This form of A/B testing or "optimization" if you like (unaccountable 3rd party script spawners) should probably not exist in the modern agentic era. It was a flimsy premise _before_ but borders on malpractice now. Even as a business case, using these kinds of frontend-based frameworks slows down performance (which is known to impact conversion/ ux) for the sake of letting some twit change button colors from red to blue (which will almost certainly impact conversion less than the performance loss). It's like saying "let's drop conversion by 4 percent by ruining performance and then see if we can raise it 1 percent by changing button colors". There's no reason for it on the modern Web.
I also cannot describe how much it fills me with rage when I am part of a UI experiment with no way to opt out. I think this is most noticeable with Facebook’s apps. I usually just do the opposite of whatever action they clearly want me to take to do some small part in ruining the results.
or you know, letting users know you wanna test new stuff with them, and then allow them to consent or not ? The ones consenting would probably even be happy to write a line of feedback about their experience once in a while if asked nicely I'm sure. And if you really wanna encourage people you may even incentivize somehow, like a shiny badge which costs you nothing on their profile or smth?
Jk, most tech bros have a hard time understanding the concept of "consent".
so, like, McDonalds shouldn't test new menu items in a few locations first, just either roll them out everywhere (at great expense and risk) or nowhere?
No, not like that at all because you can choose to buy a new item or not; you aren't forced to do something you don't want to. No joke dude but do you actually understand what consent is?
This for online content too. I cannot stand the constant changing of titles and thumbnails on YouTube, makes me feel like I’m going crazy. It degrades the shared reality that the internet should be
My marketing team had a contractor run AB tests on my static pages via Optimizely. I had to insist that they run each test by me before going live. They would essentially re-implement my design system in Javascript, inevitably with tons of mistakes, in order to build their experiments. (In hindsight it could've maybe been a use case for web components). Fortunately it was shut down after enough people questioned the statistical significance (there was none).
It's time that we hold websites accountable for the data they host. If Google shows me an ad to a scam page, I should be able to get Google to pay me back the money. After all, Google profited from this exchange.
Re: dubious ads, I'm not a big IG user, but META really seems to be scraping the bottom of the barrel for DTC brand ads now.
I've started to get drug paraphernalia ads in my feed, and not even for pot. "Discrete powder storage" and stuff like this, very sleek looking nicely machined metal stuff. I don't use, and my follow/view habits haven't changed at all. It feels like a change in how META is screening ads.
Was an interesting divergence from the usual middle aged guy ads of expensive electronics, jackets, record players, fidget spinners and sneakers.
This form of A/B testing or "optimization" if you like (unaccountable 3rd party script spawners) should probably not exist in the modern agentic era. It was a flimsy premise _before_ but borders on malpractice now. Even as a business case, using these kinds of frontend-based frameworks slows down performance (which is known to impact conversion/ ux) for the sake of letting some twit change button colors from red to blue (which will almost certainly impact conversion less than the performance loss). It's like saying "let's drop conversion by 4 percent by ruining performance and then see if we can raise it 1 percent by changing button colors". There's no reason for it on the modern Web.
I also cannot describe how much it fills me with rage when I am part of a UI experiment with no way to opt out. I think this is most noticeable with Facebook’s apps. I usually just do the opposite of whatever action they clearly want me to take to do some small part in ruining the results.
What's the alternative? no experimenting is done and the update is rolled out to everyone without data right? isn't this obviously better?
or you know, letting users know you wanna test new stuff with them, and then allow them to consent or not ? The ones consenting would probably even be happy to write a line of feedback about their experience once in a while if asked nicely I'm sure. And if you really wanna encourage people you may even incentivize somehow, like a shiny badge which costs you nothing on their profile or smth? Jk, most tech bros have a hard time understanding the concept of "consent".
But that will introduce some selection bias that will disturb the quality of the test results >.<
The alternative is to stop experimenting on humans that do not consent to such actions.
so, like, McDonalds shouldn't test new menu items in a few locations first, just either roll them out everywhere (at great expense and risk) or nowhere?
One might expect that customers who order new menu items also consent to receiving and eating those items, as the parent explained.
No, not like that at all because you can choose to buy a new item or not; you aren't forced to do something you don't want to. No joke dude but do you actually understand what consent is?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consent
Informed consent. Let beta users opt in. Don’t experiment on people without their knowledge.
Meta isn't big on consent. It's probably best to use their product as little as humanly possible.
This for online content too. I cannot stand the constant changing of titles and thumbnails on YouTube, makes me feel like I’m going crazy. It degrades the shared reality that the internet should be
The testing cost is temporary and the gains are permanent.
My marketing team had a contractor run AB tests on my static pages via Optimizely. I had to insist that they run each test by me before going live. They would essentially re-implement my design system in Javascript, inevitably with tons of mistakes, in order to build their experiments. (In hindsight it could've maybe been a use case for web components). Fortunately it was shut down after enough people questioned the statistical significance (there was none).
If it's a constant 4% loss, but occasional 1% increases, it's well worth it in the long term.
It's time that we hold websites accountable for the data they host. If Google shows me an ad to a scam page, I should be able to get Google to pay me back the money. After all, Google profited from this exchange.
Re: dubious ads, I'm not a big IG user, but META really seems to be scraping the bottom of the barrel for DTC brand ads now.
I've started to get drug paraphernalia ads in my feed, and not even for pot. "Discrete powder storage" and stuff like this, very sleek looking nicely machined metal stuff. I don't use, and my follow/view habits haven't changed at all. It feels like a change in how META is screening ads.
Was an interesting divergence from the usual middle aged guy ads of expensive electronics, jackets, record players, fidget spinners and sneakers.
Elect politicians that will allow suits like this to go forward.
German court holds Google liable for fake AI answers: https://www.dw.com/en/german-court-holds-google-liable-for-f...
This is an interesting one. Perhaps platforms should get to choose to either be neutral or be held responsible for what's on their sites
US law tries to codify this distinction with Section 230 and the like.
But enforcement is lacking
[dupe] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50524767