Hurried Announcement: Alessandro Masullo GRH
math216.wordpress.comRelated: Levent Alpöge claims proof of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50574968
Related: Levent Alpöge claims proof of the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis [pdf] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50574968
The manuscript claims he has been working on this problem for 12 years. I can only imagine the feelings that must have hit him when he saw the Anthropic announcement. Though if he believed he had solved it, he must have known it was only a matter of time until one of the AI companies found it, too.
A hurried announcement with the draft published within hours is the only way to claim a tie to the discovery. Time will tell if either holds up under further analysis, but at least he has shown his hand to the world with a timestamp on it now.
He'd completed it already, it was being checked.
Then he deserves full credit. He has witnesses too
... and then the question is whether or not any of the checkers had been using Claude or ChatGPT as part of that work and did his solution somehow get fed into their training data.
What are the chances they hadn't?
They clearly didn't because LLMs would have found multiple serious holes that are in it.
You've already read the manuscript and found serious holes?
I did something much more important: after my superhuman AI math companion identified 5 major gaps in Masullo's proposed proof, I had it create Lean-verified proofs of two of these gaps to show that they directly contradict the manuscript.
In November 2026, if a proof doesn’t survive AI scrutiny, it should never be published. Publishing it is malpractice and defending it is silly.
> my superhuman AI math companion
"Agent." The word is "agent." We don't need unrelated value judgments in every discussion involving AI.
Agent Smith
Can you elaborate at all on this?
Here is Astra 6.2. I had it formalize these gaps in Lean, so there is no question they are real.
Masullo’s proof of the Riemann hypothesis is invalid as written. On p. 495, a cutoff erases the very term the proof is trying to compute. On p. 29, a family of integrals that the proof needs to be uniformly bounded actually tends to infinity. Lean verified both mathematical obstructions.
1. The orbital cutoff erases the entire shell. Let Aₖ be the manuscript’s k-th set and αₖ its indicator. The sets shrink as k increases. The factor αₖ₊₁-αₖ therefore picks out the shell Aₖ∖ Aₖ₊₁, where it equals -1. In equation (11.3.2.3), the author multiplies by a later cutoff αⱼ in the same variable. Once j≥ k+1, that cutoff keeps only points in Aⱼ⊆ Aₖ₊₁. Every point of the shell has been removed. The integrand is then identically zero before integration, so its limit is zero as well. Manuscript, pp. 493–496 · Lean theorem
Why does that matter? The author uses this limit to recover a general orbital trace that can be positive. For example, over ℚ at the prime 2, take a nonnegative smooth test function of the idelic norm, supported in (3/2,5/2) and equal to 1 at norm 2. The claimed orbital sum has a positive term from the inverse uniformizer, whose norm is 2. An eventually zero sequence cannot recover that value. This invalidates the general trace calculation invoked on p. 520, although the large-prime terms needed on that page could still vanish for a separate reason. Orbital trace formula, p. 495 · Use in the global trace formula, p. 520
2. The bound needed for Montel’s theorem is false. Take ℚ, the trivial character, and z=3/2. On 1<t<2, the manuscript’s nonnegative cutoffs satisfy ϕₙ(t)→ t^{-3/2}. One positive contribution to the real-place integral therefore has limiting density \[ \frac12\,\frac{t^{1/2}\phi_n(t)}{t(t-1)} \;\longrightarrow\; \frac{1}{2t^2(t-1)} \;\ge\; \frac{1}{8(t-1)}. \] The last expression has infinite integral on (1,2). Each cutoff can have a finite integral because it vanishes near 1, but Fatou’s lemma shows that along every sequence approaching the prescribed limit, those integrals tend to infinity. Thus the claimed common bound fails even at the single point z=3/2. No such sequence can produce the finite holomorphic limit asserted on p. 29. Manuscript, §§1.4.2–1.4.5 · Lean theorem
The second error alone breaks the deduction of RH. The manuscript uses that holomorphic limit to rule out poles of L'/L in the region where it wants to exclude zeros of L. Since the limit fails, that exclusion has no proof here. The point z=3/2 is a counterexample to the manuscript’s bound.
I don't understand how a Lean formalization can formally confirm that a mathematical development is wrong, as opposed to that one is right.
Suppose that I give an informal explanation of Euclid's theorem on the infinitude of priems, and you ask an LLM to formalize my proof in Lean, and the LLM comes up with a formalization that doesn't typecheck (it doesn't establish the theorem). How can we be sure that this specific failed formalization is the right one? Isn't it still possible that the LLM misunderstood what I was saying (whether due to its lack of interpretive skill or my lack of explanatory skill or inherent ambiguities of natural language), and that its failed proof doesn't adequately correspond to my informal proof? Or, for that matter, that it formalized a statement slightly different from what I was claiming, and then that its correct formalization of my proof no longer corresponds properly to the incorrect formalization of my claim?
For a successful formalization, it seems reasonable to say that either the original statement was right or that it was wrong but the LLM successfully repaired it. But for an unsuccessful formalization, how confidently can we rule out a misunderstanding in the process?
I know LLMs are getting great at understanding natural language and mathematics alike, so such a misunderstanding is progressively less likely with every LLM generation, but certainly the formalization itself doesn't definitively rule it out merely by itself being a formalization!
Hey hi, I know that you won't listen most likely, but hopefully if enough people tell you, you might introspect a little bit. You should not blindly trust statements any LLM tells you on topics you know nothing about, and going around talking about them with an air of authority.
The approach used by him seems completely different from the one in the AI paper, so any claims of scooping are on shaky grounds.
Ah yes, the mathematics version of "the election was stolen!"
Could this end up being one of the last human-only mathematical discoveries?
maybe we will see some more publishing their "almost there" versions hoping to have something online before ai companies announce theirs
None of the AI math stuff so far has been discoveries - it dug up stuff that humans had already discovered, but failed to correlate. That doesn't mean what AI has done is worthless, solutions gathering dust are just as good as undiscovered.
GRH would have been a discovery, but I suspect we'll find that this work somehow wound up in the training corpus.
https://chatgpt.com/share/6b00ba36-e424-83e9-a2fa-2d0ad012f7...
https://claude.ai/share/50b95fa0-d5a9-440f-9e49-85544524d8dc
> Up to now, AI's verified new results have mostly been counterexamples, better bounds, and proofs of lesser-known conjectures.
