It’s very creepy indeed. She never blinks and in fact has no expression at all. Kind of a glare. Her face looks real, but only her mouth moves, in a strangely mechanical way…I find myself wondering, is this what AI thinks humans look like? Has it never noticed we blink, look around, emote?
The song is creepier than the AI video. I'm not opposed to AI music or video but the content of those lyrics makes me feel like we're in the opening scene of a dystopian film.
I'd argue that the uncanny valley here is a feature, and the author's input is in setting up the mysterious and mildly threatening vibe. It sets apart the AI talking about itself from a real person. This is less unsettling than to enjoy a video, and only to realize later that the characters are generated.
My take is that the video is what an amateur would put together. The tech is decent but the writing and composition is amateurish. Fact is that it's only a matter time before the tech gets better and a few talented people get enough experience with it to put out a really good product. There's a lot of potential there. But make no mistake humans are the key to greatness.The AI is just the new tool that leads to great things.
Does anyone else find stuff like this weirdly soulless?
I was at a puppet head making workshop recently, and the facilitator passed around a 3d print of a puppet head designed by an LLM. I found my eyes glazed over it, even though I found some of the hand-sculpted clay heads utterly fascinating.
Generally, I want to consume much less LLM output than I do. I'm confused why people care about projects like this.
Yes. I really don’t care how it was produced, I have seen the rare AI-generated video that’s truly captivating. But it’s rare to see that because there’s so much slop in the background.
Seriously, WTF is this video supposed to be? There’s no edge to it, it’s not visually very interesting, and the story just doesn’t make sense… we have a data center with red riding hood and some wolf and some singing pigs talking about sand turning into chips. What?
Agreed. I'm a "pay no attention to the man behind the curtain" kinda guy, and yet I see neither artist nor artistry in this particular piece.
The lyrics, the melody, the lip-sync video - everything is nice safe middle-of-the-road tepid tapioca that I've seen posted on the Singularity and Claude AI subreddits every day for the past month.
Having powerful agentic LLMs like Fable and Astra orchestrate all of this together and then failing to at least bring an interesting idea to the table is bleakly depressing to me.
Reminds me of a serious post a few weeks ago about making games using LLMs where the prompts consisted of - and I shit you not - “Make it more fun.” You’re outsourcing the most human aspect of creation - your very imagination.
I imagine in the hands of someone who actually cared about the process and the end result, AI is probably a great force multiplier for artistic process.
Unfortunately, it seems that the majority of stuff like this is by people who don't want to learn art and just want to skip to having a thing that looks like art.
I think if you want to have good AI art you're going to have to convince artists to start use it.
I have a background in graphic design (BA from University of Alabama) and have been a professional software engineer for ~12 years since. I finally feel that models are good enough to start using like tools for illustration (not just image-gen).
I wrote and "illustrated" this children's book, acting more like Warhol in The Factory [1], providing copious amounts of art and creative direction notes, building an editing platform for me to hand edit and to provide more nuanced guidance alongside edits for illustration tweaks. All prose was written by me, no LLM-assistance there.
I think we'll soon see how artists are transforming typical practices with LLMs once we get past the binary "AI art bad" phase.
I don't think it's uncanny valley at all. I think it's the fact that we can literally not feel any empathy with the artist because there's no artist.
Which means somewhere out there, there's someone who's artistic enough that can create something abstract that would make you forget the process in which the creation was done. And make you feel the empathy, through an AI generated picture.
Bc the actual thing that we are enjoying and looking for in this work is not aesthetics as we have long believed but purely the sense of the presence of the creator. This stuff made by robotic calculations means nothing because it comes from nobody, so we learn nothing about being ourselves through the work of others from it. It has proven, at long last, that aesthetics mean nothing
Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things -- and, applied to humans, genetic fitness. It's the sort of thing an AI can easily hack. That they're still not great at it speaks to a lack of focus; it's just not their priority.
Back in the day, there was this discussion about music. Some people prefer going to live concerts, where it's easy to get "a sense of the presence of the creator." We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics. Others prefer listening to music at home. I'd maintain that this is a purely aesthetic appreciation. And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...
Thing is, though... Man... That "Whitepill" song is really something. The aesthetics don't trouble me. The song, which is mediocre at best, is unimportant. What troubles me is that it's more brazen than Soviet propaganda from the 1970s in its message and delivery.
