robin_reala 5 days ago

The scooters in the first place are a nightmare for accessibility: people leave them all over the place with no thought as to whether they’re blocking rights of way.

  • ZoneZealot 1 day ago

    The funniest bit of the clearly LLM generated article is this:

    > Scooters primarily travel where their use is permitted and commercially viable. They may miss residential streets, pedestrian paths and disconnected sections that create the greatest problems for wheelchair users.

    The scooters from these ride share companies are notoriously not geo-fenced to only the areas they can legally be ridden in. They know they're ridden on pavements the vast majority of times - rather than only bicycle lanes, the road, and shared-use pavements.

    • pimlottc 1 day ago

      It’s frustrating but I highly doubt anyone has the ability to create a geo-fencing system precise enough to keep people off sidewalk while still allowing use of roads right next to them.

      • duskwuff 23 hours ago

        And even if you can detect when a user leaves the sidewalk, making the scooter stop abruptly - in the road - would be more dangerous than letting them continue.

        • podocarp 22 hours ago

          You don't need to stop them, maybe just send a fine like how it should work? Although the precision is of course the primary blocker.

          • dan_grec 22 hours ago

            You want a private company to fine people for breaking road rules?

            That slope isn’t slippery, it’s pure ICE.

            • toss1 20 hours ago

              The company would not be fining them. It would be adding a surcharge the next time they ride or to renew their membership. There is no obligation to ride again on their service — the person being "fined" can simply abandon the service and never pay a cent.

              The bad behavior surcharge should discourage the bad practices or drive the bad actors off the platform. Either way, mission accomplished.

        • alright2565 20 hours ago

          In the USA, the opposite is needed. It is illegal to ride the electric scooter on the sidewalk.

          • lxgr 19 hours ago

            Isn’t that the case in most regions? Scooters are usually regulated like bicycles, which also don’t belong on sidewalks.

      • bluGill 20 hours ago

        GPSes that can get you within a couple centimeters of your location are readily available. That is more than good enough for a geofence.

        Of course, we're talking more than $5,000 per unit to get that level of GPS, so I can well understand why they wouldn't put one on a scooter, but the technology has existed for decades.

        The other part missing, of course, is someone needs to map where all the safe places for a scooter to ride are and put that into a system. This is not particularly difficult, but it is tedious and it's going to cost a lot of money.

        • 0_____0 20 hours ago

          Even with RTK you're going to have a hard time getting consistent position in an urban canyon with all the multipathing. Not really workable for mobile GPS.

        • pimlottc 6 hours ago

          Can they do it consistently while moving at 15 miles per hour?

  • yipinwong 23 hours ago

    You obviously live in a shittiest neighborhood. my neighborhood is fine. people park right at the right places at the right time.

    I am willing to pay Bolt for their data for finding good neiborhood as this is a good indication for good residential areas.

  • nomel 21 hours ago

    That problem has nothing to do with the scooter. And, you can report that so the problematic person gets banned, in the app.

    • LtWorf 20 hours ago

      How

      • dijit 20 hours ago

        There are “report” numbers on the scooters, they’ll ask you what the number on the scooter is (near the QR).

        You can report in the app directly too.

        However I think its my duty to let everyone know that I’ve seen people moving these parked scooters into the street- I guess to stir up animosity or to be otherwise anti-social.

        Also; You are forced to send a photo of the finished ride for validation when the ride ends btw, so it would be easy for the ride-sharer to validate someone doing something crappy.

        Ironically when the scooter companies try to clamp down harder on parking, they can make the problem worse but without addressing these “pranksters”: https://blog.dijit.sh/enforcement-can-have-the-inverse-effec...

        • goosejuice 19 hours ago

          That's why this is not a good solution. People move them out of their way and in someone else's way.

          • dijit 19 hours ago

            its good that people realise how little infrastructure there is for bikes that even parking (1 car space for every 10 bike spaces) is a limiting factor for e-scooters.

          • nomel 19 hours ago

            You misunderstand. They require taking a picture when you park. THAT is the image they use when judging the reports. If the reported image matches the parked image (or the parked image is a picture of the sky), then the person that parked it is the issue. If the parked image is fine, but the reported image is not, then it was a prankster, or the person that parked went out of their way, moving the thing with the motor off, to be an ass.

