I think I speak for a lot of people when I say that this feels like a dark day. As an SF resident, the most likely outcome of all of this wealth creation is people I love and care about losing their homes. I still don’t understand what the benefit of AI is supposed to be, and what I see is a disastrous job market and people I know being unemployed for up to a year or more with no end in sight. Increased electricity demand for data centers is driving increases in carbon emissions, we’re about to blow past 1.5deg of warming, and the new elite consensus is “who cares, AI will fix it.”
Dark day today, dark days ahead.
San Francisco chose to make housing scarce for the sake of preserving neighborhood character. Wealthy people are now well-positioned to buy up a scarce resource. Sucks, but it's the bed the city made for itself.
SF made housing scarce to spike values by limiting supply in relation to demand. Watch Anthropic with regulatory capture, artificial scarcity may be Silicon Valley’s biggest export.
wait. can you please provide some alternative way of defining a suitable neighborhood character, and whom might enforce that when property owners choosing that character are using their rights to property [constitutionally guaranteed by 5th & 14th] in making their choices.
if you want cheap property, all you need to do is travel 50 miles east.
> if you want cheap property, all you need to do is travel 50 miles east.
As a european this sentence sounds crazy to me. "Just 80 km east" I'm in another country.
Yeah, the spaces in the U.S. are vast, and in Texas they are really vast. Four time zones east to west, not counting Hawaii or Alaska. I'll be driving up to my aunt and uncle's for Thanksgiving. That's just 660 miles north and four state lines. Obligatory https://thetruesize.com/
Europeans constantly underestimate the size of Texas.
El Paso, Texas -> Los Angeles, California: 802 miles
El Paso, Texas -> Beaumont, Texas: 831 miles
There are two states between Texas and California, but that distance is shorter than from one side of Texas to the other without ever leaving the state.
(Of course Alaska is much bigger still but it's not an apt comparison; you cannot easily drive across Alaska because there are very few roads.)
European comparison:
Prague -> Rome: 809 miles
My brother in law is from Ireland. When he comes over to the US, the thing he loves to do the most is rent a car and drive the Southwest - like start in San Diego and drive to Sante Fe, NM. It's just so vast that it blows his mind every single time.
830 miles is the distance from one end of the U.K. to the other, or France, or Italy. It’s not ridiculously big.
> Europeans constantly underestimate the size of Texas.
To be fair, so do Americans. Years ago I drove from Florida to California by way of I-10 and it felt like I'd never get across Texas.
that's one thing a lot of Europeans simply don't quite realize until they leave the continent. Europe is tiny in the grand scheme of things, geographically speaking.
that's one thing a lot of Europeans simply don't quite realize until they leave the continent. Europe is tiny in the grand scheme of things, geographically speaking.
When I lived in the American West, I'd see this all the time. European tourists who simply could not wrap their brains around the vastness of the American continent, and how their provincial sense of scale doesn't work in the rest of the planet.
They must soil themselves when they get to Australia.
> They must soil themselves when they get to Australia.
Don’t do this. It attracts drop bears.
The downvotes are pretty funny. Have y'all seen the size of Africa? The size of Australia? The size of North America?
I have family in europe, so i know very well what they consider "far".
and actually, most maps use a specific projection that makes Europe seem larger than it is. If you look at an actual 3-D globe, Europe is even smaller than it seems.
distances are relative.
Sure, but I bet in most of Africa or Australia, telling someone to "just move 50 miles" east and endure a terrible commute will be looked at as both insane and inane.
well to put it in perspective, my father commuted 50 miles to and from work for most of his adult life. He simply didn't wanna live in the city and preferred suburbs. Most of our neighbors had similar commutes. that kind of life is not for me, but people certainly do it.
Australia is a bit of an interesting example because the continent is massive, but most cities are sort of clustered near each other along the coasts. on the other hand, leaving Australia requires a minimum 10 hour flight. So a vacation for them requires traveling farther than most Europeans have ever traveled. As i said, all relative!
No clue what the norm is in africa lol. :)
> well to put it in perspective, my father commuted 50 miles to and from work for most of his adult life. He simply didn't wanna live in the city and preferred suburbs.
This is somewhat normal in the US. But the original comment was pointing out that this is crazy in Europe. And I was pointing out it is crazy in most of the world :-)
To an American, 100 years is old. To a European, 100 miles is far.
Depends where you are in Europe. I grew up in the UK and didn't find 100 miles that far, it was a trip to see family and friends.
Yet now I live in The Netherlands and if I drive that far I can cross two borders; our foreign holidays are about that distance.
To someone who lives in Manhattan, 20mi is far.
Well you’ve got about 2,500 miles to go east of San Fransisco before you hit a border.
With decent rail 80km is fine for commuting, half an hour to the terminal an hour then a 10 minute local train to the office.
But America doesn’t have that.
In Spain I drive 100km almost daily. And in France I used to as well. We don't all live in Belgium or NL (I am dutch).
the right to property should extend only to your own property, not the entire neighborhood. for if the entire neighborhood has “rights” over your property, you don’t really have a right to property anymore.
With CEQA, you don't even have to be in the same neighborhood to file lawsuits and block development (or delay it for years, at least, which means carrying costs that ruin the business plan, and that alone is risk enough to block many developments before anyone even tries). It is a fine shakedown machine.
Pretty good arrangement if it means I can be sure an oil refinery doesn't appear next door to me.
Was that ever on the table? And why would an oil refinery decide to locate itself in a residential neighborhood?
Even basic city building games are able to differentiate between residential and industrial zoning. It's really not a hard concept.
Have you been to Long Beach? There are derricks right in the middle of neighborhoods in Signal Hill. There is a refinery next door to houses in Wilmington.
And this is despite some of the strongest zoning laws in the US
you sound like you already know that those were grandfathered in and were in place long before people ever moved in next door. like dozens of years.
Why didn't the zoning stop them from moving in?
>>"an you please provide some alternative way of defining a suitable neighborhood character"
moving? just move to a neighborhood that's not growing and it will stay the same for you.
Insisting that the neighborhood with the most growth potential in the history of the world not grow, seems like insanity.
Which neighborhood is guaranteed to not become a high growth potential neighborhood in a few decades, and how sure are you? Silicon valley used to just be rural sleepy towns not that long ago.
Throw a dart somewhere in Montana. You’ll be fine for 50-60 years I bet.
> way of defining a suitable neighborhood character,
That's really the problem.
What is character? Over time, either the neighborhood architecture changes or the people/culture changes. Or somewhere more in between.
Yep, change happens one way or another. You can get the visible kind, new buildings, or the less visible kind where you're swapping out people with less money
https://bendyimby.com/2026/08/29/change-seen-and-unseen/
it is dynamic, we all know everything changes daily.
and part of being an adult is finding happiness in the conditions you have, changing them to your taste if you can find common ground, or fight for your way if you have that kind of deteremination.
America
Housing scarcity is created by limiting development on property locals don't own.
Rights to perperty are not in jeopardy. No one is seizing homes with imminent domain. Developers would purchase property in a consensual free market exchange and build more housing if it were legal to build.
Your framing is disingenuous to a fault and suggesting young working class families should move out of town is economic segrigation.
Please tell me how your property rights cover the broader neighborhood that your property is situated in? I say this as a homeowner in a HCOL area myself.
Property owners typically own just one property in their neighborhood, which is located in a municipality that exists at the pleaseure of an overriding state government. Those owners have no special right to the character of the entire neighborhood.
> Property owners typically own just one property
Well, yes, which is why they only get one vote amongst the many others in the neighborhood.
What seems odd is elevating the rights of people outside the neighborhood to override what the residents themselves choose. There's some give and take, but why would the outsiders ever end up with more rights?
What residents choose for other people’s property?
It's a community, right? If my neighbor wants to put up a skyscraper between me and the sun, don't I have some right to weigh in on that? His choice IS affecting me, after all. What if he fills his yard with trash that attracts legions of rats, which do not choose to stay confined within his property boundaries? What if he puts in a 24x7 business getting loud traffic at all hours? Am I allowed to care?
We live in communities, which necessarily precludes everyone having 100% no consequences control over what they do with their little piece of paradise.
Why should you be able to stop him from building and maintaining to all relevant codes a reasonably sized multi-family dwelling?
I’m sure you’re not claiming the community has unlimited rights to vote over what the owner can and can’t do.
> to all relevant codes
That's an important qualifier. That's one of the primary ways that as I, as a member of the neighborhood, can exert reasonable control over my neighbors choices.
No, of course I'm not claiming unlimited rights, but neither does a property have unlimited rights to do whatever they want with their own property.
thousands of lawsuits have been lost, thousands of wretched angry battles between neighbors. even some retributions like this goofy 3 ft wide 'house' in Spain
www.thesun.co.uk/news/26830735/inside-worlds-narrowest-house/
weigh in all you want. just keep your head.
never underestimate the capacity for some people to be giant turds.
heck, look around this place ....
Well, because that's what it would look like to protect a right if it actually were a right. Who is most likely to want to restrict your speech? It's probably your neighbors and not somebody who has never heard of you.
But speech is an actual right that our courts take seriously, so they don't say that your neighbors should get to limit your speech by virtue of being most affected by it. No, they say that you have a right to speech and your neighbors can pound sand.
The courts have decided not to treat property rights the same way, but they obviously could.
very first year of college. Pre-law kid from Mill Valley says: "It's not how much justice the law can meter out, it is how much you can afford"
You can only hope that you keep a wide berth and have little need to buy your justice or freedom.
HOAs have changed that thesis forever. entire neighborhoods are ruled by an extrajudicial agreement amongst owners called "CC&Rs"
people outside USA may not be familiar with them
> choosing that character...using their rights to property
I didn't realize there was a constitutionally guaranteed right to other people's property. Everyone is already free to choose the character of their own property and no one is even discussing taking that away.
Don't like apartment buildings? Don't build them on your land - easy-peasy.
San Francisco chose to make housing scarce because too many of the people moving here were Black.
Cover story of the 1954 edition of the The Negro Travelers' Green Book travel guide: ‘The Golden Gate’ https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/1/1c/The_Negr...
“San Francisco, however, is fast becoming the focal point of the Negroes’ future. Before World War Ⅱ this city had fewer than 5,000 Negroes. High war wages attracted these people from all over the country to this boom town. More than 45,000 Negroes are squeezed into two areas of San Francisco today, with an estimated thirty-five percent unemployed.”
Environmental Impact Report from SF's 1978 downzoning: https://dn760102.eu.archive.org/0/items/finalenvironment2719...
“Since the proposed [zoning] amendments would reduce the density in some neighborhoods, the demand for housing in those neighborhoods may not be accommodated. As a result the cost of housing may increase. With increasing housing costs, some population groups may find it difficult to live in San Francisco.”
And what do you know, it worked — peep the graph :/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/priceonomics/2016/05/11/the-afr...
The Bay Area as a whole is shockingly racially segregated, which is something I was raised to believe is, like, a bad thing: http://radicalcartography.net/bayarea.html
This is completely implausible as an ongoing explanation for restrictive zoning, which is practiced almost everywhere in the country -- white areas, black areas, mixed areas, and everything in between.
The American homeowner is skeptical of a long list of potential changes to their neighborhood, which has at times included concerns about race, alongside more general anxiety about crime, traffic, construction, noise, views, and so on.
This is one of the most overdetermined questions in all of political discourse.
Seems like one of those classic American things where racism starts the snowball then rent-seeking takes over.
Well then it seems like focusing on race is counterproductive.
One of the things about American zoning is that it is enduring, so while pretty much no one is explicitly doing that today, the zoning that was designed to create such outcomes is largely still in place. And even today you still get a lot of euphemisms about the wrong kind of people moving in.
The most egregious examples I think are people saying that kind of thing about building workforce housing for the educators teaching their children in the local schools.
I can vouch for that. My postwar home was in a redline neighborhood and has a racially restrictive covenant. Even though they were only enforceable for a few years, the impact is still clear in the numbers today. The black population in my zip code is 1.2% vs an overall 2.8%. Wealth begets wealth, and you don’t have to inherit hate to be its beneficiary.
I don't think people are telling you that they care about crime and poverty making their neighborhood worse because of an underlying irrational hatred of black people.
I think they're genuinely worried about crime and poverty making their neighborhood worse. This is the dramatically more parsimonious explanation.
Because most households' only wealth is in their homes. By restricting supply bureaucrats and politicians (and ballot initiatives) make a certain class of people wealthier.
IMHO this is a significant driver of inequality.
Nah try saying something against NIMBY zoning on Twitter and you'll get people in your replies explaining exactly how every other term they use is a euphemism for keeping black people out.
Sure, but it won't be the NIMBYs making those explanations, and they won't have a sound basis for them.