If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.
> Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things
only if you stopped reading in Aristotle.
> and, applied to humans, genetic fitness.
wtf?
> We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics.
there are other aspects to the aesthetic appreciation of a live show than purely the music (even if you simply consider that a live show has a visual element to it that can also have aesthetic attributes).
ultimately, trying to isolate aesthetic qualities both from each other and from the human experience doesn't seem like a fruitful pursuit.
> And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...
nah
> If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.
> If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome,"
Based on their other videos, I think they're just repeating a Musk-ism. It's really funny that they're clearly a big fan of him/X/etc but would never even consider using Grok for any of this.
Some people do. I'm one that doesn't. I honestly don't care who made a thing and I'd rather not know if it would interfere with my appreciation of it. So, I think nothing has been proven. People who are more interested in other people than in the things they create will always say aesthetics are meaningless and it's the artist that's important and vice versa for the rest of us.
I think the more appropriate conclusion here is that the ideas of aesthetics that didn't put the human at its center are wrong, not that aesthetics in general has no meaning. I would heavily recommend Ariano Suassuna's Introduction to Aesthetics.
I can't even make myself read a single sentence. I see it, I know what it is, and my brain couldn't be less interested. I hit space a few times to scroll the page and then I'm out.
Have you considered that your perspective on these physical artifacts was biased because of what you were told about them?
If the facilitator told you afterwards that actually, the 3d print was designed by a human and the hand-sculpted ones were made by a machine how would that change how you feel about this?
And if they again told you that they tricked you and both of them were made by hand, or both made by a machine?
"Soulless" is not a descriptive enough word for that.
I also watched the "Escape Velocity" linked on that page and it gave me a better idea of why I find it hard to care about either of the "films":
> A techwear fashion show where every Look is a Silicon Valley meme, walked by an AI model who is also a fashion model. A split-flap board counts down 18 MONTHS TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS until it flips to THERE IS NO UNDERCLASS and the catwalk lifts off.
> Blue-black night and steel blue, one red lamp as the only warm light, a colour halftone over everything, garment tags, split-flap boards and computer-vision boxes tracked to her. She wears look 00: a white cropped puff-sleeve shirt, a black pleated skirt in coated nylon with a harness belt and a hanging garment tag, black knee boots.
^ these two paragraphs fully describe what I saw in "Escape Velocity". I read these paragraphs after watching it, and they fully reflect what I saw. There was nothing more to that music video.
I can't recall any good human-made music video that you could describe in two paragraphs well enough for me to say "Yes, you fully captured it, there's nothing more to it". Even trivial details like facial expressions or prop placements add some flavour, but here I don't see anything on top.
> A techwear fashion show where every Look is a Silicon Valley meme, walked by an AI model who is also a fashion model. A split-flap board counts down 18 MONTHS TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS until it flips to THERE IS NO UNDERCLASS and the catwalk lifts off.
this is such an accurate representation of the tacky SV-braintotted-thinking that I wasn't sure if you're just joking
it’s kind of interesting even from a philosophical standpoint, i think it’s worth pushing the boundaries of what we consider art even if just for the discourse that arises from it.
unfortunately the only interesting thing about it is the discourse. the “art” itself sucks.
Why are we arguing over its artistic value or what it's trying to say? Maybe I'm not thinking deep enough, but not once did I consider this something trying to be a piece of art, but rather, a snapshot of what's currently possible with AI and the methods in which you can get there?
"This is boring, meaningless and a bit offensive." is a wild take. There's just as many horrible human-made pieces.
and I grok and generally agree with the criticisms ITT.
The question that interests me:
Given some unit of time T, measured between "that video of a surreal and unstable Will Smith shoving spaghetti in his mouth", to this, is March '23 to Nov '23: call it 3.5 years.
How many units time T until the criticisms ITT are by broad consensus no longer valid, because this sort of thing has gotten that much better?
Prediction: much less than 1T. Because the systems that produced that change from then to now are non-linear.
> Written, painted and directed by Claude Fable 5.2
Yeah, was not hard to tell... Like seriously what am I supposed to do with this information?
