Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
This here is about google, abusing their monopoly.
So clearly not a good effect on society, but maybe a wake up call for some. And AI in general will replace jobs, can be good, can be bad, depending if those replaced find something more meaningful.
I'm pretty sure the same question from the google search has been asked on chatgpt too, the answer was in part derived from the article-writers website, but no users were directed there and no ads were served. Same for other ai chatbots where people ask stuff instead of google-for-websites and watch ads on those websites.
You see the issue as abusing monopoly? If there were more competitors with more chat bots, you think the situation would be better for All About Berlin?
If web search would not be controlled by one company, that can just change the rules any day and not link anymore, like they used to, yes I do see the issue here as abusing their monopoly. I don't want a chat box, when I am looking for a link. On the other hand, when I am looking for information, I do ask claude nowdays to find me sources. But I ain't the majority.
Everything was fine with google, as long people were earning with ads, now that google change their main product, its not fine anymore? I guess its just time to find a new business idea?
Google was fine to me, when they were one of many search engines - and offered the best experience. Clean empty search page - clear results, ads in between clearly marked.
This specific case is of course a net negative for society I think. At the same time... It's 100% worth the money I pay each month. It allows me to create things I couldn't on my own. It helps me learn new skills. It saves tons of time while searching.
Corruption is a word that has meaning. Using it to equate it with paying for a subscription for a tech service completely destroys that meaning.
I could use any example where a beneficiary of literally any kind of service causes some real or perceived harm to some real or perceived group of people and equate it with corruption.
AI is a tool. It's massively useful and people pay for that. It's our economy that's broken.
I don't think the person above is saying "this is literally corruption", they're just using corruption as an example of behaviour that is financially beneficial to the person or group doing it and harmful to society at large.
Yes, that's my point. They are using the word in a way that morphs it into "something good for a specific individual but generally harmful" or something.
No useful information is conveyed beyond "AI is bad for society" so I'd rather just mention that instead of bringing the loaded word "corruption" into it.
I think there are analogies between corruption and the broader LLM phenomenon, as it's playing out.
It degrades truth, quality, trust, and reliability. It feeds off the work of people who do things the correct way. People know there are big problems, but constantly point to short term benefit. People deride people who take a principled stand and say, "you think things were good before? Nothing's perfect, relax and enjoy it. Adapt or die." They laugh at people who try to do things correctly and say it's "impossible in this day and age."
Yes, there are parallels, especially if you consider the broader LLM phenomenon as it is playing out, as you said. I think I agree.
But that does not automatically mean that those parallels stem from the nature of the AI technology. Corruption is related to moral or aesthetic or other values: someone does something for their own gain but which makes things worse in general (in moral, aesthetic, or some other sense). But AI is just a technology, and it is not clear that all its uses must lead to corruption. In fact, I believe that it is a technology that could cause a lot of good. If handled correctly.
Its corruptive effects are results of how our societies work; I don't think AI is to blame, we are.
>Its corruptive effects are results of how our societies work; I don't think AI is to blame, we are.
Isn't this the issue exactly - that unregulated AI is glaringly obviously resulting in harmful behaviours, and we are failing to regulate this in a responsible way to shape its use and outcomes?
Similarly, the notion of corruption is (as you say) related to moral and aesthetic considerations. For example: Helping your friends by doing favors for them is widely considered good and pro-social! But there's some ways of helping your friends that might be nepotism, or even corruption if it unjustly or harmfully warps some social process.
For that reason, we have legal frameworks to manage it and moral/social sanctions against obvious offenders. Exactly where AI requires social, moral or legal regulation is socially produced and reproduced continually, as with any other phenomenon. But we need to figure this one out fast because it's breaking a lot of things very fast.
They help tremendously. Can explain concepts in your language, at your skill level. Can help you explore codebases, that might be outside of your deptph. Can visualize complex topics in seconds. Can create interactive tutorials on the fly. And I could go on and on.
For me, they help me with the unknown unknowns. There's so many technologies one can use for all sorts of things nowadays, just asking an LLM "what should I consider for the DB for this app" etc. opens my eyes on various things.
They can't, of course, teach you things the same way Neo was thought Kung Fu :)
Why do you assume I delegate the doing to the LLM when I'm asking it to teach me something? For example... The socratic teaching skill that someone linked to last week works surprisingly well imo.
Conflicted is how I feel. The tools are undoubtedly useful, I feel like I work on more intersting problems day to day now (rather than churning out boiler plate code) and will help us make technological progress that will benefit all of humanity (provided the benefit is distributed), and while I wish I'd chosen a career as a carpenter, because wood doesn't change like tech in the computer world does, I'm up for the challenge of figuring out how to adapt. But not everyone is, and the change, and the vacuuming up and re-vendoring of data (I'm not sure whether it's theft or not) is at best undemocratic - even national boundaries didn't stand a chance at controlling this. Ironically it was probably a predictable outcome of an 'open' internet.
You and me both! I think though, it helps to separate out LLMs as a technology in themselves, and the prospect of increased technological dominance from a few small tech companies, as a result of that technology.
I'm a lot more enthusiastic about the first than the second, I suspect a lot or people are similar.
I think everyone needs to fight to keep standards around AI tooling open, even if proprietary models are inevitable given the investment they take. AGENTS.md is a good example. Every Claude integration (Github CI etc), every shared artifact your boss comes to rely on entrenches us further. I think where possible all AI outputs need to be persisted in your own systems
For example rather than have Claude create an artifact, have it create an HTML app / report in a repository you control. Make your own tools if you have to. I'm working on building a Formal Verification system for reviewing agent output into my notes / project management tool https://app.etherpk.com based on local markdown graphs for example.
It requires a LOT more effort, but all of my tooling is non-agentic and fully model independent. If necessary, I can swap it all out to local or private cloud services.
It results in a far more involved development process, which helps keep me in the loop but also has a big speed impact.
Not handing it all off to agents can trigger some FOMO. I'm not sure how long I can keep it up and still compete.
Hey totally agreed, having a system external to the LLM ecosystem already helps with being able to coordinate data between chats, different LLMs, etc, and it will likely be increasingly important as you say in maintaining control over your data in an age of increasingly more capable AI that tends towards keeping your data in formats that are platform biased by default like artifacts in Claude.
Also minor bit of feedback, on your webpage you use the term PKMS. I'm guessing it means Personal Knowledge Management System, but it could be helpful to define it in parentheses or explicitly.
Otherwise, the app looks interesting. I'm probably not the target segment as nowadays I'm building out a lot of my own custom systems that I find myself using day to day to have granular control of the system to make it super customized, but I could see it being interesting to people who currently use miro/obsidian/notion/etc.
> the prospect of increased technological dominance from a few small tech companies
Isn't it the goal of every player within a capitalistic game ? TBH I use to eat what bigFood teach me to at school, take the pills bigFarma lobbied my doctor with and consume whatever bigOil extracted. Sure, thinking is another field but it's not like we're not already sinking in energy, health and food distopia.
I'm pretty confident a carpenter's days are numbered too. Maybe if you're making some artisanal but for every day building it's only a matter of time before most things a carpenter could create and be build by robots or something. I expect in 5-20 years, robots will build houses and skyscrapers much faster than humans to do today.
But in this case, AI can serve good answers because it takes them from All About Berlin (and other sources). By killing All About Berlin, it kills the source. Where will the answers come from then?
From the archive that the big players had already build. Killing the source websites now doesn't change anything for them. This is also why I can only laugh about polititians who claim that their country should enter the ai race. There is no race. Openai et al have sucked up all the information available and have them stored privately years ago. The worlds reaction was to remove some of the source information from the net and at the same time flood it with ai slop. So the process can't be copied anymore, there is no way to build another openai, anthropic, meta or google ai.
> Killing the source websites now doesn't change anything for them.
Of course it does. It the info in their archive is not up to date, then the AI output is first less reliable, then outdated, finally entirely wrong. With policies, rules, laws, processes etc. changing all the time, that won't take long. Then users will have to ignore the AI summary again, and look for human-input posts on reddit and other pages, like this one. But, this page, and reddit, too, it seems, are seeing less and less visitors lowering the probability of them being kept up to date.
Businesses will feed companies their info (like they always have done with directories) to keep things up to date. But it will increasingly once again just turn into mass-media advertising where the businesses expose just what they want to expose, and human-curation-at-large-scale will probably go mostly extinct in favor of small-scale networks not big enough to pop up in the AI searches and answers.
I don't know, maybe it is still possible to compete. As AIs get better at validating facts, maybe we can undo some of the poison. Maybe. I'm not entirely sure how, I think it will be different for every field. Software is the easiest. Doesn't really matter how much misinformation is out there, programs can be written and tested. Law can probably be verified against official law books. Health would be nasty though. Hard to confirm stuff without human test subjects.
That only works if the facts are written down somewhere where machines can find it. A human must taste the banana bread and leave a review before an AI can recommend it.
I think the bigger question is will humans continue to put things online if they are not getting paid? So far we have seen that the answer is a resounding yes (You and I both left a comment on HN), but will AI be the thing that makes people hesitant going forward? Is humanity going to suddenly stop posting their thoughts online? I think that's a harder question to answer.
I think there's a very meaningful difference between relatively casual conversations like those here on HN (however much good information there is in them—and there's often quite a bit), and well-researched, structured information about specific topics put on dedicated websites.
Sure, I'll comment on HN for free in my spare time because I enjoy the interaction. But if you want me to spend 30 hours researching what the best 5 places are in Berlin to experience some specific aspect of local culture are (or, hell, even something much more specific to my own interests), then put that together into a coherent and well-presented webpage, I'm going to need some kind of much stronger motivation. Like being paid.
>I guess we do have a shortage of people walking around Berlin AND diligently maintaining and updating website about real-life experiences in the city.
We don't. However, people walking around Berlin, then writing about it to feed the AI scrapers is not how the future content is going to be created.
What's going to happen instead, is AI re-creating content from the same, stale sources and recycling the same content over and over and over again in slightly different forms embellishing it to make it appear as if it's new content, then heavily pushing it with social media algorithms, which, btw, are controlled by the same people who own the AI infrastructure (mostly).
This one's easy, the highest bidder. The example search query given by nicolas is "Best german bank account for foreigners". One of the banks will just pay Google to be the designated, erm, "sponsored", response.
The big problem here isn't that AI obsoletes a specific job, but that it will hit almost all jobs, starting with office jobs. I guess, super low pay manual labor in third-world countries will survive a bit longer, simply because a robot is more expensive than a human slave.
That's a huge shift of power away from ordinary people, and will cause a lot of problems for humanity as a whole.
Time will tell if such upheavals come to pass and this is more like the Industrial Revolution or the computer revolution. Neither were good for those affected.
But if people no longer have income and the AI promises come about in full, then who pays for the AI companies?
Maybe it's worthwhile to remember that money and paying for things arose from the necessity of trade. Different humans created different value and traded with each other to all benefit. To not have to trade goods, money came to be.
If your AI can give you the benefit without having to trade, you no longer need money. But even if your AI can do everything a human can, unless it can create something out of nothing, you still need land. Both to grow food and to extract resources. And you still need to defend your land.
> Maybe it's worthwhile to remember that money and paying for things arose from the necessity of trade.
Initially, yes. But that was in a situation where (broadly speaking) people had roughly equal levels of resources, and they developed money to have a consistent way to value those resources.
Here and now, the money the super-wealthy have now represents control of those resources. You and I don't have much to offer in that context.
And if (as CodesInChaos alludes to) we are positing a future where the super-wealthy controllers of AI also have sufficient robot-power to replace human manual labor, why would they not also have sufficient robot-power to kill anyone trying to take those resources back from them? Certainly, this is the calculation many of them are already making.
It is abundantly clear that if they are allowed to continue down this road, beyond a certain point the only way back will be by overwhelming force. And if they are able to continue farther, then beyond a certain point assembling that level of force that may no longer be practical even in the rosiest of scenarios.
Yeah I think this is key to why AI is seen as such a goldmine. Because the data it consumes is considered free. As soon as it has a price on it, the cost of AI instantly becomes astronomical and it's no longer a viable business.
But that's exploitative capitalism in general. Internalise the profits, externalise the damages to society. It was that way with environmental pollution and it's that way with AI. Governments aren't going to put a halt to it now. They're too afraid of 'losing the race' and the other guy is not going to play fair.
I agree that we should keep trying but its not a forgone conclusion that we can be successful. From what I'm seeing, most people either can't see the problems or don't want to deal with the cognitive dissonance that seeing tham would mean for their own AI use.
The broader issue of value capture by finance has been going on for a while now and there seems to be no sign of successful pushback.
What do you mean by "engage politically"? Who do I engage, and what exactly do I advocate for? Do I do it as a one time thing?
You phrase this as "absolutely" like it was this easy thing that people just need to realize it's within arms reach, but don't provide anything tangible to act on. In my opinion this is insurmountable task for a regular person.
It's like asking "How do I start a company". I can't possibly answer that in a single HN post. My recommendation to get started: find nearby communities or political parties and begin attending their events. Start small.
Pay who? HN doesn't pay me for this comment. SO didn't pay the people who answered questions there. Reddit AFAIK doesn't pay commenters, and so on. People have been having their 'work' monetized by others for ages and were willing to accept fake internet points for that work. It feels a bit late to suddenly now say it's a problem.
Personally, I think it would be healthy for society go backwards and stop using social media. I just don't see that happening because people love the affirmation of others.
>Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
I find this line of argument hilarious given how much time was spent arguing copyright infringement isn't stealing and "information wants to be free!" and intellectual property rights are corporate capture... when everyone wanted to pirate movies and games.
Sure came to bite these people back in the butt, didn't it.
I mean it's probably fair to make a distinction between someone sitting at home pirating a movie for their own enjoyment, and a huge company using it's already mear-absolute control over the internet ignoring copyright to further entrench itself as our digital overlord.
Thanks for saying that, it need to be said! The hypocracy is rampant. basically, "laws should only apply to those I dont like", which is hilariously childish.
Of course, the opinion society takes is the outcome of court cases. Not posts on messageboards. So let's evaluate what REALLY happened, shall we. And just skip the fantasies ... These are the actual positions that society took, which you imply are much more reasonable, and of course they are anything but reasonable:
(note: the "rights" the models would get from being considered natural persons, even from the same law, are denied to the models. For example, if any natural person, here including AI models, makes a work, it is now a crime for anyone else to claim authorship. So the obvious consequence of this decision, even just the one from the exact same law, that it is now a crime to claim AI produced work is your work, or to deny it was made by an AI, which would be a problem for billionaire companies, did not apply)
2) if it would mean billionaires getting money from authors, hundreds of millions of copyright violations are just forgiven, even illegal downloads. In fact congress itself violates the law making that OK: https://www.wiley.law/alert-Copyright-Office-Issues-Key-Guid...
(congress violated the law here by retroactively changing the law, because of course all the AI labs violated copyright law hundreds of millions of times (that's books only) before the law was changed. Congress cannot retroactively make that OK)
Note (Capitol Records v. Thomas-Rasset) when a kid violates copyrights "owned" by a billionnaire, the punishment goes up to $222,323 per instance, as well as imprisonment PER INSTANCE. That was the punishment for for "the nappster mom" (she was a single mom caring for 3 kids). The exact same punishment, what most people would call "justice", applied to AI models, would have bankrupted, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Meta, Microsoft, all of them, and put their CEOs in jail for the rest of their life. Because of the sheer amount of copyright violations they committed. Hundreds of millions times even a small amount of jail time, is still tens of thousands of years.
2addendum) if any other country doesn't agree with point 2, the US government will threaten them militarily AND the EU commission will threaten them economically. (A German court decided the opposite, and ...)
3) if it means billionaires want to keep "their" works out of online library lending, courts have judged that they get to do that EVEN IF THE LICENSE ALLOWED IT and IT OTHERWISE WOULD BE FAIR USE. It was judged fair use is NOT allowed if, after the fact, billionaire copyright owners decide it might harm their economic interests.
That's right courts have judged that using billionaires' copyright under fair use is NOT legal if billionaires complain it would harm their financial interests, regardless of whether it actually would harm their interests.
4) The piratebay trial: Merely pointing people at copyrighted material, listing what is in a particular copyrighted work along with a way to get it without a license, got 2 years jail time and 6.4 million in damages.
Needless to say, AI companies both did that, and are still doing that, all the time.
5) Spain's telco got sued by the owner of soccer rights to turn of most of the internet, to prevent people from sending "copies" of the live soccer match (never mind that the copyright on livestreams isn't actually fully ironed out, for instance can you make short <5s clips of what happens without a license, as news companies have done since that became possible in the 1930s?). The courts ordered the shutdown. EVERYONE was punished preventively, on order of the state, because they MIGHT have otherwise have violated copyright. I would point out that this violates human rights (specifically the prohibition on states doing collective punishment), in addition to 1000 other laws, from competition law to telecom safety laws, but what do laws or human rights matter, even in a western democracy, when billionaires' money is at stake?
In fact it isn't even 100% established that it isn't legal to do (ie. if you monitor the stream and just send out short clips of goals, for example, that may or may not fall under fair use laws). So they preventively violated human right to enforce a law that isn't even what lawyers call "fully understood" yet.
TLDR: punishment for a single copyright violation for a single mom caring, alone, for 3 kids: $222,323 plus jail time PER INSTANCE (ie. she had to pay that for a couple dozen violations, and the jail time was "waived", rumor is it was waived only after the police chief protested and made clear to the judge they were never going to enforce the jail time against her)
Punishment for hundreds of millions of exactly the same violation for a billionaire: ZERO.
I can go on and on and on with such judgements. Because of the "nappster wars" there's literally tens of thousands such decisions. With very few exceptions, always against the smaller guy, with absurd excuses and ridiculous interpretations of the law to keep the money flowing to the billionaire companies. Again, and again, and again, and again. Well, until AI billionaires started getting sued, THEN it suddenly changed. Of course, you still can't illegally download and especially can't make money of Snow White, despite Scam "you shouldn't be allowed to get computer RAM" Allman and Dario "all jobs should pay me instead" Amodei, oh And Zuckerberg and Page and Gates are doing that every single day now.
Can I just ask the question: how do you get courts to judge like this? Because when it comes to billion dollar company ideas ... if I can commit hundreds of millions of crimes to make these companies, I easily have 10 diffirent billion dollar company ideas. And of course Scam Allman, Dario Amodei, and Google and Facebook, and Microsoft just risked that. They committed more than enough copyright crimes that a court could bankrupt them (and if the prison terms doled out against 9 year olds were applied to them ...)
How do I know which company I can just risk committing hundreds of millions of crimes to create? How do I get reassurance from courts, so that I can get investors to support committing crimes like they did?
When it comes to copyright crimes, what about making a Netflix, the one everybody wants, with AI versions that are near duplicates of existing works. Of EVERY existing work. From Casablanca to Snowwhite (after all both are public domain stories, so just change them slightly, and make a movie in the same style). You know, do the ridiculous version of movie X (have snow white be a 200kg black dude, for example, otherwise same style, same movie). That's a billion dollar idea. But of course, as soon as courts find Disney (who are a billionaire) suing someone like me, they will find some stupid law to misinterpret, some absurd excuse, to side with Disney. So how do I prevent that, and more importantly how do I know NOW that they'll do that for me, so I can get some investment?
I mean, all I'm asking is for courts to stand behind the "pro-AI" (but obviously really pro-billionaire) absurd judgements they've made before, to make it clear beforehand so I can get investment for that ... that's all.
Oh: in case it's not obvious, I'm not a billionaire.
And as for your claim: I think the positions of "nerds", "information wants to be free" is both the EXACT same thing billionaires did. Nerds wanted to use others' copyrighted works, for free. Nerds were heavily punished, ARE STILL heavily punished, even the ones that did nothing (violating even human rights), billionaires were completely allowed to do the same. Oh, and Chinese companies were allowed the same too (of course Amodei sees NO problem in complaining that, oh no, Chinese models are copying his work ...
Knowing that even a tiny punishment would mean those companies are now bankrupt, and their CEOs in jail for life, because they so incredibly egregiously violated copyright on a totally unseen scale AND committed the worst possible copyright offense: making money of copyright violations, and we charge and try to lock up single moms millions of dollars for doing literally 10 million times less serious violations, I would LOVE for someone to explain why these companies got off and these people are out of jail. Explain justice to me, please.
If your work wasn't publicly available on the internet, that could not have happened. Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money
Feel? What do feeling have to do with it? It is a service being offered. Relatively fast T/s without having to own the hardware and pay for the cooling. How good the deal is is another question. But feeling? Have people grown so used to free services that we're talking feeling when it comes to paying a provider now?
The way I see it LLMs scrape websites (not prohibited by copryright or any other law) and are setup to regurgitate knowledge, not verbatim extracts.
Let's put aside for a momemt the reliability of this and potential hallucinations.
a way it is the same as writing a wikipedia article getting knowledge first from various publications, most of them being protected under copyright. The main difference being wikipedia encouraging sourcing while LLMs do not always cite sources but that isn't a requirement under any law anyway.
No theft or copyright infringement has been commited in the process.
Do we need new laws or taxes to retribute people who produce content being scraped and encourage people for providing knowkedge? Maybe.
I don't have a solution either, and as I said in another reply I'm not arguing law, just ethics. But in my opinion they did steal.
Had creators known years ago that some company will take your content and sell it at a premium they would (probably) not have shared as much publicly for free. Another comment nicely said the social contract is broken, I agree.
And about Wikipedia, they don't charge for their service, it's a free encyclopedia that also requires attributions (maybe it's not enforced in all cases? but it is a requirement AFAIK).
EDIT: I don't know how much the "free" matters here though, am I mad when open source models give me code that's trained on open source code, not sure. I guess for me the key word here would be consent.
> Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
Because 3 years ago, everyone had a reasonable expectation that any publicly available work would be appropriately credited and/or compensated for, in accordance with both copyright law and open source software licenses.
You realize that even very permissive software licenses, like MIT or Apache-2.0, still require attribution? Now a few companies are making big bucks selling your ideas (and sometimes verbatim code) without adhering to the terms of that license.
The social contract is utterly broken. The legal situation is utterly questionable. The only reason they get away with it is that the inmates are in charge of the asylum in the US.
I'm European. Describing the Republican Party as "a party [I] don't like" is unbelievably out of touch. The entire world outside of the US sees and says plainly what's happening. And yeah, seen from the outside, the US justice system sure does seem broken in a number of ways.
My feelings are all over place about AI. I think the technology is amazing (in the right hands). In terms of it's capabilities.
If we are talking about application, ethical concerns then I think it fucking sucks.
The way I see it. This is the inevitable end goal of social media. The way social media grants instant gratification is the same way LLM's do just on a much larger scale. To me both of these things are connected.
We've been exploited by tech companies using fast feedback and this to me is another level of that.
What are you trying to do ?
To start a Butlerian jihad ?
We cannot just roll back AI, internet, computers. So just enjoy the view, we are for quite a ride.
Humans are inherently selfish and ultimately behave in their own personal interest.
Give them a tool that does their job for them so they can kick their feet up for the rest of the day, and they will use it. Even worse, those who take the "moral" stance and refuse to use it, get lapped by their competitors, er, coworkers who are.
AI is out of the box, and it's a prisoners dilemma. So right now you can either take for yourself, or trust that the masses won't do it.
Getting this new technology into the hands of citizens rather than a handful of companies, for example through local AI when that gets more affordable, is the way forward I think. Until then its just about learning how to use it effectively.
But at the same time it hurts me more and more thinking about the massive data collection the AI providers have at this point. People are completely unaware of the gold in form of data we are sharing to these companies. And its what keeps their wheel spinning.
As I'm from the 3rd world, open source was revolutionary in allowing me to learn. Now that incredible and noble effort is being hoovered up to make billions for people who didn't create it.
I have a deep feeling that it’ll never be for our good.
The strategy is “get them addicted first”, then “remove human thinking and understanding” (junior don’t learn like we did in 2000-2010) then they’ll do whatever they want.
They will provide the cloud and the code and the voice for anything software related, eating up everything that is in the middle.
We can’t escape it. They are too powerful and because there is positive side effects as well, and they know it, there will always be a debate.
I feel that, the common mindset in software that you rarely see elsewhere, like in big pharma, is to open and give knowledge very broadly.
But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well. That’s only fair, but that’s just one way to see it.
> But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well.
It's really a tale as old as, well, western liberal democracy I suppose! We had a commons, then the commons were fenced in, and finally we were charged rent to access the thing we built, cultivated, sustained.
The digital era makes for some interesting new ways to fight back. Distilling models into open weights is one, liberating software through reverse engineering is another.
This literally happened btw, it's not just an analogy. There were commons, areas of land everyone could use. Then people came along and built fences around the commons and said this land is mine now, pay me to use it, and everyone just accepted this because they didn't have another choice, that's how we got landlords. Literally. Not metaphorically. Look up the Inclosure Acts.
Something almost nobody has been told is this, and that almost every country also used to have internal colonization programs where the government gave free land and lots to citizens. Suggest that to anybody nowadays, and they would try to put you in jail.
> I have a deep feeling that it’ll never be for our good. The strategy is “get them addicted first”
I mean, it's not even a long term "capitalist leaders" like you describe.
These companies have figured how to be at the edge, and how to stay at the edge a bit ahead of the others. What they have not figured out yet, is how to make a positive amount of money at the end of the quarter.
So, yes you now have the "we should impose a moratorium" (so we can stop paying so much to progress without risk of being overtaken), "we should stop open models or chinese models" (because if people realize deepseek flash can do 99% of their actual AI need how can we charge them triple), ...
But also, we're about to face the biggest rugpull ever, the MOMENT they think they have the conditions in place. Hell, they've has already tried several time, exclude the top model, make it way way more expensive, etc ...
I think that value moved and we're feeling this pain because we're chasing ghosts: working on the after-image of where value used to be is a lost cause and we all feel it in fear of our own jobs.
In my expectation, governments who embrace AI and regulate on misuse rather than on protecting old structures will unlock access to the new value chains earlier on and get first-mover advantage. I hope Europe sees this instead of regulating us into pre-AI protectioninsm in an AI world.
There are so many opportunities to make the world better in line with the right-to-repair movement and their open data incentives. They were on the right track, I just hope they don't fall for the old money corruption, because that will cost way more to lower class people along the way than AI on its own ever would.
AI and old-money protectionism are likely going exactly the same place: access to more things for old-money, reduced opportunities to carve out new things for those without. Just copy the new faster and cheaper than ever. Embrace-extend-extinguish at a class-level.
So many of the things that can be automated away don't really have higher-level value chains to move to. The value was other people reducing friction for you or presenting you with novelty. The AI-maximalist/old-money goals here are identical: avoid having to pay a person for that.
The core underlying assumption in both POVs—whether "shape rotators" or "old money elites"—is that everything boils down to manipulating abstractions. The world, to these groups, isn't about people living satisfying individual lives. It's about making things as convenient for themselves as possible, not about doing concrete things in the real world for people as a whole. They are (intentionally) replacing the territory with the map.
There was a funny neoliberal concept in the late 20th century that everyone was going to transition to an information economy. That China and Brazil and Sub-Saharan Africa were just behind the curve, and if they learned to code they could also have an American standard of living.
It's obviously bullshit, because the American standard of living is based on extraction and exploitation elsewhere. If you make everyone rich, there's no gradient to exploit. If everyone everywhere does office jobs, who will work in the mines?
The AI trend is the pigeons coming home to roost. Oligarchs have extracted value from overseas, but now they also need to extract value from the underclass at home more aggressively than ever. The number has to go up.
Because people’s expectations go up. If people want cutting edge technology and medicine and old age benefits and defense against other societies, then there has to be some incentive to do the work to R&D it.
Unfortunately it's not only EU / governments but also other organizations e.g. open source funds who hold rigid anti-AI stances.
We need to adapt to what has been willed real neither by over-correcting nor through ignorance.
I'm sure there is a somewhat European middle-ground for all of this. It would have been great to have more powerful Chinese models to bootstrap it though. I guess challenge accepted?
> I just hope they don't fall for the old money corruption, because that will cost way more to lower class people along the way than AI on its own ever would.
I dont know what you mean here. AI is pushed by some of the most corrupt people on the planet. They are not "old money" either, they are new tech CEO, entirely comfortable with both corruption and tech feudal fascism.
And the last thing they care about are "lower class" people. They are in the process of getting as much power for themselves as possible and of pushing as many people as possible into lower class.
I actually think the only way to stop society collapsing is to have very strong AI safeguards and labor regulations. Its simply too powerful and disruptive to be allowed to run wild.
AI doesn't have to replace people, and it doesn't have to dumb us down. We need to do some economic re-modelling, otherwise capitalism will crumble and society will with it. I just don't see any other way, but I'm also terrified we will enter some dystopian Sam Altman Worldcoin reality where everyone has to scan their iris' to cryptographically sign anything uploaded onto the internet.
Either way, we have to get the balance right which will be very difficult... The alternative is terrifying.
> we're feeling this pain because we're chasing ghosts
I think you yourself are an example of this. The ideas that all regulation is harmful and that plucky upstart tech firms will save us were overly optimistic years ago, and now we know they aren't correct.
The danger is not old money corruption and protectionism; it's the new money robber barons of the tech industry.
In this world more than one thing can be a danger at the same time.
Old money wants to keep you paying rent forever.
New money wants to keep you paying rent forever.
The hard part is keeping money out of the regulations itself as to make a prison. No regulation, as you say, is just as bad as it allows the powerful to use it's money just as much.
A government is supposed to represent its people. There is quite a wave of AI criticism, so governments should apply incentives to the good results and oppose/mitigate the bad results.
The problem is when governments are in bed with the big corps and stop representing their people.
The governments are freaking out about being left behind. The narrative is that this is the new industrial revolution and nobody wants to be caught with their pants down using horses and muskets when every other major power has moved on to heavy industry and tanks and machine guns.
The super rich can achieve regulatory capture at a faster rate then the people can fix it. That's the real problem here. That's why we have so much consolidation in spite of anti-trust rules. That's why many industries can 'regulate' themselves. How do you think we got such absolutely nonsense copyright durations? It's not because that's what the people wanted.
The people can, on increasingly rare occasions, make such a stink that they get something they wanted and the super rich have to make a concession. For a while at least, but then it always moves back.
I predict any new AI laws that come out of government (regardless of party in power) will have a spin about being good for people, but under the hood will be designed very carefully to further entrench the power of the existing players.
You're providing information. There is a more efficient way to get this information and your website doesn't provide enough value to continue make you enough to pay your bills. Why are you allowed to gatekeep this information and domain indefinitely?
I wonder why we don't see other sob stories about businesses that go under every day.
I'm awaiting the blog post about Dominique Ansel Bakery that invented the Cronut, lamenting it's decline in sales due to other people selling Cronuts. Or all the casualties of the chicken sandwich wars.
Why do developers feel so entitled to have their work be able to fund their lifestyle indefinitely?
I personally don't care about any one website, I want to get information. This is obvious when you consider something like recipe websites that have long abused their users with long personal stories to just get a recipe and sleazy SSO abuses. Now I ask AI. We're all better for it.
If you want to add value and provide a better experience, do so. You still have your website. Get people to like your website enough that they bookmark it. But if you're providing simple info and just making users click into your website, you're not gonna make it.
The problem is that the information gets stale, and nobody will have an incentive anymore to write down more up-to-date information. Then, the models will provide inaccurate information. We may be living through the glory age of AI right now if that happens.
Its the forever problem of AI - its like a one time reaping of high quality data and then information goes stale because few people will provide information for free, fewer people will be motivated to build any content online, most things will get protected and locked down, open source is saturated with agents.
This is 100% the "glory" days of AI. The price is highly subsidized by investors, govt but thats going to ramp up and the product quality will dilute as they need to drive revenue for the markets. Its the same long lived strategy of every great tech company that has VC returns to feed. If OpenAI can stay private for a longer period of time they could ostensibly continue to build a better product and not be handcuffed to wallstreet in the near term.
Cost of AI will get subsidized for 3-4 years while corporate america gets addicted, then pricing will ramp up and corporate ameria will be dependent. This has been said millions of times over.
The same was said about Uber and Lyft in other words that once Venture Capital subsidies ended the prices would be passed on to consumers. While it's true on inflation adjusted basis is not that extreme from its low point maybe 30% higher.
And with Rideshare you have a fundamental cost of a car and a person whereas with AI costs can quickly be reduced across multiple dimensions of optimizations Hardware stack architecture region energy costs latency and other trade-offs. Then you have open models competing to bring costs down. So I just don't know that we'll ever see the cost go up
Rideshare is interesting because uber et al might actually be cheaper per ride than waymo et al. Yes, they pay a driver a very low wage which is some overhead, but they don't own any cars. The driver pays for the car, its maintenance, registration and insurance, fueling, and storage. It is dubious if it even pencils out for anyone but the power users in the gig economy. Waymo has massive overhead with its fleet requirements, on the other hand, real estate requirements as well.
AI could be similar. The costs of the bleeding edge are probably enormous. But imagine if your competitor was some cheap model, with a layer of southeast asians between the user and the model getting the apparent quality of the model far higher leveraging some cheap expert human prompters. There's some odds there that they might route you at the bleeding edge. Plus also, plenty of users probably aren't even that sensitive to a low quality vs high quality response for their purposes.
I think using AI in 10 years will feel like using StackOverflow today. SO is kind of stuck in time, where every answer there is how you’d do things in 2015. They structurally can’t seem to let go of old answers and ingest new information, so they are dying in the past.
The same might happen to AI if it stops having access to fresh information. If people move to walled gardens that can’t be consumed by AI then there is a chance that these products eventually get stuck in the past, too. I don’t know what would be a walled enough garden for this, but it might happen.
The problem is that the losers here are usually sites riddled with ads and low-quality writing to begin with - festooned with promotional links to 'recommended products' and tracking cookies.
This site is a perfect example of why you’re wrong. It's a small human-written site created by someone about an interest of theirs - their home town. It is the antithesis of 'sites riddled with ads and low-quality writing... festooned with tracking cookies'.
The scammy sites, which you describe as losers (and equate this site with), will not in fact lose in this new world, they'll just adapt and start serving ads inside your AI chats (already available!). Yes google let search deteriorate (I haven't used Google in years), but are you happy with the open web being shut down and replaced by AI chatbots? Is that really the future you would like? Do you think AI answers are going to remain free forever? The same enshitiffication seems inevitable.
Small sites like this which provided local information with a human voice will simply cease, as nobody will visit them anymore. It was difficult to justify before, but there really is zero incentive to feed human 'content' to Google now.
The inconvenient truth is that the number of technologists asking these types of questions is on the rise because they feel threatened and are being harmed. A minority of them asked these types of questions when software was eating the world and other workers were losing their jobs.
There was a lot of arrogance. "Learn to code". "Things change". "Adapt".
So what are you telling software engineers who are being laid off, and those who fear that they might lose their jobs or see their wages decrease?
Many of them are complaining about the fact that AI labs aren't playing fair ("stealing" content and code for training) and cutting costs to the potential detriment of service quality and security, but they didn't express the same level of concern about tech companies that "asked for forgiveness, not permission" when they exploited legal gray areas to build their businesses (the Ubers and Airbnbs of the world), used massive amounts of venture capital to engage in predatory business practices designed to undercut and drive out established companies, etc.
I’m not telling them anything, there’s a reason why I said “would” rather than “did” on my previous post.
Also, there are businesses other than the ones you mention that would not be properly characterized by software-first. They don’t pay as much but you can make a pretty good living off them.
> Also, there are businesses other than the ones you mention that would not be properly characterized by software-first. They don’t pay as much but you can make a pretty good living off them.
Many of those businesses exist (or initially did, at least) to put people out of work. Software exists for efficiency, and much of those efficiency gains went into putting masses of people out of work. Both directly and indirectly.
There are some exceptions of course. Gaming companies come immediately to mind. But most "boring" IT work is there to make business processes more efficient, which almost always means either directly firing people or working to automate systems and processes as to not have to hire more.
IT professionals are simply the engineers and mechanics of the industrial age, creating and servicing machines that eliminate or greatly reduce vast swaths of industry.
This might be true in some (if not most) cases, but it is also very reductive. Many industries can actually create good jobs for qualified workers, especially those with a big R&D component.
Capitalism, but now the dagger has been pointed towards white collar.
I really wonder what the marketing of Anthropic is doing and how they were not fired after the first “AI will take your job, and youre gonna be fucked!” claims to pump AI.
Any insider know how they can simultaneously make sweeping claims about the future of society and unbelievably tonedeath about actual society?
What I meant is that the negative externalities of capitalism now affect white collar workers. Usually, those at the bottom of the pyramid get most fucked.
Months? I feel like it's been years. The weekly news cycle moves at such an insane pace. I'd love to say you can just ignore it but you can't anymore with how expensive everything is getting and how job security feels like an all time low. The only solice I have is that throughout history these cycles repeat and tend to correct themselves and the periods after the corrections tend do be the greatest times. But that doesn't make it any better living in the build up to a correction.
There is defiantly concerted action taking place to shift public perception and social norms about this. Change the rules before the average person even realizes what they are losing. That being said, the people who study the intersection of technology and society have been talking about this exact thing for 20 years.
In five years everything will be bland and boring, people will start to ask about unique things and just get redirected to <ad paying company> instead.
It will speed up the death of content on the open internet, it didn’t start with AI, it’s just being massively accelerated by it.
Most people will be dumber and more easily tricked and controlled, others will start to distrust everything.
Everything will be worse, except for the stockholders of the gatekeepers (and their owners).
And before anyone asks, I’m using AI heavily every day.
I don't like hearing that AI is bringing you and the article's author hardship. But I think it's more complicated than tech companies taking away work through greed. Technological progress is the culprit here and this time you're the victim, unfortunately.
That site's business model is similar to the many paper magazines you'd get for free in tourist welcome centers, hotels and on the street. Companies (usually very small) who published those guides got replaced by the website. Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago.
A family member used to own a magazine about arts and crafts that went bankrupt because of Youtube creators and free Internet articles - well before AI. It was a small magazine and profits were just enough to maintain a middle-class lifestyle. Random people online, relying on technology, destroyed his livelihood and he has been struggling ever since.
You can try using laws and spreading the word against progress, but it's certain you'll lose in the end. I'm not saying it's not worth it because you may delay it long enough to give you time to settle elsewhere, but change will come against our will.
A multi national stealing data from a solo dev and presenting it as their own?
For decades people fought against the media industry with some really good arguments about how music/film/software piracy doesn't deprive the original owner of their material so it's 'copyright infringement' and absolutely not theft. Now the same people will happily argue that since it's their work being copied and used, and they're losing out on the rewards and their jobs are at risk, now it's a heinous act of theft.
It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
Copyright infringement is not theft, and copying some software to use for other purposes (e.g training AI) is very specifically allowed under some open licenses.
(I appreciate that this is a semantic argument that doesn't really matter very much.)
I think people believe that the law should protect the powerless against the powerful. Good examples of this are the common pro-patent arguments about the solitary inventor and the common pro-copyright arguments about the solitary author. These arguments are usually fielded by large corporations!
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak. It's already dystopian and it's likely to get tremendously worse once they have become indispensable - they are not yet, at least outside of the SV bubble.
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak.
That's a fair argument while things remain stable but it falls down if things change.
AI companies have only really become powerful in the last few years, and they were taking the content a decade ago. The argument would only work if we either apply it retrospectively ("you took the content when you were weak, but now you're powerful so it's bad") or if we stopped anyone taking the content if they have the potential to become powerful ("you might invent AI in 10 years, so no content for you.") I don't see how that would work.
I don't see any problem with your first option. If you take something and then get powerful off it, you have to stop and give it back so you're no longer powerful. The relevant issue is not the taking or using of things, but the increase in power itself. Most entities that are currently powerful should be made un-powerful. That would be a good thing.
Copyright infringement is treated like theft in every part of the world. I am not sure where did you get it isn't. Try copying anything from any business and you will be sued to death and loose. Big business requires and loves copyright.
The only reasons LLMs are allowed is because big business thinks they will be able to get rid of much of their labour force AND because LLMs make it really hard to figure out whos copyright you are breaking so you can trick people who don't understand how LLMs work.
So we are effectively in middle where copyright is more and more only for big companies and individual work is not gonna be protected.
Fine lets go all the way and kill copyright. Of course that won't happen.
> It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
It's interesting that we as workers apparently have to act inside the bounds of the law AND inside the bounds of our preferred legal structure (even though this was never turned into a law), while the rich and powerful are bound by neither.