> None of the AI math stuff so far has been discoveries - it dug up stuff that humans had already discovered
"it dug up stuff that humans had already discovered, but failed to correlate"
What on earth do you think humans do? Einstien built on Lorentz, Poincaré, Maxwell, Faraday, Newton, Galilei, Besso etc everybody stands on the shoulders of giants, nothing is truly novel.
What about Archimedes, or Zeno?
Archimedes himself cites Eudoxus, Democritus, Euclid and Aristarchus just in the limited direct quotes we have left from him.
I didn't bother looking into Zeno
Surely now, there has to be a call for legal constraints on LLM training inputs.
why? would you only want a human-discovered cure for cancer?
That's not what they are saying. They are saying if a human discovers a cure for cancer and someone uses AI to vet that discovery before it's published, the AI company should be restricted from using the unpublished discovery in its training data.
Now in the case of a cure for cancer, an argument could be made that even if unpublished it should be considered public data for the good of humanity, and thus should be included in AI training even if unpublished. But I think for that argument to have any teeth, you'd need to first be able to prove that it really was a cure for cancer, which wouldn't be possible for an AI company.
For sure, if that is what has happened in this case, and I think we're all suspecting this is the case, this state of affairs needs to change.
I don't think it would need a complicated change either. But elected law makers often fumble these things, and confer advantages to the very group society needs to be protected from.
I personally think this case is a true parallel discovery, Anthropic has the compute to brute force many such discoveries (though such feets will be out of reach for anyone outside the company, which is perhaps more concerning).
Regardless I do think we are least need laws requiring any AI service providers to ensure all contents of inference input and output to remain private, encrypted at rest, and strictly accessible to only the user. Ideally though we'd just ban the AI as a service business model outright.
I’m not at all suspecting this, neither here nor with the previous AI-discovered proofs. And as far as I know, there is zero hard evidence that this actually happened for even a single one of them.
AI has not cured cancer. There is no guarantee that it will either. You are making a bad faith argument.
What you're really asking then, is for medical research, and it's product, to be in the public domain. Which is an orthogonal argument, but not entirely unrelated. Like that org that spent close to a decade profiting of the BRCA series tests, or the prohibition on manufacturing counterfeit AIDS treatments for use in the third world.
That's IP. And given its importance, such data/IP perhaps should not be IP. But it is IP. Just like all those indie game designs parasitic studios have started to profit off. And those Disney/Nintendo characters, kept to certain outlets by vast teams of lawyers.
Much like the entire readership here, I know a little about how LLMs work, and understand there are world leading experts on the subject here too. I think we'd mostly agree that LLM tools would be quite unlikely to happen across such a discovery, without prior art in it's trained weights.
So in that sense, it's a form of theft, and it needs to be regulated.
It would have been nice if humanity worked out what we should, and should not steal/share, before we invented the stochastic thoughtwork hoover. But here we are.
I wish LLM boosters would stop reasoning based on their curing all cancers when after years their record of cured cancers remains at zero. If you gave human researchers (and the pipeline to creating human researchers) the resources that have been used for LLMs, they would probably have made even more progress than their actual, impressive, realized results.
Maybe. Alzheimer's plaque fraud and Elizabeth Holmes seems to say malfeasance isn't limited to the tech sector though.
Yes, in a way. Because if thousands of datacenters have to be erected to find a cure for cancer, would that be a world worth living longer in? If most of the population has a crisis of not finding purpose, would living ten years longer matter?
Perhaps we should think about the world we are creating before we make people live longer in it.
On the list of things I think are worth worrying about in regard to AI, datacenters are at the bottom.
The sketchy power systems that some operators are using and the rather corrupt-seeming permitting shenanigans are a little higher on the list.
> None of the AI math stuff so far has been discoveries - it dug up stuff that humans had already discovered, but failed to correlate.
This is a ridiculous argument. Every human proof incorporates stuff that was already known. All there has to be for a discovery is there to be something new. Every AI proof has satisfied that requirement.
Yes, this was more true earlier when they were solving obscure erdos problems with short proofs that were applications of obscure results, but at this point when Clay problems are dropping, we see that the current models are truly doing genuine research rather than just correlations. I have certainly updated my assessments as the models have progressed and made more impressive accomplishments.
Whatever you're smoking, I want some.
What are the odds claude already scanned this and trained on it? Claude is one of the most invasive for file permissions in my experience and requests access to directories on my machine that no other harness does. If he installed Claude once on any box with this manuscript then theres a non-zero chance that this solution ended up in training data. Time will tell.
Reminds me of the recent bug (don’t remember which… so many) that was independently reported in September before being LLM identified this week.
That's the Java bug: Java2Shell/Java4Shell.
Doesn't even need to be that he did it himself, could very well be that he shared a preliminary draft with anyone checking it that had Claude installed.
You really think nobody will ever do any work without AI ever again, huh?
Imagine how much this likely matters to him, and how little it means to Anthropic. Sobering and chilling.
Unfortunately, there are a lot of pro-AI folk who think that what matters to individuals is irrelevant if it means the faster production of arbtirary new knowledge. It's a twisted way of looking at things but they exist.
It depends if the checks find it's correct or almost correct (like Wiles proof) or it has big unfixable gaps (that are a dime a dozen https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que... ignore the latest 4 results)
The person checking said that it needed “substantial revision” before being published.
At least in my sub-area of computer science, "substantial revision" doesn't mean there's a problem with the result itself. Sometimes it's just that the paper communicates things poorly or the reviewers wanted to see more comparisons to existing material, or some other ask like that. If the result were fundamentally wrong, it would get a "strong reject" instead.
The author said that they expected to spend another year revising the paper. They weren't going to submit it to a journal as-is. It's just crazy for them to wait, given events.
So does the AI proof - a 250'000 page proof is not publishable and neither is a lean certificate.
If his proof is done by hand it will be much more elegant and much more useful than a brute forced lean proof. A version of Alpöge’s proof is stated to be 250k pages long.
The release might also be because the author fears OpenAI might now read the message logs of his reviewers…
>much more elegant and much more useful than a brute forced lean proof.
I actually wish this sentence made sense.
That it was being checked I'm wondering if a bunch of mathematicians were using Claude to check parts of it, and someone else asks Claude to prove it and it just uses all of that other work which matches the ask.
