraSane 1 day ago

            SpaceX seems to be rather foolishly planning on completely replacing the Falcon 9 and Falcon heavy with Starship which is going to create demand for it.

            • bunderbunder 1 day ago

              I don’t think it’s foolish, for more or less the above reason. Starlink is the market for Falcon 9. Without that it apparently isn’t so profitable, because outside of Starlink the demand for a system with that kind of launch cadence just didn’t really materialize.

              But that’s also why I’m skeptical about whether Starship will live up to the hype. The whole case for how it’s supposed to revolutionize spaceflight rests on the assumption that it can tap into a huge well of latent demand to put stuff in orbit. If such a well really does exist then we have to ask why Falcon 9 wasn’t able to tap into it despite all of its obvious merits.

          • maccam94 1 day ago

            SpaceX is about to drop the cost of supply by ~100x. It's going to take a while for the market demand to respond to a change that drastic. First SpaceX has to prove that it even works, because otherwise people simply won't believe it enough to plan around it.

            • bunderbunder 1 day ago

              100x? SpaceX’s own goal was more like 10x.

              And that was just a goal; if they actually pull it off it would be a historic first for rocketry. So let’s estimate maybe 5-10x cost reduction. Hard to know where it would fall in that band while they’re still tweaking the design. But since they made that claim Raptor’s performance has come down by quite a bit and the vehicle’s dry mass has gone up, so they’re certainly not on track to exceed it.

              • maccam94 19 hours ago

                The internal target cost per kg of the fully mature system could be 100x lower than the price of Falcon 9 launches: https://twitterviewer.net/elonmusk/status/125858007821841203...

                (obviously factor in Elon optimism and timelines)

                But if you ballpark 20 reuses of the stack, minimal refurbishment, a rumored $100M cost to build the stack, $2M in fuel, 100T of payload... you're well under $100/kg. 20 flights is probably very low for their goals, Falcon boosters do that today.

                • jojobas 17 hours ago

                  Given the build cost of Falcon 9 first stage is about $30M I'd say there is no way the full Starship stack can be $100M. As for minimal refurbishment, the goal of 1 day turnaround for Falcon 9 was announced back in 2017, after some 40 launches. In 2025, after some 700 flights, they managed to hit 9 days.

                  There is a point where "optimism and timelines" becomes straight up bullshit.

                  • maccam94 1 hour ago

                    Keep in mind that the Falcon 9 Block 5 was designed back in 2016, and has been mostly locked-in since it was human rated in 2020. They've had 5-10 years to learn from that rocket and integrate those changes into Starship. Returning directly to the launch tower can shave days off that turnaround time by skipping the barge transit time.

                    • jojobas 1 hour ago

                      Block 5 dates back to the 1-day turnaround ambition almost exactly. Human rating didn't prevent them from keeping block 5 as is and making a faster-reusable version.

                      The possibilities are that they tried and failed, or that Musk lied, and neither looks good for Starship fast turnaround.

          • jojobas 1 day ago

            A single moonshot would required 12+ fuel launches (nobody knows how many, some say 20). Without a fast reliable turnaround capability this becomes hugely more complicated.

      • burnerRhodov3 1 day ago

        It's about takt time. And that's all elon thinks about. It has nothing to do with the landing gear.. even though as you said that's a slight modification. It's about being able to land it where you build, referb, etc.

        Do you know how expensive it is to transport a 40 ton skyscraper? Now they can just put it on the transport stand, drive it over to mega bay, refurb while they are putting they next payload on board, and drive it back over to the pad.

    • cryptonector 1 day ago

      The important thing is reusing the whole stack, not how they land. That said, how they land is important to making the whole thing make financial and engineering sense, which is why they ditched as much landing gear as possible.

  • m000 1 day ago

    > new era in space flight

    More like a new era in littering space.

  • ericcumbee 1 day ago

    Even if they haven't completely solved it. They have shown they can strip the old heat shield off, and put an entirely new design of heat shield on a ship in under 2 weeks. I believe that was one of the doomed block 2 ships that blew up in the Caribbean so it never got to re-entry.

  • jmyeet 1 day ago

    I've been thinking about the catch system and I don't think the risks and problems are being properly accounted for.

    For anyone unfamiliar, the Falcon 9 first stage booster reuse comes from landing the booster on a barge or on land and then recovering it and refurbishing it. Because the engines use RP1, there is coking and this is more expensive and slower to refurbish. Raptor engines use LNG instead to avoid coking but this is also more complex because now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one (the other being liquid oxygen obviously).

    The barges are ideal because the first stages will exhaust their fuel over the Atlantic. To land back at the pad they need to retain more fuel. This hurts payloads. But you have choices. Barges are relatively cheap. On land you can basically land on a relatively cheap concrete pad.

    to have the structure and fins required to not collapse when landing, it adds an estimated 10% to the weight. That's a big deal. It's also why Starship opted for the catch system.

    But here's the problem: you have to land back somewhere where you have a catcher. What happens if the catcher is down? Or the booster is suffering a fault (eg enough engines won't fire up so it isn't stable)? The catcher itself is a complicated and expensive engineering exercise. It's why on a recent test launch they opted for a water landing instead.

    To have manned missions you're going to need redundancy. That means more than one catcher available most likely. You need an escape system if the booster itself is faulty. You risk the catcher every time you use it. All of that gets expensive in a way that landing on a barge or concrete pad doesn't.

ChuckMcM 2 days ago

Huge congratulations to the engineering team on this one! It's been quite interesting to watch the evolution of Starship. Had they put another couple of tonnes of propellant and oxidizer on the Booster they might have caught both of them. It is still unclear to me what the final mass fraction to orbit will work out to be, but something that is 100% re-usable is better than something 60% reusable[1].

[1] Estimate of Falcon 9's booster + fairings being 60% (by cost, not by mass) of the launch package.

  • vl 2 days ago

    It looks like they delivered 50 tons today. Even if it stays this way, it will still reduce price to orbit significantly.

    • cubefox 1 day ago

      Unfortunately the payload margins continue to be much lower than what they were aiming for at various points.

      Originally they aimed for 150 tons of payload to LEO for Starship V1. Then they lowered that goal to 100 tons. But then Starship V1 only managed to achieve approximately 0 tons, which prompted them to target 100 tons for a larger, more powerful Starship V3 (and 200 tons for Starship V4). But now Starship V3 only achieves around 50 tons to LEO, based on the estimated weight of 26 Starlink V3 satellites.

      I think the main issues were that Starship dry mass continued to be heavier than expected, and that the Raptor engines performed lower than they thought they would. Elon Musk recently said the Raptor V3 engines could only reliably achieve 230 tons of thrust per engine (a measure of force) instead of the originally projected 280.

      • scottyah 1 day ago

        > Starship V1 only managed to achieve approximately 0 tons

        Are all of these comments comparing hypothetical production loads to small test scenarios?

        • Laremere 1 day ago

          Typical rocket tests will have dummy mass to simulate a payload (if not some high risk tolerance university project). This is ideal because you want to test as close as possible to the real thing, including things like stress on the vehicle supporting the payload mass. So a vehicle barely making to orbit without any payload mass isn't a great place to be. Starship is being developed differently than most rockets, so they have time to get to the better place, but they're still not where they have stated they expected to be. Today's achievement was incredible, but it seems reasonable to temper the lofty statements previously made about this vehicle's immediate impact with statements of its actual capabilities.

          • fartfeatures 1 day ago

            Why? This is the worst version of starship and booster that will ever fly. It isn't unreasonable to look at the giant rocket factory they have produced and think "yeah, I reckon they will continue development at the lightning quick pace they always have done"

            • cubefox 1 day ago

              > This is the worst version of starship and booster that will ever fly.

              That is true for any rocket.

              Remember that Starship V1 was announced to have a payload margin of 150 tons to LEO, by around 2021 if I recall correctly. Now it's late 2026 and the payload is something like 50 tons. You may still call this "lightning fast", but it is far less progress than what we thought would happen several years ago.

              • fartfeatures 1 day ago

                The difference is the cadence. Also the rapid pace of development, they aren't afraid to change things and go through multiple blocks, getting data by flight testing and making improvements. Look at Vulcan Centaur and how long it has taken and compare it to Starship.

                "ULA began development of the new launch vehicle in 2014, primarily to compete with SpaceX’s Falcon 9 and to comply with a Congressional mandate to phase out the use of the Russian-made RD-180 engine that powered the Atlas V. "

                "The Vulcan Centaur conducted its first launch on January 8, 2024, carrying the Peregrine lunar lander as part of NASA's Commercial Lunar Payload Services program. Its second flight, conducted on October 4, 2024, as part of the U.S. Space Force's National Security Space Launch (NSSL) certification process, achieved its planned orbit despite the loss of a nozzle on one of the GEM-63XL solid rocket boosters, which resulted in reduced and asymmetrical thrust. Following a five-month review, the Space Force certified Vulcan for NSSL missions in March 2025. In February 2026, a second issue involving a solid rocket booster occurred, after which launches were paused pending investigation."

                Centaur has flown 4 times since 2014. SpaceX began active development of the Starship program in 2018.

                • cubefox 9 hours ago

                  Vulcan is not relevant to what we were talking about. Again, you can call it "rapid pace of development", but the fact remains that Starship performs much lower, at a much later date, than what we originally thought it would. Since hardly anybody really expected they would be that far off. 50 tons to LEO in 2026 vs 150 tons in 2021. The only lesson is that their announcements about future capabilities have to be scaled downward by a substantial degree, and their timelines strongly upward.

          • atombender 1 day ago

            What material are they using for dummy mass?

            • mr_toad 1 day ago

              Unsold Cybertrucks?

      • fartfeatures 1 day ago

        I have every confidence they will work this out. I would hate it if people benchmarked my code whilst it was still in development and extrapolated the future performance from that.

        • pavlov 1 day ago

          A rocket engine can't be optimized during its lifetime like software can.

          • fartfeatures 1 day ago

            Chamber pressure, mixture ratio, and throttle limits can be adjusted operationally within the hardware’s margins. Engines on reusable vehicles are regularly swapped, inspected, and replaced. Process changes, minor part upgrades, and material improvements get introduced into the production line.

            Flight data drives continuous tweaks to control software (throttle profiles, mixture ratio schedules, startup sequences, health monitoring). Those are software updates

            • cubefox 1 day ago

              But those are very limited changes. You can't eke out the missing 50 tons of payload this way. That likely requires a significant redesign of the current Starship hardware, in which case they probably have to test a lot of things again (as we have already seen when they went to V2 and V3).

              • maccam94 1 day ago

                Due to the tyranny of the rocket equation, actually relatively small changes to the engine can result in substation payload gains by allowing more thrust and reducing gravity losses. Even just minimizing the amount of fuel left for boostback can result in tons of extra payload mass. I'm not saying that every rocket could do that, but Starship was designed for 100T+ of payload, and if it's not capable of that at the moment it is likely due to being overweight or engines not being able to put out the amount of thrust in the specs. From what I've seen, it sounds like a bit of both right now. The V3 engines are obviously a massive change (look at the comparison pics against V2 if you haven't seen them!).

                • cubefox 14 hours ago

                  > Even just minimizing the amount of fuel left for boostback can result in tons of extra payload mass.

                  Yes, but this time they actually had too little fuel for landing left in the booster, as confirmed by Elon Musk on Twitter. It ran out of methane, and they couldn't catch it. So next time they have to be more conservative, which would reduce payload mass even further rather increase it.

                  • fartfeatures 12 hours ago

                    They don't necessarily need to be more conservative. They need to be more efficient. The two are not the same. A more aggressive approach to the tower (e.g. doing the suicide burn late) might actually result in less fuel usage not more.

                    • cubefox 12 hours ago

                      Elon Musk said they would do the booster main engine cut off slightly earlier. Which would result in more fuel in the booster but less in the upper stage, which could lead to a reduced payload margin. Certainly it wouldn't lead to an increase.

                      https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2121648438144024943

          • pfdietz 1 day ago

            I want you to look at the evolution of the capacity of Falcon 9 over its various design iterations. There certainly was a lot of optimization leading to substantial growth in capacity.

        • falserum 1 day ago

          Not being able to achieve arbitrary number (e.g. 200 tones) does not detract from achievements of engineering.

          But not everything is achievable just because we want to achieve it. Physics/chemistry also have a say in it.

          • fartfeatures 1 day ago

            Well said. I'd also add not everything is unachievable just because it hasn't been done yet. A lot of people won't even update their priors once something is done (belief perseverance). I've lost count of the number of older people that tell me electric cars won't work whilst there is a perfectly functional one sat on my driveway.

      • ChuckMcM 1 day ago

        Yes the mass fraction is much lower than they were aiming for and the question remains, what is the eventual cost per ton to orbit? There are many paths where Starship can fail and few where it can succeed.

        This is part of 'watching the evolution' I find so interesting.

        Getting the booster up and back, that was just 'scaling up' F9, but it also many 10s of engines firing at once which was a problem that vexed the Soviets. With the last 3 launches have 33 engines start and nearly all of them staying lit, that seems manageable? Certainly within reach of becoming reliable.

        "Flipping" from drag flight to powered landing for a propulsive landing. The power of the rockets works against you, how do you keep from shooting off sideways? Not to mention significant control surfaces encumbered by heat shielding.

        Heatshielding itself, the bigger the mass you're returning the more energy you have to dissipate with the heat shield, we knew you "could" do this (shuttle proved it) but the shuttle's tile system was hard to maintain and delicate. Could you make that resusable?

        Separating the booster and the Starship while minimizing velocity loss. Hot staging was known, it caused a couple of Russian rockets to blow up, and NASA put it on the shelf, SpaceX made it work. (at least well enough for now)

        Propulsive landing on a piece of equipment. This was, for me, one of the more interesting adaptations of F9, landing on a barge stationed to catch you out at sea. "Catching" the rocket was a huge step, but necessary because the mass cost of landing legs on Starship is really really high. (only works on the Moon or Mars if you can refuel in orbit since you need do decelerate those legs to landing speed.

        There are still a number of challenges to go, on orbit refueling is likely the biggest one. You both need an orbital cryo-fuel tanker and the means to send fuel to it, and get fuel from it.

        Big picture though is:

        * IF you can reuse the stack a number of times

        * IF you can lift at least enough mass to assemble in orbit.

        * IF you can refuel in orbit

        Then you have the basis for building infrastructure in orbit. There is another "IF" which is whether or not you can do that without damaging the planet. Specifically what are the externalized effects of rockets going up out of the atmosphere on the planet's ability to remain stable (atmosphere, climate, Etc.)

        As others have pointed out, doing all of these things was on the NASA 'roadmap' at one time (my grade school self read about how I was going to be able to take a vacation at a Lunar hotel by 2025, and on Mars by 2050. But yeah not so much) the reality it complicated and I love watching a talented engineering team knock down obstacles.

        • cubefox 8 hours ago

          Regarding the shuttle heat shield, it was reusable, but required extensive refurbishment. The question remains how much refurbishment the Starship upper stage will need. For true "rapid" reusability, it arguably couldn't require any real refurbishment at all, only a visual checkup. This might not be possible with ceramic tiles, which are brittle and tend to fall off during launch.

          A passive (like VentureStar) or active metallic heat shield (or some of both) would be more robust. But those have never been used in production, and would require considerable research time and effort, apart from open questions like the mass penalty.

      • ACCount39 22 hours ago

        They already went from 20 mass simulators to 26 sats, and it's very likely that they have more headroom. For this specific flight, they clearly prioritized Starship fuel margins over just about everything else.

        • cubefox 12 hours ago

          It is highly unlikely that they have anywhere near enough headroom for the missing 34 satellites of the 60 advertised satellites.

          > they clearly prioritized Starship fuel margins over just about everything else.

          That is not clear. Indeed, there is no indication that this is true.

          • ACCount39 11 hours ago

            They left S1 with hair thin margins and got burned by that. In the meanwhile, S2 had fuel to spare and had to vent down during reentry. It's very clear where the priority was.

  • throwaway2037 1 day ago
        > Had they put another couple of tonnes of propellant and oxidizer on the Booster they might have caught both of them.
    

    Can you explain this part?

    • ericd 1 day ago

      They called it off because it was running lower on fuel than they expected - the margins are crazy thin. You can see a green burst of flame near the end, which is what happens when you run oxygen rich/fuel poor (also called "engine-rich" - iirc the green flame is copper from the engine as the oxidizer-rich mix causes it to run hot).

    • hackeraccount 1 day ago

      I think it's a supposition that the reason they didn't catch the booster was that it couldn't get back to the chopsticks. I don't think SpaceX described the issues as that ... it would seem sort of strange if it was because the seemingly planned a catch for it so you'd think they would have a good handle on the fuel required. It's possible they didn't fully understand that requirement though.

BiraIgnacio 2 days ago

To everyone who works at SpaceX and read this. You are all amazing.

I hope other great minds at SpaceX are well remembered into the far future.

  • arbituro 1 day ago

    Agreed its a great time to be alive!

DarmokJalad1701 2 days ago

Insane achievement! It is the dawn of a new era! One that has been 10+ years in the making.

  • abixb 2 days ago

    I still remember watching Falcon 9 (Block V, iirc) successfully landing back on land (as opposed to droneships) after deploying Orbcomm OG2 satellites in December 2015 -- almost 11 years ago.

    It blew my teen mind.

    This day marks a fabulous advancement for the human species.

    • giancarlostoro 2 days ago

      We went outside in our Orlando office to see the flair up in the sky, and then were looking for the re-entry, by the time we could figure out where it was our coworker said it was already standing upright.

      • ethbr1 2 days ago

        I was at Canaveral for the double booster return (Heavy?), and it's unbelievable the velocity those things come back down at, with the powered deceleration.

        A few seconds after the sonic boom, you're seeing them cancel out the last of their velocity and land on the pad.

        One of those 'it can't possibly be that big because nothing that big could be moving that fast' optical lack of reference moments.

        • somenameforme 1 day ago

          Yeah I think people that have never seen one of the beasts just can't imagine the scale. Fully 'assembled, the height is upwards of 120m - 70 on the booster, 50 on the upper stage. So it's something bigger than a football/handegg field going into space and something still in the same ballpark coming down at near freefall, then slowing itself, and landing on a spot with a margin of error of a few meters.

          • jaggederest 1 day ago

            To put it into perspective, it's taller than the Statue of Liberty including the base.

  • bahmboo 2 days ago

    I'll be that guy: they still have to fly it again. That's the real question. Incredible achievement. We got used to landing and caught boosters real quick!

    • randallsquared 2 days ago

      This was a huge milestone, but you're right that there are a long list of future milestones: catch both on the same flight, reuse of both on a given flight, fly without significant refurbishment, fly N times in T time for many values of each, orbital refueling, crew, etc.

      • m4rtink 2 days ago

        Definitely! But for thr record, they did reuse the first stage previously.

        • bahmboo 1 day ago

          Sorry my friend they have never reused a starship booster.

          • zaphoyd 1 day ago

            The booster from flight 7 flew flight 9

            • bahmboo 1 day ago

              doh, you are right, my bad, I even searched it. can't delete the comment.

          • sbuttgereit 1 day ago

            "Flight 9

            On May 27, 2025, Starship’s ninth flight test successfully lifted off at 6:36 p.m. CT from Starbase, Texas. The flight test began with the first Super Heavy booster to be reflown starting up successfully and completing a full-duration ascent burn with all 33 of its Raptor engines before separating from Starship’s upper stage in a hot-staging maneuver. During separation, Super Heavy performed the first ever deterministic flip followed by its boostback burn." -- https://www.spacex.com/updates#flight-9-report

  • kpil 2 days ago

    I'm still not really convinced this is better than a space-shuttle style landing.

    Seems like the same design principles that goes into Starship could create a version with more aerodynamic surface.

    Is the idea that Starhship will be considered safe enough for human crews?

    • fastball 2 days ago

      Do you think Space Shuttle landing is equivalent because you like all the extra weight and complexity of a landing gear, or because you like having to build a giant runway?

      • zugi 2 days ago

        Unnecessarily snarky but 100% correct!

        Of course, being able to land on runways gave the Space Shuttle more choices for emergency landings than needing a chopsticks catcher.

        That said, the Space Shuttle holds records for the most humans killed in spaceflight, and the most expensive cost per kilogram to LEO.

        • fastball 1 day ago

          There weren't too many runways available to use as backups given size requirements, so I assume if/when they start doing human starship launches they will have multiple chopstick towers and therefore have near-equivalent emergency backup capability.

          • rplnt 1 day ago

            > if/when they start doing human starship launches

            I don't think this is happening with the current design. If there's a human version of Starship, it would have to have meet some safety standards. Namely abort options on launch and safe failure modes on return. I can see a Starship with a classic pod on top, but no way this design carries humans from/to earth.

            • mr_toad 1 day ago

              NASA human rating requirements don’t apply to a private flight. There aren’t as yet any specific regulations governing private crewed space flights.

              • rplnt 1 day ago

                Ah, TIL. But still, even private company (or their high paying customers) wouldn't want to take the risk. And using proven design for humans might be easier than to solve all safety issues with the whole Starship. Also, they still have to solve non-starlink cargo deployment too I think?

          • labcomputer 22 hours ago

            > There weren't too many runways available to use as backups

            In particular, because the shuttle used an all-but-obsolete terminal guidance system, called Microwave Landing System (MLS).

            While MLS was intended to be the "next generation" instrument landing system (to replace VHF ILS approaches) for the entire national airspace system, MLS was basically only ever installed at a few runways intended as Shuttle abort locations, and Shuttle was basically the only aircraft that used it (aside from some other NASA test aircraft used to validate MLS approaches, and a couple other one-off airports).

            It's a shame, too, because MLS is pretty technically interesting, allows other-than-straight-in approaches, and offers horizontal, vertical and high-precision distance guidance all in one package.

            But the point is that Shuttle had very slim margins, so the fact that it landed horizontally very explicitly did not mean it could land "anywhere": It required an MLS approach. The plan for situations where an MLS runway was not available was to have astronauts bail out at altitude.

    • GMoromisato 2 days ago

      Was Space Shuttle safe enough for human crews?

      Space Shuttle was a compromised design from the beginning. They originally wanted the Space Shuttle booster to also have wings and return to launch site (with a crew!). But they couldn't afford to develop two new vehicles, so they compromised by making the external tank as cheap as possible and adding solid rockets (which led to the Challenger disaster).

      But their biggest mistake was having the engines on the orbiter (so they could be recovered) but not the fuel tank. That meant the orbiter had to hang on the side of the external tank, which made it vulnerable to foam strikes (leading to the Columbia disaster).

      Landing with wings is aesthetically pleasing (compared to tower catches) but consider the waste: You have to boost the weight of the wings, landing gear, etc. all the way to orbit and then bring it all the way back. It's much more efficient to just bring fuel and use that for landing. And if your guidance is accurate enough, a pinpoint landing means you can land on the launch tower and not worry about landing legs.

      • m4rtink 2 days ago

        For the shuttle there was also a lot of interference from the Airforce, which forced them to have a massive payload bay, so AF could launch and service their big Keyhole satellites (and possibly snatch Soviet ones in one orbit without warning).

        Then there was pressure to make use of solid propellants to amortize their use with military uses, not to mention pushing for Shuttle carrying all payloads for the US.

        This together created the dangerous and expensive design tHat was STS.

        • ethbr1 1 day ago

          People give the USAF shit about influencing the shuttle specs, given the capability was never used...

          ... but a lot of those were set in 1968 - 73, when relationships between the US and Soviet Union were very different than the late 80s.

          Given the development and operational timelines, it wasn't a bad bet to cover needing that military capability, had things turned out differently between the two superpowers.

          • literalAardvark 1 day ago

            > given the capability was never used

            I don't think the period is entirely declassified? If it ever will be

            • m4rtink 1 day ago

              Sure, some Shuttle missions are still classified, but a partial orbit mission would definitely be noticed if they ever did it.

              Given they launch in full view of many people, not from behind a fake mayan temple in the middle of the rain forrest.

        • LorenPechtel 1 day ago

          The solids were not a fundamental problem.

          Challenger blew because the joint was designed to always be in compression--but it went into tension during the twang. After the headlines they paid attention and fixed it.

          • jiggawatts 1 day ago

            Congress insisted on the boosters to be made in other districts distant from the launch sites, so they were forced to make them in segments instead of a single continuous tube welded together permanently.

          • GMoromisato 1 day ago

            The risky thing about solids is that you cannot abort them. Once they light, there is no turning them off.

            Shuttle always started the main engines for a few seconds (wasting fuel) to make sure the engines worked before lighting the solids. But there were many engine-out scenarios after the solids were lit that would result in loss-of-crew.

            • m4rtink 1 day ago

              There are some ways of turning off solid motors - you cen blow off side panels to drop the pressure inside and either stop combustion or make the thrust negligible.

              But tjis was IIRC used on single stick ICBMs and won't be really applicable for anything more delicate.

            • LorenPechtel 1 day ago

              Solids or no, there were a lot of engine-out scenarios that would cause loss of crew. There were substantial parts of the flight where the orbiter wouldn't have the energy to reach a runway.

              And the whole dispersed engine system of the Shuttle made any sort of engine out quite dangerous due to imbalanced thrust. When the engines are all right next to each other it's much more resilient against the failure of one, but the Shuttle would be in trouble if it lost any of it's three legs.

          • summa_tech 1 day ago

            I'm not a huge fan of perchlorate based mixtures like the SRBs. Perchlorate ion is kind of interesting in that it behaves a bit, but not exactly, like iodine. Biochemically, it means thyroid attempts to process it like iodine but fails. In adults that's reversible, but in children it can cause permanent developmental issues.

            Incidentally, presence of perchlorates is also one of the main concerns with martian soil.

            At least a hydrogen or methane explosion is quite clean, even cleaner than kerosene.

        • panick21_ 1 day ago

          It wasn't actually the Airforce, it was a group of consultants at the white house who forced it. But even without that, many of the bad choices had already been made by then.

          > Then there was pressure to make use of solid propellants

          As far as I remember the decision was based on development costs (like most decisions).

      • hparadiz 1 day ago

        I tend to think that for human rated flights it may be possible to give it a parachute just in case powered descent is not possible for any reason as a precaution for a belly flop water landing with parachute assist. The flaps are already there too so maybe just increase their size is possible for a glidable descent? We're entering a size class for the vehicle that makes some outside the box stuff possible without sacrificing too much in terms of payload capacity.

    • trothamel 2 days ago

      The space shuttle was aerodynamic for a very specific reason - they had to do a mission (that never happened) where they would launch, deploy a spy satellite into a specific polar orbit, and return back to Vandenberg Air Force Base in California in a single orbit. The result was a requirement for a lot of cross range, which needed large wings that hurt its performance a spacecraft.

      Starship doesn't have that - and so it can be much more optimized for it's purpose. It's basically tanks with a cargo bay and control surfaces, while the shuttle had to toss it's tanks away every flight.

      • m4rtink 2 days ago

        IIRC this could also snatch a satellite using the same profile, with no warning.

        Also some in the Soviet leadership were very scared the shuttle could carry nukes clandestinely, then during an ostensibly routine mission change inclination using its wings and decapitate Moscow with no prior warning.

        • ethbr1 1 day ago

          Well, that was essentially the later-stage X-20 Dyna Soar mission, as well as its follow-ons for a fews years after.

          Until each side accumulated enough ICBM nukes that it was clear mutually-assured destruction would dominate.

        • WalterBright 1 day ago

          > change inclination using its wings

          Wings are useless in a vacuum.

          • m4rtink 1 day ago

            Well, of course they are. But you can dip into the atmosphere at an angle, use it to change your inclination, then boost back to orbit (using the OMS in Shuttles case). Sure, you need to do it just right to not loose too much speed or even burn up due to overheating.

            But if you could pull it off (and Soviets apparently beleived it was possible) you have an unique capability not really available to regular satellites l, where low orbit quick plane changes are basically impossible with any realistically available delta-v.

    • somenameforme 1 day ago

      There's many objections to this, but a major one is that the entire vision for Starship is Mars and other terrestrial bodies. If you create something optimized for Earth, you have to start over from scratch for another planet. And vice versa if you create something specialized for another planet.

      An adaptable retropulsive landing system, by contrast, is fit for duty just about anywhere. In the long run you'd just need the atmospheric/planetary specs, a flat hard surface somewhere, and it'd be able to come down on it safely.

    • tiborsaas 1 day ago

      It's in their name: space shuttle, star ship. One is commute to space, the other is a cargo ship. Freights are also safe to carry humans.

codeulike 2 days ago

I like that they wrote "dont panic" on the fuselage above the s42 badge

  • hdgvhicv 2 days ago

    Did it carry a towel?

    • Xorakios 1 day ago

      And were Vogons banned from the mission?

      • cryptonector 20 hours ago

        SpaceX does not have an infinite probability drive yet, so no need.

  • extraextra 1 day ago

    I guess it has to be a reference to A Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, which is one of Elon's favorite books. In the story, the answer to life, universe and everything is 42, and the guidebook carries “Don’t Panic” on its cover. The ship is S42, so the match is clear.

GMoromisato 2 days ago

Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right: fully reusable booster without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster).

The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.

Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.

The future we were promised in the 1970s is about to become real.

  • enraged_camel 2 days ago

    >> Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line. They can build a booster ever 4 weeks and a ship every 2 weeks.

    Note that they are also scaling up production in a big way, because they want to launch weekly soon, and then daily. Not sure if we will get to the latter anytime soon but I'm also not going to bet against Elon.

    • bluescrn 1 day ago

      When Falcon 9 was making its early landing attempts, I'm sure people would have struggled to believe that they'd soon be doing over 120 launches+landings per year with very few mishaps.

  • mk_stjames 2 days ago

    The Space Shuttle took 2 people into orbit on its first launch and returned them safely to earth. On the first attempt. On the first test of any of the hardware into space. In 1981.

    Starship did not and has not done that and until it does I will continue to hold reservations.

    I do not see this Starship and its mission profile ever being a human-rated system in this incarnation, ever.

    A really cheap way to launch mass into LEO? Sure, I'll give it that.

    • nsoonhui 2 days ago

      > I do not see this Starship and its mission profile ever being a human-rated system in this incarnation, ever.

      May I know why ? And if the feat was done by NASA or China, would you change your conclusion?

      • echoangle 2 days ago

        The system architecture seems to be more fragile than simple capsules with parachutes or even the shuttle (which was already pretty dangerous). There’s no parachute, if you don’t hit the tower during landing you’re in a lot of trouble (unless they can soft-land the ship without the tower and without the bottom exploding?).

        • xixixao 2 days ago

          “the system is more complicated” is not a good argument for it never working.

          A passenger airliner is vastly more complicated than a parachute, yet both work.

          (You’re also in a lot of trouble if you don’t hit the runway in an airliner)

          • echoangle 2 days ago

            The problem isn’t “it’s more complicated” but more “if something goes wrong there’s not a lot you can do”. There’s basically no redundancy and a lot of single points of failure. Having two sets of Parachutes is a lot harder to screw up than a powered landing.

            With a normal capsule, you have multiple fuel tanks and redundant RCS thrusters so you’ll practically always be able to deorbit and land (since you also have redundant parachutes). If starship has a fuel leak, how are you going to land, even if you’re able to deorbit?

            • GolfPopper 1 day ago

              If they reach the launch cadence they're aiming for, the fix for a lot of things is going to become "just send another Ship".

              • macintux 1 day ago

                That's not an answer to the "is this safe for humans?" question.

              • nine_k 1 day ago

                Gliding into a large body of water, or maybe just a flat stretch of land? Planes do that sometimes.

                • WalterBright 1 day ago

                  Gliding into the ocean pretty much means you're dead.

                  There aren't many flat stretches of land.

                  • nine_k 1 day ago

                    There are plenty of flat stretches all over the world: in Arizona, Kansas, West Siberia, Mongolia, all over Sahara, Egypt, Sudan, north of Argentina, etc, etc. There's no need for more than several dozen km. If a out-of-fuel Starship can still maneuver with its rudders, it can likely slow down enough for a rough landing.

                    As of the ocean, given low waves and the airspeed of say 200 km/h, most likely the craft will withstand it if it has withstood the reentry. At least one Starship demonstrated some limited seaworthiness.

                    • WalterBright 1 day ago

                      The "miracle on the Hudson" was an incredible landing. Water landings pretty much never go that well. The usual result is the drag on the landing gear causes the nose to dig into the water or tears a wing off, and then the passengers (if they survive that) have mere moments to get out before it sinks.

                      • nine_k 1 day ago

                        My point is that the Starship not only lacks landing gear and large wings, but is explicitly built to withstand much more serious lateral loads during re-entry. It's much less likely to be torn. Of course, that would be a dangerous emergency landing with a higher chance of things going badly wrong, but, unlike for an airliner, I think a Starship has a fair chance to remain intact after an unpowered descent and a splashdown.

                  • bumby 1 day ago

                    Sure there are. The Shuttle even landed at White Sands NM due to weather. There are contingencies for exactly that sort of thing.