If Anthropic could legally steal from AAB but AAB could also legally steal music from Sony, there would probably be less outrage. But what's actually happening, is that rules are consistently applied to prevent poorer people forcibly taking value from richer people, and consistently not applied to prevent richer people forcibly taking value from poorer people. In the past, revolutions happened over this kind of greedy hypocrisy.
what happens when all of these websites with useful up to date information become abandoned? Maybe we'll all be hanging out in town squares talking to each other face to face and having fun throwing stones at the Anthropic drones trying to record new content.
I think we use the wrong term here - it's not progress, because progress in my mind means that we are working towards a goal and that goal gets closer. And I think humanity, or the universe for that matter don't have a well defined goal. Change however IS inevitable and these technologies represent change. There are always winners and losers when something's changing. As Max Tegmark puts it, this is the work of Moloch - everyone knows it's bad on a certain level, yet everyone has to play along, or their losses will be even greater.
Of course change is inevitable, but the specific changes aren't. This is just how immoral people justify themselves; someone was gonna do it so it might as well be me!
Of course there is a goal we're all working towards, and that goal is efficiency. For some reason or the other we collectively made striving for efficiency our ultimate end goal, and that's what 'progress' actually means. From this perspective replacing all human labor with AI actually 'makes sense'.
Efficiency is survival. The country with the industrial revolution dominated several countries without industrial revolution in asia and africa. You must also avoid paying normal prices for medicine as it won't exist at all or at that price point without tools of efficiency like electric motors, generation, high throughput screening etc. likewise with every other tech.
Efficiency is one aspect of it. What we see is, one factor being made as the ultimate goal, pushing the human condition out of balance. The example of industrial revolution is great, as it resulted in the same out of control greed as we have today.
Its very easy, african culture or asian culture couldn't save them from Britain. So clearly their type of community didn't survive well against the British type of community. Would you rather have been a colonised asian/african or a brit if you had to live back then?
Community is good and bad. You live in a low karen culture, cherish it, you won't like a high karen culture.
No amount of community can save you from various conditions and injuries, if you don't have hospitals and medicines and the things that are required to have them for example. Clealry the capitalist community, or even the soviet community managed to survive better and able to take care of more of their people.
This gets repeated like a mantra, along with “survival of the fittest”, when we want sciencey-soudning justification for our bad impulses. No, efficiency is not survival, and natural process do not optimise for efficiency. They optimise for good enough.
Even human systems do not optimise for efficiency. Disproportionate wealth concentration and monopolies is not an efficient economic system in the abstract. It is efficient at wealth extraction. So, when we want to wax lyrical about efficiency, we should at least be honest: we’re saying that greed is good.
It has nothing to do with science, it is simply common sense and observed reality. Natural processes are irrelevant when you will be steamrolled by a country or group that doesn't have neuroses about technology. Natural processes didn't have much to do with why Britain ruled most of the world.
I'm not sure those analogies work. The problem OP has is that his value is being effectively 'stolen' and 'resold' by google itself. If he stops keeping his page up to date (which seems to be a likely outcome), then where will google AI take the knowledge from?
My family member doesn't care about who took his business. Google and technology enabled someone else to steal his livelihood for a cut. To his children, who's getting the money now is inconsequential.
YouTube isn't a charity for creators. It's one of the biggest businesses in the world that takes enormous profits. While you can argue that certain large business models are better for society than others, it's still tech "destroying jobs".
Also, something gets lost in the transition. The magazines articles were in-depth and the photos were professionally taken. All these people lost their jobs to "You won't believe what I made for $5" and general SEO.
You completely missed the core question: "then where will google AI take the knowledge from?"
Your analogies / examples do not cover this.
The core concern is that you are punished for creating useful information and putting it on the internet. Because if you do, it will be stolen by way of excessive AI traffic that makes you no money, while simultaneously suppressing human traffic that does.
So unless you are doing it entirely out of the goodness of your heart, and are also willing to effectively pay for Google and other AI overlords using your bandwidth, this information will disappear.
This is bad for everyone, but a confident AI will just slap together some random half truth from official sources that are required to be there, and that will be the new quality ceiling of information on the internet.
I would guess that from less formal, non-profit sources.
Having a page whose business model is talking about Berlin or restaurants might go away, but talking about Berlin or restaurants will not.
Think HN, we have plenty interesting discussions here out of the "goodness of our hearts", and I for one don't expect to profit from any contribution I might make when I post here.
HN is useless to find specific information when you need it. Redit used to be quite good at that, but the quality was very uneven. And of course, now it’s mostly gone. Now, the easiest way to find information is YouTube, with its whole set of issues.
What these changes are doing is killing the middle ground between purely hobbyist blogs and large companies websites. Blogs will remain because they were not making much money in the first place. Major newspaper will remain because they will find a way between subscriptions, sponsoring, and advertising. Everything in between is being overgrown by slop factories (this predates AI, but it is now completely unbearable) in a race to the bottom as they are displaced by Google’s AI (as if the bar was high in the first place). We are all losing.
That's Google's problem, really. I didn't address it because I don't find it very interesting.
There was a world before free information on the Internet, you know? Aside from the personal hardship of the site's owner, I won't shed tears for the ad-supported Internet. Not a droplet.
The only kind of truly free information ever available on the web was from small self-motivated authors and that will remain. They don't feel "punished" if others, including AI, reads it. I have stuff online and I don't care if AI uses it.
If Google needs information for its AI, it better start paying for it. And perhaps a world of paid information providers will emerge.
If not, I'll be happy to keep the web hobbyists, forums like this one and paper books. Isn't that the old Internet we miss?
No such thing as theft of public data. Especially when the output is impossible to match to a given input.
the "Theft" argument is just a bunch of people who'd otherwise hate copyright laws seething that they didn't get money from info that people'd otherwise never pay for.
it will trivially aggregate it from other sources. I'm sorry about the all about berlin author, but it's essentially a website aggregating information that's readily available from a mixture of official government resources and private user discussions that are publically available.
this is not to detract from the overall problem. some people have provided value which is replaced by AI which can not be automatically replicated in their absence, yet the impact of AI on their finances might make it unfeasible for them to continue doing that work.
purely from a systemic point of view, it shouldnt matter though. if all about berlin cant operate on 1/4th the traffic, maybe someone else will (perhaps, using AI) create an equivalent service for 4 different subjects that each have 1/4th of the traffic and be profitable that way. if such a thing cant be profitable, society has deemed that it has no value in the first place.
this is a different argument from AIs effects on individuals of course.
> it will trivially aggregate it from other sources.
Hahahaha no.
A website like All About Berlin is compiling a lot of information that simply doesn't exist in any structured way online. (Alongside some that does, of course.)
By its very nature, the Google AI Overview is eating its seed corn. It should not exist, and should never have been allowed to exist.
When I say "any structured way", I mean things like even mentioning that the thing you saw is in Berlin.
If you lose sites like All About Berlin, then there's a very, very high chance that any given piece of information about it existing online doesn't have enough context and metadata around it to even recognize and compile it. If it's even on a publicly-available site, and not on a private forum somewhere behind a login wall.
AI isn't omniscient or magic. It can distill structure that's very dilute, but it's much, much harder for it to bring together information that genuinely doesn't have that structure in the first place and add it in.
I think there's a crucial difference between your example of the print magazine getting replaced by Youtube, vs what's happening now.
When the internet displaced print media, that was done by individual creative people, not a large corporation (at least initially, today's YouTube is a different place). The person who used to write articles for a print magazine could learn the new skillset associated with online publishing, and apply their old skills and pivot to the new normal. It wasn't easy, but it was possible to survive.
But now, what options do we have? I'm not about to buy a data centre...
Did the website steal and remix the content from the magazine? Did the YouTube creators do so as well? Probably not.
This is just not the same, but I agree that (unfortunately) it cannot be stopped and the big players will never be held accountable.
Sorry to ask you this, but have you read the article or just the headline? Nobody is talking about tech progress, but stealing and killing creative work. Author is not complaining about losing their comfortable income stream, but they are sad because they won't be able to support their work from ads and will need to find something else to do.
This summary widget could have been done before the current "AI" tech, no progress there. Why google does it, is a good question. What is your take if you are not focusing on the word "progress" but think a bit more broadly about google landing page and its layout and contents.
This is a classic. It’s not businesses and their business models; it’s the Invisible and Inevitable Hand of Progress. You may fight the businesses, but the “progess” is inevitable.
It’s so inevitable that Capital is pricing out personal computers and every IT-adjacent business is stuffing AI into their offerings in order to KPI-max to their managers. The top-down inevitability.
The OP claims:
> It will get worse. Last week, Google has made two announcements: AI-generated answers will replace search results entirely, and they have ads in them.
Yet more inevitability: Google will replace search results, that’s that. This is just progress.
On the other hand, people might like to get direct search results and be able to connect a person to their recommendations. It is possible. But it won’t, apparently, even be an option with Google soon enough. Because how to guerilla ads into other people’s websites? Much easier to guerilla them into AI “content”.
Also: Kagi (which has a good reputation here it seems) is a good search engine. How? By using Google’s services without the enshittification. More progress: the profit-maxing Google search engine is worse for the user, on purpose.
And all of this for what? No more original sources, no more authorship, no more talking to other people? This is progress?
> This is a classic. It’s not businesses and their business models; it’s the Invisible and Inevitable Hand of Progress. You may fight the businesses, but the “progess” is inevitable.
As someone once said: there is no alternative.
(Except that, of course, there are alternatives, they just really want you to shut up and stop trying to improve things for normal people).
It’s actually not. Tech progress is not happening in a vacuum. It’s accompanied by unprecedented inequity, corruption, monopolistic mega corporations, etc. Remove (or reduce) the cancer feeding on the technology progress and you may find it beneficial to us all.
The website in question is not the originator of any information. It is a collection and a summarization of bureaucratic rules and laws. The man behind the website does not own the information he has re-published there.
The difference here is that the replacement is outright worse than the original thing its replacing. I never ever use AI for things that a search engine could do because its wasteful and inefficient and often not right. I know I'm an outlier here and one day it will inevitably be AI but urgh. I wish it wasn't so.
I find myself not even trying normal web search anymore because the quality is so bad. LLMs often search the web AND aggregate/digest/interpret the results for me, so I get a filtered result that actually (more or less) matches what I asked for.
This results in fewer clicks for some pages, and for clicks to pages I would have never found otherwise.
Without Google or anyone distributing it for free, may be the person would have smaller revenue but might have built a search engine to promote their site too that becomes wildly popular and he might have become the next billionaire, who knows!
Let's not go with wild speculation that have "your are a small fish and nothing without us" connotations.
To be really honest I question the business sense of people putting information for free anywhere and then act surprised when it gets vacuumed up. I don't like it at all and I'd rather live in a romantic village where we all share freely and frolick in the meadows. I really, really do, but wishing for that doesn't make it so.
It is not exactly brain drain but I think it has similar effect minus the benefits to the person relocating.
Instead of attracting/relocating the talent, now their knowledge is copied and it benefits the entity copying (again overwhelmingly from one region) but no payments so the source that spent the resources doesn't even benefit in the form of few remittances. Atleast the recent post about Japanese hometown tax was one solution for the brain drain problem within a country.
Yes the knowledge resource is still there but due to the search monopoly, os monopoly, mobile duopoly and other reasons it is hard to compete for visibility or free packaging of the same.
I don't know what it is, but it feels like some implied social and/or political contract has been broken.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Isn't most work built on top of existing work? Regarding the example in the article, do you think OP opened an account at every German bank to compare them, or also relied on information from other people?
These companies (or rather their-suite) are pathological liars.
They keep reassuring us that alignment is a very important topic. Attribution and citation were the canaries in the coal mine, as one would expect an intelligence aligned with human expectations would deem those to be indispensable. They don’t give a damn about alignment, it is not a problem they are trying to solve.
I’m not sure either. Will AI be the collapse of the middle class when it replaces all jobs? Will that cause societies to collapse before institutions can find a way to respond? Or will we all get universal income and live happily ever after?
Or will AI be the collapse of the corporation? Giving rise to millions of tiny companies providing incredible products and services through the use of AI? Or will it be the collapse of small businesses?
Or will AI be the end of digital content? Making it all meaningless as we drown in a sea of AI slop? Or will AI give rise to a new era of digital content never before imagined.
I have no idea. I have little hopes in the institutions in charge of all of this. I hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
In this specific case there is quite a simple solution, google (and oai/anthropic as well) should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries, they literally did this with adsense and youtube!
Sure, there's some technical hurdles, like identifying who's actually using the info they read, but impressions are a thing in ad networks, then there's broader questions about evaluating what training data was useful and used to ultimately produce what token, I'm still just taking about the kind of ai summaries in search related to the article, seems doable with the same system we use for ad networks.
When it comes to coding and more generalized knowledge there's already been interpretations about copyright laws and fair use that seem to allow what oai and ant are doing and how they are capitalizing on it, doesn't mean we should rethink them.
I'm sure there are technical solutions that can be translated to this sort of issues as well that could be derived from ad networks, I mean, imagine a world where your code and your blog post get a score on their usefulness to train LLMs and you get a share of the revenue, wouldn't this be better for all players? they get good training data, we get paid for it.
> In this specific case there is quite a simple solution, google (and oai/anthropic as well) should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries
The actual problem here is so weird that this doesn't actually work.
Consider something like Stack Overflow or Reddit. The people answering questions weren't getting paid to begin with, so you're solving the wrong problem.
And weirdly, the thing the AI summaries are doing is the thing sites like that have long been trying to do themselves. If someone has a common question that has already been answered, the AI summary answers it for them and then they don't show up to post the 5000th duplicate of the same question. It even lowers the operating costs of the site since then 5000 people don't have to load the same page when they don't need to post anything new.
Whereas if they have a question that hasn't been answered, there is nothing for the AI summary to summarize, so then the user isn't satisfied with it and proceeds to actually visit the site and post the novel question that hasn't been answered yet. In some kind of theoretical sense that should work. The site only gets used for new questions.
But it actually doesn't work, because it breaks an important part of how sites like that function, which is that the users vote on the answers. When you have the common question, you don't need to post anything new, but you upvote the correct answer, which gives the person answering the question a sense of accomplishment and lets them know that people value the thing they spent the time to write. And if you try someone's answer and it doesn't work then it gets downvoted and the low score lets other users know to be skeptical of it.
If the AI summary shows the answer without the feedback mechanism then it breaks the site. The people who post good answers then can't see anyone interacting with them and feel like they're wasting their time, and if that happens the site is dead.
The question is, how do you fix that when "just show me the answer immediately" is the thing the user of the search engine actually wants?
For sites like the one in the article the feedback loop and payment it's there with revenue sharing.
For web 2.0 (remember this term? Haven't used it in a while) you're right, the community building part is hampered by the LLM middle layer, but as you said if you're going past "just show me the answer immediately" and actually click on the site you may start to participate and this could actually improve the quality of contributors?
I kinda hate it but the "marketing funnel" is a valid model to apply here, and I'm sure there is an equilibrium to be found which benefits everyone, regardless of size and the kind of platform involved, history is not on my side here, but I need to be optimistic to keep being sane.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
Yes I do have this feeling. I combat this by not paying a dime to the largest culprits (all frontier AI producers) and by recommending others to do the same.
If using AI on a large scale remains unprofitable then I hope the situation improves for everyone. The hardest part would be convincing large businesses not to use frontier AI either. Due to the large costs for businesses some have figured this out on their own already.
I have this feeling. I feel a growing cognitive dissonance and AI psychosis slowly but surely overtaking my brain. At first these models were extremely useful tools that I could find joy in using and now they've become something else entirely. Now every day my brain gets fried from all the non stop junk information it is trying to decode and make useful. And at the same time i'm constantly being told that my replacement is coming for me and I should work harder.
This capitalist machine's only concern is profit. People all around me have lost their purpose to do the job. Nobody really cares anymore and we can see the effects on that. For example the recent FAA disruption or bank outages are likely a result of this exact thing on a macro scale.
Personally I'm dealing with this by detaching. I no longer use big tech products (beside apple's). No youtube, no social media, no algorithmic feeds. I try to be very mindful of my LLM usage and to use it to learn (somehow). I decided to start my own product so that nobody can have any expectations of me.
I also pulled my money away from the AI bubble. I put everything in a global ETF (part of which is AI but I couldn't find one with less AI in it). I'm voting by not paying for this. I will ABUSE all these services like openai & anthropic and the moment they raise prices I'm gone. They can kindly have fun with the aftermath of the collapse.
The single most important thing they should be spending time on is UBI. If they are so sure they are building SI how come they do not understand that people are afraid? All these geniuses with the EQ of Zuckerberg can go to some other planet.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
This industry did it onto themselves with "free and open source". Do hedge funds open source their proprietary software algorithms because "free software"?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
They don't care and it is self inflicted.
> Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
From smug jerks, most valuable workers from the future who don't need no stinking unions, to starving artists in half a decade.
Free Software is actually remarkably similar to LLMs regarding its economic consequences for software, with a few important differences. It does make software cheaper to produce and it does redistribute economic value from the little guy to everyone. Two huge differences are that FOSS authors keep some control and recognition for their work, and that there is no third party jamming itself between FOSS producer and consumer, controlling everything. Maybe not for lack of trying on the part of GitHub...
> Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
Hm, not even close. If you only did relatively easy tasks that are well defined and don't have big change "radius", then maybe (never worked in such big companies and industries). But at my job I see coding part of the job that gained some speed, but all other aspects are more or less unchanged.
Meeting with client, analyzing and planning, meeting with other members of the team, analyzing, planning again, and some more important parts of the software are still coded by hand.
So maybe 20% of my job has gained a lot of speed (not 100% sure about that long term, because now making a decision about part of the app that was not coded by hand is not intimately known like it was before takes a lot longer or at least cannot be made on the spot but must be made by spending tokens).
So yeah not even close.
P.S. Not to mention that there are cases where coding by hand is MUCH faster then using LLM
Even worse, being part of those companies, having no morals nor ethics in name of equity and a comfortable retirement plan, contrary to all of those affected by their work.
I've had this feeling multiple times over my 40 year career. First, it was the operation centers - the only place you could actually get access to a computer, which was fridge-sized, loud, noisy and expensive. Along comes the PC and my terminals are wiped away and I now have new technology to learn in order to gain access, remotely, to the computers I used to sit next to and warm myself. So, I did that.
Then, it was the PC again, new "incredible" 4GL database software arrives, replacing the million-dollar database server with a small box that sat on the side of my desk. Now every tiny office in every bodunk part of every irrelevant town can have massive relational database reports generated, running their profits up, satisfying customers that no longer need Big Metal. That profit is fun!
Then, it was compilers. The incredible onslaught of devtools meant there were tons of new things to learn again. So, I did that. "No more command line C compiler for me!", I exclaimed, and launched Turbo Pascal and Turbo C and Delphi and .. yeah. Maybe a bit too much Visual Basic, but whatever, it was RAD.
Then, Linux arrived, just when we all thought Unix was going to die and we need not keep learning new Unix things, except we do. Linux made the SBOM costs go way, way down, so .. some new things to learn, some old things to re-learn. So, I did that. (Oh, what a relief to go back to command line C compilers and things) Suddenly, we don't need Big Metal, we can do the same exact things on Little Metal.
Then, the Internet revolution arrived, and nobody wanted fancy local native things any more - everything had to be done in this new technology, even if it wasn't quite ready yet, the world was moving in that direction and we had to learn it. So, I did that. And boy, did I ship a lot of things and many profits were made.
What came next .. oh yeah, mobile! iPhone this and Android that, and all the knowledge about how to write great user interfaces was thrown out the window to be replaced with Hot New Stuff™ that the kids were using, grandad! Catch up already, sheesh! Maybe we need a bit of Big Metal for it, but yeah, the web was a great way to provide the user with an excuse to not learn how to install software and maintain their PC hygienically. So, I did that.
And now, the AI revolution is well and truly happening. So, so many new things to learn. So, I'm doing that.
I think the difference is, I've been in this game all along mostly because I love learning things, and computers have always been a mysterious box from which one can learn a great, great deal many things. I used to say "there is nothing mysterious about computers, only unknown - if its working and in front of you, its because someone, somewhere out there, knows it - so that means I can too", and that was a good maxim because it means I know assembly and multiple languages and can navigate all the layers of OSI with ease, and can invent things that others will have to catch up and learn, so .. they do that.
If you were in this for the paycheck, you're hurting. But if you're in it because you love making technology for your fellow human begins, then .. just do that. Embrace the things you don't know. Find your inner hacker spirit, and let it run world.
Get a DGX Spark, learn to use it. Learn to train models. Learn to SHIP those models to customers who will profit from using them. The data that all these other companies are using is out there for you to use, too! Don't forget that!
>Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No, I do not. I didn't feel good about renting slots on a timeshare system, either, which is why I embraced the PC when it arrived. All the C compiling I could want, none of the bills!
It is the same as it ever was: Go local, or gtfo. Get that DGX Spark and get on with it. Next year is going to be fun! (Unless you're only in it for profit, in which case you're not gonna have a good time unless you can actually have fun, doing that which you need to do, to profit...)
We have always had problems with Big Metal trying to keep everyone sequestered and subjugated. Always. Every single one of the new revolutions I've described have been a battle against Big Metal, controlling everything.
This is exactly how I feel, I started a bit later, but I still remember the 2.4 Linux kernels, the empowerment that Linux gave me, and I feel like that again now. LLMs brings so much of the things I wanted to do -but gave up on because one can do only so many things- (dashes all mine) back in scope. I'm enjoying it!
And I will get that GPU (perhaps not a DGX spark but who knows) someday. It's important to me as well.
I hope you have a great time learning LLMs and using them to do great things. People forget, AI is just as scary as VMS once was. As Unix was. As Linux was (but truly isn't).
AI is just software. Learn how to use it to improve the lives of other humans, and you'll do fine.
I handed my notice in last Friday. The newest CEO wants "AI at the heart of everything we do" and so it is at the heart of my departure. Actually I've been unhappy in tech since 2020, full time remote work is bad for my mental health and even though I go into the office I'm still remote because most of the people I work with are elsewhere. I never wanted to work for a large company (and refused job offers for more money for that reason in the post) for similar reasons and have been "forced" into that as we were bought by an international outfit just over a year ago. AI is just the final bale of hay.
This is professional suicide for me, of course. I'm not qualified for anything else that isn't also going to be remote, fully AI infused, or both, so for some time at least I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third (maybe a half with long hours) of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
There are a few other things to investigate. Physical network installation/support and such. But there are not that many jobs available in any of those options, a fair few people wanting each one, and some of those people have direct experience/training that I lack. I hope the basic jobs are not all I'll ever do from here-on, but I can make it work financially, and mentally, if I have to, and in the short term I might even enjoy it (a change is as good as a rest!).
Right now my priorities are:
• getting out
• taking a sabbatical (some weeks, maybe two months) to deal with some of the immediate burn-out effects (fixing everything is a much more long term matter)
• then doing anything to pay the bills, so I'm not eating too much into savings for a long time.
There are quite a few people around me feeling exactly the same way, but they can't afford to take the risk of what I'm doing for various reasons (still paying mortgage/rent, partners and children to think about, etc.).
I can cope short-medium term on minimum spending etc, medium-long if I do something basic - I was thinking of doing something more physical like you mentioned, network installing (cabling etc) which I quite like doing but don't do it often. I know I couldn't get enough work to compete against what I get now, but maybe its enough.
The problem with "cloud computing" it doesn't break enough for people to care, so contracting work has been killed off by this. Probably costs more long term as well for the small business, small long term hidden costs etc.
This might feel a bit gross, but hear me out. AI is going to drive a lot of consolidation, but it's also going to help facilitate starting a ton of new businesses. It's clear big companies are going to need less help maintaining their automations so fewer jobs for people who do that. But there are tons of situations where more automations were always desirable but never economically feasible.
Imagine knowing that there's a product that could bring in $500k/year but would take 2 people 3 years to make it, well, it was always going to be a chicken-and-egg problem. Now it might be possible for 1 person and several GPUs / high subscriptions to build that business in 6mo.
It's scary for sure to try and make something from scratch. But I think actually owning some kind of small business is going to be the best defense against getting laid off from a big company. People in tech for sure have challenges as they're really good at doing the thing vs seeing how the thing is used, but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills.
Using AI to work on my own, to escape AI and working on my own due to remote working, doesn't feel like a solution I can work. If “just use AI” was viable for my mindset then I'd stay where I am in a safe salaried job rather than a more risky start-up, and use AI here.
> … to build that business in [time]…
One of the things I know that I am not cut out to be, is a businessman. I would not want to work for a start-up run by me!
> but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills
Again, if I'm going to learn skills that I would really rather not learn, then getting behind AI and staying here would be the safer option.
> This might feel a bit gross
Yup!
I do see your point, but it is not a solution that I think could work for me.
To me the best parallel I can think of is the industrial revolution. The best (economic) position to be in during that time was to somehow figure out a way to be involved in steam engines. Building or maintaining them, putting one to work in your business, finding a business that you could change with one, etc. Some people chose not to and that's fine, but a lot of basic assumptions about the way people lived got turned on their head whether they liked it or not. People didn't effectively boycott the steam engine even if there were some short periods of success with the Luddites. It's easy for us to be completely dispassionate about this from 200 years in the future.
I think the same flavor of advice holds today. It's totally fine to not like it or not want to participate in it, maybe even boycott it. But you're signing up for a more difficult life. It might well be more rewarding too, we won't know for a long time.
You'll probably need to find an Amish or Amish-like community to join or start your own. It takes enormous money to get into commercial farming but artisinal market gardening is an option with as little as 1/2 acre. You'll want to go as far down the value chain as possible because then even if AI ends up being deployed somehow into a domain you're in, you're at least going to be able to sustain yourself with your own labor. Homesteading is a good way to think about it. Work to minimize what you need from "the grid" in terms of energy, food, etc. One good generic metric is how much you have to spend in a month/year tells you how dependent you are on society. Buying solar panels can help both literally and figuratively. Having a really well insulated home. Getting a very efficient EV you can charge from your solar panels, but even better if you can bike or at least use an e-bike. If you can drive your monthly expenses below $1k it's relatively easy to sustain yourself with low leverage work. You might want to consider moving to somewhere less expensive where you can have more land (for food, solar, water, etc), and lower payments / own it outright.
Obviously I can't tell you that the future will play out the way I'm describing here. This is just my best guess. I have been thinking about it for a while after I was asked a question by a friend "how will all this play out?" months ago. History tells us how people are likely to deploy an invention across society, not because the society is the same but because human nature is.
> so for some time at least I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third (maybe a half with long hours) of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
Sounds like a good time to start a new venture of your own? If you're captain of your own ship, you can make sure that it's not AI infused. And coworking spaces can feel a lot like offices, if you take care to go every day.
I think that a lot of people feel the same way you do, so there might be an opportunity in that.
I tried a few different coworking spaces for a while. It never really felt quite like an office, everyone is working on separate things, busy with their own team /product/company. Some people have a few colleagues there with them, so they end up grouping up together, some others are alone, but always seem busy doing their thing... I did not meet many people there, and with the people I did meet I did not really build any meaningful relationships like I would with actual colleagues.
While my company was paying for it, it was fine, I could go there whenever I felt like having some people around. When my company stopped paying for it (the company stopped existing), I switched to another (cheaper) coworking space, but the experience remained the same. Actually worse because now I was at a coworking space, looking for a job, while others where working on their product/company with their colleagues and teams, and I was shelling out money just for the privilege to have people around me.
My office feels a lot like a coworking space. We are all working for the same company, but the people I'm actually working with are mostly in other locations, and that goes for many of the others too. Still, we now have the pleasure of being physically present in the office five days a week.
I, for one, hate it. And the most galling thing is that my company has (of course) fully embraced the advantages of remote working for itself, buying up companies left and right and creating teams with people from different locations, but now insists that we employees should mostly give up those advantages.
> Sounds like a good time to start a new venture of your own?
I am no manager by anyone's definition, and to some extent you have to be in order to be successful that way, unfortunately.
> coworking spaces can feel a lot like offices
Like rob74's sentiment: my current office feels more like a co-working space! Better than being at home wrt work/other separation & balance, but it doesn't really work for me.
It's sad, and sadly solutions to the problem are non-trivial. Cory Doctorow discusses some solutions in his book. TL;DR from memory: increased regulation, in particular anti-trust and consumer rights.
The book is definitely worth reading. It discusses the central problem of today's Internet. It's a bit wordy/repetitive on the problem description side, but still ...
As much as I would like to have empathy let's not pretend that before it was all roses, with the top Google results basically being SEO optimized websites and Pinterest-like link aggregation. The example query "best bank in Berlin for expats" is the exact SEO hell that I'm glad I don't have to deal anymore.
There was a game and you played it well, but the game has changed, what do you want me to do? Should we also bring back the horses?
I don't feel conflicted, I have always felt that "information wants to be free" and these kind of developments are inevitable. We improvise, we adapt, we overcome. We use the new tools to achieve new things in a new reality, we just need to learn how. It's what Homo Sapiens is best at.
I do really feel bad from another angle, I feel bad about not owning my means of production, and can't wait for the time when I can host my own, as I have always done. But I can see that that is going to happen, it will just take a while. I hate that a third party can take stuff away from me, and I need to be online for it to work.
Just the fact that Muses and Dots are just free VMs with (depending on reports) 12 GB of RAM, for free gets my blood boiling a bit, they borrowed the money, took everyone's RAM supply and put it in a machine to get us hooked before squeezing value back out of us later. I did not and will not sign up for this. I want to host my own. My machines are an extension of my mind and my thoughts are my own.
The work? The information? Meh, I'll adapt. But don't touch my agency, my privacy, my (for lack of a better word) sovereignty.
I think the alternative is open source. You need to own the model you run, the data you feed, no cloud. I think it would be nice if the future is more crowdsourced training and data networks that evolve open source models. For now, I think we need to find ways to reward open weights, if that means China, so be it.
It’s one of the most evil technology and industry possible. Anti-human, by design. I feel terrible at the idea that I contributed a tiny bit to those company success and paid for their service. At the same time I know a good amount of people at Anthropic and they are personally awesome. But I’m convinced it is lead by a doomsday cult that doesn’t care one bit about the negative externalities they are causing
You cannot publicly discuss the few options that might work for legal and moral reasons, but imho it'll end up like it always does when people get more and more alienated.
This site is full of people who voluntarily, on their own time, help these companies with their subscriptions and training. Just see the mountain of comments on every His Majesty The Frontier LLM Release submission where they write about their side projects.
They have about as much “cognitive dissonance” about their fecklessness as I have about eating meat. (the dilemma: on the one hand it is murder; on the other hand it is delicious.)
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
That depends on what you mean by "us".
Companies are paying taxes. Should they be paying more taxes? I really have no clue. Probably, as labor share of income decreases.
Should companies instead pay "us" (as in: creators) directly? I think here the issue is mostly that we are in unprecedented territory.
What needs to be paid for? What is okay to do with content that other people produced under a different regime? The rules so far have been pretty lax and in fact we are happy to share the knowledge, because it benefits all of us.
All of a sudden we have this machine that eats it all up systematically and creates outsized effects that are hard to compete with. This seems super messy. LLMs should exist, it's just good to have them. Again, taxing the corps seems like the simple solution, but idk.
What is curious is that we had the dry run: Google got rich and made people rich by linking to other peoples information. This to me is the same thing from a different angle. Who allowed Google to systematically index all this information? Well, nobody, but also nobody explicitly disallowed it, because nobody thought of it being a thing.
Then there is a separate question: What happens with those taxes in the future? Should it be used to fund UBIsh things? Again, crystal ball says: Probably, because what else? Also: Why not?
It seems all the discussion revolve around the short/medium term issues, but the longer one I see that might bring back some balance is the creation of new content. Short/medium term yes the issues are what you list, the AI companies steal content, creators go bankrupt. But then how a new "All About Berlin" for a new subject emerges? As I see it the problem then will not be a new one emerges and is stolen, it's that there will be no new one altogether.
So to answer your question on how we'll combat this, I think "old" content / the web is lost, that new quality free content, be it websites, posts or Youtube videos, will dry up and move behind paywalls. Now is a difficult transition period for creators because the incentive for consumers are not yet there.
On the optimistic side, the mainstream web was already sick, it didn't wait for Google AI overview. So it might just finishes it off that dying model for creators with most of the ad and SEO industry.
Automation has the power to make workers' lives better by producing more. That won't happen as long as the wealthy capitalists control it. It will be used to exploit and dispossess. The same thing happened in the industrial revolution. It was the labor movement that improved people's lives.
Less frustrated with the few thousand rich grifters than the 10s of millions effectively shrugging
Frustrated Fellow Americans put obligations on me but provide no assurance.
Same with environment; pearl clutching but stop driving. Flying. Psh. No.
When we don't know how to solve a problem we ignore it. So we're fucked. But then there was no beating physics anyway; life is the leading cause of death.
Downside to knowledge work has been the loss of all the manual skills that workers could fall back on, effectively look away from the digital virtual economy and just do the plumbing and roofing etc etc
(Yes yes hard on body but large enough labor pool (everyone that can) distributing load on a schedule).
I highly doubt they become profitable; Apple m7 and beyond or some other local device chip will come along that handles local inference on my own data just fine -or- society collapses seems most likely right now
Have seen it written we are in a cold world war 3, how this period is the Hitler's troops marches unobstructed across Europe" phase.
I don’t like it. I personally try to limit AI overviews as much as possible, and use Kagi for search. I’ll then follow the links.
I will say though, LLMs have made the deluge of AI generated websites with information even worse. I’m not even sure I can confidently find human made content anymore.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
No.
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
No.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No. It’s conflicting. The tools are useful, but I don’t use them for content creation in the way of words to read, art to look at, etc. It doesn’t feel good though. On one hand I feel bad, on the other I have personal projects that would never have gotten done before.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Net positive? No. There will definitely be some positives. I don’t think they’ll outweigh the negatives.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I have it every day. I don’t combat it, not well at least. But to quote Jango Fett: “I’m just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe.”
The large software giants will get into problems selling their software stacks due to AI. SaaS might be replaced with self-made open source solution developed with the help of AI.
There is good and bad things. Sure, nobody thought the first thing AI replaces would be the creative work.
Currently the frontier models are leading here and people become dependent on them. I don't think their moat will last too long, even if they try to make hardware scarce, at some point open models will replace them as well.
I don't think you can combat it much. But we can leverage the positive sides, even if they seem smaller right now.
Largest problem for developers right now is that the pipeline for new talent is broken. Well, in regards to anything to do with software, Germany hated building knowledge in several disciplines. A former engineering culture was replaced by lazy consumers and that was before AI in the picture.
> The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves. It inspired two government portals and a few similar websites in other cities.
perhaps if All About Berlin can pivot into consulting about UX design, they can share/sell the source of their compelling way of presenting the data
zeitgeist will never be in reach of AI, just by virtue of it always taking time to train / being reactionary (people catch on to trends instantly, and spontaneously generate them too)
Like crap, but like with everything else in life you can't control: go with the flow and make the best of it. If I could re-wind to the pre-AI era and give Geoffrey Hinton something else that's interesting to do I would.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Most definitely not. But what to do about it?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work?
Most definitely not.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
I don't and I never will.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
No, I think it will lead to worse than ever seen before wealth concentration and probably the end of the societies we have come to know.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I don't combat it other than by writing (for instance: https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-ai-contradiction/ ), by trying as hard as I can to get local AI systems working for me that are not beholden to the scammers and by comforting myself that no matter which way this goes I'm too old for it to make a huge difference on my life. But at the same time: I worry for my kids and the world they will have to make their way in.
I feel bad about it, but like a virus or wildfire, I think it is just an inevitable consequence of an explosion in technological capability. Like tissues or dry brush, information was always vulnerable to being tainted like this.
Companies are going to be deceitful either way; we have only discovered the extent to which they are able to be deceitful given advanced technology was far higher than ever imagined.
It occurred to me recently that there's an analogy to be drawn with the disputes of the 1970s/80s in the UK between organized labour who went on strike to try to maintain their share of the profits from their labour, and the capital owners who brought in outside "un-unionionized" labour to break the strikes.
The un-unionized labour were the target of horrific shaming, intimidation, and abuse by the unionized labour. Of course "scabs" as they were known to the strikers were just trying to adapt to the situation they found themselves and take care of their families so even though my sympathies lie (then and now) with the strikers (or anti-AI crowd), I feel a great deal of empathy for them. Just as I feel empathy for anyone who finds themselves in a position now (as I do) of needing to use AI to stay relevant in their jobs. But I do feel like it makes me a bit like a "scab" of the current era.
I'm sure I can't be the first to have made this connection.
People need to organize, first online and then offline. Contradicting AI propaganda is the first step.
People also need to stop using clankers entirely. The blog post's message is severely undermined by the fact that the blog is Claude slop, so it also steals from other people.
Yes, it's okay. This guy made money because Google directed to his website. Now he's making less because they're directing less. What is the argument here? That he has a "right" for Google to direct traffic to his site?
I googled "best german bank account for foreigners" and compared his site to the Google AI response. They aren't even the same! Google recommends "C24 Bank" as its #2 choice whereas All About Berlin classifies it as "not expat-friendly." Google is not simply regurgitating information from his site.
Nowhere in this article does he question whether the experience is better for the users. Ulitimately, this is plain old creative destruction. I understand it sucks when it comes for you, but "I can't earn a living doing X anymore" isn't a good justification for stopping it.
The point is not really just about this one page or this one website.
Every single website had a symbiotic relationship with Google that had become increasingly strained and now is entirely one way and has become parasitic.
The web, and thus Google, cannot exist if that continues. No the world doesn’t owe this one guy visits to his website, but the way Google operates now the only people getting visits are people paying for ads.
The issue is not that they are no longer getting redirections, but why they are no longer getting redirections.
The redirection is no longer necessary because an AI model, likely trained on their work, gives them the answer without having to go onto their site.
It’s a departure from old search engines made it easy to find the “right” site and showed a couple of ads before the user clicked onto the site, then seeing the site’s ads so they could make money too.
I have a similar feeling. Personally I combat it by running my own company. While I use a bunch of LLMs, its an “AI-last company”. I code by hand, design by hand, write by hand, and edit by hand.
There are two things I tell myself to keep my head:
1. There are really two possible outcomes. Either “AGI/SI/RSI” is achieved, or it’s not. The former will change everything so drastically, there is literally no way to prepare for it or imagine the reprocusions. Nothing about that path is in my control, so I don’t spend any time thinking about it or worrying it. Doing so would be the equivalent of us practicing hiding under our desks for when the nuclear alarms go off. It helps that I don’t find it likely, but that “1% chance” lingered in the back of my brain until I embraced this mentality.
2. The amount of investor capital and debt involved in these businesses give me very little hope for their ability to innovate. The squeeze/enshittification will come faster than with any other technology. Those business that can outlast it will come back in demand. Private drivers were almost wiped out by uber, now I know several private drivers making a killing because people are tired of Ubers. AirBNBs were posed to take out hotels or BnBs or alternative lodging; nearly everyone I know now has sworn off airbnbs, and there are tons of cool alternative options.
It sucks that these companies can steal and get away with it. They’re destroying large swathes of society and ruining millions of people’s lives to make a few rich people even richer.
But eventually the check will come due and the music will end. Forest fires burn away hundred year old trees, but in doing so allow a new generation of seeds to take root. I refuse to believe the money inferno will burn up all human desire for uniqueness, creativity, and artisanry.
Keep doing what you’re doing, follow your passions, hone a craft, use AI as little as possible, refuse AI when you don’t want it, don’t get doomtrolled, and wait for the fire to burn out.
the internet used to be a common ground, the digital commons. Now it has been appropriated by the big players. It's a new situation, for us - but not without historic precedent.
I suspect that all usable information will be behind a paywall, at some point. That was the reaction of news sites in Germany, as far as I know. Maybe we will get a workable micro payment system, as a result.