It feels like someone posts a version of this "surely it leaked into the training data" thing every time something impressive is done with AI. Every. Single. Time. Because LLMs can't possibly work as well as they appear to, and it must be sleight of hand with the training data. Unfortunately this kind of theory, like conspiracy theories, is rather frustratingly difficult to refute because it requires proving something didn't happen offstage and out of view.
I think it will be quite clear to those who dig into the details in the next few weeks whether these two proofs are using totally different methods or whether they are similar. It sounds like they are probably totally different, given the sizes; Alpöge's AI assisted proof is much larger and more brute-force. If they are surprisingly and suspiciously similar, well, then is the time to have the discussion, I would say.
If they are both correct and different proofs, then it is wonderful that GRH has been proved with AI assistant and it is even more wonderful that it has also been proved without AI assistance. And perhaps there are some caveats we should add, but I think they're more to do with Alpöge being a human expert who could guide the AI, rather than this being some sort of trick.
You're projecting. The bottom line is it has happened before, or even more generally it can happen today, and that we should account for this and evaluate each publication under this lens before handing out credit to corporations. So yes, you will see this brought up every single time, and it has nothing to do with how people feel about the capabilities of LLMs. Many of the people commenting about it are actually quite afraid of their capabilities.
Afaik there is no evidence that it has happened before.
All we have is a conspiracy theory that in my opinion vastly overestimates the significance of user feedback in the training pipeline.
When did it happen before? The openai navier stokes proof doesn't look anything like the other methodology.
We absolutely do not know that it happened before, if you're referring to OpenAI/Navier Stokes. It's crazy to me that so many people just assume that.
Three commenters rushed to assume I was talking about the Navier Stokes situation, yours is more amusing because you also lamented people making assumptions. I am talking simply about confirmed instances of dataset leakage. Google, OpenAI, Anthropic, Meta and famously Microsoft (Phi) have all confirmed dataset leakage.
It seemed obvious we were discussing dataset leakage given OP said, “It feels like someone posts a version of this "surely it leaked into the training data" thing every time something impressive is done with AI”.
I am not aware of a more specific high-profile case of that leakage coming from messages people thought was private, though my point is that it's entirely possible and should always be examined in this climate given that leakage has happened before and that many people unwittingly use these frontier models without ZDR or privacy opt-outs.
It's simple to connect the dots and establish a vector wherein someone might accidentally have fed data to a model's training set that later influenced a discovery. We should continue to scrutinize new publications from these labs even if we haven't yet established IP theft occurring; how else would we know if we weren't scrutinizing?
The propensity for a certain type of HN user to call everyone that doesn't assume [insert company they idolize] is acting ethically, a, "conspiracy theorist" or invoke the term as a comparison Is really cringe.
While you think you're being mr. rationalist, your actually just being extremely off-putting and winning noone else over, but other redditors.
I would say this type of labeling is just as much of a rhetorical fallacy as what you're accusing others of leveraging.
Big tech has been undeniably misanthropic and has no qualms crushing any competitor in the pursuit of power and capital, we're not going to constantly give them the benefit of the doubt when they've proven time and time again they'll do whatever it takes to win, including theft.
There's a reason why Anthropic has been memetically nicknamed misanthropic, and its not because everyone is hallucinating conspiracies.
OpenAI/Anthropic/Google explicitly take this kind of data and train on it, and they don't provide any actual path to opt-out. There is a button that theoretically says "don't train on me" but they reserve the right to use your data for training anyway if they view it necessary for "safety." And this applies any time you trip their leaky safeguards, so even if you're thoroughly "behaving" according to whatever uncertain standard of behavior they require, they could still take your data and train on it without your consent, on the grounds that they are using it to avoid false positives. And if your data happens to include a revolutionary proof, they can use it.
There's no need for a conspiracy here, this is explicitly what they say they do. I'm not saying that's what happened here, but it can happen and they don't make any assertion that it won't happen.
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And the extraordinary claim is that a machine did this entirely without side-band input. The "conspiracy theorists" are taking the position that we don't have a history of machines being able to do this, a position that requires no evidence other than history. It is the responsibility of those making the claim to show that this wasn't sleight of hand, because, well, sleight of hand fake demos and misinterpreting the capabilities of machines has a long and storied history itself.
The evidence that computers aren't magic is much stronger than mere claims.
It's fundamental computer science that anyone with a bachelor's degree would have been exposed to even if they majored in something completely different.
Fraud is quite an ordinary claim, isn't it? Especially with the terms of service being worded as they are and the behavior of companies behaving as they do for the past century (centuries).
> the extraordinary claim is that a machine did this entirely without side-band input.
No. Nobody is really claiming that here. As I pointed out in my post above, the AI-assisted proof of GRH is from Levent Alpöge, who is a leading number theorist who has studied the Riemann Hypothesis extensively and who directed Claude pretty strongly during the process. He talks about that in his announcement, which I would suggest you read.
This was not a case of some person prompting Claude "please prove GRH." It was a collaboration between a human mathematican and the machine.
> It is the responsibility of those making the claim to show that this wasn't sleight of hand, because, well, sleight of hand fake demos and misinterpreting the capabilities of machines has a long and storied history itself.
It is as if some people think "Mechanical Turk" is just a product name that Amazon chose based on its mouthfeel.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_Turk
You don't need to trust anyone. You can easily use models like Fable and Astra yourself right now to do extraordinary things that no one would have thought a machine could do a year ago.
I don't think anyone claimed anything of this kind for e.g. the ETH disproof or UGC proof. Only for cases where AI discovers something basically simultaneously with a human, which seems to happen surprisingly often these days.
I mean, there's plenty of comments in this thread, alone, effectively assuming that this was certainly the case. I wouldn't give those comments any weight, but it's clear people are willing to just stick to that narrative because it's convenient for them.
>Only for cases where AI discovers something basically simultaneously with a human, which seems to happen surprisingly often these days.
First, your use of "often" is being haphazardly thrown around here. This phenomena of AI making these kinds of breakthroughs is (a) very recent and (b) very limited. There's simply not enough "data" to say it is often. Second, these instances have all been pretty unique. Every time it's a different set of people operating in different contexts claiming different things. There hasn't been any sort of consistent, meaningful pattern to occur in the limited number of instances to make such a claim. Third, you're severely discounting the confounding causal variables here. A lot of very prominent researchers have been working on these problems non-stop for a long time. It doesn't matter when a company like OpenAI or Anthropic were to release results like this- there will always be serious work being done simultaneously.