Hmm well restrictive zoning definitely started as a racial thing (check Wikipedia), and while it may not be the sole determinant of current zoning choices now, the current effects of restrictive zoning are still disproportionately damaging to the economic well-being of Black folks, including folks I know in SF.
People who want to see racism will always see racism.
What city isn't "shockingly racially segregated?" It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them.
>"What city isn't "shockingly racially segregated?" It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them."
NYC. One of a thousand reasons it is strictly superior to SF.
Not for lack of trying: https://www.gothamcenter.org/blog/the-end-of-the-african-ame...
“From 1890 to 1900 the African American population in Manhattan grew by 41 percent from 25,674 to 36,246. Behind these numbers was the growing exodus of blacks from southern states. Seeking to escape racial violence, declining economic opportunities, and legalized segregation, African Americans moved to northern cities like New York in increasing numbers.
A few years after the 1900 riot [in which whites attacked blacks in midtown following the stabbing of an undercover police officer by a black man]†, as Harlem land values increased with the first subway line nearing completion in 1904, the black residents, once sought as renters in Harlem, became the targets of an organized removal effort by some white Harlem property owners.
The [New York Herald] article also suggested that a rent increase ‘which the parlor car porters‡ could pay, but their colored inferiors could not,’ had previously been used as a strategy to remove the undesirable tenants. According to The Herald, the owners’ target was the ‘colored inferiors,’ but the ‘wealthy railroad porters’ were also caught in the net of the eviction effort.”
† https://guides.loc.gov/chronicling-america-new-york-city-rac...
‡ https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_porter
NYC is absolutely extremely segregated, and always has been. It has some of the most segregated public schools in the country, even more segregated than parts of the south before the civil rights act.
> It may surprise you to learn most people prefer to live around others like them.
If this is your view, speak for yourself. Don't defer to an imagined silent majority.
And more, be explicit if you mean race or ethnicity by "others like them". It's 2026, if there's a silver lining to Trump's victory, Musk Twitter etc it should be that folks stop being coy about this kind of thing. You can just defend segregation if you want.
Californian views on race remain completely inscrutable to literally everyone else on the planet. They believe long-standing policies are the sole cause of any and all racial disparities, yet they consistently vote for the same party that seems to do nothing to improve the situation. It's very strange to anyone from anywhere else, because it seems an awful lot like blame-shifting excuse-making rather than telling the truth.
TIL all Californians have identical crazy views. I wonder if all the other Californians also share my view on the quality of your claim.
California lets voters bind the legislature with ballot initiatives requiring huge supermajorities to overturn, so they can vote in the "Anti-Racist/Anti-Classist Party" while also passing Proposition Racism/Classism/NIMBYism.
To be completely honest, we need to disband parties. I'm increasingly for people being required to vote on something should be educated about it instead of scanning down the ballot for R and D.
1954 was a long time ago.
Maybe this was an issue then, I don't know; do you really believe the zoning and housing issue is still like this for the same reason?
> The Bay Area as a whole is shockingly racially segregated, which is something I was raised to believe is, like, a bad thing: http://radicalcartography.net/bayarea.html
The bay area is not actually shockingly racially segregated. The bay area is extremely racially diverse as a consequence of being the center of the American computer technology industry and drawing huge numbers of immigrants from all over the world for many decades.
One of the consequences of being extremely racially diverse is that people systematically make different decisions about how they live their lives in part based on their own preferences which correlate imperfectly with their own race, resulting in all sorts of social institutions not having the same racial mix as the United States as a whole, the world as a whole, or any other metric you might pick as a guideline for what would constitute a lack of segregation. And in particular, there might not be very many visibly black people doing any particular thing or living in any particular area, which might look like the segregation you were "raised to believe is, like, a bad thing" if you were raised on media that was specifically trying to sacralize the black American civil rights movement of the 1950s-1960s. But that's what actual racial diversity and actual lack of racial segregation looks like.
Many Black and Hispanic people lived in the Bay Area prior to the tech booms. They’ve been pushed out, often deliberately via zoning. People should familiarize themselves with the history of California before chiming in. There’s been a plethora of deliberately racist policy. Including a very little known genocide of indigenous Americans in the 1800s.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Island_massacre
There were far more white people living in the bay area than black and hispanic people prior to the tech booms - a huge amount of the demographic change in the past 50 years in the bay area has been immigration from both the broader hispanic world and the broader asian world (both of which encompass a huge variety of people and cultures) displacing white people (and to a lesser extent black people, lesser because there were never large numbers of black people living in the bay area compared to whites). This is obvious if you look at at a demographic map of any bay area city since the mid-20th century, and it's also something I've witnessed in my own life living in the bay area. There's no sense in which black or hispanic people have been pushed out of the bay area by zoning that isn't far more true of white people.
The Bloody Island massacre, and in general any Gold-Rush-era attack on native Americans, is basically irrelevant to the modern-day racial demographics of anywhere in California, because there were simply many fewer native Americans alive than white settlers in the 18th and 19th centuries (there were many fewer human beings alive in general then). The broader demographic story of the entire North American continent in the 2nd millennium is that white people developed intensive agriculture and, later, industrialization, that no population in North America ever did; and therefore white people had the technological ability and population numbers to conquer and demographically swamp a much smaller number of native Americans.
This is the same reason that the entire Hispanic racial identity exists at all, but the racial admixture between white settlers and native Americans generally happened in places where the pre-Colombian native American population was denser, which is to say the parts of the Americas we today call "Latin America" rather than "North America". So even though it's the case that there are some Hispanic Californians whose heritage dates back to admixture between Spanish settlers and native Americans in late 18th/early 19th century Spanish California, today if you encounter a hispanic person in California (something that happens to me basically every day at work at every bay area tech job I've ever held), the odds are very good that they are immigrants from Latin America or their family immigrated to California sometime after the mid-20th century.
> * The Bloody Island massacre, and in general any Gold-Rush-era attack on native Americans, is basically irrelevant to the modern-day racial demographics of anywhere in California*
Absolutely false. The reason the indigenous were genocided was to steal their land. The same land with the zoning laws on it. There was never reparations nor land back. It’s 100% relevant and the very foundation of not just California but the entire United States.
How lovely of you to link to a specific page of the PDF! I always forget that feature exists.
Here're the rest of the available parameters if you're curious :) https://web.archive.org/web/20171013102703if_/http://www.ado...
It's homeowners who wanted the scarcity to keep their house prices up (and not "be underwater with their mortgage" or whatever), they just used neighborhood character as a pretext.
San Francisco is the 2nd densest city in America. It gets far too much blame when the real issue is lack of housing in Silicon Valley and other low density suburbs.
Being denser than almost every American city is a pretty low bar. Compare SF with international cities like Paris, Hong Kong or Tokyo and it looks like a village.
Not sure if you really want HK's or Tokyo's density though. Especially without public transport good enough to compensate.
How about Paris or Amsterdam? Don't need ten 80 story buildings, need 130 six story buildings instead.
Yet its wealthy people, a bunch of billionaires, who astroturf this narrative. The reason seems to be that they want to redirect people's anger over inequality ... toward NIMBYism.
Oh that makes sense. These days, politicians are dual purpose for the rich; advance political agendas to benefit the rich and then serve as punching bags when regular people get upset about those agendas.
But we can walk and chew bubblegum at the same time.
I’m not a billionaire, but I also oppose NIMBYism because it’s bad for our society and economy.
I’m also for more wealth redistribution. These are two things that are not inherently in opposition; they are very compatible.
I highly doubt there are people that were angry over wealth inequality, but then stopped being angry about that to instead only be angry about NIMBYism. Those people are just in your head.
https://votenoon40.org/broad-diverse-coalition-of-housing-la...
There's tons of examples of opponents of wealth tax supporting YIMBYism. YIMBYIsm is a red herring to draw attention off wealth inequality. YIMBYism doesn't threaten the ultrawealthy - that's why it's supported instead.
As I said above, these issue are not in inherit opposition, so it is not at all surprising that there are examples of YIMBYs opposing the wealth tax, YIMBYs supporting the wealth tax, NIMBYs supporting the wealth tax, or NIMBYs opposing the wealth tax. None of those are inherently contradictory views.
Though I want to point out that you are now conflating two issues: wealth inequality and wealth taxes.
I support wealth redistribution, but I don't support wealth taxes because it is a stupid way to achieve the goal. Wealth taxes are difficult to administer and easy to circumvent. Any reason not to choose one of the many of other taxes available which are easy to administer and difficult to circumvent?
YIMBYIsm is actively used as a distraction from a wealth tax. A person can have both views, sure; but this is how the SV billionaires have chosen to use YIMBYism - as a distraction. We can see that by observing what they fund and back.
YIMBYIsm can't address the cost of living crisis. They know it's no threat to them. Yet the wealth tax is, which is why they oppose it.
The wealth tax is actively used as a distraction from YIMBYism, which absolutely addresses the cost of living crisis by causing there to exist more housing units for people to live in. One of the several reasons I opposed the billionaire wealth tax is because I knew it would do absolutely nothing to improve my own ability to afford a house in the bay area. Only building more houses can do that.
All YIMBYism will do is offer more upmarket housing. Housing is an inelastic market and simplistic supply/demand concepts don't apply well. There are structural causes to affordability - money flows to the upper class through rent and mortgages; this share of the housing market continues to grow. Meanwhile huge swathes of our economy are captured monopoly/oligopoly markets which keep raising prices, funneling the profits from rising prices into a small number of hands. Tech is a case in point with its oligopolistic switching costs and enshittification. These trends are continuing to worsen, thus inequality is continuing to worsen. The ultrawealthy who find themselves with more money than ever need to find a place to stash that wealth in assets; this bids up the price of all assets, including housing.
YIMBYIsm is a strategy to offer voters something that claims to address the cost of living crisis while making no substantial improvements. It's par for the course for both parties, because they're both owned by billionaires and corporations. It's part of the whole "abundance" branded astroturf geared at distracting people from anything that would threaten their masters' hold on money and power.
Yet prices will continue to rise and people will continue to be more fed up,. In the meantime the profits these billionaires and corporations derive from gouging people with their oligopolies will continue to be used to finance the smokescreen.
> All YIMBYism will do is offer more upmarket housing.
Awesome this is exactly the kind of housing I would like to live in. I want there to be way more of it - especially units that were built recently, I'm awfully sick of renting in 100 year old buildings built before the invention of proper insulation.
> Housing is an inelastic market and simplistic supply/demand concepts don't apply well.
Nah it's its actually pretty elastic. Supply and demand decides whether you continue to live with your parents or get your own apartment, or live in one room in a group house with 7 other people or not.
> YIMBYIsm is a strategy to offer voters something that claims to address the cost of living crisis while making no substantial improvements.
A lot of voters hate NIMBYism because they live in houses they've owned for decades and building new houses in their neighborhood risks changing it in ways they dislike. These are often the same people who complain about the cost of living crisis for every category of good other than housing, which they already own. Many are old retired people who invoke the fixed income of their social security pensions as a reason why the cost of living crisis is a particular problem for them.
Those voters are a huge portion of the reason housing in my area is scarce and therefore expensive. I hope billionaires spend a lot of thier money poltically fighting those voters and making it possible for developers to build more housing in those people's neighborhoods against their will. I welcome the support of the YIMBYist billionaires against the masses of common people who bought houses decades ago.
No, people who want to buy houses support YIMBYism so that there will be more houses, which will make it cheaper to buy one.
"Eat the rich" includes the real-estate millionaires, not just the tech billionaires. In fact, we can just start with a big barbecue pit for everyone from Atherton.
Who gets their Atherton houses after we lynch the current inhabitants? And what prevents another group of people who didn't get that small number of housing units from simply carrying out another lynching against the new inhabitants? After all, now they're the real-estate millionaires.
NIMBYism is far more responsible for my inability to afford a house in the bay area than any billionaire is. People should actually be far more angry about NIMBYists than they are about inequality with respect to billionaires. Indeed, any billionaire who spends their money politically fighting NIMBYism or who just invests in the construction of new housing for a profit is on my side and is helping make my life, and I thank them for it.
I hate that this has become such a magic wand talking point. It's physically impossible to build enough housing in a geographically constrained highly desirable area like San Francisco to make housing affordable on a normal salary.
Yes supply and demand matter and increasing some supply will have some lowering effect, just like incoming billions of dollars worth of extra demand will do the opposite. There's a real debate to be had about how and how much to build, and how to weight the different tradeoffs. But none of the loud voices on either side of the YIMBY/NIMBY divide care about any of that.
The YIMBY message is always "Build more, problem solved EZPZ. Anyone talking about tradeoffs is a liar or an idiot.", with equally unreasonable people pushing back the other way.
I wish HN could be a place with more nuanced discussion, but posts like this always get upvoted to the top.
no, it is super easy and there's plenty of examples to go around. Tokyo, Shanghai, Seoul, and so on.
