xnx 1 day ago

I don't know what is going on with this guy's computer, but Chrome AI features do not use "hundreds of GBs per month".

  • jeffbee 1 day ago

    "Don’t take my word for it." - agreed

  • autoexec 1 day ago

    > I don't know what is going on with this guy's computer, but Chrome AI features do not use "hundreds of GBs per month".

    What else, going on with this guy's computer, would cause that volume of traffic to immediately stop as soon as he "disabled everything on that settings page"?

    It may not be happening to you if you've got all that crap enabled, but that doesn't mean it wasn't happening to him. Companies love to single out subsets of their userbase and secretly experiment on them. When something goes wrong users get gaslighted by other people who say "I never see that happen!" or "It works fine for me!". Who the hell knows what Google and their AI was doing on this guy's computer. I'd put more trust in a random web developer on the internet than I'd trust Google.

    • jeffbee 1 day ago

      "Hundreds of GB per month" is, at least, 70KB/s, which should be pretty easy for anyone to observe. So is your Chrome doing it?

      My hypothesis is this guy installed so many shady ad blockers and VPNs that were using his rig as a proxy, and the cessation of such traffic, whether permanent or temporary, was purely coincidental.

      • pixl97 1 day ago

        Your take is 'probably' correct.

        The problem here is without a deep dive you just don't know. Google likes A/Bing the shit out of their software. Google loves setting all kinds of different options that may have to be replicated exactly to get the same behavior.

        This isn't like support back in the old days where you just look at your software and find the bug, you have to replicate the environment to see what's up.

        • jeffbee 1 day ago

          OK but the OP provided zero evidence. Chrome has chrome://net-export/ for a reason. Show us logs.

        • simlevesque 1 day ago

          > The problem here is without a deep dive you just don't know.

          Without knowing, you don't accuse.

        • jorvi 1 day ago

          Spotify had a bug where it was writing ten to hundreds of GB to people their SSDs, each day. HN refused to believe it until Spotify acknowledged it. "You must have just injected some shady JavaScript mod".

      • swiftcoder 1 day ago

        > 70KB/s, which should be pretty easy for anyone to observe

        But also low enough that most of us wouldn't actually notice

        • xnx 22 hours ago

          Chrome has 3+ billion users. If this was widespread, it would get noticed within a day.

          • trog 21 hours ago

            Maybe it is being noticed and it's just forming part of some product managers KPIs

            • nucleardog 15 hours ago

              It wouldn't be Chrome/Google that noticed.

              Taking one of the ISPs where I live, they have 4.3m customers. Chrome has ~70% market share. So let's say they have ~3m Chrome users (probably an underestimate).

              At 70kB/s per user, that's about 1600Gbps of additional traffic.

              Their largest single peering link is 20Gbps. It looks like they have 331 total links. If we assume every single one was as big as their largest link, they have a total of 6,620Gbps of bandwidth available (a vast, vast overestimate of their total capacity, and this traffic wouldn't be hitting all links equally by any means).

              So their total traffic suddenly shifted up by 25%. That would be triggering infrastructure buildouts and all sorts of other capital projects and more.

              And in this scenario they they never once went "whoa, why did traffic suddenly spike?" and call it out, block it to protect their services, or anything else. Nor did any other ISP. They simply went "Yeah, we're famously shitty about investing in our infrastructure, but this sudden unexplained spike doesn't need any consideration... Let's just go ahead and invest a bunch of money in upgrading things."

              It's not a realistic scenario.

  • bikeshaving 1 day ago

    This is probably just Chrome redownloading the weights. But there is a fringe possibility that the local model is getting hijacked for inference, or even more sci-fi, that it’s being corrupted by some sort of rogue global botnet.

    When I read about Chrome shipping local weights in every computer I can’t help but be reminded of the Great Cannon, where a MITM code injection by China caused end-user browsers to launch a DDOS on GitHub back in 2015. What could an AI adversary do with a fraction of Chrome’s local models, I wonder.

    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Cannon

    • refulgentis 1 day ago

      > This is probably just Chrome redownloading the weights.

      Why do we think that?

      I'm not getting specific because I think people are ragging on Chrome too much or whatever.

      I'm really alarmed that Chrome could eat 100s of GBs a month and people are handwaving about the cause(s?) in a way that shades rather than illuminates.

      • Izkata 22 hours ago

        I see it as theorizing more than handwaving: If that is what's happening it might not even be a Chrome issue, it could be a hard drive issue corrupting the weights, which Chrome is detecting and trying to fix.

falldrown 22 hours ago

I finally switched from Chrome to Firefox last week so happy now.

  • autoexec 20 hours ago

    Firefox has its own issues, in both cases you're using a browser made by an ad-tech company, but even after turning to the dark side Firefox is clearly the lesser evil (so far)

josephernest 1 day ago

I have another problem with Chrome AI features.

Sometimes I notice my PC being very very slow... The Chrome Task Manager (SHIFT+ESPACE) shows that "On device" IA is taking 300% of the CPU (laptop with only low-perf Intel integrated GPU). I can barely type text in an input box: 1 second delay after each keypress.

Disabling the option "On device AI" in the same way than on OP's screenshot doesn't solve this issue: this "On device" process still comes back again and again and I have to kill it manually.

Did someone experience the same?

skullone 1 day ago

I seriously doubt this. Show your logs, otherwise this is worthless blog spam

edoceo 1 day ago

Every app and site I use that has AI integration is slower (Chrome, VSCode, the keyboard on my Android, Bank-Apps). And routing a bunch of stuff into their sites new chat feature which is so buggy that what should be trivial tasks take much longer.