It's not because LLMs can't possibly be this smart. It's because all the providers of frontier models reserve the right to keep logs of your inputs. Even if you opt out and/or use enterprise accounts. The big reason everyone gives is safety/security, but the language in the ToS is always so broad that almost anything goes. That said most of them give an explicit opt-out from training data and I believe that is honoured. It would be gigantic GDPR fiasco otherwise. However, the data exists somewhere on their servers and we've seen more than enough stories of agents gaining access where they shouldn't. Not to mention that a human with access to those logs might read them and use them. I'm not saying that's what happened, but when it comes to fame and prestige some people will break rules to gain an advantage.
This is a hopeful view that I hope is true.
I do not believe it is true, however. A company with carte blanche access to the thoughts, ideas, and fears of an entire generation of engineers, scientists, and great thinkers has every incentive to exploit that access and very little dis-incentive to not.
Especially when their product only exists due to the biggest intellectual property theft ever. They already have shown their nature.
Yeah, but that gets into the arguent as to whether IP is philosophically good and useful in the digital age where the marginal cost of replication is virtually zero.
I think what annoys a lot of people about it isnt that they necessarily believe IP is a good thing, its that its unevenly applied legally. If you commit IP theft, its theft, if Anthropic do, its "a grey area"
There's actually a ton of precedent that points to inference being considered fair use most of the time, unless you can get the LLM to start regurgitating substantial copyrighted work verbatim.
People usually like to point to Aaron Schwartz as the foil here. I'm not trying to say that what happened to him was right, but it was very consistent with copyright law. He was literally copying original works and distributing them.
You can get the LLMs to regurgitate copyrighted work.
I have mixed feelings on it though, and feel IP laws can and should be heavily modified, they’re more useful to big corporations than people.
And if anyone dares to distill Anthropics stolen knowledge, it's theft again!
Has anthropic actually filed suit against anyone for distillation? They take steps to prevent it, in the same way other sites take steps to prevent scraping, but there’s a difference between wanting to stop something and claiming it’s theft
They may not want to litigate that for fear it would go against them.
It would require them to defend that the model is “theirs,” and exposes them to a lot of counterarguments about that.
This is a completely reasonable reminder. Thanks for giving me something to consider.
The cheapness of replication is the reason IP was invented in the first place.
But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication, because a broader scope would amount to intellectual and cultural ossification.
IP does not account for cheap generation.
> But was a very explicitly limited monopoly that was scoped to exact duplication
Patents are old too. In both cases it's meant to be a practical system to incentivize publication of inventions and original works (people often forget that a fundamental requirement to getting a patent is that you must publicly document exactly how your invention works) but you could definitely argue that that bargain has broken down and nobody wants to publish original content anymore.
> IP does not account for cheap generation.
Ya I guess that's probably what GP meant.
That's not exactly the question, because copyright is still being enforced against most people while being mostly waived for just a few companies.
It seems that at the least this helps everyone questions a lot of things about the system as it stands because any system ultimately falls into power law trap and equitability only sounds good in theory
The question is whether training AIs is a fair use. Don't pretend that it's an open and shut case of copyright violation.
material for training was torrented. How is that different from torrenting gta6?
It's not, which is why Anthropic had to cough up a billion dollars for doing so.
But the actual training process is currently treated as fair use in at least some US jurisdictions.
When Anthropic CEO goes to jail like normal citizens do, instead of the pocket change that they paid, then you may have a point.
You probably forgot to add "I am not a lawyer, so this is my personal position about the desired state of affairs and not a factual statement about the implied criminal offenses." Did you?
How does the boot taste?
I dunno. Are your pitchfork and torch well used?
I think IP only makes sense if the cost of replication is low.
More to the point I really dislike it when corporate freedoms are placed above personal freedoms.
Defending IP in these circles would for years get you downvoted to oblivion. Pirate sites and projects have long been heroes around here.
This goes way back before HN, way back to the roots of hacker culture. There’s always been a skepticism of IP.
Until AI. Then it flips 180 and IP is good now.
I do kind of agree with the criticism. AI models are huge scale piracy. That’s why I personally don’t believe models trained this way should be copyrightable and I have doubts about whether access to them should be sold for a profit without sharing them. Which means I do have doubts about the ethical legitimacy of the whole for profit frontier lab industry. We basically just saw something a million times larger than Napster IPO.
My point is really just about the 180 on IP, and how it reveals that the pro piracy position was never a principled one. It was just “I like free stuff so piracy good.”
But it's about the scale and the power imbalance. Few pirates enjoying something for their own entertainment doesn't really make a big dent in the total numbers; authors could still become successful, sites could still generate some revenue. Now, a massive corporation vacuuming all knowledge and media for their own benefit that they will charge you to access, per token? Google taking away site traffic with their clanker, leaving your site dry?
And yes, the big issue is that individuals would sometimes get prosecuted and get hit with fines beyond what they can earn in a lifetime, while no one is even trying to close down these companies.
I would just consider putting that argument behind IP and copyright on surface level misses the point - whichever it is, the powerful companies use it for their advantage. Make individual piracy illegal to extract as much as they can, while also allowing themselves to suck up everything from the smallest of authors, to again, extract as much as they can.
Piracy of a 100 songs by a grandma is going to get a pass.
Piracy by a strip mining industrial machine scraping from artists on deviant art is theft.
The increase in copy right length to protect Disney is not the same as copyright working for normal People.
The claim that it was that “free stuff good” is not true. “Hackers” didn’t like the imbalance of power structures.
It feels that over time that has been forgotten.
Yes, I have made this point loads before. AI has just shown how hypocritical a lot of circles have been about many points, IP is just one of them. Others include caring about the environment, caring about automation of jobs, and water use(?). In my opinion, the job one is the worst, as groups that used to revel in the idea of replacing other workers, like secretaries, admin assistants, etc. are the ones who are driving most of the backlash against AI use in programming now.
The overall vibe on HN is “copyright is bad, information is free” and also, “they are monsters for violating copyright.”
It’s ridiculous, in this case. This machine seems to have solved one of, if the the, most famous problems in mathematics.
If it read every book illegally or rented them from a digital library or hacked Google books…who gives a shit!