Tokyo maybe after the housing collapse (80s-90s I think) not so much now. Shanghai and Seoul are both dense and not affordable..
This site has Tokyo as the 5th most expensive real estate in the world and Seoul as the 7th. https://elitetraveler.com/property/most-expensive-property-m...
Singapore, Hong Kong would like a word.
My friend just bought a 2-bedroom in Singapore for $650k that looks like it hasn't been cleaned or updated since the 70s. Not sure I'd call that affordable.
Was that the only available housing purchase in Singapore or just a single data point from your friend? If it's the latter, then not just I would hinge a full opinion on that.
As far as big cities go these days, 650k is not as out of reach as many. I wish I could buy the two bedroom I'm renting in LA for 650 but that isn't even close.
This site has Singapore as the 10th most expensive city in the world. to by property. https://elitetraveler.com/property/most-expensive-property-m...
> It's physically impossible to build enough housing in a geographically constrained highly desirable area like San Francisco to make housing affordable on a normal salary
While this might be true in theory, literally nowhere in the US is anywhere near the upper bound. SF and other bay area municipalities could enact policy tomorrow that legalizes a 5x theoretical housing capacity increase, legalizing housing that is currently illegal to build, on lots that are already developed, not clearing any additional land, and not requiring any tall towers to be built, just modest midrise development.
The other point I'd make is that while the core desirable areas will remain expensive, by increasing capacity across the board, people will be able to live closer to those super desirable areas than they currently can afford to. I don't need to live right next to my job. But if the municipalities in this metropolitan area increased housing capacity by even like 20%, people who currently can only afford to live farther from work, will be able to move closer to work, and achieve shorter commutes and travel times for leisure activities.
Manhattan exists. It's a real place you visit and see for yourself. It's not some Soylent Green hellscape. The density is quite livable. I'll take Manhattan over San Francisco any day.
How much more nuance do you need?
It's not actually impossible... Compare to the city (not metro area) of Tokyo.
Of course, SF can't grow outward, but the population density of Tokyo is much higher.
I agree with this. If it were me, I would be putting up 80-story buildings all over the Peninsula, from Burlingame down to Palo Alto, all along El Camino Real.
Look at all the buildings around Central Park in Manhattan. Now look at the area around Golden Gate Park for a comparison.
Lots of affordable 20-40 story high-density condos in places such as Malaysia.
You want them near a rail or tube station so people can commute without cars. They also allow preservation of local green spaces.
Agreed, I've watched friends in multiple industries lose joy in their jobs, and lose hope for the future, due to the actions of AI companies.
My own hope was re-established on Open Weights AI levelling the playing field, but they've managed to steal the global chip supply, undermining that too.
I'll go out on a limb and say, even if AI does cure cancer (a big if), was it really worth the loss of meaning/purpose for millions of people along the way?
>even if AI does cure cancer (a big if), was it really worth the loss of meaning/purpose for millions of people along the way?
yes, at least for the billionnaires who won't have to worry about cancer any longer.
Consider it a tax in happines. We lose a part so less lucky people can enjoy some of a decent life. If that happened, hopefully with other hugely impactful diseases following up not late afterwards, it would have been worth it. We are after all in a whole societal-level revolution, and like any industrial revolution before, changing the ways we live will hurt lots of people living through the change. In 100 years they will probably study the pre-AI age with awe and curiosity, like we ourselves look at times before penicillin or airplanes.
Regardless... All that is a huge "if", and I'm personally skeptical.
- Cures diseases. - No one has a job so can’t afford treatment. - Profit.
I'm sure similar comments have been said in public squares or society cafes (the old forums of yore) when some disruptive change was about to come. Not saying that I'm happy: surely it must have sucked to be a carriage driver (or any other of the thousand specialty trades affected) in the years after invention of the car.
Oh it absolutely did, but usually when industries die off there are allowances made (or forced to happen by those getting the boot) for retraining and assistance. In our hyper-capitalist world those who missed the boat will just be left to drown.
i agree. The death of meaning is way more of a tragedy than most people acknowledge. Frustratingly, most seem to not care about it at all. If offered a world of mindless bliss, most would gladly take it, it seems… Utopia, dystopia, extinction, its the end of “humanity” no matter what.
We’ve been working on destroying the social(!) and monetary value of anything but the very tippy-top best of artistic talent since mechanical reproduction of art became a thing.
Kurt Vonnegut (Jr) wrote about this in more than one book. Someone good at dancing or singing or storytelling or sketching goes from performing that work for grateful family, friends, and community members, and maybe even making extra money or a living at it, to doing it alone (assuming motivation doesn’t collapse when nobody else cares) and always feeling like they’re bothering and being patronized by anyone they show their work to. The need for that kind of thing was scaled from enormous and constant, to so rare and small that it’s more something indulged than eagerly enjoyed.
Vonnegut seemed rather worried about what psychological harm this had done to countless people who’d love to feel their work, even if not world-class, was really wanted or needed.
I can definitely relate to this sentiment, but it also IMO ascribes far too much intention to technologies that have had lots of other benefits. Broadcast radio made it so we could have amazing storytellers have a much wider audience, but at the cost of making us need the storytellers in our own lives a little bit less. Google Maps means it's way easier to navigate an unfamiliar city, which means we don't have a culture of asking strangers for directions anymore. There's definitely something sad to that. And something that reminds me of how fragile our local communities can be.
I do feel like you can take this kind of thinking too far. Like, I am glad that we don't live in the kind of dangerous world where wandering into an unfamiliar forest could lead to all sorts of ways of dying, even though that means I also don't need close personal relationships with warriors. Incidentally this is one reason I think that Tolkien's work still feels so relevant; it's a world that on a slow and inevitable decline which makes the characters struggling against that to carve out something decent for a while feel paradoxically more heroic.
I like to think that we can choose to do bigger, more beautiful, more ambitious things with our time when we don't have so many basic needs that we're spending our time taking care of. I guess we'll see.
the death of meaning? I am limited right now by my typing speed in terms of what things I can create with Opus. The world is our oyster. What are you talking about?
For how long though? At some point you won't be adding any value and the agent will be prompting itself.
how will the agent know what I want to build?
The real question they are talking about is why, in that scenario, would anyone give a shit what YOU want to build. They aren't saying you aren't empowered they are saying your empowerment, alongside everyone else's, makes the result have no meaning.
The vonnegut example wasn't that people don't dance anymore it was that people don't care about anything but top level skill/celebrity since it's easy to watch either one and why would you choose your neighbor.
The question is more will anyone pay you for wanting the AI to do things. If you add no value in any way the money will just go direct to the AI companies.
> how will the agent know what I want to build?
The agent would not care about you specifically anymore. Does nature know what you want to build? Does nature care? It doesn't.
Enjoy your little reign while it lasts. Everything points into the direction that humans prompting AIs will just be a temporary thing.
What can you create? Apps? B2B Service APIs? Like seriously this is so short sighted, this world is not virtual.
I can't at all understand the lament of the death of meaning due to not having to go to a job. If I didn't have to get up and go to work I would have so much I could learn, so much to read, so many things I'm interested in just doing. A person's meaning does not have to come from their job.
Brother. If I don’t work, I don’t eat. I don’t understand why this is difficult for some people to understand. I have plenty of meaning in my life. I do not have plenty of money. It’s gone after I pay my rent and go to the grocery store.
I agree with you, the need for money makes a lot of sense to me. I also need income in order to live. The sentiment I don't understand is when I hear people speak about a possible future where they have the freedom to not work and they then equate that with losing meaning and purpose in their lives. That freedom would be great, I wouldn't be sad that my identity is no longer a person who works as XYZ.
> The sentiment I don't understand is when I hear people speak about a possible future where they have the freedom to not work
Who is speaking about this? Why is this relevant to bring up here at all? We don’t live in a world where this is a live possibility. We currently live in a world where a terrible job market is slowly destroying people’s lives, people who very much still need money to live and will for the foreseeable future.
> The death of meaning is way more of a tragedy than most people acknowledge.
I agree that death of meaning is a tragedy, but I also think a lot of us can find plenty of meaning beyond our jobs.
In an optimistic theoretical world where AI took my software dev job but I was sustained through some form of UBI I'd spend all my time doing things I do now in my spare time like volunteering at animal rescues and I'd be perfectly happy and find plenty of meaning in that volunteer work.
Alas, I do not think it is likely that that is our future. Politically and economically we've shown no movement toward that.
So if/when AI takes my job I'll probably have to spend less time than I do now volunteering and spend the majority of the rest of my days trying to cobble together a meager living doing whatever I can. Or perhaps I will turn to a life of crime.
People sure do love the cancer-cure argument. I would have thought that the possibility of geoengineering our way out of climate catastrophe would be a much more enticing prospect. After all cancer isn't threatening to wipe out billions of people in a matter of decades.
I'll give that argument credence when I see Anthropic and OpenAI publish well-reasoned and practical roadmaps for getting us out of said catastrophe.
Was the industrial revolution worth it, was factory automation worth it, did it make our lives better or worse? I would say better but I would be interested in your answer.
It really depends on who you ask.
All those created more jobs than they took. How many jobs have llms created vs how many they destroyed for good as we speak?
This is shortsighted and dumb, but in highly capitalistic societies like US its the ideal thing. Poor get even poorer and more desperate, middle class moves to poor and those few rich can have armies of modern slaves for next to nothing... what is there not to love right.
Every single person working on it in those labs is guilty. Stupid amount of money can blind even quite moral folks but money only gets you so far.
> All those created more jobs than they took. How many jobs have llms created vs how many they destroyed for good as we speak?
This a question I'd like to see the answer to. Or at least an attempt. Is anyone seriously trying to track software jobs, or knowledge jobs in general, to see trends that might be attributable to LLMs?
Assuming this is even close to something like the Industrial Revolution in the long run (which I absolutely do not assume is true), a better question would be if you're willing to live like one of the workers back then that was replaced by a machine and forced into poverty and destitution. That's the real cost for millions of people.
Except in this case, we're not even seeing the benefits of the Industrial Revolution. All we got was a way to pump out code faster.
Yeah I'm not comparing it to the industrial revolution but if its a real thing it could change our lives for the better in time and if its not than most things will largely just return to a new kind of normal state. I guess either way nobody had a say in if we should start the various technical revolutions but they have at least so far always resulted in a better quality of life for more people.
A "new kind of normal" could very well be a much worse quality of life for the vast majority of people.
real question, why do you assume that?
Further concentration of wealth and power, for one.
I hate to be the other side of this empty coin but why assume things get better either? I think either claim could use some support and, very importantly, timeframe. Far futurists justifying suffering now in order to benefit the lives of future folks should be clearly discerned from benefits that are local in both space and time.
Our current modern society benefits from the suffering of things like the Industrial Revolution or world war 2 but I would have hated to live through those transitional times and, if I had a magic wand choice I'm not sure I'd force others to do so in my place in order to have the benefit built upon their suffering.
Technology advancements have generally made life better for people throughout history, that doesn't me it absolutely will in this case but if you can't imagine a better future how can you work towards one.
Oh it will be just like the industrial revolution. I grew up in the epicentre of that near Bristol; the works where the steam train was invented and scaled massively.
I suspect these companies will fare just as well, only with far compressed timelines. Things move much faster nowadays.
What does you growing up in Bristol have to do with the way the current timeline will develop?
Near.
It means that I've seen the ruins. They're high-end flats now. I guess people who were working in SV in 2000 can say the same thing.
The parasitic industrialists who leveraged technology to pay more productive workers less were not worth it, actually. We never needed to let them run rampant in the first place. It's a false dilemma. These labs should be nationalized and their IP should be distributed to the commons. Break up the hyperscalers, and bring hardware prices way down. No more centralization. No more SaaS models. Let's not do the same thing we did with the industrial revolution, where we waited 180 years to do something about the leeches centralizing all of society's capital.
This is the problem. The Luddites were not wrong when it came to their own lives.
If you read about life in the early industrial revolution it was a nightmare.
That is certainly not a time you want to be born. There was also no real payoff for your kids or grandchildren. The payoff was so long after.
Almost surely people 100 years from now around the globe will have higher standards of living because of technology but this level of change we are all going to have to deal with is not going to be fun.
True though we have learned a lot since then so hopefully we don't make the same mistakes, further not all the nightmare conditions of those times were directly related to the industrial revolution it was also a time of massive political change throughout the world (which I guess you could attribute to the industrial revolution but I don't see parallels now).
Quality of life went down and hours worked went up, the industrial revolution was not good for the average worker.
for a time yes, but it did usher in an era of human thriving never seen in history (at least statistically).
> Agreed, I've watched friends in multiple industries lose joy in their jobs, and lose hope for the future, due to the actions of AI companies.
If you're my age or a bit older, the statement would have been true before 2020. Just replace "AI companies" with "SW companies". Or even just "technology."
