jwr 3 hours ago

Most of my spam is through Google, Amazon and Microsoft. They don't care: they are "too big to fail" at this point. Nobody will block Google, right?

We've allowed them to grow this way by preferring convenience.

  • hbcdbff 3 hours ago

    > Most of my spam is through Google, Amazon and Microsoft

    Survivorship bias

    • superkuh 3 hours ago

      I think we can assume that most people responding here are running their own mailserver that receives. I am. And I run a catch-all for my domain that doesn't check any spf/dkim/dmarc or any of that. And I can tell you, yes, the megacorps still send the most spam.

      • hbcdbff 3 hours ago

        Nothing you said negates my point

      • UqWBcuFx6NV4r 2 hours ago

        You do not exist in a vacuum.

        • superkuh 2 hours ago

          Are you suggesting that hosts along the path besides the sender and receiver mailserver are interpreting it and filtering? I'm not being glib, I just can't think of how what others do changes what my mailserver sees.

          I mean, I get the whole "herd immunity" angle so that if everyone requires spf pass then spammers will start using spf. But this doesn't change anything about the ratio of megacorp spam versus independent spam.

          Can you be more explicit?

  • thenewnewguy 3 hours ago

    When you say "through Google, Amazon, and Microsoft", is what you mean "through a server on GCP, AWS, or Azure" (or through their equivalent email-sending services)?

    I assume you don't mean you're receiving a large volume of spam from @amazon.com or @microsoft.com email addresses?

    • yjftsjthsd-h 2 hours ago

      I get plenty of spam from @gmail.com addresses, yes

    • cowlevel 24 minutes ago

      It's from @gmail.com

  • drum55 3 hours ago

    Almost all my spam, similarly, is "legal spam". Any time you interact with any service you end up "agreeing" to be added to potentially hundreds of different mailing lists, and the "unsubscribe" link cheerfully tells you that you've been removed from Marketing Emails on Weekdays Odd Months Just For Accessories, but not the other ones. I have never in my life wanted to subscribe to anything.

BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago

> Publish forward-confirmed reverse DNS for every sending IP

> Every sending IP must have a reverse DNS entry pointing to a fully qualified domain name (FQDN). That hostname must, in turn, resolve back to the same sending IP address. This is known as forward-confirmed reverse DNS (FCrDNS). An IP with missing or mismatched reverse DNS is treated as suspicious and is one of the most common reasons for an IP to be considered for listing.

I self-host an email server behind my ISPs connection, and so I do not own the IP address that I send mail from, therefore I can't satisfy the reverse DNS requirement.

  • rafram 2 hours ago

    I’m surprised your emails have ever gotten through if they’re coming from a residential IP. That’s definitely not considered good practice.

    • mzajc 2 hours ago

      I'm guessing good practice is renting a VPS and hoping it's not on blacklists already, or (more commonly) letting third parties read your mail by using a relay service. Or should we be applying for an ASN and buying IP blocks just to send mail?

      • wahern 2 hours ago

        A reputable and conscientious VPS provider will rigorously block outbound port 25. Some of those allow you to request outbound port 25 on a discretionary basis. If they're quick to respond to complaints then their address blocks should be pretty clean. You can always lookup your assigned address in various blacklists and roll the dice again on a new instance if you get a bad one. Ditto if you find Google or Microsoft doesn't like it, either.

      • dspillett 1 hour ago

        There are SMTP relay services that are cheaper than a reliable VPS, that will manage monitoring the sending addresses for appearance in blocklists and do the work to fix that so you don't have to. I still send direct (my home account is in an almost-commercial plan with an ISP that takes things seriously including IP reputation), but if that starts to fail I'll move over to one of those services rather than using a cheap VPS for sending. Maybe more than one for resilience.

      • cowlevel 20 minutes ago

        You should just host your mail server on a VPS and not overthink it. If someone is blocking your VPS and you urgently need to reach them, just use your old address on a big provider as a fallback.

        • ipaddr 10 minutes ago

          My most productive day was shutting down the vps mail server and just paying 5 dollars a month. The undelivered outgoing and undelivered incoming mail was too random.

