xhevahir 1 day ago

I was interested to read in 1491 that a lot of archaeologists and naturalists believe the ecosystem of the Amazon may have been altered significantly by people before the arrival of Europeans. This article goes into that: https://www.mpg.de/11147178/amazon-rainforest-pre-columbian

  • Affric 1 day ago

    Underpinning a lot of the assumptions of evolutionary biology done in Australia and the Americas for a long time is the (racist) idea of indigenous peoples living in harmony with nature but the evidence is that much like anywhere else humans were masters over nature.

    • OgsyedIE 1 day ago

      The even had the popular idea that animals themselves lived in harmony with nature instead of battling for mastery in the same way that we do with a vastly more limited toolkit and cognition. One infamous effort to see how rabbit population numbers behaved under variation of predator numbers and kinds accidentally involved selecting the rabbits to restrain their own population through cannibalistic infanticide.

    • oska 23 hours ago

      Is it also 'racist' to be averse to and to shun straw men ?

      (e.g. your assertion of how evolutionary biology is done in Australia and the Americas)

    • joe_the_user 23 hours ago

      Your comment is like a mix-up of multiple false dichotomies.

      Both Europeans and Indigenous people altered the natural world but indigenous people generally had a distinct approach to Europeans. The default operation of European colonists was generally to alter the situation they found in terms of extracting resources without worry about what the end result would be whereas many indigenous peoples altered to natural world to create roughly sustainable system of living and producing the means of life. I'm pretty sure this latter approach is what a lot of people, including indigenous people, describe as "living in harmony with nature".

      • parineum 21 hours ago

        This is the exact misconception op is talking about. Indigenous people took what they wanted from nature. The only real difference is scale and that's a result of not having developed agriculture and cities.

        • lithocarpus 21 hours ago

          Many indigenous cultures had (and some still have) cultural injunctions against certain things, often including cutting down or otherwise killing old trees. Even some indigenous cultures of the British Isles had this kind of rule in many places.

          The type of rules and degree of adherence to them varied, for sure. But it's not like everyone has always had the attitude of "take anything you want or can get away with" without regard to other living beings.

          • graemep 10 hours ago

            Its not a division between European and indigenous: most of the world in inhabited by people who are neither European nor indigenous.

            As you point out (although I suspect you are misusing the word "indigenous" - is a largely meaningless term in the old world) European cultures have some prohibitions and traditions that protect the environment too.

            Many cultures, all over the world, going back to ancient times, did much the same. Just more slowly and further from our time.

            • lithocarpus 3 hours ago

              I mean there's a way in which no human is indigenous because basically all humans are always descended from people who came there from somewhere else.

              I'm fine with using indigenous to refer to a culture that developed in a place over a long period of time, but words are less important than what we mean by them.

      • senderista 18 hours ago

        Austronesian migrants (like in Hawaiʻi) brought rats, pigs, and dogs with them, which had devastating impacts on local ecosystems well before the arrival of Europeans.

      • graemep 11 hours ago

        I do not think it is a distinct approach. The difference is simply that in most cases pre-industrial societies change more slowly so they often reached a relatively stable state. This usually followed drastic changes to the environment. Some things are very obvious - almost every where humans go the extinction of a lot of megafauna swiftly follows: from when humanity first left Africa to New Zealand just a few hundred years ago.

        Hunter gatherer peoples might settle into an indefinitely sustainable system. Agricultural peoples will inevitable keep expanding and over-exploit.

      • Affric 11 hours ago

        If you consider sending all Australian megafauna (except the Kangaroo, Crocodile, Emu, and Cassowary) extinct sustainable and forever changing plant assemblages to be oriented towards fire then that is true of Aboriginal Australians. If you consider the extinction of ground sloths and equines sustainable then it’s true of the indigenous peoples who reached the Americas. If your bar for sustainability is what early modern Europe did to an Americas and Australia then a lot looks sustainable.

        None of this changes the injustices of dispossession, conquest, and genocide. But these humans were already dominating their landscapes as best they could per their economic systems when Europeans arrived. They did not fit into the previous ecosystem as a benign new member.