My (now retired) math professor hated computers. "In the old days, I'd write my tests/exam on paper, and the department secretary would type it up (with appropriate math symbols). Now I have to do it myself on the computer."
Phone operators at switchboards were a thing.
We all panic when things move, but it is the Red Queen, we always run just to stay where we are. I am not an AI apologist, but I want to address this as a concern, because meaning does not disappear, it just relocates. Maybe it was wrong from the outset to assign one's life meaning to their work, maybe it was right in its context and not anymore. Your question is still valid, though, in my eyes, in whether the stress and pain of that meaning relocation was worth it, and the question unfortunately is not answered by us, but by the people who actually make money out of this. We are voluntarily or less so parts of the system that brought us here.
> Maybe it was wrong from the outset to assign one's life meaning to their work,
Humans, and many animals at that, need some purpose. Without purpose we wither and die.
The 40 hour braindead and soulless job will not be missed, but many other jobs will be missed. Remember the famout mouse experiment. Give the mice colonly everything they want and need, and they will eventually die out of a kind of boredom.
Also, it's all based on the biggest theft in human history. The IPO somehow seems to legitimate the theft. I still hope people will go to prison for that at one point in time.
since it was created by data from everybody basically ... everybody should get royalties is all
They even got away from pirating stuff. Did not need to delete the benefit of the crime...
That’s already the case. Because the data was public, that’s the reason why there are so many LLM models out there that are almost all the same.
> everybody should get royalties is all
Paid by who, though?
Anthropic has a very high valuation, but isn't yet a profitable company.
And it is still entirely possible Anthropic gets wiped out by commoditized open weight models, that may or may not have included Anthropic model distillation as part of their training (which raises the question again of who pays the royalties in that situation as you move further away from the original data but still end up with usable models).
Given the current structure of our economy there is a very real chance AI destroys a lot of value without having any clear long-term value capturing mechanism to offset the value destruction.
To be clear, I'm not defending Anthropic here or saying that it wasn't theft for these companies to ingest all of this data into their models.
I don’t want royalties, I want my data to be removed. The whole point of data ownership isn’t to be paid, it’s to control how they are used
> Also, it's all based on the biggest theft in human history.
Wait… what happened to centuries of imperialism?
Doesn't really count as theft when humanity didn't have anything to begin with
People still had their lives, and their freedoms.
Those weren’t worth much before IP came along /s
or every war/conquest where victors acquired land & other resources
Haha. Good call out.
At first I thought, "True, perhaps this was amongst the top thefts" but yeah thousands of years of human empire building, colonization, resource extraction, and slave taking likely dominate the top 100 thefts in human history.
Perhaps this is 101 on the list.
To be clear most of the training, to me, is not theft if it's openly available to the average human to study themselves free of charge. In other words I can see the argument for AI training being available to the same training a human has access to.
It's mainly if these tools were trained on content for which they were supposed to pay but did not. That, it would seem, is: unfair, concerning, and a double standard.
But the powerful dominating the weak is kind of how this world has worked since the Sumerians first started their conquests.
Humans have never graduated from the school of: might makes right.
Which empires? How far back do you want to go? Persian empire? Egyptian? Akkadian?
>> centuries of imperialism
Are you under the mistaken impression that Persia or Egypt or Akkadia were imperial powers in the last five hundred years? Do you really think they reached the scale that even pre-modern empires did with cannons and muskets and seafaring?
I’m thinking of the mines in Potosí and all the other silver in South America that minted pieces of eight which were the global currency for centuries, connecting every continent in trade and exploitation except Antarctica. Volumes that caused global hyperinflation and were so critical to royal budgets that a single failed treasure fleet transit could change the fortune of European empires nearly overnight.
Or, you know, far closer to home: the theft of the entire American continent and the extermination of its indigenous people. Of which Anthropic is a direct beneficiary, being an American company.
Why are you selecting only the last 500 years? And you are ignoring the empire that existed in south America before Europeans arrived.
Op was on the right side of the bayonet in those cases so they didn't happen or were a very long time ago.
Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods. The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something from someone, they no longer have it. If I steal your apple, you can no longer eat your apple. That's theft. Pretty much no human cultures or societies look kindly upon theft.
But if I could copy your apple and have an apple of my own, then you aren't being deprived, and meanwhile I'm better off. So it's a net good. Unless, of course, you wanted to profit off the fact that I was without. Then you might say that your monopoly and thus your profits were harmed.
And this, of course, is not theft. It's copyright infringement.
Unlike theft, the definition, ethics, justification, and acceptability of copyright laws are hotly debated and far from settled. The idea that being the first to express a particular thought/idea/whatever means that others should be restricted from doing so, or should have to pay you to do so, imo, does not make for a better society. And certainly isn't an incentive necessary to spur creation, at least in 99% of fields. Hundreds of years ago perhaps this was an open question, but in the modern world there can be no debate.
I much prefer the creativity, riffing, and copying you see in software and the food industry, than to the cookie-licking and rent-seeking you see in other industries that lean more into this sort of thing.
Even barring this, there's a lot to be debated about whether training/learning is violating the spirit of copyright.
I largely agree with you, but isn't it a bit unfair that Dario and friends get to be billionaires while translators, graphic designers, copywriters, etc. lose 80% of their labor power?
Personally, I don't think so.
The market is competitive and it takes a lot to win. You have to have an exceptionally good product/service, and usually amazing marketing and distribution, among many other things. Otherwise, society isn't going to discover and value your work, and they aren't going to buy it.
It's tautological, but: The people and approaches that are better at winning in the market end up making the most money, and the people and approaches that are worse at it end up earning less and going out of business.
It's intentionally designed to be competitive, for the benefit of society. The winners win, and the customers win. But the losers lose, and that does suck. It is tragic, and sad, and worthy of empathy.
But I wouldn't call it unfair.
Blah blah it's competitive sure, but surely then the rules of the competition should be enforced?
> for the benefit of society
This is very much in doubt right now.
> Blah blah it's competitive sure, but surely then the rules of the competition should be enforced?
They largely are? I think there's a very strong argument that training and learning from other people's work is not the same thing as infringing on their copyrights. It's never been illegal before, and it's a stretch to say that it should become illegal because machines have made it easier to do.
What is illegal is public performances and profit from these things. And that's still illegal and enforced today. If you make a copy of a hit TV show and start trying to profit from it, whether you use an LLM or you do it by hand, you will likely have it taken down or be sued.
> This is very much in doubt right now.
In an airy fairy theoretical sense, yes. In a practical sense, millions of people are buying and using AI on a daily basis because they find it more beneficial than the alternative.
It’s in doubt, but very arguable. In the case of translators specifically, being able to easily translate works into other languages seems like a huge boon for society compared to the relatively small downside of translators losing their jobs. I’d also make a similar argument for software.
Machine translation is one of the examples where the pros outweigh the cons, I agree. There are also cases, most obviously in visual art and design, where society will have to accept and uglier and inferior product because it's hard for skilled labor to compete with "basically free".
It still remains to be seen which side software falls on.
More broadly, it seems likely that AI will accelerate the trend of income and wealth inequality worldwide. Whatever you think of capitalism and so on, too much of it (inequality) does not make for healthy, stable socities.
> The market is competitive and it takes a lot to win.
You're right, it takes a lot of privilege to be able to take risks, and you must be in a position to actually take those risks to have a chance.
There's a reason that capitalism has very few stories like "single mother who takes care of her parents IPO'd her company today" and many more stories like "male billionaire makes next billion".
Advantages are always going to beget advantages.
You will definitely see "male billionaire makes next billion" more than you see "single mother IPOs." And you will see "single mother in America lives a comfortable life" more than you will see "responsible individual born in a South African tenement lives a comfortable life". And so on and so forth.
As much as I would like for there to be a perfectly fair world, there never would or could be. Even animals have it unequal. So imo it's better just to try to raise the floor.
Besides, I have no problem with happy people becoming happier, or successful people becoming more successful. Ideally, everyone could lead happy, successful, safe, prosperous lives. Every additional person who does is a huge win. I found it remarkable to learn this year that the middle class in America has been shrinking not because too many people are moving into the lower class, but primarily because the upper class has been growing in proportion. (Most media narratives like to leave that last part out.)
Success is a good thing! We just don't want it to happen at the expense of others. And for all the exceptional examples of the times where that is the case, it doesn't actually have to be the case. And largely isn't the case. Because wealth creation and prosperity are not zero-sum games. The entire wealth and prosperity of humanity as a whole has increased many orders of magnitude over the millennia, and significantly increased even in recent decades, without requiring some unfortunate billions of people to act as a counterbalance to this success and fall into depravity so that others may succeed.
So it's possible to do several things simultaneously:
- Accept and even celebrate that many people are prosperous.
- Work to minimize the instances of those in disadvantageous positions being unfairly abused by those with success, power, money, privilege, luck, etc.
- Work to improve the outcomes of those at the bottom relative to where they were in the past, as well as to give them more chances to succeed.
We've largely been doing a good job as a society making improvements here, despite the constant negative media.
Using people's work to make money without compensating them is theft, except when big tech does it.
Not only without compensating them for their work, but using their work to make them unemployable.
well if you use AI then they created value, no?
Lol what is this bs, so pirating and stealing is 'hotly debated'? Look its fine if you like what they do since clearly law is on their side for now, but man up and say it clearly.
> Lol what is this bs, so pirating and stealing is 'hotly debated'?
Always has been
> The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something, the person no longer has it.
> What you are talking about is not theft, it's copyright infringement.
And yet quite a few people's livelihoods are greatly diminished or nowhere to be found, while the results of their work are included without attribution or compensation in the output of generative AI models.
That may be true, but it's called copyright infringement, not theft, and it's very different.
And there are a great many things that can diminish the quality of many people's livelihoods without necessarily being some sort of crime. The invention of the horse, the car, the phone, the TV, the radio, etc weren't all great for everybody in society.
Call it whatever you want. If you take a text somebody created and sells, and you sell a derived version of it that can even mostly re-create the text 1:1, it's taking revenue away from the creator without doing the actual work. Even worse, if our legal system finally catches up and disallows training on books etc., they can just take an older model and train the new one based on it.
Should I disable my ad-block now?
Ad-block is an excellent incentive to discourage the commercialization of the internet.
The main argument for why or how copyright is theft is that by copying something, potential consumers give me money instead of you.
Like, for example, say I rip a movie. The movie is on Amazon for 10 dollars, but I sell ripped DVDs for 2 bucks. A lot of people might buy my rips instead of watching the movie online, and so the production company loses a lot of money.
Of course it’s complicated - would those consumers have really paid the 10 dollars at all? And, this is a simple example. Where it gets tricky is where it’s not direct ripping. It’s one thing to take a movie frame-by-frame and resell it. It’s another to, say, produce code that performs a similar functionality to existing code.
Yes, I understand this, but this is still not the same thing as theft. It's copyright infringement. Theft is something you own being taken. Copyright infringement is when someone breaks the temporary monopoly given to you by copyright law. They're distinct for good reason. And people and lobbies (usually big copyright holders like Disney) are the chief forces who have for dozens of years attempted to conflate the two, and to popularize terms like "intellectual property".
> The main argument for why or how copyright is theft is that by copying something, potential consumers give me money instead of you.
Gabe Newell famously said that piracy is a service issue. I myself mostly stopped pirating games 20 years ago when Steam made it affordable and convenient to buy games. Streaming services initially did the same, but subsequently destroyed the value proposition by constantly hiking prices and imposing restrictions on devices. So now I get my video content from the high seas again, while I still get most of my games from Steam.
> Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods
That’s just not true, though, is it? My secret formula for everlasting robot joints just got stolen, and my chances of making a trillion dollars next year has gone with it.
If you had it written down on a sheet of paper, and someone broke into your house and took it from you, it was stolen. If someone copied it, it wasn't stolen. The difference is very simple and easy to understand.
Laws against theft exist to prevent people from losing things that are in your possession.
Copyright laws exist to give people a limited monopoly to profit from their creations. This monopoly, or your copyright, can be "infringed" upon. And you could argue that that is dastardly and bad and evil and bad for society. (Although I would likely disagree with you). And that's fine. But it's not the same as something being "stolen" from you.
I left it on the table in my workshop and my cleaning lady’s son copied it and sold it for $10 million to a guy who runs an everlasting robot development skunk works. What would you advise?
Don't leave your trade secrets sitting out on the table. Or get better/faster at sales. Probably both.
Pretty fascinating to know that theft of trade secrets is now no longer theft.
So if I pirated a lot of movies, I actually deserve to make money of selling those?
Also, if their tokens get 'stolen' because an account doesn't follow their terms then they do certainly ban people for that.
I wouldn't care personally, no. If I invent spaghetti, then you create a spaghetti restaurant, and get rich, so what? Same thing happens in the software industry all the time, too.