            I'm incredibly confused at this thread.

            • goosejuice 13 hours ago

              I'm well aware of how they work.

              > then it was a prankster, or the person that parked went out of their way, moving the thing with the motor off, to be an ass.

              In other words it's not a good solution.

              • nomel 40 minutes ago

                No, it is a good solution. It's just not a perfect solution.

    • transitorykris 20 hours ago

      Everything to do with the scooter, the world will continue to make more people incapable of thinking about or caring how their actions affect others.

    • themaninthedark 20 hours ago

      Right, so if random company's scooters are left around the first step to taking care of the problem is to download an app....

      How about the company take some responsibility and get designated parking spots, then if the scooters are left out of the spots the company can ban that user. Now it's not my job to police two 3rd parties that are shitting up the commons.

      • nomel 19 hours ago

        People aren't putting them in the right place. What would motivate them to go to a designated parking spot? And, you've clearly never used one. There can't be designated parking spots at every possible destination.

        > the first step to taking care of the problem is to download an app

        It only happens because some cultures only think to consider their fellow man if punishment is involved, and you live in a space where one or more of those cultures is predominant. I think the best mechanism would be to turn it into a traffic violation, with significant fines, so these type of people have some reason to not be asses. Bolt already requires an ID scan, and I'm sure the city would enjoy all the extra revenue! Unfortunately, it tends to be that areas with the kind of culture you have are also areas that vote against enforcing consequences for improper behavior in public spaces, usually finding some reason to excuse/justify them.

        • snayan 16 hours ago

          I feel like if you can't solve this design problem in a way that doesn't externalize the management of consequences to random people forced to download the app, or the city to start fining people, perhaps it just shouldn't exist.

          It feels like a lot of people's sentiment around these things is the costs outweigh the benefits but we lack mechanisms or enforcement to stop shit ideas like this from making a non negligible portion of societies lives worse.

          The scale of impact on public spaces in situations like this seems to have grown at a dramatically faster rate than legislation.

          • nomel 14 hours ago

            I think the answer is the same: monetary consequences. If the city cared, they could just impound any scooter blocking a sidewalk (PLENTY of existing laws for this), with some fee for retrieval. This would result in only neighborhoods with reasonable people having them, and motivate the companies to geofence to those areas, to prevent loss. I bet the enforcement by the scooter companies would be fixed in a few days.

        • watwut 10 hours ago

          > What would motivate them to go to a designated parking spot?

          Scooter does not count as returned and keep chargimg, unless on designated spot.

          Easy.

          Scooters being left wherever is predictable and company ignores it, because ignoring makes them convenient. Which makes them have more customers.

        • speedstyle 6 hours ago

          In London you can't end the ride and stop paying except at designated parking spots. Spots aren't quite as frequent as bike racks (you need a map) but they're within 200m of any destination, and right next to popular ones. I last saw one on the pavement maybe six months ago

    • goosejuice 20 hours ago

      > That problem has nothing to do with the scooter.

      The scooter, no. The company that it belongs to, yes. Putting it out of the way of pedestrians and taking a photo is a solution, but it's not a good one.

    • lxgr 19 hours ago

      The problem is an externality tolerated by the operating company, so it has a lot to do with it.

buran77 1 day ago

A nice initiative that hopefully bring some benefit, collecting data says nothing about the intentions to act on it. But scooter riders can and will slalom between cracks, potholes, etc. while people in wheelchairs won't have the option.

This being said, how will they assess the obstacles the scooters themselves pose to everyone else?

  • AngryData 22 hours ago

    Well if you have accelerometers on board you can tell how extreme the road or rider is riding. But you only really need to look at the gentlest rides or sections of a ride to identify problems and map safe courses. The guy hopping curbs and jumping stuff can easily be excluded unless you are trying to make a search for radical skate moves.

rwyinuse 1 day ago

Banning these scooters would improve urban accessibility greatly. The idea is good, but the actual end result is chaos as nobody enforces rules with parking, how people ride them and so on.