I think that such a micro payment system will come with it's own search engine, in order to help with discovering information.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
We've been stealing each others work since the beginning of time. Nothing new. Let's take open source as an example. Who are the biggest contributors to open source? Typically, employees of big tech companies who have enough free time to build side projects and too much money to bother charging for it. Without big tech companies, open source wouldn't be as popular and AI wouldn't have enough data to train on. By using open source projects, we're stealing from big tech companies, so it's only natural for them to have the right to steal our jobs.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
Yes because unless I'm able to train my own models, I'm happy about paying some megacorp to get access to a trained one.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Any company that becomes profitable has a positive effect on society. People die from eating MacDonalds and KFC every year, but there are plenty of people who's happiness levels are increasing because of these companies. I guess AI should be seen as fast food. There are some weirdos who will talk to it about everything, but normal people will understand its limits.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
There's nothing to combat. Just accept reality. Worse case scenario I can become a construction worker or plumber. There are always houses to build and pipes to fix.
> Any company that becomes profitable has a positive effect on society
I feel like you should lead with this so we know we are speaking to a radical/extremist. This casual dismissal of the most fundamental change to humanity in a long time leads me to believe you are equating the fact you are OK with it to everyone being OK with it.
> We've been stealing each others work since the beginning of time. Nothing new.
I’m so tired of this refrain. Anytime AI clearly makes something a much bigger problem or makes it way too easy to do something nefarious the response is “well we’ve always done that” as if the speed, scale, and ease of access hasn’t meaningfully changed. AI can’t be a revolutionary tool when promises are being made and inconsequential when issues arise.
People could always get hurt crossing the street. I’d say the advent of cars made the discussion rather different, however. If somebody started talking about how dangerous crossing a street became once cars reached a critical mass, would the correct response be to throw up your hands and go “people could always get hurt crossing the street”?
Any human progress is bound to introduce dangers that can then be worked around. Crossing the road became safe after the invention of zebra signs and traffic lights. Humanity will invent solutions to the dangers of AI and I'm excited to see them.
I’m not saying the problems are insurmountable. I’m saying you can’t just dismiss the problems with “well we’ve always had that” when the scale has changed so much it is functionally a different problem.
Like you’re sitting here saying we will figure it out, but how can we fix something if we won’t even acknowledge it’s a problem?
I’d also say we haven’t exactly solved road safety.
We already know the answer we just don’t do it. Prioritize pedestrians and cyclists, safe and clear delineations everywhere, smaller/lighter/fewer cars and better public transit.
I feel like the internet is a bunch of hypocrites who celebrated liberation of knowledge up until their knowledge got liberated. Now knowledge liberation is bad.
The takeaway from this is that people on the whole are reliably selfish and self interested. If a company gives them all of everyone else's knowledge for $20/mo, they'll pay it (and complain).
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Oh hell no. You shall own nothing and rent everything, that is where we are heading. And when the AI bubble pops and lights every American's (and a lot of non-American's) pensions on fire, the AI overlords that have cashed in during the IPOs will buy up the ashes.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
By refusing to engage with AI slop of all kind, by calling out AI slop when I spot it - and by quitting the industry. I'm heading for an EE degree now, should be safe enough from clankers because at least in Germany, if the clankers take over, it's an extra exam about the electrical code and you can go from an EE degree into the trades.
In some sense it's the paperclip thing that all these people talked about.
Earth's matter is being turned into compute at an accelerating rate. These companies are moving exergy(== money) into this gigantic and rapidly growing dissipative structure at historic rates.
Yet, from an individual human being's perspective, the value of this is tough to quantify. Sure, I love making more paper clips. Claude can make paperclips really fast. Is that the point of life? Sure seems to be, based on what we are doing, in a 'purpose of the system is what it does' kind of way.
Hey, I'm Nicolas from All About Berlin. This post is a few months old. I went through a psychological rollercoaster since I wrote it. Things got worse, but so far, I can still live from the website. Next year might be my last year running it full time.
I'm traveling at the moment, but I'll grab a drink and read this thread later today. In the meantime, feel free to email me. Reader mail would be a lovely break from the flood of LLM-generated outreach emails.
This looks very different from AAB. It’s basically a classic AI-written kitchen sink of real-time data views (weather, transit, legislation, events, etc.), while AAB is a detailed human-written guide to laws and processes involved in living in Berlin. You couldn’t easily vibe-write AAB, but you could (and I assume the author did) vibe-code that app.
I’m the developer of the app. It is sad to see that someone who didn’t even use the app can talk about the app I’ve spent hundreds of hours more than a year like this. If you switch to App Store Germany, you can see that the app has more than hundreds of reviews with only 5-star.
It looks really cool, and I don't doubt that you've spent a lot of time on it, but the truth is that it fits a common mold that normally indicates "vibe-coded": a hyper-targeted super-app with hundreds of features that are mostly visualizations of public data sources. Not really in the same category as All About Berlin.
You seem to be complaining that something written by a human looks similar to AI-written stuff... which is an inevitable occasion because AI simply mimics human writing.
It's not the fault of the website that you see similarities. The beam is in your eye.
I already have a free (and ad-free) newsletter. I thought of offline marketing, but only because it seemed like a fun thing to do.
In the end, I have a "use it when you need it" website, so I don't acquire an audience the way "subscribe for fun updates" websites do. People only care about a citizenship guide if they're about to apply for it.
As a recent arriver to Berlin (7 months or so).. being able to opt into "I just landed".. I'd give you.. $250(?) for a year of drip emails about the things I need to be doing or the rhythms of life here, etc.
It's hard to remember what the next level of german paperwork I need to be doing is.. or that St Martin's Tag is a thing and how I should teach my kid how to celebrate it, or that there's a kite thing in the fall that's a big deal or... etc etc etc.
May not be the thing you're trying to build/write though.
Funny that you mention it because I had the same idea (sans monetization). A newsletter starting on your chosen date of arrival, trickling helpful information along your journey.
The infrastructure is already there, since I have built a pension refund reminder tool a while ago.
i had a similar idea for "things to do before/after having a kid (...in germany)" calendar (based on DOB in this case) - it's a generic idea that works for many things.
saw there's a bunch of them last time i checked though
partially helps with events/goings-on that's not very polluted with 6 month things showing up as "an event in your area" every day for 6 months (don't remember which stupid site does that)
I just saw they have the one for kids and signed up myself :P
Thank you for your hard work! When I arrived in Berlin 4 years ago with just my laptop in my hands and no knowledge of German language your site helped me immensely. It is still my go to place for all questions regarding German bureaucracy.
Your website was a lifesaver when I moved to Berlin, finding reliable information about how to deal with all the quirks and customs of Germany really made my life infinitely easier. I still use it from time to time.
It sucks what's happening. Not sure how to reach your audience, but your work is still relevant. Maybe you could publish it as a book and get it distributed around the city where newly coming people might find it.
Also you should consider translating your content into video format and establish a social media presence. Your content is still valuable for newcomers (and expats in general) so you could find a new way for your audience to find you now that Google search is dead.
Your website was invaluable when I needed it. Having immigrated to another country before that and tried to help other people with the same, it was exactly the kind of website I wanted to write in that situation. Everything about it was very refreshing and helpful.
That's so sad to hear. I got the habit of just going to All About Berlin directly, because the results in Google/ChatGPT led me down the wrong path too many times. But this usage pattern is limited to people who already know you, and it's not so frequent.
Have you considered any spin-off products? You still have a solid brand, and from what I can see, most expats here know AAB because it saved their lives at some point.
Yep. I'm applying the same integrity to health insurance, an industry that desperately needs it. I work with a trustworthy broker to get people better insurance. The commissions are a sizeable chunk of my income.
Until recently it was just another page on the website, so I didn't need to think hard about it. Now with dwindling traffic I have to choose between growing that side business and building things I consider more useful things.
I don't love that, but it beats returning to software dev. It also means that my work still revolves around giving honest advice to immigrants.
the cats out the bag, but would a more restrictive robots.txt get you out of the AI summaries? Maybe there's a way to still end up in the AI summary, but instead of the answer the AI can be "forced" to present the link to your site with the actual answer?
Given your brand awareness, have you ever considered something akin to like a concierge service? As in, go the complete opposite away from AI and offer human, in-the-flesh assistance, not necessarily with the actual legal work, but as a "guy who knows a guy"?
I am quite close to the relocation industry, and they're all suffering. People still use their services, but often after getting in trouble because Claude gave them incorrect advice.
It's also much harder to work directly for customers, especially when you can't do much to fix the bureaucracy you're helping with.
Have you ever written a blog post or done an interview thanking Google for the free organic traffic that turned your side hustle into a location-independent main income, allowing you to travel and overall brought comfort and money to your life?
I love your site. I hate Google.
But the way I see it, Google does not owe you traffic.
I rarely comment here, but this warrants a comment. I've been a big fan of All About Berlin since I moved to Germany. Such a well-put, precise, concise and reliable source of information for immigrants.
I appreciate you and your work, and I'm really sad to see how things are turning up for developers like you, and valuable projects like these.
People are being conditioned to think that all the answers come from AI, or that AI knows everything.
But AI is only getting (inaccurate shadows of) the info from these sources which it is simultaneously working to kill. (Websites like this, StackOverflow, human written code)
What happens when there are no more sources and everyone just expects AI to answer everything or write everything? Recursive self-improvement? I doubt it.
It already starts to show. Everything is going to be the same.
Recently I started to see AI banners in local stores here in Berlin. I have seen youtube videos of americans about it, but now it came here too. And they all look the same. they look like trash. And now all that AI content will be fed into it again, taking the average of the average. Everything will be the same turd. No matter in which field of life. I don't know how this will end, but probably not in a good way
An optimistic scenario: people and companies will at some point notice this and any human creative effort will be more in demand again, because it is then special.
I'm not sure this is a counterexample. What you're highlighting is the unfortunate and increasing bifurcation into junk for the masses and luxury goods for the elite (with their associated pricing quirks) and the elimination of the middle class. That's not a reaction by those who have the junk increasingly forced upon them.
> Everything will be the same turd. No matter in which field of life. I don't know how this will end, but probably not in a good way
Let’s be optimistic: human output will always have the edge. Artists will see respect and admiration again, unseen since the middle ages. But it will all be drowned by an abundance of grey slop.
> Recently I started to see AI banners in local stores here in Berlin
It's been going on for a while already in France and Belgium, to the point that I am pleasantly surprised when I see an illustration that is not AI.
Local events that could certainly find a local artist (I mean, if you're organising an event for local produce or local artists, you can certainly find a local graphic designer as well?), big supermarket or restaurant chains that certainly have enough money to pay an actual person to produce something that goes with their branding, city administration, schools, it seems like everyone uses it, even people who really should know better.
Interestingly though it's rarely the same overly crowded yellow-tinged design as I see being criticised online. What I see is always a lot lighter and at least quite legible, the problem is just that it completely lacks character and generally highlights the least important info.
If you think it's bad in Berlin, you should see how it is in India. I've seen AI-AI-generated ads before a film at the cinema. AI-generated menus and banners are everywhere, even at proper sit-down restaurants. You see AI-generated foods in Google maps, AI-generated government billboards.
At one point, I thought model collapse (AI models getting trained on AI output) was a solved problem since we know what content improves a model and what weakens it. Now I'm not sure.
While I know what you mean, the reality is that for many types of query the cost of extracting relevant information from the web has been trending upwards as a result of people gaming the attention economy. There are of course exceptions like wikipedia.
AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.
This is already happening. Some of the earliest movers in this space were nation-state actors. Israel’s funding of operatives to try to bias AI towards being sympathetic towards Israel’s “situation” was well-publicized. The operatives propped up a bunch of websites overnight with a deluge of pro-Israel content.
Yeah I wouldn’t be surprised if that happened. But of course it gets weaponized by state actors from Russia to China to US, etc. My own experience is with the IRGC and Iranian government heavily weaponizing it in the disinformation warfare for minimizing/hiding the atrocities they commit. So far the impact of this tech on journalism and (dis)information has been abysmal.
In other words: Google has contributed to enshittifying the web by favoring ad-infested SEO-optimized sites, so people of course prefer the "AI summary" to sifting out some nugget of wisdom from between all the SEO copy (plus AI slop) and ads. And the rare non-ad-infested (or only moderately ad-infested) genuinely useful sites like All About Berlin end up as collateral damage...
Recursive slopification. But at the point we reach it perhaps we'd all have turned into brain rotted zombies. The internet has been dead for years now.
I'm not sure hackernews is the golden source of truth you think it is - Objectivity quickly breaks down here when anything political comes up, its really not much better than a tech subreddit
With "websites like this" I was not referencing hackernews. I was referencing the website that the article is talking about, All About Berlin. I don't know anything about that website or it's quality. I was just using it as an example of source of human-generated content.
Besides "discussions", there are definitely some comments by "tech personalities" on HN (e.g. about startup and open source history) that act as primary sources that you can't find anywhere else.
Getting people's attention with things you do is a game that keeps on changing. I grew up before the internet was a thing. The way things work changing dramatically because of the internet has been a constant throughout my life.
The status quo of small websites scraping together revenue that largely depends on Google sending traffic their way is, for better or worse, no longer valid. Google is competing with AI agents now, which scrape together answers from websites and largely remove the need of going to these websites. Google is losing traffic to these agents and is itself trying to adopt a similar strategy.
I see people projecting a lot of morality here but what this boils down to is that people had a nice ride on Google driving traffic to websites for a while that is now disappearing. That's unfortunate of course but it bounces the question back to these small websites about how they themselves are going to adapt and deal with their apparent dependence on Google driving traffic their way.
Part of that may be AI companies driving revenue to quality content. Google has done similar things historically through sponsored content, preferential treatment, etc. And part of this is content producers maybe having to find new ways of producing content and getting eyeballs on that content. There's a lot of stuff competing for people's attention out there. But people wanting to express themselves and finding ways to do so is a constant throughout history. I don't have all the answers here of course; I don't think anyone has. But I doubt people are going to be just passive consumers of information. They'll want to express themselves and they'll find new ways.
A lot of small websites were never about the money to begin with. I never got a single dollar for putting anything on stack overflow, Github, various public forums, etc. and I still did that. Stackoverflow imploded over the years. I noticed some big changes with Github where small projects like my own are largely ignored by AI agents. I have a few small projects that are definitely getting a lot less stars and PRs since about a year. Github wasn't a thing until about 2010 of course. OSS existed and thrived before that. But perhaps not at the same scale.
Exactly. For factual stuff that updates occassionally like the local scene or local laws the models will have to source original content from somewhere.
I wonder if the solution is to stop giving free updates on your website, and then contact the big model makers that you have been using my content for free but its no longer updated. If you really want updates i will provide a paid api or rss feed for you to consume. or just sign a retainer contract with me.
I would like to think most model makers should agree to this or risk providing outdated/hallucinatory info to their users.
some kind of collective action where a lot of popular content owners form associations and negotiate together may work even better.
Yeah, I think so. If they have multiple live audio/video/lidar/ISAC feeds of every bar in Berlin, why wouldn’t they be able to know what the best bar in Berlin is?
They also have all your communications to other humans about the bars.
Potentially they even have transaction data showing daily revenue and spending patters.
Should be very doable with liquid enough data markets and sufficient compute.
This is satire, right? Do you genuinely believe that a meaningful answer to a question like "best bar" can be derived from wiretapping every public space? That "most popular" is close enough to what people actually mean when they ask that question that the loss of everything else will be accepted?
To your third, I think you misunderstood. I am not saying that “most popular” will be used as a proxy for “best”. I am saying that by having enough sensors distributed through society that we are able to tell what people think the “best” bars are to a high degree of accuracy and usefulness.
Also I want to be clear that I am not desiring this. It just seems clear that this is the machine we are building. This is why google feels comfortable cannibalizing search traffic.
I mean, companies already enter their opening hours into Google Maps for fee, rather than updating their own website (or OpenStreetMap, for that matter).
And instead of talking and learning about the craft so many people are dedicating all their efforts towards the latest harness setup etc. So much ground is being lost.
They just let the LLMs hallucinate and lie to us. It's not like you could verify anything anymore because fact-reporting organizations have been killed off by then too.
Idea: Once LLM sites identify subject matter experts, they offer some SME incentive (free tokens, upgraded model usage) in exchange for a few minutes time to fill an oft-requested gap in the LLM knowledge base.
I hate myself for writing this on a public forum to be scraped and monetized.
People are also conditioned to think that sites like All About Berline and StackOverflow know everything. They don't, they get lots of stuff wrong. At least with AI you can have a conversation, push back, etc
I cannot see any other explanation other than "they are harvesting new, fresh human input" for some types of so-called-social media bots. The sort that is 24/7 baiting (believed to be) humans into writing an up-to-date assessment without ever contributing back. Of course that, too, will stop working eventually, as platforms that wish to retain their human user base must work to shut down such behavior.
The A.I. genie is probably never getting back in the bottle. How I would like for this technology to just not exist.
The hackernews frontpage would be sooo much nicer again as well. I used to browse hackernews being amazed and (pleasantly) surprised about the cleverness and imagination of people. but these days you have to look for the nice stuff with a lookingglass between the onslaught of breathless AI stories.
I just can't be bothered anymore to be amazed about what AI can dow now. I mean, it is amazing of course that we now more or less live in the asimov sf world. But it the kind of amazement I would very much prefer to have stayed a fantasy.
I personally would not have wanted it 10 years ago. Not everything needs to be automated. I always liked creating things more for the community and for communicating with others my own creative vision, not being a soulless one-person factory.
> but these days you have to look for the nice stuff with a lookingglass between the onslaught of breathless AI stories.
Not my impression. Ofc there is content about/involving AI but they are definitely interesting if you are interested in the topic (which I am and have to be as a software developer).
This is the massive elephant in the room; AI needs human-made work, published openly to further develop, and simultaneously heavily discourages human-made work to be published openly, either because the people who previously did it now use AI to do it or because the people who still do no longer have any incentive to publish it openly (and lets be honest, the incentives were pretty meagre before).
But craziest of all is that the best plan this trillion-dollar industry can come up with is "we'll figure something out later". Maybe we will, maybe AI will be able to train off synthetic data or we'll achieve the perfect model that never needs improving or we'll simply hit a wall with how much training data we need, but for a problem that an existential threat to LLM's, that's a lot riding off a few maybe's
This is awful. It’s already hard to trust information online and this will make it even more opaque. Imagine you are curious about a war or political movement or event for example and the only way to get informed would be the chat box of a handful of mega corporations.
The real elephant is that we've "funded" "content creation" (barf) for 20 years on the back of advertising. That is the long-term unsustainable problem, not AI.
It's unfortunate for 'good' website creators/maintainers but many people would prefer an AI summary of multiple peoples views on "getting a bank account in Germany" generated from lots sites on the internet than clicking through links of content of unknown quality and possibly outdated information that may just prioritize the banks with the best affiliate commission.
...an AI summary, where you have to check by reading all the sources anyway, because once you get into more niche topics, it turns out that the source of the AI overview is often a comment from a random Redditor without any supporting evidence (and often just wrong).
Of course, many people just take whatever AI overview says at face value without any very verification.
Or the source doesn't even say what the summary says. And you have to dig and dig to realize that what you read was just a hallucination.
Yeah, great point! I was trying to find some information about what is actually in the EPI Wero requirements (due to some banks now requiring Play Integrity for Wero payments). And AI overview often completely made up statements, where the stated did not occur in the sources.
It works for extremely well-known basic information, so people think it can also answer niche or difficult questions.
This is analogous to how it can make basic apps and websites, so people think it can make everything.
The people who are working with interesting info that AI can't answer or making interesting programs that AI can't write know that it is smoke and mirrors.
The AI overview is worse because it presents hallucinations and randomly sourced Reddit comments as facts. Yeah, sure, there is a tiny grey text below it that says "AI responses may include mistakes."
But this is the typical big tech modus operandi. If it destroys democracy, incites hate, or whatever, it's always the user fault for misusing/misunderstanding value-neutral tech. "Guns don't kill, people kill", yet in all countries that have gun control, gun deaths are much lower.
Besides that, in AI overviews reputable sources (e.g. good news papers) get mixed up with random Reddit comments, etc. In pure search, people develop an intuition to assign a confidence score to sources. (E.g. Wikipedia > some random Reddit comment or Tweet.)
They would in this case, because the content is available from Reddit and other social networks. "All About Berlin" was fundamentally just a nice organisation of things "every expat knew" about living in Berlin. Now AI can know things "everyone knows", the marginal benefit of a website is low for most casual users. It's still useful to the core market of fresh-off-the-plane expats, and maybe he can pivot to targeting them specifically.
I think Reddit (or an equivalent) will always exist, because people want a place to talk to other humans anonymously on the internet. And Reddit's data will always be accessible to AI labs, because that's Reddit's whole monetisation strategy.
Now reddit increasingly requires a login to read, and it's completely left out of Claude answers. Reddit has the same issue as All About Berlin right now.
I've been a long-time reddit user, had an account for 15+ years.
These days, Reddit just isn't the same anymore. The talk aspect is drying up, and it is clear there's a lot of AI involvement in discussions - I'm not talking 'user has had AI rephrase their own thoughts', but 'user is an ai'. Eventually, Reddit will dry up.
I also admit, I welcome it. Maybe we can stop using the web as a money-generating venture and go back to a more private web. Fewer users, but more connection.
So much of reddit is already bots. Even posts about hating AI are clearly written by an LLM. I think the online places that will remain predominantly human will be strongly-moderated, small, closed groups that will not be indexed by search engines and not accessible to LLMs.
> "All About Berlin" was fundamentally just a nice organisation of things "every expat knew" about living in Berlin.
I think this is selling allaboutberlin.com short. There is e.g. a tax calculator (I just had a cursory look, but it seems to get the basics right). It seems to be actively curated and much better organized than a whole bunch of threads with statements of facts intermingled with opinions and rumors you'd find at a social media site.
The organisation is genuinely great. But if you need just one answer, the AI will be a better UI than even the best organised site, not least because it can also join all the threads from around the internet together and synthesise them in a superhuman fashion.
I slightly disagree here. Many of the things on the website come from interviews with experts, or from collecting data directly.[0] This information was not on the internet. Hell, even immigration experts are often confused about things. We have a group chat where we help each other out. I had to create that community.
I created that website in direct response to all the incorrect information on Reddit and in Facebook groups. In the absence of official information, you are bound to find a lot of rumours. I used to be pretty active on the /r/berlin subreddit and boy oh boy were they wrong about a lot of things.
When I travel, I have a similar experience with more obscure border crossings. The information about them is generally incorrect, and you end up with a dozen websites parroting the same incorrect source. Curation involves checking the information.
The AIO gives more or less the same answer as you for the permit question, without ever citing you[1]. They instead cite ESCP, ServicePortal Berlin, Expats in Wonderland, Proforg, r/berlin, the Aussies in Germany FB group and Visaguard. Your data collection effort is cool and impressive, and makes it easy to recommend your site as a one-stop-shop for new expats; but to answer the question, you are sufficient but not at all necessary.
It is interesting to think about whether we will lose some key sources of information if AIs snipe all the easy queries that can be answered from multiple sources, leaving not enough traffic for the people who were generating the data to live off (because they were cross-subsidising the hard work with traffic to their easily reproducible work). I guess one option is more paywalling for the stuff that requires hard work (i.e. the way news/blogs went, and also the way this used to work, when people would buy a book to guide them on a move to a new city).
EDIT: just noticed the Reddit post cited is actually you! I can see the rationale for citing Reddit/HN comment threads over the page itself, but it also feels a bit like citation-washing.
Just because AI Overview doesn't cite All About Berlin specifically, that doesn't disprove that All About Berlin contributed to the generated answer.
I don't know the details of how Google AI Overview tracks data provenance, but I don't think they have an accurate way of tracing the provenance of data in their model weights.
If the value fluctuates much, then the value baked into the model will be unreliable, though? I don't think that the answer here comes from the model's intuition, but rather from the search results it got from a tool call. Especially because it's a clear paraphrase of those cited sources.
Berlin (Service Berlin) is getting its data for me. It has started adding it to its own pages, but a year or two ago it did not collect nor share that data. I have direct sources confirming it.
It's always been possible to trivialize such efforts by framing it as "every target audience member knows" if you just twist target audience definition to your liking.
Not to say of course models appropriate and resell information that just one person ever wrote about.
The quality of most sites is abysmal, mostly due to ads (content repackaging etc).
Trying to find answers today means wading through oceans of garbage websites instead of meaningful ones. Only to maybe find honest sites. That choice is by design, as search engines can shape the internet the way they see fit. They now seem to cut out the good results and make everyone pay more. “Neutral” answers where every tech bro tries to game the results for more cash.
AI answers have removed that enormous friction and constant source of frustration, also at the cost of the few good sites that are left.
Allegedly only to repeat this enshittyfication process once again. Tangentially we currently might be living in the best iteration of AI. Sure the answers can be sometimes awful and wrong, but they are mostly honest, direct, undiluted and try to be truthful.
Perfect example. Usually when I would Google something like this, it would point at absolutely sloppy sites with tons of ads and fluff content to stuff seo keywords before getting to the point.
The problem with this is "garbage in, garbage out". Deterioration of search engines has already leaked into AI and full on slop results are what dominate many of such "ai summaries". At the same time, reddit gets more and more dominated by bots that in the future will probably make it an even worse source of information for these "summaries". Ime AI without a good source of information/ground truth to link at is either useless or too expensive.
People here complain about SEO infested, low quality sites but these are exactly what gets into the context of the ai summaries.
The paradigm shift we are living through is about leverage. It's akin to the printing press insofar as guilds literally lost much of the leverage to control pricing when printers would give away "how to do things" in pamphlets. Reselling the information the guilds had developed.
This will be economically devastating. It was back then. The question changes to how value can be created moving forward. The world in which information becomes free -- in literally every case -- creates a more prosperous world. How and whether that prosperity gets distributed equitably is the concern.
The fact that the tech industry has not unionized, because of their profound leverage over the last 30 years is unfortunate, but times have changed and we need to move forward. Businesses built on scalability may die, heck the open models my even kill off the brand name models.
People will still need to buy things. Developing ways to provide those things will still be valuable. Creative destruction marches onward.
The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
But AI summaries are pretty much indistinguishable from that. The search engine is the user-agent in this case. The user's actual desire is to get the information, and their agent (the search engine) is providing them an easier way to do it. The only differences are that it's on-by-default for 90% of the users rather than opt-in at 25% market share, and that there's no pro-forma page fetch of the content that could in principle be rejected by the site.
And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to. There's a lot of reasons for why the status quo would have been preferrable, while the only real reason for a change is that the status quo was not tenable and they would have lost share to the sites giving users what they wanted.
The situation is a lose-lose, but it was also the logical outcome of saying that the end-user's wishes have total primacy over the other stakeholders.
> The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
I'd argue that the vast majority of HN has always been against tracking, and against obtrusive ads. Ad blocking is only necessary because the former and latter seem to be the only way of doing ads.
> And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode.
> We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to.
Couldn't it be that Google thinks it can make more money in the long run by putting themselves even more between the user and websites with AI summaries? It could also be that they want to project their AI to new users, and that the summaries are effectively ads for using Gemini.
I personally don't believe that AI summaries are what users truly want. At least for me: I despise them for how often they are wrong or disregard the context, and how often they seem to take information of copycat Q/A websites.
Websites with the level of quality like All About Berlin were rare before AI, but I think Google will also shoot itself in the foot if it doesn't compensate its sources properly, as quality sources like this will cease to exist.
> I'd argue that the vast majority of HN has always been against tracking, and against obtrusive ads. Ad blocking is only necessary because the former and latter seem to be the only way of doing ads.
So where is the popular ad-blocker that exempts "good" ads and analytics?
If you inspect those ads on this site they are just images wrapped in a hyperlink. Those types of ads do not bother me. I block ads because Google has no right to know what I do on sites they do not control.
It's also the logical outcome of a very hostile, any-abuse-is-acceptable web. People are happy with the AI overview because their experience going through to actual links is often an incredibly negative experience.
Dickovers, teasers, paywalls, cookie banners for 976 partners, auto playing video at full volume, a hijacked browser history, and on and on...oh and now the fact that they looked at that content is going to follow them to Facebook, LinkedIn, and so on.
And if you deal with all of that, often it was SEO-maxxed content that had human bots scalp from other sites. Sites that didn't invest in the "get to the top of the front page" SEO spamming and who made the actual content that just got stolen never got the love in the first place, in many cases.
On Apple mobile devices, forced to use the Safari browser whether reskinned or not, the internet is an especially hostile place. On my iPhone I basically don't go to URLs I don't know, despite having weak ad blockers in place.
The web we accepted as normal basically set the stage for this. Users are conditioned to wince at following a link. We made our bed by allowing this to become the norm.
I know of someone who lost their job in journalism, not because they are using AI to write but because the site is completely starved of traffic now.
Long term, with the current state of affairs, why would people continue to create online if it just feeding the machine? Surely we are not going back to paper?
That said, Private Eye never went online and is a successful publication.
>why would people continue to create online if it just feeding the machine?
That’s precisely the reason I stopped posting anything useful or creative online. Obviously all the things I posted before have been scraped, but who could have known that the collective digital output of humanity will just be stolen like that.
I will add something unrelated to tech to that - I have a love for photographing architecture with telephoto lenses, taking advantage of the background compression effect which creates stunning and unusual visuals, especially when the Sun or the Moon are in the background - it takes a lot of planning and luck to execute such a shot.
That was the last thing I was posting online, but I stopped doing that, too, because I mostly get comments about how it’s fake/AI generated. Quite sad. I still enjoy doing that, only that it’s just for me now.
Doesn't help that good-quality and bad-quality journalism cost the same, look the same (even after you buy them) and there's much more of the latter. Classic market for lemons.
They are not, and this will be the death of the internet and downstream it will also kill the LLMs. LLMs kill themselves by posioning their own food (data). The net result of this LLM craze will be that we lose the valuable internet. Once again we reveal how incredibly short-sighted people and capitalism is.
To be fair, the website in question is highly recommending banks with an affiliate link first - banks that are in hot waters for violating anti money laundering regulations. If your business model is so dependant on a third party you have absolutely no control over, it wasn’t really a good business to start off with.
And yes, LLMs will eat the lunch of any information-only sites that don’t anchor their audiences somehow.
I mean I hate deutsche bank as much as the next person but criticizing a content creator for using referrals is unfair. It’s great referrals and ads could fund so much useful research in the past hundred years. What comes next?
LLMs will eat their lunch, not realizing it's actually eating itself. Once these information-only websites are gone, since they can no longer monetize, all that will be left will be the thousands of AI-generated websites. On top of that, Google search is practically useless today because of the amount of LLM websites, so we're forced to use LLMs to search, exacerbating the problem.
The problem is that a lot of companies/websites will already have been destroyed and society ripped apart by a post-fact world. Chances are that Google won't even be hurt by it, because together with some other big-tech companies they completely control the information that is fed to people.
Ultimately, I think there will be a business for providing accurate, up-to-date information to LLMs. It probably won't be high-margin, though, and I don't think we're there yet.
Sure it will end the digital age as we know it, but we'll have great shareholder returns for the next few years. That's a problem for the poor people of tomorrow!
So these LLMs, which rely entirely on either being trained to have the knowledge already, or being able to search these sites to find the knowledge, are going to "eat the lunch" of these sites, killing them.
Which means LLMs are then going to... what, exactly? How are they going to be able to answer these questions in the future? It's an easy answer, so I'll answer for you - they're not going to be able to. They'll have only stale training data and outdated, abandoned websites to search, if the owners bother to keep them online. The web will get worse, and LLM-based search will get worse, too.
It was a fine business model for a long time (steady traffic increases for 7 years? I'll take that), but who could have foreseen where we are today seven years ago?
Having migrated myself, there is often very limited choice for banking as only the larger banks have processes and support for new arrivals and English language speakers (which is explained on that page). There isn't much choice between a bad bank and no bank. Sometimes people switch later, when they can.
It's the bank I use since 2016. It's fine. The main concern though is not finding a GOOD bank - they all kind of suck - but finding a bank that accepts immigrants that don't have the right combination of passport, residence permit and Anmeldung.
Why would I care if my bank violates AML regulations? Actually that makes them a better bank in every way, because AML regulations are a huge pain in the ass.
May I propose an alternate way of thinking of this?
Internet advertising is a bubble; ad blockers were the canary in the coal mine; and AI summaries are the straw that broke the camel's back.
In this case, the "mom and pop" websites like All About Berlin probably need to find a different revenue source or publishing model. This, BTW, is "normal." In years past, "All About Berlin" might be an annual printed guide, a monthly magazine, a quarterly pamphlet, ect, ect.
All about berlin is an incredible resource. Helped me a lot when I moved from the bay area to Berlin and also with all the constant visa procedures post move.
I'm working on something[1] similar to All About Berlin but for Hamburg. Instead of going with a website, I went with an app. Sure, it is hard to reach more people but at least, I don't have to deal with this kind of situation and I can create a much better experience.
People (authors etc) are understandably upset about this. The models CLEARLY trained on data where they didn't own the IP. It just sort of happened too fast for laws to catch up, and now it just is what it is.
But let's assume for a moment that laws caught up. That courts decided that "no, you can't train an AI model by just scraping any content you want, and if you serve an AI model that suggests being trained on such content, you're also breaking the law".
What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?
But what if this is the "right" thing to do? Are we incapable of doing what's "right" now? Did the AI companies' bets on being quicker than legislation pay off?
> What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?
Yes? There's going to be a cataclysmic change to the economy when the money runs out anyway. Why should these brand new companies who skirted and ignored the law get a free pass. Is it really sensible to have environment where you can become too-big-to-fail in less than a decade because a dozen guys with cash decided it should happen?
If we outlaw these models, but Chinese companies don't, then companies like Deepseek who offer models based on it would need to be banned in the west just like the sale of conterfeit Gucci bags is. It's just fair trade policy. But the end result of that is basically that we accept that "western" models, and the models available to all of western industry are much worse than what Chinese companies use. E.g. Chinese software development firms get Opus 5.5 level AI help, while everyone at US software firms get AI agents that are 2023 level. Those US firms would quickly realize that offshoring pays massively.
You don't just ban the unethical technology but also ban imports of goods created with it. The same is true with other immoral "tools" that greatly benefit companies like slaves or just dumping your waste wherever or mixing in unhealthy chemicals into your food to make it look better.
In the end, I think it would be extremely difficult to have such a "taint" rule for (for example) software. It would essentially be a complete ban with cooperation with companies outside the great-ai-wall of the west. Having a management consultant from India? big no no because his recommended reorg might have run through Deepseek.
I don't think this is about training, it's about creating an "AI summary" specific enough for a particular query, that the user never clicks the citation link and visits the website.
Yes they're two related things. Google always crawled and indexed, and an index could always show a "summary" e.g. the first paragraph of the page in search results. Some news outlets were upset even before AI that the summaries were too long/detailed that users never had to click.
An Ai just supercharges that problem. The "AI summary" can basically leave people with no reason to click the link.
The other thing is the "AI answers", i.e. when there is an answer at the top of a search result which answers the search query as an LLM answer, potentially wiht some links etc. That could suggest it's actually taken from training data rather than just page summaries.
Whe should absolutely "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses if they are making things worse for everyone else. Not doing that sends the message that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail. That would be an even more devastating position for society to take.
> that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail
That’s exactly the world we live in though, and have for a long time.
Why are we still burning fossil fuels on the scale we do? Why are we still selling cigarettes and alcohol on the scale we do? We are we still giving so many subsidies to tech businesses, or older businesses (like Walmart, McDonalds etc) through food stamps? Why is the orange man still in charge of destroying the civilized world despite so breaking so many laws and open corruption? Banks bailed out after they get in trouble by being reckless and breaking the financial system?
The list is endless. Rules don’t apply if you have enough money.
Here's the simple answer: these models were trained on the sum total of human knowledge, so they belong to humanity.
The judge rules that they are exempt from all intellectual property and trade secret laws, the labs must publish the weights and all the documentation needed to write an engine, and the labs' employees are indemnified from any adverse action for leaking anything their employers withheld.
The crime of stealing all our data has been committed but at the very least they could be forced to remove information from the training data when requested.
The thing about the Google AI overview that I find most baffling is how self-defeating it is. You kill the traffic to sites, the sites die, now you don't have anything for your AI summary to pull from. Also Google is an ad company, they're literally removing their own revenue sources by reducing clicks.
Google's stock actually crashed because costs are up and ad revenue is down specifically because of the search results AI, but they still haven't learned.
Learned what? If that overview wouldn't be there people would just flock to Anthropic or ChatGPT even more than they do now.
Search and Ads on websites are getting eaten alive by LLMs. No one knows how to properly monetize AI search yet but VC funds don't care they keep pumping money into OpenAi and Anthropic
So either Google has to cannabalize their search revenue or get eaten by OpenAI and Anthropic while they figure out how to turn a profit.
They know, they've always known. There was a post years ago back when AI was emerging from one of google SEO public relations people who basically articulated that what's happening now would kill the ad supported search model they'd been running since google was founded.
The issue is, OpenAI came on the scene and forced their hand. If Google doesn't do what they're doing then OpenAI or Anthropic becomes the new google search.
So they must adapt or die.
As to how new information gets into the LLM's, my guess is instead of being on the web it gets split up across multiple places. Youtube for edutainment, apps for controlled access to relevant specifics, but ultimately there will no longer be a single openly accessible text version of new information anymore because all the incentives to create something like that are gone.
Relying on Google for traffic was never a great strategy and I learned this the hard way myself. I have a website that produced ad revenue for very little work and used just make a big chunk of my income until about 15 years ago when Google traffic just collapsed, and that was that.
Its not AI, its big tech control that is the central problem.
I recommend everyone try the example search for themselves (best german bank account for foreigners) and look at everything in the first SERP.
On DDG I get All About Berlin as #6. All the sites above it appear to be LLM generated. Everything is affiliate slop.
On Google I get All About Berlin #2, below Reddit. It only gives me 7 standard search results and a lot of other garbage. Everything besides Reddit is affiliate slop.
On Kagi I get All About Berlin #1. Out of the other 25 results one is Reddit, one is Facebook, and the rest seem to be all the same list style as All About Berlin with a mix of clearly LLM generated content and some that may have been but isn't clear. It's all SEOed.
This is a case where all the results are bad. I don't ever want to be recommended something from an affiliate site. It's just another form of advertising. I also don't want to see any LLM generated sites. None of this is organic content. It's all SEO sites to sell you stuff.
Intellectual property rights came into being to address the free-rider problem — patents, trade secrets, copyrights.
We might need a new form of IP right.
But to restate the obvious: A new form of IP right would likely require legislation — at the federal level. Therein lies the problem: Pretty much all elected officials spend (too) much of their time dialing for dollars for their reelection campaigns. That can make them reluctant to enact, or even endorse, measures that are opposed by their big campaign donors.
To be fair, Google’s been suffocating search for years, before AI. Actual search results have been pushed below the fold for a long time, if you happen to not use an adblocker.
The usual advice is "do GEO now" and optimize to get cited in the AI answer. I'm not sure that saves a site like this. Even when you get cited, almost nobody clicks the link, because the whole point of the answer is that you don't have to. Being the source the AI uses and being a business are separate things now.
Don't you click the link because you want the actual truth instead of the AI summary? Plus more information around the answer, details the AI left out etc.
The outcome is the same: you get no traffic, then your website dies. It's hard for individuals to combat monopolistic behaviour.
Reddit is a far more powerful player, and they are facing the same fate. Currently, they're blocking Claude, and it just means that their content isn't surfaced in Claude's response. Does it benefit reddit? Probably not.
Regardless of who provides what resource, the fundamental question is: is a static guide a better way to support people who want to learn about Berlin, or is the AI bot derived from that static guide better. Once you remove hallucinations from the evaluation (2024, what a crazy time, right?) it's pretty clear the bot wins, right?
That sucks for the content creator, I know. We're heading for a crazy pace of change, similar to but more intense than when Walmart was busy killing downtown shops, or when Amazon was busy killing bookstores and other internet retailers.
How does the bot win? Rephrasing or paraphrasing means that the reader loses some precision and context that the author intended you to read. Summaries often lose advice that you did not ask for, but still need to receive. Think "I know you're asking about X, but since you're on that journey, you really ought to also do Y and Z".
Newspapers aggregated public info and got wiped out. What would make you think online info aggregators wouldn't get wiped out too?
If you aggregate something, AI will aggregate a thousand times better than you
It's time for horseback messengers to understand that cars and planes deliver info faster and better than them, and that applies to ALL branches of work
If it can be replaced by AI it will be, so be prepared and don't complain
This is a quite miopic comment and the analogy does not work.