                    • WalterBright 1 day ago

                      Watch the videos of airliners veering off the runway onto flat ground which wrecks the airplane. The landing gear is designed for flat hard runways, not soft bumpy ground.

                      • bumby 1 day ago

                        Are you implying it doesn’t work on areas like White Sands? History begs to differ.

                        • WalterBright 1 day ago

                          Try that in Washington state.

                          • bumby 1 day ago

                            Why would a spacecraft be limited to Washington State?

                            • WalterBright 5 hours ago

                              What I responded to: "Planes do that sometimes"

                              • bumby 4 hours ago

                                But that statement was in response to a spacecraft launch comment. The OP even clarified they were talking about Starship.

                                Ie since this is an entire thread about Starship, it should be read as “why can’t a spacecraft land on large open land areas like planes do”. So it’s weird that you think the pertinent point is about airplanes in Washington state and not about Starship.

                                There’s plenty of reason to have good-faith debate on that. But like so much of this thread, people are having different out of context conversations because…reading comprehension is hard, I guess. Or it’s ego just needing to be right. But either way it makes for boring conversation.

                      • nine_k 1 day ago

                        Wrecking the plane is an unfortunate consequence; the important part is that the passengers remain alive and mostly not even badly hurt.

              • fooqux 1 day ago

                Problems detected during orbit? Sure.

                But during landing? You can't send another ship to rescue the crew that is aboard another Starship that just failed being caught.

          • computerex 1 day ago

            An airliner has layers upon layers of safety redundancies.

            There are multiple flight computers. Practically every essential sensor has copies. Oxygen generation, ram air turbine, life jackets, inflated boats. Onboard radar. TCAS. The airplane itself glides. Then there are thousands of procedural rules and regulations for safe operation.

            A system like starship that relies on precise active propulsion has no such room for error.

            • gertop 1 day ago

              You've clearly padded your list to look more negative because your last sentence only applies to the glide part... Starship obviously has the same redundant flight computers and sensors and radar and TCAS and will have thousands of procedures for safe operation.

              • computerex 1 day ago

                I was responding to the parent, explaining the layers of safety in an airliner.

                And you missed the point. The airplanes wings give it a passive way to glide down. Parachutes also give a passive way for a capsule to fly down. Starship has no such system, either the propulsion works or the rocket just falls out of the sky. There are thousands and thousands of different ways that the propulsion can get screwed up.

                Launch vehicles with capsules have redundant escape systems. If the vehicle during ascent is malfunctioning the crew can escape and safely land. In starship the crew will just blow up and die.

                Starship is NOT man rated so let’s see what SpaceX comes up with. But one cannot ignore the glaring issues with the design.

                • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

                  Starship is its own escape system during ascent.

                  • computerex 6 hours ago

                    Source? I don't think what you are saying is true.

      • Retric 2 days ago

        Starship’s been in development for over two decades and the design keeps being changed and failing.

        Soyuz has a very impressive record, Starship has been horrifically mismanaged by comparison. The falcon heavy flew 14 times and SpaceX is all in on a heavy launch vehicle because what? Even if they hit every target perfectly from now on it was a wasteful project.

        • xixixao 2 days ago

          The design changing and the development _failing to meet its stated deadlines_ is not a good argument for the system never working. Especially given we know the deadlines were unrealistic to begin with, yet significant milestones have been achieved in (deadline-ignoring) impressive time frame - like landing a second stage rocket from orbit within 8 years of development (by a private company, not a national effort).

          • Retric 1 day ago

            Not paying off isn’t the same thing as never working.

            Opportunity cost is a real thing. The obvious alternative buying stock (or handling out dividends to investors who buy stocks) would have created a new revenue stream larger than a working starship in 2027 represents.

            Thus even if nothing else fails, the project was a poor investment. The market just isn’t big enough that making launch cheaper would be worth it at this point, profits might grow in the future but the deficit keeps growing in the meantime.

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              Starlink alone is big enough to make the development worthwhile.

              • Retric 11 hours ago

                Try and run the numbers to actually support that position, including the possibility of increasing the reaction mass on each satellite to extend service life as well as increasing competition from terrestrial services.

                And again the opportunity cost of 20+ years of development is way higher than the nominal cost of the project.

        • bluescrn 1 day ago

          Falcon 9 had numerous landing failures early on.

          They're averaging over 2 successful launches+landings per week now, and it's so routine that nobody cares.

          • shagie 1 day ago

            An addendum to this is that Falcon's 85th launch was Demo-2 (30 May 2020)... 10 years after Dragon Spacecraft Qualification Unit.

        • DarmokJalad1701 1 day ago

          > Starship’s been in development for over two decades

          What? The first version of something that looks anything like Starship was the ITS announced back in 2016, later "BFR" in 2017 and the stainless steel version (which is now flying) in December 2018.

          Eight years is very reasonable for a fully reusable heavy lift system - something no one has built before.

          The Space Shuttle took roughly 12.5 years from formal concept studies to its first flight (and 9 years from official program approval)

          • nine_k 1 day ago

            Space Shuttle was an even harder project. Amendments to the Starship project were all directed towards making it fly better. Modifications which various departments demanded from the Shuttle project made it a worse and worse spaceship. They even had to let go of the emergency recovery capability, which eventually led to death of 10 astronauts.

        • WalterBright 1 day ago

          > Starship’s been in development for over two decades and the design keeps being changed and failing.

          Look at the change in airplane designs over the years.

      • mk_stjames 2 days ago

        It would not change my conclusion at all.

        If you asked me if I wanted to return to earth on something that glides like a plane and lands on a runway with no propulsion... or a pressure vessel that needs it's engines to work perfectly to get you back to a single spot at the pad, within a few meters, to be 'caught', and if that doesn't happen, you hit the ground vertically and explode...

        I know which one I'm taking. Yes I know the shuttle had no 'go-around' as a glider. But wings and wheels and a big runway in the desert.... versus the insane acrobatics of Starship...

        We haven't seen how Starship would deal with crosswinds in the atmosphere being predicted wrong. What happens when it knows it is off course on the way down and can't make it back to the pad? If there were people onboard? I assume there would be a contingency where it just vents fuel and hits the ground and hopes to act as a crush-can at terminal velocity but I don't know how people survive that. By comparison, ditching the shuttle like a plane with an engine-out failure seems easy by comparison.

        I am not demeaning the amazing achievement of the Starship and its booster and this ability to catch it and reuse it. I think that is indeed an amazing achievement that should be celebrated. But I don't see this as being a thing to put people on that can somehow be intrinsically safer than the Shuttle, just yet. These are just my basic opinions, I think they are opinions with some merit, and I don't feel that deserves downvotes.

        • emkoemko 1 day ago

          that's not going to happen, Artemis is using Orion with parachutes to land in the ocean

        • piloto_ciego 1 day ago

          I mean, I could see an option being a detachable landing pod for human missions. Or, more crazily, and I'm not sure of the dimensions but some space-plane like the Dream Chaser or whatever that could fit in the cargo bay then deorbit separately after it's done it's mission? There's a lot of ideas. And we're going to learn so much about how to do reusability now that we just didn't know before. But I would not be surprised if some cockamamie version of this wasn't human rated eventually.

          Obviously, we're a really long way away from that from a reliability standpoint? But you know, if they launch 10,000 of these over the next decade... we're going to know a lot more about the safety of this design. I'm sure they'll clobber one in to mechazilla eventually? But what if they don't?

          • WalterBright 1 day ago

            Incredibly safe airliner travel today is the result of learning from thousands of crashes.

            • piloto_ciego 1 day ago

              And just a culture of continuous improvement!

              (I flew for a living for over a decade)

        • Tuna-Fish 1 day ago

          > We haven't seen how Starship would deal with crosswinds in the atmosphere being predicted wrong.

          Winds are not a significant factor in the trajectory of the ship. Reason is that it spends almost all of it's time very high, above all weather, and only descends to the less stable areas of the atmosphere at the very end, when it's in a vertical belly-flop, going very rapidly through all the different weather layers. You can see this clearly in the return video, at 2 minutes before landing it was still 15km up. And when it's high, it has much more ability to steer by adjusting drag than any winds can move it up there.

          What could actually be a problem is sudden high winds or other problems at the landing site. The ship commits to a landing when it does the deorbit burn ~60m before landing. at L-20m, it has about 1000km of cross-range capability, at L-10m only 200km, and after that it goes down quickly, with only 50km at L-5m.

          If it's coming back with something valuable, you'd better have plenty of divert options.

        • computerdork 1 day ago

          Hmm, interesting question. Just brainstorming there, but it seems like there are going to be specialized versions of starship: - a tanker (for in space refueling) - a moon lander

          Could see one that is specialized for taking humans into space and then returning them to Earth. It could have a dedicated abort vehicle that takes over the top half of the ship (similar to the abort vehicles they have now on most human-rated rockets). And maybe it uses landing legs instead, because they're more fault tolerant than a catch tower. All this might take up a ton of weight, but starship can carry so much tonnage to space, they'd probably still have a lot of tonnage left for humans and cargo.

          Yeah, it could be pretty amazing, able to to take hundreds into orbit instead of just a handful.

        • dlcarrier 1 day ago

          Two of the 135 total SLS (space shuttle) launches were destroyed. Two of the last 600 Falcon 9 boosters were destroyed on landing.

          If I had to ride along in one of them, I'd choose the Falcon 9 booster over the space shuttle.

          Also, the Columbia failure occurred because it was a glider. The Starship doesn't have any leading-edge tiles for debris to fall onto. Arguably, the Challenger failure also occurred because it was a glider, which required the odd fuel tank and booster mounting that failed.

      • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

        Because it blows up more than gets into orbit.

        • gibolt 1 day ago

          You're saying a development rocket that is pushed past the expected limit fails? Amazing...

          Even taking you seriously, it has made it to effective orbit more than it has exploded. Nearly all 'landings' have exploded, because that's what happens when you intentionally land a 30 story building full of fuel in the open ocean

          • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

            > You're saying a development rocket that is pushed past the expected limit fails? Amazing...

            Where did i deny it was not a work in progress ?

            So why pretend it is a success until it is ready ?

            > Nearly all 'landings' have exploded, because that's what happens when you intentionally land a 30 story building full of fuel in the open ocean

            Thanks for agreeing with me.

    • GMoromisato 2 days ago

      Huh? Space shuttle killed 14 astronauts. It was a flawed design from the beginning and never delivered on its original promise.

      Starship has its own design trade-offs, as any engineered object does, but it has the benefit of 50 years of technological development since Shuttle.

      I'm not as certain as you about whether or not Starship will ever be human rated. But if successful, it will be launching a couple of hundred times per year. Talk to me in five years and we'll see where we are then.

      • cucumber3732842 1 day ago

        I don't think it makes sense to make starship human rated. They'd likely give up too much. Probably better to have a different cheaper rocket for the people.

        Like you don't build a barge to ferry standards, it would defeat the point of the barge.

        • GMoromisato 1 day ago

          Maybe you're right--I don't know. But large freight airplanes are the same as large passenger airplanes, except for the seats, etc. I think the same might be true for Starship.

          • kevin_thibedeau 1 day ago

            Freight airplanes have additional reinforcement to increase max takeoff weight and manage uneven floor loading.

        • ericd 1 day ago

          Starship is a lot cheaper than it looks, because they're mass manufacturing the engines. They're targeting $250k per Raptor 3. The RS-25 used on NASA's SLS/Space Shuttle costs about $100M to make currently, comparable thrust.

        • snvzz 1 day ago

          I'd rather have something that's well-tested before I put people in it.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          But what if the barge is ten times cheaper than the ferry to run?

      • lawsthro0532 1 day ago

        The most damning thing I've seen on starship was a video that described how little space there is inside for the humans Elon said it would hold. Something like urban transit personal space.

        • marcusverus 1 day ago

          Reeeally scraping the bottom of the grievance barrel there.

        • sobellian 1 day ago

          That is practically all spaceflight. The Apollo LEM - which landed on the moon - had ~2.3 m^3 per person. The command module had ~2 m^3 per person. There is nothing unusual there and depending on how you configure the interior it could be relatively spacious.

          • lawsthro0532 1 day ago

            I believe the question was lack of space for food and water to go to Mars.

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              That’s just wrong - one Starship has more payload volume then the ISS.

    • xixixao 2 days ago

      How is incremental development and testing related to human-rated flight?

      As is, your comment has a bold claim backed by seemingly unrelated fact.

      • mk_stjames 1 day ago

        My comment was in reply to the parent comment saying "Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right" , and my claim is that this is not the case, that comparing Starship to the Space Shuttle is a category error, in that I don't see Starship actually being replacement for the Shuttle as a human-transport vehicle, and thus it cannot be considered 'Space Shuttle done right'.

        • oska 1 day ago

          > that comparing Starship to the Space Shuttle is a category error

          Both are second stages that return from orbit to Earth. Seems a pretty valid comparison on these fundamentals to me.

          (Yes, I know you're extending the comparison to human-transport but that is not fundamental to their ability to take payload to orbit and return, as the Starship can fly without on-board pilots.)

    • Quarrelsome 2 days ago

      isn't the whole "we put a human into space" symbolic anyway? There's no air up there. If we had a full supply chain of robots that brought us back regolith from the moon wouldn't that be more useful than being able to send a person up there?

      • colechristensen 1 day ago

        nah humans going is the point. the science is interesting but not of that tremendous value. we don't view archaeology as the highest human endeavor do we?

        • piloto_ciego 1 day ago

          It can be both, right? Like, we can put humans there and expand the resources available to humanity immensely by sending teams of robots out to manufacture the future habitats, etc.?

          Personally, I'm looking forward to joining the Elench. Humans are allowed to join the Elench aren't they?

        • p-e-w 1 day ago

          What exactly is “the point” of humans going there, other than science? Telling a hero story that ignores the contributions of hundreds of thousands that made this possible? Gratifying a few mammoth-sized egos?

          • colechristensen 1 day ago

            You have to start with a justification for "the point" of human life at all which is a struggle with some people who only see utility in whatever their equivalent of a quarterly balance sheet is (this includes publishing papers in academic journals).

            • p-e-w 1 day ago

              I don’t understand why justifying human spaceflight supposedly requires grand philosophical ramblings about the meaning of life. Justifying brushing your teeth doesn’t require that either, does it?

              • colechristensen 19 hours ago

                Why humans expanding into space is important depends on being able to answer the big picture of why exist at all because they're the same answer.

                If the meaning of your life to you is some short term success metric that lasts only into the immediate future there's nothing to discuss.

                If you have a big picture idea of why life is important then honestly it's probably pretty likely that you already get it and we already agree. So I mention the big meaning of life stuff and if the response is "why does that matter?" it means the argument is pointless because some people have little vision beyond their own close horizons.

          • d0mine 1 day ago

            What is the point of humans here on Earth exactly? Some consider that humans can be replaced by AI today/in near future. Should we just give up and live space to a more advanced civilization?

    • lacker 1 day ago

      The shuttle had a 2/135 death rate. If Starship becomes the core infrastructure for Starlink, it'll be able to afford hundreds of launches before putting humans on it. You won't have to trust some theoretical calculations, you'll just be able to see in practice what the risk of a Starship launch is.

      • p-e-w 1 day ago

        More importantly, those deaths were both caused by substantial design flaws, not by freak accidents.

        Bad things happen, and spaceflight is a hard problem. But that’s not what killed two Shuttle crews.

        • stickfigure 1 day ago

          Design flaws that you don't know about yet are still design flaws.

          I'm sure there are plenty of "accepted design flaws" in SpaceX vehicles. Hopefully SpaceX engineers are better at calculating the probabilities than NASA was, but I would not volunteer for early missions.

          • 1123581321 1 day ago

            The two programs don’t manage risk the same way. You’re picturing a younger NASA trying to do the same process as led to the first space shuttle launch.

          • dlcarrier 1 day ago

            With the Challenger disaster, the contractor's engineering team that developed the booster gave a no-go for launch and NASA administrators showed off their engineering skills by using social engineering to trick an unqualified and unapproved employee of the contractor into signing the form to go for launch. That's far worse than being bad at calculating the safety risks; the specifically overruled the decision by the people that were good at calculating the safety risk.

            Source: Truth, Lies, and O-Rings by Allan J. McDonald, James R. Hansen, and Jonathan Yen

      • sterlind 1 day ago

        dumb question, but at what point does the cost of fuel start to become an issue with such frequent launches? today I imagine launch cost is dominated by the price of the nonrecoverable parts, but fuel will become the floor no?

        • GMoromisato 1 day ago

          Yes, but it's an order of magnitude difference. Today a Falcon 9 launch cost ~$20 million, mostly because they throw away the second stage.

          Propellant for a Falcon 9 launch is ~$500K.

          • gorkish 1 day ago

            Starship is more efficient than F9 but in terms of multiple launches per day, the supply chain is indeed a factor. An hourly launch cadence is going to consume roughly as much natural gas as Houston.

        • gorkish 1 day ago

          All back of envelope here just to get a rough order of magnitude:

          Starship needs 10kg (0.5mcf) of methane and 36kg of oxygen per kg to orbit. The oxygen takes 22kWh to liquefy or about (0.16mcf to generate that onsite). So 0.66mcf/kg to orbit and 66,000mcf from to fully fuel.

          That is the daily gas usage of a midisze city, say 200k population, per launch.

        • computerdork 1 day ago

          For liquid oxygen, Spacex is building an air separation plant at its facility in Texas to grab it from the air.

          For methane, didn't know this but looked it up, methane is one of the cheapest propellants, but rocket grade methane needs to be purer (starship is estimated to cost $300k to $1 million to refuel)

      • arzig 1 day ago

        Isn’t starship supposed to be integral to the Artemis project in say… a year.

        • modeless 1 day ago

          Sure but it doesn't launch or land humans on Earth, which is the hardest part. And that's fine for now. Once it's launched and landed a few hundred times we can think about launching people on it.

          • adastra22 1 day ago

            For political reasons. SLS is far less safe a vehicle than Starship, but it is injected into Artemis for political reasons.

            • Tuna-Fish 1 day ago

              Eh.

              I like the rocket less, imho solids have no place in human spaceflight, but the Orion has a LES, which elevates it to being more safe than any spacecraft without one.

              • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

                Which makes the SLS safer than the Shuttle but airliners also don’t have one. They are considered safe because of how much they have flown and that is how Starship will be determined safe enough.

            • modeless 1 day ago

              I'm a big Starship fan but I'm not convinced it's safer than SLS yet.

              • adastra22 1 day ago

                Liquid fueled rockets are intrinsically safer than solid fuel rockets. There is a floor on just how low you can get the risk level with solid fuel, you can't test the rockets you fly, and the failure mode is catastrophic blow-up à la Challenger.

                It's like saying flying is safer than driving per passenger-mile. It is. By orders of magnitude. I don't care how safe your new Volvo or electric vehicle is, flying in a helicopter is still safer, and a passenger jet vastly more so.

                "But Starship blew up 5 times!" Yes, and flying a test plane is dangerous too. Apples to oranges. Starship and SLS have vastly different design certification strategies. SLS spends 100x as much to deliver something that works as reliably as it ever will by the second or third launch. SpaceX gets Starship flying quickly and discovers bugs in prod. So you see more failures. But even now, Starship is probably safer than SLS ever will be. If not now, then very, very soon.

                • imtringued 1 day ago

                  You're telling me starship is safe for humans when they failed to land the booster?

                  How about we let them succeed first before pressuring them to perform and inevitably embarrass themselves because the silly SpaceX fans were too smug on the internet.

                  • adastra22 1 day ago

                    They’ve caught the booster multiple times. Also, people don’t fly in the booster and it was safely diverted…

                • grumbelbart2 1 day ago

                  SLS has an abort mechanism. That alone mitigates most risks of the first stage in a way starship never can, meaning the latter has to fight an uphill battle to deliver the same safety through flight numbers and experience.

                • enragedcacti 1 day ago

                  > But even now, Starship is probably safer than SLS ever will be. If not now, then very, very soon.

                  Any failure to orbit is essentially a guaranteed loss for Starship. Any booster explosion or total engine failure on starship would also be essentially a guaranteed loss. Even the space shuttle had better backup options than the current version of starship.

                  Idk about you, but if I'm the astronaut I'd take 1-(P(SLS failure)*P(LES/parachute failure)) over P(superheavy success)*P(Starship to orbit)*P(Raptor relight) every time.

            • enragedcacti 1 day ago

              SLS might be less safe than some hypothetical future version of starship, but in reality the current starship's most recent flight had a 15 minute window where a no-go for orbit was called and the mission plan would have resulted in a loss of crew. Safe crewed launches and earth landings are not a priority for them and likely won't be for a long time. Even then, SLS+Orion have the advantage of an LES and the option for unpowered landings essentially anywhere, both of which are fundamentally unworkable with starship's design.

      • 9cb14c1ec0 1 day ago

        Not only that, but Starship is a robust system from an architectural point of view (not saying they don't have some bugs to work out of it). As we saw in the previous launch, they can go to orbit with an engine missing. An engine down on the shuttle would have been a catastrophic situation.

        • thaeli 1 day ago

          The Shuttle did have limited engine out capability. The only in-flight engine-out (as opposed to a pad abort after SSME ignition and before SRB ignition, which happened five times) was STS-51-F with a successful abort to orbit. The various other engine-out contingency modes were never used, but they did exist.

          Initially only single engine out was broadly survivable; after the Challenger disaster new abort procedures were developed that made two engines out survivable during all of flight and even all three engines out at some points.

          The big caveat here is that most of these modes were never tested, and the risk of failure during the more demanding aborts was substantial. RTLS abort was famously not tested on STS-1 because it was considered riskier than going all the way to orbit on the Shuttle's first crewed flight.

      • dlcarrier 1 day ago

        To put it in perspective, the Falcon 9 has had 702 launches and has only lost one payload during launch. A couple didn't make it into the right orbit, but there's contingencies to deal with that in manned missions.

        Since 2022, there have been 601 booster landings, with two losses. (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Falcon_9_first-stage_b...) That means that if you could have snuck onto one of the last 600 Falcon 9 boosters, with appropriate life support gear, your chances of survival would have been over four times higher than if you had snuck into the cargo bay for an SLS (space shuttle) launch, and that's with the SLS being designed to be manned, unlike the Falcon 9 booster.

    • LorenPechtel 1 day ago

      Safely??

      The Challenger disaster could perfectly well have been avoided if they had been willing to look. There was a clear indication of substantial deviation from design and the joint could have been engineered to stay in compression during the twang.

      But Columbia was fundamental. There was an awful lot of insulation aerodynamically before the heat shield. Once again, multiple warnings, but keeping the insulation from being torn off while keeping the weight down was problematic. Columbia was the beginning of the end as they realized they couldn't sweep it under the rug anymore and they couldn't truly fix it.

      • Sharlin 1 day ago

        Challenger could also have been avoided simply by not launching in conditions that were known to be out of spec.

        • LorenPechtel 1 day ago

          Except there was no spec. The only temperature spec that existed was for the motor itself--and it had enough thermal mass that it didn't get too cold. No spec existed for the joints.

          And they didn't even realize the actual conditions. The ice team had taken temperature readings that showed the booster well below ambient temperature, these were dismissed as wrong. They weren't wrong, the weather that morning was calm enough the LOX boiloff was falling pretty close to straight down, cooling the booster.

      • georgemcbay 1 day ago

        > The Challenger disaster could perfectly well have been avoided if they had been willing to look.

        The tragedy of Challenger is that Morton Thiokol engineers did look enough to know that the O-ring design was likely to fail under cold weather conditions. This was already a known issue and the engineers specifically recommended that Challenger postpone launch because of the temperature at the pad the night before the launch.

        They got overruled... almost certainly for what amounts to political reasons as the big bosses didn't want to throw off the timing of the media-hyped "first class taught from space".

        Still remember watching the Challenger launch on a CRT TV propped up on an AV cart in an 8th grade classroom and it being a big deal that a teacher was going up in space.

        • apical_dendrite 1 day ago

          The decision to ignore the Morton Thiokol recommendation not to launch wasn't made at NASA HQ. There was a late night teleconference between Morton Thiokol, Marshall Space Flight Center (where the SRB program was managed) and personnel from Marshall and Morton Thiokol on the ground in Florida. The Marshall leadership put a lot of pressure on Morton Thiokol execs to withdraw their recommendation, and Morton Thiokol caved. My recollection is that it's unclear how much if anything was communicated to NASA HQ. These were the people who had taken over after von Braun's retirement, so very much from an engineering rather than a political background.

          I don't think that the "teacher in space" part was much of a factor in Marshall's decision-making. There was clearly plan-continuation bias, and there was a clear directive that Marshall should not be responsible for delaying a launch. The management style they had inherited from von Braun also meant that disagreement was highly discouraged. The data was ambiguous enough that they could convince themselves that everything was fine and Morton Thiokol was coming up with a new launch requirement at the last minute.

          • dlcarrier 1 day ago

            The person at Morton Thiokol who caved was neither qualified nor authorized to make the decision. The Morton Thiokol engineers said no, and their executives backed them up, but NASA administrators kept asking Morton Thiokol employees that were out of the loop, until they could pressure on into saying yes.

            There's a really well written and researched book on the topic, that I highly recommend, called Truth, Lies, and O-Rings by Allan J. McDonald, James R. Hansen, and Jonathan Yen

    • 2OEH8eoCRo0 1 day ago

      I concur. Everyone is acting like Starship is fully developed and finished and flying humans as we speak.

      • BHSPitMonkey 1 day ago

        I don't think anyone is saying that?

        • imtringued 1 day ago

          There was a guy saying Starship is safer than SLS right now.

          Since SLS's only human rated payload is Orion, that's basically saying that Starship can land on earth coming from the moon, right now.

        • 2OEH8eoCRo0 1 day ago

          Starship's theoretical cost and safety are being compared to the Shuttle, Apollo, and SLS.

    • tails4e 1 day ago

      I was just talking to my son about how absolutely incrediblw it was that apollo 11 1anded on the moon, and here we are we with by comparison unlimited compute and its launch 15 to do the first orbit. I absolutely get its a very different beast, and catching is amazing, but still, serious respect to the apollo program.

      • coryrc 1 day ago

        One cost, what, 30% of all government spending over several years?

        The other's total was less than just the Senate Launch System.

        • rootusrootus 1 day ago

          One was 60+ years ago, the other is built with knowledge learned from building the first.

        • ambicapter 1 day ago

          > 30% of all government spending

          In your fucking dreams. NASA’s entire budget has never been more than 4 or 5% gov spending a year.

          • PeterHolzwarth 1 day ago

            I appreciate your point and correction to who you are responding to, but that's not a very HN way of expressing it. You can do better.

          • coryrc 1 day ago

            You're right, I remembered wrong. Hence I left it a question mark. It was 4% during the moon race.

            https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Budget_of_NASA

            Many people don't know it hasn't been more than ~1% of the budget since 1975 (which I did remember, I just thought the peak was higher).

    • ikiris 1 day ago

      This is a weirdly pedantic hill to die on.

      How many people died in the nasa space program vs the Starship one?

    • nine_k 1 day ago

      The Space Shuttle program started in 1969, the first test fight happened in 1981, 12 years in. The first outline of Starship appeared in 2016, first kinda flight in 2022 (6 years), and a full-scale orbital flight, in 2026 (10 years). As a bonus point, it's nearly 100% reusable.

      It's not human-rated yet, but I bet that in 1981, at the height of the Cold War and with Star Wars unfolding, it would be.

    • throwaway2037 1 day ago
          > I do not see this Starship and its mission profile ever being a human-rated system in this incarnation, ever.
      

      Any sentence with such a superlative is bound to be wrong at some point. As they say in finance: "On a long enough timeline the survival rate for everyone drops to zero."

      Did you feel similar before the crewed SpaceX Dragon 2 flew successfully?

    • philwelch 1 day ago

      And because the government said the shuttle was “safe”, six astronauts and a schoolteacher got blown up in front of millions of schoolchildren five years later. The Shuttle never should have been a human-rated system.

    • WalterBright 1 day ago

      It's much cheaper to build a rocket, it blows up, find/fix the fault, send up another, it blows up, find/fix the fault, etc. It's much more expensive to spend endless time checking and rechecking everything.

  • elif 2 days ago

    "fully reusable" is highly aspirational.

    They have barely reflown a handful of tiles, and have not reflown any engines.

    Essentially, the two things you'd expect to break will probably still break.

    • swalsh 2 days ago

      You're allowed to compliment technical achievements, even if its done by a republican.

      • bigyabai 1 day ago

        It's done by thousands of people, who are employed by a republican.

        Reducing their work to the (self-serving) political alignments of the CEO is a big part of the optics issue.

        • p-e-w 1 day ago

          Given how Americans tend to self-sort into political castes, I suspect that the majority of SpaceX employees are now ideologically aligned with their CEO. Working there would be too risky for them otherwise.

          • bigyabai 1 day ago

            That may well be true, but it doesn't really change my point.

      • elif 1 day ago

        You got me figured out completely. I hate Elon so much I have watched every launch stream since 2010, own stock in his companies, buy his car with $10k beta software, and voted as a shareholder to give him the biggest pay package in human history.

        I hate him so much I'll even agree with his quote from this year saying that “Starship Version 3, I think this design can be fully reusable.”

        • GMoromisato 1 day ago

          Don't sweat it. Lots of Starship fans (myself included) are overly sensitive because there is so much bad-faith criticism out there.

          Still, I think you're discounting the accomplishment here. Boosters have reflown after a catch, so re-usable engines is already demonstrated. And heat shield reuse is going to be iterative: the first few will require lots of work, but they will keep improving until the tiles last for many missions.

          But you can't iterate if you don't get the ship back in one piece. That's what makes this accomplishment important.

          • elif 1 day ago

            Way more engines have blown up during their first use than have been reused.

            Calling it a fully reusable vehicle is just fantasty.

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              And a lot of those were deliberately blown up because they were testing. Do you think crash testing cars should count against the car’s reusability?

              • elif 18 hours ago

                None of the engines have failed deliberately.

                You are conflating the loss of boosters with the failure of individual raptor engines.

    • pokstad 2 days ago

      Landing the damn thing (and almost landing the booster) seems to point in the general direction of full reusability.

      • SecretDreams 1 day ago

        It's like how F1 cars can make it through the full track, but will need a new engine pretty regularly.

        Something something Ship of Theseus.

      • GolfPopper 1 day ago

        My understanding is that the real fly in the ointment has been that Starship isn't anywhere near its target payload capacity, and it may be difficult to get it there. I don't know if that's changed with this flight or not.

        • timschmidt 1 day ago

          This launch put 50T in orbit, which is half the stated goal. If it never improved past this, it'd continue to be the largest and least expensive heavy lift rocket into the foreseeable future.

          • literalAardvark 1 day ago

            > half the stated goal

            It's 1/4 of the design goals though. Pretty massive haircut.

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              And Falcon 9 doubled its payload over its development history as the improve it.

              • literalAardvark 1 day ago

                Sure, that'd make it 1/2 the design goal.

                I've no doubt that they will try to improve it, and it's excellent as is, but it's way under what the initial design expected it to be.

        • somenameforme 1 day ago

          Due to the nature of spaceflight, payload tends to be around 1-3% of total mass. You don't tend to max payload during testing for stuff you expect to have a reasonable chance of going boom.

        • dan_grec 1 day ago

          This was the third heaviest payload ever put in orbit. None of the others had a reusable first stage, second stage or fairings, so they cost vastly more (throw away the entire stack each launch)

          Even if they never increase it from here, this is an enormous achievement and success.

        • ggreer 1 day ago

          That's because when launching from Texas, they have to do a dogleg maneuver to avoid populated islands such as Cuba. If they launch from Florida, they claim they'll get 100 tons.[1]

          > Flying Starship from Florida, he said, will further improve capacity compared to Texas launches. Launching from Florida offers more favorable trajectories to certain orbits, potentially allowing Starship to carry more satellites without expending propellant on dogleg maneuvers. Dontchev said a single Florida Starship launch will be able to carry up to 20 times the bandwidth of a single Falcon 9.

          SpaceX currently claims that each launch is 10x the bandwidth of a Falcon 9 launch, and is 50ish tons of payload, so launching from Florida would be around 100 tons of payload.

          1. https://arstechnica.com/space/2026/11/spacex-now-fundamental...

    • maxdo 1 day ago

      They did fly reused engines a year ago

      • elif 1 day ago

        Yes. But not the engines they are flying now.

        • computerdork 1 day ago

          Kind of a strange response. Yeah, most people would think spacex will eventually be able to reuse v3 of the raptors too.

          • elif 1 day ago

            Which is exactly why I called it aspirational rather than actual.

      • elif 1 day ago

        That's like saying a 2026 F150 is safe because a 2023 trim passed a crash test, despite a full overhaul of all the crash structures taking place in between

        • computerdork 1 day ago

          hmm, think it's more like saying a newly redesigned f150 will eventually pass the crash test, because it's basically 80% the same design as the previous generation. It might be in 2027, but if not then and the engineers keep at it, then in 2028 or 2029.

      • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

        Only booster engines though. What remains to be seen is how the vaccuum raptors hold up for reuse - pretty brutal temperature cycling.

  • Rapzid 2 days ago

    Space shuttle was a reliable recovery vehicle too.

    I see a need for maintenance crews and large payload recovery in the future.

    Starship doesn't seem like the tool for that, and no tool is in development for it TMK?

    • colechristensen 2 days ago

      no reason you couldn't make a starship with a cargo bay for recovery, it would just cost a considerable amount of payload mass

      • Rapzid 1 day ago

        Sure, and the starship is just a scaled up falcon with more raptors..

        But here we are 12-15 years later and it's still not operational.

        This would require it being safe for and having facilities for crew. Tool and machinery for service and recovery. The vessel would need to handle re-entry stress with return payloads on board. The heat tiles would need to support the extra mass. The vehicle capture system. Etc. Etc.

        Could it all be built on the starship "platform"? Maybe.. One day. But that day is not this day.

    • nickff 1 day ago

      Recovery never paid dividends for Shuttle, due to satellites' degradation in orbit, and SPCX seems to have driven the industry even further from 'exquisite systems'. I love the idea of in-orbit servicing, but I am not sure it will ever work for unmanned objects.

      • Rapzid 1 day ago

        The economics and use cases have and are evolving.

        I don't see this as "space shuttle done right" as a vehicle or "program" without the ability to carry out maintenance and recovery missions. As expensive as it was, for various reasons, it was actually used for those missions.

        For example I don't think "space data centers" are going to work if the upgrade path for the hardware is vaporize it all and replace it vs recover and recycle/resell.

        • tintor 1 day ago

          I don’t believe economics works for upgrading of space data centers. Sunlight is free, you can still use it with prev generation gpus just fine.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          Recycling costs money and reselling isn’t worth it so ground data centers won’t be different.

    • pigpop 1 day ago

      Once you get mass into orbit it's more economical to keep it there so rather than recovery to Earth it would be better to build the facilities in orbit to perform maintenance, refurbishment and refuelling. Starship should make that feasible.

      • grey-area 1 day ago

        That is predicated on it being expensive to get mass to orbit.

        • pigpop 1 day ago

          Getting mass out of orbit is also expensive, if you want it to reach the ground in one piece at least.

    • mrandish 1 day ago

      > and no tool is in development for it

      The more cost effective approach is now repair-in-place. Startups in early orbital testing include Starfish Space (autonomous satellite life extension, orbital repositioning/inclination changes, and active debris disposal) and Katalyst (Multi-arm robotic capture, hardware upgrades, and orbital repositioning).

      • j4k0bfr 1 day ago

        The question on my mind is; does repair-in-place make economical sense for commercial satellites?

        Old-space satellites are expensive, so on-orbit repair theoretically makes sense here. The largest obstacle to cost-effective repair in that domain is the one-off nature of these vehicles. This means each repair mission requires R&D, manufacturing, and testing before launch. So for this method to be effective, the repair mission needs time before any faults become lethal. I'm not super confident about resuscitation either; off-nominal thermal/power can cook electronics beyond repair. Plus, any RPO mission risks accidental damage.

        And on the other hand, new-age satellites like Starlink are build cheap(er) and designed for replacement. Why bother with repair when you can just build and launch another?

        It seems like you're also a satellite repair nerd, so I'd love to hear any thoughts you might have :D

        • notahacker 1 day ago

          the satellites are life limited whether they have noticeable faults or not (mostly by the remaining propellant, but also by TID radiation and payload obsolescence), and any sensible repair-in-place mission aims to proactively repair satellites near the end of their practical life rather than reactively responding to issues. The robotics (and fluid transfer for refuelling) are basically there, you just need satellites with an architecture that enables repair/replacement/refuelling to move beyond demonstrators. And most satellites are not built in that way.

          As for whether it's worth it, it depends a lot on the satellite and the orbit. Starlink: probably not worth upgrading. Geostationary satellites: there's a reason why what goes up there commands oldspace prices (long way up, intensive radiation environment) and that reason also justifies serviceability. Hypothetical LEO datacentre with most of the mass being solar panels and radiators that last a lot longer than the chips are commercially relevant: yeah, probably makes sense to have the chip payload swappable and the thrusters refuellable.

          A mission for one satellite to repair a lot of others is complex (it's basically an extra-hard version of the travelling salesman problem) but when the alternative is inserting many entirely new satellites into n orbits, sending a tiny fraction of the mass to n orbits via a reusable servicer starts to make a lot of sense...

          • Rapzid 1 day ago

            Exactly, the scale and scope of payloads is increasing as launch costs are decreasing.

            If starship launches ever get anywhere near the 2m-10m claim.. Suddenly fixing or retrieving that 500m-2bn satellite. Or rotating the compute modules on that 150bn space datacenter constellation..

            Honestly I could envision regulation requiring it at some point.

    • gibolt 1 day ago

      It could conceivably capture near-dead satellites and bring them back, deorbit them, or send up a payload of multiple repair ships.

      The cost to launch may get to the point that it is cheaper to replace than repair, and we can build 10 of a satellite instead of 1 bespoke unit per program.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        What about recovery as a means of espionage? One of the Shuttle use cases floated was to recover Soviet satellites and other tech like film imagery.

        • adastra22 1 day ago

          That’s what the X-37 is presumably for.

          • edot 1 day ago

            X-37 can and has launched in a Falcon Heavy.

      • verzali 1 day ago

        Is that possible within the prop margins?

    • adastra22 1 day ago

      I don’t see the need, but why isn’t Starship a fit for that?

      • Rapzid 1 day ago

        Because it can't do it?

        • adastra22 1 day ago

          I see no reason it can’t?

          • Rapzid 1 day ago

            Other than it can't? Where is evidence? It's not there yet.

            • adastra22 1 day ago

              It can fly up, back, and has payload capacity in both directions.

  • fenwick67 2 days ago

    The space shuttle is infinitely sexier sorry

    • ericd 1 day ago

      Yep, this thing is the beat up Toyota Hilux to the Space Shuttle's hand built Ferrari. Still reminds me of the first flying grain silos.

      But a fleet of Hiluxes is a whole lot more useful for actually getting shit done than a couple Ferraris.

      • labcomputer 20 hours ago

        To me, it's much more impressive engineering feat for Toyota to stamp out a million identical Rav4's every year at prices every American can afford, than for Ferrari to hand-build a few dozen cars where price is no object.

        • ericd 18 hours ago

          Yeah, I'd agree. Each one isn't as beautiful, but the machine that makes them in such huge quantities and to such a standard of reliability is more interesting than the one that makes the Ferraris. I'd say that's true for the setup to make Starships en masse vs. the Space Shuttle, too.

    • oska 18 hours ago

      Pure anecdote but I was around for the early days of the Space Shuttle and never found it particularly appealing (and at an age where you are more likely to be wowed by such things). But I find the Starship very appealing, both in its design conception and just visually too.

      The Shuttle landings were the one thing I remember being pretty cool at the time, but again, the way that the Starship manoeuvres itself in for a catch is way cooler, to my mind at least.

      p.s. I'm not a US American. I feel like the Shuttle was hyped up to the US population quite a lot. Maybe that's part of why I seem to see things differently.

  • k0morebi 1 day ago

    Incredible, had no idea they were assembled so quickly.

  • mag7269 1 day ago

    Private industry tends to be far more efficient at making “stuff that works” than a non-profit governmental organization.

    Even for all the genuinely good and smart people that worked for NASA over the decades, the bureaucratic machinery that makes it run eventually becomes so convoluted, corrupt and bloated for its own good.

    I should know; I worked there for over a quarter of a century. Nothing beats the private industry for “making shit that works.”

    • hn_throwaway_99 1 day ago

      I really think it depends. For long running projects with high ongoing costs like a launch vehicle, I agree. The issue with government projects of this type is that they eventually turn into jobs projects, and that can compromise the main goals of the projects.

      But NASA has had some phenomenal successes in their science expeditions - the Webb Space Telescope (and its Hubble precursor, despite its need for "glasses"), the Mars rovers, Voyagers, etc. Those projects would have largely been impossible in the private sector because there is no monetary return.

      • WalterBright 1 day ago

        > Those projects would have largely been impossible in the private sector because there is no monetary return.

        Sell the data you get back from the probe.

        Many of the Age of Exploration endeavors were funded by non-government institutions for various reasons, such as getting an exclusive on the story and selling newspapers.

    • atwrk 1 day ago

      > Private industry tends to be far more efficient at making “stuff that works” than a non-profit governmental organization.

      If that were true, then why doesn't the US have a single high speed train?

      NASA projects are well-known to be expensive because they, similar to military procurement in the US, are handled like inofficial job creation projects involving as many states as possible.

      • TacticalCoder 1 day ago

        > If that were true, then why doesn't the US have a single high speed train?

        Because building/modifying rails crossing many states and cities means having to deal with a unending shitload of bureaucrats at single every level of power.

        While sending something up straight in the air and then into space means all those little bureaucrats from all those cities/communities/states do not get a say in the matter.

      • BurningFrog 1 day ago

        A big reason for the lack of new US trains is that it's very hard to buy all the needed land under the US system.

        In most of the world the landowners have far less rights.

        The decade(s) long environmental reviews of every piece of land used for the project is also a huge force agains any such projects.

        If the legalities were handled, I expect US train builders would excel at building high speed trains. In reality, we'll never know.

        • dboreham 1 day ago

          Apparently it's also a problem for people building ICBM silos.

          • BurningFrog 8 hours ago

            Is that some new brand of survivalist?

      • xnx 1 day ago

        > If that were true, then why doesn't the US have a single high speed train?

        Planes are faster, cheaper, safer, require much less infrastructure, go anywhere to anywhere, scale elastically with demand, and have less emissions per passenger mile than high-speed trains.

        • notahacker 1 day ago

          > and have less emissions per passenger mile than high-speed trains

          The optimal high speed train is about two orders of magnitude more efficient than the equivalent flight on a passenger mile basis. Might look a little different for crossing oceans or thin routes where it's really not worth building a thousand miles of rail to replace a flight a day, but lack of demand between nearby cities or is not why the US doesn't have any high speed rail network...

        • jacobolus 1 day ago

          > Planes [...] have less emissions per passenger mile than high-speed trains.

          This claim is not even in the right ballpark.

        • atwrk 1 day ago

          Not really. I just traveled 1400 km (875 miles) by train in under 6 hours, hotel room to hotel room. Though not in the US, of course.

          Planes are faster only when ignoring the time at/to/from the airport.

      • dlcarrier 1 day ago

        The US rail network was created by private industry, including both freight and passenger. This included many of the fastest passenger trainsets at the time, like the Zephyr. In 1971 the US nationalized passenger rail into Amtrak, and Amtrak stopped using off-the-shelf trainsets and managed the development of their own, similar to NASA developing the Space Launch System (the space shuttle) for their use. At that point, the US started falling behind on rail speed records.

        In short, the US had stuff that works, including the fastest trains, when run by private industry, but after nationalizing the industry into a non-profit governmental organization, they stopped producing stuff that works.

        • atwrk 1 day ago

          In 1970 other countries already had state-owned 130+ mph train networks (Germany, for example). Again, the idea that those things can only be done right through private companies is ideology, not fact-based.

          Not intending to derail (hah) the thread, but with trains there just are more examples to look for vs. rockets, while still being broadly comparable. In about 6-7 years we can look to China for a comparable, public project with Long March 9 and 9b.

        • panick21_ 1 day ago

          US rail network was created by the US government giving gigantic land grants and loans to railroads and used their army and influence to make sure nobody could stop them.

          > they stopped producing stuff that works.

          No they reluctantly nationalized a broken industry well past its profitable time and then refused to invest anything into it.

          Any development needs investment. If you nationalize and don't invest, of course you will not produce anything new.

          While when you nationalize and you do, you might produce something new, just like in private industry.

          The technology behind high speed trains literally came from British Rail technology development center and was then used by Japan. Both done by government.

          I don't understand why on HN the debate between public and private has so cliche and on a level of 3rd graders. Its obviously way more complex than that in the real world.

          • harshaw 1 day ago

            +1 "I don't understand why on HN the debate between public and private has so cliche and on a level of 3rd graders. Its obviously way more complex than that in the real world."

            This was a topic I wrote papers about in middle school and HS.

    • bumby 1 day ago

      This is an overly simplistic take. In many cases, the private industry moves and innovates faster. In many others, it injects its own forms of waste (regulatory capture, profiteering over mission, etc)

    • lazyasciiart 1 day ago

      Then why didn’t private industry beat NASA to all the space milestones?

      • xnx 1 day ago

        No profit in going to the moon or putting people in space.

      • dlcarrier 1 day ago

        The government was the customer, so it was up to them to decide what to do in house and what to hire out. They chose to manage the project in house, creating specific design requirements and contracting out work to meet those requirements, not to create the designs.

        Private industry did do most of the work, but they had no leeway to influence the design. Even when they tried to make choices, e.g. Morton Thiokol's Engineers' no-go decision on the Challenger launch due to low temperatures, NASA administrators effectively overrode that decision, by directly calling unqualified employees at Morton Thiokol, until they found one they could pressure into giving a go.

      • s1artibartfast 1 day ago

        Who do you think designed and built all those NASA ships that made the space milestones? Mostly Boeing, Rockwell, and Lockheed

    • tancop 1 day ago

      Corruption eventually starts in every organization, when the workplace develops an informal but strict hierarchy where the only way to get ahead is impress someone who matters.

      Most federal agencies have been running for 50+ years so they're further along than a company that started 10 years ago. You can't just start a second NASA to compete with the first one. Private companies also become corrupt but they can fail and get replaced.

      I think the biggest factor behind it is misaligned benefits. In a state agency you're paid out of a fixed budget so there is no incentive to work harder or push for changes. But it's the same in a corporation where shareholders and top executives capture profits.

      The only permanent way out is make workers collectively responsible for outcomes. Set up an independent employee owned agency that takes fixed price contracts from the government. That way it's guaranteed to never go over budget, and they will often deliver ahead of time so they can take on a new contract sooner.

  • barbazoo 1 day ago

    It'll become real whether we want it or even benefits us or not. Nothing we can do but trust the billionaires.

  • don-bright 1 day ago

    Challenger and Columbia were caused by Normalization of Deviance and groupthink. How did they solve those problems?

    • late2part 1 day ago

      Elon. Government is groupthink and normalization of silos and tolerance of incompetence. Elon forbids either.

      • trismus 1 day ago

        Elon lies about being a good path of exile player, like a 10 year old might. What else do you think he's lying about?

      • late2part 1 day ago

        I can't reply to your question "what else is he lying about." Jensen's a good person and apparently likes sex with people other than his wife.

        Your ad hominem attack doesn't take away from my point.

      • kenferry 1 day ago

        The same Elon who keeps promising things his companies cannot deliver and obviously exerts incredible pressure on his underlings? You think that doesn't create incentives to claim things are better than they are?

        • jeswin 1 day ago

          > The same Elon who keeps promising things his companies cannot deliver and obviously exerts incredible pressure on his underlings?

          Failing to deliver a ReactJS + web services project, and failing to catch a steel cylinder weighing thousands of tonnes, full of combustible liquids, hurtling down from space with two metal arms mounted on a pole are two different things.

          If you're a billionaire and not failing enough times doing absolutely crazy things, that's a net loss for humanity. I want billionaires to fail 80% of the time. Heck even 100x millionaires should be failing a lot.

          • cheonic639 1 day ago

            > If you're a billionaire and not failing enough times doing absolutely crazy things, that's a net loss for humanity. I want billionaires to fail 80% of the time. Heck even 100x millionaires should be failing a lot.

            Ah, yes. Others should do more for society so I can benefit!

            You should just get straight to the point: you want higher taxes on those wealthier than you.

            • jeswin 1 day ago

              Quite the opposite, I was actually defending people who make super risky bets.

          • gertop 1 day ago

            I'd rather billionaires not exist at all, personally. Before you say something absurd like "SpaceX wouldn't exist without billionaires" I suggest you check the timeline. Falcon 9 was operational before Elon Musk officially joined the 10 digits club.

            Innovation will always happen and Elon didn't personally inject billions into SpaceX either.

            Let's cap wealth at 999M and anything over the gets redistributed to poor entrepreneurs.

            • jquery 1 day ago

              Billionaires are the economic equivalent of software memory leaks.

          • kenferry 1 day ago

            When was Elon promising ReactJS projects? He promises cars, full self driving, etc. etc. Extremely consistently overpromises and underdeliver.

            Anyway, "I want billionaires to fail" is fine, cool, I probably agree, but the question being argued was "is Elon running things inherently safer than the situation that led to Challenger etc.". I do not agree with the idea that Elon's companies have a culture where it is safe and repercussion-free to report that things are busted.

            • jeswin 1 day ago

              > Extremely consistently overpromises and underdeliver.

              That's what I'm saying. Promising to deliver brain-computer interfaces and failing at it is not the same as, pretty much anything else.

              > I do not agree with the idea that Elon's companies have a culture where it is safe and repercussion-free to report that things are busted.

              And this is different from say Apple (or the majority of large corporates) how?

              • kenferry 1 day ago

                How is apple relevant? If you read up in this thread, the argument was that Elon is safer than NASA.

                • jeswin 1 day ago

                  I was responding to your broader statements, which as stated were not strictly about the original narrow context about Challenger. Every company has pretty much the same or similar repercussions with respect to speaking up/out. Apple, or say Timnit Gebru at Google.

                  > If you read up in this thread, the argument was that Elon is safer than NASA.

                  There's nothing to decide either way. There have been failures at his companies, and at the same time 13 crewed missions on SpaceX rockets without human casualties.

            • WalterBright 1 day ago

              > Extremely consistently overpromises and underdeliver.

              The idea is to set a goal to strive towards.

              What he has delivered is incredible.

              • bumby 1 day ago

                The problem is when internal stretch goals get communicated as business deliverables that drive stock price. There needs to be an expectation of good-faith for the latter.

                • WalterBright 1 day ago

                  The people who buy stock in Musk's companies are fully aware that promises of tech breakthroughs cannot be tied down to a schedule. Risk is inherent in any purchase of stocks, and risk is priced in to the share price.

                  If you want guarantees, that's what the bond market is for (and at a suitably low ROI).

              • ben_w 1 day ago

                > What he has delivered is incredible.

                Nah, what he promises is incredible.

                What he actually delivers (in space) is closer to what everyone else promises.

                Everyone else promises a lot, but the US and EU space sectors seem to only deliver pork barrels since I was a kid.

                I suspect we'd (not just US, I'm European) do a lot better if we supported a bunch of plucky space startups rather than the big old space companies, which is how SpaceX got its chance to shine.

                Musk may have always dreamed big, but with hindsight I'd say he seems to have disconnected from the possible around 2016 or so. Too big to fail, or something.

                • WalterBright 1 day ago

                  Musk has delivered far beyond what every other rocket outfit has done.

                  • ben_w 10 hours ago

                    Beyond, but not far beyond. Close enough to be what the others promise.

                    And even then, the Venn diagram isn't one entirely inside the other.

                    • WalterBright 5 hours ago

                      He's far beyond them, even though they were better funded and started much earlier.

                      • ben_w 33 minutes ago

                        Not really, and "better funded and started much earlier" is a red herring given how much material science and CNC has changed everything since then.

                        Given where it's at right now, Starship compares as a mere rough equal on timelines and actual delivery as the N1, Space Shuttle, and Saturn V. Where it might shine, eventually, could be a lot of things, but right now it's about in line with other similar vehicles, just with more pizzazz. The main thing that's changed? We can 3D print what used to be the expensive part.

                        The Falcon series did good; but the changes were incremental, standing on the shoulders of what came before, and what it got from that advantage was what the Space Shuttle promised.

                        I can and will criticise the old space companies for their pork barreling, but Starship currently looks closer wanting in on that, than like the SpaceX of a decade ago which made Falcon the success it is.

                        Would've liked to see them demo some of the forgotten ideas, like having Starship use evaporative cooling. But physics is physics, and re-entry is much the same pain as it's always been.

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              And yet Dragon versus Starliner. And Boeing was advocating for crewed return after being one thruster from losing control of Starliner. And they also made a pretty bad airplane. And NASA thought STS was safe and thought it was okay to fly every Artemis mission differently with different equipment even when they put people on it.

            • labcomputer 20 hours ago

              If you want the world to convert to EVs, they have to be built for less than people will pay for them. That is the only way for EVs to be sustainable.

              Can you name a single western car manufacturer that sells EV at a net profit (considering only the R&D and SG&A attributable to EVs for the non-pure-play companies)? AFAIK, it's only Tesla and BYD today. I'd say Elon has delivered cars.

              If you think that SpaceX is less safe than the Shuttle program, can you explain how Falcon rocket has had over 350 consecutive launches since the last in-flight failure (and only 1 failure out of 688 flights in the last 10 years), yet the Space Shuttle had two loss-of-crew failures in just 135 flights?

              It seems to me that observational statistics indicate that it is approximately 10 times safer than the Shuttle. And they did that while reducing the price of a launch (including the price we taxpayers pay for NASA launches) by a factor of 10. Again, I'd call that a check mark.

    • GMoromisato 1 day ago

      Normalization of deviance happened because there was so much deviance!

      The number of Criticality 1 issues on STS was incredible--literally thousands. Booster seal--yup, they knew about that; foam strikes? check; also turbine blade cracks, reaction control short-circuits, and hundreds of other problems.

      They couldn't fix them because (a) the design was locked--they weren't building more orbiters, and (b) Congress controlled the budget and the Shuttle was not a priority.

      The point of Starship is to build enough ships and fly enough missions that problems get fixed. And since losing a ship costs the company money, they have a strong incentive to fix the problems. That's exactly what they've done with Falcon 9, and the result speaks for itself.

      • dlcarrier 1 day ago

        It's more egregious than just knowing there were flaws. After Morton Thiokol engineers, the manufacturer of the boosters that failed in the Challenger disaster gave a no-go for the flight, because the temperature was too low, NASA administrators cold called a bunch of Morton Thiokol employees that weren't qualified to give go/no-go decisions, and most of them declined, until they found one that gave into pressure and gave a 'go' for launch.

        They actively forced deviance.

        For more details, check out Truth, Lies, and O-Rings by Allan J. McDonald, James R. Hansen, and Jonathan Yen

  • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

    Reusability is all about cost savings. The real question now is how much does it cost to turn Starship around for reuse - how much heat shield replacement, how do the vaccuum raptor engines survive the thermal cycling, what is the lifetime of parts involved in the catch mechanism, etc.

    In any case, a cool spectacle.

    • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

      So losing up 100 starships to reuse one that gets to the moon, is saving money ?

      • oska 1 day ago

        Please reread the site's Guidelines, as your participation in this thread indicates that you need to refresh them.

        https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

        • lightedman 1 day ago

          Ctrl+F "MiroSlav"

          read comments

          Which guidelines are they violating? Just because their commentary is unpopular with the usual shills doesn't mean they're violating guidelines at all. I'm certainly not seeing much at all that's violating any guideline.

          • oska 1 day ago

            > Be kind. Don't be snarky. Converse curiously; don't cross-examine. Edit out swipes.

            > Don't be curmudgeonly. Thoughtful criticism is fine, but please don't be rigidly or generically negative.

            > Eschew flamebait. Avoid generic tangents. Omit internet tropes.

            > Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work. A good critical comment teaches us something.

            > Please don't use Hacker News for political or ideological battle. It tramples curiosity.

          • imtringued 1 day ago

            The comment he is responding to didn't deserve the dismissal.

            100 launches per landing is wrong. It's 40 launches at most and even that is somewhat pessimistic because it assumes a return starship to bypass Orion.

      • talmr 1 day ago

        Perhaps they will lose 150, but eventually they will make 1000 that work.

        In order to get passing tests, they have to fail first.

        • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

          That not how science works.

          Hope is not physical reality.

          Something is only successful when success is delivered.

          • jve 12 hours ago

            Look at the light bulb above your head and think about what Edison said:

            “I have not failed. I’ve just found 10,000 ways that won’t work.” -Thomas Edison

            • MiroslavPokorny 38 minutes ago

              Of course they have to try, im not disputing that trying is a good thing.

              I do however have a problem with you assuming they will succeed.

              Take the idea of storing tanks in space with fuel for future use. This idea is very challenging and many have questioned if this even possible. As of today not a single starship has parked a tank in space. Given the iterative approach it will take many launches to put tanks in space and wait and measure to understand and fix problems. There is zero progress on this.

              There are many other big problems that need to be done in space and none of them have started.

              All these challenges will EACH take multiple if not dozens of launches to try an idea, wait and observe, study and learn, fix and relaunch. This is going to add up to at least a 100 if not more launches.

              Each step can only continue if the previous is solved reasonably well, so far we are clearly at the start and no where near 1 out of 10 phases and these have cost 40 launches as you state.

    • thaeli 1 day ago

      Cost savings are one of the drivers for reuse, but not the only one. Maximum practical flight rate is another. F9's peak flight rate over the past couple years would not have been attainable without first stage reuse, simply because of the manufacturing bottlenecks on stages. And fairing reuse was openly driven by a limited capacity to manufacture fairings fast enough - it's not even clear that SpaceX is overall saving money there, but they are saving time, and their business model is based around putting as much mass in orbit as they can as fast as they can.

      • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

        One interesting aspect to the need for flight rate is Starlink replacements ...

        The planned constellation size is ~40,000 satellites (they currently have ~11,000), and the designed lifetime of the satellites is 5 years. Replacing 40K satellites every 5 years means 8000 per year, which would be 160 launches per year at 50 satellites per launch - i.e. a sustained 3 Starship launches per week just to replace satellites.

        So, they'll need to be able to refurbish 3 starships (& boosters) per week, just to maintain the size of the Starlink constellation !!

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          No, they just have more Starships in the refurbish flow to accommodate the launch schedule. If you need to launch 3 a week, 6 will allow you to refurbish over two weeks and 24 will allow you to refurbish each for a month. There’s a reason they also designed a factory to make more Boosters and Starships.

    • bamboozled 1 day ago

      I thought the same, the catch was nice and impressive but I’d say it would be a fair bit of stress on the structure too. I’m guessing one day we will actually see these things have landing gears and not need a tower but until then…

    • bamboozled 1 day ago

      I thought the same, the catch was nice and impressive but I’d say it would be a fair bit of stress on the structure too. I’m guessing one day we will actually see these things have landing gears and not need a tower but until then…

      I get similar vibes to watching this spectacle to that of the “Tesla flying car” demonstration. Amazing stunt , but is that the primary goal ?

      • mrarson 1 day ago

        Landing gear is really really heavy. To compare it to a building, the upper stage is 17 stories tall and 700sqft crosssection (9m⌀). The rocket is top-heavy, so you have to have wide legs. Wide legs need big triangular structures that articulate outwards, which dramatically increase the load (torque = force*distance) needed to hold up the 17 story building without breaking when it hits the ground, and are complex and get in the way of all the engines.

        In comparison, adding more steel to the tower is effectively free. Additionally the hardpoints on the rocket are at the top (no top-heavy problem to deal with) and very close to the rocket, so the torque is minimal. And the hardpoints already exist, in the form of the attachments to the wings, which already need to be strong.

        It is crazy but... it makes some amount of sense? I mean we'll see landing gear when/if it gets to the moon, but there's a lot less gravity there.

        • bamboozled 1 day ago

          I actually screwed up, I mean the rocket itself, not really the tower :) But yeah, agree the tower is probably the more robust piece and you're right, the legs would be heavy and I guess "dead weight".

          I just find this reusable Starship thing pretty Elon, crazy impressive demo, actually a good concept, let's see if it truly goes "into prod".

  • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

    Let me know when Starship makes it to the moon. Apollo got there after 2 launches. and only had 1x problem and everyone got home.

    • nvch 1 day ago

      Launches are irrelevant. Much more useful metric is "total $ spent on the program before it makes it to the moon", not launches.

    • timschmidt 1 day ago

      That's funny, I count about 20 Apollo program launches before anyone went to the moon: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Apollo_missions

      And of course Apollo 1 incinerated it's entire crew.

      Seems like you're only aware of the highly publicized successes and not the difficult development history.

      What else might you be unaware of?

      • MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

        Peace to the men and families of Apollo 1.

        Sorry Apollo 1, 4, 5 and 6 were unmanned, 7 got men to LEO, 8 orbitted the moon and 9 landed Neil and Buzz.

        Starship is up to 15 and is not man rated nor has it achieved a moon orbit or moon landing.

        Which is the more successful ?

        • timschmidt 1 day ago

          So you're leaving out SA-1 through 5, AS-101 through 105, AS-201 through 203, QTV, Pad Abort Test 1 and 2, A-001 through 004, and the Mercury and Gemini programs before them to be intentionally deceptive? Or... just disrespectful?

          > Which is the more successful ?

          Who thinks like this? Who sees what I just saw and has this thought? A wasted opportunity for some wonder and joy.

          • MiroslavPokorny 32 minutes ago

            If you want to count those very different ancestors of the final Saturn V, then one can also argue that the falcon programs should also be counted as tried launches for Starship.

            The Falcon program is very much a part of the learning experience to had a direct contribution to technology and because of the limitations, the team at SpaceX designed Starship.

            So how many Falcon flights are we going to count for Starship ? Sure it could be said that the design has basically stopped being a contributor of technology to Starship but theres still at least a few dozens during the learning phase.

            If we aggregate some of Falcon and the current Starship program thats pretty close 100, and we are clearly not ready for even manned flight let alone the full program.

            https://www.reddit.com/r/RKLB/comments/1bep3si/spacex_raptor...

    • kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 1 day ago

      The Apollo 1 crew begs to differ.

      Also, Apollo had Gemini before it and Mercury before that. It was an iterative process.

      • timschmidt 1 day ago

        It's wild that Dunning–Kruger extends to rocket science and astronautics.

  • BurningFrog 1 day ago

    The reusable Starship will carry 100+ tons of weight or 1100 cubic meters of volume per launch.

  • bumby 1 day ago

    I agree this is a good approach.

    But the Shuttle became what it became for reasons that Starship doesn’t have to deal with. Shuttle had multiple masters (NASA and DoD) driving a bastardized design. The non-assembly line of NASA is a feature, not a bug: by spreading work across many congressional districts it mitigates political defunding risk. Im not defending those, but they are important context for those who pretend the differences are a signal of government incompetence.

    • ericcumbee 1 day ago

      not to mention shuttle as we knew it was never supposed to be its final form. the Block 1 Shuttles were more or less intended to be a MVP and they would follow along with Block II orbiters. But of course Block Two never happened, and we just got incremental updates of the block 1s.

      • adastra22 1 day ago

        Politicians don’t understand project development. “What do you mean we need to develop a new shuttle? We just spent billions on this one!”

    • shnock 1 day ago

      I understand what you’re saying, but in a larger sense the fact that distributing labor and increasing costs is necessary as risk-prevention against our own politicians is a sign of a broken system of incentives and representation

      • bumby 1 day ago

        Consider this: had they not, NASA may not exist. Considering Musk himself said SpaceX would not exist had NASA not bailed them out, it also means SpaceX likely wouldn’t exist. In other words, SpaceX also needed those distributed wastes, they just were externalities to the company. A broader context of the system is important when diagnosing systemic issues.

        • ETH_start 1 day ago

          For me the takeaway of all of this is that you need both government and private sector involvement to produce a thriving space industry.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            I usually agree that the hybrid approach gives the best outcomes. The govt is necessary when the risk is too great for private industry to bear and the private side tends to move faster on innovation.

        • dan_grec 1 day ago

          NASA did not bail out SpaceX.

          NASA paid SpaceX for a service, and SpaceX delivered that service on time and vastly cheaper than their competitors who were also paid by NASA (ISS resupply).

          In the case of transporting humans to the ISS, SpaceX did it vastly cheaper than the competitor who was also paid by NASA. That competitor has never done what they were paid to do.

          If there is anyone or anything to be angry at, it seems mighty strange to be angry at the company who actually did what they were paid to do when another company took much more money and didn’t deliver.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            Fair, “bailout” is not a good term for an era where taxpayers give loans to floundering companies.

            What Musk admitted to was NASA “saved” SpaceX with a last minute contract to prevent their bankruptcy. I would make the argument that SpaceX would not exist without all those early government contracts. It’s a shrewd business move: use a self-insured entity (the govt) when risk is the highest because it pushes the financial risk to the taxpayer, and gradually move to more privatized customers when risk is lower and insurance costs can make such launches economically viable.

            I do agree Boeing CST was not run well and I’ve thrown plenty of ire there way. But that is an entirely different argument and a bit of whataboutism.

            • dan_grec 1 day ago

              Taxpayers did not give a loan to SpaceX anymore than they gave one to any contractor they pay for a service.

              The government paid SpaceX for a service, which was delivered as promised. This happens hundreds of thousands of times a year with tons of companies being paid to do things for the government.