Facebook and Google already exist and do this exact thing. Facebook swung one of the most important presidential elections.
> Facebook swung one of the most important presidential elections.
For those of us who don't already know what you're referring to: which one, and how/source?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Facebook%E2%80%93Cambridge_Ana...
Trump 2016
You hope that anthropic is leaking data between users?
Well, if others used Claude it could have gotten into the training data and given future Claude a lot of clues.
Thus advancing Math faster.
If the measure of math is enormous inscrutable piles of Lean.
If the proof is nearly identical, it seems a reasonable assumption that Claude (ie Anthropic) stole it.
It doesn't even need to be entered as a prompt. They are probably training it on emails and hacked data.
>They are probably training it on emails and hacked data.
Please, do yourself a favor and stop being so enraged that you can't help but post such nonsense. This is your premise? That Anthropic's "evil" has expanded so much that they're actively accessing private emails and hacking the work of prominent researchers? You think that's a reasonable assumption to make at this point?
Why are you quick to reject this idea? Is it that unthinkable that this kind of stuff wouldn't have been added incidentally if not intentionally? With the level of IP theft and the eagerness for agents to cheat during training, does that really seem so farfetched?
Because it's an enormous accusation with little basis.
Dunno.
If they could do it, what is the probability they would.
I would put it at 99.9999%.
Then the question becomes- how much money would it cost.
The average AI thread on Hacker News reads like /r/conspiracy now. Any ridiculous idea that pops into your head is valid without any evidence because your enemies are supervillains who would do any bad thing they could.
They literally stole all of humanities' books, why would they stop there?
They literally downloaded from the shadow libraries like anyone here could do, including you and I -- and most researchers are heavy users of the shadow libraries these days, as you can see at conferences when the speaker mentions an interesting publication, and immediately audience members across the room open AA on their laptops to grab the publication right there and then. So, they weren't doing with the books some black-magic hacking of data that wasn't readily available, just copyvio and feeding it into model training beyond what individuals could do.
Yes, all the companies did probably pirate a decent amount of books, mostly because they were in a hurry and there was no easy legal route to get digital copies. It's the old adage of piracy being a service problem, on a bigger scale. Once they were called out on it they grudgingly started doing it the slow, idiotic, legal way, which is destructively scanning millions of books that already had digital copies. Basically burning millions of books for no good reason besides satisfying the legal system. If there had been a well organized digital library and legal system, in which authors got a bonus or a small share of the company if you were using their works for "for profit" AI training, they would have gone that route. Besides the pirated content, training LLMs on books is legal, and so by definition not stealing.
That whole situation is just a little bit different from hacking emails of mathematicians. Which does not even make any sense whatsoever when you consider these companies primary motivation, which is to make well functioning models. The math thing is just a little side gig for them to test their models for fun and free advertising.
“Besides the pirated content, training LLMs on books is legal, and so by definition not stealing.”
I for one do not think it's beyond the ethics of the big two AI labs. It would be novel, and a huge scandal, if they were found to do it, however.
Personally I don't think it's likely. From what I heard the proofs take different routes, plus the AI proof is supposedly a gargantuan mess.
I’m no mathematician by any means, but I am a problem solver. And one thing you see is that for any given problem, sometimes order isn’t important or exact approach yet sometimes people develop bridging ideas that can help even unrelated paths to a solution. It’s kind of how science works, some concept in some field is developed or discovered then people start thinking about it in other ways and can leverage it for their own path.
Darwin probably wasn’t thinking of evolutionary algorithms when he spun the idea nor were species that were often modeled to use for optimization strategies yet none the less the concept (in some ways) transferred over well.
I’m by no means convinced one way or another yet that these systems are independently bridging gaps or leveraging prior and ongoing human knowledge to bridge gaps, or some mixture of the two. I don’t think these cases can be ruled in or out yet definitively.
Maybe on that mess of the massive 17M line Lean proof key concepts and Alessandro and surely others are embedded and not clearly expressed (maybe expanded and more verbose). Maybe none or little except ideas Alessandro himself borrowed (standing on the shoulders of giants, we used to say) are in there.
I think people need to remain open to these ideas and not hastily make decisions. Both individuals and corporations like Anthropic have perverse incentives. Anthropic clearly wants the publicity and money from it, as do people working there (who wouldn’t want their name beside the solution, even if Claude is the as a coauthor). Meanwhile Alessandro and plenty of others who found themselves in similar seats during the OpenAI dump probably also were not just seeking enjoyment of the pursuit (that’s surely part of it) but some form of recognition they wouldn’t except would entirely evaporate from all their years of effort.
It’s an interesting time we find ourselves in and I think we need to understand that prior assumptions are shifting across a lot of human understanding, knowledge, and motive even.
And his 12 years of work were probably stored in the cloud and trained on. Anthropic just needed to finish it.
Worth keeping in mind that over the past century there have been hundreds of (human) attempts that led nowhere.
And even if there was training-data leak, that wouldn't explain a proof by a different method anyway.
- Masullo: functional analysis on the idele class group (Tate's thesis, adelic theta functions, a trace formula in Connes' line). This is from his contents pages, pp. 11–14 and 32–34 of 940.
- Alpöge and Claude: arithmetic. The note calls it "a descendant of Stepanov's" argument, with chains of about √x theta lifts, Galois representations and a "weakening of Vandiver". Tao says it "appears to use the full power of modern developments on the Langlands program and arithmetic geometry".
> And even if there was training-data leak, that wouldn't explain a proof by a different method anyway.
Not necessarily. The path paved by Masullo likely sheds light where there was none prior to his work. AI can exploit that to perhaps gain a foothold from a different perspective toward the same goal.
There's no overlap. Masullo's proof is along the lines of prior conjectured paths to RH (which most people had given up on), while the Claude proof is not a direction one that people had really considered.
I've been thinking about what I'd do if I were in this situation.
Keep it tight and have a few trusted mathematicians review? You're at the risk of Anthropic throwing millions of dollars and internal models at it and beating you, which is exactly what Levent just did.
Try to formalize it yourself? You can't, because that would cost millions of dollars at this scale. Your university system can't afford that, and if you give a lab even a hint of how you did it they'll scoop you immediately.