  • podocarp 22 hours ago

    An interesting example is major cities in China. In shenzhen or Beijing you can see half a street full of parked bikes or scooters. Most large roads also have a non motorized lane where it's also usually complete chaos to newcomers.

    But it does provide a huge convenience and reduces the reliance on cars so people live it it.

    Now if you wonder how on earth does everyone park so neatly, it is not due to "social credits", the solution is to just hire people to re-park everything occasionally, while also doing maintainance like collecting broken bikes and replacing scooter batteries.

    It's just an interesting brute force solution that's not possible elsewhere most likely due to the lack of cheap manpower to do the rounds each day. But just fun to observe if you see them doing it.

    • cluckindan 20 hours ago

      These re-parking and maintenance operators exist in the west too, usually they are migrants driving hella unsafe looking crusty vans and they only operate at night so people don’t see

  • arijun 22 hours ago

    If they aren’t enforcing parking, why would they enforce a ban? Surely enforcing parking rules should be the first step.

    Incidentally, the parking is enforced by the scooter companies where I live (it won’t let you park unless you’re in a designated scooter parking spot), and there are very rarely accessibility issues from them.

    • jeffbee 20 hours ago

      Usually these things need a local franchise, so the local authority can just revoke it for noncompliance with terms.

  • Zambyte 22 hours ago

    You can replace "scooters" with "cars" in your comment and it would remain true.

    • robin_reala 22 hours ago

      Cars don’t typically park directly across the pavement, blocking pedestrian access.

      • Aachen 22 hours ago

        I get around a lot for OpenStreetMap surveying. The number of ways where I need to leave the sidewalk or cycling lane due to cars far outnumber the ones where carryable electric vehicles are the problem

        Guess it's different where you're from but one doesn't absolve the other and one of them fits very nicely to getting the last mile (often half the journey time) from public transport to/from your destination, needing a lot fewer vehicles on the road in total (besides that they're almost noiseless, take much less space while driving or parked, much less particulate matter even once all cars are combustionless one day, etc.). It can hardly not be a win for pedestrians and cyclists

        Edit: to be clear, of course I'm all for fining the ones that do pose a problem. A rental car company would also have no problem forwarding tickets to the person that drove it at the time. Why enforcement seems to be lagging behind, I'm not sure

      • Symbiote 4 hours ago

        Cars very frequently block pavements, especially by people who will "just be a minute" (or 30) in a shop, or "are in a bit of a hurry".

stochastic_tn 21 hours ago

We’re working on solving the accessibility surveying problem as well over at Daxbot.

It’s really interesting to see how many different platforms are being used to attack this problem. I’m personally aware of several including iPhones, Segways, ATVs, robots (my personal favorite), and good-old-fashioned field surveying. This is the first time I’ve heard of a scooter-based approach, however!

alexpotato 22 hours ago

Reminds me of how the National Bureau of Economic Research did something similar using accelerometer data from Uber drivers:

https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w31981/w319...

  • jmpman 17 hours ago

    I've been noticing that my city's streets have been developing potholes more regularly and haven't been getting patched. The city has a 311 app which allows you to report the problem, but it doesn't appear that people are taking the time to report. Why can't a city contract with a company like Tesla to gather this road accelerometer data and use it to automatically create tickets for our 311 system, dispatching repair crews?

cluckindan 20 hours ago

Q: how to passively gather massive amounts of accurate device location and transit data in cities where GPS is often useless?

A: have a fleet of mobile scanners which people themselves want to drive around.

The damn things have cameras too. Illegal surveillance networks at someone’s fingertips.

tecleandor 21 hours ago

Those scooters shouldn't be on the sidewalk to begin with.

LegitShady 10 hours ago

"we're so desparate for arguments as to why people should like these scooters, we're going to glorify the highly intrusive sensor platforms for their ability to map everything around them and say its for disabled/the children/those we must protect."

I get its gis guys being gis guys, but bolt scooters are basically e-waste that hasn't been thrown in the river by methheads yet.

sram1337 19 hours ago

"its not mass surveillance is an accessibility network"