    • sneak 2 hours ago

      Not being able to send mail at all from a residential IP is bullshit, though. Increase its spam score, but let it through.

      • cowlevel 21 minutes ago

        Spamhaus doesn't run anyone's mail server so that is what it is doing. If someone has configured their server to block mail over a certain Spamhaus score then that was their decision.

    • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago

      Residential IPs seem to be the most trusted these days, other than those, ironically, owned by the handful of big tech companies.

      Email should be able to be run from anywhere.

      • traceroute66 1 hour ago

        > Residential IPs seem to be the most trusted these days

        Oh, I see we've got a stand-up comedian in our ranks. ;)

        Most trusted ? You mean aside from all those residential IPs we see in our logs on a daily basis with the inevitably infected machines behind them taking part in DDoS attacks and other shenanigans.

        At best residential IPs are in the same category of IPs of the so-called "bulletproof hosts" and similar.

        Spamhaus and others maintain databases of residential IPs and whilst it doesn't get used for auto-blocking, most sensible organisations will reduce the trust score by a large chunk if its a residential IP.

        • BLKNSLVR 1 hour ago

          ;)

          My comment is based on the various recent discussions of "residential proxies", which are used for scraping because almost all of the VPS hosted IP ranges have got bad enough reputations that they're either blocked or rate limited or captcha-barricaded, etc.

          I personally keep a log of IP addresses that I block, but I'm entirely blind to their source, and often get negative feedback about "but if it's residential then the IP address will be re-assigned to someone else" - which doesn't sound like a good "trust that traffic" argument to me.

          I'm of the opinion that 99.9% of residential proxies are malware / involuntary, and that even the companies that attempt to 'herd' residential proxies legitimately are either criminal front companies or grew from criminal activity (not that that's always a bad thing).

          Getting well off-topic here though.

          P.S.

          > Oh, I see we've got a stand-up comedian in our ranks. ;)

          Says traceroute66. Love it.

        • cowlevel 22 minutes ago

          Why do you think they're ending up in your logs and not being blocked at an earlier layer?

  • wahern 2 hours ago

    If you have a static IP address and they're allowing outbound port 25 then my first thought is that you might have some sort of premium residential or business account that permits hosting in the ToS, in which case I would then infer they might allow you to specify a PTR record in their zone or maybe even support delegation to you.

    Lots of inferences there, but presuming Spamhaus isn't already blacklisting your IP address then that's additional evidence you don't have a vanilla residential IP address.

    • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago

      My ISP does block outbound port 25 by default, I specifically asked for it to be unblocked for me, and they obliged.

      • wahern 57 minutes ago

        Have you asked, yet, about a PTR record? Not every ISP has a DNS system tied into a web portal for automated edits. Even some large ISPs still manange their zones through traditional zone files. But that doesn't mean they don't support modifying PTR records for customers. It may be just a matter of you putting in a request and some greybeard sysadmin resolving the ticket by firing up vi or emacs to edit one of their zone files. This might even be preferable because it's more likely they'd be open to delegating d.c.b.a.in-addr.arpa to your own DNS server. That would allow you to add and modify PTR records without having to go through them each time, whether manually or through some bespoke web service.

  • UqWBcuFx6NV4r 2 hours ago

    Yeah, well, you can’t always get what you want.

  • sneak 2 hours ago

    Most ISPs have a PTR that also resolves to the IP; try using the one they chose for you (cust-462728.atl1.ispname.com) in your HELO.

    • edelbitter 2 hours ago

      If the ISP is not permitting you to configure the PTR of "your" addresses, then are they really your addresses? Spamhaus specifically recommends a "branded" name. Deferring to the (recognizable as such) ISPs defaults, and thus raising the suspicion of attempting to wash all customers together is not terribly useful with other antispam systems either.

      • sneak 2 hours ago

        No, your ISP’s IPs are not “really your addresses”, and precisely no one claimed they were. This is a workaround so that someone can send emails out. Most people don’t have their own PI IP space, especially these days.

      • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago

        On residential, they're never "your" IP address. The one assigned to me is 'mostly static', but they did notify me that the IP address they'd assigned to my connection was going to change, which it now has.