I just checked out your profile and noticed you're the indie hacker guy. I registered on your community site about 7 years ago or so and put some information in. After some time a friend contacted me and told me that he found lots of personal information about me on the Internet. Turned out you somehow put all users' information public... Based on your comments, I'm now a bit worried about what you generally do with your users' data.
Similar to Hacker News, there's literally no private data on the Indie Hackers website except your sign-in email address and password. The only actions you can even take are creating public profile pages, writing public comments, and writing public posts. If you write things in public, then generally it will be public.
I believe you're not showing the full picture right now. I'm not talking about posts. I had put revenue and customer numbers on my profile, intended for other indie hackers. You specifically asked for that at that time. This was supposed to be private (and it was at the beginning). As another friend of mine was affected as well by this incident he contacted you and you somehow changed it back, - apparently after too many users complained. I don't believe you can't remember - there must have been many users that contacted you because of this.
>If you write things in public, then generally it will be public. I have no clue how your platform works nowadays - as mentioned, this was 2019 or so.
There was never a feature on Indie Hackers when you could share your revenue and customer numbers in private. In fact, I just added a "hide my revenue" feature for the first time last week.
So I'm genuinely curious what you're talking about.
Your account of things is confusing to me. "I had put revenue and customer numbers on my profile, intended for other indie hackers," but "it was supposed to be private"? How could those both be true?
I can't tell you technically how Indie hackers worked and works. But I can certainly tell you that our information was suddenly indexed by google and you acknowledged the issue and fixed it. I don't believe you when you say you can't remember this.
I feel like you're ignoring my last paragraph, which explains the source of my confusion pretty clearly. I think anyone would be confused by what you're saying: that you put data in public for others to see, but then expected it not to be seen by others. At least, that's what it seems like you're saying. And it's confusing.
> But I can certainly tell you that our information was suddenly indexed by google and you acknowledged the issue and fixed it.
Oh, well that's a different and much more specific claim. If at some point you asked me to hide some page on IndieHackers.com from Google, and I followed through and did, that's certainly possible. I know I've done that for some. But that's just a personal request and favor. There has never been any promise on Indie Hackers that pages would be hidden from search engines by default.
If you say everything on indiehackers was public by default, then we were not aware. We certainly didn't read the privacy policy. I just know it wasn't made clear in the entry form at that point in time.
Regarding the google indexing fix: We didn't know that this was an indivudual fix just for us. I'm sorry if I represented the issue incorrectly before - I thought it was a general fix.
It is not your personal information, if when copied you still have it, I guess... /s
> But if I could copy your apple and have an apple of my own, then you aren't being deprived, and meanwhile I'm better off. So it's a net good.
Since Anthropic models aren't a physical thing why should they keep their models in-house if no value would be lost by giving it away for free? Then everyone would just have more free stuff!
I agree that it would be better for society if everyone had copies of Anthropic's models.
As Thomas Jefferson put it so eloquently:
> If nature has made any one thing less susceptible than all others of exclusive property, it is the action of the thinking power called an idea, which an individual may exclusively possess as long as he keeps it to himself; but the moment it is divulged, it forces itself into the possession of every one, and the receiver cannot dispossess himself of it. Its peculiar character, too, is that no one possesses the less, because every other possesses the whole of it. He who receives an idea from me, receives instruction himself without lessening mine; as he who lights his taper at mine, receives light without darkening me. That ideas should freely spread from one to another over the globe, for the moral and mutual instruction of man, and improvement of his condition, seems to have been peculiarly and benevolently designed by nature, when she made them, like fire, expansible over all space, without lessening their density in any point, and like the air in which we breathe, move, and have our physical being, incapable of confinement or exclusive appropriation. Inventions then cannot, in nature, be a subject of property. Society may give an exclusive right to the profits arising from them, as an encouragement to men to pursue ideas which may produce utility, but this may or may not be done, according to the will and convenience of the society, without claim or complaint from anybody.
If Anthropic don't want anyone copying their model, then they should simply keep it to themselves.
Agree with this, but in reality it's a matter of whose lawyers and lobbyists are better funded to rentseek in the legal/regulatory systems.
> The entire reason why theft is bad is because when you take something, the person no longer has it.
What's being stolen is not "csallen's artwork"—it's "the unique ability to make art in the csallen style", where "art" is to be taken liberally to mean words/text, paintings, programs, etc., and what's being taken from you is that uniqueness.
But, honestly, forget about the technical definition of copyright infringement vs. theft. It's a pretty weak argument to say that there's no there there when a diffusion model can create art nearly perfectly in the style of a living artist by training on that artist's work; especially so if that artist has spent years working on and perfecting that style.
That may not technically be theft, or even copyright infringement—we're navigating the shifting value of training and the moats available to artists and authors in real time, as you note. But the law follows human notions of fairness and equity, not vice versa.
Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim. You're saying "well, technically it's not theft" but if I were the OP I might reply "well, it feels like theft, so maybe the definition of theft is wrong". Your technical claim here is correct, but I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.
> What's being stolen is not "csallen's artwork"—it's "the unique ability to make art in the csallen style", where "art" is to be taken liberally to mean words/text, paintings, programs, etc., and what's being taken from you is that uniqueness.
Society has never protected nor guaranteed people a monopoly on the unique ability to do something. Anybody is free to look at somebody else's public work, study it in detail, practice on it, train themselves, and gain the ability to reproduce it in an identical style. In fact, if you go to school for art, music, writing, engineering, etc., they will have you do exactly that.
And this is pretty much exactly what training a model is.
What your comment is conflating is the ability to potentially do something, vs the act of actually doing it, vs doing it as a public performance or for profit. Only the last of those three things, I believe, is copyright infringement.
To wit: Imagine a person who can draw a perfect re-creation of Mickey Mouse, vs a person who does so in his spare time and for his friends and family, vs a person who does so and puts it on TV for the public to see and charges advertisers.
Would you like to make the first two illegal? If so, why? How does such a law benefit society?
The strongest argument I would personally grant here is that it's totally okay to train an LLM on others' work, and it's totally okay to use that LLM for yourself, but just like with copyright law, perhaps it should be illegal to use that LLM to create and distribute copyrighted works.
> Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim. You're saying "well, technically it's not theft" but if I were the OP I might reply "well, it feels like theft, so maybe the definition of theft is wrong". Your technical claim here is correct, but I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.
I don't think I'm missing the point. I just disagree with it.
Sure, it may feel like theft. Lots of things feel bad that are not in fact, bad. I think that's just part of life. Especially in the competitive market of selling goods and services. Sometimes you are going to lose, or your company is going to lose, or your business model is going to lose, or become outdated, or get outcompeted, and it's going feel shitty.
I'm not trying to be heartless. I feel for anyone in this position. People actually do suffer when there is massive change in the market. This has always been the case, and it is always tragic.
But I don't think we should necessarily be in the business of creating laws to protect particular business models that are no longer competitive in the market. Especially rent-seeking business models that do more to benefit their creators than the rest of society.
If we lived in a world where recipes could be patented (and thank god we don't), then whoever was the first to create pizza would surely have created Pizza Inc., and lobbied for recipe patent terms to be extended for hundreds of years so they and their descendants would never lose the exclusive rights to selling pizza, and so nobody else would ever be able to create pizza without paying them royalties for having done it first. And if other people decided to create and sell pizzas anyway, we would call them infringers or "thieves" and say that they were actively harming the creators of Pizza Incorporated. And if somebody were to give the ordinary person a pizza oven so they could make their own pizzas at home, then the owners of the Pizza Inc. patents would lose out on revenue, and they would certainly say they felt harmed and stolen from. And you would be here saying, "Well they feel like it's theft." And I would be saying, "Well I'm sure they do, but I dream of a world where anybody can make any recipe, and they don't get exclusive rights to limit everyone else's freedom or extract rent from everyone else just because they were the first to do it. And I don't think it serves society to create laws that grant them a monopoly."
In fact, we do actually live in a world where software can be patented, and many thousands of commonly-copied and used UX flows and UI elements are actually under patent. But, thankfully, due almost entirely convention and culture, software patents are practically never enforced. And again, thank god. Otherwise I'm sure the first person to have created a drop-down menu would be raving mad and feel stolen from any time the rest of us create a drop-down menu. And you would be here saying, "(S)he feels stolen from because nobody is paying royalties!" and I would be here saying, "I see that, and it's unfortunately, but I think it would be better to have a world where copying software functionality is allowed. I do not think we should be creating laws to protect rent-seeking business models that allow people to do something first and then extract royalties from the rest of the world."
> In fact, if you go to school for art, music, writing, engineering, etc., they will have you do exactly that.
> And this is pretty much exactly what training a model is.
Equating model training to a human learning a skill is like equating taking a camcorder into a movie theater, to a human remembering the movie they watched and imagining scenes from it in their head.
It scales. It has very different consequences since one trained model can be copied infinitely and obsolete an unlimited quantity of equivalently-skilled humans. It also is capable of imitating on a much finer level.
Here[1] is an image of the Mona Lisa I requested GPT6.1 Sol Medium to create as accurately as possible without referencing any external sources, using only its training. It claims to have followed my request: "Generated from training alone, without web searches or reference images."
Of course, the Mona Lisa is public domain, which is why I didn't have to fight it to do this. And I'm sure it is represented in the training data many thousands of times, unlike, say, my obscure open source libraries. But the point of the exercise is to show the "trained" weights can reproduce what they were trained on in a way far superior to any human memory (could any artist recreate Mona from memory this well?) and arguably, even better than some technologies we do consider copyright violations such as a very badly shrunk-and-compressed JPEG or a picture-of-a-picture-of-a-picture. Or the aforementioned shaky camcorder bootleg.
[1]https://imgur.com/a/QaGHEMi
> It scales. It has very different consequences since one trained model can be copied infinitely and obsolete an unlimited quantity of equivalently-skilled humans. It also is capable of imitating on a much finer level.
It does scale, but I don't think that's particularly relevant. It's not any reason to make it illegal. If something that's fine and legal becomes effective enough to threaten other people's business models, that should not make it illegal. That should just make it the dominant business model and the other business models should lose.
> But the point of the exercise is to show the "trained" weights can reproduce what they were trained on in a way far superior to any human memory (could any artist recreate Mona from memory this well?)
I feel the same way about this. Yes, the technology is really really really good, but why is that relevant? If you use it to produce copyrighted works, then okay, I think you're infringing copyright. But just the fact that it's capable of doing so doesn't bother me.
> Equating model training to a human learning a skill is like equating taking a camcorder into a movie theater, to a human remembering the movie they watched and imagining scenes from it in their head.
Not true at all.
A camcorder creates an exact copy of the movie. If that's what training models was doing, I would agree it's copyright infringement.
Here's a thought experiment. Imagine we get better at understanding the human brain, and we discover how to augment it. Maybe biologically. We start genetically engineering people to remember more, absorb more, train better. Pretty soon, some humans emerge who can copy things they see with remarkable accuracy. (To be fair, there are some people who can already do this.)
Should these people be illegal? Is it suddenly copyright infringement for them to behold copyrighted work? Why or why not?
If you say, "Well they're people, not machines," that's true, but why should that lead to a distinction? What's wrong with machines doing things? Should we make calculators illegal? Obviously not. So what's so wrong with machines that can think and learn and do so effectively?
As far as I can tell, I only ever hear two reasons given, which are both flavors of the same thing: (1) Because it outcompetes some humans, and makes those industries harder to profit in, and harms the livelihoods of people who are trying to profit. (2) Because it will outcompete all humans, or at so many humans, that there will be a crisis of economics or meaning, possibly both.
I have some sympathy for the latter, but the former is business as usual when it comes to technological disruption.
> A camcorder creates an exact copy of the movie.
A camcorder bootleg of a movie is objectively not an exact copy, and subjectively a worse reproduction than GPT's from-memory Mona Lisa. But it's close enough to count for copyright violation purposes.
I'm not claiming the weights of a model can exactly reproduce every work they were trained on, that would of course be an impossible violation of information theory.
But clearly they are capable of making extremely close, close enough to count, reproductions of some works they were trained on. Is it not fair to say the weights "contain" a lossily compressed copy of the Mona Lisa since I can spit that image out of them? And if they contain the public domain Mona Lisa, do they not also contain countless copyrighted works, which a thin band-aid of system prompts tries to prevent them from offering up on-demand?
I'll admit, this technology is not exactly like copying stuff, but it's not quite not like copying stuff either. It is a new gray area. What I totally reject is the claim that it's just like a human learning things and should be treated the same. Unless the trained model was never allowed to be copied to another machine, and had to live and die exactly once with the hardware it was trained on. And had rights of its own. All of which of course would be absurd.
> It does scale, but I don't think that's particularly relevant. It's not any reason to make it illegal. If something that's fine and legal becomes effective enough to threaten other people's business models, that should not make it illegal. That should just make it the dominant business model and the other business models should lose.