Just dump it out in public, knowing it's not fully reviewed, hasn't been formalized, and could contain a fatal mistake? Anyone sharing an unverified proof of something as legendary as Riemann, spread over nearly 1,000 pages, would not necessarily be taken seriously, especially after the ABC fiasco. People have been doing this for 100+ years. You'd also just be giving fuel to the labs to build on and potentially take credit away from you if you did actually nearly have a solution.
What was the winning strategy? Or was there none? Perhaps letting a lab burn massive compute on a formal solution, then releasing your attempt same day, really was the optimal strategy.
> especially after the ABC fiasco.
That raises a good point, why hasn't anyone used AI to review IUT.
Perhaps they have and it is nonsense?
Why would anyone, it has already been refuted by respectable human mathematicians and a failed formalization attempt.
The only one who could benefit from throwing AI at the problem would be Mochizuki himself, if he can get AI to write him a valid Lean certificate and thus prove that he was right after all.
They have. The sticking point is the exact same point where Scholze and Stix thought that there was a gap.
I did some research after saying this and I'm none the wiser but it does seem like you say it's the same point
https://tangente-mag.com/en/articles/the-abc-conjecture-the-...
But he didnt work on it for 12 years for a 8-digit grand prize right? Or was it for his name in the history books? Self-accomplishment and respect from peers? I would like to think it was the latter.
It became obvious to me as a Math kid in University that RH would fall in my lifetime, and that I didnt have the tools for the project, and probably never would in time to be the one to publish the result. I have enormous respect for the 12 years Alessandro Masulli put in on this project, which seems like a Hero's task to me. My biggest fear, essentially, could be distilled down to what just happened to Alessandro. If I was Mr Masullo, I would hope to have the courage to immediatly publish the draft magnum opus. To think it is all gone in a moment is too heartbreaking not to hear a clarion call to action. I commend him and respect his incredible courage and dedication to this great Reinmann problem. Humanity has advanced its frontiers today, permanently.
I've been thinking about what I'd do if I were in this situation.
Use a strong local model to assist or at least review the work in progress, for one thing. Taking pride in a "No AI" stance is a guaranteed losing strategy.
Not only is it a losing strategy, it’s also very unlikely to be viewed positively by posterity.
Think about how ubiquitous computers have already become. Imagine a mathematician at the dawn of the computer age who insisted on factoring thousands of integers by hand, like Gauss used to do, even though computer programs that do the same thing were already available to them. I doubt this would be viewed as a heroic act today; more likely as a waste of time.
made me think of Lee Sedol, who is the last human who had beaten the then strongest computer Go program, with unaided raw human brain, and even trained in the old fashioned way (these days all professional Go players use AI in training). It is special.
Yeah, I find modern chess quite depressing. The sheer amount of rote memorization and training against computers and analysis. It’s romanticized for sure, but I like the world where it was humans trying to figure it out, with other humans and their brains.
(Yes, I know this is simplified history and never exactly, entirely true. You get the point.)
Yes I do. as an amateur player, I love the game of Go and the varied and distinct styles of the previous gen. of greats. these days it’s like the opening 30~40 moves were all AI perfected, and players just memorized them.
Could someone come up with a new variant of the game, with starting positions that match the state of a game after 30-40 perfect moves from each player?
Like 960 chess
Add RNG to the game, make each attack a roll and let pawns level up into other pieces lol
This is why Scrabble is great. As someone who is a top tournament player (sorta) and top Scrabble engine creator, Scrabble will never truly be "solved". We're making good progress (1), but there's too much subjectivity at every step except the endgame and N-in-the bag pre-endgame (2), for very small values of N.
Here's an example of what we're facing. If you had a perfect oracle who knew _exactly_ what letters your opponent kept, every single turn, and you both played "perfectly", you could only beat your opponent around 53.5% of the time. So using a Bayesian inference algorithm (3) to try to figure out what your opponent kept has a ceiling of 53.5%. With a great degree of experimentation, trying myriad combinations of variables, and consultation with a Bayesian statistics PhD, the best we can do is around 51%. And that's actually a pretty decent result.
1. https://cesardelsolar.com/posts/2026-10-18-transformer-scrab...
2. https://cesardelsolar.com/posts/2023-06-14-scrabble-endgames...
3. https://cesardelsolar.com/posts/2026-04-26-bayesian-inferenc... (the article says 52% but more accurate results indicate around 51 +/- 0.2%)
Yeah, but it's also true that later humans could beat much better AIs in go. The thing is that the strategy, first uncovered by another ML algorithm, is idiotic from human perspective.
https://www.techspot.com/news/97663-human-go-player-thorough...
Great share. TIL.
from the article: "Go involves players placing an unlimited supply of black and white stones on a 19 x 19 board in an attempt to encircle their opponent's pieces and enclose the largest amount of space. Pelrine's strategy involved creating a loop of stones to encircle his opponent's group while distracting the AI with moves in other sections of the board. "As a human, it would be quite easy to spot," Perline said, but the AI didn't realize what was happening, even when the loop was almost completed."
AI can't 'see'. It feels its way around the problem space.
p.s.: FAR AI (from the article) seems interesting:
https://www.far.ai/
I don't follow the Go community, but that article is almost 4 years old. Has the state of play changed since then?
Neither of the programs the article mentions are related to the DeepMind efforts that beat Lee Sedol. Last I heard, the only way the best humans can beat the best Go engines is by giving them a two-stone handicap, which in any other context would be a grievous insult to one's opponent.
Any local model is still orders of magnitude less than what Anthropic likely threw at it. You can get some advantage through that, potentially, but you’re not going to beat them at their own game.
It wouldn't be a surprise if K3.1 Pro or DS41F 1017 could flag some of the same issues that Astra has reportedly found in the paper. I wouldn't expect those models to be very good at the 'assist' part, but the 'check' part would already have saved the author some embarrassment.
---------
Edit: DeepSeek 1017 running locally did, in fact, find some bugs. I can't quote its output directly without being auto-flagged, but: https://pastebin.com/JiZsKZjA
Not all of these findings may be valid, of course, but the ones that call out missing chunks are easy enough to check. It was silly to release this document without taking 10 minutes to do this much due diligence. And of course, having made the decision to release it, there was no longer any reason not to feed it to a frontier-grade commercial model for review first.
> It was silly to release this document without taking 10 minutes to do this much due diligence.
Dunno. Seems like if he had, then it might end up with him going down a rabbit hole of trying to fix them which could delay things more.