When cars and planes arrived, the horseback messenger still had everything he had before. Nobody stole his horse. Instead, others offered a superior service and while it sucked for his livelihood, what was taken from him was opportunity, not the fruit of his labor.
AI takes what we all did for the community and profits from it. Google did not compile better information than the website. It stole it and is profiting from it.
Newspapers also created new info by employing all sorts of journalists. That is sort of the crux of the story here (who will collect this information and report it when there is no financial opportunity there anymore).
Recipe sites did that to themselves with their cancerous AEO shenanigans. Three pages of useless background drivel before I get to the recipe just so it ranks. The AI will get me a recipe, adjust it to what I have at home, help me with any cooking questions and so on, it's a better value proposition as a user, it is what it is.
I think they only did this because Google prioritized it. Google could have easily spent some human effort to promote “good” recipe sites, but they were lazy and didn’t.
It sounds like Google did that by giving the owners wrong incentives. I suspect as ads starts to infect AIs more and more you will see similar crap that will make the results less and less useless.
> The AI will get me a recipe, adjust it to what I have at home
Unless it doesn’t. I’ve had AI come up with very… interesting recipes that ended up in the trash can because they were 100% hallucinated and didn’t work in the real world.
Recipe sites were already disastrously bad, though -- thousands of words of intro and fluff before the recipe, presumably to create more space for the ads.
Aside from the bot countermeasure arms race? Vicious litigation and collective bargaining/lobbying. No way around it, there never was. Unless to you "rolling over" is an acceptable, or even necessary, solution for your particular case, or in general.
We track the W3C's TDM Reservation protocol uptake, and I'm surprised it's so low, we only see it on 1,113 sites ( last month ), 1,876 sites this month.
Yeah is funny - I thought it was a standard when I added the check for it, just people jumping on it!
From Google search console "LLMS.txt files and other "special" markup: You don't need to create new machine readable files, AI text files, markup, or Markdown to appear in Google Search (including its generative AI capabilities), as Google Search itself doesn't use them."
World is changing. Websites once killed the need of magazines and many types of books too..
I rather look at it as an opportunity to demonopolize Google as I do exactly the same (overviews and insights) I just find Google Gemini obsolete as I find better AI solutions where I can check for knowledge and information.
Open Web has a lot of content that was crawled before and I really hope that all that SEO/Traffic hunting nonsense stops to benefit Google towards major regression. They are so 00s company and we're heading towards 30s of XXI century.
Don't you feel it is a shame that the open web is being killed by the greed of companies like Google and OpenAI?
I do think honestly that we lost a lot in losing the book publishing industry, which is now a shadow of its former self - all those talented editors and illustrators didn't find work elsewhere doing their job, the jobs just ceased to exist, and the curated ideas they used to produce now doesn't exist either. For now we're feeding off the achievements of the past, ripped from old books to scan, but what happens to truth and beauty when LLMs can't distinguish either and are fed on their own pap?
What is the alternative to the open web for sharing information with other humans? How do you see this playing out?
Or go back to talking to other people? ;) Over the last couple of years I've been increasingly reaching out to friends and asking for recommendations on different topics.
It's inefficient and doesn't give an immediate response, but the quality and depth of what I've learned this way is amazing. And it's probably saved me hours of reading through marketing AI slop pushed all over the internet these days.
that's exactly what I have done years ago and long before AI came in. I stopped using Google and I found it's actually not that relevant in digital space as I thought it could be.
Think about what's coming next after the mega corps have assimilated all data in their private vaults. The next step is to go on q crusade to get the free Internet and the data they feasted on nuked from the web so that people have no choice but to rely on them.
You can expect something like browsers (chrome) refusing to load "unsafe" content i.e. material from the free Internet.
Yes! I'm very close to people who operate that way. I have the best possible network to make it happen. Unfortunately, it's a fickle, bureaucratic way of earning a living.
All About Berlin is amazing, it has helped me a lot when moving here, there’s immense value in having a curated, regularly updated, always reliable source of information. I hope it can survive and also hope similar projects can survive.
I was expecting to read about AI scrapers but it's not, it's about Google taking away their traffic by providing AI overviews. Something that's happening to many websites.
its important to distinguish between training and agentic search both have similar effects but with very different solutions. for training we need licensing rules that apply to small content not just the studios that can afford the lawyers, websites provide payment and licensing terms for training access and training systems decide if they want to skip the content or pay. for agentic access its hard to imagine an alternative to micropayments similar to what cloudflare is experimenting with. i dont think a future where search results or recommendations will be visited directly much again is realistic.
Never blame the technology. Focus on the people, or in this case the corporations wielding that power. It is in their best interest not to cause an extinction event of the ecosystem they thrive on. Currently they (Google etc) are merely leaching on the ecosystem without giving anything in return (destructive). Ideally, you reach symbiosis where there is a net positive result for both sides, ie. enough money flows back one way or another to the content creators you depend on. Either way, eventually this will come back to bite them, but in the mean time the ecosystem, maintained and built by real people, are the ones feeling all the hurt and it's a very sad state of affairs.
We need a new internet that can be protected by LLMs reading or writing it. And in general find a way to isolate the world from big tech by creating competitive products. I feel like if a lot of talented people got together we can do this.
why do it without invasive identity checks? Everything posted should be tied to a real world identity so that people own their words. Kind of like real life is :D
Because there are bad people out there who abuse this. If you think a false DMCA takedown is bad, imagine when they know your physical address. You don't know theirs, of course.
It's all running on fear anyhow. The companies using it are frightened that a competitor using AI more than them might outcompete. The leadership push that fear down till you're scared about saying anything ... and many people have a mortgage and perhaps didn't get their latest job that easily.
You can see how the doom stories coming out of the AI companies themselves are rather calculated to engender the feeling that he who is not first to somehow get onside will be crushed by the giant machine. Only the true zealots might survive etc.
I am in a position right now to determine which developers will be staying with the client's business in 2027. I can assure you that we absolutely will. There is a contingency to start over with a completely new team.
> Everything you do is a choice.
I agree. You can choose to be more moderate.
The #1 reason we are looking to off board certain developers is because of this exact extreme ideological position regarding AI.
I feel I should point out the irony of asking people "to be more moderate" while, simultaneously, being ready to fire your entire technical team for not agreeing with your decision.
We just went through our second redundancy cycle in 9 months. In the space of 3 years my team has gone from 30 people to 5. The job market is so terrible I've got ex colleagues who lost their job 9 months ago still can't find a job. I mostly keep my head down but a lot of the people who didn't get onboard with ai were those same ones who lost their jobs. As well as their interview process involving ai and how they use it. Id love to stand up and not use it but unfortunately I have a mortgage and children to feed.
Into what? It's impossible to predict what's not going to be impacted by ai - and those fields are going to become incredibly more competitive and lower paid as everyone pivots to them.
We live in a capitalistic society, it's irresponsible to think that any individual or even group of people have control of this situation. Money will drive this to a point of either the government stepping in or the end of humanity, possibly both.
More broadly, AI is killing the affiliate link and the ad-supported business model. As an AI user I love using AI, because it gives me what I seek (answers) and it takes a minuscule amount compared to what the previous systems took.
While I have never used it, All About Berlin seems like an exceptionally good resource, not showing ads, but rather making its money by driving traffic with good information and having partnerships with affiliate links.
Other than this, most of the ad-supported web I greatly dislike. Usually the noise drowns the signal, because websites competed not on the goodness of information, but the SEO rankings. I have been blocking ads since 2005 and I never used affiliate links either, so from my very narrow individual perspective, I was never a valuable visitor in the first place.
It would be great if the quality sites like AAB could get another stream of revenue that makes them sustainable, even in the AI age. I'm afraid they run into a similar problem to monetizing open source software. At the end of the day, if the information is out there, people and corporations will take it, and not contribute anything back. That won't change, so it needs to be factored in somehow.
Wecome to the club. I managed a somewhat successful community website from 2003 and by 2018 it became a shadow of itself as users flocked to Facebook, Instagram and the likes.
Do you think there is hope for small communities in 2026? I would love to launch a forum around All About Berlin because Facebook and Reddit are terrible in different ways.
It's a big weakness in our econmies that we have let Google monopolize user acquisition to the point where most online businesses are dependent on them.
To be honest I'm guilty of using AI for many things I used to use websites for. News (with web-searched sources and citations), Recipes, Exercise routines, Managing my emails
Why? because its a better user experience. It's that simple. News sites in particular (but websites in general) are ad infested hellholes or paywalled to the point of uselessness. An AI app is a single source of pretty much anything I need, for a relatively small monthly subscription and no ads. I can even have claude just build an artifact if I want the data rendered in a nice readable website
If traditional web wants to compete it needs to be a better product first and foremost. People need to pick it over an AI app
I can relate somewhat to the guy's situation, however I have no sympathy for him. The same things happened multiple times to me but already 20 years ago: boards, blogging.
I established once a well-known and used board in a niche, several blogs - and filled in the void that the major publishers later began to steal or recover from me, whatever truth there is, due to their brand power and marketing.
Due to Technorati and Digg as well as other bookmark exchanges/sharing services like StumbledUpon dying, I lost traffic and had to shift. The single best source of readers was: Google search.
So I had to consider SEO, which already had an impact on my work because either you adapt and optimize or do you thing and stay alone.
Even taking SEO into considerations, others did this, too. And as a rule of thumb: the winner takes it all. Everything below being the first link to be featured ment loss. And SEO was a rollercoaster between no visitors at all and being slashdotted so to say.
The truth is, that Google search never was and is a reliable source of income.
"Made for Google search" has never been a viable business model.
And the truth is: this has nothing to do with AI.
Back then people copied your websites and due to black hat went above you in the search results. And eben Matt Cuts killing quite a lot of the spam and fake websites, Google search stayed a rollercoaster.
I think that in the aftermath quite a few people will hopefully understand, that being featured and having a readership is not the same. Websites and blogging was a niche topic in the beginning. Even AdSense hasn't been invented. People wrote and publicized their stuff because of the exchange with others and their interest in writing in public as an author.
Now with AI it is similar with the book marked: the winners take it all, while the beginners have to fight for every reader - and convince them of their product.
I don't feel sorry for the guy because search views are no readership. Search clicks are like the AI ironically: click and gone with no value given at all.
I think that the troublesome aspect about AI is, is its sudden omnipresence and extreme capability: earlier there was the saying "Have you googled this?". Now you literally don't have to read something, you get a top notch concierge service to skip reading and directly get results bypassing thousands of experts because AI is better than anyone of them as a generalization.
This didn't happen gradually, it happened in stark waves.
No one thought Google search would ever be dying nor getting outranked.
Loyal readers are never coming from Google nor any other search engine. The guy's story is honestly a story of bad conversion it seems: after years of traffic gains, loyal readership didn't increase. I feel sorry about his work but he shouldn't blame Google.
It was Google that allowed the author’s website to have enough traffic to serve as his source of income in the first place. Google giveth, and Google taketh away.
At the top are the people with the power. At the bottom are the people who are tread on. But that's nothing interesting.
The more curious group is the middle one. They are paid by the top to help keep the bottom away from the top, or to keep the bottom giving money to the top or voting for the top, or sometimes to help members of the top compete with each other. In the Gervais model, they are the Clueless. People in the middle group often believe they have power but they do not. Cops also fall into this tier.
Google is in the top, and All About Berlin is in the middle. AAB only ever existed as an instrument for Google to funnel money towards Google, from advertisers and competitors. AAB was allowed to exist and its author was allowed to feel in control as long as he was fulfilling this purpose for Google. Once the tool no longer serves a purpose, it is discarded. In the Gervais model, the top group is called Sociopaths.
This dynamic appears to be playing out here in textbook form.
AI has many problems, but "I can not make recurring income from being a digital librarian" is not it.
> It’s hard to fund my work with only a quarter of my audience.
As someone who thinks that all the big issues of the digital economy are rooted in the misaligned incentives between consumers and producers, I think this is a great thing.
> The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves.
It's not your data, you just compiled it.
Plenty of people are doing that, for free, on Wikipedia.
And the motivation of the people doing it for free will be just as negatively affected by the machine eating up their hard labour as those who have been doing it for profit.
> people doing it for free will be just as negatively affected
Are you sure? Look at Wikipedia or Wikidata. Has the activity stopped since Google started showing snippets on the sidebar?
> affected by the machine eating up
The machine is not "eating up" anything. The website is still there. It's just now that it's not so easy to monetize people's eyeballs. This is a good thing.
> hard labour
It's not hard. If it were, people wouldn't be doing it voluntarily in the first place.
> those who have been doing it for profit.
That's the thing. Automation has been removing the value-add of a ton of jobs. We are only going to starting care about this now that we knowledge workers are starting to feel the heat?
If people want to make money from providing curation, then they need to charge upfront. Giving it for free and hoping to make up by some secondary activity leads to a race to the bottom.
I am sick of Americans not enforcing anti trust. Americans effectively get to do whatever the hell they want by enforcing a “free market” almost worldwide. A game they easily win as its rigged in favor of the richest country. Subsequently they refuse any anti trust for their tech “hyperscalers” allowing them to monopolize enabling insane margins. Then they pat themselves on the back and proclaim “American Exceptionalism”.
Also the irony of toolcalling is that the AI now uses search to be more accurate. Works great until it cooks all sources of truth. Wonder what the long term strategy looks like
Long term strategy is not to rely on a human-in-the-loop pipelines for data. Always sensing smart devices + 6G ISAC and other tech will capture raw world-data and LLMs will be used to interpret it.
It sure seems like a lot of it. When you join smart devices + self driving cars + ISAC + chat/social media + satellites you get quite a bit of coverage, especially once the rollouts are further along. Robust data markets are pretty critical to making all this stuff usable though.
What’s left? Underwater stuff, some stuff far from settlements that cant be picked up from satellites, stuff underground, stuff inside our heads, tactile sensations. And probably some more I haven’t thought of.
Of course our intrepid scientists and entrepreneurs are already chipping away at these gaps.
What bothers me, isnt that the AI overlords just stole everything as I enjoy having access to the info, whether its a book synopsis or what not.
What bothers me is that the guy who made Rediit, Aaron was some well meaning kid, who tried to download some journals, and he ended up being forced off this plane of existence for it.
I guess Im saying its not the use of the info that bothers me as much as how everyone is cool with it now but not before.
I have literally no idea why, I guess that bothers me.
It's ok, though, because if a big tech corporation decides to do it then that's just inevitable progress making the world better and you should change jobs. Except, according to them, all jobs will soon become obsolete and you're destined to be ruled by a feudalistic god-emperor.
That job only came into existence because people started thinking that writing content once and renting out space to that same big tech corporation was an ethical way to make a living.
Let me give another example from Barcelona. We were there and with no ticket two months in advance, we couldn't see Sagrada Familia. This is according to all easily accessible information at Google and with Claude researching.
Your only option is to pay weird middleman 10x the price for non-existent or shady tours.
Guess what - it was all wrong. Go there, buy a physical ticket for 2 days later. I think this is all going in the wrong direction. People with malicious intents fake the online data until nothing there is correct.
We saw this enshittification of social media already where it is all far-right now - both ownership and propaganda. People fell for this a few times, but reality hits eventually.
"Put simply, it shows immigrants how to adult in Germany their new country."
What? I suppose "Put simply, it shows immigrants how to adapt in Germany, their new country." is meant.
For the love of everything holy, people, please stop using spell check tools. One or two characters off is i) easy to spot and ii) the intended word usually obvious (at least it usually will be obvious that there is a typo). A helpfully corrected, but wrong word is more difficult to spot and makes the intended meaning hard to guess.
The answers in the screenshot are not even sourced from the site. Because "Use N26, duh" is an obvious answer to the question available from thousands of sources on the internet, and if the highest-quality ones turn off access there will still be hundreds more places confirming the same thing.
Google Ads showing Deutsche Bank and Commerzbank at top, two of the most bad guys in German financing! Involved in serious stuff regarding human rights or Russia. Fresh Hacker leak 2 days ago shows connections to unethical stuff I only knew from Swiss banks.
Best German ethical bank maybe: -> Tomorrow Bank based in Hamburg 100% digital, or
-> GLS Bank for those who care about others. ;)
Google was always bad to me so I ignored those ads with joy: a company promotes itself via Google? Then I don’t buy t you.
Others could follow.
We have the money. We decide. Then we might help those content creators/ Webhosters too.
Ethics might be a reason why you pick a bank, but you paint it a bit one dimensional. People pick bank accounts by various other factors like costs, cards, a branch close to their home, etc.
If I sign up for Deutsche Bank and receive interest am I taking money away from people who are doing human rights abuses? That seems like a good thing.
I looked at the main page. It seems like all this information should be provided at tax payers expense for the people. And an ai should then be used to sift through it as an aid to humans. So… i think we’ll be okay as long as the german government does its job. Perhaps ai can help them.
Nicholas, I would look into grants and public support. Your website is useful to Berlin in a way that the official ones are not but it does work thanks to an information organization gap. Trying to get hired to help the official resources fill the gap could be an option?
Bureaucratically very hard in Berlin, but going the Stiftung way might be an option
What scares me with the rise of synthetic content is that organic reviews, feedback, discussions have been all removed. Reddit is cut off and impossible to browse. What is coming are various "hate speech" and "anti defamation" regulations together with intensified lobbying for "digital ID" or similar.
The solution is becoming pretty simple, really: if you earn income / value from unique information only you can provide, it’s time to put that information behind a paywall.
Unfortunate for the dream of the open web, but smaller website/content creators are only reacting to what bigger companies are doing.
I won't be reading the web if I can delegate an agent to do it. Nobody is entitled to continued feasibility of their business model within which they publish.
That said, I think this site is awesome and it helped me a lot when I moved to Berlin two years ago.
>If my work just get mixed into an AI-generated answer, I lose my voice and my audience. My carefully chosen words lose their meaning. No one shakes my hand and buys me a beer. No one tells me how their citizenship application went.
As someone who writes for a living, I find this scenario both a fascinating challenge and a terrifying prospect. We've have many meetings about how to write our copy to ensure AI finds it unique enough, but succinct enough to steal for its own summaries, to give our narrative a fighting chance. Fortunately the core of our content is not easily summarized, so we're still getting passthough traffic. Moving to mobile first design years ago is paying dividends now- what few dividends there are to have, that is.
The web before AI wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows. So many websites were stuffing their pages with filler text to be ‘SEO-friendly,’ and the top results you clicked were full of affiliate links, unnecessarily long paragraphs, and, in some cases, misleading information.
Simple. Assume that you know one trustworthy website. It has a bunch of links to other websites that are similar and also verified by the website you're currently on. These websites of course want to be friendly to they link back. But they also link to other websites. In this way, you can discover an entire web of pages that are verified to contain quality material, by going through relevant topics like "travel” -> "travel to Germany" -> "expats in Germany" -> "expats in Berlin".
I have a strong feeling that someone has already invented this technology, but I cannot put my finger on it.
I think what you are describing is a link between two pages, but it's some kind of super-link, mega-link, maybe a hyper-link. And it forms a kind of mesh, net, or web of pages that spans the entire earth, the complete planet, the world wide.
If Google search results stop showing you real websites, what stops GMail from no longer showing you the real emails you receive, and instead fabricating things based on the highest bidder?
Sure, but the problem of the parasite killing the host remains. Once those business models stop working, this flow of information into the LLM stops or degrades, resulting in all around worse outcomes.
>this flow of information into the LLM stops or degrades,
Don't see this happening. Specialists sites like About Berlin are mostly about curating online data. I'm guessing that very little of that data is not already online somewhere.
LLMs become like dynamic RAG (DAG?), doing the same. Collating specialist info on whatever topic they specialize in.
Google now has to compete with open models and the low quality SEO slop we've had for years disappeard. Yay!
I think Google and rest of these companies really should be less greedy. If there is no-one visiting the websites and no-one writing them, where do your clankers find new information to feed to your ~marks~ users? In 5-10 years time, when you feed a new Berlin emigrant the best vegetarian restaurants of 2025, will they be happy with the service? So either the search bot should funnel customers via recommendations (”…And if you want to know more, allaboutberlin.com is a great site recommended often to people moving to Berlin first time…”) or AI companies should pay for the content they use.
Another thing that immediatedly came to me, so I believe thousands of others got the same idea: if you want to funnel propaganda and fake information into LLM’s to feed to the ever-so-naive public, now is your chance. Start a blog hiring couple of out-of-job writers - obviously you could use LLM’s, but I think human-written content will get higher in the results the LLM regurgitates in the future if not already - writing long-form prose on how pretty eyes Vladimir Putin has, how great the vegan restaurant -scene is in Tel Aviv or how pleasant bodily odor women say President Trump has. Or you can just funnel people to your buy goods from your scam sites.
Idk man, maybe we need to just bring paper books and newspapers back.
All signs are pointing towards the cannibalization of the open Internet. This is going to happen to pretty much every non-corporate website out there.
And ultimately, people will stop creating new content because it's not worth it for them to feed the BigCorp machine.
So in 20 years, AI content will be crap because there won't be enough up-to-date content to draw on. When I ask it to "plan me a 4-day hut-to-hut hike in the Dolomites" it'll be relying on data that's 20 years out of date.
The only up-to-date content will be stuff that profit-seeking companies will put out there (marketing materials). So "what's the best router for X" will be based on which companies were successfully able to get the LLM to train on their materials. Gaming the LLMs will become the new SEO placement race.
But hey, at least we get 10x faster coding (for those devs who still have a job) and OpenAI shareholders are happy. Hurrah!!
Looking at HN itself, the user choice for accessing paywalled information is looking for some "archive" site to skip it.
Many years of race to the bottom turned significant number of new sites into husks that strait up just republish everything from AP, only using AI to rephrase that source.
And lastly, just like it happened with streaming services, introducing paywalls doesn't mean all crap associated with ad-founded content will magically disappear (low quality, clickbait), and ads themselves will be back on site, to double dip.
1. paywall all of your content. even $1 US. The AI's won't touch it.
And unless you are a well-known newspaper or something like that, have your visitors drop to zero. Besides that, decades of internet ads have trained people that they get everything for free. It is not a bad idea, but it requires a cultural change and new discovery mechanism as well. Both are very hard.
Fully agree with point (2). If Google uses other sources to give answers, they should compensate those who wrote the material.
Besides that, the safe harbor provisions of the DSA should not be applied to AI overview and AI chatbot output. Make them responsible for generated output. Some judges in the EU have already taken this interpretation of the DSA - Google applies certain amount of algorithmic processing, so the safe harbor provisions do not apply anymore and they become responsible for their generated slop. E.g., in Germany, a judge held Google liable for fake AI answers [1]. Hopefully, this will make pushing slop in place of search results unprofitable some day.
> And unless you are a well-known newspaper or something like that, have your visitors drop to zero.
I'd rather have fewer visitors and a sustainable site than tons of visitors and an unsustainable site.
> decades of internet ads have trained people that they get everything for free
Most people won't pay. Forget them. There are enough people who will pay for high quality content. You just have to pick the right niche and provide great value. It's not rocket science. Many self-published authors earn a living off Amazon doing exactly this.
Good luck trying to get Google or tech giants to do anything. Take matters into your own hands.
There's a magazine in the UK called "Which?" and everyone who is trying to fill a new house with washing machines or whatever is inclined to find their link in search results. They have reviews and ratings of enormous numbers of products that are very useful and it's always from multiple points of view so you can decide what matters to you and it explains things too so that you can understand what is on offer better. They let part of their content out in public so you can start to see "oh, that's interesting" but the really serious nubs of most critical information are behind the paywall.
One is usually not a member forever but when you're spending 100s or 1000s of pounds on new equipment the 7/8 pound fee for a month is easily justifiable. The website still gets hits from people who only read the free content because it's still useful.
This actually happened. 10+ years ago a lot of news companies sued Google and Facebook for putting the summary of the news underneath the link so people didn't have to click on the link to know the news. They mostly won these suits, it was widely derided as a "link tax" and the "end of the internet"
So I am not sure, but the business around ads, were always something evil and not good for the internet, and quite frankly, maybe its not bad that its gone?
Google can win a lot of hearts if it can attribute eye balls back to source and give a bit of cut to source.
It it takes advice from all about Berlin and shows excerpts from the page clearly linking to it, without ads bullshit, then pass on some of that ad money.
Tech companies think they grow by sucking the air out of the room. They grow because they build platforms for more people to build more things and earn.
If AI gobbles up without giving back, they’re surely getting their ass regulated and taxed.
IMO that’s the Silicon Valley cult in a way. Break things, don’t care.
I'm afraid these creators will eventually have to move to social media, where their content isn't as easily scraped for data because these companies depend on keeping users on their platforms.
I hate it. I truly despise these platforms, but it's increasingly looking like the only option available.
When I moved from Dublin to Berlin in 2020, in the middle of the pandemic, this website helped me deal with a lot of bureaucracy. Moving to Germany involves very different processes compared to Ireland, so having clear, practical information in one place was extremely useful.
We actually hired a relocation agency to help us with the move, and they recommended this website as a resource for future reference. This could be an interesting opportunity for the creator to work more closely with relocation agencies, which could recommend the site directly to their clients.
The main problem I see with this business model is its dependence on Google Search traffic. Google is increasingly taking over this space with AI-generated answers, giving users the information they need without visiting the original websites.
The content is still valuable, but attracting visitors is much harder. Partnering with relocation agencies could be a good way to reach the right audience without relying so heavily on Google.
Looking at non-German immigration to Germany (so excluding German citizens returning). Immigration absolutely peaked in 2022/2023… over 2x the 2021 numbers.
On paper immigration in 2021 vs 2026 and the site usage is just slightly down from 2021. Could at least a partial cause be there are fewer prospective and fewer recent immigrants?
everyone in the scene hates the tourists so maybe it should stay that way.
Also they're getting shut down by their landlords at an alarming rate. Everything is, they just lost their last electronic parts store too. In 20 years the whole city will be clean corporate shiny white metal and glass, no individuality allowed.
How do you all feel about the situation?
Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
What do you mean with "these companies".
This here is about google, abusing their monopoly. So clearly not a good effect on society, but maybe a wake up call for some. And AI in general will replace jobs, can be good, can be bad, depending if those replaced find something more meaningful.
Meta does the same. OpenAI is trying the same (see Business Claim)
I'm pretty sure the same question from the google search has been asked on chatgpt too, the answer was in part derived from the article-writers website, but no users were directed there and no ads were served. Same for other ai chatbots where people ask stuff instead of google-for-websites and watch ads on those websites.
You see the issue as abusing monopoly? If there were more competitors with more chat bots, you think the situation would be better for All About Berlin?
If web search would not be controlled by one company, that can just change the rules any day and not link anymore, like they used to, yes I do see the issue here as abusing their monopoly. I don't want a chat box, when I am looking for a link. On the other hand, when I am looking for information, I do ask claude nowdays to find me sources. But I ain't the majority.
Everything was fine with google, as long people were earning with ads, now that google change their main product, its not fine anymore? I guess its just time to find a new business idea?
Google was fine to me, when they were one of many search engines - and offered the best experience. Clean empty search page - clear results, ads in between clearly marked.
This specific case is of course a net negative for society I think. At the same time... It's 100% worth the money I pay each month. It allows me to create things I couldn't on my own. It helps me learn new skills. It saves tons of time while searching.
Corruption gives great benefits to the people who use it.
It feeds families, it gives people luxurious lifestyles. It provides incredible opportunities.
But it also ruins everything for everyone.
Corruption is a word that has meaning. Using it to equate it with paying for a subscription for a tech service completely destroys that meaning.
I could use any example where a beneficiary of literally any kind of service causes some real or perceived harm to some real or perceived group of people and equate it with corruption.
AI is a tool. It's massively useful and people pay for that. It's our economy that's broken.
I don't think the person above is saying "this is literally corruption", they're just using corruption as an example of behaviour that is financially beneficial to the person or group doing it and harmful to society at large.
Yes, that's my point. They are using the word in a way that morphs it into "something good for a specific individual but generally harmful" or something.
No useful information is conveyed beyond "AI is bad for society" so I'd rather just mention that instead of bringing the loaded word "corruption" into it.
what's wrong with our economy?
I think there are analogies between corruption and the broader LLM phenomenon, as it's playing out.
It degrades truth, quality, trust, and reliability. It feeds off the work of people who do things the correct way. People know there are big problems, but constantly point to short term benefit. People deride people who take a principled stand and say, "you think things were good before? Nothing's perfect, relax and enjoy it. Adapt or die." They laugh at people who try to do things correctly and say it's "impossible in this day and age."
Yes, there are parallels, especially if you consider the broader LLM phenomenon as it is playing out, as you said. I think I agree.
But that does not automatically mean that those parallels stem from the nature of the AI technology. Corruption is related to moral or aesthetic or other values: someone does something for their own gain but which makes things worse in general (in moral, aesthetic, or some other sense). But AI is just a technology, and it is not clear that all its uses must lead to corruption. In fact, I believe that it is a technology that could cause a lot of good. If handled correctly.
Its corruptive effects are results of how our societies work; I don't think AI is to blame, we are.
>Its corruptive effects are results of how our societies work; I don't think AI is to blame, we are.
Isn't this the issue exactly - that unregulated AI is glaringly obviously resulting in harmful behaviours, and we are failing to regulate this in a responsible way to shape its use and outcomes?
Similarly, the notion of corruption is (as you say) related to moral and aesthetic considerations. For example: Helping your friends by doing favors for them is widely considered good and pro-social! But there's some ways of helping your friends that might be nepotism, or even corruption if it unjustly or harmfully warps some social process.
For that reason, we have legal frameworks to manage it and moral/social sanctions against obvious offenders. Exactly where AI requires social, moral or legal regulation is socially produced and reproduced continually, as with any other phenomenon. But we need to figure this one out fast because it's breaking a lot of things very fast.
Thank you! Yes, I think you are right.
> It helps me learn new skills
Are you sure? Like, we learn most stuff just by doing it. If you delegate doing it to the LLM, how do you learn?
Helping != Offloading
They help tremendously. Can explain concepts in your language, at your skill level. Can help you explore codebases, that might be outside of your deptph. Can visualize complex topics in seconds. Can create interactive tutorials on the fly. And I could go on and on.
For me, they help me with the unknown unknowns. There's so many technologies one can use for all sorts of things nowadays, just asking an LLM "what should I consider for the DB for this app" etc. opens my eyes on various things.
They can't, of course, teach you things the same way Neo was thought Kung Fu :)
Why do you assume I delegate the doing to the LLM when I'm asking it to teach me something? For example... The socratic teaching skill that someone linked to last week works surprisingly well imo.
Sorry, with the context of using them to build stuff I understood you meant learning in the course of this process.
And stolen goods are also worth 100% the value you'd pay a fence for them. Because you're not paying what it actually cost to make those goods.
> just took all our work without paying us a dime
What are you on? If you worked you presumably got a salary.
I think you've completely misinterpreted what "work" refers to in that comment.
Conflicted is how I feel. The tools are undoubtedly useful, I feel like I work on more intersting problems day to day now (rather than churning out boiler plate code) and will help us make technological progress that will benefit all of humanity (provided the benefit is distributed), and while I wish I'd chosen a career as a carpenter, because wood doesn't change like tech in the computer world does, I'm up for the challenge of figuring out how to adapt. But not everyone is, and the change, and the vacuuming up and re-vendoring of data (I'm not sure whether it's theft or not) is at best undemocratic - even national boundaries didn't stand a chance at controlling this. Ironically it was probably a predictable outcome of an 'open' internet.
> Conflicted is how I feel
You and me both! I think though, it helps to separate out LLMs as a technology in themselves, and the prospect of increased technological dominance from a few small tech companies, as a result of that technology.
I'm a lot more enthusiastic about the first than the second, I suspect a lot or people are similar.
I think everyone needs to fight to keep standards around AI tooling open, even if proprietary models are inevitable given the investment they take. AGENTS.md is a good example. Every Claude integration (Github CI etc), every shared artifact your boss comes to rely on entrenches us further. I think where possible all AI outputs need to be persisted in your own systems For example rather than have Claude create an artifact, have it create an HTML app / report in a repository you control. Make your own tools if you have to. I'm working on building a Formal Verification system for reviewing agent output into my notes / project management tool https://app.etherpk.com based on local markdown graphs for example.
It requires a LOT more effort, but all of my tooling is non-agentic and fully model independent. If necessary, I can swap it all out to local or private cloud services.
It results in a far more involved development process, which helps keep me in the loop but also has a big speed impact.
Not handing it all off to agents can trigger some FOMO. I'm not sure how long I can keep it up and still compete.
Hey totally agreed, having a system external to the LLM ecosystem already helps with being able to coordinate data between chats, different LLMs, etc, and it will likely be increasingly important as you say in maintaining control over your data in an age of increasingly more capable AI that tends towards keeping your data in formats that are platform biased by default like artifacts in Claude.
Also minor bit of feedback, on your webpage you use the term PKMS. I'm guessing it means Personal Knowledge Management System, but it could be helpful to define it in parentheses or explicitly.
Otherwise, the app looks interesting. I'm probably not the target segment as nowadays I'm building out a lot of my own custom systems that I find myself using day to day to have granular control of the system to make it super customized, but I could see it being interesting to people who currently use miro/obsidian/notion/etc.
> the prospect of increased technological dominance from a few small tech companies
Isn't it the goal of every player within a capitalistic game ? TBH I use to eat what bigFood teach me to at school, take the pills bigFarma lobbied my doctor with and consume whatever bigOil extracted. Sure, thinking is another field but it's not like we're not already sinking in energy, health and food distopia.
I'm pretty confident a carpenter's days are numbered too. Maybe if you're making some artisanal but for every day building it's only a matter of time before most things a carpenter could create and be build by robots or something. I expect in 5-20 years, robots will build houses and skyscrapers much faster than humans to do today.
No guarantees of that either though, the physical world is so complex and nuanced we may never get fully there
And as a side benefit we get to worry less about dodgy builders taking shortcuts!
We're all sorry for the other guy when he loses his job to a machine. When it comes to your job, that's different. And it always will be different.
McCoy, Star Trek, 1968
But in this case, AI can serve good answers because it takes them from All About Berlin (and other sources). By killing All About Berlin, it kills the source. Where will the answers come from then?
Welcome to capitalism, where such questions are a problem for someone else in the future.
The image that comes to mind inevitably reminds me of the movie The Human Centipede.
But the centipede is LLMs training on LLMs regurgitations.
Good news! You can just let the model make it up, and nobody cares anyway.
From the archive that the big players had already build. Killing the source websites now doesn't change anything for them. This is also why I can only laugh about polititians who claim that their country should enter the ai race. There is no race. Openai et al have sucked up all the information available and have them stored privately years ago. The worlds reaction was to remove some of the source information from the net and at the same time flood it with ai slop. So the process can't be copied anymore, there is no way to build another openai, anthropic, meta or google ai.
> Killing the source websites now doesn't change anything for them.
Of course it does. It the info in their archive is not up to date, then the AI output is first less reliable, then outdated, finally entirely wrong. With policies, rules, laws, processes etc. changing all the time, that won't take long. Then users will have to ignore the AI summary again, and look for human-input posts on reddit and other pages, like this one. But, this page, and reddit, too, it seems, are seeing less and less visitors lowering the probability of them being kept up to date.
Businesses will feed companies their info (like they always have done with directories) to keep things up to date. But it will increasingly once again just turn into mass-media advertising where the businesses expose just what they want to expose, and human-curation-at-large-scale will probably go mostly extinct in favor of small-scale networks not big enough to pop up in the AI searches and answers.
I don't know, maybe it is still possible to compete. As AIs get better at validating facts, maybe we can undo some of the poison. Maybe. I'm not entirely sure how, I think it will be different for every field. Software is the easiest. Doesn't really matter how much misinformation is out there, programs can be written and tested. Law can probably be verified against official law books. Health would be nasty though. Hard to confirm stuff without human test subjects.
That only works if the facts are written down somewhere where machines can find it. A human must taste the banana bread and leave a review before an AI can recommend it.
Someone will make a slightly worse version of it, way less profitable, but also a lot easier with the help of AI?
Unless the AI starts living, walking and experiencing Berlin like a human would, it can't make the content for All About Berlin
Sure, but we dont have a shortage of people walking around Berlin, do we?
I think the bigger question is will humans continue to put things online if they are not getting paid? So far we have seen that the answer is a resounding yes (You and I both left a comment on HN), but will AI be the thing that makes people hesitant going forward? Is humanity going to suddenly stop posting their thoughts online? I think that's a harder question to answer.
I think there's a very meaningful difference between relatively casual conversations like those here on HN (however much good information there is in them—and there's often quite a bit), and well-researched, structured information about specific topics put on dedicated websites.
Sure, I'll comment on HN for free in my spare time because I enjoy the interaction. But if you want me to spend 30 hours researching what the best 5 places are in Berlin to experience some specific aspect of local culture are (or, hell, even something much more specific to my own interests), then put that together into a coherent and well-presented webpage, I'm going to need some kind of much stronger motivation. Like being paid.
I guess we do have a shortage of people walking around Berlin AND diligently maintaining and updating website about real-life experiences in the city.
Replace "Berlin" with anything else define: how can AI itself be a truly trustworthy source of such information?
>I guess we do have a shortage of people walking around Berlin AND diligently maintaining and updating website about real-life experiences in the city.
Social media/reddit still exist.
We don't. However, people walking around Berlin, then writing about it to feed the AI scrapers is not how the future content is going to be created.
What's going to happen instead, is AI re-creating content from the same, stale sources and recycling the same content over and over and over again in slightly different forms embellishing it to make it appear as if it's new content, then heavily pushing it with social media algorithms, which, btw, are controlled by the same people who own the AI infrastructure (mostly).
This one's easy, the highest bidder. The example search query given by nicolas is "Best german bank account for foreigners". One of the banks will just pay Google to be the designated, erm, "sponsored", response.
They won't, and efficiency will be maximised by not needing to have real answers at all.
LLMs excel at outputting answer-shaped feelgood.
The big problem here isn't that AI obsoletes a specific job, but that it will hit almost all jobs, starting with office jobs. I guess, super low pay manual labor in third-world countries will survive a bit longer, simply because a robot is more expensive than a human slave.
That's a huge shift of power away from ordinary people, and will cause a lot of problems for humanity as a whole.
Time will tell if such upheavals come to pass and this is more like the Industrial Revolution or the computer revolution. Neither were good for those affected.
But if people no longer have income and the AI promises come about in full, then who pays for the AI companies?
Maybe it's worthwhile to remember that money and paying for things arose from the necessity of trade. Different humans created different value and traded with each other to all benefit. To not have to trade goods, money came to be.
If your AI can give you the benefit without having to trade, you no longer need money. But even if your AI can do everything a human can, unless it can create something out of nothing, you still need land. Both to grow food and to extract resources. And you still need to defend your land.
> Maybe it's worthwhile to remember that money and paying for things arose from the necessity of trade.
Initially, yes. But that was in a situation where (broadly speaking) people had roughly equal levels of resources, and they developed money to have a consistent way to value those resources.
Here and now, the money the super-wealthy have now represents control of those resources. You and I don't have much to offer in that context.
And if (as CodesInChaos alludes to) we are positing a future where the super-wealthy controllers of AI also have sufficient robot-power to replace human manual labor, why would they not also have sufficient robot-power to kill anyone trying to take those resources back from them? Certainly, this is the calculation many of them are already making.
It is abundantly clear that if they are allowed to continue down this road, beyond a certain point the only way back will be by overwhelming force. And if they are able to continue farther, then beyond a certain point assembling that level of force that may no longer be practical even in the rosiest of scenarios.
The hackerest comment of today. There's only office jobs or "super low pay manual labor in third world countries".
I think that manual labour could actually do you (and many others) some good, and give you a bit of a wider perspective on life and on the world.
It's fucked
But it's here now, and that's not going to change. There is too much to gain, and the wider public doesn't care. Or even understand.
Not true, we can absolutely keep AI companies accountable and make them pay for the work their stealing. Engage politically.
Yeah I think this is key to why AI is seen as such a goldmine. Because the data it consumes is considered free. As soon as it has a price on it, the cost of AI instantly becomes astronomical and it's no longer a viable business.
But that's exploitative capitalism in general. Internalise the profits, externalise the damages to society. It was that way with environmental pollution and it's that way with AI. Governments aren't going to put a halt to it now. They're too afraid of 'losing the race' and the other guy is not going to play fair.