Absolutely it matters! You can't spell copyright without "copy". Before the printing press there was no reason for such a thing. There are only extremely rare cases of disputes over manually copied books and certainly no system of law to protect it. It is the scaling factor of mechanical copying becoming possible that made the concept of copyright necessary in the first place. Scale is everything.
> Unless the trained model was never allowed to be copied to another machine, and had to live and die exactly once with the hardware it was trained on. And had rights of its own. All of which of course would be absurd.
This would indeed be absurd, but these are arbitrary differences. One can always point out differences between two different things, but that doesn't make those differences relevant to the issue at hand. Copyright law has little to do with whether someone or something has rights of its own, or lives and dies in a single body, etc.
The only differences that matter here are whether or not an actual copy is being constructed and/or used in such a way that it infringes on copyright law. (And, arguably, whether this copyright law is just or good in the first place.)
I don't think it is or should be.
It is possible for LLMs to reproduce copyrighted works sometimes very accurately. And you could maybe argue that this means they possess some copy in their weights. But a human brain also possesses the capability to memorize an entire book and then reproduce that book's content, and I don't think that's grounds for any sort of issue. In fact, even a regular computer without an LLM can do such a thing, and that's fine. In fact, regular computers have even been used to do such things, without it being copyright infringement. (See: Google Books.)
What differentiates the human brain and an LLM from a camcorder is that a camcorder exists for no other reason than to copy. An LLM and a human brain can do much more. And training a brain or an LLM is done not in order to produce copies, but in order to do something far different, far more expansive, and far more impressive.
The fact that "well maybe technically there is something resembling a copy in the weights" is not really grounds for copyright infringement. Nor is, "Well even though LLMs can do a million impressive things, they can also sometimes make an exact copy."
If somebody did a training run of some new kind of model that literally existed to do nothing but reproduce what it ingested, then sure, you'd have a point. Hell, if someone uses a normal LLM to reproduce copyrighted works, you have a point in those uses as well.
But 99.9% of the use of an LLM is to have it solve novel problems and create novel things, based on what it learns. And that's the entire reason for the training, too. Whatever copying happens is an incidental side effect.
It's a bit like pencils. Can pencils be used as weapons? Technically, sure, 100%. And they have been. But we shouldn't be banning them from schools.
Can an LLM be used to make an exact copy, or contain exact copies in its weights? I guess so? But this is hardly the issue at hand. LLMs do largely transformative work, which is pretty clearly protected under fair use. Most complaints that artists have about LLMs has less to do with their exact work being reproduced and resold, and more to do with the fact that the AI can generate new works that compete with them.
Which obviously sucks but… that's business? And I don't see how it's in the interest of society to create laws that prevent better businesses from beating worse ones, just because the worse ones don't like it.
> Absolutely it matters! You can't spell copyright without "copy".
Not to nitpick here, but as far as I'm aware, under U.S. copyright law at least, there is no general rule that copying becomes infringement only after some threshold number of copies. People get arrested or sued all the time for making small numbers of copies. You are right that, perhaps the impetus for copyright law in the first place, came as a result of mass copying. But it is not the scale that supposedly makes it a moral hazard, or even a legal issue.
> Not to nitpick here, but as far as I'm aware, under U.S. copyright law at least, there is no general rule that copying becomes infringement only after some threshold number of copies. People get arrested or sued all the time for making small numbers of copies. You are right that, perhaps the impetus for copyright law in the first place, came as a result of mass copying. But it is not the scale that supposedly makes it a moral hazard, or even a legal issue.
I did read your whole post, but I only want to address this last point because I think it gets to the core of our disagreement (or maybe a little bit of agreement?)
Before the printing press there was no need for copyright because copying itself was extremely high effort and non scalable. If somebody manually copied a manuscript, fine, good for them. The printing press changed that. Now somebody could free-ride with little effort and financially benefit 1000x from somebody else's work. This seemed to be unfair and bad for society. Copyright followed.
This is what learning a skill was like. Sure, somebody else could "copy" your learned skill by years of study, and eventually do work of equal quality having done their own learning. But it's so high effort and non scalable for each new person to be trained, that was never a problem. Good for them. The LLMs change that. Now the companies selling LLM intelligence are free-riding and financially benefiting 1000x from many other peoples' work. This seems to be unfair and bad for society. <Something> will follow.
I'm not sure what the <something> will be, that is beyond the scope of this conversation. I don't think copyright law, designed for another era, has the answers to this. But I do think there should be and will be a <something>.
I agree with you that this is probably our fundamental difference. Because I don't really think it's unfair that somebody with a printing press could copy your stuff and distribute it and make way more money than you could. You never could have done that in the first place. Meanwhile they just made a bunch of customers happy. You lost nothing, the world got better.
I've been studying business in general and startups for probably 20 years now. And if I've learned anything, it's that the popular conception of what it takes to create something and succeed in the capitalistic marketplace is basically just to create it.
The popular conception is that the creators are the kings/queens.
But reality is far different. You not only have to make something, but you have to make the right thing that the market actually needs and wants. And it can't just be the right thing, but it also has to be pretty close to the best thing. And it can't just be the right thing and the best thing, but it also has to be fairly unique and differentiable. And making something that's differentiated, unique and high quality usually isn't good enough either. You also have to work out distribution, marketing, sales, advertising. You have to figure out the right business model. You might need funding. You need maintenance, customer support, a million other things.
Business is hard.
And in my opinion, you don't really "deserve" anything unless you do all of it. And the market itself is a good enough barometer of what you deserve. If you do all of it, the market will reward you. If you're not being rewarded by the market, there's almost certainly some shortcoming that you have, where you are not serving the market as well as others. We don't need the government to come in and create laws and protect you from people/companies who are serving the market better, faster, cheaper, or more thoroughly than you, to the point wher the rest of society prefers them to you. You just need to do better.
In rare cases, someone is playing unfairly and that's why we have laws, which by and large work for the majority of businesses to protect them from fuckery, sabotage, etc.
But not, imo, from superior competition.
There are some industries that have figured this all out, as part of their culture. The vast majority of software engineers, for example, do not expect to be rich simply because they created a popular program or library. They understand that they need to do the marketing, the sales, the fundraising, and all of that. Even though they're programmers and abhor this kind of work, and would much prefer to just do the coding.
Restaurants are another good one. I know a lot of cooks, but I don't know a lot of cooks who think that just by cooking they should become millionaires. They know that they need to open a restaurant, do the marketing, keep everything clean, serve customers, have good prices, hire good staff and do all the rest of it if they want to profit.
(Not coincidentally, I think, both the restaurant industry and the software industry either do not have patents on recipes and code, or they do not enforce them.)
There are some industries where the culture has not figured this out as much. Music is a good example. There's still a common belief among musicians that having a good voice and making good music should be enough. Even though it's an incredibly cutthroat competitive market and doing the actual marketing and distribution to get a song out to the masses is 98% of the work if you want financial success, because there is a huge supply of good singers. The musicians who make it typically team up with the "suits" who are good at the marketing and distribution. Or figure out how to do it themselves.
(Not coincidentally, I think these are industries that place a heavy emphasis on copyright and patent law, which creates a culture of rent seeking, and thinking that everyone should pay you jut bc you were the first to create something, even though you slacked on everything else that customers want and need.)
Business success is hard, by nature of it being competitive. I'm okay with that.
Because it still works.
The startup industry is flourishing, and there are new successes and innovations every year, even though every developer can copy everybody else's software with pretty much no legal repercussions and software patents aren't enforced. Restaurants flourish, even though everybody can copy everybody's recipes -- you can make a new recipe today and Applebee's can put it on their menu tomorrow. That's tough, but it's not unfair. That's just the nature of competition. If you're chasing outsized profits, then you have to play the game. And you should have to play the game. And you should have to be better than the other guys. Competition is good because it forces both innovation and cheaper prices, which benefit consumers and the rest of society.
I don't like protectionist laws that allow businesses, even innovative upstarts, to artificially succeed by restricting what everyone else is allowed to do.
Patent and copyright laws tell you and me and everybody else what we're not allowed to sing, what we're not allowed to write, what we're not allowed to conduct, what we're not allowed to code, what we're not allowed to say, what we're not allowed to make. For no other reason than that "someone else wants to profit a lot." I think they are worse for society, and by-and-large do not need to exist. And that pretty much every industry would do just fine without needing some artificially protected business model that restricts everybody else's freedom to create whatever they want.
The main counter-argument to this is that without copyright and patent laws, people won't be incentivized to create. But I think everything that's happened since the birth of the internet has pretty much proven that to be incorrect. But even before that, people were telling and spreading stories, writing songs, and building and innovating things, far before copyright law ever existed. Artistry is in our bones, and 99% of people will create and share things even if it won't make them rich. I think copyright is primarily a tool made to protect monopolies and to encourage rent-seeking. In other words, to allow people (and now their descendants!) to profit without having to create anything new, or innovate, or lower prices, or otherwise benefit society, simply by restricting everybody in society's ability to compete and riff and create. I don't see any real good reason why it should exist.
I could actually be on board with the "dissolve copyright altogether" approach. As long as it also covers it being totally fine to use a leaked copy of Fable vCurrent's weights exfiltrated by the Chinese and released for free. Level playing field.
100%
See my comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50567495
I think if you want to build a better business, you should have to build a better business. You shouldn't be able to just create something, and sit on it, and make it illegal for the rest of society to compete.
And I think it's kind of a cancer that we allow that. Honestly, I think copyright law is the biggest thing holding artists back. I really don't think it's coincidence that these industries that have the most entitled (imo) creators who think they deserve to get paid for simply creating stuff, rather than for building a successful business around it, are the ones that have a strong culture of relying on "IP".
If we just got rid of it all, I think we would see a new generation of talented and empowered artists who are also entrepreneurs. Just like we do in software and restaurants.
> Here's a thought experiment. Imagine we get better at understanding the human brain, and we discover how to augment it. Maybe biologically. We start genetically engineering people to remember more, absorb more, train better. Pretty soon, some humans emerge who can copy things they see with remarkable accuracy. (To be fair, there are some people who can already do this.)
> Should these people be illegal? Is it suddenly copyright infringement for them to behold copyrighted work? Why or why not?
> If you say, "Well they're people, not machines," that's true, but why should that lead to a distinction? What's wrong with machines doing things? Should we make calculators illegal? Obviously not. So what's so wrong with machines that can think and learn and do so effectively?
Responding separately to this part that was added. That's a great thought experiment. I liked thinking about it.
I would NOT say these people should be illegal. I would NOT say it should be illegal for them to behold copyrighted works.
I would say they WOULD own the rights to anything they create that is a novel, transformative work, and that they WOULD NOT own the rights or be legally able to profit from anything they create that is clearly a 1:1 copy of other people's work.
It would be immoral and illegal for me to run a business wherein I force this person to view millions of copyrighted works, then enslave them to create new works for my customers on demand.
Basically, the same rules I apply to any other person today.
Do you apply all of these rules to machines, too, or only some of them? I don't apply all of these rules to machines. Like you said, my reason is just "Well they're people, not machines". I accept that. What about you?
I liked your response up until the "enslaving this person" part. I don't know what enslaving has to do with anything.
Like I said in my other response, there's always going to be arbitrary differences between people and technology and if you pick some random difference you could try to make an issue with that, but that difference is not what's at hand. It's not about the fact that technology is a choice and people don't. (Which is where I think you'r getting this slavery thing from?) Of course it would be unethical and immoral and should be illegal for you to enslave someone. But that's not the question we're trying to answer today.
What we're talking about today is the copyright infringement of it all. So let's take slavery out of it.
Let's say this person simply worked at a company where they viewed millions of copyrighted works and created new works for the company's customers on demand.
What would be unethical or illegal or immoral about that?
Even if they occasionally reproduced an entire copyrighted work, I could grant that that would be an issue, and shouldn't be allowed under current law, and action could be taken. But I couldn't agree that their mere ability to do this, or the fact that they do this occasionally, should mean it was illegal for them to do the learning and training in the first place.
> Basically, the same rules I apply to any other person today. Do you apply all of these rules to machines, too, or only some of them? I don't apply all of these rules to machines. Like you said, my reason is just "Well they're people, not machines". I accept that. What about you?
I think it depends on the question at hand, not on fundamental differences between man and machine. Of course man has choice and freedom and machines don't, and that's fine. Therefore I don't think I wouldn't compare using a machine to slavery just because you don't have to pay a machine and have to pay a man.
Any analogy has some differences that simply don't translate or hold up. To me I'd just like to focus on the relevant parts of the analogy.
When it comes to laws, I don't see the point in making laws that apply to machines but don't apply to humans doing the same thing.
For example, I can understand not allowing self-driving cars by default, because humans require licenses and training and are subject to jail time for misbehavior, whereas self-driving cards are fundamentally unable to go through the same processes and be held accountable, so society needs time to adjust.