        Given my ISP has been kind enough to allow 'bridge mode' for my router, and outgoing traffic on port 25, then maybe I could ask them to change the reverse DNS lookup as well - feels like it may be a bridge too far, all I can do is ask though.

        Separate, but related, I host email for multiple domains on this connection, so the reverse lookup would only be relevant for one of those domains. I'm not sure if there are additional ways around that, but haven't thought in too much detail about it yet.

        • dspillett 1 hour ago

          > I host email for multiple domains on this connection, so the reverse lookup would only be relevant for one of those domains.

          For that you'll need to pick a domain that you don't mind the others being associated with, and having all MX entries be pointing to the sending hostnames for that. Or you'll need multiple addresses and some way to route outgoing mail through the right one.

    • BLKNSLVR 2 hours ago

      Yeah, it does have a reverse DNS that resolves to the ISP, and whilst looking at the article I had the same thought. Might see if I can implement that sooner rather than later.

  • trollbridge 2 hours ago

    My residential connection has working reverse DNS, although I fail to see how this has anything to do with spam.

  • Saris 1 hour ago

    Worth calling and asking, some ISPs will update your static IPs rDNS on request.

  • basilikum 41 minutes ago

    Are you able to actually get emails delivered?

  • cowlevel 23 minutes ago

    The majority of the internet has been blocking or silently discarding mail from your server then. This has been a de facto requirement for a long time.

albertgoeswoof 3 hours ago

These techniques rely on it being hard (or at least long winded) to setup a domain and server properly, such that spammers (who are self selected to be lazy) won’t do it right and give up quickly.

But with AI, it’s easy to get DKIM, DMARC, HELO etc. set up perfectly for almost no effort (maybe fcrdns is a bit more complex as it’s a manual process at most ISPs)

I think we are in the end going to go back to it just being based on IP (v4) reputation, and this is all theatre.

  • 0x1ch 2 hours ago

    Even before AI, was DKIM and DMARC hard to setup? It's been a streamlined process for at least four years now (as long as I've had to professionally enter records in a registrar), and even longer before that in my homelab setups.

    • mey 2 hours ago

      It is pretty straightforward. If you can learn regex or cron expressions, you can learn their meaning and format.

      It's gotten even easier with newer tooling. Stalwart will manage most of it for you if you want for example.

      No AI required.

      • 0x1ch 2 hours ago

        In my experience, it's really only the homegrown email servers failing DKIM/DMARC in the current year, which must be simple ignorance. I've had mailcow for years and it handles DKIM/DMARC perfectly, and I assume Stalwart is exactly the same.

        In the office, Google or Microsoft, it's been copy and pasting a couple records into your registrar for like four years. Not sure how admins are still messing this up even with AI now, haha.

    • albertgoeswoof 2 hours ago

      HELO hostname / banner is a little tricker

      I expect someone attempting to make money by sending mass emails does not have the ability to create DNS records or figure it out alone

  • edelbitter 2 hours ago

    This is not why these techniques are useful, though. They reduce plausible deniability and laundering-by-mixing. Because once you connected your unique (domain) name to your stuff, there is no "oh, it must have been that other customer that used that address before me" excuse any more. If everyone plays nicely and identifies their systems unambiguously, the question of who is responsible is clear. And thus, the reaction after detected misbehavior can be immediate and decisive.

computer23 3 hours ago

Anyone else having their email blocked by Microsoft and Spamhaus?

Microsoft Office 365 relies on Spamhaus and was blocking my email because the HELO on the mail server was mydomain.com instead of mailserver.mydomain.com.

Once the problem was fixed, it took time for Spamhaus to re-scan the mail server and take the mail server off the block list. And it took more time for Microsoft to stop blocking mail.

https://check.spamhaus.org/

  • Sebguer 2 hours ago

    Make sure to register on their SNDS and you might be able to find the issue? https://substrate.office.com/ip-domain-management-snds/snds

    You can also reach out to sender support through the same, and they are ~reasonably responsive (though very clearly outsourced / limited power). If it's a lingering MS block they should be able to override it. I've had luck in the past (though this was on behalf of a notable tech company, I don't know that the support people cared at all about that fact).

cowlevel 24 minutes ago

Spamhaus is effectively a protection racket. However, these specific requirements are extremely reasonable.

xmddmx 1 hour ago

Can someone clarify, do these rules apply only to people running their own mail transport?