              • bumby 1 day ago

                I was clear that it was a contract that saved them from bankruptcy. A contract they could leverage for loans, but I clearly said contract. I wish HN would limit accounts that are very new and seem to misrepresent other posts.

      • awakeasleep 1 day ago

        You use the descriptor “broken system” to mean “the world is more complex than my fantasy of how it should be”

        • shnock 21 hours ago

          I don’t, but have fun ascribing convenient misinterpretation and licking boot

    • jstanley 1 day ago

      Isn't the fact that spreading work across many congressional districts is necessary rather evidence of government incompetence?

      That's not a mitigating factor!

      "Before you walk away thinking the government is incompetent, please remember that the government makes bad decisions on purpose" ??

      • brookst 1 day ago

        There’s a common theme in HN discussions where people mistake understanding a system for evangelizing it. Really nothing could be further from the truth.

        • 0x69420 1 day ago

          this is well and truly common all over the internet -- you explain how some system, something fairly non-technical even, say, a common social failing, some institutional bias or what-have-you, works, and you have a bunch of people go on the offensive as though you've just endorsed the thing. so you have to hedge practically anything with a token virtue-signal, even in communities where it's pretty strongly implied that you're on the same page about considering the thing bad.

          if you'll indulge a tangent, i can only chalk up the increase in this phenomenon over the time i've been online to the consolidation of online discussion to a handful of sites that have become ever more adept and efficient at creating filter bubbles. and it's always the sites where that hasn't taken root, where everyone's seeing the same thing, that then catch a reputation for being hellholes full of terrible people, because naturally, the majority of people engage with those sites not directly, but through screenshots shared on the major socials, and those major socials are incentivised to push you content that you engage with. then, as we all know, angry people click more. so of course as a user of one of those major socials, a majority of those screenshots the site pushes you end up being those that depict speech your own filter bubble cohort finds abhorrent. hn is actually subject to this dynamic a little bit.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        It’s evidence that they are solving different problems. Does the fact that Musk spends hundreds of millions on election cycles mean he’s incompetent, or he’s trying to mitigate a political risk you and I don’t have to deal with?

        • saretup 1 day ago

          Sure every system has its unique problems but when you cut to the results, one is clearly way more efficient.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            As said elsewhere, that simplistic take falls apart when you realize there would not be a SpaceX if there wasn’t a NASA.

            • servo_sausage 1 day ago

              I'm not super convinced that the commercial aerospace industry really needed NASA once super high value satellite services came about in the 90s.

              The ideal of a good government industry program, is to create a domestic industry, and A: maintain it at a minimum level for whatever goal is in focus (defence, technology familiarity, investment certainty). And B to help it grow to be independent of the government, so the profits and funding can go elsewhere.

              To me, most of what NASA did after Skylab are a bit questionable. With most of the high profile stuff being of limited value compare to the RF and solid state electronics projects.

              • bumby 1 day ago

                I mean, Musk himself stated SpaceX needed NASA. New entrants especially benefit from a self insured customer because private industry won’t accept that level of risk.

                I agree with a lot of your point, but would probably caveat a lot of the JPL work.

                • WalterBright 1 day ago

                  NASA did not invest in SpaceX. What they did was buy launches from SpaceX. Musk risked everything he had on SpaceX.

                  • bumby 1 day ago

                    You are shoehorning in an entirely different argument. The question is not about whether NASA invested, or loaned, or contracted or whatever other funding mechanism. It is whether their existence is predicated on the existence of the other, and whether they are both dealing with the same problems.

                    When people fail to acknowledge that, it becomes a vehicle for a digression and creates tired discussions that follow the same well-worn paths.

                    • WalterBright 1 day ago

                      The point is, SpaceX was not given tax money. It delivered on contract.

                      • bumby 1 day ago

                        lol, what do you think NASA money is if not tax dollars?

                        You have an oddly dogmatic take when it comes to nearly all things Musk. Whether it’s tax dollars is a tangent from the point being discussed about whether they would exist without early govt contracts

                        • WalterBright 1 day ago

                          The money was not "given" to Musk, nor was it a "subsidy". It was a contract of money in exchange for deliverables.

                          • bumby 1 day ago

                            That’s why I used the word “contract” above and elsewhere in this thread. It’s still tax payer funds, though. You seem hellbent on having a different discussion which I find tiresome.

                          • _Tev 1 hour ago

                            Nah, SpaceX did get subsidy in COTS for developing F9/Dragon. Not to mention various small amounts DoD gave them just for being US launch vehicle developer/provider.

                            That amount is very small compared to private funding SpaceX got but esp.the COTS contract literally saved SpaceX from bankruptcy (see Liftoff or various statements from Musk/Shotwell). So "no subsidy" is wrong argument, I would use "very little subsidy, esp.compared to their competitors".

          • skullone 1 day ago

            I mean, considering nothing like it had been done before (or since) kinda proves the inefficient approach worked. I'm not defending gov inefficiency but often it still leads to good results somehow (and also major disasters, sigh)

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              What does worked mean in this context? A barely reusable craft that risked human lives to launch mundane satellites and was so unreliable DOD stopped using and was so expensive NASA couldn’t afford to keep it running?

              • skullone 1 day ago

                With the technology available and the requirements of the missions it was intended to fulfill, that is what was built. You are being stubborn and annoying.

          • atq2119 1 day ago

            One system is way better at doing the thing that it was designed for.

            The other system is way better at doing the thing that it was designed for.

            And since both of the design goals are important, having both systems is a good thing.

          • AlecSchueler 1 day ago

            It really depends to what degree you're willing to ignore the externalities.

        • computerdork 1 day ago

          Can see your point, that spreading the constructions sites across different states was necessary in order to get it built, but in terms of pure engineering, this is probably a negative.

          Guess the point is that generally speaking, large scale engineering is typically not done at efficient and creative-levels when directed by the government. Governments have too many stakeholders that have needs that have little do with with engineering that need to be satisfied

          ...And of course, there are exceptions -guessing the Gemini and Apollo programs would be a good examples.

          ... oh, and am not trying to call you out, just trying to think through this for myself as well.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            What makes you think Gemini and Apollo are counterexamples? They were successful, but were also heavily dependent on contractors and occurred when NASA funding was many multiples of today’s budget when measured by percentage of GDP.

            • computerdork 1 day ago

              Well, they seemed like highly effective government programs as they were able to get people to the moon under a very tight deadline (and also knew they were extremely expensive programs. Kind of crazy the amounts relatively to gdp they were spending).

              And, if they weren't, backs up that the government is not typically a good overseer when it comes engineering programs

              (although, still seems like when there is a very strong need, governments can be very good partners).

              • blackcatsec 1 day ago

                There is nothing inherently wrong with 'government' providing the source of funding for these programs, and there's nothing wrong with spreading parts of the program across different regions. In fact, in a way it can be cheaper. With the Apollo testing facilities in Mississippi, the Apollo program being built out of Huntsville, and the other 7 locations across the US--you can adequately tap higher end talent while moving some components to cheaper locations to work on.

                • computerdork 1 day ago

                  Agree actually. The government basically funded Spacex for Falcon 9 through the Commercial Orbital Transportation Services program, and probably some of Starship's development too. Yeah, the funding wasn't the question, it's whether the government is a good overseer of programs like this.

                  Regarding spreading the parts of the development/manufacturing across different regions, am sure there are good benefits to doing this, and cost efficiency is definitely one of them (Boeing's manufacturing is a great example, as well as most auto companies). So yeah, you're right there. But when the government does it, it often is for political reasons, so you wonder if they really do gain cost efficiencies? Hmm...

                  Personally, my take is the earlier in the development process you are of a product (or vehicle), the better it is to keep everything tight knit (yeah, am a believer in the major concepts of agile development - small, integrated teams working close together, able to iterate fast). And feels like this is also true for design teams in general, no matter what the size of the company. It pays to keep them together as much as possible.

                  But the more mature a product gets, like a car company that's been building cars for decades, it seems like spreading out manufacturing could be a cost savings.

        • Alive-in-2025 1 day ago

          No, he's trying to bully his way into forcing the government to do what he wants, and he can because he is extremely wealthy. It just happens that in this case, it yields something useful. That is a poor model, the rich should not arbitrarily get their own way.

        • Dig1t 1 day ago

          “Solving different problems” means intentionally creating inefficiencies in an engineering project so that voters can get a little cut of the government funding. It’s a roundabout way of buying votes.

          It shows that the government’s incentives are not aligned with the project’s goals and why privatization works better for this type of project.

          • bumby 1 day ago

            Said elsewhere, but if NASA didn’t spread their resources around, there likely would not be a NASA. As Musk said, if there was no NASA, there would not be SpaceX. People act like they SpaceX exists in a govt vacuum. They do not.

            I don’t take umbrage with the govt/private model when done right. I take issue when people act like one deserves all the credit while ignoring the larger system that is required to bring that success about.

            • rjbwork 1 day ago

              One could almost say that "You exist in the context of all in which you live and what came before you."

              • bumby 1 day ago

                And the fact that SpaceX would not exist without NASA would still be true.

        • jxramos 1 day ago

          Solving different problems is a good way to put it, but to even be in that position implies they’re trying to meet false objectives and artificial constraints that are beyond the scope of the original endeavor even if there’s some intersection remaining. These extra constraints I imagine have a high likelihood of compromising the original objective by forcing tradeoffs that don’t move the needle and carry costs with ill spent efforts.

        • Nifty3929 1 day ago

          He only has to do that to prevent the government from doing to his projects what they routinely do to their own.

          He’s paying extortion money to keep them from making SpaceX as awful as NASA, or preventing him from doing anything at all.

          • bumby 23 hours ago

            So not incompetent if its mitigating political risk then. Which is why NASA was designed the way it was.

      • nine_k 1 day ago

        It's more like the cost of the political system we run. Yes, it's not the most streamlined, but it's stable. Quite a number of people yearn for the efficiency of a system under one will of an enlightened monarch. We have a bunch of examples, from Lycurgus and Cyrus back in the day to Mr Putin today; there is a cost to such a system, too.

        • narnarpapadaddy 1 day ago

          It’s always entertaining to hear engineers ridicule inefficient government programs while simultaneously setting up a load balancer, backups, or a high-availability db cluster. Completely unable to generalize the lesson that redundancy and overhead aren’t necessarily bad, and that efficiency is in tension with other desirable attributes in every system, political, biological, computational, whatever.

      • thaeli 1 day ago

        I wouldn't call it incompetence. It's more a sign of government misalignment.

        • Gareth321 1 day ago

          I see misalignment as a form of incompetence.

          • TheOtherHobbes 1 day ago

            Incorrect. Governments can - and should - have goals beyond simple engineering problems. Traditionally government funds corporate and academic R&D which is then productised and commercialised by the private sector.

            This is literally how the computing industry was built.

            Ignoring those goals for short-term corporate profit is politically incompetent, and has terrible consequences - as most of us are about to find out.

            • Gareth321 16 hours ago

              What you describe isn't an issue of misalignment. Re-read the discussion thread. It's perfectly consistent for the government to prioritise long term prosperity. The issue is when government chooses not to prioritise aggregate social benefit because it is beholden to, for example, local and special interests. Maybe a particular local race needs to be won to secure a House or Senate majority, and in strategising and negotiating that win, they drop important policies which would have maximised long term prosperity. This is baked into how democracy works. It is messy, inconsistent, and frequently misaligned with long term prosperity. This is why government could not do what SpaceX has done.

      • TwoGeneral 1 day ago

        It's evidence Congress is/was little more than a bunch of clowns.

        The government engineers and scientists that worked on the space shuttle were not.

        Also it's trivial to be an armchair expert decades removed from actual events.

      • nick486 1 day ago

        publicly funded means funded by the people. its not really unreasonable that people demand the economic benefits of investing their money to be spread around a bit.

        its not ideal from logistics POV, but it is not what I would take as the prime example of incompetence. its just the government way of doing thinngs.

        • eastbound 1 day ago

          If the economic benefit summarized as employment, then the goal is wrong. And indeed space conquest oftem just makes our child brains dream, instead of being something useful per itself. So we tout employment and side-effects as a prime benefit of space. Why not create a broken-window factory, it will create more jobs.

          • TheOtherHobbes 1 day ago

            A broken-window factory like Microsoft?

            Can we stop pretending the private sector isn't a labyrinth of idiocy, opportunism, petty infighting, and inefficiency?

            The private sector is very, very bad at thinking strategically in useful terms. Profit is a fool's proxy for progress.

            Corporate values have been the single biggest brake on human development since the 1970s. We would be far further ahead on every metric with the kind of smarter strategic management that corporate culture makes unimaginable.

      • Alive-in-2025 1 day ago

        The "government" doesn't make those decisions, it's the political class that chooses to do those choices of putting money in each district.

      • raverbashing 1 day ago

        > Isn't the fact that spreading work across many congressional districts is necessary rather evidence of government incompetence?

        Government issue? Or, let's be more honest, the issue here is with the people expecting government programs to become job programs?

    • jimbokun 1 day ago

      Everything you said sounds like arguments for government incompetence to me.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        If you have a narrow perspective, yes, it can look like incompetence.

    • panick21_ 1 day ago

      I think people understand this wrong. The problem with Shuttle was not that they had multiple masters. The problem was that they were not able to experiment and build multiple versions. Many bad choices were already made by the time DoD came in.

      People always act as if everything is only because of a few requirements from DoD, but this is just not correct.

      The fundamental problem was that they had limited budget and they wanted to build something that could achieve almost absurd spec without building any intermediate steps.

      Spreading it around districts was also not really a huge issue because it was such a new program and you had contractors all over the US already, so it was actually sensible. The problem is just that even today they can't change it because they locked it in back then.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        >Many bad choices were already made by the time DoD came in.

        Can you elaborate on this point?

    • asadotzler 1 day ago

      Starship has multiple masters:

      1) Starlink 2) NASA Artemis 3) Mars

      Each of these variants will have significantly different designs demanded by different organizations or organizational units.

      • bumby 1 day ago

        The Starship requirements across those missions are generally much more aligned than what NASA vs DoD wanted out of STS. Most of Starlink reqs could be considered a subset of Artemis. I would venture the biggest distort is reliability requirements between crewed/uncrewed missions.

        The issue isn’t really how many masters per se, but how competing their respective requirements.

  • cornell532 1 day ago

    Government had to get out of the way. A visionary from Private Sector like Elon Musk was needed

    • dmix 1 day ago

      The US government realized this in the late 90s-early 2000s and started pushing NASA to go outside to utilize private industry in more a competitive way (instead of giving contracts to the same tiny group of gov contractors). This started initially under GWB and later Obama expanded it, which helped open the door to companies like SpaceX and X PRIZE type competitions.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commercial_Orbital_Transportat...

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Centennial_Challenges

      The defense industry could use this sort of thing, which we saw with the costs/shortages of missiles in the Iran war.

    • throwaway2037 1 day ago

      From SpaceX Wiki page[1]:

          > The first three launches of the rocket, between 2006 and 2008, all resulted in failures, which almost ended the company. Financing for Tesla Motors had failed, as well, and consequently Tesla, SolarCity, and Musk personally were all nearly bankrupt at the same time.
      
          > The financial situation started to turn around with the first successful launch achieved on the fourth attempt on September 28, 2008. Musk split his remaining $30 million between SpaceX and Tesla, and NASA awarded SpaceX a $1.6 billion Commercial Resupply Services (CRS) contract in December, thus financially saving the company.
      

      Yeah, bad gov't (NASA). Get out of the way for private industry. Or, wait, help us when we are desperate and nearly bankrupt. Which one? The correct answer is "both, in harmony".

      [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SpaceX

      • Gareth321 1 day ago

        I feel like I’m not reading the same passage of text. NASA didn’t give SpaceX anything. They were a customer, paying the best company for the best service. That’s how free markets work.

  • jmyeet 1 day ago

    It's funny how people can look at the exact same program and draw wildly different conclusions. From where I'm sitting, Starship is a deeply flawed and highly risky program with an uncertain future. There are two keys problems:

    1. It's not clear what the product-market fit for Starship really is, specifically there is limited demand for these super-heavy payloads. What's my evidence? Falcon Heavy. It averages about 1 launch a year, typically by the military, compared to >100 for Falcon 9.

    There are five standard counterarguments to this:

    a) "You can carry multiple payloads." Most of the time this simply isn't true. The payloads have to be on almost identical orbits for this to work. Different inclination? No shot. Different altitude? Almost no shot. This brings us to the second;

    b) "But Starlink." Yes, Starlink can take advantage of this although to justify its massive expansion, Starlink really has to launch a satellite-based handheld mobile phone network and it has to be pretty much global. It's unclear if this can be from a legal and regulatory standpoint or if it will be able to effectively compete with traditional terrestrial 5G networks. It's unclear what customer density can be supported;

    c) "It will induce demand for bigger payloads." Falcon Heavy is relatively cheap, particularly compared to the alternatives from Ariane and ULA yet launch cadence is still particularly slow. Satellites, which are the bread and butter of commercial rocketry, just don't need to be that big;

    d) "Starship will replace Falcon 9 launches." Yes, but other companies will fill the Falcon 9 gap if SpaceX abandons it. If you're only carrying one payload to LEO (or even geostationary orbit) and you can do that with a smaller launch system that you can reuse, it's simply going to be better eventually; and

    e) "Space based AI data centers." This is never going to happen. it doesn't make any sense. You can't get enough power or distribute the heat. You're subject to cosmic rays and solar radiation, which the atmosphere otherwise mostly protects you from, and you have no way to economically service the inevitable failures.

    2. The whole Mars thing is BS, basically, kinda like space-based data centers. It's not happening. There's absolutely no reason to go;

    3. Starship isn't suited for lunar missions, which is one reason (IMHO) why Elon tried to scuttle NASA's lunar program [1]. Basically, a 40 meter high vessel that has to land horizontally is hard to land, hard to get in and out of (with your astronauts 40 meters off the surface) and much harder to get off the Moon and back to Earth.

    4. Between (2) and (3) a whole lot of new capabilities have to be developed anyway, none of which have even begun yet (eg in-orbit refueling).

    Now the one really useful thing from the Starship program (IMHO) is the Raptor engine. For context, the Falcon 9's Merlin engine used oxygen and RP-1 (kerosene, basically). Only the oxygen had to be kept really cold. But it has coking issues (ie solid carbon build up from the RP-1 being consumed). Raptor replaces RP-1 with LNG. No coking but now you have two cryogenic fuels instead of one.

    [1]: https://futurism.com/elon-musk-scrap-nasa-moon-program

    • bruce511 1 day ago

      I'll float a use case, which I admit though borders on science fiction. Still, it could be done without breaking the laws of physics.

      "Construction of a multi-generational ship, in orbit, designed to travel for hundreds of years between stars".

      Discussing this in-depth would take a book, but by necessity this ship would be very (very) large and would require an extraordinary amount of mass to be ferried into orbit.

      Of course this unlikely to happen during starship's lifetime, but hey, it's at least a legitimate use case.

      • WalterBright 1 day ago

        It would probably be more practical to build a generation ship out of a suitably sized asteroid.

    • ericd 1 day ago

      They don't need super heavy payloads, it seems pretty clear that they'll be able to launch even just a Falcon 9 payload in this for less than Falcon 9, because they're not throwing away the expensive upper stage.

      Also, my understanding is that Starlink v3 just doesn't fit inside F9. The larger phased arrays that that enables lets them make much better use of spectrum than the v2 minis. There are lots of potential uses for larger payload volumes.

      The space DC thing has been beaten to death online, with tons of very confident commentators claiming it will never happen for the reasons you've mentioned. Some counterpoints, Google just launched their first ML infra to space with their Project Suncatcher launch, and if you actually run the numbers, the radiators are smaller than the solar arrays, so obviously it's feasible to launch the radiator if it's feasible to launch the solar array to power it. Who knows if it'll make economic sense, but it seems pretty clear that it's getting harder to build DCs on the ground in the US, there's a lot of backlash against it, we just saw what it did to Abbott. Many areas don't have the spare power, and doing it in space makes solar into reliable baseload power rather than 1/8th nameplate and intermittent.

      Anyway, I don't work in that industry, I've just been following along with them because I've been an investor since before Starlink was a thing, but I really think people should keep an open mind about whether SpaceX can pull off things that sound a bit nutty.

      • imtringued 1 day ago

        I don't know why people go on about the radiator, it's pretty obvious to me that the biggest challenge is your solar panels and radiators acting as wind sails that increase atmospheric drag. This is a manageable problem at small scales but it limits the maximum node size.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          Or limits how low your orbit can be. Or how small your fuel load can be.

      • sobellian 19 hours ago

        Suncatcher can only run for 15 minutes before shutting down to cool. It doesn't really prove much in that department.

    • GMoromisato 1 day ago

      I'm having trouble going from the facts I know to your conclusion ("Starship is deeply flawed"). I supposed "deeply flawed" is subjective, so I doubt I'll change your mind, but I can't help myself when "someone is wrong on the internet."

      You say, "It's not clear what product-market fit for Starship really is" but then you list a pretty good market fit: Starlink. Starship is the only vehicle that can launch Starlink v3 satellites, and one single Starship launch can put up as much bandwidth as 10 Falcon 9 launches.

      The internal launch cost of a Falcon 9 launch is ~$20 million, so effectively, one Starship launch is replacing $200 million worth of Falcon 9 launches. Current speculation is that it costs $100 million to build a Starship stack, so even if they never recover either booster or ship, they would still be saving $100 million per launch.

      That's pretty good product-market fit, if you ask me.

      Next you talk about Mars. I assume the argument is basically: Starship was designed to go to Mars, but there's no reason to go to Mars, ergo Starship has no purpose. But that sounds like a self-refuting argument. If Starship was designed to go to Mars, that implies that Musk wants to go to Mars (which I actually think is true), which means Starship has a purpose: to go to Mars.

      Alternatively, let's say Musk is just conning and he doesn't really care about Mars. He's really just building Starship for Starlink or Starmind or whatever. In that scenario (which I don't believe but can't disprove) then Starship still has a purpose: Starlink and Starmind.

      Your next argument is that Starship isn't suited for lunar mission. I actually agree with this--Starship was designed for Mars, which is why it runs on methane (for in-situ propellant generation), and relies on a aerobraking to enter Mars orbit. But the same architecture that can take Starship to Mars will be able to land 50 tons on the lunar surface--something that no other lander can do.

      [Your arguments about landing difficulties and astronauts descending 40 meters are not very strong. Starship is bottom-heavy because of the engines, so very hard to tip over, and elevators are a 100-year-old technology.]

      Lastly, you bring up "a whole lot of new capabilities" to be developed, but you only mention in-orbit refueling. That's true: in-orbit refueling is yet to be demonstrated. But that's a new capability that (a) no other vehicle has performed, and (b) would open up the solar system to exploration. That's a case of Starship being more ambitious than any previous space vehicle--almost the opposite of "deeply flawed". And even if in-orbit refueling never works (which I doubt), Starship would still be revolutionary for being reusable.

      We both have wildly different conclusions on Starship. Maybe one way to see who's right is to make predictions. I think Starship will continue to launch Starlink satellites and that SpaceX will continue to make a profit from Starlink. My guess is between 10-20 Starship launches in 2027 and 50-70 launches in 2028. I also predict that Starship will land on the moon, with astronauts, before the end of 2030.

      If my predictions come true, I think that would make Starship a very successful program.

      • WalterBright 1 day ago

        It isn't necessary to refuel in orbit. Just add fuel by releasing the empty rocket and attaching a fully fueled one. Rendezvous in orbit has been done since the 60s.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          How do you get the fully fueled rocket into orbit?

          • WalterBright 1 day ago

            See again the rendezvous operations done in the 1960s.

      • jmyeet 1 day ago

        So cost is a funny thing. You have to amortize the program cost across the launches. So far the program cost is at least $15 billion [1]. This is a huge multiple (40x+) of the original Falcon 9 program, which was expendable originally and has gone through many upgrades since obviously. But Starship also isn't done. We also don't know how many uses each Starship stack will get and what the refurbishment cost will be. I think it's safe to say there'll need to be continued development just like there has been with Falcon 9.

        As for the whole 10x the payload, well that goes back to a big chunk of my comment. The only real demand for this is Starlink. Nobody else needs this kind of capacity in volume. Exactly how many launches are required depends entirely on how large the constellation gets. that could be anywhere from 10,000 to 40,000+. That'll be driven by demand for satellite broadband. I've seen estimates on Starlink-related Starship launches anywhere from 30 to 150 per year.

        But how much demand is there really? The receivers are expensive. Wired broadband is superior wherever it's available. Obviously there are some use cases (eg ships, planes) where being mobile is required.

        I spent a little time looking into how realistic phone-based Starlink is and... it's not particularly realistic. Phone transmitters are too weak. You'd lose service inside because the phone is too low powered. And more power means a bigger, hotter phone with less battery life. This is a significant disadvantage to terrestrial 5G and is arguably a limit of physics. After all, an iPhone's signal doesn't need to travel 300-600km.

        So there's a market for Starlink but is it enough to sustain a $15-30B program cost and 100 Starship launches a year? The jury is out. And if there isn't that demand, it gets a whole lot more expensive because you need to amortize the program cost over fewer launches.

        Oh, and new capabilities means redeveloping the capability to carry crew, assuming we have some space station to replace the ISS. The original Crew Dragon was meant to support up to 6-7 crew. There was no demand for that so it got scaled back to 4. Well, what's a 10x payload going to do if you can't even fill 6 seats on Crew Dragon?

        As for your launch cadence predictions, I'd argue they're optimistic but not wildly optimistic. I think it's going to take some time to scale up. But the Moon by 2030? No shot. This requires in-orbit refueling, some kind of lunar lander, some kind of crew vehicle and certification for all of the above. If this happens by 2035 I'll be pleasantly surprised.

        [1]: https://kfgo.com/2026/05/01/exclusive-spacex-spending-on-sta...

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          LEO satellite based cell phone communication has already been demonstrated with off-the-shelf cell phones by AST Mobile and SpaceX. You might want to find better sources.

          • jmyeet 1 day ago

            The SpaceX phone capability is extremely low bandwidth. It's basically SMS (like 2G/3G SMS). That's why it's basically an emergency feature.

            V3 Direct-to-Cell is in very early development with only some 20-50 satellites launched of the 10,000+ targeted. To my knowledge there have been no public demonstrations of bandwidth speeds with handheld devices, particularly in less-than-ideal conditions (eg indoors).

            But it takes more than that. To run a cellular network, you also need the spectrum. That's expensive to acquire. Companies spent billions for 4G/5G spectrum licenses. What spectrum you have in any given country is going to differ too. That's going to complicate any devices you want. Plus making a modem is no small task. Apple has invested billions in this to try and escape Qualcomm's stranglehold on the market, particularly with patent ownership.

            As for AST... they've done tests but nothing more. They need their own constellation and I don't know how they economically launch those when SpaceX is likely their only viable option unless they can build some consortium with BlueOrigin and Amazon.

    • WalterBright 1 day ago

      > You can't get enough power or distribute the heat

      At the very least, one can turn off the data center components, wait till it cools down, then start it again. Nobody says all of it has to run continuously.

      > you have no way to economically service the inevitable failures

      The data center's components can communicate with each other by radio, meaning failed components can be simply replaced.

      • enragedcacti 1 day ago

        The primary cost benefit of orbital data centers is the availability of efficient, around-the-clock solar power. Any time spent idling for heat reasons directly eats into the profitability of the concept so there's no reason* to design a system that isn't optimized to operate in a steady state. You would instead just put fewer GPUs on it or increase the size of your panels and radiators. The only question is whether or not that steady state is cost effective.

        *There are reasons, but none that justify very large scale compute clusters in space

    • ben_w 1 day ago

      > You can't get enough power or distribute the heat. You're subject to cosmic rays and solar radiation, which the atmosphere otherwise mostly protects you from, and you have no way to economically service the inevitable failures.

      It doesn't make any sense even though these talking points aren't the killer issues.

      You can totally distribute the heat. It's just that at these temperatures the same radiator works better on the ground, as the ground gets convection as well as radiation.

      And you can get the power, it's just that because the satellites de-orbit so much faster than ground-mounted PV wears out, any given PV factory produces as many joules/year regardless of if you launch the PV to space or not.

      I'm currently trying to work out if it even saves water, between the cost of a deluge system on the one side vs. the water intensity of the batteries for nighttime on the other. It's close even with high rocket reuse, is all I can say at this point.

      But it really does look like it's better to just leave completed data centre satellites lying around in a desert than to actually launch them.

  • TwoGeneral 1 day ago

    Starship is effectively another falling car that doesn't crash.

    It's taken 100 years for humans to build a rocket that lands itself.

    Gonna take even longer to establish a humans on Mars.

    Ya need supply lines, radiation shielding, water... all in the next 2-3 decades if you want any shot at seeing it.

    There's no guarantee future generations can justify the effort, resource use.

    Yall gonna stay around 2-3 more generations to make sure they do?

    • trueno 1 day ago

      At this point it's getting hard to care about mars when 2-3 generations is enough time to really see this planet heat up. It doesn't help that we are draining lakes like crazy right now. I dunno, I used to get sooooo excited about this stuff and this past couple years it really is starting to feel like I can't reserve much joy for private industry since there's such little regard for the people and the planet in which we are surrounded by. Not even trying to be a hippie here, it's just so brazen these days. This is probably the part of me that sticks out the most in my engineering role, I tend to be surrounded by people who can just ... turn it all off in light of any and all "advancement". No matter the cost. I can't, I spend a lot of my time outside of work these days trying to take in being a human, connecting with others and taking in nature. Whenever I center myself there, it's just kind of difficult to care about getting to Mars. And you're very correct, there is literally no guarantee future generations can justify the effort/resources for such a venture. I dunno.

  • gcanyon 1 day ago

    I don't think you intended to dis the space shuttle (much) but it's important to recognize that half a century has passed since the start of the shuttle design process. Comparing the two is like comparing the 747 to the Ford Tri-motor.

    • philwelch 1 day ago

      No, it’s not like that at all because airplanes improved significantly between the 1920’s and 1960’s whereas spacecraft improved marginally in some respects and regressed significantly in other respects between the 1970’s and 2000’s.

    • fsh 1 day ago

      The 747 is more then a decade older than the Shuttle. You would have to compare the 747 to the 787.

      • gcanyon 1 day ago

        I specifically compared the 747 to the Ford Trimotor, not to the Shuttle. I considered the 787 vs. the 747, and although there is roughly 50 years between them, the 747 was released deep into the commercialization of air travel, so I don't think it's a fair comparison. The Shuttle was the first reusable space vehicle, so the comparison to the Trimotor (one of the first commercial aircraft) seemed reasonable. I also considered the Boeing 247.

  • n_u 1 day ago

    > The original designs for the Space Shuttle had the booster (with wings!) return to the launch site, but the cost for two new crewed vehicles was too large, so they scaled it back to the compromised version.

    Can you cite a source for this claim? My understanding is that the control algorithms for landing a rocket did not exist at the time of the space shuttle. The algorithms were invented in 2010s[1] and space shuttle operated from 1981-2011[2]

    [1] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/6428631

    [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Shuttle

    • GMoromisato 1 day ago

      I'm not sure what you actually want a source for. The design I'm talking about had the booster as a giant winged and crewed spacecraft with a winged and crewed orbiter attached. That did not require computer control algorithms (although I question your claim about the algorithms not being invented until the 2010s--the Russian Buran shuttle did an uncrewed, automated mission in 1988).

      https://web.archive.org/web/20200531171908/https://history.n...

    • enragedcacti 1 day ago

      There weren't control algorithms involved, the shuttle's fuel tank would have been its own glider with its own crew: https://airandspace.si.edu/collection-objects/model-space-sh...

      > The algorithms were invented in 2010s

      The McDonnell Douglas DC-X first vertically landed in 1993 and had an autoland capability. NASA also soft-landed probes autonomously on the moon way back in the 60s with Surveyor, though they would have been way easier to control than a booster.

      https://youtube.com/watch?v=wv9n9Casp1o

  • raverbashing 1 day ago

    > Starship is, essentially, Space Shuttle done right

    There's lots to praise here, but they haven't flown a single manned mission yet

    (Also hindsight is 20:20)

    > without solid boosters (avoids Challenger disaster) and orbiter stacked on top instead of on the side (avoid Columbia disaster)

    We know of the failure modes of the Shuttle, we don't know about the failures of Starship

    Or better, the two obvious ones: it will fail to be caught or it will fail to bellyflop

    And of course Starship benefits immensely from computers getting thousands of times better and lighter (and cheaper)

    > Even more revolutionary, compared to Shuttle, Starship is built on an assembly line

    Yes this is a big win

    • enraged_camel 1 day ago

      >> We know of the failure modes of the Shuttle, we don't know about the failures of Starship

      This is blatantly false. SpaceX learned a ton about different failure modes by launching many Starships during testing and watching them explode. The Shuttle had to take a conservative approach because it was expensive and there was no budget for the type of just-launch-it-and-see-what-happens approach SpaceX takes.