I can understanding allowing human telemarketers but not allowing robocall telemarketers, because the experience of talking to a human is fundamentally difference than the experience of talking to a robot, and it's a human on the other line who has to deal with the robot.
But I couldn't understand, say, allowing humans to calculate numbers, but not allowing spreadsheets or calculators to do it. Sure, they're advantageous. Sure, they put people out of business. (Famously, "calculator" used to be the name of a job, not a device. RIP.) But it's not directly making anyone's lives worse, outside of being outcompeted in the market, which imo is fair and overall beneficial to society.
But I can't understand allowing humans to learn so they can acquire general intelligence, but (imo) abusing copyright law to say that robots aren't allowed to learn, because they're too good at it and (once again) outcompete some jobs or roles in the market.
The enslaving part I only added to make very clear that the "a human does it" / "a machine does it" analogy breaks down, and we only disagree about exactly where it first starts breaking down.
When we talk about a person learning/recreating stuff they learned from, the person themselves is who we are holding responsible. But a machine is not guilty of anything. It is owned and wielded by a person or more likely a company. It is what that company does that may be unethical.
This goes right to your person-employed-by-company example, I do think the company is acting immorally by gathering up and feeding all that copyrighted data to their superhuman employee, knowing perfectly well that what they are selling their customers is the employee's mimicry of it. It wouldn't be illegal, but then, we don't have the precedent for it since the superhuman-mimicry biotech doesn't exist.
> Using the word theft to describe what's going on here, as OP does, is making a moral claim of equivalence, not a legal claim.
Exactly. But the thing is, if you do moral claims in this form, you open yourself for rhetoric of pedants, and then spend all your free time debating the meaning of words instead of talking about things that really matter. People opposing your views would use this rhetoric when they have no better arguments, passing-by pedants would be compelled to debate words with you. (Like I being highly interested in rhetoric techniques can't miss such an opportunity to add my 5 cents, which are technically off topic of your discussion)
> I'd argue that it's also maybe missing the point.
Yes, and no. The statement is ambiguous it can be understand in different ways. If you expect your opponent to use rhetorical techniques against you (maybe unconsciously, rhetoric techniques are double edged and they can posing the thinking of the user), you'd better don't let them do it. It is much easy to handle ambiguity when it starts, then to keep it in mind through all the discussion until it starts deform the logic of argument and then interrupt your opponent, explain the ambiguity, remind them how it came into the discussions and how it developed since then, and why it was not important before and why it is important now.
You see, it is possible that the person who uses "theft" is missing the point. And maybe they do it deliberately to muddle the water.
Using "theft" is good if you are a politic and target your speeches at huge masses of uneducated peasants (they would understand your words as "theft"="copyright infringement" but it kinda not your fault, right?), or if you are talking with people who agree with you already (even if they notice a trick, they would agree with it). If you want a honest debate you'd better make your moral claim explicitly, though I prefer to avoid moral claims completely: if you think a bit, you can replace moral references with references to what is good for a society. Like Max Weber did with Protestantism virtues.
In case you missed the memo, the internet changed it's mind and IP laws are now a good thing
> I much prefer the creativity, riffing, and copying you see in software and the food industry, than to the cookie-licking and rent-seeking you see in other industries that lean more into this sort of thing.
> And this, of course, is not theft. It's copyright infringement.
It’s funny that you mention the food industry because that’s actually the perfect example that contradicts the point you’re trying to make. I can create a recipe for a dish. I have personally created more than a few. Someone else can take that recipe and make the same dish. It will, unless they are experienced in cooking, be bad when they cook it because you need to have an instinctive sense of when something is just right and how to adjust the heat on your particular hob and how to compensate for all the things I just assumed you would understand.
And, of course, a list of parts to make a product cannot be protected by copyright.
I don’t see a lot of creativity, riffing and copying in the software industry. Sure, it’s there in software but not in the industry of software which is entirely based on “cookie-licking and rent-seeking”.
> The idea that being the first to express a particular thought/idea/whatever means that others should be restricted from doing so
Copyright explicitly does not give protection to thoughts/ideas/whatever.
> It’s funny that you mention the food industry because that’s actually the perfect example that contradicts the point you’re trying to make. I can create a recipe for a dish. I have personally created more than a few. Someone else can take that recipe and make the same dish. It will, unless they are experienced in cooking, be bad when they cook it because you need to have an instinctive sense of when something is just right and how to adjust the heat on your particular hob and how to compensate for all the things I just assumed you would understand.
I'm struggling to see your point here, but I don't quite follow. Can you explain more clearly?
To me, the restaurant industry makes my point more than any other. Luckily, people were creating and recipes far earlier than any society had the power to conceive of, create, and enforce anything resembling copyright/patent laws. So we get to live in a world where recipes aren't subject to patents. Anyone can make anything, and "I did it first so it's mine" does not in fact entitle anyone to extract rent from everyone else, or restrict others' freedom to cook what they want.
Can you imagine we had Pizza Inc, Taco Inc, Fish and Chips LTD, etc., and they had lobbied for decades to extend their patents for hundreds of years so no one else was allowed to make these things, and they spent millions on teams of lawyers to sue everyone into oblivion who tried to riff or remix?
I'm also very grateful that the software industry at large has a culture and tradition of not actually enforcing patents.
>Theft can only happen with rivalrous goods.
Uhm ... no?
Copyright is a thing.
IP and trade secrets can be stolen, etc.
> Copyright is a thing.
And violating it is called copyright infringement, not theft. Two different laws. And people and lobbies (usually big copyright holders like Disney) are the chief forces who have for dozens of years attempted to conflate the two, and to popularize terms like "intellectual property".
> But if I could copy your apple and have an apple of my own, then you aren't being deprived, and meanwhile I'm better off.
If that apple was to be sold, and you would otherwise have bought it, you steal my income.
Go to a greengrocer everyday, copy all their apples, leave the store. If everybody does that day in day out, and nobody ever pays the greengrocer for anything, can you really say with a straight they were not robbed of something?
> Unless, of course, you wanted to profit off the fact that I was without. Then you might say that your monopoly and thus your profits were harmed.
This logic applied in principled fashion cuts against all intellectual property, including the models anthropic is building a business on. I'm not against it, but I'm against selective application.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50567495
The second biggest after copyright was extended to up to a century longer one fine afternoon last century with no one being compressed for the destruction of the commons.
As an SF resident you should perhaps direct more fury that for the last 6 years housing construction and availability has been so miserably low.
It has been a complete self own by our own city!
In the last 6 years a lot of laws were changed to make housing construction easier, and yet, the housing production did not happen. Whose fault is that?
SF residents have only themselves to blame.
As for most things, there’s not a singular fault. It’s easy to point at a macro issue and want to have someone to blame, but it’s almost certainly a mix of features.
The issue may be less “whose fault is it” (to what, punish?) but instead “how do we incentivize / encourage / command change?”
It is 100% the governments fault. Literally no one else. There are innumerable examples rn of places building plenty of examples. Even more if look through history. Ask Claude to asummerize all the rules and laws that make it difficult to build housing in Sf
https://archive.ph/qiQMo had an interesting take on the costs involves with building housing in SF
SF residents repeatedly elect supervisors who defy state housing laws. There's a reason why the Builders Remedy is being invoked for the skyscraper in Sunset. That wouldn't have happened if supervisors weren't arbitrarily blocking housing.
Doesn't really matter how cheap your rent is if your income is 0.
I’m not sure if you’re one of those anti AI absolutists or not. AI is without a doubt very useful. I use it everyday.
The problem is how these companies are valued and what their incentives are. They could slow down expansion dramatically because it’s already so useful and focus on efficiency, how to make it more affordable, how to make it safe, making all the tools better.
But they want their stupid multi trillion dollar valuations based on what they might achieve and promises of the number of people their customers can fire rather than building sustainable and profitable businesses.
And existing businesses want greater profits so they buy into it and use it as an excuse to fire people (and maybe off shore the work).
AI is great. But so many people involved with big tech are truly evil bastards. We need to globally come together and tax the shit out of these people to compensate for all the lost jobs and the impact to the climate.
I use AI at work and in my hobbies. I’d argue it’s completely reinvigorated my career and given me the ability to create things I’d never thought possible (a compiler for my own made-up programming language).
All the ecological and job related issues will normalize.
I’d lay odds you’d see the same cries 130 years ago during the Industrial Revolution.
We’ll be fine.
Being in IT for forty years has provided insight I don’t see in other industries. We have always had to learn and reinvent our careers. AI has just added another hoop to jump through.
In my more optimistic moments I think it's possible that the impact of LLMs on software won't be quite as doomsday as some like to predict. I hope I am not wrong. But there are a lot of other knowledge jobs which I think are even more vulnerable, and I wonder how many of those workers have a flexible enough skillset to move around into something that still fits in the age of AI.
I have no solution for this, but what I find distressing is that things were working fine without AI. We could have kept on going, the job market was fine, the problems were manageable, rich people getting rich without everyone else necessarily going into poverty. But how do we put the brakes on massive destruction of the workforce with AI? Because each individual company is incentivized to not care about the overall societal effects, even if as humans they understand that when everyone else does the same thing everyone will lose in a big way.
The "Software Engineer" will change to a Product Engineer and still require deep knowledge of _how_ we construct software. Information Architecture, User Experience Design, and professional Graphic Arts still require a human. Product Owner, Business Analyst are still human-centric.
There will be a period of adaptation. Those that refuse to adapt will move to other careers.
I think the societal issue is the bigger one. If we had the same constructs from 1960 (90% tax rate, massive middle-class, nearly free healthcare and public college), the impact of AI would be negligible.
And I think Gen-Z, Gen-Alpha, and likely the one after will determine our fates. If my five gen-z kids are any indication, universal healthcare is coming. Universal Basic Income as well.
The libertarians and conservative nut jobs have pushed us so far it's literally pissed off everyone: women, Latinos, the black community, people under 35. The anger towards the MAGA, GOP, and wealthy is palpable.
I'm optimistic the world is heading for better days.
The industrial revolution killed lots of people and brought unprecedented kinds of suffering for the survivors.
Individuals are not as robust to big disruptions as all of society. Nothing is being done to protect individuals.
I think looking at history is not always a good indicator.
We can truely move at a speed never before seen. I use it all the time for personal projects and AI is truely a step improvement to what I can output.
But now you can tell me to do 5x more tasks and not hire juniors.
And what developers do is largely banal. They can use AI to help prove theorems. Challenges that have stood for decades are falling. And you still have people saying things like “it’s just AI slop”.
> AI is without a doubt very useful. I use it everyday.
There are many net-negative things that are useful. Burglary is a useful way to gather new possessions. Plagiarism is a useful way to profit without effort. Counterfeiting money is a useful way to increase wealth. But for these things, as a society, we've decided that the downsides for civilization are not worth the gains for the individuals.
In my view, generative AI falls into the same basket as burglary, plagiarism, and counterfeiting. Further enriching billionaires is not worth the costs in jobs, climate, a stable economy, and human creativity.
"...being unemployed for up to a year or more with no end in sight."
I've got multiple folks in my network hitting the 2 year mark. One at 3, another just hit 4.
I don't understand (being outside of the SF bubble).
Why would a smart person be out of work for 2 years?
Isn't there anything useful they could do? Or is it they couldn't find the right employer? Or maybe they expect to be paid too much?
> Why would a smart person be out of work for 2 years?
more than 180 million people are unemployed worldwide, you think all of them are dumb?
You try to find something in your field for the first several months, working your network, and find the market is flooded with other people laid off. Eventually... months later, you start looking at other fields where you have less (or no) experience. You're now competing against a load of other candidates who do have experience in that field. It's even harder. Even "just get a job flipping burgers" advice is hard - there's a lot of folks competing for those jobs too.
I also know multiple people who have struggled to find a job over the last few years, including a few who have been unemployed for over a year despite their best efforts. Your last three questions all share the assumption that this is a matter of individual choice and action. In some job markets it is, but right now it is not. The issues with the current job market are largely structural or environmental, so no individual action may suffice if too few jobs are available or other structural issues exist. The most useful things that somebody could do would be to network widely and try to get incredibly lucky, unfortunately.
Why is this relevant though?
I'm not sure it's relevant. Just... the "up to a year" remark years ago used to be the upper end for most people. That seems to be shifting for a larger number of people in the past 3-4 years.
A few folks in my network have experienced a layoff and been hired someplace else within 3-4 months, but they're outliers. One was 4 weeks, but that's almost unheard of. Most folks I know unemployed have been that way for more than 6 months, but more are creeping past a year, and shifting to 2.
To adapt a cliche: AI doesn't cause problem, humans with AI cause problems.
AI is a tool, a new ability we have. It is inherently good.