    • contingencies 22 hours ago

      True for pop assumptions. Scientists OTOH know that the introduction of large scale human lit fires, hunting and Austronesian dogs ('dingoes': introduced only relatively recently) drastically altered Australian biomes before European arrival. However, Europeans definitely screwed more up faster and are accelerating. We still maintain a completely insane deforestation rate. The promise of AI governance is removing human corruption and restoring the biology: we have all the technology to live in a modern lifestyle sustainably in amazing environment, we just lack the capability in government to do so.

      • quixoticelixer- 21 hours ago

        Australias net deforestation rate is not particularly high. I would say the biggest problem is a total change in burn regime.

        • contingencies 18 hours ago

          Total native forest cover loss in 2025 was 960,000 ha (~98km² or 0.66% of Australia's 146 million hectares of native forest), 40% of which was in Queensland (where we have most of our rainforest).

          We are lucky to even have original forest, removing it at this rate is totally batshit insane. There is no valid justification for it. It occurs because our land is managed by corrupt government which gives undue rights to private land holders. We can convert the huge amount of shitty marginal flood prone farmland we've already created for other uses before removing any more forest.

          I'm personally for AI government just to drain the human swamp: we've tried, we've failed, it's time to move over.

          • anenefan 17 hours ago

            Would love a source you're relying on for those figures. I would hope it's referring to the clearing of forested land on the coastal plain of Queensland which have high biodiversity for real estate development, both mostly from what I see residential housing estate developers along with the less suitable areas being earmarked for industrial purposes.

            Marginal flood prone land is not really suitable for housing, or industrial developments - not just from an environmental point of view, but from an economic outcome of higher insurance costs for all - the finally economic outcome building up into these high risk areas - watched it happen around a coastal town south of me in the 90s and 2010's weather delivered answers why it was always a bad idea.

            Farmland generally in Queensland has been under a broad envelope of programs to mitigate the loss of forest / scrub around waterways for many years, much is voluntary - some people on that tangent mean well with their efforts but miss more important aspects ... of course there is the occasion twit with their simple innocent actions paint poor signs.

            • contingencies 16 hours ago

              Sounds like you're from Queensland and genuinely unaware: well, "authoritative sources for 2025 australian native forest losses" -> bingo. TIL.

              "Broad envelope of programs" = nobody has authority, everything dies due to not my department. Can't help but think we need AI government to remove corruption and bullshit. Annual fixed wing drone flyover audit: tree missing equals fine. Simple, problem solved.

              • anenefan 8 hours ago

                I'm sorry the first statement doesn't even make any sense to me, was I to search? Sadly the text you put in quotes - the one result from google, was this thread, DDG - none. That leaves the last paragraph which comes as some half hearted whine, flippant ... however that's not the reality.

                Please, if you have a source for those percentages -- I'm particularly interested in the geographic areas -> now just to see if it falls into legit or rubbery figures.

                Typically the propaganda machine aims to protect the over development (continued clearing) of the highly diverse coastal areas along Queensland, - where the $$$$ is - instead, the propaganda's focus puts sugar cane growing areas in the cross hairs (seriously what ever scrub / rainforest left on land parcels that were farmed or the country that was felled for wood, for sugar cane were well and truly over cleared by the early 20th century ... it was so savage (the pioneers felled so much country in order to power the sugar mills before starting to use the fibrous bulk of the sugar cane plant itself) it's laughable to even suggest farmers there are clearing more rainforest.) The other favourite is the sparse outback inland being cleared presently - however much that was suitable for farming or grazing was pulled [1] with dozers in the 50s to 70s and since that time, regrowth and small pockets of native forest when land changed hands ... strangely nearly every item that bemoans the wholesale devastation in the vast outback, will almost every time place an obligatory photo / video of an excavator pushing over surprisingly tall straight eucalyptus trees. To put context to this for those who are more familiar with computers, it's like showing school kids with their average laptop, insisting it's average, however one recognises it's actually top end kit or a high end gaming rig and so exceedingly out of place as to be not likely to be ... representative. Coastal areas have seen a steep growth of excavators on private properties due IMHO in part to changes in cartage - contractors (working for developers and around the mines) moving to slightly smaller excavators. Speaking of mines - again the wholesale clearing they do, seems to barely get a mention, but there are vast properties I've visited out that way that were being slowly purchased by mines, and in recent years I have been horrified to learn through the grape vine, near everything I might recall at a couple of properties I visited more than the others, has now been open cut mined in near entirety - so nothing or very little of the old landscape from horizon to horizon exists as it was.