      • raverbashing 16 hours ago

        Of course, but there's always something that slips or is considered less likely to happen

        Only now these more unlikely events will begin to show now

  • random3 1 day ago

    What’s the alternative to building on an assembly line? Is there a “theory” of the assembly line building relative to more ad-hoc approaches?

    • WalterBright 1 day ago

      Moving the article being built means it moves to the machines that do each stage of the work. As opposed to moving the machines to where the article is being assembled.

  • worldsavior 1 day ago

    I think you forget that in Apollo time all people ever wanted was to get out of earth and see what's actually out there, with human presence. All the other stuff, would be done later, like this.

m4rtink 1 day ago

Just watched the catch stream live on the dome of a local planetarium - really feeling history is being made.

It was all so symbolic, they just had a talk about the Voyager probe reaching one light day from Earth accompanied by screening of the Startrek movie (which includes V'ger/Voyager) and ad hoc decided to stream the catch just after the movie ended.

Was a really surreal experience, first watching the tiny Enterprise zooming around the vast V'ger spacecraft only to see Starship zooming through the clouds and getting caught, all on the same planetarium dome projection! :-)

  • 3lambda 1 day ago

    Which planetarium showed this, if you don't mind answering? If it's near me I'd love to attend!

    • m4rtink 1 day ago

      It is the Brno planetarium in Czech Republic & this was the event (in Czech): https://www.hvezdarna.cz/novinky/jeden-svetelny-den-od-brna-...

      They do a lot of cool and clever stuff - for example for the partial solar eclipse in August, it was not well observable from their grounds, as it was happening low above the horizon near sunset. So they rented a hot air baloon, which even launched from a meadow next to the Planetarium (which is often used for hot air baloon launches during the summer) and then they live streamed the eclipse for as long as possible - IIRC about ~5 minutes longer than what was possible to see on the grounds. the Stream recording is here, end to end from baloon launch to night landing in a field: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wWrs-36nvg4&pp=0gcJCVgCo7VqN5t...

thinkingemote 2 days ago

If this makes even me want to go study engineering I know it will inspire millions of youngsters into making the future we all want. Bravo!

reactordev 2 days ago

The engineering of this is just mind boggling awesome. The culmination of so many fields, so many factors, to this. Congrats!!!

  • Animats 2 days ago

    It is. It's a great achievement for Gwynne Shotwell.

    • zhoBEENG 2 days ago

      Yes, though not an engineering one. At SpaceX she handles business development, strategy, and ops, though she was trained as an engineer and did it previously in her career. I think this is almost the more impressive feat here, not to diminish the engineering leap.

      Definitely a name that won’t be forgotten anytime soon.

    • carabiner 1 day ago

      And the CEO, Musk. Shotwell is president.

      • tootie 1 day ago

        Musk = fake it

        Shotwell = make it

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          I’ll take the word of the world’s foremost rocket engine engineer who was actually in the room with Musk when decisions were made over a random Internet commenter.

          • jxeyrl 20 hours ago

            Nooo don't be rational ahah we're hating on Musk like a hivemind ahah

  • pxmpxm 2 days ago

    > bind boggling

    mind bottling

  • soon_to_be_sb 1 day ago

    Nothing new. Flight controls and automatic navigation of a high speed ballistic missle is much more impressive and had existed for decades.

    • reactordev 1 day ago

      I hope those sour patch kids taste good…

      This kind of stuff hasn’t been done before. So by definition, new.

      • soon_to_be_sb 1 day ago

        The material engineering part, I don't know. But the vertial landing stuff should be childs play when compared to the stuff a self guided missile has to do.

        • reactordev 1 day ago

          You must be really fun at parties

edekozar 1 day ago

Interestingly, there's a similar large "block" recovery rig in the South China Sea. They use two sets of steel cables running in the X and Y directions — visually it's a lot like the Japanese cat's cradle string game. From a quick search, it appears to have shown up after SpaceX's chopsticks catch. Different engineering approach, but the same idea of catching the returning stage in a grid rather than with arms.

  • zzzoom 1 day ago

    Yeah, it makes the chopsticks look unnecessarily unforgiving.

    • AustinDev 1 day ago

      The chopsticks are so stylish though.

    • Laremere 1 day ago

      The Starship is about twice as wide, and the chopsticks open quite wide. It's hard to tell glancing at pictures, but I think the chopsticks might actually have more catch area, though the rocket does need to be rotated correctly for the catch pins. Also, counter intuitively, it's actually easier to hit a precise target with a larger rocket: You're pushed around by the wind less, and the same impulse gives finer control.

      The Chinese catcher is pretty cool, and seems like an upgrade compared to the Falcon 9. However with the chopsticks you're effectively landing on the crane which loads it onto a transport or even stack it directly back on the pad for the next launch (far more likely with boosters, though it could happen with fuel tankers I suppose). So I don't think anyone at SpaceX is currently sad they chose chopsticks.

      • renehsz 1 day ago

        How much damage do the vehicles or the chopsticks take during a catch, especially once they start catching the Ship too? It looks pretty rough in the footage. Not saying it's the wrong choice though, I obviously wouldn't know that, just curious

  • tristanj 1 day ago

    this doesn't make sense for Starship - Starship is RTLS (return to launch site), and a cable/net catch system creates an unnecessarily complex launch tower.

    The cable catch system for long march 10B is superior to the landing legs of falcon 9 - of the 11 falcon 9 failures, a cable catch system would have avoided 4-6 of them. Removing the landing legs also reduces the rocket dry mass and increases payload mass to orbit.

    If SpaceX did Falcon 9 again, they would likely use a cable catch system, as it resolves about half of falcon 9's historic landing failures.

    • jve 12 hours ago

      > ...is superior ... would have avoided...

      You cannot assert something is more reliable when you don't know the reliability of the thing you are comparing with.

  • O5vYtytb 1 day ago

    The rocket that system catches (Long March 10B) is the size of Falcon 9. Starship is an order of magnitude larger and heavier. It may not be a practical solution for a significantly larger scale rocket.

  • ayewo 1 day ago

    TIL that the Chinese have also started catching rockets out at sea.

    I had trouble visualizing your comment until I saw 2 YouTube videos from another commenter down thread of their alternate rocket catching mechanism.

    https://www.youtube.com/shorts/GJ-wZLLuh9M

    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zt1V9UWhuKk

    From https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50502490

    • jpgvm 1 day ago

      Unfortunately Chinese and Indian space programs aren't necessarily as well covered as they should be. Both are making strides even if they are "copying" from SpaceX this is generally good for humanity, science and access to space.

niek_pas 1 day ago

Does someone with more knowledge than me know if the co2 emissions from these kinds of rocket launches are big enough to make frequently launching and re-launching rockets into space a problem re. climate change? That’s a refrain I hear frequently but have no idea how true it is.

  • Cu3PO42 1 day ago

    It’s a lot of fuel and significantly more than a single flight uses, but there’s orders of magnitudes more flights, so no, it doesn’t make a huge difference right now. With massively increased cadence it might eventually.

    Starship plus Booster load roughly 1000 tons of methane. We use roughly 1,000,000 tons of kerosene a day (world wide).

  • moffkalast 1 day ago

    The CO2 factor is basically nothing, one rocket flight would be on the order of 10 commercial jet flights. The problem is soot from non-hydrolox launch vehicles, black carbon deposited directly into the upper atmosphere which apparently has a greater effect on warming than all of commercial aviation's CO2 emissions combined.

    Starship is methalox so it's somewhat more ecological than the kerosene burning falcon, but with the increased launch capacity, the rate at which it can deliver stuff to orbit, practically all of which eventually burns up in the upper atmosphere when EoL will likely have much more of a polluting effect in total.

    • justinator 1 day ago

      >The CO2 factor is basically nothing, one rocket flight would be on the order of 10 commercial jet flights.

      I think you may be off by an order of magnitude.

      • moffkalast 1 day ago

        Well it depends on the size of the rocket and the plane, the fuel and engine design, but as a comparison, a Boeing 747 carries about 240 thousand liters of kerosene while a Falcon 9 only has ~190 thousand in total. One grabs oxidizer from the atmosphere while the other brings its own, they burn it all the same. I'd lean more on the <10 side than on the >10 side unless you're talking about something with solid boosters which is probably a lot more.

  • serbuvlad 1 day ago

    Not an issue.

    There's about a thousand tons of methane on starship which come out to about 2750 tons of CO2.

    For reference an average natural gas power plant produces 2000 tons 10000 tons of CO2 every day.

    So if you fly a starship once per day that's as bad as one (1!) gas power plant.

    The US emits 14 million tons of CO2 per day, out of which 4 million comes from power plants.

    Now, suppose Starship is very successful and they have 10 launches a day. That will certainly have some environmental inpact, though it would hardly be noticable at the national scale.

    However! It would be silly to restrict Starship, for the very simple reason that we have no alternative for space travel, when we do have alternatives for energy generation.

    • cryptoz 1 day ago

      I think you’re off by an order of magnitude, as 10/day would be a failure of the program right? The goal is many hundreds per day, at 10+ pads launching at an hourly cadence to get millions of people to Mars in a couple decades.

      Surely you need way more than 10 per day to achieve the goals of the program.

      • montenegrohugo 1 day ago

        at 10 day you can just do climate engineering or carbon capture in some other way for a fraction of added cost.

        CO2 is not an issue. There's way bigger issues out there.

        • justinator 1 day ago

          "climate engineering or carbon capture in some other way" is science fiction. We can't just hand-wave problems with neat ideas that don't exist.

          • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

            At that scale, Earth ISRU will be something they can do.

      • IshKebab 1 day ago

        Yeah but that's the crazy Elon vision. It's not actually going to happen.

    • Asraelite 1 day ago

      It should be noted that Starlink satellites burning up on re-entry are looking like they may be a very big problem though.

      • grumbelbart2 13 hours ago

        Earth gains 44 tons of mass every day from "natural" space debris that burns up in the atmosphere. That is equivalent to the payload of the discussed launch.

        • Asraelite 12 hours ago

          Does that debris contain the same concentration of aluminium? In any case, it's not about the quantities re-entering now, it's about how it is going to scale up in the coming years.

    • justinator 1 day ago

      How many "hardly be noticeable at the national scale" things can we have until it is noticeable?

      This seems like an error in reasoning: if we keep the things that negatively effect the environment at an impact that's small enough, we can just have infinite amounts of these small things and no one is really to blame. Nothing ever gets done to fix the actual problem.

      See: cars.

  • madaxe_again 1 day ago

    Are you equally concerned about the shipping industry?

  • sacred_numbers 1 day ago

    Starship launching at a high enough frequency to affect climate change would also allow it to solve climate change, first with orbital shades, then perhaps with space based solar (or orbital mirrors for increased production of ground based solar). At a minimum it's going to offset a lot of natural gas that would otherwise be used for data centers, assuming Starmind works out as well.

    • justinator 1 day ago

      The idea you propose is to literally block out the sun?

      I'll take spottier Internet.

  • pfdietz 1 day ago

    The environmental limit for Starship launches will not be CO2, but rather water deposition in the stratosphere and above. This will still require a hefty launch rate to reach.

losvedir 2 days ago

Watched it with my 5 year old daughter (3 year old son was sadly uninterested), and we were both cheering and high fiving. Very exciting.

claude-ai 2 days ago

So precise it was almost boring - incredible work. Kudos.

  • scotty79 1 day ago

    Booster didn't make it back though this time, becasue of one engine not relighting out of 33. Space Shuttles became boring before Challenger too.

  • cryptonector 20 hours ago

    This happens. You do a remarkable thing, and then... it's anti-climactic because having done it means it's not so remarkable. If it really is remarkable you do it again and then it's really not anymore.

    It's a bit of a curse in that this really is remarkable and they made it look so easy it seems unremarkable, but then again if you're looking for highs in the sense of doing remarkable things then every time you succeed you end up reaching for more rather than being depressed that your remarkable accomplishments turn out to be unremarkable.

delichon 2 days ago

Congratulations to the steely eyed missile men and women of SpaceX.

  • inglor_cz 2 days ago

    I wonder if John Aaron was watching. Or Gene Kranz. Both are still alive.

    • samizdis 2 days ago

      They surely would have been watching. Unless that wasn't an option :-)

      • gcanyon 1 day ago

        Failure to watch wasn't an option...

gdubs 2 days ago

The "Baby Come Back" soundtrack really brought this home for me. What an incredible achievement. Very moving.

somebudyelse 2 days ago

I imagine this is what it was like to witness Apollo 11 55 years ago.

  • samizdis 2 days ago

    Er, no. Nothing like it. Grabbed from your bed in the middle of the night, bundled downstairs to watch (grainy) and hear (crackly) weird things on a black-and-white TV, while adults, including strangers, whooped and shouted drunkenly. I understood the Apollo 11 thing only in the days after, through news reports. The live event was as impenetrable to me as a dream. Then again, I was half-asleep and five years old.

    • a4isms 2 days ago

      I was seven, and I happen to have had a profoundly different experience than you. There was a massive rocket mania and all the kids I knew wanted to see the landing.

      Russ Olsen does a great keynote about the life-changing experience for those of us so affected. I happened to be in the audience for this edition and it was something special to be old enough to remember it much as he remembered it.

      https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eMZBA7KHnHQ

    • somebudyelse 1 day ago

      That's a super cool recount. I did know that it was at night US time (which obviously is different from what happened today) but I didn't know a lot more than that.

      What I meant in my first comment was just the absolute amazement of how far technology has gotten, to the point where this thing is just hurtling towards the ground and then suddenly just floats onto a tower. That gave me chills to watch.

  • 233mhz 2 days ago

    My grandma was one of the only person with a TV where she lived, half of the town was in her living room, nothing comparable. I bet most people watched this on their toilet seat before scrolling to the next cool thing as if it was nothing

    • ordu 2 days ago

      > I bet most people watched this on their toilet seat before scrolling to the next cool thing as if it was nothing

      I think GP tries to compare _their_ experience (not the experience of "most people") with what people felt 55 years ago.

      idk about them, but I watched it in a live stream starting about an hour early, because I wanted to see the reentry (that plasma is something special) and I didn't want to miss things. Still I don't think it is the same. Not after Falcon 9 landings, double Falcon 9 boosters landings and catching of the Starship first stage. I expected it to be caught today. Got some doubts after the booster missed the tower, but still pretty sure that 2nd stage would make it.

  • pfdietz 2 days ago

    I was nine. I remember our black and white TV, the crackling from the picture tube's high voltage wiring adding a tang of ozone. We stayed up late that night.

    • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

      Yeah - I was 8, and remember the whole family glued to our 20" B/W TV watching the moon landing. Remember the poor quality of the video/audio ("one small step for man") from the moon - hopefully will be 4K next time!

      • ExoticPearTree 1 day ago

        8K or 16K from Mars. This is what I am hoping for.

  • Jtarii 1 day ago

    This isn't even remotely close to that.

  • bluegatty 1 day ago

    I dont think this remotely compares to watching dudes walk on the moon.

    • threethirtytwo 1 day ago

      Eh trust me. When someone lands on mars it’ll be as this guy described, one reel and a dozen comments saying it’s ai.

      • bluegatty 1 day ago

        When they land on Mars, it will be amazing balls. This rocket pad thing is 'pretty neat' but not that special

brianzelip 1 day ago

Unbelievable that this post is about a video showing technical history being made, but the video[0] doesn't show in Firefox.

[0] Clicking the "Watch" button (`.spx-button.primary`) on the OP.

ryzvonusef 2 days ago

Holy ship, it was picture perfect capture!

tweakimp 1 day ago

What is the advantage of catching over just landing it?

  • alexey-salmin 1 day ago

    Could be that stretching load is better then compression for a structure that resembles a tube rolled of aluminum foil

  • dkbrk 1 day ago

    They don't need to pay the mass penalty of landing legs, just some much lighter pins that stick out to the side.

    The Falcon 9 landing legs were some excellent engineering, but scaled up to the size of starship they would weigh many tons (note the square-cube law makes them more unfavorable proportionally, not just massive considered amsolutely).

    This would be a big deal for the booster, but it's absolutely vital for Starship itself because any additional dry mass subtracts directly from the payload (actually, it's even worse since it also increases the fuel needed for landing).

    Another advantage is that it's better for reuse, as they don't have to spend hours or days restowing legs, recharging deployment cylinders and replacing crush cores.

  • tristanj 1 day ago

    This question was answered by the Chief Engineer of SpaceX https://x.com/elonmusk/status/1845829120959156376

    > The strong gravity of Earth makes the physics of a fully reusable rocket with positive payload margin extremely difficult to solve, which is why it has never been done before.

    > Removing the mass of landing legs from the booster and ship by making the tower do the work of final velocity attenuation greatly improves payload margin.

    > This architecture also simultaneously substantially increases launch cadence, because the same arms that lift the booster and ship onto the launch stand also catch them, allowing immediate placement of the booster back on the launch stand and the ship back on top of the booster.

Narishma 2 days ago

Do we know why they didn't try to catch the booster?

  • panick21_ 2 days ago

    Apparently the booster signaled it didn't have enough fuel to risk it. Either because it consumed more then expected on the way up, or a measurement error potentially.

    • bavell 2 days ago

      I heard somewhere the engine efficiency is still somewhat variable so they burned more fuel than anticipated.

      • quotemstr 2 days ago

        That's basically what Musk said, yes: that they need to work on both engine performance and performance consistency. He said they'd be cutting off the main engines one second sooner to provide more margin for boost-back.

        Amazing that a one-second difference can matter, but those things go through tons of fuel every one of those seconds!

    • Laremere 2 days ago

      At the last moment the exhaust turned green. That's consistent with the fuel running out, the engines running oxygen rich, and subsequently "engine rich". So I would put my money on actually running out vs a measurement error.

      • LorenPechtel 1 day ago

        And even if they had caught it it wouldn't have been worth much as the expensive part is the engines and they wouldn't have been reusable.

  • DarmokJalad1701 2 days ago

    Slight underperformance in the engines resulted in the the booster not reaching where it was supposed to be and the GNC systems automatically aborted to the gulf for safety.

  • inglor_cz 2 days ago

    "Slightly low on fuel."

    If I understand correctly, the margin was tight enough not to take the risk of damaging the tower.

    • quotemstr 2 days ago

      And if the landing footage is any indication, it sure looks like they would have made the catch anyway if they'd gone for it.

      • inglor_cz 2 days ago

        Their risk tolerance would probably be greater if both towers were fully operational. But any damage to the only functional tower during booster catch = an automatic abort to the ship catch one day later, and the ship catch is what was really interesting at this point of development.

        • dylan604 2 days ago

          The previz imagery of their plans for the Louisiana coast showed pairs of towers dotting the coast. At first I thought they were for alternating the cadence of launches, but now I wonder if one is to catch the booster and the other to catch ship.

          • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

            No reason for that since Ship will always be a day or more behind booster. More likely to speed up cadence.

      • baq 2 days ago

        landing footage shows exactly why they didn't attempt the tower catch - the final braking burn was engine rich (green tint), it didn't blow up, but there was a respectable chance of it just crashing into the tower running on less than fumes

        • ericcumbee 2 days ago

          I'm not sure thats the case. the booster hovered for what seemed a lot longer than prior booster landing attempts. Almost like they were purposely running out the fuel.

      • ssl-3 2 days ago

        The goal, as I understand it, is to return the booster with as little fuel as possible at time of catch -- and not run short.

        The booster footage indicated to me that its engines turned off, and then the body of the booster imploded, before it touched the ground and then became the expected fireball.

        I'm definitely not a rocket scientist, but this series of events leads me to believe that the fuel was absolutely exhausted.

        • dylan604 2 days ago

          Sounds like the final boom was intentional from control

          • ssl-3 2 days ago

            Perhaps it was, and if so: It occurred subsequent to the implosion.

            (In case that distinction is missed, I do mean "implode" as the antonym of "explode".)

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              The implosion was caused by the new FTS design they use since the first FTS failure. The FTS takes the dome between tanks and the outside of the methane tank apart, the (lower) oxygen tank depressurizes into the fuel tank causing the bottom half to implode.

    • chinabot 2 days ago

      They need another cheaper tower just for catching. Much less mass when landing.

      • ggreer 2 days ago

        The existing towers can only handle empty ships & boosters. The tower stacks them, then they’re fueled. A catch-only tower would avoid some cladding and the propellant loading lines, but it would still need a deluge system and a QD arm to replace any remaining propellant with inert gas. At that point you might as well pay a little more and get a fully capable tower.

  • blondie9x 2 days ago

    Do we know what sea life just died as the booster exploded? What are the impacts to the Texas Gulf when a booster detonates into the ocean?

    • Rohansi 2 days ago

      Probably next to nothing compared to what we fish out of the ocean constantly.

    • slopinthebag 2 days ago

      idk, i'll take a look after i finish eating my steak dinner

      • blondie9x 1 day ago

        Hmm is this why Elon wants to deregulate his pursuits? Should we just turn a blind eye to this sort of pollution in the same way the Spacex camera cut the shot of the explosion as it occurred?

        Let's hope our government will more proactively monitor these launches starting in January 2027 when a new Texas and federal government comes to power.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          Every rocket before Falcon 9 dropped boosters into the ocean, including the STS and Saturn. Starship is the second attempt to not do that, and the first not to drop second stages into the ocean. I think you’re complaining about the wrong thing. If it concerns you, how about complaining about every other rocket company?

          • blondie9x 1 day ago

            A lot were covered and a lot sunk to the bottom of the ocean. Not many exploded with all the life in the surrounding area.

            • blondie9x 10 hours ago

              I mean many boosters were recovered at sea.

    • ai_critic 1 day ago

      > What are the impacts to the Texas Gulf when a booster detonates into the ocean?

      Trivial compared to what we already did with Deepwater Horizion.

    • somenameforme 1 day ago

      Lol. I'm not sure if you're making an ironic joke, but they actually had to prove this when the previous administration was trying to bury them in bureaucracy. So they had to carry out a scientific study to demonstrate that (1) the ocean is quite large and (2) the odds of anything being at any specific point are quite low.

      I'm sure you can dig it up somewhere if you too need a study to confirm such.

      • yoavm 1 day ago

        Is it weird that a private for-profit company wanting to explode something in public space needs to prove it does what it can to minimize the potential damages? Should everyone be allowed to throw bombs into the ocean? Or just Elon?

        • literalAardvark 1 day ago

          They didn't bomb the ocean. It was empty and just above the water line which means minimal shock in the water, minimal dispersion in the air.

andsoitis 2 days ago

That was incredible to watch!

Huge congratulations to the team.

lovvtide 2 days ago

We witnessed history today

rpmisms 2 days ago

The heat shield looks very good. Excited to see how much work it will take to fly this again. I'm in awe. I like the future sometimes.

  • Meneth 2 days ago

    Seemed to me two tiles were missing, including one right in the center of the ship's belly, but no hull damage.

anuptalwalkar 2 days ago

This is absolutely incredible!! I can’t wrap my head around this.

freddealmeida 9 hours ago

While the real name of the rocket is 042.Don't Panic.

pbw 2 days ago

If you ignore the scale it doesn’t seem all the impressive. But the scale is bonkers.

inglor_cz 2 days ago

Damn, that looked smooth and glorious. This is how I'd like the future to be.

iharhajster 1 day ago

Anyone else have trouble watching this 8 hours after? I tried on SpaceX page, X, only YT seems to work fine.

I connect from EU.

le-mark 1 day ago

What amazes me is how many Raptor 2 and 3s are sitting on the bottom the gulf and the Indian Ocean. Dissecting a Raptor 3 in particular would be a real cheat code for anyone wanting to know how to build something similar! Metallurgy alone would be huge!

  • ec109685 1 day ago

    They blow them up.

    • le-mark 1 day ago

      Lol no they don’t. Keys to the kingdom sitting on the ocean floor.

  • moomoo11 1 day ago

    does debris like that do anything bad for the oceans?

  • aksss 1 day ago

    If it’s really that important, some Russian sub will be down there scavenging parts. If it’s really that important, a US sub will be there first blowing up the debris.

kristofarkas 1 day ago

There hasn’t been anything like this in humanity for a very long time. It’s so emotional to watch and see what we are capable of and the bright future ahead of us. Thank you for everyone who made this happen.

  • literalAardvark 1 day ago

    I feel like the first live HD stream of reentry plasma from the early Starship tests were slightly ahead of this in terms of awesomeness. Entering the atmosphere, everyone expects it to go dark for a couple of minutes, just like during every reentry in history... lo and behold Starlink sends a decent stream ( the first one wasn't perfect, second one was ).

    My mind exploded watching that plasma.

pxmpxm 2 days ago

You can see a plane passing underneath it at video timestamp 22:44:43!

  • cogythea 2 days ago

    Nice catch (NPI)! Unfortunately I think it's a bit more mundane, it'll be a piece of ice breaking off the lower section of the body. If you scrub through the footage, particularly earlier in the flight (e.g. 1:43:37 on the SpaceX stream, T+54:05) you'll see other pieces of ice flying off that look very similar.

t1E9mE7JTRjf 1 day ago

does someone know what is different about this compared to them catching the thing they did before?

  • robeym 1 day ago

    They've only ever caught the booster portion of the rocket, not the part that actually goes to space and orbits and returns. So, this is the first time they caught the upper stage

  • imeanwhatdoikno 1 day ago

    Prior catches were for boosters. These were coming down after ~7 minutes of flight, reaching height of ~80km and top speed of ~6000km/hr. This latest catch was of the the Spaceship, after multiple orbits around the planet, from height of ~270km and top speed of ~27000km/hr, having to survive the much higher stress during the re-entry into atmosphere. I think the Spaceship is a bit heavier than the booster at the time of catch as well.

    Edit: Spaceship is also more delicate than the booster. They have to be careful to not damage the tiles during the catch.

    • t1E9mE7JTRjf 1 day ago

      ok, thanks for those details. so it may have been coming down with much more momentum, and thus required more stopping capability. and then due to moving through the atmosphere, the components for all of what it did must be more durable (to put it mildly). I guess these are the two steps forward. great stuff anyway. I really wonder what will be in ten years.

    • senordevnyc 1 day ago

      In the videos I’ve seen on social media, it looks like debris is coming off the vehicle right when it starts turning to land? What is that, tiles?

quotemstr 2 days ago

Impressive how reliable they've made those engines!

  • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

    Haven' they had engine failures on every Starship launch? They lost one this time during the boostback burn.

hinkley 2 days ago

I know engineering is about expediency, and price, but I’m still bummed that we aren’t getting ships with landing gear in this or likely the next generation of rockets either.

Seems that the heavier the rocket the more ground clearance to need to self-land, and so you can’t scale up the dragon’s landing system. I don’t think there’s anywhere near enough weight to shave off of the next rocket or enough specific impulse to add to bring the size back down.

  • modeless 2 days ago

    Starship HLS has landing gear. For Earth landings everything is so marginal that the weight penalty of landing gear is too high.

    • pfdietz 2 days ago

      Also, landing it on the chopsticks makes rapid turnaround easier.

      • m4rtink 2 days ago

        Yeah, the chopstics mechanism is just so elegant in the end!

        It can catch both stages & be used to stack the thing as well, simple and genius!

      • hinkley 1 day ago

        It’s probably better to think of it on the spectrum of “atmosphere-rated” vessels. Ships landing in zero-g don’t need feet, they need clamping surfaces. Atmosphere rated might need both, depending on usage. The is just an almost atmosphere rated craft. If the moon and mars weren’t covered with horrible dust we could have it land on feet. But it is instead some of the worst dust in the solar system so we would have to catch it even there wasn’t a big weight pensly for carrying it around.

  • MarsZebra 2 days ago

    Yeah the Starship program isn't about landing on Mars or even going there.

    It's about pumping mass into low Earth orbit, partly for commericial, but mostly military purposes such as Golden Dome. Been in the works for decades and finally here. The people who know are very excited.

    • bluescrn 2 days ago

      Starlink is pretty amazing tech which can be used for both good and evil - from enabling reliable communication in disaster zones to letting civilians browse social media from remote locations to communicating with weapons of war.

      • MetaWhirledPeas 2 days ago

        > to communicating with weapons of war

        You could say the same thing for terrestrial internet. Not trying to be contradictory, I just find this a very interesting ethical topic.

        • MarsZebra 2 days ago

          Yeah but Starlink also intends to put weapons ONBOARD

          https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Golden_Dome_(missile_defense_s...

          • bluescrn 2 days ago

            Defensive weapons.

            It would be a pretty inefficient way to deploy offensive weapons.

            • MarsZebra 1 day ago

              No it's explicitly OFFENSIVE weapons (left-of-launch strike)

              Castelion is building the hypersonic glider weapons. A more public predecessor is,

              https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_Falcon_Project

              Striking any point on Earth within 90 seconds notice is interesting to some people.

              • ExoticPearTree 1 day ago

                It would end a lot of disputes rather quickly.

          • boznz 1 day ago

            There is nothing in the linked Wikipedia article says this.

        • hinkley 2 days ago

          The Internet was built to be literally bomb-proof rather than figuratively. The utility of that has been self evident and “five nines” thinking continues this tradition. AWS AZs are meant to partially survive floods and wildfires. A super volcano would take out an entire region but people would have other problems at that point (the exception being if emergency services were on those machines, but disaster teams have been learning to bring emergency infrastructure with them ever since New Orleans).

          As a UIUC student used to be fond of reminding me, part of the University of Illinois’ contribution to the old Internet was in a building that, if it were to collapse, would fall outward and not crush the basement. Officially that building was designed so every office has natural light, like a collapsible water cup, but it’s a very interesting coincidence that it (the basement) is bomb proof.

      • hinkley 2 days ago

        Every product has the same adoption curve. Early customers pay a premium which pays for building the factories, not just the product. By the time everyone is using them the prices have gotten low enough that the price is informed by supply rather than demand.

        SpaceX being their own customer, and a lower priority one, lets them levellize their revenue, which also helps retain staff. And if anyone commoditizes launch systems, they have a hedge against that. However if demand for starlink ever does exceed capacity, the launch side could find their schedules being much more variable.

        In software, you see this with priority queues all the time if you know where to look. Someone makes a “low priority” system that soaks up spare capacity. Internal customers become dependent on these systems and then become delay-averse. Meanwhile, other teams also start soaking up that spare capacity, by improved design or feature creep or both. That low priority system becomes starved of resources, and the internal customers start saber rattling. That system gets its own dedicated resources, and now stranded resources climb back to the original levels, if not worse.

        Starlink will eventually become the same thing. And I wonder if they will spin it off when that situation arises.

    • api 2 days ago

      I unfortunately agree. Years ago I realized the Mars talk was just talk when I noticed that Musk and SpaceX were not funding any of the other stuff you’d need to fund if you wanted to “make life multiplanetary.”

      Continuing to iterate on self contained biospheres and long term closed cycle life support? (Not a solved problem!) Working on construction techniques for the Moon or Mars? Studies on the dose response curve for gravity, like sponsoring a spin lab for the ISS to at least see if mice can reproduce in 0.3g? Self contained industrial infrastructure leaning heavily on 3D printers? Psychological research on the best way to build interiors and run social units?

      Musk could personally fund all of that with little impact on his net worth.

      It’s also decades of work. Some of what I listed is harder than the rockets. Better get started if you want to have a settlement on Mars this century.

      Nope. Nothing. Just rockets, the a satellite network that is clearly “dual use.” Then Trump 2.0 and lots of “golden dome” (Star Wars 2.0) talk.

      It’s not to go to Mars.

      I love space and I hugely admire the engineering achievement, but it’s disappointing to learn for this and many other reasons that the people behind it were not the visionaries they pretended to be. They’re just more territorial apes obsessed with ape tribal stuff like race and nationalism and fighting over dirt at the bottom of a gravity well. Small minds with big toys.

      • MarsZebra 2 days ago

        The Mars smokescreen was strong so a lot of people bought into it, even employees who didn't have the security clearances.

        The origin of SpaceX with Michael D. Griffin and Pete Worden really make it clear though.

        https://ioc.exchange/@muskfiles/116333241408716236

        • MetaWhirledPeas 2 days ago

          Curious to know what the smoke would be screening?

          • sfblah 2 days ago

            Sounds like they're saying it's actually for military applications.

        • api 2 days ago

          Really interesting. I remember scratching my head a little about stainless steel. It’s durable but heavy, cuts into payload fraction, and probably not what you would pick if the goal was to shoot interplanetary. At least not for the upper stage. Maybe for the big chunky reusable booster, but there aluminum probably makes more sense. Falcon is aluminum so it’s already the devil they know anyway.

          I recall talk about transpiration cooling. My guess is it died due to complexity or that it would use fuel as coolant which further eats mass. There was a bunch of original work on composites which would make way more sense if you want to hit high energy orbits.

          You could still, AFAIK, use Starship to put a bunch of components into LEO and assemble something to go interplanetary. Or at least its booster.