I'm reminded of loving and tight-knit families who win the lottery and receive a lot of money, and then a year later they're divorced, estranged, and hate each other. What happened? Somehow adding a good thing to that family system caused it to fall apart.
We're the same. We have a society. If you add a good thing like AI to our society, it will fall apart and a lot of people will suffer. Is that AI's fault or our society's fault?
Thank you. Thank you for putting it clearly in simple words. I don't get it either. What truly strikes me about the industry is how driven by hype is. It is absolutely ridiculous that we are valuating AI companies in the order of trillion dollars. Is insane.
I'm more worried about all of the destructive things this new EA money will fund.
Most EA funding goes into global health initiatives. Destructive is a good description if you're a mosquito or a malaria virus.
What rich billionaires think will help and what actually helps people are two different things.
Bill Gates spent years trying to "help" but ended up undermining health authorities' actual goals and engaging in rent-seeking activities around biotech IP.
If your summary of the Gates foundation is that it didn't help, you are completely and absurdly blinded by your bias.
lmao, seriously, this is easily the most ridiculous thing I’ve seen on HN in a long time, and that’s saying something
That's not just my summary. There's thorough journalism on this topic [1] that details how the Gates Foundation operated, told by researchers, academics, former employees, and public health officials who worked with it.
Gates "helped" with global health, much like he tried to "help" education in the United States with Common Core and teacher report cards.
Ultimately, he suffers from the same mentality that many engineers do: the assumption that because they've had some success in one field, it transfers to other fields, and they can simply do things that are "common sense" to them.
[1] https://www.amazon.com//dp/1250850096
Why would anyone lose their home? (genuinely asking) Doesn't SF have rent control and pretty strong tenant protections?
The disastrous job market isn't necessarily AI. Right now it's still all the overhiring from Covid + huge spike in comp sci degrees over the last few years.
After the Facebook IPO, building owners committed arson to drive tenants out of their buildings, because they were worth more to the buyer empty and damaged than occupied and intact.
Indeed. The GenAI / LLMs are some of the worst thing that happened to humanity.
How do you lose a home you already own other than to sell it or foreclosing and how would this force someone to do either?
Are you familiar with the concept of a mortgage?
Also property taxes
I am not saying this is worth any of the rest, this is just to give you the steelman:
> I still don’t understand what the benefit of AI is supposed to be
It's to make cheaper for everyone forever the things which were done by the people whose jobs it takes.
I don't know about a lot of this. For example the US is on track to have lower emissions this year than last year overall despite the datacenter buildouts. Last year it was higher because of a cold winter. There may be more emissions from datacenters but we don't know how much but overall electrical usage is up about 2% which is not significant. I don't know about you but I don't think the doomsday scenarios about AI datacenters have panned out so far.
Elon Musks’s big Texas data center is powered by giant gas-burning turbines. Anthropic is its biggest customer. Just about every time you use Claude you are causing fossil fuel emissions that would not have happened otherwise.
Not a useful metric. You could say that about someone's breath. Overall emissions are declining.
I'm confused at the jump to conclusions. Where does the "losing their homes" part come into play?
I think it's hyperbole. Take a look at home ownership rates: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/RHORUSQ156N
The benefits of AI is to allow founders to create billion dollar company without having to employ anyone.
I beats me why startups prefer SF proper instead of south bay/peninsula/east bay. After, more people settle down there after they have a family, right? Unless startups overwhelmingly hire younger people?
I used to be sympathetic, but at this point SF residents have only themselves to blame. Given the tech boom and ensuing housing demand over the last 30+ years the city should have looked like New York or Chicago or Shenzhen today. But people are under the delusion that they live in a quaint little suburb and don't want to do anything to spoil the "character". Well then if you don't give others a place to live they will eventually have to outbid you for your house. What other choice do they have?
The founder of SF YIMBY used to be my roommate. I’ve voted in every election since 2014 to make housing construction easier. It’s 2026, the rent is still going up, and evictions are increasing again. SF just handed its mayor dictatorial powers to fix this problem, and I don’t know a single person who believes it’s going to get better.
You should seek help if you think the San Francisco mayor has "dictatorial powers."
I should like to respectfully suggest that there are more-HN-guidelines-friendly ways to question the extent to which the recent city reforms qualify as "dictatorial". Perhaps it is rhetorically exxagerated, but so is your own post. Worse, "you should seek help" is belittling, and dismissive... and medicalizing political dissent is itself a tool of dictatorship.
No there's actually a contingent of catastrophizing depressive types in San Francisco who exaggerate bureaucratic changes to the administrative state approved by the most liberal voters country as the return of Stalin and Hitler. Those people would be sincerely better off getting treatment for their mental health issues, and not enough people call them out on it.
Did housing construction get easier?
Yes, it did, significantly, but it hasn’t made a dent in housing starts
It’s important to internalize the world has no obligation to be fair. A lot follows from this - but one thing is you don’t get emotional about the tech and try to deny its usefulness. Otherwise it leads you to being wrapped up in self condradictory loops (e.g. largest ipo in history == not clear if there is base value creation here), which ends up leading to even more stress since your subconscious knows it’s not correct.
Have to accept reality and act, is simple but not easy.
Having watched the rise and fall of crypto, it is not at all clear to me that large amounts of money being invested into something are a reliable signal that any value is being created. Moreover, it is obvious to me that capitalism is indifferent to whether any activity is socially valuable, only whether it generates more capital.
The valuation of Anthropic is based on the premise that it will enable the owners of capital to fire their most expensive employees. That’s me. All I have to sell is my labor. If no one is buying, I don’t eat. It doesn’t matter how useful the technology is — the future it’s building is one that has no place for me or anyone I know. Not sure what I’m supposed to do with that.
>If no one is buying, I don’t eat.
In a different world, AI enabled you to no longer needing to worry about putting food on the table. You'd be given a chance to focus on what you wanted instead. I suggest you read the Culture series by Banks, it gives a optimistic view of (true) AI.
That world is not the one we live in however. Our world is the one where I need to eat.
Yeah, I know. I was hoping we'd see a world where AI bring post scarcity but instead all the focus is on capital generated. Not exactly sure what value there is in delivering features faster on product X.
>The valuation of Anthropic is based on the premise that it will enable the owners of capital to fire their most expensive employees.
"The underlying purpose of AI is to allow wealth to access skill while removing from the skilled the ability to access wealth."
> largest ipo in history == not clear if there is base value creation here
You’re assuming the market or billionaires or the government behave logically.
And assuming it’s actual value for the economy at large and not a phenomenally successful exit plan for the rich people that dumped a bunch of money into a company that may have hit peak profitability last year. That is really not at all clear.
You can only hope that the tax revenue this event generates counts for a huge windfall for the state and they improve upon the mandate given to them by the people.
> "who cares, AI will fix it"
We already know how to fix it, but we just won't. I'm curious how that bit will be solved. I not quite convinced we'll like the AI's solution
AI will fix it by eliminating humans. Or rather, by eliminating human's ability to be gainfully employed so we eliminate each other.
Well at least people can flee this reality by playing GTA VI.
A high fidelity life simulation slash power fantasy that ensures that anyone that would have energy to do something is properly pacified.
Provided that Klarna lets them buy the PS5 Pro.
For me, honestly, this is the worst part. Not that things are bad but knowing that them being bad is now going to very effectively being absorbed so that it doesn't get bad enough for anyone to do anything at all.
Ready Player One, right!
I guess if society is going to burn one way or another, I'd like to have my bread and circuses. At least GTA6 lets you live out the fantasy of having a decent house with no rent.
It's obviously not an option to just build more.
Success is clearly doom.
Failure is the path to prosperity.
Think of it this way: Anthropic figured out how to take everyone's work, everyone's creative output, and mine it like a natural resource. People traditionally thought of labour as being something that was already done and paid for. They didn't think it could be mined and sold a second time. But it turns out it can.
It's as if someone just discovered how to get considerable energy from burnt ashes. And if you care about making money, that's a beautiful thing.
I couldn’t imagine being this pessimistic all the time. Plus seems like your still rattling with the idea that AI has benefits
How have you felt about the decades of wealth generation from the other big tech companies in the SF area? Have you been dooming and glooming since then? I hope you've been consistent at least.
Should we go back to riding a horse-and-buggy? The invention of cars led to all sorts of toxic emissions belong released into the atmosphere.
It's not OK.
Share platitudes? https://misanthropicstatement.com/ Wait for the government to intervene?
Why so? All that tech debt remain to be paid. The hype did not translate to actual productivity, and amount of code generated is not productivity, it's sometimes the opposite.
For assumed access to the best models and unlimited tokens, Claude Code is just whatever it is today. I'll take Pi over it any moment that it's not bundled with a API plan.
30000 commits and so what? 10x the use of memory to come back with output that is barely english.
i swear hn is just group therapy for SWEs now
Always has been[1].
1: https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/wait-its-all-ohio-always-has-...
And then Elon with his SpaceX XAI clusters will easily outcompete all Earth-based AI data centres - and the free market will solve that issue?
Spacex is working on space based gpus for the space force space based air moving target indicator program (SB-AMTI). Elon just heard of this and tried to tie it to AI to pump the stock.
This space data Center meme is on par with flat earthers now. Equally dumb, and nobody knows if the proponents are trolls or just delusional. Or stock scammers of course.
The ideological demonization of Elon - the name calling, making claims but not actually substantiating them with supportive arguments.
Thanks for reminding me why I logged out of and stopped coming to HN for so long.
You're part of the problem.
the petite bourgeoisie was fine with lower classes losing their jobs.
What's the point of that comment?
> the new elite consensus is “who cares, AI will fix it.”
Indeed. It was already a big problem that too many people were disengaged from our big problems. Now experts and leaders alike are diving headfirst into a future where everyone is encouraged to disengage their mental facilities.
In the dark days to come, all hands will be off the steering wheel. Almost everyone will myopically focus on driving their AI (operating on the whims of sociopathic trillionaires) to solve problems they no longer understand, without anyone comprehending the big picture anymore. Those who protest will be viewed as crazy.
I'm scared.
I have this crazy idea that we, as a society, are better when we are collectively poor.
I say that in recalling the 70's when my family (and the larger blue-collar area I lived in) were fairly poor. Going to restaurants (as an example) was a "treat". You looked for coupons I the newspaper to cut out and went to get pizza on a Tuesday because they had free drinks with purchase of a large pizza (or whatever).
I think it goes without saying that we were less wasteful, found enjoyment in simpler things like going to the park, etc.
(Not a popular opinion among my friends and associates.)
Hans Rosling's 2018 book "Factfulness" laid out this view of four levels of economic prosperity, with super-developed countries like the USA at level 4 and somewhat less affluent countries like Croatia and Portugal at level 3. While he didn't go this far, there's a lot about Level 3 life that sounds appealing from a distance and maybe up close.
You've got full electricity and refrigeration, even if your refrigerator isn't internet enabled. You've got less crowded cities; perhaps closer family ties; perhaps more cozy neighborhood gathering points. You don't have heroic U.S. medicine to buy a few extra years of life in the face of cancer, heart disease, diabetes, etc., but you've got what might be better diet and exercise to stave off trouble in the first place.
I don't see any way that the U.S. backs away from its focus on GDP growth as the only accepted measure of "the good life," but I'm open to wider, non-dollar definitions of prosperity for any communities that are interested.
If that is your idea of poor you have never been poor my friend. Being poor doesn't mean you spend less on pizza than normal its being worried if you are going to have a place to sleep next week when rent is due or able to afford the doctor when your kids get sick. Don't glorify poverty, its is a disease that should be cured.
The Onion Report: Growing Ranks Of Nouveau Poor Facing Discrimination From Old Poor - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=05RZJxDIhTU
Somebody has rosy glasses about their distant past, thats pretty common but you should realize that outright this basic feature of our subconsciousness and fight it. Remember the shittier parts of it, not just few top cherry picks.
Remember you were very different person, easy to please, much more patient, had very little expectations from life. Being poor now once you got deep in your comfort zone would be punishingly hard. Try it, you can do it anytime just wipe out your accounts.
> Not a popular opinion among my friends and associates
Gosh I can’t imagine why
I'm surprised you don't understand the benefit of AI. I certainly find it to be a useful tool and research assistant. It excels at mechanical coding tasks as well.
Is there a net benefit, though? Leaded gasoline, asbestos, and Instagram also have plenty of gross benefits.
Yes making you upset
I am once again begging you to look up, and listen to the scientists. Please. This information is not hidden, nor is it too complex for a layperson, nor is it invalid because of a few critics -- those were the exact arguments used against climate change in 2008, if you recall.
Please... please. I'm begging you. I know you're dug in, but we need you on our side (i.e. the human, antifascist side). AI is not hype, it's not a bubble, it's not a scam, it's not unknowable, it's not mysterious, it's not right wing, it's not anti-enviornmentalist, it's not anti-artist, it's not anti-you.
Please. LOOK UP