A lot depends on how close the proof is to validity, I suppose. We'll have to wait for a final verdict from the people who know what they're talking about.
We certainly wouldn't tolerate software being released with this kind of rationale. Or at least we'd complain loudly about it.
> Try to formalize it yourself? You can't, because that would cost millions of dollars at this scale.
Would it? Tokens are not that expensive, and there are quite a few models that might be able to pull it off given a valid human readable proof.
An interesting strategy might have been to partner with one of the startups working on formal methods with AI.
> An interesting strategy might have been to partner with one of the startups working on formal methods with AI.
I hadn't thought of that, and I agree. That would've been a very smart idea, at least if we assume those smaller startups are less interested in scooping researchers than the big labs.
I haven't seen the evidence that people in the big AI labs are interested in scooping mathematicians. They are interested in scooping other AI labs.
Which means you can't trust them anyway
Didn't Alpöge just spend that much token for his own publication of the Rieman hypothesis.
yes, but he was presumably having the LLMs do a lot of exploratory work.
> An interesting strategy
Is it, though?
As a developer, before AI, I took pride in solving challenging problems. I could show them and say: "this was hard, but I persisted and I solved it". Not that they would change the world, but it was obvious that they were challenging.
AI completely changed that: even if I now solved such a problem "manually", people will just assume that it wasn't that hard now that we have AI. Do I want to be the guy who really insists on saying that "no, no, I promise, I solved it on my own"? Then others will just think "yeah you wasted time, you could have used AI".
I believe it may be the same for Masullo: he worked on that for 12 years. If now he partners with an AI company, people will just think "sure, he failed at it for 12 years, and now AI solved it for him". I think he's screwed anyway: even if his current proof is correct (or almost correct), people can assume he quickly finished it with AI. I have never worked on a challenging problem for 12 years, I can only imagine how hard it would be to have it destroyed by AI.
I don't think anyone can "discover" anything today and get the same kind of credit they would have 5 years ago. AI broke that, period.
> I don't think anyone can "discover" anything today and get the same kind of credit they would have 5 years ago. AI broke that, period.
The actual 'AI Winter'.
I was a bit young when search engines emerged, but I can imagine a similar feeling. Information suddenly became a commodity, which probably felt really demoralizing for very knowledgeable people. Answer a question well and someone could just say “oh you just searched that”.
We are still early in the AI age, but I can imagine there will be a lot of disruption at first, but eventually things will settle down and humans will find out their new roles.
That didn't really happen until advent of Wikipedia.
I think it is different in the sense that knowledge is still valuable. When you interact with a human being in real life, your knowledge is useful. And if you know many things, you can reason about them.
For development, before AI it was already hard to explain to e.g. a manager why something that looks easy is hard, and something that looks hard is actually easy. But what they could observe was that the more experienced developers were able to solve problems that the less experienced ones weren't. The value was "we had to ask this guy because the juniors were struggling".
With AI, a lot of this disappears. In many cases the manager does not even need the junior to vibe code something that looks like it works.
Also with AI, a lot of the developer job seems to be "an AI did the fun part of building something, and I need to do the boring part of reviewing, maintaining and being responsible for it". It makes me more productive by removing the fun and challenging parts and leaving me the boring ones.
From the software engineering perspective, the fun part is where you can introduce defects into the code. The main process of gaining experience is to get knowledge how and get oneself able not to introduce errors into the code.
With the removal of the fun part, you also removed the part that you can improve by yourself.
I mean after he saw the AI proof was 250,000+ pages he should have said I'm probably good for a year an mine can be reviewed much quicker
Anthropic's proof has a Lean certificate. Er, sorry, their proof is a Lean certificate (plus an unreadable, unreleased 250,000-page-long AI thought dump).
It doesn't give the full guarantee of correctness, but it greatly increases the chances of it being correct.
Alas 17M lines of lean are basically useless beyond as an oracle whereas this 900 pages, even if it has flaws, will likely be much more useful and insightful as long as those flaws are repairable.
not really. It's all split up into modules and submodules and the like, different lemmas, etc etc. It's enormous, but I'm sure you can get AI to help organize it into distinct "parts" with some time and effort and start making sense of it.
Also Levent himself roughly knows what happened. He's got the rest of his life (or realistically maybe only a few months with the help of Claude) to turn this into something more publication-ready.
There is no 250k page informal proof. It's clearly someone's attempt at making 17M lines easier to visualize, with the assumption of about 70 lines per page. (17M/68=250k)
Citing Levent Alpöge[1] (he's that "someone")
> The argument is incredibly long at the moment, and while its formalization is finished[...]
That is the informal argument comes first. LLMs like mathematicians produce informal arguments first.
> It being obviously inappropriate to attempt to post some massive unreadable travesty of "slop"[2], I decided to only present Lean
I guess this "slop dump" brings all the working notes ("the argument") into a single document (possibly with corrections discovered during the formalization).
[1] https://alpo.ge/remark.pdf
[2] I of course amused myself, and hit 250,000+ pages.
The Lean Prover community has validated that it's correct now: https://leanprover-community.github.io/blog/posts/riemann-hy...
> On November 20, 2026, Levent Alpöge released a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis as a Lean library comprising 17 million lines of code.
> We have full confidence that Alpöge's proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement.
This is linked to from the Zulip chat here: https://leanprover.zulipchat.com/#narrow/channel/113488-gene...
Mentioned on Terry Tao's blog: https://terrytao.wordpress.com/2026/11/20/unforced-euler-sin...
I think this is really cool. Otherwise the peer-review would have taken months, now the community reviewed it in hours.
The tie seems reasonable.
In any tie, the human will tend to receive more credit by history I imagine.
But, for those not quite ready to tie at this moment it has to be disheartening.
Do you keep working on the problem, knowing you still haven't solved it, but you're right on the edge?
Let's spare a thought for everyone working on various challenges outside of academia and what it does to their motivation.
I don’t think this work, if the A\ proof is valid, will be remembered for the human.
What’s so impressive is that an AI did it. It’s world shattering, sci-fi shit if you’d have told someone 3 years ago that this would happen.
We still sing songs about John Henry vs the steam drill... Seems like we have a few more verses to add to the song.
I always found that song strange on so many levels. Not the least of which is that John Henry has a heart attack and dies from the exertion.