> Governments aren't going to put a halt to it now. They're too afraid of 'losing the race' and the other guy is not going to play fair
Again, engage politically and push for politicians that do care.
I agree that we should keep trying but its not a forgone conclusion that we can be successful. From what I'm seeing, most people either can't see the problems or don't want to deal with the cognitive dissonance that seeing tham would mean for their own AI use.
The broader issue of value capture by finance has been going on for a while now and there seems to be no sign of successful pushback.
I don't think that's going to work. AI is too big to fail now. Too much money tied up in it.
I don't think anything will be done until the lack of content will cause AI itself to become unstable due to lack of sources of information.
We managed to heavily curve the global slave trade once upon a time, even though an immense amount of money was tied up in it.
What do you mean by "engage politically"? Who do I engage, and what exactly do I advocate for? Do I do it as a one time thing?
You phrase this as "absolutely" like it was this easy thing that people just need to realize it's within arms reach, but don't provide anything tangible to act on. In my opinion this is insurmountable task for a regular person.
It's like asking "How do I start a company". I can't possibly answer that in a single HN post. My recommendation to get started: find nearby communities or political parties and begin attending their events. Start small.
> pay for the work their stealing
Pay who? HN doesn't pay me for this comment. SO didn't pay the people who answered questions there. Reddit AFAIK doesn't pay commenters, and so on. People have been having their 'work' monetized by others for ages and were willing to accept fake internet points for that work. It feels a bit late to suddenly now say it's a problem.
Personally, I think it would be healthy for society go backwards and stop using social media. I just don't see that happening because people love the affirmation of others.
>Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
I find this line of argument hilarious given how much time was spent arguing copyright infringement isn't stealing and "information wants to be free!" and intellectual property rights are corporate capture... when everyone wanted to pirate movies and games.
Sure came to bite these people back in the butt, didn't it.
I mean it's probably fair to make a distinction between someone sitting at home pirating a movie for their own enjoyment, and a huge company using it's already mear-absolute control over the internet ignoring copyright to further entrench itself as our digital overlord.
Thanks for saying that, it need to be said! The hypocracy is rampant. basically, "laws should only apply to those I dont like", which is hilariously childish.
Turns out the hive mind of the internet, which always held itself in high intellectual regard, is actually just developmentally a 16 year old.
Strawman fallacy. There's no reason to think that the majority of those who doesn't like models to be trained on their work likes software piracy.
Of course, the opinion society takes is the outcome of court cases. Not posts on messageboards. So let's evaluate what REALLY happened, shall we. And just skip the fantasies ... These are the actual positions that society took, which you imply are much more reasonable, and of course they are anything but reasonable:
1) to prevent programmers getting money from billionaires, we declare AI models "natural persons": https://www.courthousenews.com/coders-lose-appeal-in-copyrig...
(note: the "rights" the models would get from being considered natural persons, even from the same law, are denied to the models. For example, if any natural person, here including AI models, makes a work, it is now a crime for anyone else to claim authorship. So the obvious consequence of this decision, even just the one from the exact same law, that it is now a crime to claim AI produced work is your work, or to deny it was made by an AI, which would be a problem for billionaire companies, did not apply)
2) if it would mean billionaires getting money from authors, hundreds of millions of copyright violations are just forgiven, even illegal downloads. In fact congress itself violates the law making that OK: https://www.wiley.law/alert-Copyright-Office-Issues-Key-Guid...
(congress violated the law here by retroactively changing the law, because of course all the AI labs violated copyright law hundreds of millions of times (that's books only) before the law was changed. Congress cannot retroactively make that OK)
Note (Capitol Records v. Thomas-Rasset) when a kid violates copyrights "owned" by a billionnaire, the punishment goes up to $222,323 per instance, as well as imprisonment PER INSTANCE. That was the punishment for for "the nappster mom" (she was a single mom caring for 3 kids). The exact same punishment, what most people would call "justice", applied to AI models, would have bankrupted, OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, Meta, Microsoft, all of them, and put their CEOs in jail for the rest of their life. Because of the sheer amount of copyright violations they committed. Hundreds of millions times even a small amount of jail time, is still tens of thousands of years.
2addendum) if any other country doesn't agree with point 2, the US government will threaten them militarily AND the EU commission will threaten them economically. (A German court decided the opposite, and ...)
3) if it means billionaires want to keep "their" works out of online library lending, courts have judged that they get to do that EVEN IF THE LICENSE ALLOWED IT and IT OTHERWISE WOULD BE FAIR USE. It was judged fair use is NOT allowed if, after the fact, billionaire copyright owners decide it might harm their economic interests.
That's right courts have judged that using billionaires' copyright under fair use is NOT legal if billionaires complain it would harm their financial interests, regardless of whether it actually would harm their interests.
4) The piratebay trial: Merely pointing people at copyrighted material, listing what is in a particular copyrighted work along with a way to get it without a license, got 2 years jail time and 6.4 million in damages.
Needless to say, AI companies both did that, and are still doing that, all the time.
5) Spain's telco got sued by the owner of soccer rights to turn of most of the internet, to prevent people from sending "copies" of the live soccer match (never mind that the copyright on livestreams isn't actually fully ironed out, for instance can you make short <5s clips of what happens without a license, as news companies have done since that became possible in the 1930s?). The courts ordered the shutdown. EVERYONE was punished preventively, on order of the state, because they MIGHT have otherwise have violated copyright. I would point out that this violates human rights (specifically the prohibition on states doing collective punishment), in addition to 1000 other laws, from competition law to telecom safety laws, but what do laws or human rights matter, even in a western democracy, when billionaires' money is at stake?
In fact it isn't even 100% established that it isn't legal to do (ie. if you monitor the stream and just send out short clips of goals, for example, that may or may not fall under fair use laws). So they preventively violated human right to enforce a law that isn't even what lawyers call "fully understood" yet.
TLDR: punishment for a single copyright violation for a single mom caring, alone, for 3 kids: $222,323 plus jail time PER INSTANCE (ie. she had to pay that for a couple dozen violations, and the jail time was "waived", rumor is it was waived only after the police chief protested and made clear to the judge they were never going to enforce the jail time against her)
Punishment for hundreds of millions of exactly the same violation for a billionaire: ZERO.
I can go on and on and on with such judgements. Because of the "nappster wars" there's literally tens of thousands such decisions. With very few exceptions, always against the smaller guy, with absurd excuses and ridiculous interpretations of the law to keep the money flowing to the billionaire companies. Again, and again, and again, and again. Well, until AI billionaires started getting sued, THEN it suddenly changed. Of course, you still can't illegally download and especially can't make money of Snow White, despite Scam "you shouldn't be allowed to get computer RAM" Allman and Dario "all jobs should pay me instead" Amodei, oh And Zuckerberg and Page and Gates are doing that every single day now.
Can I just ask the question: how do you get courts to judge like this? Because when it comes to billion dollar company ideas ... if I can commit hundreds of millions of crimes to make these companies, I easily have 10 diffirent billion dollar company ideas. And of course Scam Allman, Dario Amodei, and Google and Facebook, and Microsoft just risked that. They committed more than enough copyright crimes that a court could bankrupt them (and if the prison terms doled out against 9 year olds were applied to them ...)
How do I know which company I can just risk committing hundreds of millions of crimes to create? How do I get reassurance from courts, so that I can get investors to support committing crimes like they did?
When it comes to copyright crimes, what about making a Netflix, the one everybody wants, with AI versions that are near duplicates of existing works. Of EVERY existing work. From Casablanca to Snowwhite (after all both are public domain stories, so just change them slightly, and make a movie in the same style). You know, do the ridiculous version of movie X (have snow white be a 200kg black dude, for example, otherwise same style, same movie). That's a billion dollar idea. But of course, as soon as courts find Disney (who are a billionaire) suing someone like me, they will find some stupid law to misinterpret, some absurd excuse, to side with Disney. So how do I prevent that, and more importantly how do I know NOW that they'll do that for me, so I can get some investment?
I mean, all I'm asking is for courts to stand behind the "pro-AI" (but obviously really pro-billionaire) absurd judgements they've made before, to make it clear beforehand so I can get investment for that ... that's all.
Oh: in case it's not obvious, I'm not a billionaire.
And as for your claim: I think the positions of "nerds", "information wants to be free" is both the EXACT same thing billionaires did. Nerds wanted to use others' copyrighted works, for free. Nerds were heavily punished, ARE STILL heavily punished, even the ones that did nothing (violating even human rights), billionaires were completely allowed to do the same. Oh, and Chinese companies were allowed the same too (of course Amodei sees NO problem in complaining that, oh no, Chinese models are copying his work ...
Knowing that even a tiny punishment would mean those companies are now bankrupt, and their CEOs in jail for life, because they so incredibly egregiously violated copyright on a totally unseen scale AND committed the worst possible copyright offense: making money of copyright violations, and we charge and try to lock up single moms millions of dollars for doing literally 10 million times less serious violations, I would LOVE for someone to explain why these companies got off and these people are out of jail. Explain justice to me, please.
So I get to copy whatever I want now? Oh, it's still only big corporations who get to do that?
You are free to read things and then learn from them, and use that to make new things, yes.
>So I get to copy whatever I want now?
Well, yeah, if LLMs are mass copyright theft, and you can use one, then by your definition you already have that.
I don't think it's hilarious that other people's opinions came back to bite me in the but.
> just took all our work
If your work wasn't publicly available on the internet, that could not have happened. Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money
Feel? What do feeling have to do with it? It is a service being offered. Relatively fast T/s without having to own the hardware and pay for the cooling. How good the deal is is another question. But feeling? Have people grown so used to free services that we're talking feeling when it comes to paying a provider now?
> But feeling? Have people grown so used to free services that we're talking feeling when it comes to paying a provider now?
It's not the paying, it's the fact that the "provider" stole the work without attribution.
If that stance was so clear cut as you present it, I am sure a ton of copyright holders would already have won their lawsuits. Apparently not.
I'm making an ethical argument not a legal one. Laws are not always ethical.
That arguments assumes that courts are just and apply the law to everyone equally.
Did they stole?
The way I see it LLMs scrape websites (not prohibited by copryright or any other law) and are setup to regurgitate knowledge, not verbatim extracts.
Let's put aside for a momemt the reliability of this and potential hallucinations.
a way it is the same as writing a wikipedia article getting knowledge first from various publications, most of them being protected under copyright. The main difference being wikipedia encouraging sourcing while LLMs do not always cite sources but that isn't a requirement under any law anyway.
No theft or copyright infringement has been commited in the process.
Do we need new laws or taxes to retribute people who produce content being scraped and encourage people for providing knowkedge? Maybe.
I don't have a solution either, and as I said in another reply I'm not arguing law, just ethics. But in my opinion they did steal.
Had creators known years ago that some company will take your content and sell it at a premium they would (probably) not have shared as much publicly for free. Another comment nicely said the social contract is broken, I agree.
And about Wikipedia, they don't charge for their service, it's a free encyclopedia that also requires attributions (maybe it's not enforced in all cases? but it is a requirement AFAIK).
EDIT: I don't know how much the "free" matters here though, am I mad when open source models give me code that's trained on open source code, not sure. I guess for me the key word here would be consent.
> Why did you publish anything, if you didn't want it to be used by third parties?
Because 3 years ago, everyone had a reasonable expectation that any publicly available work would be appropriately credited and/or compensated for, in accordance with both copyright law and open source software licenses.
You realize that even very permissive software licenses, like MIT or Apache-2.0, still require attribution? Now a few companies are making big bucks selling your ideas (and sometimes verbatim code) without adhering to the terms of that license.
The social contract is utterly broken. The legal situation is utterly questionable. The only reason they get away with it is that the inmates are in charge of the asylum in the US.
> The only reason they get away with it is that the inmates are in charge of the asylum in the US.
Wait, because a party you don't like got elected, the whole judical system is also broken? I find that hard to believe.
I'm European. Describing the Republican Party as "a party [I] don't like" is unbelievably out of touch. The entire world outside of the US sees and says plainly what's happening. And yeah, seen from the outside, the US justice system sure does seem broken in a number of ways.
My feelings are all over place about AI. I think the technology is amazing (in the right hands). In terms of it's capabilities.
If we are talking about application, ethical concerns then I think it fucking sucks.
The way I see it. This is the inevitable end goal of social media. The way social media grants instant gratification is the same way LLM's do just on a much larger scale. To me both of these things are connected.
We've been exploited by tech companies using fast feedback and this to me is another level of that.
What are you trying to do ? To start a Butlerian jihad ? We cannot just roll back AI, internet, computers. So just enjoy the view, we are for quite a ride.
Why can't we? Are we not free beings who can think and make choices for themselves?
Humans are inherently selfish and ultimately behave in their own personal interest.
Give them a tool that does their job for them so they can kick their feet up for the rest of the day, and they will use it. Even worse, those who take the "moral" stance and refuse to use it, get lapped by their competitors, er, coworkers who are.
AI is out of the box, and it's a prisoners dilemma. So right now you can either take for yourself, or trust that the masses won't do it.
Getting this new technology into the hands of citizens rather than a handful of companies, for example through local AI when that gets more affordable, is the way forward I think. Until then its just about learning how to use it effectively.
But at the same time it hurts me more and more thinking about the massive data collection the AI providers have at this point. People are completely unaware of the gold in form of data we are sharing to these companies. And its what keeps their wheel spinning.
As I'm from the 3rd world, open source was revolutionary in allowing me to learn. Now that incredible and noble effort is being hoovered up to make billions for people who didn't create it.
I have a deep feeling that it’ll never be for our good. The strategy is “get them addicted first”, then “remove human thinking and understanding” (junior don’t learn like we did in 2000-2010) then they’ll do whatever they want. They will provide the cloud and the code and the voice for anything software related, eating up everything that is in the middle.
We can’t escape it. They are too powerful and because there is positive side effects as well, and they know it, there will always be a debate.
I feel that, the common mindset in software that you rarely see elsewhere, like in big pharma, is to open and give knowledge very broadly. But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well. That’s only fair, but that’s just one way to see it.
> But OpenAI, Anthropic absorbed everything and are not playing along. They should have continued giving free knowledge of everything as well.
It's really a tale as old as, well, western liberal democracy I suppose! We had a commons, then the commons were fenced in, and finally we were charged rent to access the thing we built, cultivated, sustained.
The digital era makes for some interesting new ways to fight back. Distilling models into open weights is one, liberating software through reverse engineering is another.
This literally happened btw, it's not just an analogy. There were commons, areas of land everyone could use. Then people came along and built fences around the commons and said this land is mine now, pay me to use it, and everyone just accepted this because they didn't have another choice, that's how we got landlords. Literally. Not metaphorically. Look up the Inclosure Acts.
I think you’re explaining this person’s point to them?
I want more people to be aware that it happened. Not everyone will Google the analogy.
Something almost nobody has been told is this, and that almost every country also used to have internal colonization programs where the government gave free land and lots to citizens. Suggest that to anybody nowadays, and they would try to put you in jail.
There are lots of towns all over the world that will give you a free plot of land in exchange for moving there.
There's always some huge catch.
Yeah. It’s that it’s shit land in towns four hours from the nearest airport. What did you think homesteading was?
The law locks up the man or woman
Who steals the goose from off the common
But leaves the greater villain loose
Who steals the common from off the goose
The law demands that we atone
When we take things we do not own
But leaves the lords and ladies fine
Who take things that are yours and mine
The poor and wretched don't escape
If they conspire the law to break
This must be so but they endure
Those who conspire to make the law
The law locks up the man or woman
Who steals the goose from off the common
And geese will still a common lack
Till they go and steal it back
(Seventeenth century protest song)
https://i.postimg.cc/TfNZgXYg/the-sack-of-flour-by-will-carl...
> I have a deep feeling that it’ll never be for our good. The strategy is “get them addicted first”
I mean, it's not even a long term "capitalist leaders" like you describe.
These companies have figured how to be at the edge, and how to stay at the edge a bit ahead of the others. What they have not figured out yet, is how to make a positive amount of money at the end of the quarter.
So, yes you now have the "we should impose a moratorium" (so we can stop paying so much to progress without risk of being overtaken), "we should stop open models or chinese models" (because if people realize deepseek flash can do 99% of their actual AI need how can we charge them triple), ...
But also, we're about to face the biggest rugpull ever, the MOMENT they think they have the conditions in place. Hell, they've has already tried several time, exclude the top model, make it way way more expensive, etc ...
I think that value moved and we're feeling this pain because we're chasing ghosts: working on the after-image of where value used to be is a lost cause and we all feel it in fear of our own jobs.
In my expectation, governments who embrace AI and regulate on misuse rather than on protecting old structures will unlock access to the new value chains earlier on and get first-mover advantage. I hope Europe sees this instead of regulating us into pre-AI protectioninsm in an AI world.
There are so many opportunities to make the world better in line with the right-to-repair movement and their open data incentives. They were on the right track, I just hope they don't fall for the old money corruption, because that will cost way more to lower class people along the way than AI on its own ever would.
AI and old-money protectionism are likely going exactly the same place: access to more things for old-money, reduced opportunities to carve out new things for those without. Just copy the new faster and cheaper than ever. Embrace-extend-extinguish at a class-level.
So many of the things that can be automated away don't really have higher-level value chains to move to. The value was other people reducing friction for you or presenting you with novelty. The AI-maximalist/old-money goals here are identical: avoid having to pay a person for that.
The core underlying assumption in both POVs—whether "shape rotators" or "old money elites"—is that everything boils down to manipulating abstractions. The world, to these groups, isn't about people living satisfying individual lives. It's about making things as convenient for themselves as possible, not about doing concrete things in the real world for people as a whole. They are (intentionally) replacing the territory with the map.
There was a funny neoliberal concept in the late 20th century that everyone was going to transition to an information economy. That China and Brazil and Sub-Saharan Africa were just behind the curve, and if they learned to code they could also have an American standard of living.
It's obviously bullshit, because the American standard of living is based on extraction and exploitation elsewhere. If you make everyone rich, there's no gradient to exploit. If everyone everywhere does office jobs, who will work in the mines?
The AI trend is the pigeons coming home to roost. Oligarchs have extracted value from overseas, but now they also need to extract value from the underclass at home more aggressively than ever. The number has to go up.
>The number has to go up.
Because people’s expectations go up. If people want cutting edge technology and medicine and old age benefits and defense against other societies, then there has to be some incentive to do the work to R&D it.
Unfortunately it's not only EU / governments but also other organizations e.g. open source funds who hold rigid anti-AI stances.
We need to adapt to what has been willed real neither by over-correcting nor through ignorance.
I'm sure there is a somewhat European middle-ground for all of this. It would have been great to have more powerful Chinese models to bootstrap it though. I guess challenge accepted?
> I just hope they don't fall for the old money corruption, because that will cost way more to lower class people along the way than AI on its own ever would.
I dont know what you mean here. AI is pushed by some of the most corrupt people on the planet. They are not "old money" either, they are new tech CEO, entirely comfortable with both corruption and tech feudal fascism.
And the last thing they care about are "lower class" people. They are in the process of getting as much power for themselves as possible and of pushing as many people as possible into lower class.
How is EU regulating into AI protectionism?
I actually think the only way to stop society collapsing is to have very strong AI safeguards and labor regulations. Its simply too powerful and disruptive to be allowed to run wild.
AI doesn't have to replace people, and it doesn't have to dumb us down. We need to do some economic re-modelling, otherwise capitalism will crumble and society will with it. I just don't see any other way, but I'm also terrified we will enter some dystopian Sam Altman Worldcoin reality where everyone has to scan their iris' to cryptographically sign anything uploaded onto the internet.
Either way, we have to get the balance right which will be very difficult... The alternative is terrifying.
> we're feeling this pain because we're chasing ghosts
I think you yourself are an example of this. The ideas that all regulation is harmful and that plucky upstart tech firms will save us were overly optimistic years ago, and now we know they aren't correct.
The danger is not old money corruption and protectionism; it's the new money robber barons of the tech industry.
In this world more than one thing can be a danger at the same time.
Old money wants to keep you paying rent forever.
New money wants to keep you paying rent forever.
The hard part is keeping money out of the regulations itself as to make a prison. No regulation, as you say, is just as bad as it allows the powerful to use it's money just as much.
The play was to gaslight us into what basically amounts to a (protection) racket.
From a "Technodollar" perspective you could say that Jensen Huang really has done all the jobs and indeed it's safe to retire now.
I can't shift perspective and approach "all alone" apparently, so I keep tracking main script by saving up for my next GB10 spark box either way.
See Evgeny Morozov & co:
> Sovereignty for Sale
https://mondediplo.com/2025/11/03tech
> What's Left of Europe's Technological Sovereignty
https://youtu.be/gojoOXWRg28
> The play was to
How could you possibly know?
Backpropagation.
That’s not what ‘know’ means
You are absolutely right
Just disagree with "we can't escape it".
A government is supposed to represent its people. There is quite a wave of AI criticism, so governments should apply incentives to the good results and oppose/mitigate the bad results.
The problem is when governments are in bed with the big corps and stop representing their people.
The governments are freaking out about being left behind. The narrative is that this is the new industrial revolution and nobody wants to be caught with their pants down using horses and muskets when every other major power has moved on to heavy industry and tanks and machine guns.
Repeat after me three times: "Last mile AI guided drones".
Now go to https://xkcd.com/652/ lt used to be extremely accurate. Now I feel old.
For context, this xkcd was published in October 2009
Source : https://www.explainxkcd.com/wiki/index.php/652:_More_Accurat...
The super rich can achieve regulatory capture at a faster rate then the people can fix it. That's the real problem here. That's why we have so much consolidation in spite of anti-trust rules. That's why many industries can 'regulate' themselves. How do you think we got such absolutely nonsense copyright durations? It's not because that's what the people wanted.
The people can, on increasingly rare occasions, make such a stink that they get something they wanted and the super rich have to make a concession. For a while at least, but then it always moves back.
I predict any new AI laws that come out of government (regardless of party in power) will have a spin about being good for people, but under the hood will be designed very carefully to further entrench the power of the existing players.
Voltaire already surmised that "government" is nothing but a tool for the ruling class to employ for their benefit.
> The problem is when governments are in bed with the big corps
So, every government in the world today? I agree.
You're providing information. There is a more efficient way to get this information and your website doesn't provide enough value to continue make you enough to pay your bills. Why are you allowed to gatekeep this information and domain indefinitely?
I wonder why we don't see other sob stories about businesses that go under every day.
I'm awaiting the blog post about Dominique Ansel Bakery that invented the Cronut, lamenting it's decline in sales due to other people selling Cronuts. Or all the casualties of the chicken sandwich wars.
Why do developers feel so entitled to have their work be able to fund their lifestyle indefinitely?
I personally don't care about any one website, I want to get information. This is obvious when you consider something like recipe websites that have long abused their users with long personal stories to just get a recipe and sleazy SSO abuses. Now I ask AI. We're all better for it.
If you want to add value and provide a better experience, do so. You still have your website. Get people to like your website enough that they bookmark it. But if you're providing simple info and just making users click into your website, you're not gonna make it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cronut
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicken_sandwich_wars
The problem is that the information gets stale, and nobody will have an incentive anymore to write down more up-to-date information. Then, the models will provide inaccurate information. We may be living through the glory age of AI right now if that happens.
Its the forever problem of AI - its like a one time reaping of high quality data and then information goes stale because few people will provide information for free, fewer people will be motivated to build any content online, most things will get protected and locked down, open source is saturated with agents.
This is 100% the "glory" days of AI. The price is highly subsidized by investors, govt but thats going to ramp up and the product quality will dilute as they need to drive revenue for the markets. Its the same long lived strategy of every great tech company that has VC returns to feed. If OpenAI can stay private for a longer period of time they could ostensibly continue to build a better product and not be handcuffed to wallstreet in the near term.
Cost of AI will get subsidized for 3-4 years while corporate america gets addicted, then pricing will ramp up and corporate ameria will be dependent. This has been said millions of times over.
The same was said about Uber and Lyft in other words that once Venture Capital subsidies ended the prices would be passed on to consumers. While it's true on inflation adjusted basis is not that extreme from its low point maybe 30% higher.
And with Rideshare you have a fundamental cost of a car and a person whereas with AI costs can quickly be reduced across multiple dimensions of optimizations Hardware stack architecture region energy costs latency and other trade-offs. Then you have open models competing to bring costs down. So I just don't know that we'll ever see the cost go up
Rideshare is interesting because uber et al might actually be cheaper per ride than waymo et al. Yes, they pay a driver a very low wage which is some overhead, but they don't own any cars. The driver pays for the car, its maintenance, registration and insurance, fueling, and storage. It is dubious if it even pencils out for anyone but the power users in the gig economy. Waymo has massive overhead with its fleet requirements, on the other hand, real estate requirements as well.
AI could be similar. The costs of the bleeding edge are probably enormous. But imagine if your competitor was some cheap model, with a layer of southeast asians between the user and the model getting the apparent quality of the model far higher leveraging some cheap expert human prompters. There's some odds there that they might route you at the bleeding edge. Plus also, plenty of users probably aren't even that sensitive to a low quality vs high quality response for their purposes.
I think using AI in 10 years will feel like using StackOverflow today. SO is kind of stuck in time, where every answer there is how you’d do things in 2015. They structurally can’t seem to let go of old answers and ingest new information, so they are dying in the past.
The same might happen to AI if it stops having access to fresh information. If people move to walled gardens that can’t be consumed by AI then there is a chance that these products eventually get stuck in the past, too. I don’t know what would be a walled enough garden for this, but it might happen.
Another step in this strategy is to blur the line between what's good and what's ugly to the point when people start liking AI slop.
The problem is that the losers here are usually sites riddled with ads and low-quality writing to begin with - festooned with promotional links to 'recommended products' and tracking cookies.
It's hard to feel bad for them.
This site is a perfect example of why you’re wrong. It's a small human-written site created by someone about an interest of theirs - their home town. It is the antithesis of 'sites riddled with ads and low-quality writing... festooned with tracking cookies'.
The scammy sites, which you describe as losers (and equate this site with), will not in fact lose in this new world, they'll just adapt and start serving ads inside your AI chats (already available!). Yes google let search deteriorate (I haven't used Google in years), but are you happy with the open web being shut down and replaced by AI chatbots? Is that really the future you would like? Do you think AI answers are going to remain free forever? The same enshitiffication seems inevitable.
Small sites like this which provided local information with a human voice will simply cease, as nobody will visit them anymore. It was difficult to justify before, but there really is zero incentive to feed human 'content' to Google now.
The inconvenient truth is that the number of technologists asking these types of questions is on the rise because they feel threatened and are being harmed. A minority of them asked these types of questions when software was eating the world and other workers were losing their jobs.
There was a lot of arrogance. "Learn to code". "Things change". "Adapt".
> There was a lot of arrogance
To be honest, I never saw that as arrogance but rather as an answer to the utilitarian question of how to make more money.
I would never tell a skilled professional to learn to code if they can make a living wage and like what they do.
I do understand how that might come across as arrogance, I just think it is an unfair characterization.
So what are you telling software engineers who are being laid off, and those who fear that they might lose their jobs or see their wages decrease?
Many of them are complaining about the fact that AI labs aren't playing fair ("stealing" content and code for training) and cutting costs to the potential detriment of service quality and security, but they didn't express the same level of concern about tech companies that "asked for forgiveness, not permission" when they exploited legal gray areas to build their businesses (the Ubers and Airbnbs of the world), used massive amounts of venture capital to engage in predatory business practices designed to undercut and drive out established companies, etc.
I’m not telling them anything, there’s a reason why I said “would” rather than “did” on my previous post.
Also, there are businesses other than the ones you mention that would not be properly characterized by software-first. They don’t pay as much but you can make a pretty good living off them.
> Also, there are businesses other than the ones you mention that would not be properly characterized by software-first. They don’t pay as much but you can make a pretty good living off them.
Many of those businesses exist (or initially did, at least) to put people out of work. Software exists for efficiency, and much of those efficiency gains went into putting masses of people out of work. Both directly and indirectly.
There are some exceptions of course. Gaming companies come immediately to mind. But most "boring" IT work is there to make business processes more efficient, which almost always means either directly firing people or working to automate systems and processes as to not have to hire more.
IT professionals are simply the engineers and mechanics of the industrial age, creating and servicing machines that eliminate or greatly reduce vast swaths of industry.
This might be true in some (if not most) cases, but it is also very reductive. Many industries can actually create good jobs for qualified workers, especially those with a big R&D component.
Capitalism, but now the dagger has been pointed towards white collar.
I really wonder what the marketing of Anthropic is doing and how they were not fired after the first “AI will take your job, and youre gonna be fucked!” claims to pump AI.
Any insider know how they can simultaneously make sweeping claims about the future of society and unbelievably tonedeath about actual society?
> Capitalism, but now the dagger has been pointed towards white collar.
What does this comment even mean?
That the ones suffering from the bite of capitalism are higher up the social-class ladder.
And therefore that a certain social group is finding out that the "it doesn't affect me" escape doesn't apply to them anymore.
What I meant is that the negative externalities of capitalism now affect white collar workers. Usually, those at the bottom of the pyramid get most fucked.
Months? I feel like it's been years. The weekly news cycle moves at such an insane pace. I'd love to say you can just ignore it but you can't anymore with how expensive everything is getting and how job security feels like an all time low. The only solice I have is that throughout history these cycles repeat and tend to correct themselves and the periods after the corrections tend do be the greatest times. But that doesn't make it any better living in the build up to a correction.
There is defiantly concerted action taking place to shift public perception and social norms about this. Change the rules before the average person even realizes what they are losing. That being said, the people who study the intersection of technology and society have been talking about this exact thing for 20 years.
In five years everything will be bland and boring, people will start to ask about unique things and just get redirected to <ad paying company> instead. It will speed up the death of content on the open internet, it didn’t start with AI, it’s just being massively accelerated by it. Most people will be dumber and more easily tricked and controlled, others will start to distrust everything.
Everything will be worse, except for the stockholders of the gatekeepers (and their owners).
And before anyone asks, I’m using AI heavily every day.
I don't like hearing that AI is bringing you and the article's author hardship. But I think it's more complicated than tech companies taking away work through greed. Technological progress is the culprit here and this time you're the victim, unfortunately.
That site's business model is similar to the many paper magazines you'd get for free in tourist welcome centers, hotels and on the street. Companies (usually very small) who published those guides got replaced by the website. Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago.
A family member used to own a magazine about arts and crafts that went bankrupt because of Youtube creators and free Internet articles - well before AI. It was a small magazine and profits were just enough to maintain a middle-class lifestyle. Random people online, relying on technology, destroyed his livelihood and he has been struggling ever since.
You can try using laws and spreading the word against progress, but it's certain you'll lose in the end. I'm not saying it's not worth it because you may delay it long enough to give you time to settle elsewhere, but change will come against our will.
How is this progress? A multi national stealing data from a solo dev and presenting it as their own?
There is no progress here, only greed and destruction
A multi national stealing data from a solo dev and presenting it as their own?
For decades people fought against the media industry with some really good arguments about how music/film/software piracy doesn't deprive the original owner of their material so it's 'copyright infringement' and absolutely not theft. Now the same people will happily argue that since it's their work being copied and used, and they're losing out on the rewards and their jobs are at risk, now it's a heinous act of theft.
It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
Copyright infringement is not theft, and copying some software to use for other purposes (e.g training AI) is very specifically allowed under some open licenses.
(I appreciate that this is a semantic argument that doesn't really matter very much.)
I think people believe that the law should protect the powerless against the powerful. Good examples of this are the common pro-patent arguments about the solitary inventor and the common pro-copyright arguments about the solitary author. These arguments are usually fielded by large corporations!
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak. It's already dystopian and it's likely to get tremendously worse once they have become indispensable - they are not yet, at least outside of the SV bubble.
AI companies are the powerful taking from (and re-selling to) the weak.
That's a fair argument while things remain stable but it falls down if things change.
AI companies have only really become powerful in the last few years, and they were taking the content a decade ago. The argument would only work if we either apply it retrospectively ("you took the content when you were weak, but now you're powerful so it's bad") or if we stopped anyone taking the content if they have the potential to become powerful ("you might invent AI in 10 years, so no content for you.") I don't see how that would work.
My comment was about common-sense ethics, not a suggestion for new laws. But it does help to first understand what feels just before thinking of laws.
I don't see any problem with your first option. If you take something and then get powerful off it, you have to stop and give it back so you're no longer powerful. The relevant issue is not the taking or using of things, but the increase in power itself. Most entities that are currently powerful should be made un-powerful. That would be a good thing.
Copyright infringement is treated like theft in every part of the world. I am not sure where did you get it isn't. Try copying anything from any business and you will be sued to death and loose. Big business requires and loves copyright.
The only reasons LLMs are allowed is because big business thinks they will be able to get rid of much of their labour force AND because LLMs make it really hard to figure out whos copyright you are breaking so you can trick people who don't understand how LLMs work.
So we are effectively in middle where copyright is more and more only for big companies and individual work is not gonna be protected.
Fine lets go all the way and kill copyright. Of course that won't happen.
> It doesn't work that way. People in the tech industry made some very clear statements about how copying is not theft, and we don't get to just take them back because we're all the victims now.
It's interesting that we as workers apparently have to act inside the bounds of the law AND inside the bounds of our preferred legal structure (even though this was never turned into a law), while the rich and powerful are bound by neither.
If Anthropic could legally steal from AAB but AAB could also legally steal music from Sony, there would probably be less outrage. But what's actually happening, is that rules are consistently applied to prevent poorer people forcibly taking value from richer people, and consistently not applied to prevent richer people forcibly taking value from poorer people. In the past, revolutions happened over this kind of greedy hypocrisy.
Instead of having to go to an ad-ridden slop site I can just get an answer immediately.
All About Berlin is hardly a slop site
what happens when all of these websites with useful up to date information become abandoned? Maybe we'll all be hanging out in town squares talking to each other face to face and having fun throwing stones at the Anthropic drones trying to record new content.
cant that day come any sooner...
Progress is not something that exists in the abstract nor is it inevitable.
I think we use the wrong term here - it's not progress, because progress in my mind means that we are working towards a goal and that goal gets closer. And I think humanity, or the universe for that matter don't have a well defined goal. Change however IS inevitable and these technologies represent change. There are always winners and losers when something's changing. As Max Tegmark puts it, this is the work of Moloch - everyone knows it's bad on a certain level, yet everyone has to play along, or their losses will be even greater.
Of course change is inevitable, but the specific changes aren't. This is just how immoral people justify themselves; someone was gonna do it so it might as well be me!
Of course there is a goal we're all working towards, and that goal is efficiency. For some reason or the other we collectively made striving for efficiency our ultimate end goal, and that's what 'progress' actually means. From this perspective replacing all human labor with AI actually 'makes sense'.
Efficiency is survival. The country with the industrial revolution dominated several countries without industrial revolution in asia and africa. You must also avoid paying normal prices for medicine as it won't exist at all or at that price point without tools of efficiency like electric motors, generation, high throughput screening etc. likewise with every other tech.
Community is survival. Nurturing is survival.
Efficiency is one aspect of it. What we see is, one factor being made as the ultimate goal, pushing the human condition out of balance. The example of industrial revolution is great, as it resulted in the same out of control greed as we have today.
Its very easy, african culture or asian culture couldn't save them from Britain. So clearly their type of community didn't survive well against the British type of community. Would you rather have been a colonised asian/african or a brit if you had to live back then?
Community is good and bad. You live in a low karen culture, cherish it, you won't like a high karen culture.
Greed is much better than rule of kings. Greed created friendlier societies and the ability for people to move up the social ladder.
> Greed is much better than rule of kings.
Why do you think those are mutually exclusive? History is full of greedy kings at the top of corrupt regimes. Is Putin’s Russia your role model?
Putins russia is a bad model because it is corrupt and dictatorial. Markets need a bit of light touch environment to thrive.
No amount of community can save you from various conditions and injuries, if you don't have hospitals and medicines and the things that are required to have them for example. Clealry the capitalist community, or even the soviet community managed to survive better and able to take care of more of their people.
> Efficiency is survival.
This gets repeated like a mantra, along with “survival of the fittest”, when we want sciencey-soudning justification for our bad impulses. No, efficiency is not survival, and natural process do not optimise for efficiency. They optimise for good enough.
Even human systems do not optimise for efficiency. Disproportionate wealth concentration and monopolies is not an efficient economic system in the abstract. It is efficient at wealth extraction. So, when we want to wax lyrical about efficiency, we should at least be honest: we’re saying that greed is good.
It has nothing to do with science, it is simply common sense and observed reality. Natural processes are irrelevant when you will be steamrolled by a country or group that doesn't have neuroses about technology. Natural processes didn't have much to do with why Britain ruled most of the world.
I'm not sure those analogies work. The problem OP has is that his value is being effectively 'stolen' and 'resold' by google itself. If he stops keeping his page up to date (which seems to be a likely outcome), then where will google AI take the knowledge from?
My family member doesn't care about who took his business. Google and technology enabled someone else to steal his livelihood for a cut. To his children, who's getting the money now is inconsequential.
YouTube isn't a charity for creators. It's one of the biggest businesses in the world that takes enormous profits. While you can argue that certain large business models are better for society than others, it's still tech "destroying jobs".
Also, something gets lost in the transition. The magazines articles were in-depth and the photos were professionally taken. All these people lost their jobs to "You won't believe what I made for $5" and general SEO.
You completely missed the core question: "then where will google AI take the knowledge from?"
Your analogies / examples do not cover this.
The core concern is that you are punished for creating useful information and putting it on the internet. Because if you do, it will be stolen by way of excessive AI traffic that makes you no money, while simultaneously suppressing human traffic that does.
So unless you are doing it entirely out of the goodness of your heart, and are also willing to effectively pay for Google and other AI overlords using your bandwidth, this information will disappear.
This is bad for everyone, but a confident AI will just slap together some random half truth from official sources that are required to be there, and that will be the new quality ceiling of information on the internet.
Online reviews by amateurs that are not as good, but does anyone really care?
I would guess that from less formal, non-profit sources.
Having a page whose business model is talking about Berlin or restaurants might go away, but talking about Berlin or restaurants will not.
Think HN, we have plenty interesting discussions here out of the "goodness of our hearts", and I for one don't expect to profit from any contribution I might make when I post here.
HN is useless to find specific information when you need it. Redit used to be quite good at that, but the quality was very uneven. And of course, now it’s mostly gone. Now, the easiest way to find information is YouTube, with its whole set of issues.
What these changes are doing is killing the middle ground between purely hobbyist blogs and large companies websites. Blogs will remain because they were not making much money in the first place. Major newspaper will remain because they will find a way between subscriptions, sponsoring, and advertising. Everything in between is being overgrown by slop factories (this predates AI, but it is now completely unbearable) in a race to the bottom as they are displaced by Google’s AI (as if the bar was high in the first place). We are all losing.
That's Google's problem, really. I didn't address it because I don't find it very interesting.
There was a world before free information on the Internet, you know? Aside from the personal hardship of the site's owner, I won't shed tears for the ad-supported Internet. Not a droplet.
The only kind of truly free information ever available on the web was from small self-motivated authors and that will remain. They don't feel "punished" if others, including AI, reads it. I have stuff online and I don't care if AI uses it.
If Google needs information for its AI, it better start paying for it. And perhaps a world of paid information providers will emerge.
If not, I'll be happy to keep the web hobbyists, forums like this one and paper books. Isn't that the old Internet we miss?
You are ignoring the fact that "stealing" here refers to stealing products of OP work rather then "winning the business competition".
No such thing as theft of public data. Especially when the output is impossible to match to a given input.
the "Theft" argument is just a bunch of people who'd otherwise hate copyright laws seething that they didn't get money from info that people'd otherwise never pay for.
it will trivially aggregate it from other sources. I'm sorry about the all about berlin author, but it's essentially a website aggregating information that's readily available from a mixture of official government resources and private user discussions that are publically available.
this is not to detract from the overall problem. some people have provided value which is replaced by AI which can not be automatically replicated in their absence, yet the impact of AI on their finances might make it unfeasible for them to continue doing that work.
purely from a systemic point of view, it shouldnt matter though. if all about berlin cant operate on 1/4th the traffic, maybe someone else will (perhaps, using AI) create an equivalent service for 4 different subjects that each have 1/4th of the traffic and be profitable that way. if such a thing cant be profitable, society has deemed that it has no value in the first place.
this is a different argument from AIs effects on individuals of course.
> it will trivially aggregate it from other sources.
Hahahaha no.