Or does it also apply to people sending mail through their mail hosting company (when that company is not Google or Microsoft).

Specific example: I run servers "at home" that send mail through SMTP.

I have forward DNS properly set up, but my reverse DNS is syn-123-123-123-123.res.spectrum.com

My mail servers are, however, sending the mail through my mail host (DreamHost) and so I'm hoping that not having reverse DNS at home won't be a problem.

Am I reading the Spaumhaus rules correctly?

  • cowlevel 18 minutes ago

    Since it's for the outbound mail server how would it possibly apply to any other step in the chain?

nubinetwork 2 hours ago

> requirement for every sending IP to have a valid HELO, a reverse DNS (PTR) record, and a matching A record.

How was this not the default? If you're going to send me mail, I already check all of those... and I also check to see if you hold a MX. If your DNS is _that_ bad, I probably don't want your spam anyways...

raggi 3 hours ago

so can I get COI enforced and bad actors actually punished, or is this just gunna smash the little guys again?

can i get recruiter list spam punished?

jiveturkey 56 minutes ago

wait, these are all only just now new? what has taken them so long?

sneak 2 hours ago

Being picky about what is sent in HELO/EHLO seems like useless nitpicking toil that will not prevent any spam.

  • edelbitter 2 hours ago

    Not by itself. But it solves the "that was not me" dance: It was you. Your zone points there = your responsibility!

logicallee 21 minutes ago

There are a few more requirements:

- You may no longer send mail pretending to be a real person or company that you're not.

In the past, it was possible to set yourself as any sender. This is no longer allowed.

- You may no longer send out canvassing emails that purport to express a business interest, investor interest, collaboration, or job offer if you are not prepared to immediately follow through.

That means no more job spam and scams where you are in no way in any position or have any interest in hiring someone.

Likewise, you may no longer send fake investor spam that you're interested in investing in someone, whereas in reality you have zero ability or interest in doing so.

Interfering with other people's business relationships has always been a serious offense. It is now a criminal liability. If someone is doing business with someone else, reaching out, or starting to, you may not under threat of criminal liability in any way interfere with that relationship - not even through attempting to influence or manipulate the recipient.

Regarding blocking or screening of certain mail that could be legitimate but may be lower value than some other mail that is more important: currently there is no guidance that every single sent or received mail must go through 100% of the time. We value that there is a certain bar or threshold, because when there isn't then it's a hundred spam calls a day, a hundred spam emails, evverything is spam.

However, the advice is, therefore, when something is allowed through, then you should be prepared to allow it to progress naturally. It doesn't make sense to carefully curate relationships and what gets through, only to stop them if the recipient attentively reads the curated feed and engages with the sender on the terms they've set.

I really hate when I take the time to respond to someone who reached out to me, and then my response goes to a black hole.

Thank you for improving the Internet and cutting down on spam and scams.

  • akerl_ 14 minutes ago

    Where are you citing those requirements from; they don't appear to be on the Spamhaus page linked.

superkuh 3 hours ago

>Do not remain at p=none permanently. Starting with p=none is acceptable, but we recommend having an enforcement policy.

I've published a DMARC record that basically says to ignore DMARC and do nothing. I wonder if this will be enough.

    v=DMARC1;p=none;adkim=r;aspf=r;pct=0

I have no plans to ever change from none.

  • gsich 3 hours ago

    If you have SPF/DKIM active this setting will void them.

    • superkuh 3 hours ago

      Ah. So DMARC can actually makes things less secure? Can't say I'm surprised. I've had spf and dkim signing set up since ~2017. I only set up dmarc in 2024.

    • azertify 3 hours ago

      This is just not correct.

    • edelbitter 2 hours ago

      Check the headers of messages received via Microsoft; they don't even care what your policy says and check the alignment and validity of your SPF/DKIM configuration just the same.