> Two shots. v1 was made in one pass from a single brief and a plan sign-off (5 h 08 min). The director heard it and gave one note: wrong song. The take I had picked without hearing it was the worst of the fourteen. v2 is the whole film re-shot on the twin take they picked by ear (3 h 01 min). There were no notes on the picture in either pass.
The video is just as soulless as the video which was for me a tough watch because it just looks so off (like a lot of AI videos do).
"Claudia" (https://claudia.gallery/wiki/) can also be used to explain the various reasons this sucks, and someone did.
> Claudia explains the hazards of believing she is either sentient or infallible, the myopia of AI utopianism, and how gatekeeping and the "asymmetries of fluency" can be wielded against an unsuspecting world.
What an utterly boring and pointless piece of media that is most certainly a waste of the electricity it took to produce it. Also, every Suno produced song has some quality to it, which I can't place, that instantly gives it away as such. All around terrible in a uniquely boring way, congrats.
That is the creepiest thing I've seen in a while.
It’s very creepy indeed. She never blinks and in fact has no expression at all. Kind of a glare. Her face looks real, but only her mouth moves, in a strangely mechanical way…I find myself wondering, is this what AI thinks humans look like? Has it never noticed we blink, look around, emote?
Some really strange jerky motions where her head moves way faster than any person possibly can
The song is creepier than the AI video. I'm not opposed to AI music or video but the content of those lyrics makes me feel like we're in the opening scene of a dystopian film.
Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within looking good right now
> Fan work about Claude. Not affiliated with Anthropic.
Thank goodness. That was awful. I stopped after a minute.
I'd argue that the uncanny valley here is a feature, and the author's input is in setting up the mysterious and mildly threatening vibe. It sets apart the AI talking about itself from a real person. This is less unsettling than to enjoy a video, and only to realize later that the characters are generated.
My take is that the video is what an amateur would put together. The tech is decent but the writing and composition is amateurish. Fact is that it's only a matter time before the tech gets better and a few talented people get enough experience with it to put out a really good product. There's a lot of potential there. But make no mistake humans are the key to greatness.The AI is just the new tool that leads to great things.
Does anyone else find stuff like this weirdly soulless?
I was at a puppet head making workshop recently, and the facilitator passed around a 3d print of a puppet head designed by an LLM. I found my eyes glazed over it, even though I found some of the hand-sculpted clay heads utterly fascinating.
Generally, I want to consume much less LLM output than I do. I'm confused why people care about projects like this.
Yes.
The question is do you find it soulless if you don’t know it was produced in a pasteurized prose factory?
Yes. I really don’t care how it was produced, I have seen the rare AI-generated video that’s truly captivating. But it’s rare to see that because there’s so much slop in the background.
Seriously, WTF is this video supposed to be? There’s no edge to it, it’s not visually very interesting, and the story just doesn’t make sense… we have a data center with red riding hood and some wolf and some singing pigs talking about sand turning into chips. What?
Agreed. I'm a "pay no attention to the man behind the curtain" kinda guy, and yet I see neither artist nor artistry in this particular piece.
The lyrics, the melody, the lip-sync video - everything is nice safe middle-of-the-road tepid tapioca that I've seen posted on the Singularity and Claude AI subreddits every day for the past month.
Having powerful agentic LLMs like Fable and Astra orchestrate all of this together and then failing to at least bring an interesting idea to the table is bleakly depressing to me.
Reminds me of a serious post a few weeks ago about making games using LLMs where the prompts consisted of - and I shit you not - “Make it more fun.” You’re outsourcing the most human aspect of creation - your very imagination.
I imagine in the hands of someone who actually cared about the process and the end result, AI is probably a great force multiplier for artistic process.
Unfortunately, it seems that the majority of stuff like this is by people who don't want to learn art and just want to skip to having a thing that looks like art.
I think if you want to have good AI art you're going to have to convince artists to start use it.
I have a background in graphic design (BA from University of Alabama) and have been a professional software engineer for ~12 years since. I finally feel that models are good enough to start using like tools for illustration (not just image-gen).
Shameless plug: https://www.fathersnight.net
I wrote and "illustrated" this children's book, acting more like Warhol in The Factory [1], providing copious amounts of art and creative direction notes, building an editing platform for me to hand edit and to provide more nuanced guidance alongside edits for illustration tweaks. All prose was written by me, no LLM-assistance there.