A website like All About Berlin is compiling a lot of information that simply doesn't exist in any structured way online. (Alongside some that does, of course.)
By its very nature, the Google AI Overview is eating its seed corn. It should not exist, and should never have been allowed to exist.
Precisely what AI excels at is compiling information and giving it structure. It certainly doesn’t need a human doing that for it…
When I say "any structured way", I mean things like even mentioning that the thing you saw is in Berlin.
If you lose sites like All About Berlin, then there's a very, very high chance that any given piece of information about it existing online doesn't have enough context and metadata around it to even recognize and compile it. If it's even on a publicly-available site, and not on a private forum somewhere behind a login wall.
AI isn't omniscient or magic. It can distill structure that's very dilute, but it's much, much harder for it to bring together information that genuinely doesn't have that structure in the first place and add it in.
I think there's a crucial difference between your example of the print magazine getting replaced by Youtube, vs what's happening now.
When the internet displaced print media, that was done by individual creative people, not a large corporation (at least initially, today's YouTube is a different place). The person who used to write articles for a print magazine could learn the new skillset associated with online publishing, and apply their old skills and pivot to the new normal. It wasn't easy, but it was possible to survive.
But now, what options do we have? I'm not about to buy a data centre...
Did the website steal and remix the content from the magazine? Did the YouTube creators do so as well? Probably not. This is just not the same, but I agree that (unfortunately) it cannot be stopped and the big players will never be held accountable.
The people who create the value no longer receiving anything for it is the opposite of progress.
Sorry to ask you this, but have you read the article or just the headline? Nobody is talking about tech progress, but stealing and killing creative work. Author is not complaining about losing their comfortable income stream, but they are sad because they won't be able to support their work from ads and will need to find something else to do. This summary widget could have been done before the current "AI" tech, no progress there. Why google does it, is a good question. What is your take if you are not focusing on the word "progress" but think a bit more broadly about google landing page and its layout and contents.
This is a classic. It’s not businesses and their business models; it’s the Invisible and Inevitable Hand of Progress. You may fight the businesses, but the “progess” is inevitable.
It’s so inevitable that Capital is pricing out personal computers and every IT-adjacent business is stuffing AI into their offerings in order to KPI-max to their managers. The top-down inevitability.
The OP claims:
> It will get worse. Last week, Google has made two announcements: AI-generated answers will replace search results entirely, and they have ads in them.
Yet more inevitability: Google will replace search results, that’s that. This is just progress.
On the other hand, people might like to get direct search results and be able to connect a person to their recommendations. It is possible. But it won’t, apparently, even be an option with Google soon enough. Because how to guerilla ads into other people’s websites? Much easier to guerilla them into AI “content”.
Also: Kagi (which has a good reputation here it seems) is a good search engine. How? By using Google’s services without the enshittification. More progress: the profit-maxing Google search engine is worse for the user, on purpose.
And all of this for what? No more original sources, no more authorship, no more talking to other people? This is progress?
Kagi does use several sources besides Google and I assume are trying to build out their own stuff and minimize Google dependence.
Sadly it's very hard to build a search index in this era. You can't just run a recursive wget like it's 1994.
> This is a classic. It’s not businesses and their business models; it’s the Invisible and Inevitable Hand of Progress. You may fight the businesses, but the “progess” is inevitable.
As someone once said: there is no alternative.
(Except that, of course, there are alternatives, they just really want you to shut up and stop trying to improve things for normal people).
> Technological progress is the culprit here
It’s actually not. Tech progress is not happening in a vacuum. It’s accompanied by unprecedented inequity, corruption, monopolistic mega corporations, etc. Remove (or reduce) the cancer feeding on the technology progress and you may find it beneficial to us all.
> But I think it's more complicated than tech companies taking away work through greed
When technology companies choose to take others information without compensation, what do you call it?
> Some small publisher likely felt the same a few years ago
Your analogy has no relationship to this situation. Unless you’re alleging small publishers, Work was stolen by websites and copied.
The website in question is not the originator of any information. It is a collection and a summarization of bureaucratic rules and laws. The man behind the website does not own the information he has re-published there.
Where did I say that the website was the originator? What does that have to do with this discussion?
Clearly, the collection and summarization of bureaucratic rules and laws is valuable, if Google is taking what he created and summarizing it?
The difference here is that the replacement is outright worse than the original thing its replacing. I never ever use AI for things that a search engine could do because its wasteful and inefficient and often not right. I know I'm an outlier here and one day it will inevitably be AI but urgh. I wish it wasn't so.
I find myself not even trying normal web search anymore because the quality is so bad. LLMs often search the web AND aggregate/digest/interpret the results for me, so I get a filtered result that actually (more or less) matches what I asked for.
This results in fewer clicks for some pages, and for clicks to pages I would have never found otherwise.
I'm also surprised traffic is going down. Chatgpt and Claude always list links with every answer, and often I click them to get further information.
Basically I only don't if the question and answer are very shallow.
> it's more complicated than tech companies taking away work through greed
it's really not
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
It's about the Google search page. Without Google, the website wouldn't have gotten any traffic in the first place.
Without Google or anyone distributing it for free, may be the person would have smaller revenue but might have built a search engine to promote their site too that becomes wildly popular and he might have become the next billionaire, who knows!
Let's not go with wild speculation that have "your are a small fish and nothing without us" connotations.
> Without Google, the website wouldn't have gotten any traffic in the first place.
Without useful content on the websites, Google wouldn't have any traffic in the first place.
To be really honest I question the business sense of people putting information for free anywhere and then act surprised when it gets vacuumed up. I don't like it at all and I'd rather live in a romantic village where we all share freely and frolick in the meadows. I really, really do, but wishing for that doesn't make it so.
If your livelihood depends on a thing, guard it.
Fwiw I feel this too and I don’t really know what to do about it.
It is not exactly brain drain but I think it has similar effect minus the benefits to the person relocating.
Instead of attracting/relocating the talent, now their knowledge is copied and it benefits the entity copying (again overwhelmingly from one region) but no payments so the source that spent the resources doesn't even benefit in the form of few remittances. Atleast the recent post about Japanese hometown tax was one solution for the brain drain problem within a country.
Yes the knowledge resource is still there but due to the search monopoly, os monopoly, mobile duopoly and other reasons it is hard to compete for visibility or free packaging of the same.
I don't know what it is, but it feels like some implied social and/or political contract has been broken.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Isn't most work built on top of existing work? Regarding the example in the article, do you think OP opened an account at every German bank to compare them, or also relied on information from other people?
These companies (or rather their-suite) are pathological liars.
They keep reassuring us that alignment is a very important topic. Attribution and citation were the canaries in the coal mine, as one would expect an intelligence aligned with human expectations would deem those to be indispensable. They don’t give a damn about alignment, it is not a problem they are trying to solve.
I’m not sure either. Will AI be the collapse of the middle class when it replaces all jobs? Will that cause societies to collapse before institutions can find a way to respond? Or will we all get universal income and live happily ever after?
Or will AI be the collapse of the corporation? Giving rise to millions of tiny companies providing incredible products and services through the use of AI? Or will it be the collapse of small businesses?
Or will AI be the end of digital content? Making it all meaningless as we drown in a sea of AI slop? Or will AI give rise to a new era of digital content never before imagined.
I have no idea. I have little hopes in the institutions in charge of all of this. I hope for the best, prepare for the worst.
When the press complained about google caching extracts on contents, people mostly sided with Google.
Now that it impacts the bread and butter of smaller companies or individuals it becomes not ok.
I'd say that people have probably been delusionnal to expect making a living without charging money for goods or service.
In this specific case there is quite a simple solution, google (and oai/anthropic as well) should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries, they literally did this with adsense and youtube!
Sure, there's some technical hurdles, like identifying who's actually using the info they read, but impressions are a thing in ad networks, then there's broader questions about evaluating what training data was useful and used to ultimately produce what token, I'm still just taking about the kind of ai summaries in search related to the article, seems doable with the same system we use for ad networks.
When it comes to coding and more generalized knowledge there's already been interpretations about copyright laws and fair use that seem to allow what oai and ant are doing and how they are capitalizing on it, doesn't mean we should rethink them.
I'm sure there are technical solutions that can be translated to this sort of issues as well that could be derived from ad networks, I mean, imagine a world where your code and your blog post get a score on their usefulness to train LLMs and you get a share of the revenue, wouldn't this be better for all players? they get good training data, we get paid for it.
> should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries, they literally did this with adsense and youtube!
https://x402.org can facilitate that, we just need forcing the Big AI to pay out.
Cloudflare experimented with this model as well.
They would quickly have zero traffic if they demanded payment.
> In this specific case there is quite a simple solution, google (and oai/anthropic as well) should share revenue with the website they scrape to provide the ai summaries
The actual problem here is so weird that this doesn't actually work.
Consider something like Stack Overflow or Reddit. The people answering questions weren't getting paid to begin with, so you're solving the wrong problem.
And weirdly, the thing the AI summaries are doing is the thing sites like that have long been trying to do themselves. If someone has a common question that has already been answered, the AI summary answers it for them and then they don't show up to post the 5000th duplicate of the same question. It even lowers the operating costs of the site since then 5000 people don't have to load the same page when they don't need to post anything new.
Whereas if they have a question that hasn't been answered, there is nothing for the AI summary to summarize, so then the user isn't satisfied with it and proceeds to actually visit the site and post the novel question that hasn't been answered yet. In some kind of theoretical sense that should work. The site only gets used for new questions.
But it actually doesn't work, because it breaks an important part of how sites like that function, which is that the users vote on the answers. When you have the common question, you don't need to post anything new, but you upvote the correct answer, which gives the person answering the question a sense of accomplishment and lets them know that people value the thing they spent the time to write. And if you try someone's answer and it doesn't work then it gets downvoted and the low score lets other users know to be skeptical of it.
If the AI summary shows the answer without the feedback mechanism then it breaks the site. The people who post good answers then can't see anyone interacting with them and feel like they're wasting their time, and if that happens the site is dead.
The question is, how do you fix that when "just show me the answer immediately" is the thing the user of the search engine actually wants?
Good points.
Maybe there's technical solutions?
For sites like the one in the article the feedback loop and payment it's there with revenue sharing.
For web 2.0 (remember this term? Haven't used it in a while) you're right, the community building part is hampered by the LLM middle layer, but as you said if you're going past "just show me the answer immediately" and actually click on the site you may start to participate and this could actually improve the quality of contributors?
I kinda hate it but the "marketing funnel" is a valid model to apply here, and I'm sure there is an equilibrium to be found which benefits everyone, regardless of size and the kind of platform involved, history is not on my side here, but I need to be optimistic to keep being sane.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
Yes I do have this feeling. I combat this by not paying a dime to the largest culprits (all frontier AI producers) and by recommending others to do the same.
If using AI on a large scale remains unprofitable then I hope the situation improves for everyone. The hardest part would be convincing large businesses not to use frontier AI either. Due to the large costs for businesses some have figured this out on their own already.
I have this feeling. I feel a growing cognitive dissonance and AI psychosis slowly but surely overtaking my brain. At first these models were extremely useful tools that I could find joy in using and now they've become something else entirely. Now every day my brain gets fried from all the non stop junk information it is trying to decode and make useful. And at the same time i'm constantly being told that my replacement is coming for me and I should work harder.
This capitalist machine's only concern is profit. People all around me have lost their purpose to do the job. Nobody really cares anymore and we can see the effects on that. For example the recent FAA disruption or bank outages are likely a result of this exact thing on a macro scale.
Personally I'm dealing with this by detaching. I no longer use big tech products (beside apple's). No youtube, no social media, no algorithmic feeds. I try to be very mindful of my LLM usage and to use it to learn (somehow). I decided to start my own product so that nobody can have any expectations of me.
I also pulled my money away from the AI bubble. I put everything in a global ETF (part of which is AI but I couldn't find one with less AI in it). I'm voting by not paying for this. I will ABUSE all these services like openai & anthropic and the moment they raise prices I'm gone. They can kindly have fun with the aftermath of the collapse.
The single most important thing they should be spending time on is UBI. If they are so sure they are building SI how come they do not understand that people are afraid? All these geniuses with the EQ of Zuckerberg can go to some other planet.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
This industry did it onto themselves with "free and open source". Do hedge funds open source their proprietary software algorithms because "free software"?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
They don't care and it is self inflicted.
> Personally I feel that I'm living with severe chronic cognitive dissonance - and have been for many months at this point. But I'm not sure what I can do, I have rent to pay and children to feed.
Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
From smug jerks, most valuable workers from the future who don't need no stinking unions, to starving artists in half a decade.
Free Software is actually remarkably similar to LLMs regarding its economic consequences for software, with a few important differences. It does make software cheaper to produce and it does redistribute economic value from the little guy to everyone. Two huge differences are that FOSS authors keep some control and recognition for their work, and that there is no third party jamming itself between FOSS producer and consumer, controlling everything. Maybe not for lack of trying on the part of GitHub...
> Software engineers slowly realizing that they are the new starving artists.
Hm, not even close. If you only did relatively easy tasks that are well defined and don't have big change "radius", then maybe (never worked in such big companies and industries). But at my job I see coding part of the job that gained some speed, but all other aspects are more or less unchanged. Meeting with client, analyzing and planning, meeting with other members of the team, analyzing, planning again, and some more important parts of the software are still coded by hand. So maybe 20% of my job has gained a lot of speed (not 100% sure about that long term, because now making a decision about part of the app that was not coded by hand is not intimately known like it was before takes a lot longer or at least cannot be made on the spot but must be made by spending tokens). So yeah not even close.
P.S. Not to mention that there are cases where coding by hand is MUCH faster then using LLM
Even worse, being part of those companies, having no morals nor ethics in name of equity and a comfortable retirement plan, contrary to all of those affected by their work.
I've had this feeling multiple times over my 40 year career. First, it was the operation centers - the only place you could actually get access to a computer, which was fridge-sized, loud, noisy and expensive. Along comes the PC and my terminals are wiped away and I now have new technology to learn in order to gain access, remotely, to the computers I used to sit next to and warm myself. So, I did that.
Then, it was the PC again, new "incredible" 4GL database software arrives, replacing the million-dollar database server with a small box that sat on the side of my desk. Now every tiny office in every bodunk part of every irrelevant town can have massive relational database reports generated, running their profits up, satisfying customers that no longer need Big Metal. That profit is fun!
Then, it was compilers. The incredible onslaught of devtools meant there were tons of new things to learn again. So, I did that. "No more command line C compiler for me!", I exclaimed, and launched Turbo Pascal and Turbo C and Delphi and .. yeah. Maybe a bit too much Visual Basic, but whatever, it was RAD.
Then, Linux arrived, just when we all thought Unix was going to die and we need not keep learning new Unix things, except we do. Linux made the SBOM costs go way, way down, so .. some new things to learn, some old things to re-learn. So, I did that. (Oh, what a relief to go back to command line C compilers and things) Suddenly, we don't need Big Metal, we can do the same exact things on Little Metal.
Then, the Internet revolution arrived, and nobody wanted fancy local native things any more - everything had to be done in this new technology, even if it wasn't quite ready yet, the world was moving in that direction and we had to learn it. So, I did that. And boy, did I ship a lot of things and many profits were made.
What came next .. oh yeah, mobile! iPhone this and Android that, and all the knowledge about how to write great user interfaces was thrown out the window to be replaced with Hot New Stuff™ that the kids were using, grandad! Catch up already, sheesh! Maybe we need a bit of Big Metal for it, but yeah, the web was a great way to provide the user with an excuse to not learn how to install software and maintain their PC hygienically. So, I did that.
And now, the AI revolution is well and truly happening. So, so many new things to learn. So, I'm doing that.
I think the difference is, I've been in this game all along mostly because I love learning things, and computers have always been a mysterious box from which one can learn a great, great deal many things. I used to say "there is nothing mysterious about computers, only unknown - if its working and in front of you, its because someone, somewhere out there, knows it - so that means I can too", and that was a good maxim because it means I know assembly and multiple languages and can navigate all the layers of OSI with ease, and can invent things that others will have to catch up and learn, so .. they do that.
If you were in this for the paycheck, you're hurting. But if you're in it because you love making technology for your fellow human begins, then .. just do that. Embrace the things you don't know. Find your inner hacker spirit, and let it run world.
Get a DGX Spark, learn to use it. Learn to train models. Learn to SHIP those models to customers who will profit from using them. The data that all these other companies are using is out there for you to use, too! Don't forget that!
>Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No, I do not. I didn't feel good about renting slots on a timeshare system, either, which is why I embraced the PC when it arrived. All the C compiling I could want, none of the bills!
It is the same as it ever was: Go local, or gtfo. Get that DGX Spark and get on with it. Next year is going to be fun! (Unless you're only in it for profit, in which case you're not gonna have a good time unless you can actually have fun, doing that which you need to do, to profit...)
We have always had problems with Big Metal trying to keep everyone sequestered and subjugated. Always. Every single one of the new revolutions I've described have been a battle against Big Metal, controlling everything.
Go local, or gtfo. Same as it ever was.
Thanks for posting, an interesting perspective.
This is exactly how I feel, I started a bit later, but I still remember the 2.4 Linux kernels, the empowerment that Linux gave me, and I feel like that again now. LLMs brings so much of the things I wanted to do -but gave up on because one can do only so many things- (dashes all mine) back in scope. I'm enjoying it!
And I will get that GPU (perhaps not a DGX spark but who knows) someday. It's important to me as well.
I hope you have a great time learning LLMs and using them to do great things. People forget, AI is just as scary as VMS once was. As Unix was. As Linux was (but truly isn't).
AI is just software. Learn how to use it to improve the lives of other humans, and you'll do fine.
> Do you all just not have this feeling?
I certainly do.
> How do you combat it?
I handed my notice in last Friday. The newest CEO wants "AI at the heart of everything we do" and so it is at the heart of my departure. Actually I've been unhappy in tech since 2020, full time remote work is bad for my mental health and even though I go into the office I'm still remote because most of the people I work with are elsewhere. I never wanted to work for a large company (and refused job offers for more money for that reason in the post) for similar reasons and have been "forced" into that as we were bought by an international outfit just over a year ago. AI is just the final bale of hay.
This is professional suicide for me, of course. I'm not qualified for anything else that isn't also going to be remote, fully AI infused, or both, so for some time at least I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third (maybe a half with long hours) of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
So what are your plans long term? Do you see this "stacking of shelves" or "waiting tables" as the end or are you looking for something next?
There are a few other things to investigate. Physical network installation/support and such. But there are not that many jobs available in any of those options, a fair few people wanting each one, and some of those people have direct experience/training that I lack. I hope the basic jobs are not all I'll ever do from here-on, but I can make it work financially, and mentally, if I have to, and in the short term I might even enjoy it (a change is as good as a rest!).
Right now my priorities are:
• getting out
• taking a sabbatical (some weeks, maybe two months) to deal with some of the immediate burn-out effects (fixing everything is a much more long term matter)
• then doing anything to pay the bills, so I'm not eating too much into savings for a long time.
There are quite a few people around me feeling exactly the same way, but they can't afford to take the risk of what I'm doing for various reasons (still paying mortgage/rent, partners and children to think about, etc.).
I'm at this point minus handing the notice in.
Not sure what to do next.
I can cope short-medium term on minimum spending etc, medium-long if I do something basic - I was thinking of doing something more physical like you mentioned, network installing (cabling etc) which I quite like doing but don't do it often. I know I couldn't get enough work to compete against what I get now, but maybe its enough.
The problem with "cloud computing" it doesn't break enough for people to care, so contracting work has been killed off by this. Probably costs more long term as well for the small business, small long term hidden costs etc.
This might feel a bit gross, but hear me out. AI is going to drive a lot of consolidation, but it's also going to help facilitate starting a ton of new businesses. It's clear big companies are going to need less help maintaining their automations so fewer jobs for people who do that. But there are tons of situations where more automations were always desirable but never economically feasible.
Imagine knowing that there's a product that could bring in $500k/year but would take 2 people 3 years to make it, well, it was always going to be a chicken-and-egg problem. Now it might be possible for 1 person and several GPUs / high subscriptions to build that business in 6mo.
It's scary for sure to try and make something from scratch. But I think actually owning some kind of small business is going to be the best defense against getting laid off from a big company. People in tech for sure have challenges as they're really good at doing the thing vs seeing how the thing is used, but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills.
Using AI to work on my own, to escape AI and working on my own due to remote working, doesn't feel like a solution I can work. If “just use AI” was viable for my mindset then I'd stay where I am in a safe salaried job rather than a more risky start-up, and use AI here.
> … to build that business in [time]…
One of the things I know that I am not cut out to be, is a businessman. I would not want to work for a start-up run by me!
> but it's absolutely possible to learn the more product-management-ey and business-ey skills
Again, if I'm going to learn skills that I would really rather not learn, then getting behind AI and staying here would be the safer option.
> This might feel a bit gross
Yup!
I do see your point, but it is not a solution that I think could work for me.
To me the best parallel I can think of is the industrial revolution. The best (economic) position to be in during that time was to somehow figure out a way to be involved in steam engines. Building or maintaining them, putting one to work in your business, finding a business that you could change with one, etc. Some people chose not to and that's fine, but a lot of basic assumptions about the way people lived got turned on their head whether they liked it or not. People didn't effectively boycott the steam engine even if there were some short periods of success with the Luddites. It's easy for us to be completely dispassionate about this from 200 years in the future.
I think the same flavor of advice holds today. It's totally fine to not like it or not want to participate in it, maybe even boycott it. But you're signing up for a more difficult life. It might well be more rewarding too, we won't know for a long time.
You'll probably need to find an Amish or Amish-like community to join or start your own. It takes enormous money to get into commercial farming but artisinal market gardening is an option with as little as 1/2 acre. You'll want to go as far down the value chain as possible because then even if AI ends up being deployed somehow into a domain you're in, you're at least going to be able to sustain yourself with your own labor. Homesteading is a good way to think about it. Work to minimize what you need from "the grid" in terms of energy, food, etc. One good generic metric is how much you have to spend in a month/year tells you how dependent you are on society. Buying solar panels can help both literally and figuratively. Having a really well insulated home. Getting a very efficient EV you can charge from your solar panels, but even better if you can bike or at least use an e-bike. If you can drive your monthly expenses below $1k it's relatively easy to sustain yourself with low leverage work. You might want to consider moving to somewhere less expensive where you can have more land (for food, solar, water, etc), and lower payments / own it outright.
Obviously I can't tell you that the future will play out the way I'm describing here. This is just my best guess. I have been thinking about it for a while after I was asked a question by a friend "how will all this play out?" months ago. History tells us how people are likely to deploy an invention across society, not because the society is the same but because human nature is.
> so for some time at least I'll most likely end up stacking shelves or waiting tables for a third (maybe a half with long hours) of what I have been earning. I have the luxury of a paid mortgage (it is a small flat, but it is all mine), no debts, some savings, and no dependents other than the cats - others are not so lucky so couldn't make this choice even if they wanted to.
Sounds like a good time to start a new venture of your own? If you're captain of your own ship, you can make sure that it's not AI infused. And coworking spaces can feel a lot like offices, if you take care to go every day.
I think that a lot of people feel the same way you do, so there might be an opportunity in that.
I tried a few different coworking spaces for a while. It never really felt quite like an office, everyone is working on separate things, busy with their own team /product/company. Some people have a few colleagues there with them, so they end up grouping up together, some others are alone, but always seem busy doing their thing... I did not meet many people there, and with the people I did meet I did not really build any meaningful relationships like I would with actual colleagues.
While my company was paying for it, it was fine, I could go there whenever I felt like having some people around. When my company stopped paying for it (the company stopped existing), I switched to another (cheaper) coworking space, but the experience remained the same. Actually worse because now I was at a coworking space, looking for a job, while others where working on their product/company with their colleagues and teams, and I was shelling out money just for the privilege to have people around me.
My office feels a lot like a coworking space. We are all working for the same company, but the people I'm actually working with are mostly in other locations, and that goes for many of the others too. Still, we now have the pleasure of being physically present in the office five days a week.
I, for one, hate it. And the most galling thing is that my company has (of course) fully embraced the advantages of remote working for itself, buying up companies left and right and creating teams with people from different locations, but now insists that we employees should mostly give up those advantages.
> Sounds like a good time to start a new venture of your own?
I am no manager by anyone's definition, and to some extent you have to be in order to be successful that way, unfortunately.
> coworking spaces can feel a lot like offices
Like rob74's sentiment: my current office feels more like a co-working space! Better than being at home wrt work/other separation & balance, but it doesn't really work for me.
I think this is not even specifically about AI progress.
Classic example of enshittification. In hindsight (not blaming the content creator!), relying on ads revenue from big players only worked for a while.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
It's sad, and sadly solutions to the problem are non-trivial. Cory Doctorow discusses some solutions in his book. TL;DR from memory: increased regulation, in particular anti-trust and consumer rights.
The book is definitely worth reading. It discusses the central problem of today's Internet. It's a bit wordy/repetitive on the problem description side, but still ...
B-but I thought I was just going to be a leader planning the glorious revolution, not that I'd be forced to toil in the fields with the other kulaks!
The question is? Without the author of All About Berlin, how will the AI know about new things happening in Berlin? It won't.
As much as I would like to have empathy let's not pretend that before it was all roses, with the top Google results basically being SEO optimized websites and Pinterest-like link aggregation. The example query "best bank in Berlin for expats" is the exact SEO hell that I'm glad I don't have to deal anymore.
There was a game and you played it well, but the game has changed, what do you want me to do? Should we also bring back the horses?
I don't feel conflicted, I have always felt that "information wants to be free" and these kind of developments are inevitable. We improvise, we adapt, we overcome. We use the new tools to achieve new things in a new reality, we just need to learn how. It's what Homo Sapiens is best at.
I do really feel bad from another angle, I feel bad about not owning my means of production, and can't wait for the time when I can host my own, as I have always done. But I can see that that is going to happen, it will just take a while. I hate that a third party can take stuff away from me, and I need to be online for it to work.
Just the fact that Muses and Dots are just free VMs with (depending on reports) 12 GB of RAM, for free gets my blood boiling a bit, they borrowed the money, took everyone's RAM supply and put it in a machine to get us hooked before squeezing value back out of us later. I did not and will not sign up for this. I want to host my own. My machines are an extension of my mind and my thoughts are my own.
The work? The information? Meh, I'll adapt. But don't touch my agency, my privacy, my (for lack of a better word) sovereignty.
I think the alternative is open source. You need to own the model you run, the data you feed, no cloud. I think it would be nice if the future is more crowdsourced training and data networks that evolve open source models. For now, I think we need to find ways to reward open weights, if that means China, so be it.
It’s one of the most evil technology and industry possible. Anti-human, by design. I feel terrible at the idea that I contributed a tiny bit to those company success and paid for their service. At the same time I know a good amount of people at Anthropic and they are personally awesome. But I’m convinced it is lead by a doomsday cult that doesn’t care one bit about the negative externalities they are causing
> How do you combat it?
You cannot publicly discuss the few options that might work for legal and moral reasons, but imho it'll end up like it always does when people get more and more alienated.
I feel conflicted.
I should be able to read “all about berlin” and tell other people about Berlin without paying a separate license.
I should be able to share statistical results of analysis on copyright material.
And somehow the merging and scaling of those two don’t sit quite right with me.
That's what courts are supposed to be for, they judge each individual case by its own merits instead of applying a blanket rule.
This site is full of people who voluntarily, on their own time, help these companies with their subscriptions and training. Just see the mountain of comments on every His Majesty The Frontier LLM Release submission where they write about their side projects.
They have about as much “cognitive dissonance” about their fecklessness as I have about eating meat. (the dilemma: on the one hand it is murder; on the other hand it is delicious.)
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
That depends on what you mean by "us".
Companies are paying taxes. Should they be paying more taxes? I really have no clue. Probably, as labor share of income decreases.
Should companies instead pay "us" (as in: creators) directly? I think here the issue is mostly that we are in unprecedented territory.
What needs to be paid for? What is okay to do with content that other people produced under a different regime? The rules so far have been pretty lax and in fact we are happy to share the knowledge, because it benefits all of us.
All of a sudden we have this machine that eats it all up systematically and creates outsized effects that are hard to compete with. This seems super messy. LLMs should exist, it's just good to have them. Again, taxing the corps seems like the simple solution, but idk.
What is curious is that we had the dry run: Google got rich and made people rich by linking to other peoples information. This to me is the same thing from a different angle. Who allowed Google to systematically index all this information? Well, nobody, but also nobody explicitly disallowed it, because nobody thought of it being a thing.
Then there is a separate question: What happens with those taxes in the future? Should it be used to fund UBIsh things? Again, crystal ball says: Probably, because what else? Also: Why not?
Random collection of thoughts and open questions.
> How do you all feel about the situation?
It seems all the discussion revolve around the short/medium term issues, but the longer one I see that might bring back some balance is the creation of new content. Short/medium term yes the issues are what you list, the AI companies steal content, creators go bankrupt. But then how a new "All About Berlin" for a new subject emerges? As I see it the problem then will not be a new one emerges and is stolen, it's that there will be no new one altogether.
So to answer your question on how we'll combat this, I think "old" content / the web is lost, that new quality free content, be it websites, posts or Youtube videos, will dry up and move behind paywalls. Now is a difficult transition period for creators because the incentive for consumers are not yet there.
On the optimistic side, the mainstream web was already sick, it didn't wait for Google AI overview. So it might just finishes it off that dying model for creators with most of the ad and SEO industry.
Automation has the power to make workers' lives better by producing more. That won't happen as long as the wealthy capitalists control it. It will be used to exploit and dispossess. The same thing happened in the industrial revolution. It was the labor movement that improved people's lives.
Less frustrated with the few thousand rich grifters than the 10s of millions effectively shrugging
Frustrated Fellow Americans put obligations on me but provide no assurance.
Same with environment; pearl clutching but stop driving. Flying. Psh. No.
When we don't know how to solve a problem we ignore it. So we're fucked. But then there was no beating physics anyway; life is the leading cause of death.
Downside to knowledge work has been the loss of all the manual skills that workers could fall back on, effectively look away from the digital virtual economy and just do the plumbing and roofing etc etc
(Yes yes hard on body but large enough labor pool (everyone that can) distributing load on a schedule).
I highly doubt they become profitable; Apple m7 and beyond or some other local device chip will come along that handles local inference on my own data just fine -or- society collapses seems most likely right now
Have seen it written we are in a cold world war 3, how this period is the Hitler's troops marches unobstructed across Europe" phase.
> How do you all feel about the situation?
I don’t like it. I personally try to limit AI overviews as much as possible, and use Kagi for search. I’ll then follow the links.
I will say though, LLMs have made the deluge of AI generated websites with information even worse. I’m not even sure I can confidently find human made content anymore.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
No.
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work? (or would have moved slower)
No.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
No. It’s conflicting. The tools are useful, but I don’t use them for content creation in the way of words to read, art to look at, etc. It doesn’t feel good though. On one hand I feel bad, on the other I have personal projects that would never have gotten done before.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Net positive? No. There will definitely be some positives. I don’t think they’ll outweigh the negatives.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I have it every day. I don’t combat it, not well at least. But to quote Jango Fett: “I’m just a simple man, trying to make my way in the universe.”
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
I'm not sure what you're talking about. Yes I put some things on GitHub with permissive licenses. If it makes the clankers a little better, yay.
But I have no delusions that the LLM revolution is somehow dependent on my stuff. It's dependent on the collective effort.
The large software giants will get into problems selling their software stacks due to AI. SaaS might be replaced with self-made open source solution developed with the help of AI.
There is good and bad things. Sure, nobody thought the first thing AI replaces would be the creative work.
Currently the frontier models are leading here and people become dependent on them. I don't think their moat will last too long, even if they try to make hardware scarce, at some point open models will replace them as well.
I don't think you can combat it much. But we can leverage the positive sides, even if they seem smaller right now.
Largest problem for developers right now is that the pipeline for new talent is broken. Well, in regards to anything to do with software, Germany hated building knowledge in several disciplines. A former engineering culture was replaced by lazy consumers and that was before AI in the picture.
> The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves. It inspired two government portals and a few similar websites in other cities.
perhaps if All About Berlin can pivot into consulting about UX design, they can share/sell the source of their compelling way of presenting the data
zeitgeist will never be in reach of AI, just by virtue of it always taking time to train / being reactionary (people catch on to trends instantly, and spontaneously generate them too)
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable?
You do not need to worry about that
I don't think we should do work for the sake of it.
What we really need is to spread the existing work load out amongst people _evenly_.
Hence 4 day weeks, but really this has to come with the 4 day pay.
And of course all the savings will mean we can afford this......
There will be no savings, continuous growth is the metric to the money makers and if that growth is actually more than the population, who cares?!
> How do you all feel about the situation?
Like crap, but like with everything else in life you can't control: go with the flow and make the best of it. If I could re-wind to the pre-AI era and give Geoffrey Hinton something else that's interesting to do I would.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
Most definitely not. But what to do about it?
> Is it okay that they are replacing our jobs with tech that would never have existed had they not taken all that work?
Most definitely not.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
I don't and I never will.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
No, I think it will lead to worse than ever seen before wealth concentration and probably the end of the societies we have come to know.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
I don't combat it other than by writing (for instance: https://jacquesmattheij.com/the-ai-contradiction/ ), by trying as hard as I can to get local AI systems working for me that are not beholden to the scammers and by comforting myself that no matter which way this goes I'm too old for it to make a huge difference on my life. But at the same time: I worry for my kids and the world they will have to make their way in.
I feel bad about it, but like a virus or wildfire, I think it is just an inevitable consequence of an explosion in technological capability. Like tissues or dry brush, information was always vulnerable to being tainted like this.
Companies are going to be deceitful either way; we have only discovered the extent to which they are able to be deceitful given advanced technology was far higher than ever imagined.
It occurred to me recently that there's an analogy to be drawn with the disputes of the 1970s/80s in the UK between organized labour who went on strike to try to maintain their share of the profits from their labour, and the capital owners who brought in outside "un-unionionized" labour to break the strikes.
The un-unionized labour were the target of horrific shaming, intimidation, and abuse by the unionized labour. Of course "scabs" as they were known to the strikers were just trying to adapt to the situation they found themselves and take care of their families so even though my sympathies lie (then and now) with the strikers (or anti-AI crowd), I feel a great deal of empathy for them. Just as I feel empathy for anyone who finds themselves in a position now (as I do) of needing to use AI to stay relevant in their jobs. But I do feel like it makes me a bit like a "scab" of the current era.
I'm sure I can't be the first to have made this connection.
People need to organize, first online and then offline. Contradicting AI propaganda is the first step.
People also need to stop using clankers entirely. The blog post's message is severely undermined by the fact that the blog is Claude slop, so it also steals from other people.
Yes, it's okay. This guy made money because Google directed to his website. Now he's making less because they're directing less. What is the argument here? That he has a "right" for Google to direct traffic to his site?
I googled "best german bank account for foreigners" and compared his site to the Google AI response. They aren't even the same! Google recommends "C24 Bank" as its #2 choice whereas All About Berlin classifies it as "not expat-friendly." Google is not simply regurgitating information from his site.
Nowhere in this article does he question whether the experience is better for the users. Ulitimately, this is plain old creative destruction. I understand it sucks when it comes for you, but "I can't earn a living doing X anymore" isn't a good justification for stopping it.
The point is not really just about this one page or this one website.
Every single website had a symbiotic relationship with Google that had become increasingly strained and now is entirely one way and has become parasitic.
The web, and thus Google, cannot exist if that continues. No the world doesn’t owe this one guy visits to his website, but the way Google operates now the only people getting visits are people paying for ads.
The issue is not that they are no longer getting redirections, but why they are no longer getting redirections.
The redirection is no longer necessary because an AI model, likely trained on their work, gives them the answer without having to go onto their site.
It’s a departure from old search engines made it easy to find the “right” site and showed a couple of ads before the user clicked onto the site, then seeing the site’s ads so they could make money too.
> Now he's making less because they're directing less
No. There are less visits to his site from Google because they’re directly displaying information from his website on their page.
That is not an accurate statement.
I have a similar feeling. Personally I combat it by running my own company. While I use a bunch of LLMs, its an “AI-last company”. I code by hand, design by hand, write by hand, and edit by hand.
There are two things I tell myself to keep my head:
1. There are really two possible outcomes. Either “AGI/SI/RSI” is achieved, or it’s not. The former will change everything so drastically, there is literally no way to prepare for it or imagine the reprocusions. Nothing about that path is in my control, so I don’t spend any time thinking about it or worrying it. Doing so would be the equivalent of us practicing hiding under our desks for when the nuclear alarms go off. It helps that I don’t find it likely, but that “1% chance” lingered in the back of my brain until I embraced this mentality.
2. The amount of investor capital and debt involved in these businesses give me very little hope for their ability to innovate. The squeeze/enshittification will come faster than with any other technology. Those business that can outlast it will come back in demand. Private drivers were almost wiped out by uber, now I know several private drivers making a killing because people are tired of Ubers. AirBNBs were posed to take out hotels or BnBs or alternative lodging; nearly everyone I know now has sworn off airbnbs, and there are tons of cool alternative options.
It sucks that these companies can steal and get away with it. They’re destroying large swathes of society and ruining millions of people’s lives to make a few rich people even richer.
But eventually the check will come due and the music will end. Forest fires burn away hundred year old trees, but in doing so allow a new generation of seeds to take root. I refuse to believe the money inferno will burn up all human desire for uniqueness, creativity, and artisanry.
Keep doing what you’re doing, follow your passions, hone a craft, use AI as little as possible, refuse AI when you don’t want it, don’t get doomtrolled, and wait for the fire to burn out.
> How do you all feel about the situation
the internet used to be a common ground, the digital commons. Now it has been appropriated by the big players. It's a new situation, for us - but not without historic precedent.
I suspect that all usable information will be behind a paywall, at some point. That was the reaction of news sites in Germany, as far as I know. Maybe we will get a workable micro payment system, as a result. I think that such a micro payment system will come with it's own search engine, in order to help with discovering information.
> How do you all feel about the situation?
I feel like it's a good thing.
> Is it just okay that these humongous companies just took all our work without paying us a dime?
We've been stealing each others work since the beginning of time. Nothing new. Let's take open source as an example. Who are the biggest contributors to open source? Typically, employees of big tech companies who have enough free time to build side projects and too much money to bother charging for it. Without big tech companies, open source wouldn't be as popular and AI wouldn't have enough data to train on. By using open source projects, we're stealing from big tech companies, so it's only natural for them to have the right to steal our jobs.
> Do you feel good supporting these companies by giving them money every month?
Yes because unless I'm able to train my own models, I'm happy about paying some megacorp to get access to a trained one.
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Any company that becomes profitable has a positive effect on society. People die from eating MacDonalds and KFC every year, but there are plenty of people who's happiness levels are increasing because of these companies. I guess AI should be seen as fast food. There are some weirdos who will talk to it about everything, but normal people will understand its limits.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
There's nothing to combat. Just accept reality. Worse case scenario I can become a construction worker or plumber. There are always houses to build and pipes to fix.
> Any company that becomes profitable has a positive effect on society
I feel like you should lead with this so we know we are speaking to a radical/extremist. This casual dismissal of the most fundamental change to humanity in a long time leads me to believe you are equating the fact you are OK with it to everyone being OK with it.
> We've been stealing each others work since the beginning of time. Nothing new.
I’m so tired of this refrain. Anytime AI clearly makes something a much bigger problem or makes it way too easy to do something nefarious the response is “well we’ve always done that” as if the speed, scale, and ease of access hasn’t meaningfully changed. AI can’t be a revolutionary tool when promises are being made and inconsequential when issues arise.
People could always get hurt crossing the street. I’d say the advent of cars made the discussion rather different, however. If somebody started talking about how dangerous crossing a street became once cars reached a critical mass, would the correct response be to throw up your hands and go “people could always get hurt crossing the street”?
Any human progress is bound to introduce dangers that can then be worked around. Crossing the road became safe after the invention of zebra signs and traffic lights. Humanity will invent solutions to the dangers of AI and I'm excited to see them.
I’m not saying the problems are insurmountable. I’m saying you can’t just dismiss the problems with “well we’ve always had that” when the scale has changed so much it is functionally a different problem.
Like you’re sitting here saying we will figure it out, but how can we fix something if we won’t even acknowledge it’s a problem?
I’d also say we haven’t exactly solved road safety.