                Getting back to that second paragraph. As for monitoring - actually it's satellite and very close to live for the folks tasked to interface with farmers from what I hear up here in Queensland. There are a few different regulatory bodies involved as far as I am aware, and thus far, even a neighbour has had a visit when they, whichever arm, arrived as a drop in visit, to complain that around one of their cattle watering troughs in their back paddock, was less than 70% ground cover around where the cattle congregated waiting to drink ... um yeah - most watering points like troughs are fixed and not mobile but anyhow ... I guess my solution would be to build some shade over the entire pad :)

                [1] The process of pulling refers to a typical formation of two large dozers that are attached to each end of a single heavy chain or large diameter wire rope that's weighted. It's economic for clearing light scrub, heavier scrub or light forest may require a chaser dozer to push over the larger trees.

                • contingencies 3 hours ago

                  I find Google and DDG are ~useless outside of corporate website detection today. You have to use an AI to query (pick one: claude, perplexity, gemini ... boycott scama's chatgpt). Install https://handy.computer/download and talk to it with voice, it's easier and maintains privacy. For primary written sources, use Anna's Archive, Sci Hub or similar.

                  Anecdotes aside, the key point here is the native forest is still being destroyed at an alarming rate. The corrupt Queenslanders can't manage it. They're worse, but not of a different ilk, than the other state governments. Maybe they need to be removed from office, and authoritative Federal Government with AI powered policing can sort them out.

                  TIL = today I learned.

    • ghastmaster 20 hours ago

      The idea you are proposing is very similar to the "noble savage". It is not racist, but ignorant and predjudicial. Predjucial attitudes can lead to or expose racism, but by definition are not racist.

      https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noble_savage

      • cortesoft 18 hours ago

        Why is that not racism? Believing that some people are 'closer to nature' is believing that certain races are different.

        • defrost 18 hours ago

          It's a behavioural difference, not ingrained within genetics.

          You could have a shot at a bigoted belief, perhaps.

          • lmz 16 hours ago

            So is committing crime, yet saying X people commit more crimes is branded "racist".

            • defrost 16 hours ago

              How is saying marginalised people in poor economic circumstances isolated in various ways from more affluent parts of society commit more crime, and have other {list of issues} racist?

              Particularly as it applies as much to redlined communities and Appalachians after the mines close and the Sattlers more in?

              Although, there may well be a racial element in the differences between committing crime and charged and found guilty of crime.

          • ghastmaster 8 hours ago

            Precisely. Racism has an element of belief that one race is superior to another, not just a belief that they are different.

            • cortesoft 3 hours ago

              That is one definition, but the original definition is just believing that there are separate races with separate ingrained traits.

        • pvaldes 7 hours ago

          All "races" are different. They evolved in different climates and hybridized with different species of Homo. Racism is thinking that people adapted to cold are superior than people adapted to heat (for example).

  • Exmoor 1 day ago

    Much of North America was heavily managed by native peoples. I read a anecdote about a group of native people returning to the Okanogan area of Washington after decades of absence and being horrified at how much growth there was in the forests. They'd used fire to keep the growth down and the area was apparently more like parkland until Europeans arrived.

    • lithocarpus 21 hours ago

      Important to note you mean they were horrified at how much growth of understory/brush there was. Not growth of the big trees. The problem with letting the understory/brush grow, is that it makes the whole forest including larger trees more vulnerable when a severe fire comes through.

Exmoor 1 day ago

> While the genus has a very long evolutionary history, around half of its extant species emerged only within the last 6 million years.

I imagine that to a biologist familiar with these things may see this as notable, but I was thinking we might be counting in the thousands of years when I opened the article. Species in the same genus diverging within the last 6 million years seems quite expected to me? I'm also used to animal species where we can start to see the divergence of populations starting during the most recent glacial maximum.

Zarathustra30 1 day ago

Is this surprising? I was under the impression biodiversity happened when a niche opens up, then dwindles as species anneal toward an optimum.

Affric 1 day ago

I would be interested to see if this pattern is replicated anywhere else.

  • OgsyedIE 1 day ago

    I'm more curious about why it isn't everywhere else. The orthodoxy is that meiotic reproduction, complementary pairs of gametes, lossy recombination and senescence all evolved to increase the speed of speciation in an arms race against the increasing speed of parasite speciation.

    Why do, for instance, crocodiles and deep-sea sharks speciate so slowly?