i’ve never stumbled across any of these pages and had them be useful in any way shape or form. maybe others have had a different experience, but i think removing them is actually a great idea.
It seemed like most threads were dominated by a handful of people who wrote long mostly copy-pasted responses that typically ended in suggesting you reformat your hard drive and reinstall macOS.
Edit: forgot about resetting PRAM and SMC. Those are classics too!
They were never useful. All of the answers sounded like corporate talking points which was surprising given the answerers were supposedly mostly volunteers. The answers reeked of AI copypasta before LLMs were even a thing.
FYI When try and download the needed VirtualBox tool from https://www.virtualbox.org/ it gives a payment error .... Puzzling . Probably has nothing to do with ArchiveTeam ADMIN - if this query , here , not allowed .... please just delete it now Thank You
I cannot speak to why you’re getting a payment error on the virtual box site, I did not receive the same when I attempted to download binaries for windows or mac to test. Its license is free for personal or educational use.
Ironically - i'm running the docker container directly on a mac M1 mini (using colima), and ran into a bit of a problem due to this bug https://github.com/golang/go/issues/77572
Adding `-e GODEBUG=madvdontneed=0` to the docker run command for the warrior should let other apple computers install and run the applediscussions project!
I never understood the point of the blind leading the blind within the Apple Support Community. There was quite a bit of misinformation there, but not nearly enough official instruction from Apple itself. Am I wrong about this?
You're not wrong. As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
"They were full of people asking questions and not getting useful answers, with many responses given by users who were more motivated to gain karma in the forum’s user-ranking system than to help." — Jason Snell (https://sixcolors.com/link/2026/11/ding-dong-the-apple-suppo...)
I agree that unweighted "solutions" from random (and often incorrect) people with good intentions may well lead many down wrong paths... but that having those paths preserved and clearly described is of value in and of itself.
> As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
But Internet Archive isn't discoverable by search engines? I think it isn't anyway, I've literally never seen a Wayback Machine link in Google so I assume it's on purpose.
There's no robots.txt on web.archive.org and it seems to come up with you use `site:` modifiers, so I think it's just ranked very low. Probably on purpose but probably not on IA's part.
Yes, never had to look at the Apple one too much mercifully, but my heart would sink every time a Microsoft one came up in a search for some problem I was having.
On one hand I deeply understand the desire to archive the years of human effort which went into asking and answering forum posts.
On the other hand, Apple should have voluntarily done the archiving. Predictably they didn't and wouldn't, because the only single thing these companies care about is profit and everything else can happily go to shit.
In a just world, Apple's refusal to spend the absolutely miniscule amount of effort to archive the forum themselves would earn them a massive reputational stain and they'd face an enormous backlash for effectively spitting on the very people who allow them to exist.
That won't happen, because consumers simply don't care. Corporations have proven time and time again that consumers will tolerate - or even celebrate - being trampled upon as long as their new shiny baubles make them feel superior in some way.
It is a travesty that Apple's support forum was created virtually exclusively by volunteers, and it's a travesty that it's up to other volunteers to ensure its ongoing survival.
Fuck Apple, squarely and truly and wholeheartedly. Fuck Apple.
It has always seemed like a really impoverished place with low quality answers compared to stuff like Stack Exchange. And now they’ll burn it to the ground. Mixed feelings.
I support anyone’s noble attempts to avoid loss of information, and these forums do at least track the long history of reported issues with Apple products, so, good for them.
But if ever there was a more frustrating support forum, this one was it.
Only Apple could pull off something so audacious: hosting a support forum with zero paid representatives present, while still having almost every thread feature one or more responses written in a corporate tone that deliver the Apple talking points (and if necessary, even dismissing the user’s problem as a skill issue or a matter of opinion, rather than an egregious design flaw or bug).
All done by people so devoted to Apple that they perform this labor for decades without any form of compensation. Not even like coupons or something. I’ve been astounded by it since my first visit.
Precisely this. It was ridiculous, beyond audacious, to depend on the public to provide what Apple should have provided all along. Was it ever known whether Apple reviewed the community posts to learn about their product defects? It was as if a million voices screamed into the void and God (Apple) never listened.
It’s usually pretty straightforward to get a human on the phone with Apple. I had a problem with a return the other day and was routed to a human pretty quickly.
Google, on the other hand, I am pretty sure don’t even employ people for phone support
Whew. I thought I would really miss searching about some age-old glitchy problem in iOS or why I lost all my contacts in a software update, finding out that hundreds of other people have been dealing with the same problems, not finding any answer and just shrugging my shoulders. Now, Apple says "just shrug your shoulders."
i’ve never stumbled across any of these pages and had them be useful in any way shape or form. maybe others have had a different experience, but i think removing them is actually a great idea.
agreed, nearly everytime i googled an issue (such as alarms going off completely silent), i would find 100s of threads with nonanswers
It seemed like most threads were dominated by a handful of people who wrote long mostly copy-pasted responses that typically ended in suggesting you reformat your hard drive and reinstall macOS.
Edit: forgot about resetting PRAM and SMC. Those are classics too!
They were never useful. All of the answers sounded like corporate talking points which was surprising given the answerers were supposedly mostly volunteers. The answers reeked of AI copypasta before LLMs were even a thing.
You can see the live progress here: https://tracker.archiveteam.org/applediscussions/
Related: The Apple Support Community will permanently close on November 20, 2026 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50449440
One can contribute by firing up an ArchiveTeam Warrior docker container or VM. 2.68M items remaining todo with three days to go, as of this comment.
https://wiki.archiveteam.org/index.php/ArchiveTeam_Warrior
Thanks for posting that. I really appreciate the work that Archive does. I didn't know I could help.
“Many hands make light work.”