I won't be surprised if Super Intelligence solves road safety for us.
We already know the answer we just don’t do it. Prioritize pedestrians and cyclists, safe and clear delineations everywhere, smaller/lighter/fewer cars and better public transit.
I hope all these big tech companies one day die of bankruptcy and the top CEOs of them get thrown in prison. That's how I feel.
I feel like the internet is a bunch of hypocrites who celebrated liberation of knowledge up until their knowledge got liberated. Now knowledge liberation is bad.
The takeaway from this is that people on the whole are reliably selfish and self interested. If a company gives them all of everyone else's knowledge for $20/mo, they'll pay it (and complain).
Do you consider knowledge liberated when it's served by a chatbox that inserts ads and manipulates such knowledge before delivering it to you?
Compared to knowledge that's liberated when it's served by a webpage plastered with ads that author wants you to click on?
Or knowledge that is liberated on message boards filtered through agenda mods and a hive mind?
What's your baseline here?
> What do you think will happen if these companies become profitable? Do you think it will have a positive effect on our society?
Oh hell no. You shall own nothing and rent everything, that is where we are heading. And when the AI bubble pops and lights every American's (and a lot of non-American's) pensions on fire, the AI overlords that have cashed in during the IPOs will buy up the ashes.
> Do you all just not have this feeling? How do you combat it?
By refusing to engage with AI slop of all kind, by calling out AI slop when I spot it - and by quitting the industry. I'm heading for an EE degree now, should be safe enough from clankers because at least in Germany, if the clankers take over, it's an extra exam about the electrical code and you can go from an EE degree into the trades.
In some sense it's the paperclip thing that all these people talked about.
Earth's matter is being turned into compute at an accelerating rate. These companies are moving exergy(== money) into this gigantic and rapidly growing dissipative structure at historic rates.
Yet, from an individual human being's perspective, the value of this is tough to quantify. Sure, I love making more paper clips. Claude can make paperclips really fast. Is that the point of life? Sure seems to be, based on what we are doing, in a 'purpose of the system is what it does' kind of way.
Ai should fall under libraries, the well established repositories for humankind's knowledge.
Hey, I'm Nicolas from All About Berlin. This post is a few months old. I went through a psychological rollercoaster since I wrote it. Things got worse, but so far, I can still live from the website. Next year might be my last year running it full time.
I'm traveling at the moment, but I'll grab a drink and read this thread later today. In the meantime, feel free to email me. Reader mail would be a lovely break from the flood of LLM-generated outreach emails.
Your work is very good, thanks! Just in case you may have missed this, for Hamburg it runs in an app: https://fruitfulapps.com/franzbroetchen/
Aside the issue at hand with LLMs stealing visitors, a website is much preferred. Particularly, if it is so well made as allaboutberlin.com .
And so it begins... the humans have begun to hide from the robots
This looks very different from AAB. It’s basically a classic AI-written kitchen sink of real-time data views (weather, transit, legislation, events, etc.), while AAB is a detailed human-written guide to laws and processes involved in living in Berlin. You couldn’t easily vibe-write AAB, but you could (and I assume the author did) vibe-code that app.
I’m the developer of the app. It is sad to see that someone who didn’t even use the app can talk about the app I’ve spent hundreds of hours more than a year like this. If you switch to App Store Germany, you can see that the app has more than hundreds of reviews with only 5-star.
It looks really cool, and I don't doubt that you've spent a lot of time on it, but the truth is that it fits a common mold that normally indicates "vibe-coded": a hyper-targeted super-app with hundreds of features that are mostly visualizations of public data sources. Not really in the same category as All About Berlin.
You seem to be complaining that something written by a human looks similar to AI-written stuff... which is an inevitable occasion because AI simply mimics human writing.
It's not the fault of the website that you see similarities. The beam is in your eye.
Reread my comment - I'm not talking about AAB. There's very little prose in the app we're discussing here.
I understand the concept isn’t easy for everyone to grasp, but dismissing the app as vibe-coded without even opening it seems unfair.
Isn't it?
and what concept is that?
Looking at the the website it doesn't look vibe coded at all to me. Far too much attention to detail.
The Hamburg app? You don't think "One download covers every device. Each gets a layout made for its size." looks vibe-coded?
Wouldn't it be wise to go the analog way to promote your website? Leave nice qr-codes everywhere, promote your website in travel magazines, and so on.
And maybe start with a paid newsletter subscription.
I already have a free (and ad-free) newsletter. I thought of offline marketing, but only because it seemed like a fun thing to do.
In the end, I have a "use it when you need it" website, so I don't acquire an audience the way "subscribe for fun updates" websites do. People only care about a citizenship guide if they're about to apply for it.
As a recent arriver to Berlin (7 months or so).. being able to opt into "I just landed".. I'd give you.. $250(?) for a year of drip emails about the things I need to be doing or the rhythms of life here, etc.
It's hard to remember what the next level of german paperwork I need to be doing is.. or that St Martin's Tag is a thing and how I should teach my kid how to celebrate it, or that there's a kite thing in the fall that's a big deal or... etc etc etc.
May not be the thing you're trying to build/write though.
Funny that you mention it because I had the same idea (sans monetization). A newsletter starting on your chosen date of arrival, trickling helpful information along your journey.
The infrastructure is already there, since I have built a pension refund reminder tool a while ago.
i had a similar idea for "things to do before/after having a kid (...in germany)" calendar (based on DOB in this case) - it's a generic idea that works for many things.
saw there's a bunch of them last time i checked though
If I had more bandwidth I'd love to back that project. Kids is a topic I never got to cover, but it could be a whole business.
https://www.berlin.de/kultur-und-tickets/newsletter/
partially helps with events/goings-on that's not very polluted with 6 month things showing up as "an event in your area" every day for 6 months (don't remember which stupid site does that)
I just saw they have the one for kids and signed up myself :P
Thank you for your hard work! When I arrived in Berlin 4 years ago with just my laptop in my hands and no knowledge of German language your site helped me immensely. It is still my go to place for all questions regarding German bureaucracy.
I just want to say Thank you. Your website was absolutely essential when I moved to Berlin. Like, it was my first stop for everything.
Your website was a lifesaver when I moved to Berlin, finding reliable information about how to deal with all the quirks and customs of Germany really made my life infinitely easier. I still use it from time to time.
It sucks what's happening. Not sure how to reach your audience, but your work is still relevant. Maybe you could publish it as a book and get it distributed around the city where newly coming people might find it.
Also you should consider translating your content into video format and establish a social media presence. Your content is still valuable for newcomers (and expats in general) so you could find a new way for your audience to find you now that Google search is dead.
Your website was invaluable when I needed it. Having immigrated to another country before that and tried to help other people with the same, it was exactly the kind of website I wanted to write in that situation. Everything about it was very refreshing and helpful.
I hope the future may be bright somehow.
That's so sad to hear. I got the habit of just going to All About Berlin directly, because the results in Google/ChatGPT led me down the wrong path too many times. But this usage pattern is limited to people who already know you, and it's not so frequent.
Have you considered any spin-off products? You still have a solid brand, and from what I can see, most expats here know AAB because it saved their lives at some point.
Yep. I'm applying the same integrity to health insurance, an industry that desperately needs it. I work with a trustworthy broker to get people better insurance. The commissions are a sizeable chunk of my income.
Until recently it was just another page on the website, so I didn't need to think hard about it. Now with dwindling traffic I have to choose between growing that side business and building things I consider more useful things.
I don't love that, but it beats returning to software dev. It also means that my work still revolves around giving honest advice to immigrants.
the cats out the bag, but would a more restrictive robots.txt get you out of the AI summaries? Maybe there's a way to still end up in the AI summary, but instead of the answer the AI can be "forced" to present the link to your site with the actual answer?
Given your brand awareness, have you ever considered something akin to like a concierge service? As in, go the complete opposite away from AI and offer human, in-the-flesh assistance, not necessarily with the actual legal work, but as a "guy who knows a guy"?
I am quite close to the relocation industry, and they're all suffering. People still use their services, but often after getting in trouble because Claude gave them incorrect advice.
It's also much harder to work directly for customers, especially when you can't do much to fix the bureaucracy you're helping with.
Have you said thank you once?
Have you ever written a blog post or done an interview thanking Google for the free organic traffic that turned your side hustle into a location-independent main income, allowing you to travel and overall brought comfort and money to your life?
I love your site. I hate Google.
But the way I see it, Google does not owe you traffic.
I rarely comment here, but this warrants a comment. I've been a big fan of All About Berlin since I moved to Germany. Such a well-put, precise, concise and reliable source of information for immigrants. I appreciate you and your work, and I'm really sad to see how things are turning up for developers like you, and valuable projects like these.
People are being conditioned to think that all the answers come from AI, or that AI knows everything.
But AI is only getting (inaccurate shadows of) the info from these sources which it is simultaneously working to kill. (Websites like this, StackOverflow, human written code)
What happens when there are no more sources and everyone just expects AI to answer everything or write everything? Recursive self-improvement? I doubt it.
It already starts to show. Everything is going to be the same.
Recently I started to see AI banners in local stores here in Berlin. I have seen youtube videos of americans about it, but now it came here too. And they all look the same. they look like trash. And now all that AI content will be fed into it again, taking the average of the average. Everything will be the same turd. No matter in which field of life. I don't know how this will end, but probably not in a good way
An optimistic scenario: people and companies will at some point notice this and any human creative effort will be more in demand again, because it is then special.
Exactly. It will be like fast fashion, most people can buy jeans for $20, but there are plenty of brands selling $500 jeans doing alright.
But both are made in Asian sweatshops
I'm not sure this is a counterexample. What you're highlighting is the unfortunate and increasing bifurcation into junk for the masses and luxury goods for the elite (with their associated pricing quirks) and the elimination of the middle class. That's not a reaction by those who have the junk increasingly forced upon them.
And what are the market sizes of each if these two business models?
And the hucksters will line up to sell ways to fake human creative effort cheaply.
> Everything will be the same turd. No matter in which field of life. I don't know how this will end, but probably not in a good way
Let’s be optimistic: human output will always have the edge. Artists will see respect and admiration again, unseen since the middle ages. But it will all be drowned by an abundance of grey slop.
> Recently I started to see AI banners in local stores here in Berlin
It's been going on for a while already in France and Belgium, to the point that I am pleasantly surprised when I see an illustration that is not AI.
Local events that could certainly find a local artist (I mean, if you're organising an event for local produce or local artists, you can certainly find a local graphic designer as well?), big supermarket or restaurant chains that certainly have enough money to pay an actual person to produce something that goes with their branding, city administration, schools, it seems like everyone uses it, even people who really should know better.
Interestingly though it's rarely the same overly crowded yellow-tinged design as I see being criticised online. What I see is always a lot lighter and at least quite legible, the problem is just that it completely lacks character and generally highlights the least important info.
If you think it's bad in Berlin, you should see how it is in India. I've seen AI-AI-generated ads before a film at the cinema. AI-generated menus and banners are everywhere, even at proper sit-down restaurants. You see AI-generated foods in Google maps, AI-generated government billboards.
> Everything is going to be the same.
We've heard the same refrain for decades. This is nothing new.
At one point, I thought model collapse (AI models getting trained on AI output) was a solved problem since we know what content improves a model and what weakens it. Now I'm not sure.
I think model collapse is plausible in non-verifiable domains and implausible in verifiable ones since there is still a cheap external signal.
You don’t need a model collapse if you lose the sources for new data.
While I know what you mean, the reality is that for many types of query the cost of extracting relevant information from the web has been trending upwards as a result of people gaming the attention economy. There are of course exceptions like wikipedia.
AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.
> AI has cut through that trend and that's why people use it.
Ads and SEO (AIO?) for AI content in 3… 2… 1…
This is already happening. Some of the earliest movers in this space were nation-state actors. Israel’s funding of operatives to try to bias AI towards being sympathetic towards Israel’s “situation” was well-publicized. The operatives propped up a bunch of websites overnight with a deluge of pro-Israel content.
Yeah I wouldn’t be surprised if that happened. But of course it gets weaponized by state actors from Russia to China to US, etc. My own experience is with the IRGC and Iranian government heavily weaponizing it in the disinformation warfare for minimizing/hiding the atrocities they commit. So far the impact of this tech on journalism and (dis)information has been abysmal.
In other words: Google has contributed to enshittifying the web by favoring ad-infested SEO-optimized sites, so people of course prefer the "AI summary" to sifting out some nugget of wisdom from between all the SEO copy (plus AI slop) and ads. And the rare non-ad-infested (or only moderately ad-infested) genuinely useful sites like All About Berlin end up as collateral damage...
Recursive slopification. But at the point we reach it perhaps we'd all have turned into brain rotted zombies. The internet has been dead for years now.
I'm not sure hackernews is the golden source of truth you think it is - Objectivity quickly breaks down here when anything political comes up, its really not much better than a tech subreddit
With "websites like this" I was not referencing hackernews. I was referencing the website that the article is talking about, All About Berlin. I don't know anything about that website or it's quality. I was just using it as an example of source of human-generated content.
Besides "discussions", there are definitely some comments by "tech personalities" on HN (e.g. about startup and open source history) that act as primary sources that you can't find anywhere else.
Getting people's attention with things you do is a game that keeps on changing. I grew up before the internet was a thing. The way things work changing dramatically because of the internet has been a constant throughout my life.
The status quo of small websites scraping together revenue that largely depends on Google sending traffic their way is, for better or worse, no longer valid. Google is competing with AI agents now, which scrape together answers from websites and largely remove the need of going to these websites. Google is losing traffic to these agents and is itself trying to adopt a similar strategy.
I see people projecting a lot of morality here but what this boils down to is that people had a nice ride on Google driving traffic to websites for a while that is now disappearing. That's unfortunate of course but it bounces the question back to these small websites about how they themselves are going to adapt and deal with their apparent dependence on Google driving traffic their way.
Part of that may be AI companies driving revenue to quality content. Google has done similar things historically through sponsored content, preferential treatment, etc. And part of this is content producers maybe having to find new ways of producing content and getting eyeballs on that content. There's a lot of stuff competing for people's attention out there. But people wanting to express themselves and finding ways to do so is a constant throughout history. I don't have all the answers here of course; I don't think anyone has. But I doubt people are going to be just passive consumers of information. They'll want to express themselves and they'll find new ways.
A lot of small websites were never about the money to begin with. I never got a single dollar for putting anything on stack overflow, Github, various public forums, etc. and I still did that. Stackoverflow imploded over the years. I noticed some big changes with Github where small projects like my own are largely ignored by AI agents. I have a few small projects that are definitely getting a lot less stars and PRs since about a year. Github wasn't a thing until about 2010 of course. OSS existed and thrived before that. But perhaps not at the same scale.
> revenue that largely depends on Google sending traffic their way
Ask yourself how did it come to that, and what could be the alternatives?
Exactly. For factual stuff that updates occassionally like the local scene or local laws the models will have to source original content from somewhere.
I wonder if the solution is to stop giving free updates on your website, and then contact the big model makers that you have been using my content for free but its no longer updated. If you really want updates i will provide a paid api or rss feed for you to consume. or just sign a retainer contract with me.
I would like to think most model makers should agree to this or risk providing outdated/hallucinatory info to their users.
some kind of collective action where a lot of popular content owners form associations and negotiate together may work even better.
Improvement in sensor technology and data markets means we will no longer need to rely on humans for sensory info about the world.
"Best Irish bar in Berlin" sensor?
Facebook: From analyzing meta-glasses content
Twitter: From trying to send a humanoid robot remotely controlled by some guy in SEA
Google: From paying a kid to go wearing one of those street view backpacks
Obviously /s
Yeah, I think so. If they have multiple live audio/video/lidar/ISAC feeds of every bar in Berlin, why wouldn’t they be able to know what the best bar in Berlin is?
They also have all your communications to other humans about the bars.
Potentially they even have transaction data showing daily revenue and spending patters.
Should be very doable with liquid enough data markets and sufficient compute.
This is satire, right? Do you genuinely believe that a meaningful answer to a question like "best bar" can be derived from wiretapping every public space? That "most popular" is close enough to what people actually mean when they ask that question that the loss of everything else will be accepted?
No.
Yes.
To your third, I think you misunderstood. I am not saying that “most popular” will be used as a proxy for “best”. I am saying that by having enough sensors distributed through society that we are able to tell what people think the “best” bars are to a high degree of accuracy and usefulness.
Also I want to be clear that I am not desiring this. It just seems clear that this is the machine we are building. This is why google feels comfortable cannibalizing search traffic.
I mean, companies already enter their opening hours into Google Maps for fee, rather than updating their own website (or OpenStreetMap, for that matter).
Website? You mean Facebook page?
I mean the same goes for coding. There's no innovation in any of what AI offers because it simply can't innovate, it can just replicate.
Nobody seems to realize this will lead in massive loss of innovative material.
Exactly. I for one realize this.
And instead of talking and learning about the craft so many people are dedicating all their efforts towards the latest harness setup etc. So much ground is being lost.
> What happens when there are no more sources
They just let the LLMs hallucinate and lie to us. It's not like you could verify anything anymore because fact-reporting organizations have been killed off by then too.
That sounds like a next quarter problem.
Idea: Once LLM sites identify subject matter experts, they offer some SME incentive (free tokens, upgraded model usage) in exchange for a few minutes time to fill an oft-requested gap in the LLM knowledge base.
I hate myself for writing this on a public forum to be scraped and monetized.
People are also conditioned to think that sites like All About Berline and StackOverflow know everything. They don't, they get lots of stuff wrong. At least with AI you can have a conversation, push back, etc
Most websites or blogs don't pretend to be an all knowing entity that has all the answers.
The other day I saw an ad for CoPilot that was like "Have a question? We have the answers."
>What happens when there are no more sources
I cannot see any other explanation other than "they are harvesting new, fresh human input" for some types of so-called-social media bots. The sort that is 24/7 baiting (believed to be) humans into writing an up-to-date assessment without ever contributing back. Of course that, too, will stop working eventually, as platforms that wish to retain their human user base must work to shut down such behavior.
The A.I. genie is probably never getting back in the bottle. How I would like for this technology to just not exist.
The hackernews frontpage would be sooo much nicer again as well. I used to browse hackernews being amazed and (pleasantly) surprised about the cleverness and imagination of people. but these days you have to look for the nice stuff with a lookingglass between the onslaught of breathless AI stories.
I just can't be bothered anymore to be amazed about what AI can dow now. I mean, it is amazing of course that we now more or less live in the asimov sf world. But it the kind of amazement I would very much prefer to have stayed a fantasy.
Please may I have some less.
What amazes me is that we use a futuristic technology to create things that the past would be amazed at but that are presently anodine at best.
Every one of us would want this 10 years ago, nobody wants it today.
I personally would not have wanted it 10 years ago. Not everything needs to be automated. I always liked creating things more for the community and for communicating with others my own creative vision, not being a soulless one-person factory.
I think it's nice to dream of something without facing the reality of its implications on society and people's lives, livelyhoods, and self worth.
We may need to figure out how to bifurcate the internet.
> but these days you have to look for the nice stuff with a lookingglass between the onslaught of breathless AI stories.
Not my impression. Ofc there is content about/involving AI but they are definitely interesting if you are interested in the topic (which I am and have to be as a software developer).
This is the massive elephant in the room; AI needs human-made work, published openly to further develop, and simultaneously heavily discourages human-made work to be published openly, either because the people who previously did it now use AI to do it or because the people who still do no longer have any incentive to publish it openly (and lets be honest, the incentives were pretty meagre before).
But craziest of all is that the best plan this trillion-dollar industry can come up with is "we'll figure something out later". Maybe we will, maybe AI will be able to train off synthetic data or we'll achieve the perfect model that never needs improving or we'll simply hit a wall with how much training data we need, but for a problem that an existential threat to LLM's, that's a lot riding off a few maybe's
My guess is that they plan on just buying sources of data directly and/or paying people to gather that data.
This is awful. It’s already hard to trust information online and this will make it even more opaque. Imagine you are curious about a war or political movement or event for example and the only way to get informed would be the chat box of a handful of mega corporations.
As opposed to a text box on news websites owned by a handful of megacorporations?
Yeah it’s even worse than that. But that’s also a straw man and a glaring one under a post about an independent source being destroyed.
The real elephant is that we've "funded" "content creation" (barf) for 20 years on the back of advertising. That is the long-term unsustainable problem, not AI.
It's unfortunate for 'good' website creators/maintainers but many people would prefer an AI summary of multiple peoples views on "getting a bank account in Germany" generated from lots sites on the internet than clicking through links of content of unknown quality and possibly outdated information that may just prioritize the banks with the best affiliate commission.
[1] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/best-bank-germany
prefer an AI summary
...an AI summary, where you have to check by reading all the sources anyway, because once you get into more niche topics, it turns out that the source of the AI overview is often a comment from a random Redditor without any supporting evidence (and often just wrong).
Of course, many people just take whatever AI overview says at face value without any very verification.
Scary stuff...
Or the source doesn't even say what the summary says. And you have to dig and dig to realize that what you read was just a hallucination.
This is a wide-scale erosion of truth, and people are not thinking about the far reaching long term consequences.
(Queue comments saying, "you think it was good before? Internet pages were already full of junk." Yes, but this is fundamentally worse.)
Or the source doesn't even say what the summary says. And you have to dig and dig to realize that what you read was just a hallucination.
Yeah, great point! I was trying to find some information about what is actually in the EPI Wero requirements (due to some banks now requiring Play Integrity for Wero payments). And AI overview often completely made up statements, where the stated did not occur in the sources.
It works for extremely well-known basic information, so people think it can also answer niche or difficult questions.
This is analogous to how it can make basic apps and websites, so people think it can make everything.
The people who are working with interesting info that AI can't answer or making interesting programs that AI can't write know that it is smoke and mirrors.
Alternative is weeding through clickbait spam sites trying to find something useful
We can't pretend search is better
The AI overview is worse because it presents hallucinations and randomly sourced Reddit comments as facts. Yeah, sure, there is a tiny grey text below it that says "AI responses may include mistakes."
But this is the typical big tech modus operandi. If it destroys democracy, incites hate, or whatever, it's always the user fault for misusing/misunderstanding value-neutral tech. "Guns don't kill, people kill", yet in all countries that have gun control, gun deaths are much lower.
Besides that, in AI overviews reputable sources (e.g. good news papers) get mixed up with random Reddit comments, etc. In pure search, people develop an intuition to assign a confidence score to sources. (E.g. Wikipedia > some random Reddit comment or Tweet.)
Top search results are also gamed and present a manipulated view
Search was better. But gaming SEO and paid results ruined it before AI did.
The AI summaries won’t exist without the content of unknown quality you refer to though
They would in this case, because the content is available from Reddit and other social networks. "All About Berlin" was fundamentally just a nice organisation of things "every expat knew" about living in Berlin. Now AI can know things "everyone knows", the marginal benefit of a website is low for most casual users. It's still useful to the core market of fresh-off-the-plane expats, and maybe he can pivot to targeting them specifically.
And how long until Reddit dries up? How long until Google promotes ING as the sponsored-not-sponsored recommendation?
I think Reddit (or an equivalent) will always exist, because people want a place to talk to other humans anonymously on the internet. And Reddit's data will always be accessible to AI labs, because that's Reddit's whole monetisation strategy.
Reddit is removing anonymity (as is much of the web; seems like everything wants me to login with Google..)
Well, pseudonymously. Reddit has always required login to post.
Now reddit increasingly requires a login to read, and it's completely left out of Claude answers. Reddit has the same issue as All About Berlin right now.
I've been a long-time reddit user, had an account for 15+ years.
These days, Reddit just isn't the same anymore. The talk aspect is drying up, and it is clear there's a lot of AI involvement in discussions - I'm not talking 'user has had AI rephrase their own thoughts', but 'user is an ai'. Eventually, Reddit will dry up.
I also admit, I welcome it. Maybe we can stop using the web as a money-generating venture and go back to a more private web. Fewer users, but more connection.
So much of reddit is already bots. Even posts about hating AI are clearly written by an LLM. I think the online places that will remain predominantly human will be strongly-moderated, small, closed groups that will not be indexed by search engines and not accessible to LLMs.
> "All About Berlin" was fundamentally just a nice organisation of things "every expat knew" about living in Berlin.
I think this is selling allaboutberlin.com short. There is e.g. a tax calculator (I just had a cursory look, but it seems to get the basics right). It seems to be actively curated and much better organized than a whole bunch of threads with statements of facts intermingled with opinions and rumors you'd find at a social media site.
The organisation is genuinely great. But if you need just one answer, the AI will be a better UI than even the best organised site, not least because it can also join all the threads from around the internet together and synthesise them in a superhuman fashion.
I slightly disagree here. Many of the things on the website come from interviews with experts, or from collecting data directly.[0] This information was not on the internet. Hell, even immigration experts are often confused about things. We have a group chat where we help each other out. I had to create that community.
I created that website in direct response to all the incorrect information on Reddit and in Facebook groups. In the absence of official information, you are bound to find a lot of rumours. I used to be pretty active on the /r/berlin subreddit and boy oh boy were they wrong about a lot of things.
When I travel, I have a similar experience with more obscure border crossings. The information about them is generally incorrect, and you end up with a dozen websites parroting the same incorrect source. Curation involves checking the information.
[0] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/immigration-office/wait-ti...
The AIO gives more or less the same answer as you for the permit question, without ever citing you[1]. They instead cite ESCP, ServicePortal Berlin, Expats in Wonderland, Proforg, r/berlin, the Aussies in Germany FB group and Visaguard. Your data collection effort is cool and impressive, and makes it easy to recommend your site as a one-stop-shop for new expats; but to answer the question, you are sufficient but not at all necessary.
It is interesting to think about whether we will lose some key sources of information if AIs snipe all the easy queries that can be answered from multiple sources, leaving not enough traffic for the people who were generating the data to live off (because they were cross-subsidising the hard work with traffic to their easily reproducible work). I guess one option is more paywalling for the stuff that requires hard work (i.e. the way news/blogs went, and also the way this used to work, when people would buy a book to guide them on a move to a new city).
[1] https://imgur.com/a/ETyhjE8
EDIT: just noticed the Reddit post cited is actually you! I can see the rationale for citing Reddit/HN comment threads over the page itself, but it also feels a bit like citation-washing.
Just because AI Overview doesn't cite All About Berlin specifically, that doesn't disprove that All About Berlin contributed to the generated answer.
I don't know the details of how Google AI Overview tracks data provenance, but I don't think they have an accurate way of tracing the provenance of data in their model weights.
If the value fluctuates much, then the value baked into the model will be unreliable, though? I don't think that the answer here comes from the model's intuition, but rather from the search results it got from a tool call. Especially because it's a clear paraphrase of those cited sources.
Berlin (Service Berlin) is getting its data for me. It has started adding it to its own pages, but a year or two ago it did not collect nor share that data. I have direct sources confirming it.
It's always been possible to trivialize such efforts by framing it as "every target audience member knows" if you just twist target audience definition to your liking.
Not to say of course models appropriate and resell information that just one person ever wrote about.
It would be fine if people preferred AI overviews, if the content creators were still fairly compensated for their work (instead of scammed out of it)
The quality of most sites is abysmal, mostly due to ads (content repackaging etc).
Trying to find answers today means wading through oceans of garbage websites instead of meaningful ones. Only to maybe find honest sites. That choice is by design, as search engines can shape the internet the way they see fit. They now seem to cut out the good results and make everyone pay more. “Neutral” answers where every tech bro tries to game the results for more cash.
AI answers have removed that enormous friction and constant source of frustration, also at the cost of the few good sites that are left.
Allegedly only to repeat this enshittyfication process once again. Tangentially we currently might be living in the best iteration of AI. Sure the answers can be sometimes awful and wrong, but they are mostly honest, direct, undiluted and try to be truthful.
Huh... so the job title on its way out is an "affiliate"?
I might be okay with it.
Perfect example. Usually when I would Google something like this, it would point at absolutely sloppy sites with tons of ads and fluff content to stuff seo keywords before getting to the point.
Yeah that site is total human slop and clearly just writing whatever ad people told them to write. Good riddance.
The problem with this is "garbage in, garbage out". Deterioration of search engines has already leaked into AI and full on slop results are what dominate many of such "ai summaries". At the same time, reddit gets more and more dominated by bots that in the future will probably make it an even worse source of information for these "summaries". Ime AI without a good source of information/ground truth to link at is either useless or too expensive.
People here complain about SEO infested, low quality sites but these are exactly what gets into the context of the ai summaries.
The paradigm shift we are living through is about leverage. It's akin to the printing press insofar as guilds literally lost much of the leverage to control pricing when printers would give away "how to do things" in pamphlets. Reselling the information the guilds had developed.
This will be economically devastating. It was back then. The question changes to how value can be created moving forward. The world in which information becomes free -- in literally every case -- creates a more prosperous world. How and whether that prosperity gets distributed equitably is the concern.
The fact that the tech industry has not unionized, because of their profound leverage over the last 30 years is unfortunate, but times have changed and we need to move forward. Businesses built on scalability may die, heck the open models my even kill off the brand name models.
People will still need to buy things. Developing ways to provide those things will still be valuable. Creative destruction marches onward.
The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
But AI summaries are pretty much indistinguishable from that. The search engine is the user-agent in this case. The user's actual desire is to get the information, and their agent (the search engine) is providing them an easier way to do it. The only differences are that it's on-by-default for 90% of the users rather than opt-in at 25% market share, and that there's no pro-forma page fetch of the content that could in principle be rejected by the site.
And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to. There's a lot of reasons for why the status quo would have been preferrable, while the only real reason for a change is that the status quo was not tenable and they would have lost share to the sites giving users what they wanted.
The situation is a lose-lose, but it was also the logical outcome of saying that the end-user's wishes have total primacy over the other stakeholders.
AI summaries are very well distinguishable from an ad-blocked browser in the sense you still had to click through.
And second difference, you still had to see the information the way the author decided to present them to you.
There is also reader mode, which I would be very much in favour of but rejects the authors presentation.
I am explicitly in favour of reader mode
https://nicolasbouliane.com/blog/read-it-as-you-please
> The vast majority of HN has always been pro-ad blocking, arguing that the user's wishes (to see no ads) override the content creator's interests (getting compensated for their work). The HN consensus is also generally, but less strongly, in favor of the primacy of the user-agent over the site in all other ways.
I'd argue that the vast majority of HN has always been against tracking, and against obtrusive ads. Ad blocking is only necessary because the former and latter seem to be the only way of doing ads.
> And let's be clear: users clearly do want AI overviews / AI mode. > We might not understand why the users want it, but Google would not be implementing it if they didn't have to.
Couldn't it be that Google thinks it can make more money in the long run by putting themselves even more between the user and websites with AI summaries? It could also be that they want to project their AI to new users, and that the summaries are effectively ads for using Gemini.
I personally don't believe that AI summaries are what users truly want. At least for me: I despise them for how often they are wrong or disregard the context, and how often they seem to take information of copycat Q/A websites.
Websites with the level of quality like All About Berlin were rare before AI, but I think Google will also shoot itself in the foot if it doesn't compensate its sources properly, as quality sources like this will cease to exist.
> I'd argue that the vast majority of HN has always been against tracking, and against obtrusive ads. Ad blocking is only necessary because the former and latter seem to be the only way of doing ads.
So where is the popular ad-blocker that exempts "good" ads and analytics?
https://adblockplus.org/acceptable-ads
I use uBlock Origin and sites that use non-spyware ads still have ads show up.
Example site: https://theweekinchess.com/
If you inspect those ads on this site they are just images wrapped in a hyperlink. Those types of ads do not bother me. I block ads because Google has no right to know what I do on sites they do not control.
It's also the logical outcome of a very hostile, any-abuse-is-acceptable web. People are happy with the AI overview because their experience going through to actual links is often an incredibly negative experience.
Dickovers, teasers, paywalls, cookie banners for 976 partners, auto playing video at full volume, a hijacked browser history, and on and on...oh and now the fact that they looked at that content is going to follow them to Facebook, LinkedIn, and so on.
And if you deal with all of that, often it was SEO-maxxed content that had human bots scalp from other sites. Sites that didn't invest in the "get to the top of the front page" SEO spamming and who made the actual content that just got stolen never got the love in the first place, in many cases.
On Apple mobile devices, forced to use the Safari browser whether reskinned or not, the internet is an especially hostile place. On my iPhone I basically don't go to URLs I don't know, despite having weak ad blockers in place.
The web we accepted as normal basically set the stage for this. Users are conditioned to wince at following a link. We made our bed by allowing this to become the norm.
This website has also been against copyright since forever. Call them what they are: hypocrites.
I know of someone who lost their job in journalism, not because they are using AI to write but because the site is completely starved of traffic now.
Long term, with the current state of affairs, why would people continue to create online if it just feeding the machine? Surely we are not going back to paper?
That said, Private Eye never went online and is a successful publication.
>why would people continue to create online if it just feeding the machine?
That’s precisely the reason I stopped posting anything useful or creative online. Obviously all the things I posted before have been scraped, but who could have known that the collective digital output of humanity will just be stolen like that.
I will add something unrelated to tech to that - I have a love for photographing architecture with telephoto lenses, taking advantage of the background compression effect which creates stunning and unusual visuals, especially when the Sun or the Moon are in the background - it takes a lot of planning and luck to execute such a shot.
That was the last thing I was posting online, but I stopped doing that, too, because I mostly get comments about how it’s fake/AI generated. Quite sad. I still enjoy doing that, only that it’s just for me now.
More importantly, who could have known that governments would just side with the thief even though the negative consequences to society are obvious.
Too many people are not willing to spend for good-quality journalism, sadly.
The reporter that gets shot for telling you what's up in Syria today doesn't come for free, they need to eat.
Doesn't help that good-quality and bad-quality journalism cost the same, look the same (even after you buy them) and there's much more of the latter. Classic market for lemons.
> why would people continue to create online
They are not, and this will be the death of the internet and downstream it will also kill the LLMs. LLMs kill themselves by posioning their own food (data). The net result of this LLM craze will be that we lose the valuable internet. Once again we reveal how incredibly short-sighted people and capitalism is.
They kill themselves and all of us with them. Capitalism is a suicide pact.
To be fair, the website in question is highly recommending banks with an affiliate link first - banks that are in hot waters for violating anti money laundering regulations. If your business model is so dependant on a third party you have absolutely no control over, it wasn’t really a good business to start off with. And yes, LLMs will eat the lunch of any information-only sites that don’t anchor their audiences somehow.
I mean I hate deutsche bank as much as the next person but criticizing a content creator for using referrals is unfair. It’s great referrals and ads could fund so much useful research in the past hundred years. What comes next?
content creator
LLMs will eat their lunch, not realizing it's actually eating itself. Once these information-only websites are gone, since they can no longer monetize, all that will be left will be the thousands of AI-generated websites. On top of that, Google search is practically useless today because of the amount of LLM websites, so we're forced to use LLMs to search, exacerbating the problem.
The problem is that a lot of companies/websites will already have been destroyed and society ripped apart by a post-fact world. Chances are that Google won't even be hurt by it, because together with some other big-tech companies they completely control the information that is fed to people.
Google has already had its revenue and stock price crash because it isn't directing people to pages with ads any more.
Ultimately, I think there will be a business for providing accurate, up-to-date information to LLMs. It probably won't be high-margin, though, and I don't think we're there yet.
Sure it will end the digital age as we know it, but we'll have great shareholder returns for the next few years. That's a problem for the poor people of tomorrow!
So these LLMs, which rely entirely on either being trained to have the knowledge already, or being able to search these sites to find the knowledge, are going to "eat the lunch" of these sites, killing them.
Which means LLMs are then going to... what, exactly? How are they going to be able to answer these questions in the future? It's an easy answer, so I'll answer for you - they're not going to be able to. They'll have only stale training data and outdated, abandoned websites to search, if the owners bother to keep them online. The web will get worse, and LLM-based search will get worse, too.
It was a fine business model for a long time (steady traffic increases for 7 years? I'll take that), but who could have foreseen where we are today seven years ago?
Having migrated myself, there is often very limited choice for banking as only the larger banks have processes and support for new arrivals and English language speakers (which is explained on that page). There isn't much choice between a bad bank and no bank. Sometimes people switch later, when they can.
The LLM business model is dependent on the direct FUNDING from those same firms.
It's the bank I use since 2016. It's fine. The main concern though is not finding a GOOD bank - they all kind of suck - but finding a bank that accepts immigrants that don't have the right combination of passport, residence permit and Anmeldung.
Why would I care if my bank violates AML regulations? Actually that makes them a better bank in every way, because AML regulations are a huge pain in the ass.
May I propose an alternate way of thinking of this?
Internet advertising is a bubble; ad blockers were the canary in the coal mine; and AI summaries are the straw that broke the camel's back.
In this case, the "mom and pop" websites like All About Berlin probably need to find a different revenue source or publishing model. This, BTW, is "normal." In years past, "All About Berlin" might be an annual printed guide, a monthly magazine, a quarterly pamphlet, ect, ect.
But then what will come after it?
No one knows at the moment
All about berlin is an incredible resource. Helped me a lot when I moved from the bay area to Berlin and also with all the constant visa procedures post move.
I can recommend signing up to his newsletter for berlin events - https://allaboutberlin.com/newsletter.
I'm working on something[1] similar to All About Berlin but for Hamburg. Instead of going with a website, I went with an app. Sure, it is hard to reach more people but at least, I don't have to deal with this kind of situation and I can create a much better experience.
[1] https://fruitfulapps.com/franzbroetchen/
This seems like the way to go for now. Too bad for the open web though.
Other people would go with Discord groups.
People (authors etc) are understandably upset about this. The models CLEARLY trained on data where they didn't own the IP. It just sort of happened too fast for laws to catch up, and now it just is what it is.
But let's assume for a moment that laws caught up. That courts decided that "no, you can't train an AI model by just scraping any content you want, and if you serve an AI model that suggests being trained on such content, you're also breaking the law".
What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?
But what if this is the "right" thing to do? Are we incapable of doing what's "right" now? Did the AI companies' bets on being quicker than legislation pay off?
That‘s been Silicon Valley‘s MO for about three decades
> What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy? We'd suddenly "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses, and the quality of AI models would jump backwards several years (Which on an AI timescale is like a century)?
Yes? There's going to be a cataclysmic change to the economy when the money runs out anyway. Why should these brand new companies who skirted and ignored the law get a free pass. Is it really sensible to have environment where you can become too-big-to-fail in less than a decade because a dozen guys with cash decided it should happen?
I think the problem here, as always, is "But what about China?"
What about them? That argument hasn't had any impact on IP laws before so why should it now?
If we outlaw these models, but Chinese companies don't, then companies like Deepseek who offer models based on it would need to be banned in the west just like the sale of conterfeit Gucci bags is. It's just fair trade policy. But the end result of that is basically that we accept that "western" models, and the models available to all of western industry are much worse than what Chinese companies use. E.g. Chinese software development firms get Opus 5.5 level AI help, while everyone at US software firms get AI agents that are 2023 level. Those US firms would quickly realize that offshoring pays massively.
You don't just ban the unethical technology but also ban imports of goods created with it. The same is true with other immoral "tools" that greatly benefit companies like slaves or just dumping your waste wherever or mixing in unhealthy chemicals into your food to make it look better.
In the end, I think it would be extremely difficult to have such a "taint" rule for (for example) software. It would essentially be a complete ban with cooperation with companies outside the great-ai-wall of the west. Having a management consultant from India? big no no because his recommended reorg might have run through Deepseek.
I don't think this is about training, it's about creating an "AI summary" specific enough for a particular query, that the user never clicks the citation link and visits the website.
Or, am I misunderstanding what is TFA is about?
Yes they're two related things. Google always crawled and indexed, and an index could always show a "summary" e.g. the first paragraph of the page in search results. Some news outlets were upset even before AI that the summaries were too long/detailed that users never had to click.
An Ai just supercharges that problem. The "AI summary" can basically leave people with no reason to click the link.
The other thing is the "AI answers", i.e. when there is an answer at the top of a search result which answers the search query as an LLM answer, potentially wiht some links etc. That could suggest it's actually taken from training data rather than just page summaries.
Whe should absolutely "outlaw" several of the world's largest businesses if they are making things worse for everyone else. Not doing that sends the message that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail. That would be an even more devastating position for society to take.
> that the law doesn't matter if you can scale up quickly and become too big to fail
That’s exactly the world we live in though, and have for a long time.