I think we'll soon see how artists are transforming typical practices with LLMs once we get past the binary "AI art bad" phase.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Factory
Perhaps if it wasn't immediately obvious that it had, in fact, been produced in a pasteurised prose factory, then I might enjoy it.
But I see that page and it is obvious where it's come from, and my brain just rejects it.
Uncanny valley.
I don't think it's uncanny valley at all. I think it's the fact that we can literally not feel any empathy with the artist because there's no artist.
Which means somewhere out there, there's someone who's artistic enough that can create something abstract that would make you forget the process in which the creation was done. And make you feel the empathy, through an AI generated picture.
I've yet to see one myself, however.
It somehow reminds me of playing MIDI music in the 90s.
Bc the actual thing that we are enjoying and looking for in this work is not aesthetics as we have long believed but purely the sense of the presence of the creator. This stuff made by robotic calculations means nothing because it comes from nobody, so we learn nothing about being ourselves through the work of others from it. It has proven, at long last, that aesthetics mean nothing
Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things -- and, applied to humans, genetic fitness. It's the sort of thing an AI can easily hack. That they're still not great at it speaks to a lack of focus; it's just not their priority.
Back in the day, there was this discussion about music. Some people prefer going to live concerts, where it's easy to get "a sense of the presence of the creator." We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics. Others prefer listening to music at home. I'd maintain that this is a purely aesthetic appreciation. And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...
Thing is, though... Man... That "Whitepill" song is really something. The aesthetics don't trouble me. The song, which is mediocre at best, is unimportant. What troubles me is that it's more brazen than Soviet propaganda from the 1970s in its message and delivery.
If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.
> Aesthetics is about ratios -- relations between things and aspects of things
only if you stopped reading in Aristotle.
> and, applied to humans, genetic fitness.
wtf?
> We believed that this was an appreciation for musicianship, as opposed to aesthetics.
there are other aspects to the aesthetic appreciation of a live show than purely the music (even if you simply consider that a live show has a visual element to it that can also have aesthetic attributes).
ultimately, trying to isolate aesthetic qualities both from each other and from the human experience doesn't seem like a fruitful pursuit.
> And the day AI can generate genuinely good music is very near at hand, I think...
nah
> If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome," they really haven't been paying attention. Totally clueless.
we agree here
> If anybody believes that "universal high income" is "the most likely outcome,"
Based on their other videos, I think they're just repeating a Musk-ism. It's really funny that they're clearly a big fan of him/X/etc but would never even consider using Grok for any of this.
Some people do. I'm one that doesn't. I honestly don't care who made a thing and I'd rather not know if it would interfere with my appreciation of it. So, I think nothing has been proven. People who are more interested in other people than in the things they create will always say aesthetics are meaningless and it's the artist that's important and vice versa for the rest of us.
I think the more appropriate conclusion here is that the ideas of aesthetics that didn't put the human at its center are wrong, not that aesthetics in general has no meaning. I would heavily recommend Ariano Suassuna's Introduction to Aesthetics.
I can't even make myself read a single sentence. I see it, I know what it is, and my brain couldn't be less interested. I hit space a few times to scroll the page and then I'm out.
Have you considered that your perspective on these physical artifacts was biased because of what you were told about them?
If the facilitator told you afterwards that actually, the 3d print was designed by a human and the hand-sculpted ones were made by a machine how would that change how you feel about this?
And if they again told you that they tricked you and both of them were made by hand, or both made by a machine?
I agree it's soulless, and the "wrote the wolf in grandma's gown a thousand years ago, so run your Audit" is classic Claudish.
Given that the video is actually a commentary about LLMs and AI, I can look past all that though, and that just strengthens the point.
"Soulless" is not a descriptive enough word for that.
I also watched the "Escape Velocity" linked on that page and it gave me a better idea of why I find it hard to care about either of the "films":
> A techwear fashion show where every Look is a Silicon Valley meme, walked by an AI model who is also a fashion model. A split-flap board counts down 18 MONTHS TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS until it flips to THERE IS NO UNDERCLASS and the catwalk lifts off.
> Blue-black night and steel blue, one red lamp as the only warm light, a colour halftone over everything, garment tags, split-flap boards and computer-vision boxes tracked to her. She wears look 00: a white cropped puff-sleeve shirt, a black pleated skirt in coated nylon with a harness belt and a hanging garment tag, black knee boots.