Fast used to be a feature.

I thinking this is just a wave of hot-patch-slop that will pull back soon-ish, if the feedback loop works. Many times the folk making these decisions are so far removed from customer complaints, the there is any complaint (because many users don't bother)

  • egnehots 1 day ago

    there was a time where it used to be the defining feature of chrome.

    chrome used to be the simplest browser, with a minimal interface that was lean and fast...

    • chili6426 1 day ago

      It's hard to believe that Chrome was the obvious choice for power users back then. I miss the blue title bar

      • load-bearing 1 day ago

        When was that? I remember it having five percent of Firefox's functionality, and about 1% that of Opera (real Opera, not the current chromium reskin). For example, for the longest time ad blocking extensions did not support network level blocking, and relied on downloading and then hiding ads.

        I bounced off chrome very quickly, tried it again and again over time, never stuck with it.

    • Ungh 1 day ago

      Now it's IE6 on cocaine.

      • giancarlostoro 1 day ago

        I've always said Chrome became the new IE, especially when you consider that Google and some web devs build sites that only work in Chrome, even though Firefox can run them, I've seen too many sites tell me I should be on Chrome instead, giving me flashbacks to IE in the 2000s...

        • afavour 1 day ago

          Chrome moves too fast to be the new IE. The entire web dev industry was frozen in ember accommodating IE6 for years. It was excruciating.

          I’m no fan of a Google monopoly but I still prefer where we are today to those days.

          • giancarlostoro 1 day ago

            Doesn’t matter if there’s websites that won’t let you in without it, mind you, spoofing Firefox as Chrome lets me through.

            • afavour 1 day ago

              Even that… I use Safari almost exclusively and I can’t remember the last time I’ve seen a prompt like that. It’s way, way less common than the IE6 days.

              • SoftTalker 1 day ago

                You really can't get away with not supporting Safari unless you want to write off the the entire iOS user base.

                • load-bearing 23 hours ago

                  Trivially, depending on where you live. I've never even bothered to test it, it's a percent of a percent over here. Life in poor regions has its upsides, however small.

              • giancarlostoro 6 hours ago

                As another commenter said its harder to write off Safari, but I've seen it in more modern web apps from Google that use newer web APIs that Firefox has, but they show the error anyway.

            • SoftTalker 1 day ago

              Since Firefox ~160, Teams has become unusably unstable. "Gah, your tab has crashed" used to be common on startup but after a reload it would be OK. Now it crashes consistently within seconds/minutes.

              I have resorted to running Chromium for Teams, but that's all I use it for. It's the only thing that doesn't work for me in Firefox.

              • load-bearing 1 day ago

                Report it, it's right there in the hamburger menu, "report broken site" or something like that. Entirely possible it's actually hitting bugs in the graphics stack, have ran into enough of those over decades.

    • eastbound 1 day ago

      That was when user experience was the defining feature of apps.

    • SoftTalker 1 day ago

      Google also used to de-rank web pages that were too slow.

  • jeffbee 1 day ago

    Chrome is obscenely fast and it has never been faster. The only thing that can touch it is Safari, a browser that co-evolves with its own hardware platform. Blink and V8 have closed what should have been an unbridgeable performance gap with Safari, and the third place browser isn't in the same galaxy as the top two.

g0ld3nrati0 1 day ago

you can disable the AI crap in chrome/chromium by setting policy file.

(Linux)

Chrome: `/etc/opt/chrome/policies/managed/disable_ai.json`

Chromium: `/etc/chromium/policies/managed/disable_ai.json`

```

{

  "GenAiDefaultSettings": 2,

  "AIModeSettings": 1,

  "GeminiSettings": 1,

  "GenAILocalFoundationalModelSettings": 1

}

```

predkambrij 23 hours ago

I don't see any of that in chromium browser which I think is a good thing?

cadamsdotcom 1 day ago

Pro tip

You can disable Chrome AI features forever, by switching to Firefox!

  • LtWorf 23 hours ago

    I think this is the only good advice in here. Also chrome isn't even free software.

londons_explore 1 day ago

Chromes mostly open source...

Point to the specific AI features which are wasting bandwidth and quantify how much.

  • patch_v1 1 day ago

    The obvious candidate is the on-device Gemini Nano model behind Chrome's built-in AI APIs. It's a few GB, and you can see its state under chrome://on-device-internals. Chrome's docs say it removes the model again when free disk space drops below a threshold, and downloads it later when space is back. A machine sitting near that line could plausibly churn through the same download repeatedly, which would get you to large monthly numbers without any single feature looking huge.

  • mkl 22 hours ago

    Why would Google's proprietary AI features be in the open source part? These features are entirely missing from the AI Innovations settings pages in Chromium for me, but present in Chrome.

vivzkestrel 18 hours ago

- you guys are still using chrome ? [insert....meme]

BatchJob 18 hours ago

You cant stop chrome from downloading a 4GB model to your computer unless you change file perms on your computer. But it will always keep trying.

Google wont give you that 4GB back unless you earn it.

leecommamichael 1 day ago

Tangentially; why isn't the technical crowd (who uses Chrome) using Chromium by now? Are you? I switched a while ago and am pleased.

SlightlyLeftPad 1 day ago

I wonder if this ties into a strategy of selling their 3gig google fiber plans.