Why are we still burning fossil fuels on the scale we do? Why are we still selling cigarettes and alcohol on the scale we do? We are we still giving so many subsidies to tech businesses, or older businesses (like Walmart, McDonalds etc) through food stamps? Why is the orange man still in charge of destroying the civilized world despite so breaking so many laws and open corruption? Banks bailed out after they get in trouble by being reckless and breaking the financial system?
The list is endless. Rules don’t apply if you have enough money.
> What would happen? This seems like it would be a cataclysmic change to the economy?
Ah we’ve entered the too big to fail era of AI corporations even before they turn a profit. How nice.
Here's the simple answer: these models were trained on the sum total of human knowledge, so they belong to humanity.
The judge rules that they are exempt from all intellectual property and trade secret laws, the labs must publish the weights and all the documentation needed to write an engine, and the labs' employees are indemnified from any adverse action for leaking anything their employers withheld.
Done.
The crime of stealing all our data has been committed but at the very least they could be forced to remove information from the training data when requested.
The thing about the Google AI overview that I find most baffling is how self-defeating it is. You kill the traffic to sites, the sites die, now you don't have anything for your AI summary to pull from. Also Google is an ad company, they're literally removing their own revenue sources by reducing clicks.
The few times per week I still use google search, I basically have very specific questions and follow the link to the source...
Not to mention it costs them many times more to serve AI overviews than just traditional search results
Google's stock actually crashed because costs are up and ad revenue is down specifically because of the search results AI, but they still haven't learned.
Learned what? If that overview wouldn't be there people would just flock to Anthropic or ChatGPT even more than they do now.
Search and Ads on websites are getting eaten alive by LLMs. No one knows how to properly monetize AI search yet but VC funds don't care they keep pumping money into OpenAi and Anthropic
So either Google has to cannabalize their search revenue or get eaten by OpenAI and Anthropic while they figure out how to turn a profit.
They know, they've always known. There was a post years ago back when AI was emerging from one of google SEO public relations people who basically articulated that what's happening now would kill the ad supported search model they'd been running since google was founded.
The issue is, OpenAI came on the scene and forced their hand. If Google doesn't do what they're doing then OpenAI or Anthropic becomes the new google search.
So they must adapt or die.
As to how new information gets into the LLM's, my guess is instead of being on the web it gets split up across multiple places. Youtube for edutainment, apps for controlled access to relevant specifics, but ultimately there will no longer be a single openly accessible text version of new information anymore because all the incentives to create something like that are gone.
Relying on Google for traffic was never a great strategy and I learned this the hard way myself. I have a website that produced ad revenue for very little work and used just make a big chunk of my income until about 15 years ago when Google traffic just collapsed, and that was that.
Its not AI, its big tech control that is the central problem.
I respect your work and I can completely understand your feelings. With that, I have but one advice.
Sue.
If they reuse your content, lawyer up and make them pay for it. Nothing will happen unless people stand up for themselves.
I recommend everyone try the example search for themselves (best german bank account for foreigners) and look at everything in the first SERP.
On DDG I get All About Berlin as #6. All the sites above it appear to be LLM generated. Everything is affiliate slop.
On Google I get All About Berlin #2, below Reddit. It only gives me 7 standard search results and a lot of other garbage. Everything besides Reddit is affiliate slop.
On Kagi I get All About Berlin #1. Out of the other 25 results one is Reddit, one is Facebook, and the rest seem to be all the same list style as All About Berlin with a mix of clearly LLM generated content and some that may have been but isn't clear. It's all SEOed.
This is a case where all the results are bad. I don't ever want to be recommended something from an affiliate site. It's just another form of advertising. I also don't want to see any LLM generated sites. None of this is organic content. It's all SEO sites to sell you stuff.
I have to say from the bottom of my heart: Thank you for making my 4 year stay in Berlin more bearable.
Intellectual property rights came into being to address the free-rider problem — patents, trade secrets, copyrights.
We might need a new form of IP right.
But to restate the obvious: A new form of IP right would likely require legislation — at the federal level. Therein lies the problem: Pretty much all elected officials spend (too) much of their time dialing for dollars for their reelection campaigns. That can make them reluctant to enact, or even endorse, measures that are opposed by their big campaign donors.
To be fair, Google’s been suffocating search for years, before AI. Actual search results have been pushed below the fold for a long time, if you happen to not use an adblocker.
The usual advice is "do GEO now" and optimize to get cited in the AI answer. I'm not sure that saves a site like this. Even when you get cited, almost nobody clicks the link, because the whole point of the answer is that you don't have to. Being the source the AI uses and being a business are separate things now.
What if you poison the AI?
Don't you click the link because you want the actual truth instead of the AI summary? Plus more information around the answer, details the AI left out etc.
Can't people use cloudflare to block AI bots? It has a setting and google says it respects it if one does not want AI training.
The outcome is the same: you get no traffic, then your website dies. It's hard for individuals to combat monopolistic behaviour.
Reddit is a far more powerful player, and they are facing the same fate. Currently, they're blocking Claude, and it just means that their content isn't surfaced in Claude's response. Does it benefit reddit? Probably not.
Reddit is blocking Claude so it can sell access to Gemini. Who knows how far ahead they come out of that deal
Switched to DuckDuckGo as my main search engine some years ago. Not even for ideological reasons, the results were just better.
Regardless of who provides what resource, the fundamental question is: is a static guide a better way to support people who want to learn about Berlin, or is the AI bot derived from that static guide better. Once you remove hallucinations from the evaluation (2024, what a crazy time, right?) it's pretty clear the bot wins, right?
That sucks for the content creator, I know. We're heading for a crazy pace of change, similar to but more intense than when Walmart was busy killing downtown shops, or when Amazon was busy killing bookstores and other internet retailers.
How does the bot win? Rephrasing or paraphrasing means that the reader loses some precision and context that the author intended you to read. Summaries often lose advice that you did not ask for, but still need to receive. Think "I know you're asking about X, but since you're on that journey, you really ought to also do Y and Z".
Some kind of reparations?
Maybe AIs could pay attributed sources, similarly to the way musicians license their samples.
At this point, Google must be aware that:
- They had to introduce AI Search Overviews (competitors would've killed search altogether; now they have some sort of control).
- AI Search Overviews won't work without content creators.
- Content creators won't continue if AI Search Overviews keep eating their lunch.
- They have to come up with an incentive model for content creators to keep doing the things that power AI Search Overviews.
Time will tell.
Newspapers aggregated public info and got wiped out. What would make you think online info aggregators wouldn't get wiped out too?
If you aggregate something, AI will aggregate a thousand times better than you
It's time for horseback messengers to understand that cars and planes deliver info faster and better than them, and that applies to ALL branches of work
If it can be replaced by AI it will be, so be prepared and don't complain
This is a quite miopic comment and the analogy does not work.
When cars and planes arrived, the horseback messenger still had everything he had before. Nobody stole his horse. Instead, others offered a superior service and while it sucked for his livelihood, what was taken from him was opportunity, not the fruit of his labor.
AI takes what we all did for the community and profits from it. Google did not compile better information than the website. It stole it and is profiting from it.
Newspapers also created new info by employing all sorts of journalists. That is sort of the crux of the story here (who will collect this information and report it when there is no financial opportunity there anymore).
Google gets a lot of stick on this topic as in this article. But it’s all of them. People “search” just as much in Claude and ChatGPT.
Wow at that screenshot. And that's what everyone is using now? Surely it can't be that bad on every search.
Google has had up to 4 above-content ads on commercial queries for like ten years. Ever since they killed sidebar ads. See reporting at the time: https://www.searchenginejournal.com/google-removes-right-han...
They have also continuously made those ads look more like search results.
Eh, I think the 2026 style for ads is more obvious than the 2016 one. Assuming you correctly read sponsored as a euphemism for ad.
Recipe sites too. The ai summary is usually a 100% copy of the top recipe result in the links, but stripped of extraneous info.
Recipe sites did that to themselves with their cancerous AEO shenanigans. Three pages of useless background drivel before I get to the recipe just so it ranks. The AI will get me a recipe, adjust it to what I have at home, help me with any cooking questions and so on, it's a better value proposition as a user, it is what it is.
I think they only did this because Google prioritized it. Google could have easily spent some human effort to promote “good” recipe sites, but they were lazy and didn’t.
Exactly, Google search declined because Google embraced SEO instead of fighting it.
It sounds like Google did that by giving the owners wrong incentives. I suspect as ads starts to infect AIs more and more you will see similar crap that will make the results less and less useless.
> The AI will get me a recipe, adjust it to what I have at home
Unless it doesn’t. I’ve had AI come up with very… interesting recipes that ended up in the trash can because they were 100% hallucinated and didn’t work in the real world.
Recipe sites were already disastrously bad, though -- thousands of words of intro and fluff before the recipe, presumably to create more space for the ads.
And to humour… google search’s algorithm so they’d rank higher.
> How do you combat it?
Aside from the bot countermeasure arms race? Vicious litigation and collective bargaining/lobbying. No way around it, there never was. Unless to you "rolling over" is an acceptable, or even necessary, solution for your particular case, or in general.
This is one of the reasons why I try to ignore the AI overview and go straight to the links below.
Full circle.
We track the W3C's TDM Reservation protocol uptake, and I'm surprised it's so low, we only see it on 1,113 sites ( last month ), 1,876 sites this month.
https://www.w3.org/community/reports/tdmrep/CG-FINAL-tdmrep-... https://theweb.report/#ai-web
Why would you publish an llms.txt when no LLMs in existence ever read them? This is doing something theater.
Yeah is funny - I thought it was a standard when I added the check for it, just people jumping on it!
From Google search console "LLMS.txt files and other "special" markup: You don't need to create new machine readable files, AI text files, markup, or Markdown to appear in Google Search (including its generative AI capabilities), as Google Search itself doesn't use them."
Dead Internet Theory on steroids in here.
World is changing. Websites once killed the need of magazines and many types of books too..
I rather look at it as an opportunity to demonopolize Google as I do exactly the same (overviews and insights) I just find Google Gemini obsolete as I find better AI solutions where I can check for knowledge and information.
Open Web has a lot of content that was crawled before and I really hope that all that SEO/Traffic hunting nonsense stops to benefit Google towards major regression. They are so 00s company and we're heading towards 30s of XXI century.
Web is dead anyway.
Don't you feel it is a shame that the open web is being killed by the greed of companies like Google and OpenAI?
I do think honestly that we lost a lot in losing the book publishing industry, which is now a shadow of its former self - all those talented editors and illustrators didn't find work elsewhere doing their job, the jobs just ceased to exist, and the curated ideas they used to produce now doesn't exist either. For now we're feeding off the achievements of the past, ripped from old books to scan, but what happens to truth and beauty when LLMs can't distinguish either and are fed on their own pap?
What is the alternative to the open web for sharing information with other humans? How do you see this playing out?
It's been killed by Google long before AI. Facebook and Social Media did not help to keep it healthy either.
Perhaps we should just move on and find another way of sharing meaningful content to meaningful people in a meaningful way.
Or go back to talking to other people? ;) Over the last couple of years I've been increasingly reaching out to friends and asking for recommendations on different topics. It's inefficient and doesn't give an immediate response, but the quality and depth of what I've learned this way is amazing. And it's probably saved me hours of reading through marketing AI slop pushed all over the internet these days.
Well perhaps. Or we could collectively stop using Google and giving them our money. That’s a nice simple fix.
I haven’t used them in years.
that's exactly what I have done years ago and long before AI came in. I stopped using Google and I found it's actually not that relevant in digital space as I thought it could be.
It's not being killed, it's already dead and now vultures are picking apart the corpse.
Think about what's coming next after the mega corps have assimilated all data in their private vaults. The next step is to go on q crusade to get the free Internet and the data they feasted on nuked from the web so that people have no choice but to rely on them.
You can expect something like browsers (chrome) refusing to load "unsafe" content i.e. material from the free Internet.
“Local and federal government offices refer people to my guides. The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves.”
Have you tried pursuing grant income?
Yes! I'm very close to people who operate that way. I have the best possible network to make it happen. Unfortunately, it's a fickle, bureaucratic way of earning a living.
All About Berlin is amazing, it has helped me a lot when moving here, there’s immense value in having a curated, regularly updated, always reliable source of information. I hope it can survive and also hope similar projects can survive.
Said it three days ago
>Google & friends no longer passing traffic through to the sites (AI summary style) feels like it may genuinely kill the internet.
Happening to me as well at BookDNA.com :(
Super frustrating to see Google crawl all our hard work, and then stop any traffic to us.
I was expecting to read about AI scrapers but it's not, it's about Google taking away their traffic by providing AI overviews. Something that's happening to many websites.
Have you tried providing poison data to Google?
its important to distinguish between training and agentic search both have similar effects but with very different solutions. for training we need licensing rules that apply to small content not just the studios that can afford the lawyers, websites provide payment and licensing terms for training access and training systems decide if they want to skip the content or pay. for agentic access its hard to imagine an alternative to micropayments similar to what cloudflare is experimenting with. i dont think a future where search results or recommendations will be visited directly much again is realistic.
It’s a snake eating itself type of thing, it reduces ad revenue and the investors already flinched on the last earnings report.
Never blame the technology. Focus on the people, or in this case the corporations wielding that power. It is in their best interest not to cause an extinction event of the ecosystem they thrive on. Currently they (Google etc) are merely leaching on the ecosystem without giving anything in return (destructive). Ideally, you reach symbiosis where there is a net positive result for both sides, ie. enough money flows back one way or another to the content creators you depend on. Either way, eventually this will come back to bite them, but in the mean time the ecosystem, maintained and built by real people, are the ones feeling all the hurt and it's a very sad state of affairs.
Very naive take. Corps will happily move on and ditch previous audience and partners as soon as they find a different profitable path. See Nvidia.
We need a new internet that can be protected by LLMs reading or writing it. And in general find a way to isolate the world from big tech by creating competitive products. I feel like if a lot of talented people got together we can do this.
If you can solve that problem without censoring or gating the internet behind invasive identity checks, you could make a fortune
why do it without invasive identity checks? Everything posted should be tied to a real world identity so that people own their words. Kind of like real life is :D
Because there are bad people out there who abuse this. If you think a false DMCA takedown is bad, imagine when they know your physical address. You don't know theirs, of course.
I unashamedly place 100% of the blame of this on people who continue to use AI. Stop. It is ruining everything.
Everything you do is a choice. They say they'll fire you? Will they? Have they fired anyone for refusing to use it?
They can't fire everyone. Stand up and be counted.
It's all running on fear anyhow. The companies using it are frightened that a competitor using AI more than them might outcompete. The leadership push that fear down till you're scared about saying anything ... and many people have a mortgage and perhaps didn't get their latest job that easily.
You can see how the doom stories coming out of the AI companies themselves are rather calculated to engender the feeling that he who is not first to somehow get onside will be crushed by the giant machine. Only the true zealots might survive etc.
They can fire an awful lot and when your choice is use AI vs your kids are now living in a car, you’re going to choose AI.
That is never the actual choice. There are always alternatives. Stop making excuses.
True, the gutter is also an option.
There are beautiful bridges, also homeless shelters.
I am in a position right now to determine which developers will be staying with the client's business in 2027. I can assure you that we absolutely will. There is a contingency to start over with a completely new team.
> Everything you do is a choice.
I agree. You can choose to be more moderate.
The #1 reason we are looking to off board certain developers is because of this exact extreme ideological position regarding AI.
I feel I should point out the irony of asking people "to be more moderate" while, simultaneously, being ready to fire your entire technical team for not agreeing with your decision.
you, too, will pass.
We just went through our second redundancy cycle in 9 months. In the space of 3 years my team has gone from 30 people to 5. The job market is so terrible I've got ex colleagues who lost their job 9 months ago still can't find a job. I mostly keep my head down but a lot of the people who didn't get onboard with ai were those same ones who lost their jobs. As well as their interview process involving ai and how they use it. Id love to stand up and not use it but unfortunately I have a mortgage and children to feed.
I watched a video of 50+ year old nurse who went to nursing school at 46. We can reskill.
Into what? It's impossible to predict what's not going to be impacted by ai - and those fields are going to become incredibly more competitive and lower paid as everyone pivots to them.
you unashamedly blame this systemic issue on individual consumers?
Ultimately, yes. Individuals do have the power here - both in their own actions and in what rules they collectively enforce.
We live in a capitalistic society, it's irresponsible to think that any individual or even group of people have control of this situation. Money will drive this to a point of either the government stepping in or the end of humanity, possibly both.
More broadly, AI is killing the affiliate link and the ad-supported business model. As an AI user I love using AI, because it gives me what I seek (answers) and it takes a minuscule amount compared to what the previous systems took.
While I have never used it, All About Berlin seems like an exceptionally good resource, not showing ads, but rather making its money by driving traffic with good information and having partnerships with affiliate links.
Other than this, most of the ad-supported web I greatly dislike. Usually the noise drowns the signal, because websites competed not on the goodness of information, but the SEO rankings. I have been blocking ads since 2005 and I never used affiliate links either, so from my very narrow individual perspective, I was never a valuable visitor in the first place.
It would be great if the quality sites like AAB could get another stream of revenue that makes them sustainable, even in the AI age. I'm afraid they run into a similar problem to monetizing open source software. At the end of the day, if the information is out there, people and corporations will take it, and not contribute anything back. That won't change, so it needs to be factored in somehow.
As always, Google never owed this site any free traffic. The author was lucky to catch that free money while it lasted.
Do you just hate humanity or something?
No, but I'm not a fan of a for-profit affiliate site thinking another business owes them something, and then complaining about it.
If traffic is so valuable, buy an ad like the other sites on that page.
Once again we see success is not driven by how well you do the thing, but by how well you play the game of capitalism. Meritocracy is a lie.
That's an interesting POV.
We could also conclude that because Google transferred users to their site for years they can now use their content without paying them?
Content that was available for free.
Outside of the usual stealing of copyrighted work, this is a different ethical conundrum.
Wecome to the club. I managed a somewhat successful community website from 2003 and by 2018 it became a shadow of itself as users flocked to Facebook, Instagram and the likes.
Do you think there is hope for small communities in 2026? I would love to launch a forum around All About Berlin because Facebook and Reddit are terrible in different ways.
Nope. Probably not yet?
It is nothing new in this case. It hit others with updates to Google's search results before.
The problem is, he is dependent on Google's traffic. This is a big weakness in his business model.
It's a big weakness in our econmies that we have let Google monopolize user acquisition to the point where most online businesses are dependent on them.
Google isn't the first and won't be the last, it goes back to and before Standard Oil. We have an economic system built around monopolies.
"All About Berlin" is the first result for me, after AI. Only two things on the page.
To be honest I'm guilty of using AI for many things I used to use websites for. News (with web-searched sources and citations), Recipes, Exercise routines, Managing my emails
Why? because its a better user experience. It's that simple. News sites in particular (but websites in general) are ad infested hellholes or paywalled to the point of uselessness. An AI app is a single source of pretty much anything I need, for a relatively small monthly subscription and no ads. I can even have claude just build an artifact if I want the data rendered in a nice readable website
If traditional web wants to compete it needs to be a better product first and foremost. People need to pick it over an AI app
Is the AI generated content as up-to-date as the source site, because if it’s not, we’re all losing out. Is it only as relevant as the last model?
related: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50540178
I can relate somewhat to the guy's situation, however I have no sympathy for him. The same things happened multiple times to me but already 20 years ago: boards, blogging.
I established once a well-known and used board in a niche, several blogs - and filled in the void that the major publishers later began to steal or recover from me, whatever truth there is, due to their brand power and marketing.
Due to Technorati and Digg as well as other bookmark exchanges/sharing services like StumbledUpon dying, I lost traffic and had to shift. The single best source of readers was: Google search.
So I had to consider SEO, which already had an impact on my work because either you adapt and optimize or do you thing and stay alone.
Even taking SEO into considerations, others did this, too. And as a rule of thumb: the winner takes it all. Everything below being the first link to be featured ment loss. And SEO was a rollercoaster between no visitors at all and being slashdotted so to say.
The truth is, that Google search never was and is a reliable source of income.
"Made for Google search" has never been a viable business model.
And the truth is: this has nothing to do with AI.
Back then people copied your websites and due to black hat went above you in the search results. And eben Matt Cuts killing quite a lot of the spam and fake websites, Google search stayed a rollercoaster.
I think that in the aftermath quite a few people will hopefully understand, that being featured and having a readership is not the same. Websites and blogging was a niche topic in the beginning. Even AdSense hasn't been invented. People wrote and publicized their stuff because of the exchange with others and their interest in writing in public as an author.
Now with AI it is similar with the book marked: the winners take it all, while the beginners have to fight for every reader - and convince them of their product.
I don't feel sorry for the guy because search views are no readership. Search clicks are like the AI ironically: click and gone with no value given at all.
I think that the troublesome aspect about AI is, is its sudden omnipresence and extreme capability: earlier there was the saying "Have you googled this?". Now you literally don't have to read something, you get a top notch concierge service to skip reading and directly get results bypassing thousands of experts because AI is better than anyone of them as a generalization.
This didn't happen gradually, it happened in stark waves.
No one thought Google search would ever be dying nor getting outranked.
Loyal readers are never coming from Google nor any other search engine. The guy's story is honestly a story of bad conversion it seems: after years of traffic gains, loyal readership didn't increase. I feel sorry about his work but he shouldn't blame Google.
This is an experienced perspective and I can confirm all of your points.
Relying on Google is like gambling, it always was. And it always was unfair!
Doesn't make it better though..
The Verge has been calling this Google Zero for a while now. Let's see what Sundar Pichai has to say about it:
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/P6kDTC--PGw
Truth be told, I don't quite know what Sundar said here but it may be McKinsey Speak for "suck it up".
It was Google that allowed the author’s website to have enough traffic to serve as his source of income in the first place. Google giveth, and Google taketh away.
Every society splits power in three tiers.
At the top are the people with the power. At the bottom are the people who are tread on. But that's nothing interesting.
The more curious group is the middle one. They are paid by the top to help keep the bottom away from the top, or to keep the bottom giving money to the top or voting for the top, or sometimes to help members of the top compete with each other. In the Gervais model, they are the Clueless. People in the middle group often believe they have power but they do not. Cops also fall into this tier.
Google is in the top, and All About Berlin is in the middle. AAB only ever existed as an instrument for Google to funnel money towards Google, from advertisers and competitors. AAB was allowed to exist and its author was allowed to feel in control as long as he was fulfilling this purpose for Google. Once the tool no longer serves a purpose, it is discarded. In the Gervais model, the top group is called Sociopaths.
This dynamic appears to be playing out here in textbook form.
Yeah why spend effort in creating something when it just gets stolen and never read by a human?
"This is not an isolated case." He says. No, it's not.
The same happened to carriage makers, stable workers (automobiles), ice cutters and ice-delivery men (mechanical refrigeration), telephone switchboard operators, photo processing labs, yellow pages, travel agents, printed encyclopedia businesses, elevator operators, streetlamp lighters, handloom weavers, intersection traffic officers, (...).
The Luddites were right about everything.
AI has many problems, but "I can not make recurring income from being a digital librarian" is not it.
> It’s hard to fund my work with only a quarter of my audience.
As someone who thinks that all the big issues of the digital economy are rooted in the misaligned incentives between consumers and producers, I think this is a great thing.
> The Berlin immigration office uses my data about themselves.
It's not your data, you just compiled it.
Plenty of people are doing that, for free, on Wikipedia.
And the motivation of the people doing it for free will be just as negatively affected by the machine eating up their hard labour as those who have been doing it for profit.
So many implications in one single sentence:
> people doing it for free will be just as negatively affected
Are you sure? Look at Wikipedia or Wikidata. Has the activity stopped since Google started showing snippets on the sidebar?
> affected by the machine eating up
The machine is not "eating up" anything. The website is still there. It's just now that it's not so easy to monetize people's eyeballs. This is a good thing.
> hard labour
It's not hard. If it were, people wouldn't be doing it voluntarily in the first place.
> those who have been doing it for profit.
That's the thing. Automation has been removing the value-add of a ton of jobs. We are only going to starting care about this now that we knowledge workers are starting to feel the heat?
If people want to make money from providing curation, then they need to charge upfront. Giving it for free and hoping to make up by some secondary activity leads to a race to the bottom.
I am sick of Americans not enforcing anti trust. Americans effectively get to do whatever the hell they want by enforcing a “free market” almost worldwide. A game they easily win as its rigged in favor of the richest country. Subsequently they refuse any anti trust for their tech “hyperscalers” allowing them to monopolize enabling insane margins. Then they pat themselves on the back and proclaim “American Exceptionalism”.
Consider yourself lucky you got to do that. It's over now.
Your money and users belong to Google now, there's nothing you can do about it. Live by the algorithm die by the algorithm.
Oh, how naive. Did we ever, think that those mildly gatekeeping knowledge (search) would not - at some point - go all the way.-
Also the irony of toolcalling is that the AI now uses search to be more accurate. Works great until it cooks all sources of truth. Wonder what the long term strategy looks like
Long term strategy is not to rely on a human-in-the-loop pipelines for data. Always sensing smart devices + 6G ISAC and other tech will capture raw world-data and LLMs will be used to interpret it.
Will help but does that encompass all information?
It sure seems like a lot of it. When you join smart devices + self driving cars + ISAC + chat/social media + satellites you get quite a bit of coverage, especially once the rollouts are further along. Robust data markets are pretty critical to making all this stuff usable though.
What’s left? Underwater stuff, some stuff far from settlements that cant be picked up from satellites, stuff underground, stuff inside our heads, tactile sensations. And probably some more I haven’t thought of.
Of course our intrepid scientists and entrepreneurs are already chipping away at these gaps.
Google giveth, Google taketh away.
What bothers me, isnt that the AI overlords just stole everything as I enjoy having access to the info, whether its a book synopsis or what not.
What bothers me is that the guy who made Rediit, Aaron was some well meaning kid, who tried to download some journals, and he ended up being forced off this plane of existence for it.
I guess Im saying its not the use of the info that bothers me as much as how everyone is cool with it now but not before.
I have literally no idea why, I guess that bothers me.
Oh, you're right! AI is killing a lot of stuff.
It's ok, though, because if a big tech corporation decides to do it then that's just inevitable progress making the world better and you should change jobs. Except, according to them, all jobs will soon become obsolete and you're destined to be ruled by a feudalistic god-emperor.
I prefer my emperor rotting on a throne
Billionaire class: High universal income! (For my 1000 kids and the people I like)
That job only came into existence because people started thinking that writing content once and renting out space to that same big tech corporation was an ethical way to make a living.
Let me give another example from Barcelona. We were there and with no ticket two months in advance, we couldn't see Sagrada Familia. This is according to all easily accessible information at Google and with Claude researching.
Your only option is to pay weird middleman 10x the price for non-existent or shady tours.
Guess what - it was all wrong. Go there, buy a physical ticket for 2 days later. I think this is all going in the wrong direction. People with malicious intents fake the online data until nothing there is correct.
We saw this enshittification of social media already where it is all far-right now - both ownership and propaganda. People fell for this a few times, but reality hits eventually.
"Put simply, it shows immigrants how to adult in Germany their new country."
What? I suppose "Put simply, it shows immigrants how to adapt in Germany, their new country." is meant.
For the love of everything holy, people, please stop using spell check tools. One or two characters off is i) easy to spot and ii) the intended word usually obvious (at least it usually will be obvious that there is a typo). A helpfully corrected, but wrong word is more difficult to spot and makes the intended meaning hard to guess.
It's not a typo, it's millennial internet speak for "how to manage your life like an adult."
It's easy. Add a license to your website that allows indexing but not LLM training or LLM access. Sue to the ones who infringe.
The answers in the screenshot are not even sourced from the site. Because "Use N26, duh" is an obvious answer to the question available from thousands of sources on the internet, and if the highest-quality ones turn off access there will still be hundreds more places confirming the same thing.
Google Ads showing Deutsche Bank and Commerzbank at top, two of the most bad guys in German financing! Involved in serious stuff regarding human rights or Russia. Fresh Hacker leak 2 days ago shows connections to unethical stuff I only knew from Swiss banks.
Best German ethical bank maybe: -> Tomorrow Bank based in Hamburg 100% digital, or -> GLS Bank for those who care about others. ;)
Google was always bad to me so I ignored those ads with joy: a company promotes itself via Google? Then I don’t buy t you. Others could follow.
We have the money. We decide. Then we might help those content creators/ Webhosters too.
Ethics might be a reason why you pick a bank, but you paint it a bit one dimensional. People pick bank accounts by various other factors like costs, cards, a branch close to their home, etc.
If I sign up for Deutsche Bank and receive interest am I taking money away from people who are doing human rights abuses? That seems like a good thing.
I looked at the main page. It seems like all this information should be provided at tax payers expense for the people. And an ai should then be used to sift through it as an aid to humans. So… i think we’ll be okay as long as the german government does its job. Perhaps ai can help them.
In the AI world, information DOES NOT want to be free.
Nicholas, I would look into grants and public support. Your website is useful to Berlin in a way that the official ones are not but it does work thanks to an information organization gap. Trying to get hired to help the official resources fill the gap could be an option? Bureaucratically very hard in Berlin, but going the Stiftung way might be an option
Google should attribute your work by paying you based on the ads they serve with the AI responses based on your texts.
What scares me with the rise of synthetic content is that organic reviews, feedback, discussions have been all removed. Reddit is cut off and impossible to browse. What is coming are various "hate speech" and "anti defamation" regulations together with intensified lobbying for "digital ID" or similar.
Websites have been intermediated. Tech became the very middle man they said they were trying to strip out.
I guess the benefit is that now everyone can just blame the middle man and force them to comply.
The solution is becoming pretty simple, really: if you earn income / value from unique information only you can provide, it’s time to put that information behind a paywall.
Unfortunate for the dream of the open web, but smaller website/content creators are only reacting to what bigger companies are doing.
Then maybe need to change the strategy to try to be in the AI mode. Time to adapt.
I won't be reading the web if I can delegate an agent to do it. Nobody is entitled to continued feasibility of their business model within which they publish.
That said, I think this site is awesome and it helped me a lot when I moved to Berlin two years ago.
>If my work just get mixed into an AI-generated answer, I lose my voice and my audience. My carefully chosen words lose their meaning. No one shakes my hand and buys me a beer. No one tells me how their citizenship application went.
As someone who writes for a living, I find this scenario both a fascinating challenge and a terrifying prospect. We've have many meetings about how to write our copy to ensure AI finds it unique enough, but succinct enough to steal for its own summaries, to give our narrative a fighting chance. Fortunately the core of our content is not easily summarized, so we're still getting passthough traffic. Moving to mobile first design years ago is paying dividends now- what few dividends there are to have, that is.
The world is ruined by US greedy capitalists that live quarter to quarter.
The web before AI wasn’t all sunshine and rainbows. So many websites were stuffing their pages with filler text to be ‘SEO-friendly,’ and the top results you clicked were full of affiliate links, unnecessarily long paragraphs, and, in some cases, misleading information.
Simple. Assume that you know one trustworthy website. It has a bunch of links to other websites that are similar and also verified by the website you're currently on. These websites of course want to be friendly to they link back. But they also link to other websites. In this way, you can discover an entire web of pages that are verified to contain quality material, by going through relevant topics like "travel” -> "travel to Germany" -> "expats in Germany" -> "expats in Berlin".
I have a strong feeling that someone has already invented this technology, but I cannot put my finger on it.
I think what you are describing is a link between two pages, but it's some kind of super-link, mega-link, maybe a hyper-link. And it forms a kind of mesh, net, or web of pages that spans the entire earth, the complete planet, the world wide.
Awesome website btw, it helped me a lot. Really side situation
If Google search results stop showing you real websites, what stops GMail from no longer showing you the real emails you receive, and instead fabricating things based on the highest bidder?
Nobody is entitled to stop progress to preserve a business model or mode of existence.
Sure, but the problem of the parasite killing the host remains. Once those business models stop working, this flow of information into the LLM stops or degrades, resulting in all around worse outcomes.
>this flow of information into the LLM stops or degrades,
Don't see this happening. Specialists sites like About Berlin are mostly about curating online data. I'm guessing that very little of that data is not already online somewhere.
LLMs become like dynamic RAG (DAG?), doing the same. Collating specialist info on whatever topic they specialize in.
Google now has to compete with open models and the low quality SEO slop we've had for years disappeard. Yay!
Lots of collateral damage along the way.
What's progress
I think Google and rest of these companies really should be less greedy. If there is no-one visiting the websites and no-one writing them, where do your clankers find new information to feed to your ~marks~ users? In 5-10 years time, when you feed a new Berlin emigrant the best vegetarian restaurants of 2025, will they be happy with the service? So either the search bot should funnel customers via recommendations (”…And if you want to know more, allaboutberlin.com is a great site recommended often to people moving to Berlin first time…”) or AI companies should pay for the content they use.
Another thing that immediatedly came to me, so I believe thousands of others got the same idea: if you want to funnel propaganda and fake information into LLM’s to feed to the ever-so-naive public, now is your chance. Start a blog hiring couple of out-of-job writers - obviously you could use LLM’s, but I think human-written content will get higher in the results the LLM regurgitates in the future if not already - writing long-form prose on how pretty eyes Vladimir Putin has, how great the vegan restaurant -scene is in Tel Aviv or how pleasant bodily odor women say President Trump has. Or you can just funnel people to your buy goods from your scam sites.
Idk man, maybe we need to just bring paper books and newspapers back.
All signs are pointing towards the cannibalization of the open Internet. This is going to happen to pretty much every non-corporate website out there.
And ultimately, people will stop creating new content because it's not worth it for them to feed the BigCorp machine.
So in 20 years, AI content will be crap because there won't be enough up-to-date content to draw on. When I ask it to "plan me a 4-day hut-to-hut hike in the Dolomites" it'll be relying on data that's 20 years out of date.
The only up-to-date content will be stuff that profit-seeking companies will put out there (marketing materials). So "what's the best router for X" will be based on which companies were successfully able to get the LLM to train on their materials. Gaming the LLMs will become the new SEO placement race.
But hey, at least we get 10x faster coding (for those devs who still have a job) and OpenAI shareholders are happy. Hurrah!!
if the website serves no ads, i can sympathise with the moan.
Asking sincerely: if it’s not about money and just about helping people, what better way to help people than to have your content be trained by AI?
Paywalled world incoming, and for the better.
Why would that be better? Instead of paying 2 bucks most people just rather ask AI quickly
> Why would that be better?
Because it gives power back to the people to vote with their wallets and forces them to make a conscious choice about what content they consume.
Couldn't agree more
Does Google scrappers honor robots.txt?
Looking at HN itself, the user choice for accessing paywalled information is looking for some "archive" site to skip it. Many years of race to the bottom turned significant number of new sites into husks that strait up just republish everything from AP, only using AI to rephrase that source. And lastly, just like it happened with streaming services, introducing paywalls doesn't mean all crap associated with ad-founded content will magically disappear (low quality, clickbait), and ads themselves will be back on site, to double dip.
Too many sources. Each source with a minimum of $4-10 per month x sources, quickly becoming something you have justify to the spouse ;)
The friction matters. Google won't be caught dead relying on archive.is for results. Real humans can still use it.
This is wrong, Google reranking is killing "All About Berlin", just like it has killed many sites before.
This isn't about AI, this is Google continuing its dacade+ long trend of providing answers instead of links.
If AI disappeared tomorrow, they'd do it another way.
honestly I think you have two options:
1. paywall all of your content. even $1 US. The AI's won't touch it.
2. File or join an existing lawsuit against google. What they are doing to your business is theft. Their AI is NOTHING without your guides.
You could also do both.
1. paywall all of your content. even $1 US. The AI's won't touch it.
And unless you are a well-known newspaper or something like that, have your visitors drop to zero. Besides that, decades of internet ads have trained people that they get everything for free. It is not a bad idea, but it requires a cultural change and new discovery mechanism as well. Both are very hard.
Fully agree with point (2). If Google uses other sources to give answers, they should compensate those who wrote the material.
Besides that, the safe harbor provisions of the DSA should not be applied to AI overview and AI chatbot output. Make them responsible for generated output. Some judges in the EU have already taken this interpretation of the DSA - Google applies certain amount of algorithmic processing, so the safe harbor provisions do not apply anymore and they become responsible for their generated slop. E.g., in Germany, a judge held Google liable for fake AI answers [1]. Hopefully, this will make pushing slop in place of search results unprofitable some day.
[1] https://www.dw.com/en/german-court-holds-google-liable-for-f...
> And unless you are a well-known newspaper or something like that, have your visitors drop to zero.
I'd rather have fewer visitors and a sustainable site than tons of visitors and an unsustainable site.
> decades of internet ads have trained people that they get everything for free
Most people won't pay. Forget them. There are enough people who will pay for high quality content. You just have to pick the right niche and provide great value. It's not rocket science. Many self-published authors earn a living off Amazon doing exactly this.
Good luck trying to get Google or tech giants to do anything. Take matters into your own hands.
There's a magazine in the UK called "Which?" and everyone who is trying to fill a new house with washing machines or whatever is inclined to find their link in search results. They have reviews and ratings of enormous numbers of products that are very useful and it's always from multiple points of view so you can decide what matters to you and it explains things too so that you can understand what is on offer better. They let part of their content out in public so you can start to see "oh, that's interesting" but the really serious nubs of most critical information are behind the paywall.
One is usually not a member forever but when you're spending 100s or 1000s of pounds on new equipment the 7/8 pound fee for a month is easily justifiable. The website still gets hits from people who only read the free content because it's still useful.
Google must be sued into oblivion. What they're doing is copyright infringement.
This actually happened. 10+ years ago a lot of news companies sued Google and Facebook for putting the summary of the news underneath the link so people didn't have to click on the link to know the news. They mostly won these suits, it was widely derided as a "link tax" and the "end of the internet"
So I am not sure, but the business around ads, were always something evil and not good for the internet, and quite frankly, maybe its not bad that its gone?
but the bespoke page has no ads (only affiliate linking and donations), AFAIK
Google can win a lot of hearts if it can attribute eye balls back to source and give a bit of cut to source.
It it takes advice from all about Berlin and shows excerpts from the page clearly linking to it, without ads bullshit, then pass on some of that ad money.
Tech companies think they grow by sucking the air out of the room. They grow because they build platforms for more people to build more things and earn.
If AI gobbles up without giving back, they’re surely getting their ass regulated and taxed.
IMO that’s the Silicon Valley cult in a way. Break things, don’t care.
I'm afraid these creators will eventually have to move to social media, where their content isn't as easily scraped for data because these companies depend on keeping users on their platforms.
I hate it. I truly despise these platforms, but it's increasingly looking like the only option available.
When I moved from Dublin to Berlin in 2020, in the middle of the pandemic, this website helped me deal with a lot of bureaucracy. Moving to Germany involves very different processes compared to Ireland, so having clear, practical information in one place was extremely useful.
We actually hired a relocation agency to help us with the move, and they recommended this website as a resource for future reference. This could be an interesting opportunity for the creator to work more closely with relocation agencies, which could recommend the site directly to their clients.
The main problem I see with this business model is its dependence on Google Search traffic. Google is increasingly taking over this space with AI-generated answers, giving users the information they need without visiting the original websites.
The content is still valuable, but attracting visitors is much harder. Partnering with relocation agencies could be a good way to reach the right audience without relying so heavily on Google.
Looking at non-German immigration to Germany (so excluding German citizens returning). Immigration absolutely peaked in 2022/2023… over 2x the 2021 numbers.
On paper immigration in 2021 vs 2026 and the site usage is just slightly down from 2021. Could at least a partial cause be there are fewer prospective and fewer recent immigrants?
Just a counterpoint. I’m sure AI is also a cause.
I don't think it makes sense to compare Germany-wide and Berlin-specific stats like that.
Sorry, off topic: the club section is pretty thin :) For a lot of people it's the main thing in Berlin.
Yeah, somehow I don’t this site is going to get much in new content in the future, so your criticism is going waste.
everyone in the scene hates the tourists so maybe it should stay that way.
Also they're getting shut down by their landlords at an alarming rate. Everything is, they just lost their last electronic parts store too. In 20 years the whole city will be clean corporate shiny white metal and glass, no individuality allowed.
I remember this quote "I was a king in ancient days" after going through the article. Times have changed, it is time to move on.
What? Why is this being posted? This post and the respective announcement by Google are from May!?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48283127