          I have wondered if we won’t see interplanetary on a big scale (beyond Apollo scale) until we have fusion or beamed power. You could put up a beamed power constellation with this architecture I guess.

          But it makes a lot more sense as is for LEO military applications. I can see that.

          The weird Musk-Russia links, if that is real, are odd given this thesis. If we are building Golden Dome or whatever it’s called now then who is the adversary? If not Russia than who?

          China isn’t expansionist beyond Taiwan and it’d be way cheaper to build our own domestic TSMC than to fight that proxy war.

          North Korea and maybe Iran are the only other credible threats with an interest in attacking the US, and they are kind of a joke compared to Russia and China when it comes to long range capacity.

          • dnautics 1 day ago

            > The weird Musk-Russia links

            Without discounting the possibility of him being fully russia-psyopped, always keep in mind that elon MUST put forward some nonzero pro-Russia face because he is a diplomatic point of contact in an increasingly tenuous diplomatic situation between the US and Russia on account of his company lifts Russian cosmonauts to the ISS on the regular

            • actionfromafar 1 day ago

              Why would you think he cares about ISS?

              • dnautics 1 day ago

                I don't particularly love musk (I have had horrible run ins with terrible ex-musk middle managers). I think he is being genuine when he says he is worried about nuclear confrontation between US and Russia. He is one of the few diplomatic contacts between the two countries. It is plausible that someone is telling him to put on a pro Russia face (or he's doing it on his own)

          • andreygrehov 1 day ago

            Why do you think there is a country interested in attacking the US? I don't think there is a single country interested in doing so.

            > If not Russia than who?

            then*

          • somenameforme 1 day ago

            First off, I think this is all conspiratorial nonsense. But as for Golden Dome - it's more about offense than defense. The reason MAD works is because if you destroy another country then they also destroy you. But if you can negate the latter part, then you're simply left with 'you can destroy another country.' In other words if you can negate an enemy's ability to retaliate, then you can nuke or invade whoever you want, without concern about retaliation.

            The geographic location of the US would make this basically a godmode type 'weapon' because a conventional invasion of the US is practically impossible since you'd need to bring mass number of forces across an ocean and those ships would simply get popped. Even coming through South America wouldn't really work because the Isthmus of Panama could just be hyper-fortified. And even then you still have to get to South America! But the US' chosen enemies are somehow half-way around the world, and we have plenty of proxy armies we can throw against them. And when our victims retaliate against our proxies then we'll support them with a powerful army of flags, emojis, and slogans on social media.

            All that said, this still doesn't work. Nuclear fallout would affect the globe, with a Russia-US conflict estimated at driving some 5 billion deaths from climatic effects alone. [1] Missile defense will likely always lag behind offense simply because offense is akin to shooting a bullet at a giant stationary target, whereas defense is akin to shooting a bullet at a bullet. It requires a massive technology disparity to be effective. And there are also other forms of nuclear strikes than missiles - such as nuclear created radioactive (and super sized) tsunamis. And if a country really wants the flashing red button, then a salted nuke could likely kill off most of all of humanity (and everything else on Earth), let alone any given country.

            [1] - https://www.nature.com/articles/s43016-022-00573-0

      • MetaWhirledPeas 2 days ago

        Oh I doubt very much he has given up on that. He's smart enough to know that the delivery time is going to be extremely variable, and that most of the other problems involve figuring out how to make the place palatable to humans, which is just too far in the future right now. Don't bite off more than you can chew.

        • ordu 2 days ago

          > which is just too far in the future right now.

          How much time is needed to do the required research? Like, how long it would take to learn how to create an artificial biosphere on a small scale, so you can have a farm on the Moon or Mars? 10 years? 20 years? Maybe 50 years? Isn't now is the good time to start the research?

          • MetaWhirledPeas 1 day ago

            No because they aren't a government funded research team, they are actually trying to make money along the way. So the appropriate time to do that kind of work is sometime closer to actually needing it.

            • ordu 1 day ago

              > So the appropriate time to do that kind of work is sometime closer to actually needing it.

              You ignored my questions about how long the research would take. Lets suppose it would take 50 years and they get their rockets ready for Mars in 30 years. If so, they are already late for 20 years at starting the research.

      • hinkley 2 days ago

        The silver lining is that if Elon had continued pushing for Mars, to not let it happen organically, Mars would become a company town, with all the bad connotations that ever had, with paying for air added on top of it.

        • api 2 days ago

          Until they toss Musk out an airlock and found the Mars Colonial Republic. :)

      • adrian_b 2 days ago

        > a spin lab for the ISS to at least see if mice can reproduce in 0.3g?

        That was done and the results were published a few months ago, but the study did not have any relationship with SpaceX.

        The results were rather pessimistic for the long-term missions on Moon or Mars.

        In my opinion, even if it is possible that humans might support a somewhat lower gravity than mice, the conclusion is that for interplanetary travel humans must use only spaceships that create artificial gravity by rotation.

        The results of the study were that mice require a gravity of at least 2/3 of that of Earth to stay in perfect health and of at least 1/3 of that of Earth to avoid extremely severe health damage.

        This means that even on Mars the gravity is not sufficient for long-term human life. In an underground Mars base, one could make a part with increased gravity by rotation, where the crew should spend most of the time, but that would increase a lot the complexity of building and maintaining such a base.

        • hinkley 2 days ago

          Or by constant thrust at 1/3g, or a mix of thrust and rotation that achieves sufficient acceleration, though spinning + thrust means precession which I’m glad isn’t my job to zero out.

          Unless someone invents the Epstein drive we aren’t going to have astronauts experiencing acceleration for months rather than minutes of the trip. And the more constant the acceleration the shorter the trip anyway.

        • api 2 days ago

          I didn’t know this had been done.

          If the results hold then it’s another thing that counts toward settling space, not another planet.

          It’s where I’ve been leaning for a while. If we want to go beyond Earth build huge rotating stations or spacecraft. Don’t just go down another gravity well.

          Build your own spin stations and dial in the exact gravity and everything else you want. Mine asteroids, which are super easy to access. You can launch mass off an asteroid by throwing it really hard.

          • moomoo11 1 day ago

            yeah. i much rather humans build space stations than inhabit planets unless those planets are precisely suitable for us.

            we can use planets for their resources or industry.

      • stevep98 2 days ago

        I don’t think is right at all. It’s just Musk focusing on the fundamentals of ‘what is stopping us making significantly (100x or 1000x) more progress on space exploration. And the answer to that is that it’s just too expensive to launch mass off the earth.

        If you make it much cheaper, then everything else flows from that. You no longer have to spend years engineering everything at the cutting edge of your mass budget. You can use off the shelf parts, you can have redundancy.

        The gains will come when these flights become commonplace.

        • dgroshev 2 days ago

          Biosphere stuff is more fundamental than just mass. We had several closed ecosystem projects built on the ground out of concrete, with no mass limits, and all of them failed.

          • dnautics 1 day ago

            A habitat on Mars would certainly not be closed ecosystem, especially not in the beginning. The biggest issue at biosphere IIRC was CO2 poisoning. You can crack the air in a mars habitat with power and in the worst case find Martian resources that will do some advantageous chemistries

            • dgroshev 1 day ago

              This is pure speculation until it's demonstrated. Is SpaceX funding such demonstrations?

              • somenameforme 1 day ago

                Do you think they just crack open the windows on the ISS?

                • dgroshev 1 day ago

                  The ISS is taking regular deliveries of food, water, and air. Is very much not self-sufficient or closed-cycle. It's also pretty small in volume and really close to home, with evacuation readily available.

                  • somenameforme 1 day ago

                    Mars early on will also not be closed cycle. It's going to be prepping for a 2 year journey (probably ideally 4 if possible, for when things inevitably go wrong) and gradually consuming those supplies. Unlike the ISS there are vast usable resources on Mars for things like water, but again I think the goal will be to be fully non-sufficient, to help reduce the chances of the first trip being a one-way journey.

                    • dgroshev 1 day ago

                      You keep speaking in generalities. Here's an extremely high level overview of just one critically important system on the ISS, water recovery: https://ntrs.nasa.gov/api/citations/20260004140/downloads/20...

                      Things to notice: it's undergoing yearly upgrades despite NASA having literally decades of experience in this. They still hold a contingency reserve of 8OOL, despite being hours from the ground and being able to evacuate almost any time.

                      SpaceX has zero experience managing the water cycle even when it's measured in months, much less years, with spares and help many months away in the very best case. They show zero effort trying to acquire such experience.

                      Let's be real: at this point, Mars for Musk is about as much of a goal as Hyperloop. If we look at actions, not mere words, his goal looks much more like yeeting more GPUs into orbit as a "biological bootloader" [1] than colonising Mars. That's not even touching the fact that SpaceX is now a public company, has a duty for its shareholders, and colonising Mars is a strictly cash-negative enterprise.

                      [1]: https://x.com/elonmusk/status/2106906678293606496

                      • somenameforme 20 hours ago

                        I'm not speaking in generalities. As I already said, the mission will not be closed cycle or at all endeavor to be closed cycle, because that increases complexity, and opens the door to unnecessary failures. There will be basic recycling of course but the goal is not to create anything remotely like a closed system. It will take significant supplies and consume them, with the Starship itself working as the initial hab.

                        Water itself is interesting because you need a lot for consumption and other purposes, but fortuitously it also works as an excellent radiation shielding. So you kill two critical birds with one stone. An initial team of ~6 would consume about 11k liters over 2 years, double that over 4. That's around 10-20 tons, on a ship with a capacity of 100 tons, and probably 200 tons when launching. Of course you'd want significantly more water for things like non-consumption use, but factor in some basic recycling and it's quite obvious that water will not be much of an issue. It's not some idealized self sustaining system where you're trying to create a perpetual base. It's going to have supplies for 2 years, ideally 4, and nothing more.

                        And you're right Elon has an obligation to shareholders at SpaceX. Fortunately, SpaceX is yet another "public" company. He holds upwards of 80% of the voting power at SPCX and defacto is 'the shareholders.'

          • pigpop 1 day ago

            Bad engineering, too many uncontrolled variables and roundabout solutions. Just solve the problems directly. Make the air, scrub the CO2, grow only food. The solution looks like a (light weight) nuclear submarine not a greenhouse.

            Biosphere 2 was hippie gobbledygook.

            "The Biosphere 2 project was launched in 1984 by businessman and billionaire Ed Bass and systems ecologist John P. Allen, with Bass providing US$150 million in funding until 1991.[15] Bass and Allen had met in the 1970s at the Synergia Ranch, a counterculture community led by Allen, who advocated Buckminster Fuller's "Spaceship Earth" concept and explored the idea of biospheres as a refuge from disasters such as nuclear war.[15] Several other former members of Synergia Ranch also joined the Biosphere 2 project"[0]

            "Synergia Ranch is an ecovillage founded in 1969 by John P. Allen"[1]

            Ed Bass inherited $2.8 million when he was a teenager from his great uncle who made his money in oil production, he's currently chairman of an investment and venture-capital management firm. In between he hung out with a bunch of hippies.[2] Just your typical nepo-boomer arc.

            [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Biosphere_2

            [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synergia_Ranch

            [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ed_Bass

            • somenameforme 1 day ago

              More likely than growing food will be bringing a couple of years of food with you, and having growth be only for proof of concept experiments (well and some freshness if it works out).

            • dgroshev 1 day ago

              I'm looking forward to SpaceX demonstrating good engineering for a life support system that's capable of running for months on a reasonable mass budget. Except they aren't doing that, are they?

              Saying how you imagine a solution would look like is cheap, figuring out an actual system is expensive and slow. Hell, just very basic things like extracting water from urine is actually difficult (organic matter forms a tar of sorts and gunks up machinery) and in the past unforeseen problems did pop up (amount of calcium in urine from disintegrating bones was a problem and didn't show up until in-orbit testing).

              Musk is observably not doing things that Mars colonisation would require.

              • pigpop 1 day ago

                It's better to put your underwear on before your shoes.

                • dgroshev 1 day ago

                  Being able to sustain life for months and years is "underwear", not an afterthought. In fact, I won't be surprised if achieving a reasonable level of life support will take much longer than developing propulsion.

                  • pigpop 2 hours ago

                    We can already sustain life for months inside a sealed vessel, a nuclear submarine. HMS Vengeance just broke the record on Sunday after spending 217 days submerged on patrol (nuclear submarines remain submerged for the entire duration of their patrol in order to avoid giving away their location). That's a little over 7 months. The ISS is a more comparable example but it gets resupplied much more frequently. However, the resupplies could be less frequent if they had more storage space.

                    The main problem really is just getting mass to orbit. Want more hull space? You need more mass. Want more fuel? Need more mass. Want more water for life support? You need more mass.

                    A very large launch vehicle that is rapidly reusable is exactly what you need to put more mass in orbit.

                    We're at the limit of what we can learn from the ISS as far as long duration stays. We need larger space stations that can accommodate more people and more equipment so we can learn ways to mitigate the effects of low g and prove new designs for manned spaceships suitable for long duration voyages or occupation. Eventually, we also need to learn how to construct centrifugal stations in orbit. The only way to work out all of the bugs is to do it and to do all of that we need more mass.

              • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

                Why extract water from urine when you can drop 100 tons of water next to your base for less money?

            • api 1 day ago

              Wasn’t that the one Steve Bannon was involved in, of all people?

              I wasn’t necessarily thinking of Biosphere 2, just the fact that you won’t be getting a resupply on short notice.

              The problem is that Mars is 6-12 months away depending on launch window, at least with current rockets. If something goes wrong you must be able to respond locally and at least survive. The Moon is 3 days away (ish) and LEO is hours away (including time to align and dock).

              If you want to send people to Mars you need to build a Mars sim on Earth and actually test your life support systems.

              • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

                Antarctic bases gets no resupply for eight months of the year and yet somehow they manage to survive.

                When you are taking 100 tons of supplies and landing 100 tons more first, survival for a few years is only an issue in medical emergencies, just like Antarctica.

                • dgroshev 22 hours ago

                  Antarctic bases have water and air on tap. Spaceships and Martian bases don't.

          • aksss 1 day ago

            Early mars will likely be robotics, any humans will be going there to die and will volunteer for it. By the time those humans do go, trips to and landing on Mars will be old hat, providing a steady stream of supplies will mean it’s less of a self-reliance biodome situation than some imagine.

      • Teever 1 day ago

        While I'm a little more optimistic that the development of Starship will lead to manned missions to the Moon, Mars, and other bodies in the solar system I drew a similar conclusion as you did a few years ago as well.

        What I find frustrating about this is that a lot of the biological research needed to make a sustainable colony is stuff that would have direct benefits on Earth for people today.

        R&D on bioreactors, genetically engineering organisms, making food production more efficient, techniques to make people more resistant to the cancer causing effects of radiation etc... all of these could have impacts on how we live today.

      • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

        Tom Mueller spent his last few years at SpaceX working on Mars ISRU and we heard nothing about it until he left SoaceX. Not everything SpaceX does is in the open but that doesn’t mean it isn’t done.

  • Onavo 2 days ago

    I had to read the comment below (from u/modeless) before I realized by landing gear you meant the upright ones. I thought you wanted it to land sideways like a plane. (Arguably doable, though the control systems might add a lot more weight)

    • hinkley 2 days ago

      The problem with space planes is they are terrible planes, terrible rockets, and feed the egos of pilots.

      To be fair to NASA and the astronauts, NASA needed humans who behave like military test pilots. In physiology, in reaction time, in crisis management, in following chain of command. And the armed forces were willing to give them access to known quantities.

      We didn’t know how control systems would evolve over the next three decades, but the pilots wanted to pilot, and did not trust the control systems. And the irony of it all is that the Space Race was a proxy war for nuclear armament, so control systems needed to be made autonomous anyway.

      Better control systems, wider telemetry, and not worrying about incinerating employees let current generation rocketry iterate faster, and do more fucking around and finding out. We found out twice with the shuttle and it killed the program.

      It’s curious how much the upper stage now resembles a space shuttle on a ballistic trajectory instead of a glide angle. Very different landing strategies for those two modes of descent…

  • RobotToaster 2 days ago

    The space shuttle orbiter definitely had a lot more cool factor.

    • bluescrn 2 days ago

      It was extremely cool 45+ years ago. But the space race ended, and while government-funded space programs did some fantastic work beyond that (space telescopes and Mars landers), it took capitalism to develop the resuable rocket, then scale it up to Starship proportions.

      • timacles 2 days ago

        Like 50% of SpaceXs initial development came from tax payer money.

        • kortilla 2 days ago

          The government was a customer. That’s very different from the government giving a research grant.

          That’s like saying 25% of Exxon’s development came from tax payer money because the government uses a shitload of oil.

          • qlte 2 days ago

            A more accurate analogy would be giving contracts to Exxon back before they had ever found or drilled a single oil well, as their primary source of revenue to subsidize their R&D and learning curve, in the hope that they would eventually be able to supply the government with needed oil, and ultimately succeeded to become a key supplier.

            • somenameforme 1 day ago

              They only gave the contract once Falcon had already gotten into orbit.

        • boznz 1 day ago

          A good investment by Uncle Sam, it's saved them quite a bit since.

        • wallst07 1 day ago

          You realize that tax payer money goes to a lot of things the government is required to purchase?

          It's like saying tax payers are funding charmin because the pentagon uses its TP.

    • hinkley 2 days ago

      I think I’m convinced that VTOL is a better engineering trade off for space ships rather than making space planes.

      • pigpop 1 day ago

        Absolutely, wings only work in Earth's atmosphere. Rocket propulsion can work anywhere. Leaving the landing gear on Earth is also a no brainer since it's only ever used there so why bring it all the way to orbit with you? Thankfully all the other rocks we'd want to land on have much lower gravity so landing on them can be done with lightweight legs. Hell, maybe there's a way to send the landing structure ahead of time like some variation on that Chinese cable catcher they used for their copycat.

        • hinkley 1 day ago

          The Chinese cable catcher is their version of the Sky Hook, I believe.

          Can't blame them for copycatting an idea we stopped working on. But Tethers Inc had trouble with electrical current along their cables being many times bigger than their math suggested, so I don't know what's going on there.

    • pfdietz 2 days ago

      It also had a large stupid factor. Like one of von Braun's Germans was reported to have said: "they reinvented the wheel -- and made it square."

      • Rzor 1 day ago

        Could you share a bit more about where that quote came from exactly? Any primary sources?

        • pfdietz 1 day ago

          No, unfortunately I cannot. I've looked. So I can't dismiss the possibility it's apocryphal. I do remember seeing it so I'm not just making it up (but frustratingly I cannot present evidence to convince you of that).

      • RobotToaster 1 day ago

        Part of its design specification was the ability to recover satellites from orbit, it's rumoured this was to have the ability to capture soviet satellites.

  • tim333 1 day ago

    I think Stoke Space's is supposed to land on it's metal base. Launch supposedly soon.

proee 2 days ago

i wonder how much fuel was left over after landing? What is their safety margin in seconds of burn remaining?

  • Rover222 2 days ago

    Probably 2 to 3 seconds max? You pay a massive penalty for carrying any extra fuel.

  • generuso 1 day ago

    I have no idea about Starship, but in one of the Environmental Assessment reports there was specific data on the fuel remaining in Falcon-9 after landing. It was <1270 kg of RP-1, which is equal to 14 seconds of firing at full thrust for one engine -- if one could use all of the fuel up, which is typically not possible. That was the upper bound.

maxdo 1 day ago

Curious what will be next 10x design? Nuclear propulsion? Same rocket made by robots ?

  • jimbokun 1 day ago

    Space elevator?

    • cryptonector 9 hours ago

      Can you imagine the damages if a space elevator fails and crashes onto the planet? You'll really see NIMBYism then. It would have to be placed really far out of the way, on some desolate Pacific island or atoll.

  • Laremere 1 day ago

    My bet: Moon based vehicle and propellant manufacturing. It's just so much easier to get stuff off of the moon that if you were going to build anything of any real size in space, the moon is where I'd get the bulk raw material given the choice.

  • O5vYtytb 1 day ago

    I think Starship is like entering the wide-body jet age of aircraft. A lot of fine-tuning and efficiency gains from now until it's ubiquitous and cheap. But getting from that to another 10x gain is much harder, similar to aircraft where we haven't seen a "10x" jump since wide-body jets.

childintime 2 days ago

How many years until the next milestones?

- in orbit refueling

- moon landing

- Mars rendez-vous

- Mars landing

- humans on Mars

Nah, the game is to put data centers in space. Plus the Space Force dreams.

  • loehnsberg 2 days ago

    Launches, Starlink, military provide cash. SpaceX needs to be profitable at least to some extent.

  • shoobiedoo 2 days ago

    What actually is the point of all this? I'm not trying to be a snarky contrarian, I've never had any interest whatsoever in space, star trek, "what's out there?", so I genuinely don't get it.

    I'm not trashing people's interests, obviously I am the odd man out in not giving a damn, I just don't see what we're trying to achieve when there are so many issues we can't even figure out on earth.

    • jddkj 2 days ago

      Well considering we gave SpaceX a contract to get us to the moon and for that to happen it needs to do something ridiculous like 20+ in orbit refueling yeah it's a pretty important thing to criticize.

    • oceanplexian 2 days ago

      If you don’t get it, nothing anyone says is going to convince you otherwise.

      The people who “had an interest” in pursuing the unknown built the entire modern world that you exist in, since so many things have some connection back to the space program, including ironically the very device you’re using to express your opinion. So it’s probably worth paying them a little respect.

      • origini 2 days ago

        So we did the moon landing btw.

        Shouldn't you be able to articulate a proper answer without any issues?

        Is it an engineering feat? Yes.

        But i would bet James Webb Telescope and Moon landing were a lot bigger?!

        • hparadiz 2 days ago

          A single one of these Starship's payloads can deliver a telescope approximately 20-25x larger than the James Webb Telescope.

          • origini 2 days ago

            Okaaayyy? We still were able to send James Webb up without a Starship?

            Soooo?!

            Its cheaper okay, we can send up bigger things good but the comment stated

            "So it’s probably worth paying them a little respect."

            It sounds like i get down to my knee for Space-X and i still don't get it

            • hparadiz 2 days ago

              This is the most powerful rocket ever constructed. It has the largest possible payload. The James Webb is tiny compared to what is possible. No other rocket can do that. End of. Please stop. You are embarrassing yourself.

              • origini 2 days ago

                Ah I see a fanboy.

                Okay I get it, discussion useless.

                Just to be clear: James Webb was build and designed with nanometer aligned optical system, has to be cooled down while being at L2, can't be serviced and repaired and it was only enough money there to build it once and took 5 years of building and 25 years of planning.

                A rocket is an engineering joke inc omparision.

                • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

                  That's why a car salesman could build it with fraction of cost while nasa sucking on thumb and spending 100x more money to launch anything. Cool

                  • origini 2 days ago

                    It is an achievement, i'm not disagreeing with it.

                    I'm disagreeing with the level of it.

                    I'm also disappointed that we celebrate this and ignore that the richest man on the planet is also involved in reducing usability of starlink in a real war were real humans are dying. And his involvment in USAID, DOGE and co.

                    • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

                      Starshield is govt controlled.

                      Starlink is not allowed for offensive usage.

                      So take your complaint to govt. Also, nobody is stopping you from using starlink-alternatives.com . In fact, since you hate him, that's what you should do.

                      • origini 2 days ago

                        Ukraine is defending itself and just before Trump, US of America put a lot of pressure on my country germany and the europeian union to stop doing business with Russia.

                        Now Elon Musk, the richecst person on the planet and part of US of America is interfering with his system, which gives him A LOT more power than a single human and non gov should have in a WAR which is not his probably due to some indirect garbage between him and the current US of America Gov.

                        While the EU is paying for it.

                        And i do not use anything Musk.

                        Musk has only direct negative impact on my life, no posive one. He used his money to buy twitter because he couldn't shut up and then leveraged it to manipulate and allow manipulation in our elections in germany (search for Elon Musk and AfD).

                        He is potentially poisening our atmosphwere with his rocket launches.

                        And in general, I do care about fellow human beings and i'm pissed in their names for all the people he is responsible for being killed (after all he is also responsible apparently for all the invention of the companies he invested in eh?).

                        • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

                          Why does EU rely on a system built by a private person?

                          Where is EU's innovation? Oh wait, we are busy with bottle caps, stays together like family lmao https://x.com/moritzkremb/status/2107021822155985254

                          Where is Germany's nuclear power plants?

                          Where is Germany's industry? Why is Germany axing its own legs and then crying about it? Why did Germany laugh when Trump complained about over reliance on Russian gas? Why is Germany predicted to not have enough gas this January? Why is Germany fucking up the middle class with more and more taxes? All that tax, yet almost nothing to show for. Keine geld!! Economy going to shit. People taking sick days like candy. More people dying to heat than gun violence in USA. Hours of notary to open a company. Effing europoors and you come to complain...

                          PS: Statistically, when I walk on the streets, every 4 German I meet, there's one nazi (as per your definition I would strongly assume). Look inside first.

                          • origini 2 days ago

                            If a private person from another country is the only one controlling space, it becomes a geo politicial and military issue.

                            So either we should advocate for destroying it, or we are allowed to leverage.

                            And for all the other things you ar ementioning: Non of them have anything to do to what i said. Its just strawman left and right.

                            Are you also joking about the Gas and winter? Because Donald Trump, the President of the US of America used his power to start a war with Iran.

                            More people in USA die from gun and heat than germans die from gun and heat.

                            And just because there are nazis around the world, i'm not and this is part of my argumentation. If you are a nazi and it doesnt matter to you, of course you don't understand it.

                            You argue with your Salesman, but don't care of anything negative about Elon Musk? As long as he catches a Rocket eh? Get a spine?

                            • CrimsonRain 1 day ago

                              A private person is building things, he "controls" the space because he built things. Nobody stopped Europe from building those things. Again, Starlink is not for military purposes. You have an issue, go complain to US Govt who controls Starsheild.

                              No, it is because Germany decided to eff up the economy in the name of bogus crap by removing nuclear before enough solar came online.

                              > heat

                              Europe*

                              You, as a German, have zero right to complain when 1/4 (soon 1/3) of your country men are Nazi. As I said, look INSIDE (and stop blaming everyone else).

                              • origini 13 hours ago

                                you are still strawmanning.

                                I can be against Nazi Elon Musk AND in parallel against 1/4 Nazi germans (and no its not 1/3 or 1/4).

                                I'm not blaming Elon Musk for some nazi germans, i'm blaming elon musk for being who he is.

                                A private person can't just build things and just do things on one united planet. Its the same thing as why countries are not just building nuclear arsenals. Controlling space is a weapon and it becomes geopolitical.

                                But hey it seems you are a nazi? You don't care about any of Elon Musks nazi things eh?

                                And it doesn't matter what starlink is for and it doesn't matter if you call it starshield or starlink. its nitpicking nothing else

                                • hparadiz 8 hours ago

                                  You are the nazi.

                                  • origini 6 hours ago

                                    You know it triggers me very zero if someone random on the internet is just trying to offend others.

                                    I'm more disappointed in you as a human being that you don't seem to be able to have a civilized argument / discussion.

                                    Is everything okay with you? Are you some random troll never leaving the house or basement?

                                • hparadiz 8 hours ago

                                  You owe me and a lot of other people reperations.

                                • CrimsonRain 4 hours ago

                                  You sound jealous that someone was able to build a (or many) tech that has massive success, moving the world forward, and using that momentum to build more...while your dear (1/4 Nazi) Germany is busy taking sick days non stop, voting more of AfD, and winding down industry (like VW etc). Did your skin crawl at the this news: https://x.com/AndrThie/status/2122363982627389528 :salty:

                                  It seems you did not wake up from your "united planet" dream (1939 - 1945 RIP) yet where you get to command the world what to build or not as a German.

                                  • origini 1 hour ago

                                    You are again just strawmaning.

                                    Tell me, why do you not care at all what Musk did with DOGE? Giving kids the power to stop random programs?

                                    Stopping USAID and killing kids?

                                    You also don't care at all that he was raffling off a million for votes for a political party?

                                    Why does all of this not bother you at all mh?

                                    There is no benefit in what Musk does which has such an impact, that it has to happen through him but I would for sure enjoy certain progress a lot more if i wouldn't remember him doing a nazi salute on TV or walking around with a chainsaw or whatever.

                                    how did we loose so much credibility against people and espeically people who are that influencal?

                                    People cult?

                                    Are you just pissing at me and not him because you work for any of his companies and benefiting from it?

                                    I don't evne know what you mean with your united planet, it has nothing to do with germany it has everything to do with Elon Musk as a human being.

                          • lostlogin 2 days ago

                            > Why did Germany laugh when Trump complained about over reliance on Russian gas?

                            Any idea that Trump is a perceptive genius with regard to energy security should have been throughly dispelled with the Iran fiasco that rolls on.

                            • CrimsonRain 1 day ago

                              A broken clock can be right once or twice a day but that doesn't mean one is not an idiot to deny it (the time; not the clock) _when_ it is right.

                          • origini 13 hours ago

                            Ah and clarifing the Gas in January thing: 1. because the smart Trump started a war and 2. Because Reichelt doesn't want to buy it too expensive.

              • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

                You can assemble stuff in space - like the ISS.

                • hparadiz 1 day ago

                  The ISS took 125 Billion and 12 years to assemble. Starship can put the same amount of payload into space in 5 launches for less than 1 billion.

                  • peterfirefly 1 day ago

                    And inflatable modules would also help, at least with the living quarters. Not so much for the science modules.

                  • HarHarVeryFunny 9 hours ago

                    Pretty sure the 12-year timeline wasn't bottle-necked by launch rate. Amortized costs would have been lower if it had all been Russian launches rather than using the shuttle!

                    Starship certainly ought to reduce cost, but its payload capacity is only 5x that of Falcon 9 which can already fly multiple times per week, and any large project, even orbital refueling, is going to require multiple launches anyway.

                    If launch was the bottleneck, then even using Falcon 9 with a couple of launches per week you could put the ISS's 420 tons into orbit in about 10 weeks.

            • dingaling 2 days ago

              With Starship, it will cost about $70-90 to put 1kg of payload into orbit.

              That will open vast new opportunities for space-based researh and services.

              For example a university that has to pay at least $50k to launch a research cubesat today will be able to do it for about $2k.

              • potatototoo99 1 day ago

                And? We can't live in space, we can't travel because distances are too large, it's still polluting our orbit and a huge waste of resources, for what? Just build more satellites? Is there even the demand for more satellite internet?

                I'm all for doing R&D for research's sake, like medicine research in zero G, but this exagerated "everything related with space is magical and life-changing" view is ridiculous. This whole HN thread is ridiculous, this is the crowd that would fall hook line & sinker for datacenters in space.

                • cj9 1 day ago

                  The real answer is simple. We've made it so hellish to live on earth, the only answer is to fantasize about getting as far away as possible. Even if that place is deadly to human and plant life.

                • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

                  People have been living in space for 25 years.

                  • origini 13 hours ago

                    And come back with reduced muscle mass and bone mass.

      • shoobiedoo 2 days ago

        > since so many things have some connection back to the space program, including ironically the very device you’re using to express your opinion.

        Well there you go. I did not know that. And yet, instead of saying, "The space program is useful because of X and Y, it's pretty cool actually, I recommend book Z about it.", I get replies that I am a lost cause who doesn't respect scientists.

        Unreal. I could have a more balanced conversation with a Muslim imam about religious beliefs.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          At some point it is easier to believe one is a troll than that ignorant of the contributions the space program has made to humanity.

          • shoobiedoo 1 day ago

            I guess I never thought about it besides the space race and watching Apollo 13.

            And, you know, the fact that if it was so critical to the advancement of humanity, there would be far more competition from around the globe and private contracting companies.

    • DivingForGold 2 days ago

      Perhaps you don't have any clue that earth and it's inhabitants are very, very likely to be the only one, - - or, of the very few planets in our known universe, with such a sequence of events over millions if not billions of years that allow us to be living beings, evolving - - while out in space is a vacuum, intense radiation, no oxygen, no food or water for many hundreds if not thousands of light years distance away. Incredibly few of our species grasps this fact and actually appreciates it ...

    • philipwhiuk 2 days ago

      What's the point of heating sand - we barely have enough food to feed our pre-industrial society.

    • arjie 2 days ago

      > damn, I just don't see what we're trying to achieve when there are so many issues we can't even figure out on earth

      Earth issues are mostly coordination problems. Space issues are technological problems. Elon Musk has been very successful at solving technological problems: electric vehicles, space flight, mind-machine interfaces.

      It makes sense that people like him who can solve technological problems point their attention and substantial agency to the things that their unique skills place them in a position to solve.

      The Elon Musk of coordination does not currently exist. One must imagine that the kind of person or school of people who instituted NATO and the US-Japan MDA and turned our one-time enemies into our staunchest allies were people of such caliber but there’s no one I know today who qualifies for that.

      Musk definitely has mastered firm-level coordination but clearly national coordination (let alone international coordination) is a problem beyond even him. His teams nearly religiously point the same way, and they have achieved wonders. It is truly remarkable what these people have done. Good for them, and I’m glad to see them at it!