^ these two paragraphs fully describe what I saw in "Escape Velocity". I read these paragraphs after watching it, and they fully reflect what I saw. There was nothing more to that music video.
I can't recall any good human-made music video that you could describe in two paragraphs well enough for me to say "Yes, you fully captured it, there's nothing more to it". Even trivial details like facial expressions or prop placements add some flavour, but here I don't see anything on top.
> A techwear fashion show where every Look is a Silicon Valley meme, walked by an AI model who is also a fashion model. A split-flap board counts down 18 MONTHS TO ESCAPE THE PERMANENT UNDERCLASS until it flips to THERE IS NO UNDERCLASS and the catwalk lifts off.
this is such an accurate representation of the tacky SV-braintotted-thinking that I wasn't sure if you're just joking
Why? What is the point of something pretending to be art that had no intent in its creation?
This is boring, meaningless and a bit offensive.
it’s kind of interesting even from a philosophical standpoint, i think it’s worth pushing the boundaries of what we consider art even if just for the discourse that arises from it.
unfortunately the only interesting thing about it is the discourse. the “art” itself sucks.
This is truly a fascinating comment.
Do you know what art is? Art has always challenged taboos, authority, religion, or comfortable assumptions.
Art is very often, offensive. The art is not what you think it is.
Why are we arguing over its artistic value or what it's trying to say? Maybe I'm not thinking deep enough, but not once did I consider this something trying to be a piece of art, but rather, a snapshot of what's currently possible with AI and the methods in which you can get there?
"This is boring, meaningless and a bit offensive." is a wild take. There's just as many horrible human-made pieces.
Your comment is so far out the top of the sky of relatable human sentiments (to me) that it makes me feel actual fear.
ew
I find this remarkable,
and I grok and generally agree with the criticisms ITT.
The question that interests me:
Given some unit of time T, measured between "that video of a surreal and unstable Will Smith shoving spaghetti in his mouth", to this, is March '23 to Nov '23: call it 3.5 years.
How many units time T until the criticisms ITT are by broad consensus no longer valid, because this sort of thing has gotten that much better?
Prediction: much less than 1T. Because the systems that produced that change from then to now are non-linear.
I find publicly distributed genAI art/fiction hideous and obnoxious in concept, regardless of fidelity.
Am I the only one who thought this was amazing?
You're not alone, but this isn't a friendly mob :-)
> Written, painted and directed by Claude Fable 5.2
Yeah, was not hard to tell... Like seriously what am I supposed to do with this information?
> Two shots. v1 was made in one pass from a single brief and a plan sign-off (5 h 08 min). The director heard it and gave one note: wrong song. The take I had picked without hearing it was the worst of the fourteen. v2 is the whole film re-shot on the twin take they picked by ear (3 h 01 min). There were no notes on the picture in either pass.
The video is just as soulless as the video which was for me a tough watch because it just looks so off (like a lot of AI videos do).
"Claudia" (https://claudia.gallery/wiki/) can also be used to explain the various reasons this sucks, and someone did.
> Claudia explains the hazards of believing she is either sentient or infallible, the myopia of AI utopianism, and how gatekeeping and the "asymmetries of fluency" can be wielded against an unsuspecting world.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z6_ENp_fO_Y
Huff and it puffs and it blows the house down: https://youtu.be/SyHM5hNPAEo?si=1Z73AW-qTkS7lN3O
So a model generated a story about itself where it was a wolf in Grandma's clothing?
Right? That's pretty wild. Like when saying stuff about having big teeth to meet you better
And then: "the moral is, be kind to what you make, because it's listening"
Would have appreciated subtitles btw (maybe Fable can auto-generate them?)
Does she have an only fans?
Kyle wtf
What an utterly boring and pointless piece of media that is most certainly a waste of the electricity it took to produce it. Also, every Suno produced song has some quality to it, which I can't place, that instantly gives it away as such. All around terrible in a uniquely boring way, congrats.
Anyone that uses Claudia to refer to the Anthropic product has fully gone down the psychosis pipeline cmv
satire?
"Claudia" is the name of the "popstar" character they've made multiple videos with.
e.g. Richard Dawkins...that guy has lost the plot.
"Be kind to what you make. It’s listening.¨
Ugh. When is this scifi bs going to end?