I have an old Intel NUC laying around that's about to get busy :)
FYI When try and download the needed VirtualBox tool from https://www.virtualbox.org/ it gives a payment error .... Puzzling . Probably has nothing to do with ArchiveTeam ADMIN - if this query , here , not allowed .... please just delete it now Thank You
I cannot speak to why you’re getting a payment error on the virtual box site, I did not receive the same when I attempted to download binaries for windows or mac to test. Its license is free for personal or educational use.
Ironically - i'm running the docker container directly on a mac M1 mini (using colima), and ran into a bit of a problem due to this bug https://github.com/golang/go/issues/77572
Adding `-e GODEBUG=madvdontneed=0` to the docker run command for the warrior should let other apple computers install and run the applediscussions project!
Are each of those names usernames of people from the community? Or are they also the usernames of internal internet archive employees?
Archive Team and Archive.org are related like hamsters and ham. The usernames on the left are volunteers crawling.
Community.
Some may have more than 1 instance running.
ArchiveTeam != Archive.org
I never understood the point of the blind leading the blind within the Apple Support Community. There was quite a bit of misinformation there, but not nearly enough official instruction from Apple itself. Am I wrong about this?
Have you tried resetting the PRAM and resetting the SMC?
The number of Apple devices that I've "fixed" with a PRAM reset is pretty high tho.
Incredible compression ratio
You're not wrong. As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
"They were full of people asking questions and not getting useful answers, with many responses given by users who were more motivated to gain karma in the forum’s user-ranking system than to help." — Jason Snell (https://sixcolors.com/link/2026/11/ding-dong-the-apple-suppo...)
"Good riddance." — John Gruber (https://daringfireball.net/linked/2026/11/11/apple-support-c...)
This is where "context" is important.
I agree that unweighted "solutions" from random (and often incorrect) people with good intentions may well lead many down wrong paths... but that having those paths preserved and clearly described is of value in and of itself.
> As much as I deeply respect the mission and accomplishments of Internet Archive, keeping it discoverable by search engines and LLMs is a net-negative IMHO.
But Internet Archive isn't discoverable by search engines? I think it isn't anyway, I've literally never seen a Wayback Machine link in Google so I assume it's on purpose.
I'm not sure - I've never seen Google return a Web Archive link but I was pleasantly surprised to see Yandex return one today.
There's no robots.txt on web.archive.org and it seems to come up with you use `site:` modifiers, so I think it's just ranked very low. Probably on purpose but probably not on IA's part.
This is also true of Microsoft and Google "Support Communities". A bunch of people LARPing customer support with overly verbose and useless replies.
Yes, never had to look at the Apple one too much mercifully, but my heart would sink every time a Microsoft one came up in a search for some problem I was having.
On one hand I deeply understand the desire to archive the years of human effort which went into asking and answering forum posts.
On the other hand, Apple should have voluntarily done the archiving. Predictably they didn't and wouldn't, because the only single thing these companies care about is profit and everything else can happily go to shit.
In a just world, Apple's refusal to spend the absolutely miniscule amount of effort to archive the forum themselves would earn them a massive reputational stain and they'd face an enormous backlash for effectively spitting on the very people who allow them to exist.
That won't happen, because consumers simply don't care. Corporations have proven time and time again that consumers will tolerate - or even celebrate - being trampled upon as long as their new shiny baubles make them feel superior in some way.
It is a travesty that Apple's support forum was created virtually exclusively by volunteers, and it's a travesty that it's up to other volunteers to ensure its ongoing survival.
Fuck Apple, squarely and truly and wholeheartedly. Fuck Apple.
It has always seemed like a really impoverished place with low quality answers compared to stuff like Stack Exchange. And now they’ll burn it to the ground. Mixed feelings.
That forum had zero value. Nobody ever found solution to anything there. Killing it was long overdue. There is nothing worth archiving.
I support anyone’s noble attempts to avoid loss of information, and these forums do at least track the long history of reported issues with Apple products, so, good for them.
But if ever there was a more frustrating support forum, this one was it.
Only Apple could pull off something so audacious: hosting a support forum with zero paid representatives present, while still having almost every thread feature one or more responses written in a corporate tone that deliver the Apple talking points (and if necessary, even dismissing the user’s problem as a skill issue or a matter of opinion, rather than an egregious design flaw or bug).
All done by people so devoted to Apple that they perform this labor for decades without any form of compensation. Not even like coupons or something. I’ve been astounded by it since my first visit.
Precisely this. It was ridiculous, beyond audacious, to depend on the public to provide what Apple should have provided all along. Was it ever known whether Apple reviewed the community posts to learn about their product defects? It was as if a million voices screamed into the void and God (Apple) never listened.
The very idea of Apple considering the possibility of defects in their products - never mind addressing those defects - is laughable.
Yeah, for all the other hate Microsoft is getting, I've at least had good experience with getting support.
Had a minor issue once, tried all the things on forums, didn't work. Sent a request, and the next day someone actually called me and helped fix it.
While Google and Apple I've never even been able to reach a human. Which was quite stressful when my Gmail got accidentally locked for a week..
It’s usually pretty straightforward to get a human on the phone with Apple. I had a problem with a return the other day and was routed to a human pretty quickly.
Google, on the other hand, I am pretty sure don’t even employ people for phone support
Yes I got Apple on the phone easily enough once but the offshore person stuck to the script, so my hijacked account stayed closed with no recourse.
You summed it up exactly. The only site I ever blocked from Google search results
Whew. I thought I would really miss searching about some age-old glitchy problem in iOS or why I lost all my contacts in a software update, finding out that hundreds of other people have been dealing with the same problems, not finding any answer and just shrugging my shoulders. Now, Apple says "just shrug your shoulders."
Are these the pages that broke the back button on my mouse so I had to go and click back every time?