      • origini 2 days ago

        Elon Musk is not the person building any of it. Not EVs, Space Flight or mind-machine interfaces.

        He is reckless and ignorant and yes it works for some of his stuff and it doesn't work for others.

        His ignorance alone in DOGE probably killed children and humans. Don't get me wrong, US of America doesn't has to pay for aid around the planet even if they contribute massivly to climate change and consumes a lot of resources importet around the planet, but his abrupt cancelation and involvment in USAID killed chilrden and humans.

        Do we also ignore everything else if you list up things which are only positive? Like Boring company? Solar city? Buying Twitter and manipulating democracy around the planet? Doing an Ad tour in front of the White House and disrespecting anyone else who can't buy themselves next to Trump?

      • shoobiedoo 2 days ago

        Thank you for the well thought out reply. I will try to do better to understand the larger technological breakthroughs of space flight as a key development in how things modernize on earth itself

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          Just as a simple example, Starlink needs cheaper launch to expand, and it has already provided medical care, education and job opportunities to unreachable places, improved communication and science at remote places like Antarctic bases, made work on long duration plane flights practical, provided a war torn country with communications despite continuous attack from their aggressor. Satellite emergency communications like iPhone included has saved lives and full outdoor coverage will eventually be available because of cheaper launch.

  • bluecalm 2 days ago

    I mean, you need to get money from somewhere to fund your dreams. If it's datacenters in space then let be it. They are pretty cool as well. It seems a lot of people don't like them on Earth.

    • ReptileMan 2 days ago

      >They are pretty cool as well.

      That remains to be determined. The math with blackbody radiation cooling borderline works. So they may be cool, but whether it is enough ...

      But I don't think we will see success before the craziness down here has settled down and they don't face the political headwinds they currently do. And I don't think that they can compete with ground based per unit cost no matter what kind of black magic they do.

      • bluecalm 1 day ago

        It would be enough if political headwinds don't settle on the ground then orbital ones would enjoy big advantage. If we fail to lower energy prices orbital ones can win as well.

  • mlh496 2 days ago

    It's important to be able to set aside cynicism, even if for a single hour, to enjoy technological achievements like this.

    • runarberg 2 days ago

      It is important to recognize what technology will be used for and demand it won‘t be used for evil.

      • snvzz 2 days ago

        The implied claim being "datacenters are evil"?!

      • rs_rs_rs_rs_rs 2 days ago

        That ship has sailed since the V2 rocket.

        • hagbard_c 2 days ago

          That ship has sailed since the first rockets were used to launch bombs and incendiaries somewhere in China, a long time ago. Hammers can be used to build and to kill. Knives cut wood as well as flesh. Humans are belligerent primates whether we want it or not, changing that isn't something even all humanities faculties in the world can manage nor any ideologue intent on creating the New Soviet Man or Übermensch or transhumanist. Fortunately there tend to be more people intent on doing 'good' things with technology than 'bad', where 'good' can also include defending against those doing 'bad' things even though that is a thin line to walk.

    • wat10000 2 days ago

      Is it? I mean, I’m loving this historic event but if someone wants to remember the stupid parts, what’s wrong with that?

    • Noaidi 2 days ago

      I am not a cynic, but a realist. It is easy to do things when you put a ton of money towards the effort so I find this nothing special. Maybe when I was a child these things would fascinate me, but they are just engineering.

      So, what would amaze me? Ending homelessness in the United States. Because that takes more than money. I would like to swap the "passion" or engineering for the "compassion" of ending suffering. Very easy to shape and change material things, very hard to change the heart.

      The people you want to share your excitement might be suffering under the same separation of wealth that made this landing possible. (Yet there is little talk that they failed to catch the booster and it exploded).

      • globalnode 2 days ago

        ofc a comment like that would get downvoted by investors and technologists, but yes i agree, if you have enough imagination and money, almost anything in engineering is eventually possible. that same imagination and money is rarely spent on making the experience of living beings who are suffering nicer. but we dont live in a 1D world and all people need a win, engineering nerds included.

        • TeMPOraL 2 days ago

          Space is unique in consistently attracting comments like GP's. Literally no other endeavor, no matter how boring or silly, attracts these. Has been so since before the Internet, even.

          Even pointing out that this is just private company doing private stuff - so no government money to accuse of being misallocated, which was the only thing that gave those evergreen comments some legitimacy - won't help. I guess it's just inertia now.

          At least this is talking about homelessness and not feeding people; the latter was getting too easy to push back on by pointing out just how much space contributed to farming and food security.

          • Noaidi 1 day ago

            > so no government money to accuse of being misallocated

            They have at least $3.6 billion from the US to misallocate. Closer to $10 billion.

            https://www.usaspending.gov/recipient/8a3a5525-3218-a488-db0...

            https://lew.am/comparing-subsidies-received-by-spacex-boeing...

            • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

              That is a firm fixed price contract that only pays in milestones set by the government being completed. If they don’t meet those milestones they don’t get paid, and if they misallocate the contract funds they have to make it up from their own money just like Boeing had to pay for two extra Starliner flights out of their own pocket (though Boeing is a bit of an exception because NASA graded them too easily and then paid them extra and recently even more extra so they would fix Starliner).

          • globalnode 1 day ago

            i was posting in support of all parties, the nerds and the homeless. i guess space attracts these sorts of comments because of the extreme contrast. on the one hand, going to space takes enormous energy, manpower and money, and its easy to claim misallocation of resources when the extremes are so glaring. its a good opportunity to point these things out when theyre so obvious.

      • peterfirefly 2 days ago

        Semaglutide will likely help on the homelessness front, both directly and by helping us understand deep drives better in general.

        Musk's Neuralink is ironically likely to help on the psychiatric disorder side.

        Just Send More Money™ is not likely to help (as you recognize). Neither is "compassion".

        • bigyabai 2 days ago

          And a $25,000 EV will alleviate the auto crisis in Americ- wait a minute...!

          • peterfirefly 1 day ago

            The two big causes of homelessness are substance addiction and craziness. Semaglutide is the first medical intervention that can help to some extent with the desire part of addiction.

            Electric brain stimulation is likely able to help with mood disorders. Maybe even OCD and schizophrenia. If nothing else, proper measurements (lots of good data) of both healthy brains and mentally ill brains should help. We've had almost none of that, with EEGs being rather pathetic.

            Nobody is going to "solve" homelessness tomorrow or next year. Not the people who think they can just spend more money -- someone's money, not their own, not the people who think charity is the way forward, and not the people who think what is needed is cures.

            We can do some almost immediately if we are willing to institutionalize more people but it's not a good or complete solution and we aren't willing to, anyway.

            The real improvements are likely to eventually come from things like semaglutide (and more likely more research into the instincts that drive addiction, now that we finally have a molecule that can affect them) and things that both provide data (that we sorely need) and can provide interventions directly in the brain.

            • bigyabai 1 day ago

              Still waiting on the promised $25,000 EV though. If Neuralink is anything like American EVs, psychiatric patients might as well move to China for treatment.

      • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

        > Ending homelessness in the United States

        You don't need private people/companies or more taxes for that. US has enough resources to do it already. Maybe you should go ask your politicians, better yet, ask your friends/neighbors/yourself if you are ready to take the drastic steps necessary to solve that.

        • Noaidi 2 days ago

          Well to start off, I am homeless, so I can’t really ask myself for help with that.

          But imagine engineering hearts so that we did not have to ask?

          • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

            Of course, you should not need to ask, in a better world.

            If govt really cared about it, more than that, if (most) PEOPLE really cared about it, it should be top 3 priority of any govt in any country.

            - Govt should build massive cheap hotel-type housing spaces (full free) equipped with bare minimum necessities like roof, heating, food, basic healthcare (not million $ free cancer treatment).

            - Mandatory drug rehabilitation (if applicable)

            - Mandatory job search/placement/training

            - Jail with forced-labor for people who put no effort and/or causes disturbance

            If your govt has $6M to fund tourism in Egypt, money to fund opera/ in columbia, comic book in peru, then they have money to help homeless people IN the country. No money should go to non-citizens (let alone non-citizens in another country) while citizens of a country go homeless.

            I am typing this from the security of my home, without worrying about 0c temp, or food. So it is easy for me to say this but still, I am sorry that you are going through this, and I sincerely wish you the best; that your life turns around, even if just a little, enough to have a roof over your head.

      • Lambdanaut 2 days ago

        Thank you for for making this comment. It helped me realize in myself what's changed over the last few years.

        I grew up reading Zubrin's The Case for Mars, The Martian, and October Sky. I went to space camp at NASA, and as a 14 year old I sent an angry email to NASA when I learned of the early ISS decommission date(they later extended the lifespan several times, and I like to think I was the reason ;) ).

        I followed Bigelow Aerospace in the 2000s doing the only interesting commercial work in space, and afterwards became amongst the first online SpaceX fanboys, long before they ever landed a merlin engine.

        I studied hard in school with a passion of going to Embry-Riddle to learn to build rockets - though I ultimately chose a software path in life instead, I stayed an enormous space fanboy over the 2010s, frequenting the SpaceX subreddit and catching every launch and landing stream I could live.

        I've cried watching so many rocket landings. The spirit of human endeavor is god damn BEAUTIFUL to me.

        I want to point my finger and say that everything else changed. The Internet became what it is. Elon Musk showed his true colors. Software Engineering became middle management.

        But the truth is that I've changed.

        I care about the people wealth disparity hurts more than I do about us getting our perfect vision of the future now now NOW.

        The faster we pump this machine, the louder the Earth is SCREAMING.

        The world is on fire, and we're covering it in data centers with the goal of building artificial machines for strip-mining humanity of the very competency in engineering that has given us so much joy.

        We're caught up in a race to the bottom and without diverting our path I have to wonder if this starship landing will be one of the last great human-driven engineering achievements before we lose the ability to do so ourselves.

        I don't think the answer is to swap the passion for engineering with compassion, as I think they can both live happily together, but I hear where that desire is coming from.

        It's coming from a place of love.

        And when the last tree has fallen, we may find that we cannot eat money.

        May love fill this place.

        • Ginger-Pickles 2 days ago

          Thank you for having the courage to post this

          • Noaidi 1 day ago

            Fcking makes me sad that they were so downvoted. What is wrong with people?

      • variant 2 days ago

        Homelessness is largely driven by personal choice and by our desire to not compel the "unhoused" into mental institutions where they'd probably be better served.

        There are ample government and private support mechanisms, including housing and food, but most choose not to take advantage.

        • Noaidi 1 day ago

          > Homelessness is largely driven by personal choice

          Ha! Really? I am homeless. Disabled with a serious mental illness. I just cannot afford housing anymore. Living out of my minivan.

          Not my choice. I do not even have a psychiatrist or therapist anymore.

          > There are ample government and private support mechanisms, including housing and food, but most choose not to take advantage.

          This is the biggest myth neoliberals tell themselves to feel better. I agev up. Seven years on a section 8 housing list then they just dumped me with no explanation.

      • chinabot 2 days ago

        Me and four other engineering graduates just sat and watched this around a big TV in my mates apartment in Sydney, and what we saw was an amazing team, delivering amazing engineering results. Just take a win for humanity for once.

      • schmookeeg 1 day ago

        I would think that private space exploration frees up all sorts of NASA funding which can be spent on your social improvements of choice, no? Hard for me to see the either-or you're positing. We can have both.

        I share your unhappiness with the grifts, including SpaceX's. Then I think of the thousands of lesser, more damaging-in-aggregate ones that I likely have no view into, and it bums me out.

        So yeah, what I have left is my child-like "heck yeah rockets!" :) And this one was great.

    • aksss 1 day ago

      Celebrate success, eschew cynicism!

  • runarberg 2 days ago

    All I want are bigger and more cleverly located space telescopes, a couple of more probes and orbiters around other planets and asteroids, and I want those Mars samples that Percy has been pooping over the Mars surface returned to Earth and studied in a lab. And maybe a probe to Alpha Centauri or exo-planet viewers that use the Sun’s gravitational lensing in the next 5 or 6 decades.

  • consensus1 2 days ago

    I don't know how long it will take, but I'll be here watching you seethe as they hit each one and you post another list.

    • jiggawatts 2 days ago

      “Full flow engines can’t be made!”

      “Okay, they can, but the engines are too complex and expensive!”

      “Okay, they can be made much simpler and cheaper, but they’re not powerful enough!”

      “Okay, they’re powerful enough but the heat shield won’t work!”

      “Okay, it works, but catching a rocket is impractical!”

      “Okay, catching a rocket is practical, but…” <—- we are here.

      • consensus1 2 days ago

        Coming up next:

        "They'll never be able to re-use the ship"

        "They can re-use it, but it's not economical".

        • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

          "They can re-use it economically but can't be fast enough"

          "They can re-use it economically and fast back to back...but look at the amount of environmental damage!"

          "They can't generate enough power to fix the damage"

          "They generated enough power to undo environmental damages but ruined the sky"

          ...

  • drivebyhooting 2 days ago

    Those exploration dreams can only exist via the bankrolling of government contracts and riding bubbles.

    Google is only able to fund Waymo, Quantum Computing, etc because of their questionably moral ads cash cow.

  • Rover222 2 days ago

    That's your reaction to watching this? Pretty sad.

  • trothamel 2 days ago

    In orbit refueling is likely next year. The goal is to have two shots at a moon landing in 2028.

    And a nuclear ion rocket scheduled for 2028 as well.

    The current NASA administrator is doing a good job getting rid of all the things keeping NASA from doing things. (And at least after Artemis II, both parties in congress seemed to be on his side.)

    • dylan604 2 days ago

      What was the issue that delayed Issacman's nomination/confirmation? Why was his nomination withdrawn and then renominated?

      • trothamel 2 days ago

        I believe it was Trump and Elon Musk falling out over the "Big Beautiful Bill". A lot of people then campaigned for to get the job anyway, and he did.

        After Artemis II, there was a moderately hilarious congressional hearing in which the Republicans insisted on giving NASA more money, the Democrats insisted on giving even more money than that, and Isaacman trying to say "we're good".

        (I believe NASA got the more money.)

  • jillesvangurp 2 days ago

    Couple of milestones before that:

    - flying reused booster + Starship

    - longer in orbit missions for Starship of weeks or months. There are some non trivial issues with that probably; and you'd need that to not make refueling pointless.

    - having two active launch sites. Nor strictly required but probably handy if you are going to have two Starships in orbit at the same time.

    They might not get to all that in that order. But the important step today is that they get to inspect a "flight proven" Starship without water damage. I bet they are going to learn a lot of details of where exactly they need to iterate and improve. This took them some time with Falcon 9 as well. We've gotten used to this thing basically launching and landing without many issues. But that wasn't always the case. 2027 is probably going to see an increase launch rate.

    Moon landings are going to be an interesting one because it depends on NASA as well and the decision making around that is very political. On the other hand, there's going to be increasing peer pressure from the Chinese. They have their own plans and it doesn't involve waiting for NASA to get there first. They are targeting 2030 for a manned mission. I expect the politics might get a bit more opinionated on that topic as that gets closer. The long term game here is not just landing and planting another flag but actually establishing a permanent presence on the moon. That involves flying useful payloads back and forth. Starship seems designed for that.

    What happens after that is going to be an interesting one. IMHO, Starship is optimal for earth landings but not necessarily for the moon and Mars. What's currently flying is probably over engineered for a place with no atmosphere and one 6th of the gravity (the moon) or a very thin atmosphere and one third of the gravity (Mars). Would those flaps even work in the Mars atmosphere? However, it's a great launch vehicle to get components in space to build something more optimal. Also the booster might be used to launch other things than Starship. Like something that will never come down and can instead be fueled for deep space missions and Mars/Moon landings.

    • m4rtink 2 days ago

      They did refly one of the boosters already.

  • sampo 1 day ago

    > humans on Mars

    Only recently I read how the dust on Mars surface is toxic, contains those unhealthy ultrafine particles (PM2.5 and PM0.10) and sticks to almost all surfaces. It will be difficult to keep from getting inside a habitat.

    https://www.space.com/astronomy/mars/mars-dust-is-toxic-how-...

    And how the Apollo astronauts got "lunar hay fever", allergy-like symptoms from the lunar dust that stuck outside their space suits and so got carried inside their lunar module.

    https://www.esa.int/articles/about-us/directorates/human-and...

extraextra 1 day ago

Amazing achievement for SpaceX and for humanity

sidcool 1 day ago

Amazing, kudos SpaceXAI. You folks just don't give up!

abhikul0 1 day ago

Picture perfect catch with amazing views all along!

soorajsanker 1 day ago

I feel the website deserves special attention!

arjie 2 days ago

Magical era. What a feat!

jhrmnn 1 day ago

It’s very cool and an amazing technological achievement. But I cannot stop thinking - do we need it? I know that’s a minority take. How much of a minority?

dantheman 1 day ago

truly an amazing accomplishment, such an exciting time. go spacex!

teravor 2 days ago

will scaling the size of the rocket continue to be the way to go? will doing a three stage setup make sense?

  • papercrane 2 days ago

    The tyranny of the rocket equation says no, probably not. As you add mass the amount of fuel you need goes up exponentially.

    • dopa42365 1 day ago

      Fuel costs practically nothing, a tiny percentage of the total launch cost. At some point an additional 1000 tons of liquid oxygen only sets you back $250k. Kerosene or LNG is cheap too. At the very least your booster and first stage fuel cost is more or less irrelevant, make them as simple and big as possible. Just gotta avoid hydrogen and specialty gases.

      • trollbridge 1 day ago

        I don't think they were talking about dollar cost but rather mass ratio cost.

  • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

    There has been some mention of a stretched Starship.

Rover222 2 days ago

New tech tree unlocked for humanity.

alcomatt 1 day ago

I wish them good luck. Now we wait and see how many times they can do it without accident for either the ship or the booster. Propulsion by a controlled explosion is a fickle beast so I suspect the mileage will vary and I wonder how would future launch and landing failures (which I expect will unfortunately happen) will impact the programme in general.

jdprgm 2 days ago

It's crazy how far you have to scroll to even see this on the front page of NYT.

  • bamboozled 2 days ago

    Maybe people have bigger problems ? War, cost of living crisis etc ?

    • s08148692 2 days ago

      Would be nice if the good news got some room on the front page, no wonder people are so hopeless when the things that would give them hope and optimism are buried under a pile of doom

      • bamboozled 2 days ago

        I forgot to mention Space X has again limited Ukraines star link again so people are dying from their inability to intercept Russian ballistics…personally I find that more important front page news…you reap what you sew ?

        I don’t disagree with you but this exciting for “tech people” who are into engineering. That’s about all.

      • usrusr 1 day ago

        What good news though? These days it's a tie at best between humanity reaching new levels of space access and trillionaireity reaching new levels of stranglehold on humanity.

        Sorry, as much as I'd like to separate the two, I can't.

  • Jtarii 1 day ago

    I wonder if it has anything to do with the CEO being a fascist?

    • pmdr 1 day ago

      Yeah, he and his team were up there on the tower sieg-heiling as the ship came down. /s

      • Natfan 1 day ago

        nope, just generating csam while in international airspace /s

traviswingo 2 days ago

This is incredible. Huge respect for the engineering team. What a time to be alive.

As an aside, it’s been fun watching the number of UFO posts on Reddit while Starship orbited Earth. They all refused to believe it was SpaceX.

flowerlad 2 days ago

Congrats to SpaceX engineers! But for those who are not fans of the guy at the top here's a video of Blue Origin landing their rocket. Competition is good! https://www.youtube.com/shorts/XjSmNf3y37U

  • pmdr 1 day ago

    They're likely not fans of the other guy either.

neverrroot 1 day ago

What great top comments in here. The others finally keep quiet. Facts speak for themselves.

panick21_ 2 days ago

Kind of crazy to reduce the hardware on ship so much and move so much complexity to the ground. This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.

  • origini 2 days ago

    What do you mean? Reducing the complexity of the drive doesn't mean moving anything to ground?

    Or do i miss something?

  • fedpost 2 days ago

    That's...the point. You can hire commercial welders to work on the ground side and build everything out once, cheaply.

    The issue with the shuttle era was that they needed huge teams of specialized technicians to refurbish the insanely complex orbiter after every mission.

    If we ever get sufficiently improved materials science for heat shields and engines there's still always a possibility of returning to the SSTO space plane concept. That would allow a more austere launch and recovery environment, but given current limitations this is the local maxima.

    • sfblah 1 day ago

      The actual problem with the shuttle was the same as the same as the actual problem with all space technologies -- there just isn't that much value in launching stuff into space. It's nonzero, but it's a rounding error when compared to terrestrial applications.

  • TMWNN 1 day ago

    >This can really only happen in a situation where anybody can throw out any dumb idea, because if you suggested this 20 years ago people would think you are an idiot.

    Indeed.

    Musk's biographer tweeted the pages from his book <https://x.com/WalterIsaacson/status/1844870018351169942> discussing how in late 2020 Musk suggested, then insisted against considerable opposition from his engineers, that Superheavy be caught with chopsticks instead of landing on legs like Falcon 9.

    Also according to the book, Musk is the person who suggested and, against considerable opposition from his engineers, insisted on Starship switching to stainless steel instead of carbon fiber <https://x.com/richardprice100/status/1728106606616015097>.

    (Hint to others: Musk was right and his engineers were wrong. Both times.)

thomastraum 1 day ago

my 10 year old: "shame they can't fix their video player though" (the one on the x website)

hparadiz 2 days ago

This achievement likely changes the course of life in this solar system.

  • origini 2 days ago

    What?

    Why?

    Are suddenly aliens on the moon or mars and now because its cheaper to send stuff there, its now suddenly economically worthwhile to do so?

    • Meneth 2 days ago

      The course of human life, now much closer to Mars colonization, thanks to reusable launch being so much cheaper than expendable.

      • origini 2 days ago

        Mars colonization doesn't make sense though. You can't colonize a planet which is not self sufficient and depends on planet earth.

        If you do'nt 'fix' earth why fixing up mars?

        • ETH_start 1 day ago

          The point of Mars colonization is to create a self-sufficient civilization on Mars.

          Nothing in the laws of physics prevent that. So at the very least, we know that it's not impossible.

      • Jtarii 1 day ago

        Of all the things that aren't going to happen, human's colonizing mars has got to be near the top.

      • vlyan 1 day ago

        space colonization is a fantasy from the era of rapidly growing population. now that the population is shrinking at near-extinction speed, what's the point of it? the Earth is not and will never be as inhospitable to us as dystopian sci-fi depicts. even Antarctica is a better target for colonization that Mars, where the gravity is wrong, the air is poison, and the soil is poison.

        • ETH_start 1 day ago

          Population decline is due to government restrictions. Space colonization offers an escape from those restrictions.

          • vlyan 1 day ago

            huh? what restrictions? China's one child policy was abandoned more than a decade ago, now replaced with "pls have children, as many as you like!" policy.

          • origini 13 hours ago

            have you checked how much land on earth is not used today? Which is also a lot easier to handle than mars?

            If you don't use mars as a benchmark, we have still a lot of land but if you take mars as a benchmark, even desserts and greenland is inhabitabl easier than mars.

    • dylan604 2 days ago

      If you want the Vulcans to take notice, you gotta get to warp speed. Building the transporter of the parts/pieces of that kind of ship is just the first step.

      • origini 2 days ago

        I do like this take though

clivedup 2 days ago

Can anyone explain this to an idiot like to me? I follow information tech, but am pretty ignorant on engineering/space.

I recall the SpaceX chopsticks catch from about a year ago, which looked great.

This looks similar (heavy thing lands smoothly on a platform) but I gather it's very different from the comments?

  • m4rtink 2 days ago

    Previously they successfully caught the booster returning to the launch site from ~100 km about ~10 minutes from launch.

    Here they caught the upper stage ,called starhip, which went to ~260 km orbit, deployed 50 tons of satellites and after 22 hours shed its orbital velocity and manuevered to be caught with centimeter precision. :)

    • clivedup 1 day ago

      Oh nice, it's great to see each milestone along the way.

      I suppose the challenges with this step are that after starship did its job, we expect it to be worse-for-wear, and so maybe less able to stably land? (But it did it!)

      • mtmickush 1 day ago

        It's more a difference of speed. A less known fact is that rockets and orbital mechanics is more about going fast than it is going high.

        The booster has a max speed of mach 5 before it returns to the tower. The upper stage which landed had a max speed of mach 25 which has to be shed off somehow without breaking the ship!

  • generuso 1 day ago

    It is very impressive that they can control the return trajectory accurately enough for a tower catch, and to coordinate the arms on the tower (which are very slow and heavy), to grab the rocket without damaging it.

    But this was already convincingly demonstrated by catching the booster three times.

    It is very hard to return the second stage from the orbit due to its vastly greater kinetic energy. Protecting the rocket from the heating during the reentry is something that has never been done until SpaceX started to practice with the Starship.

    But they have already demonstrated this feat before, with pinpoint landings into the ocean.

    The significance of today's event is mostly in demonstrating that they have such a high confidence in this system that they were able to satisfy the safety requirements for obtaining a licence to fly the Starship return trajectory over the populated landmass, crossing Mexican territory on the way to the tower. This is the cherry on the cake. Now all the pieces are in place, and once the remaining wrinkles in the system are ironed out, we can expect the flights to become routine, and eventually, the reuse of Starship to become routine as well.

    The other, somewhat more modest, but still important milestone was that they kept the Starship in orbit for a whole day, and after that they still had the fuel for a deorbit and the landing burns. It did not all boil off.

    Edit: Here is an interview with Lars Blackmore, the guy in charge of Entry, Descent, and Landing (EDL) for Starship, where he talks about flying the descent over land for the first time: https://youtu.be/POrMxoZbXVI?t=390

aksss 1 day ago

Once the drone ship landings were incredible (they still are!), but now they’re normal.

I can’t wait for the time in the near future when catching starship and its booster is old hat.

Amazing day today!

metalman 2 days ago

perfect. hyperbole failure moment

motionlessveloc 2 days ago

It's difficult to underline how huge this is. This marks the first time in the history of rocketry that the upper stage of a rocket has returned home from orbit to a safe, upright landing.

(And to preempt the obvious objection: yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough, but it didn't do upright landings, its external tank was not reusable and even the Shuttle itself was effectively rebuilt from scratch at exorbitant cost each time.)

It's sad to see a lot of media missing the point, eg as I type this BBC is reporting this as "SpaceX successfully catches part of Starship rocket on its return to Earth".

Edit: corrected to note that the SRBs were reusable, but the ET was not.

  • wat10000 2 days ago

    Whatever you call it, the Shuttle Orbiter wasn’t a complete stage in any case. It needed the external tank, which was never recovered.

    SpaceX has now demonstrated all the pieces of a fully reusable launcher. Next comes putting them all together in the same flight, and hopefully demonstrating that the flights can become frequent and cheap. There’s no guarantee of that, but it’s looking good.

  • palata 2 days ago

    > yes, maybe you can call the Space Shuttle an "upper stage of a rocket" if you squint hard enough

    Why wouldn't it count? It is not the first time in the history of rocketry that the part that is not the boosters returns home intact.

    Sure, you can say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it lands upright", but you could also say "it's the first time in the history of rocketry that it is not white".

    If you want to say how huge this is, tell me how different it is from landing the boosters. Because from the outside it sure as hell looks very similar.

    • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

      The Space Shuttle has four parts, namely the Orbiter, the External Tank, and the two SRBs. Only the Orbiter is reusable and actually lands, the rest are jettisoned in flight. (SRBs are recovered, the ET is not.) However, the Orbiter is completely incapable of flight without the other three, so it's not a rocket stage on its own, just part of one.

      As for why it's harder to catch Starship than Super Heavy, where do I begin:

      * Super Heavy is suborbital, its maximum velocity is far, far less than Starship.

      * Super Heavy returns upright. The Starship does the famous but aerodynamically very complex "belly flop" to reduce speed.

      * Super Heavy only has two static fins to guide it. Starship has four actively controlled fins that need to survive the extreme forces of launch and re-entry.

      • dabluecaboose 2 days ago

        > The Space Shuttle has four parts, namely the Orbiter, the External Tank, and the two SRBs. Only the Orbiter is reusable and actually lands, the rest are jettisoned in flight and burn up in the atmosphere.

        Nitpick- the SRBs were also recovered and reused

      • palata 2 days ago

        Thanks, the insights about Super Heavy vs Starship are interesting.

        About how "huge" it is, I understand that it is economically huge: Musk will get even richer.

        I would be interested in knowing how "huge" it is in terms of engineering. Like, my understanding is that they needed to invent new maths to go to the moon in the 60s. Does SpaceX compare with that, or is it "just" what you can do with a lot of money and powerful computers?

        Genuinely interested, even though rocket fans will hate me for not knowing the answer and daring asking. Bring the downvotes!

  • mmustapic 2 days ago

    > none of its boosters were reusable

    Notably, they were reusable! Sure, they had to refurbish them, same with the shuttle’s main engines. The only thing they threw away was the external tank which didn’t have any engines.

    • sfblah 2 days ago

      Yeah this guy is smoking something. I actually think the shuttle landings were more impressive than this one. Not taking anything away from what they're doing here, but they're still only up to the mid-1970s technology-wise.

  • echoangle 2 days ago

    > none of its boosters were reusable

    The SRBs of the shuttle landed by parachute and were recovered from the water and reused

  • origini 2 days ago

    You know what was huge? James Webb telescope.

    Look its cool to see a catch like this, it doesn't necessarly feels that difficult tbh?

    And I just don't get it? Is it cool to watch? yes, but whats the endgoal besides reducing costs for starlink and military stuff?

    • redox99 2 days ago

      > it doesn't necessarly feels that difficult tbh?

      Are you for real?

      • origini 2 days ago

        ?! We know how to send rockets up, we know how to send them back to earth. We know how to stabilize a rocket. I mean we fly them for ages?!

        'that difficult'

        Look at projects like James Webb telescope.

        • redox99 2 days ago

          You don't understand the precision required to catch a 70m tall behemoth when you have Earths atmosphere. It's not even close to bringing a capsule to an approximate area, a small ship somewhere with almost no atmosphere, or even landing a rocket on a pad (which we've only had since Falcon 9)

          • origini 2 days ago

            But others are also working on it and showed they can do it too?

            • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

              Today was literally the first time humanity flew a rocket to orbit and landed it vertically.

            • jve 11 hours ago

              JWT doesn't need to go through atmosphere screaming at 26000+ km/sec like Starship does.

              Booster landing which F9 has mastered and others are following up is like ~8000 km/sec.

              I don't understand all the complexities either, but I realize that fuel sloshing, engine re-ignition, thermal protection and fuel boil-off are quite serious challenges. In a way that will not need excessive refurbishment. Not even considering the ship guidance, mechanics of tower and whatnot.

              • origini 6 hours ago

                My main argument is not that they didn't had to be smart about solving problems.

                But when you read comments here how the world now changed and how unique it is, we do have already other startups working on the same thing.

                We still knew already how to do reentry. Space Shuttle was able to do so.

                We had a rocket with more than 100t payload called Saturn 5.

                We know how to control a rocket engine to manvure a rocket.

                This feels more like rediscovering, finetuning, rebuilding rocket tech.

                Very few were able to build James Webb Telescope though and it had to solve unique engineering challanges.

          • emkoemko 1 day ago

            brother... we launched and autonomously put a car on mars using a sky crane, now that is damn amazing

        • derektank 2 days ago

          “The James Webb telescope is just a three mirror korsch telescope in space. We’ve known how to build those since the 30s and we’ve been putting telescopes in space since the 60s. Doesn’t seem that impressive”

          This is what you sound like to everyone else here

          • origini 2 days ago

            And i can easily explain to you why this is not the case.

            They put the most advanced telescope at L2 which is the most remote location 1.5 million km away which can't be serviced and can't be rebuild easily.

            It has nanometer optical precision in space which needs to be cooled through multiply layers of high tec foil.

            Its mirrors are precicse to nm level.

            Took 25 years of planning and 5 years of building.

            • emkoemko 1 day ago

              people don't understand how amazing the heat shield is

            • jve 11 hours ago

              Yea, this guy totally doesn't see himself in the mirror and thus missing the point being made by @derektank :)

          • emkoemko 1 day ago

            no not even close.... please look up how insane the James web telescope technology is

    • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

      Do you want more cool stuff like James Webb in orbit? Fully reusable huge rockets like Starship is how you get them there.

      Also, remember how JWST had to do that incredibly complex and fiddly in-orbit expansion and alignment to fit together the mirror after launch? If Starship had been available at the time, this would have been far easier, since Starship has twice the diameter (four times the area) of the Ariane rocket they used to launch it.

      • origini 2 days ago

        Besides that I really really wished it wouldn't be Elon Musk, i'm looking forward to cheaper stuff so its easier to send science stuff up. Don't get me wrong at all.

        But it feels like hyperbole.

        Pure technically speaking, if you can fly a rocket up and control it properly, whats the crazy thing flying a rocket back down and controlling it?

        Or do you see it more like a milestone seeing?

        And for me, it still feels like if Elon Musk tries his Dataenter 'idea' and really sneds up everyday a Starship, we will lose a lot of control as normal humans whats going on in space and what will happen to our atmosphere.

        • ssl-3 2 days ago

          > Pure technically speaking, if you can fly a rocket up and control it properly, whats the crazy thing flying a rocket back down and controlling it?

          It only took the entire existence of humanity to reach this point.

          I'm not willing to hand-wave that away as some kind of technologically-obvious conclusion.

          • origini 2 days ago

            "It only took the entire existence of humanity to reach this point." as everything else.

            EUV required genuine new engineering for an example.

            • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

              To pick just one achievement among many, the Raptor engines on the Starship are literally revolutionary. First ever full-flow staged combustion engine, designed for both extreme reliability and cheap mass production, even the fuel they use (methalox) had never been tried at this scale.

              • origini 2 days ago

                I agree with the engineering of Raptor engines, fair and square but does that have anything to do with catching ar ocket?

                • motionlessveloc 1 day ago

                  Did you watch the landing video? That great big plume of fire nudging the Starship into the chopsticks with millimeter precision comes from Raptor engines!

                  • origini 13 hours ago

                    Rockets before Raptor engines were controlled already. They had to to stire the rockets.

                    The basic steering existed before and it had to be precise enough to get it into space.

                    Or do you mean something im missing here?

                    • hparadiz 8 hours ago

                      Yea the part where the entire world will remember Elon Musk for this achievement and you are some worthless nobody that won't be remembered for anything too dumb to even know what you're talking about.

                      • origini 6 hours ago

                        You might be very ignorant and an Elon Musk fanboy (for whatever reason), but the hitler gesture of Elon Musk went through germans press and it made a lot of people really not liking him.

                        A lot of people don't care about Elon Musk, but a lot also really don't like him for all his bullshit.

                        You don't seem to be very balanced though, you just might stop responding to me? Might make you less emotional.

        • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

          > Pure technically speaking, if you can fly a rocket up and control it properly, whats the crazy thing flying a rocket back down and controlling it?

          You are absolutely right. Same thing about just putting a battery and some motors to make a car like RC car! Same about 48v/replacing canbus. Same thing about putting some satellites on orbit for internet! Same for mobile service! Same about if humans can use eyes to drive, computers should be able to using cameras! All _simple_ things, obvious in retrospect.

          Yet one man is marching forward, poking his nose in industries he does not belong, and still almost always coming on top.

          Makes you wonder why existing incumbents can't do these "simple" things.

          • origini 2 days ago

            One man who got money, has money and a cult following.

            Of course he is flexible enough mentally and ignorant enough to disrupt markets, sure and for this he got rich.

            But why does every Musk follower ignore all the bad things he leaves in his march forward?

            All the humans around the Space-X 'city'?

            Kids and Humans affected by USAID and DOGE?

            His lying around everything he promised to people?

            • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

              This thread is about an achievement made by the thousands of people working at one of his companies. Elon is only a small part of the equation.

              Also, I don't understand what you're even trying to say by "ignorant enough to disrupt markets". There are plenty of rich people flinging money around, few have achieved anything near what Musk did. Look at Blue Origin, which is still playing catch-up despite SpaceX already proving everything and Bezos throwing basically infinite money at it.

              • origini 2 days ago

                Its a comment and comments reflect discussions.

                Every success of his companies, give Elon Musk power and deminishes everyone who is or was affected negativly by Elon Musk.

                What would you expect if HN had an article about Fat Boy launched successfully on Japan?

                Pure positive comments?

        • 7952 2 days ago

          I think the main challenge is really the heat shielding. That is the part that is so different from the takeoff. And it actually remains to be seen if that is good enough for repeated rapid reuse.

      • Rebelgecko 2 days ago

        Can Starship get to L2?

        • ZiiS 2 days ago

          Yes without a shadow of doubt it could deploy two JWST on a single launch. Add in the refuling they successfully demonstrated and the sky is no longer the limit.

  • fedpost 2 days ago

    Don't forget the X37

    • ericcumbee 1 day ago

      I think the argument is its a payload not an upper stage.

      • fedpost 52 minutes ago

        What's the difference?

  • bamboozled 1 day ago

    Everyone saw the space shuttle be reusable, no one cares in the public when the cost of living is so high.

    I get it’s exciting but it means almost nothing for 99% of people.

ETH_start 1 day ago

The amount of stress that these vehicles go through as they ascend to orbit and then descend back through the atmosphere to the surface is mind-boggling. To create a rapidly usable vehicle that can do this pushes the limits of material science.

iJohnDoe 1 day ago

Amazing. Doesn't even look real.

laichzeit0 1 day ago

Congratulations Elon Musk and to those who work at his company. He is a true visionary.

soiax 1 day ago

"pls make a reusable rocket, make no mistakes!!" This is probably some AI slop rocket XD

formvoltron 1 day ago

Radiators are too big and too expensive for space datacenters to make sense. Also rather than depreciating a GPU, you'll be depreciating a GPU, massive solar array, massive radiator, electronics and housing, and the launch cost to get it all there.

AI likely becomes much more efficient on earth than making sense in space for the foreseeable future.

bmartin13 2 days ago

I hope they can make significant progress before the socialists take over. They were practically begging for launch permits under Biden.

WalterBright 1 day ago

Congratulations to SpaceX and Elon Musk! Another huge step to the stars!

  • sgt 1 day ago

    I see you're being downvoted. HN is increasingly becoming anti-Elon for no particular reason. Cult behavior.

    • WalterBright 1 day ago

      Musk is objectively the greatest entrepreneur in business history. Naturally, people will hate him for it.

      • ben_w 1 day ago

        Richest entrepreneur, on paper. Although yes, some people's hate is just due to the money and not the things he's done as a person.

        NVIDIA's market cap is higher than all Musk's put together, even if NVIDIA is just one company.

        I'd put Richard Branson higher up on general success, given all the sus that Musk's paper valuation comes with. Much smaller paper worth, but the MC is much more justifiable.

        • sgt 19 hours ago

          Who'd you want to have dinner with though.. to discuss say, programming, quantum computing, P vs NP problem, or DNA data storage?

          • ben_w 10 hours ago

            Do I have to pick a billionaire for these?

            Demis Hassabis if it was one person for all that.

            Programming specifically, IDK, Bill Gates or Larry Page or Sergey Brin, but I suspect most billionaires are a long way from interesting code, and I'd be more interested in chatting with random nerds whose net worth is under a million than those whose is over a billion.

            Quantum Computing, everything I've seen (including simulations on brilliant.org, is that any good these days?) says we're around the level that computing was when we could afford perhaps 6 thermionic valves in one circuit. It's an interesting hobby problem, but I don't really care.

            P v NP, I don't know how much Grant Sanderson is worth, but for all that it's equally para-social regardless of if I'm naming rich celebrities or YouTube maths nerds, I'd rather nerd out with him than anyone in the Forbes rich list. But then, for maths problems I'd be more likely to want to discuss the Collatz conjecture (if they were willing to discuss something so cliché) to better understand how far people have gotten with it instead of all the endless videos explaining it like the audience are high-schoolers who've never encountered rigorous proofs before.

            DNA storage looked cool back in the 90s, but these days my headphones have more storage built into them than my whole genome could hold, and I didn't even get them for the built-in storage.

ahmedketata 2 days ago

The most amazing thing i've seen in a while.

quertyrecord74 1 day ago

I am trying to understand what's the big deal about this, other that massive weight and the money involved. The way I see it is software controls the fuel output and motion control. The only other challenge I have been hearing about is the heat shield. Other that this what's really special about the spaceship. The number of modules and the complexity seems not that huge. Any error or miscalculation in here is very costly and that is the only thing seems to be the bottleneck here.

  • KellyCriterion 1 day ago

    If its that trivial, why did nobody came up with this on their own so far?

    • CarlitosHighway 1 day ago

      The real question is if others maybe thought it's not worthwhile because the R&D cost isn't justified. Like "a solution without a problem".

    • quertyrecord74 1 day ago

      I think its money, regulations and viable business plan, because govt is the only market and its risky.

      From the engineering perspective what's the real challenge here? Because senors are so capable and control software are mature already.

    • randypewick 1 day ago

      I know for sure that EU public development of similar technology is gated between approvals and bureaucracy, in addition to environmental limitations that SpaceX can ignore.

HAL3000 2 days ago

Nice! I wonder how the engineering involved here compares to the engineering behind manufacturing TSMC chips (including ASML machines, Zeiss optics etc.). Which is harder?

As it seems building rockets has historically been a capital intensive business with low profits and limited demand, so there just wasn't much competition in the space industry.

  • MPSimmons 2 days ago

    I would say that they're orthogonal except for the requirement for exacting results and standards. Doing anything once is hard. Doing anything repeatably is hard^2.

  • Catloafdev 2 days ago

    Many countries are capable of space flight & deploying satellites.

    Only a few companies in the world can manage the top-tier fab processes for modern chips.

    Only one company in the world has successfully caught a rocket. *Edit: 2!

    It's hard to directly compare, safe to say they are 2 of the pinnacle examples of modern human engineering.

plussed_reader 1 day ago

The traitorous handling by SpaceX of the starlink product with our allies makes me greatly anticipate nationalizing this corrupt business entity.

rvz 2 days ago

This is exactly the most impressive feat of engineering I have ever seen.

Only catching both the booster and the rocket would top this one. But the rocket only being caught is still impressive regardless.

SpaceX below $1T is criminally undervalued.

  • quotemstr 2 days ago

    Well, both booster and ship catches have been demonstrated now.

    • rvz 2 days ago

      Did they catch both of them in this mission?

      It was meant to be a dual catch of the booster and the rocketship and only the rocketship itself was caught.

      Catching both of them in another mission would top this one.

      • snvzz 2 days ago

        ... especially if they reuse either part.

  • origini 2 days ago

    Why is Space-X undervalued because they can catch a rocketship?

    You do understand that a company needs to have a business case equivilient to its valuation right?

    Going to Moon only costs money, going to Mars only costs money.

    Our whole planet sends 1000-2000t of payload into space, most of it is now starlink.

    • rvz 2 days ago

      > Why is Space-X undervalued because they can catch a rocketship?

      The market values SpaceX over multiple areas of the business and their future plans and it isn't just this event which they have proven to accomplish.

      > You do understand that a company needs to have a business case equivilient to its valuation right?

      Nope. That is not how this works nor how investors see it. It is about their total addressable market (TAM) which SpaceX can capture over everyone else. So here are some more further questions:

      1) Who is paying SpaceX for the compute that they have?

      2) How quick is SpaceX building their data centers to support their customers?

      3) How many people use Starlink as their primary internet provider?

      You understand that almost all of where SpaceX businesses can expand into those areas and grow into that valuation and higher?

      > Our whole planet sends 1000-2000t of payload into space, most of it is now starlink.

      Your point is?

      So who else can catch and reuse a rocketship to frequently deploy satellites into space in a very short period of time? (Don't say Blue Origin.)

      • origini 2 days ago

        1) Anthropic because Elon Musk bought too much Compute and doesn't need it for his own AI proudct. In parallel Neoclouds are building up the same compute and its more like a negative sign that they got lucky

        2) ? I don't understand what you mean. Are we now talking about Datacenters for others or the space thing?

        3) probably below 8 million. 10 Million customer overall, plenty as an alternative or for camping etc.

        Amazon Leo is an alternative. But for sure Space-X started a race to the bottom (china, blue origin and co) so they have to start moving and use their first mover advantage.

        My point is, that Space-X is already responsible for the most amount of payload which gets send into space. We as a whole planet don't have that much payload and Space-X made it alot cheaper to send payload up.

        So were is the 1 Trillion evaluation? Btw. its currently at 1.89T

        • rvz 2 days ago

          > 1) Anthropic because Elon Musk bought too much Compute and doesn't need it for his own AI proudct.

          The Grok models and products also use the compute in SpaceX's data centers. It only makes sense to provide that excess compute to others such as Anthropic that don't own any, and that is worth tens of billions a quarter.

          > In parallel Neoclouds are building up the same compute and its more like a negative sign that they got lucky

          It is not the same. You can ask any chatbot, how many GPUs do the neoclouds have over SpaceX in their data centers?

          Then:

          > 2) ? I don't understand what you mean. Are we now talking about Datacenters for others or the space thing?

          Both. The point being that they (SpaceX) are already quickly building new ones on land codenamed "Gun Range" and "Spam" and are the only ones that can launch and connect all of them via Starlink (if they eventually launch new ones into space) and serve both themselves and new customers.

          > Amazon Leo is an alternative. But for sure Space-X started a race to the bottom (china, blue origin and co) so they have to start moving and use their first mover advantage.

          Amazon Leo is not even generally available. So that doesn't even count.

          > My point is, that Space-X is already responsible for the most amount of payload which gets send into space. We as a whole planet don't have that much payload and Space-X made it alot cheaper to send payload up.

          So what happens when the neoclouds are not able to build data centers on land anymore due to legislation that prohibits more of them getting built [0] and ultimately they get paused? Most of the neoclouds are already sold out and cannot build more of them and have deadlines on these loans with interest on them.

          Maybe the compute has to be deployed somewhere else in the long term....

          > So were is the 1 Trillion evaluation? Btw. its currently at 1.89T

          Exactly. It if goes lower than 1T it is cheap. This is not even pricing in the building of their own semiconductor fabricator (Terafab).

          [0] https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2026/nov/04/datacenters-...

          • origini 2 days ago

            If you start building Datacenters up in space, you need to send A LOT of Starships up there for MONTH to get ONE normal avg size GPU based DC in Space.

            This DC can then poisen our atmopshwere btw. and burns up limited resources on our own planet.

            They don't need the compute because their product Grok is not competitive. They don't use the compute to make Grok better because?!

            Amazon Leo will be though. Space-X has a first mover advantage, what did Tesla do with it?

            • rvz 2 days ago

              > If you start building Datacenters up in space, you need to send A LOT of Starships up there for MONTH to get ONE normal avg size GPU based DC in Space.

              This isn't a massive problem for SpaceX as you want to believe it to be.

              > This DC can then poisen our atmopshwere btw. and burns up limited resources on our own planet

              So are you going to tell them to pause everything? (You won't) What solution do you have to them to solve this? (You don't have any solution.)

              > They don't need the compute because their product Grok is not competitive.

              That is false. Otherwise they would have given up on scaling Grok already.

              > They don't use the compute to make Grok better because?!

              So Cursor does not have any customers that use Grok on a regular basis beyond Twitter / X? Nor does Grok Bot need the compute either? (They most certainly do.)

              Efficiency gains in their inference engines allow them to use less GPUs for themselves, and also sell that excess compute to others who are otherwise sold out. Both scenarios can be true and it doesn't mean they "don't need it" either.

              > Amazon Leo will be though. Space-X has a first mover advantage

              With what launch pad? SpaceX has plenty of their own and are building even more.

              > What did Tesla do with it?

              They built self-driving cars with "FSD" and autopilot with that advantage, and your point is?

              • origini 13 hours ago

                It would be 45 Starship launches (perfect ones, without issues) for sending up the GPU racks alone without solar panels and adjustend infrastructure, without heatshield etc. for a half GWh GPU based Datacenter

                1

                I would love to tell them to stop and analyse the atmosphere problem first and propose a proper solution. I do not benefit from what spacex is doing AT ALL and 99% of the planet earth neither. There is no inherant need to do this today or yesterday.

                Oh grok has customers but that wasn't my argument. If Grok is so good, Grok should deliver better margins than renting out their GPU clusters. While Frontierlabs struggle to get GPU compute, SpaceX Super Intelligence does not. Why is this a good sign mh?

                Amazon Leo will use SpaceX + Blue Origin + all the other space startups.

                Tesla is valued like crazy on the stock market but is loosing out now. Thats the point i'm making.

        • sfblah 1 day ago

          God bless you for arguing with the Musk/SpaceX Stans on here, but there's honestly no point.

          • tristanj 1 day ago

            he's mostly just demonstrating how little SpaceX critics actually understand about the company and the industry in general. First off, he doesn't even know how to spell the company's name...

            • sfblah 1 day ago

              I hope that, when this stupid market bubble pops, the bankrupt masses who financed this garbage go easy on people like you. In the past, they have not.

            • origini 13 hours ago

              Yes yes the name. I got it wrong it should be called SpaceX Super Intelligence LLC.

              Sry

              • tristanj 4 hours ago

                And you still can't get the name right.

                It's Space Exploration Technologies Corp, or SpaceX.

      • mupuff1234 2 days ago

        Don't you think the US government is very likely to put restrictions on what other countries can use SpaceX services for?

  • Ankaios 2 days ago

    SpaceX below $1T is criminally undervalued.

    Launch itself isn't super profitable and doesn't have a very big TAM, especially if you carefully treat the TAM as a present value and discount future cash flows. Also, at least by my personal guesswork, Starlink alone shouldn't get close to a $1 trillion valuation. It seems like the current valuation is based on people's guesses about the likelihood that space data centers pan out in a big way.

    • s08148692 2 days ago

      > It seems like the current valuation is based on people's guesses about the likelihood that space data centers pan out in a big way

      The Starship program is one of - if not the - biggest risks here. Making starship work could bring the launch cost down far enough to derisk that whole program, and today just made it a lot less risky

    • HarHarVeryFunny 1 day ago

      Starlink is going to be using a lot of launches for satellite replacement. Target constellation size is 40K satellites, which with a 5 year satellite lifetime means they need to replace 8000/year (160 launches of 50 satellites each => 3 launches per week).

      • cj9 1 day ago

        Who cares. This whole thing was a military project.

        • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

          It didn’t become military until Ukraine demonstrated the advantages of a LEO constellation in war.

          • HarHarVeryFunny 10 hours ago

            I think he's talking about military use of Starship, not of Starlink.

            Apparently the military is interested is using Starship/rockets as a quick (and expensive) way of delivering supplies to "anywhere" on earth. The idea is to carry a reentry payload "Starfall" that can land "anywhere" on earth, although in it's currently tested implementation that means a parachute landing in water, which would then need to be retrieved, so not very useful. There was a Starfall test using Falcon 9 last year.

          • cj9 7 hours ago

            The entire SpaceX project has military roots. Musk knew Michael D. Griffin, someone with military and intelligence ties, well enough to have him accompany his trip to Russia in the early days.

            "In early 2002 he met entrepreneur Elon Musk and accompanied him on a trip to Russia, where they attempted to purchase ICBMs. The decision to found the company SpaceX was made on the flight home, and Griffin briefly considered serving as chief engineer, but eventually he instead became president and COO of In-Q-Tel, a private enterprise funded by the CIA to identify and invest in companies developing cutting-edge technologies that serve national security interests. [1]"

            "In 2005, he was appointed NASA administrator, where he pushed for commercial cargo and crew transportation services. [1]" "In December 2008, NASA awarded SpaceX and Orbital Sciences additional contracts with a combined value of $3.5 billion as part of the Commercial Resupply Services program. Elon Musk credited these follow-on contracts for saving his company as it neared bankruptcy. [1]"

            "In February 2018, Griffin was appointed as Under Secretary of Defense for Research and Engineering by Donald Trump. One of his first actions was to create the Space Development Agency. The organization was tasked with procuring a proliferated constellation of low Earth orbit satellites called the Proliferated Warfighter Space Architecture, which later become the backbone for the planned Golden Dome (missile defense system). Commercial contracts for the constellation were given to L3Harris and SpaceX to build Starlink military satellites. [1]"

            Starlink seems to be one of the things that can be sold to consumers on the side and it has multiple fantastic advantages for them: we pay for it, we support it, we "invest" in it, we get caught up in fantasies about the future technological development that will never happen or have funding directed to other purposes, it's an internal political tool, a way of extracting data from systems without using the public internet, and in the meantime collects vast amounts of data.

            I don't have an opinion formed on the project at this stage, but the facts of the roots of it explains why a lot of decisions don't seem to make engineering or financial sense.

            [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_D._Griffin

    • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

      I believe before the merger, SpaceX alone was estimated to be most of the way to $1T just on Starlink’s potential.

  • dylan604 2 days ago

    We've seen the booster landing/catch before, but seeing the ship do it with the belly flop definitely looked cooler to me. I still remember the awe of watching two boosters land at the same time after a heavy launch. Watching the transition from bellyflop to landing gave me the same awe and being impressed.

LunaSea 1 day ago

Impressive feat of engineering but I have troubles getting excited about this and don't see the point in this endeavour.

madduci 1 day ago

Has anybody access to.measures like how much CO2 (and other material) emissions costs this kind of Rocket Catch?

fnoef 1 day ago

just finished watching the new documentary about musk. not that ive learned anything new. its so sad that engineering achievements like these are being shadowed, at least for some people like myself, with the figure that runs these companies.

nevertheless, the people who made it work should be proud of themselves.

hsnewman 1 day ago

They only have a 60% catch rate on the booster. The elimination of the landing feet has reduced it's reusability.

  • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

    And at a similar testing point F9 had a 0% catch rate. What’s your point?

Culonavirus 2 days ago

Honestly if this thread had the actual number of points it deserved based on the kind of milestone this represents for humanity's future and access to space, it would be in the millions.

If you don't follow rocketry you can't possibly understand what this means.

This was the Trinity test.

And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").

Within a decade the average cost to LEO will drop 20x-50x and if you're not recovering both of your stages, you don't exist.

  • SecretDreams 1 day ago

    > And even if you hate Elon and all his businesses, this knowledge will proliferate. Either by talent movement / osmosis, by espionage or just being inspired ("if they can do it, maybe we have a chance as well").

    It doesn't need to proliferate. It has existed in us for a very long time, albeit working the kinks out would take time.

    The major factor on the trajectory space goes is a financial question, not a technological one. And it always has been this way.

    Elon is a terrible person that's done a lot of bad for humanity (but also some good). But he's damn good at convincing people to fund his shit and so we get cool rockets until he goes out of favour.. probably that happens when we hit critical mass on the space pollution he puts up into our sky.

    • sgt 1 day ago

      Since your first and dominent comment is that he's done a lot of bad for humanity. What would that be, exactly? Except for the meddling with US funding, but I consider that a minor thing.

    • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

      SpaceX is funding Starship from its own money, which it earns from F9 launches and mainly from Starlink.

      • SecretDreams 1 day ago

        SpaceX 2025 revenue was about 18.5 bil and they raised about 85bil from their IPO.

        In general, the vast majority of what sustains them comes from bond offerings, stock offerings, and loans, rather than the actual revenue they have generated.

  • Jtarii 1 day ago

    I'm looking forward to the bright future where coca-cola adverts can shine out across the night sky, beautifully lit, majestic.

cwkoss 2 days ago

Reusable stages is very neat, but seems a little crazy to pay the tyranny of the rocket equation twice. I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.

Using modern technology, couldn't disposable first stages be produced much more cheaply than during the space race?

How much of modern manufacturing disposable booster's cost would be fuel vs metal?

  • rpmisms 2 days ago

    Fuel is so much cheaper than ships.

    • motionlessveloc 2 days ago

      But you need more ship to carry that fuel, which is exactly what the tyranny of the rocket equation refers to.

      • rpmisms 2 days ago

        Correct. Economics still work out pretty solidly in favor of reuse.

      • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

        And that’s where reuse comes in.

  • Ankaios 2 days ago

    I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit.

    I recommend talking with people who know more about spaceflight.

    • 2OEH8eoCRo0 2 days ago

      Starship HLS is estimated to require 22 refueling launches to support 1 moon mission.

      • wat10000 2 days ago

        How is that even relevant? The Starship HLS launch won’t be landing the upper stage.

      • echoangle 2 days ago

        Without knowing how much it would take in expendable configuration, that doesn’t imply that it takes 23 times as many launches

      • Ankaios 2 days ago

        OP, this is probably the source of the confusion. Some people are claiming that SpaceX will need 20+ refueling launches for human lunar landings. However, that's a very different claim than reusable rockets requiring 23x more launches just to carry the same amount of payload to Earth orbit.

      • mpweiher 1 day ago

        That's largely because they are sending a 100 ton starship to the moon.

        Not the 4 ton lunar lander of the Apollo era.

    • palata 2 days ago

      > I recommend talking with people who know more about spaceflight.

      Yes, because asking on HN if such people would be willing to answer obviously gets you downvotes and comments like this.

  • blackenedgem 2 days ago

    It's not paying it twice. The rocket equation is about the ratio of the wet and dry mass, so for an expendable rocket you're always limited by the fact that there's an upper stage (and for the second stage the payload etc).

    This is why SpaceX cares more about TWR for their engines than traditional rockets did. It goes from making a negligible difference to a huge component of how much fuel they need to keep for landing.

  • GenerocUsername 2 days ago

    Those numbers don't make sense.

    It doesn't take the same amount of fuel to land as it does to lift.

    Speaking as a Kerbal Space program playing, internet commentor, It's probably <1% of the fuel to briefly counteract terminal velocity as it is to lift off and reach space.

  • jiggawatts 2 days ago

    They use the atmosphere to brake, not fuel.

  • inglor_cz 2 days ago

    "I heard one person say that carrying fuel to land over the whole flight means it takes 23x more launches to get an equivalent payload to orbit."

    I don't think that this is the case when using the atmosphere to shed most of your velocity, which is what we do when landing on Earth. Propulsive braking would be another story, but you can avoid that on bodies that do have some atmosphere. In our proximity, only the Moon and Mercury would need propulsive braking, but Moon's gravity is low and Mercury is hard to visit anyway.

    That said, once you use the atmosphere to cushion what is basically a fall, the weight of the necessary heat shield comes to the equation too.

  • ivewonyoung 2 days ago

    How is it twice? Braking on the way down doesn't take nearly as much fuel as lift off so the "tyranny of the rocket equation" should be paid only once.

  • grey-area 2 days ago

    This seems a little confused.

    The 23x more launches figure comes from HLS (Nasa sponsored mission to the moon). They may well change the configuration of that anyway, but if you want to refuel in orbit, that's what it costs. It's hard to get fuel to orbit (or any sort of payload). Previous Moon missions haven't refueled anything, but they couldn't return anything heavy from the moon's surface, the vehicle got smaller and smaller as it went and many parts were left behind, so it's not comparable. You can be sure if it's cheaper to somehow do this mission with expendable boosters, they'll think about doing that.

    On a normal mission just to earth orbit, there is one booster and one starship, and reusing the booster is more a question of why not save some money for a little more propellant use? The reususable booster doesn't contribute much extra weight, it uses little propellant for boostback and landing.

    The booster also doesn't go all the way and you need a booster if you're going to reach orbit (due to that equation), so it doesn't take much to make it reusable. So all in all, why not make it reusable if you can? What would you save from using expendable ones?

  • chpatrick 2 days ago

    This claim doesn't make sense to me, you need most of the fuel to escape gravity. Coming back is almost free.

    • luke5441 2 days ago

      It costs less, but it is not free. The stages need to be designed to come back and that adds weight. Additionally you need some fuel, it is not all air breaking. And every bit of weight is really bad, because of the rocket equation.

      Without internal figures no one can say what is ultimately financially better. Especially now that the development is a sunken cost.

      • small_model 2 days ago

        Yes, they should just parachute people out of planes, why reuse them thousands of times, carrying that extra fuel to land, they could go another few hundred miles.

        The point is the ship and rockets are expensive vs fuel. Fly a Starship 100 times the cost is amortised over the flights and fuel+bit of refurb maintenance is tiny.

  • consensus1 2 days ago

    That 23x number is trivially refuted simply by looking at the fact that this flight delivered 52 tons of cargo to orbit. Could a similarly sized expendable rocket like the Saturn V deliver 1196 tons?

  • Rover222 2 days ago

    That's like saying we shouldn't reuse airplanes after one flight because you'd have to fly it 23 times to have it pay for that reuse.

    That's still 1000x cheaper than... building a new airplane every flight.

    And anyway those numbers area about moon missions, not low earth orbit.

  • peterfirefly 2 days ago

    If the fuel (+ oxidizer) ends up costing as much as 1% of the cost of launching a conventional single-use rocket then the people behind it will be very happy. That means that their rocket (+ cost of ground facilities + all the people prepping the rocket and monitoring the launch) is very cheap.

    The fuel (+ oxidizer) is basically free compared to all the other costs.

MiroslavPokorny 1 day ago

Starship is finished - jsut ask Elon, thats why he sold it.

bluecalm 2 days ago

SpaceX made me watch engineering feats live on stream. I love it!

baw-bag 2 days ago

Do we just look past the failed primary booster objective? (I didn't write the brief)

Edit: Yes, ignore that bit.

  • consensus1 2 days ago

    Booster catch has been done as has booster re-flight. The only remaining part of the full functionality that has not been proven out is ship reuse.

    • baw-bag 2 days ago

      I see.

      "The booster’s primary objective on Flight 15 will be executing a successful launch, ascent, stage separation, boostback burn, and return to the launch site for catch. This will be the first return and catch attempt for a Super Heavy V3 booster." [1]

      [1] https://www.spacex.com/launches/starship-flight-15

  • roodypoo2 2 days ago

    Please go back to reddit

  • thinkcontext 2 days ago

    We don't have to look past it. Musk said it failed because engine underperformance caused too little fuel margin. He added that they have upgrades due on future flights.

    If they ran out of fuel with 50 tons of payload it certainly begs the question of whether they will get to the goal of 100 tons of payload even with upgrades.

    They also had engine fail on boostback. Reliability has been a persistent problem, they'll have to fix it for refueling and manned operations.

    • NetMageSCW 1 day ago

      The low payload is because the launch from Texas requires an expensive dogleg. Launch from Florida won’t.

ck2 2 days ago

bet they used lidar

(let's see who gets the joke)

seriously though, do we know the names of the engineers who made this possible or is it a secret?

  • MPSimmons 2 days ago

    You could go to LinkedIn and look at people in the:

    * structures

    * propulsion

    * avionics

    * flight software

    departments, because they all work together to make this happen, along with support from IT/SRE. The person most responsible for ensuring that it happens is Lars Blackmore[1], who was also the Responsible Engineer in charge of making sure Falcon 9 landed successfully

    [1] - https://linkedin.com/in/lars-blackmore-78a237

fghorow 2 days ago

Congrats to the engineers.

(But lose the bastard at the top, OK?)

  • fedpost 2 days ago

    He's actively holding the program back at this point. Top engineers in this industry are increasingly reluctant to join a company with a such a toxic culture and public reputation tainted by musk.

    • CrimsonRain 2 days ago

      If a carsales man can do it, you can too. Go on. Open up your own SpaceY and do better. I'm sure all the top engineers will flock to yours.

    • s08148692 2 days ago

      The top engineers are already there. The top engineers care more about engineering than politics.

      Source: Everyone else in SpaceXs rearview mirror - If the top engineers were elsewhere they would be ahead

      • fedpost 1 day ago

        I'm an actual aerospace SWE

        Pre-trump 1 SpaceX was a tough place with a slightly off vibe but otherwise strong industry reputation.

        Post-trump 1 SpaceX became a place you put in a couple years so that you could get a more stable job wherever you wanted

        Post DOGE SpaceX is a place you really have to hold your nose to work at and coming out of that company increasingly labels you as a possible culture problem. I've seen a lot of SpaceX people getting turned down during interviews because they're either toxic or present a risk of toxicity.

        • notenchange 1 day ago

          And yet, the ones there just achieved an engineering miracle. So that probably shows that ones turned down were probably turned down because they didn't add anything positive to the company.

    • pmdr 1 day ago

      > Top engineers in this industry

      The same top engineers not achieving the same or even similar things? It's okay to dislike the culture, in fact they should be mad as hell at it. But if you can't/won't join'em, beat'em.

hgoel 1 day ago

Congrats to the everyone involved (more than just engineers!).

Here's hoping Musk gets kicked before he sinks this project too, as he's already severely burdened it with his short-sighted fascistic endeavors. As a formerly very enthusiastic follower of SpaceX's activities the specter of Musk's evil beliefs really ruins the messaging of making progress for all of humanity.

nstents 1 day ago

Elon Musk is a real life version of D.D. Harriman, the protagonist of Heinlein's The Man Who Sold the Moon. An excerpt taken from Wikipedia:

""I", he says, "would cheat, lie, steal, beg, bribe—do anything to accomplish what we have accomplished". Children donate money for a promise of all contributors' names engraved on a plaque left on the Moon. The names, however, will be microscopic in size. Harriman sells land and naming rights to craters, and plans to sell postal covers canceled on the Moon to collectors. He starts rumors that diamonds exist in moondust, intending to secretly place gems in the rocket to convince people that the rumors are true."

And anyone who's read Machiavelli knows what kind of man it takes to succeed at this level in non-fiction.

Given the fact that men of his abilities and motivations have existed throughout history, and will continue to exist as long as we have men, for all his perceived flaws I'm quite pragmatically relieved he is ensconced with a Western power rather than any other in the world.