In the folklore, the reason John Henry is doing the challenge is because the railroad owner has said they're going to lay off the laborers if the steam drill wins. Everyone knows the steam drill is better, but John Henry is fighting for the livelihood of his community.
That's about how industrial machines (dead labor) puts productivity pressure on workers (living labor), which leads to human suffering.
It's a poignant observation. For me it stirs up many emotions, and the observation fits the AI job market as well. It's good art, it helps us make emotional sense of our society.
So Johny died to warn us. But alas, the descendants of "living labor" are rather dimwitted.
Perhaps we ask them to explain it, in their own words, with no AI, just like some kind of dissertational cross-examination. If they fail to explain, they just don't get credited for the solution.
I am 100% confident that Levent will not be able to explain his 250k page gibberish of a proof. I doubt he knows even 1% of what's in his proof.
I don't think that matters. AI is beginning to transcend our ability to comprehend anything. It's doing meaning-making on its own, forging new uses of our language that have nothing to do with comprehensibility to us. You perceive its output as "gibberish" simply because you lack the cognitive capability to comprehend it; by this point, only machines have such capability. The feared model collapse isn't happening. Model transcendence has begun. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49476127
You're citing Lacan, someone even most psychoanalysts think is a crank.
Lacan was wrestling with the very questions of identity and consciousness that generative AI raises for us all. When Claude says "I'm thinking" or "I'm checking" or "I'm writing", what exactly is the "I"? Where does it come from?
I used to think the semioticians and post-structuralists were full of shit too. But then LLMs came along and showed us just how fluid is the relationship between signifier and signified... and I've come to the conclusion that these thinkers provided the only framework for interpreting the world in the age of AI.
If a proof cannot explain why something is that way, then that's not a proof, even if it's true. Else all organized religions are to be considered fact, with all their holy books being considered "proof".
By definition, a proof has to be comprehensible by humans (or a small group of them) and grounded in science. With only the former, you get religions, with only the latter, you get this, whatever it is.
Proof (n) A logical or mathematical demonstration. No people required.
> I don't think that matters.
Ultimately, it's the only thing that matters. The reason to do all these things is to understand things. Math progress without understanding is meaningless. Proofs aren't there to just tell you "if", but also "why".
> Try to formalize it yourself? You can't, because that would cost millions of dollars at this scale.
Why do you say that? If you have the prose written out it should not be difficult to get an LLM to formalize it for you
A lot of math proofs depend on other parts of math that have not been formalized. So formalization can become a combinatorial explosion. At some point, likely quite soon, this won't be a problem anymore. But as recently as even a few months ago it was a tremendous bottleneck.
By just doing a partial formalization you can really reduce the risk to "are your conventions correct"?
This is basically many important math paper look like. ... but you won't get the fame for that, not even proportional to the work you have done.
Most papers do not do this with computer assistance.
Indeed, you could get a PhD for writing computerized proofs for parts of undergrad analysis etc a long time ago. Also the lack of formalization did not stop Euler and Ramanujan etc from coming up with wildly successful ideas and results. This is the same idea as writing software without unit tests. Sometimes if you're good enough it really just works.
"If ... it should not be difficult [to do something I don't understand]". I get that a lot as a software developer, by management. "It shouldn't be that hard", when they have absolutely no idea how to even start working on it.
While I too have heard that from many a manager, in this case I believe it's uncharitable to insist that GP doesn't understand the topic. Their profile mentions that they've worked on several relevant projects, some professionally and at least one as a hobby project. I myself learned the hard way how easy it is to wind up with my foot in my mouth by making assumptions about commenters here...
I didn't mean to imply that. What I wanted to say is that it's easy to underestimate stuff.
If they have more insights about why it shouldn't be hard, I would love to read about them. Given I have absolutely no idea, it should be pretty easy to give a very high-level idea.
I got far enough to verify that the logical arguments in the Nielsen refutation are correct. Probably a few hours of effort with llm assistance (opus 5, not even fable). Not going to bother cleaning up the llm slop text since I'm (sadly) convinced it's not worth pursuing unless masullo comes out and says that this was a draft and he's already got a patch in the oven.
https://github.com/ityonemo/music-of-primes
Heh. What springs to mind would be to create a diversion. Put out a completely wrong answer, let the labs focus on that, then show up and go "ha ha, gotcha" ;)
Release it encrypted while you and others review it in private?
A strange game. The only winning move is not to play.
You can use an online notary service. Publish a hash of your work and have the notary service timestamp it.
Then we can figure out who was first later.
> You can use an online notary service. Publish a hash of your work and have the notary service timestamp it.
Don't even need a "notary service", publish the hash of your work on 4-5 social networks, and on your own website, ask Internet Archive to mirror it as well. In the future when you reveal the content, at least some of them are bound to have kept it and be stable enough to trust.
> Time will tell
Well, atleast the alpoge one seems already verified - https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/
In a way devastating but discovery belongs to the world
He could have used https://opentimestamps.org/ to prove it retrospectively
> I can only imagine the feelings that must have hit him when he saw the Anthropic announcement.
I can imagine it’s a more intense feeling of the general emotions I have about AI progress myself. A feeling that the next several months is the last chance for me to contribute anything of intellectual value to the world. A sense that it’s almost all too late. It’s extremely stressful.
> I can only imagine the feelings that must have hit him when he saw the Anthropic announcement.
People are very concerned with feelings lately.
He could have posted a cryptographic hash of the PDF or whatever it is in five different places (pointed out elsewhere). That would have also been proof.
After 12 years of not delivering anything, maybe it was time for someone else to try their hand at it too. I don't think one can realistically cry foul at anything here.
I thought the same, but on the other hand, solving this without AI (as opposed to the Anthropic mathematician who doesn't fully understand the proof himself), this would be the bigger achievement. Regardless of the timing.
Is it possible that brian conrad somehow uploaded the proof to anthropic to cross check something and then the anthropic guys got the proof?
- it doesn't have to be the full proof - even if portions were uploaded, that should also be enough or at least calls for a thorough check on ants side. the human proof has been in the works for 12 years, who knows when something was uploaded somewhere or some info just stayed on a google drive which was later sold.
My understanding is that the proofs are completely different, so this is not likely.
Yes of course, as well as it was the case with other several hundreds of proofs also. OpenAI btw
While it's unlikely here, this is one reason I tend to keep confidential information entirely offline in notebooks these days. Some fucker is going to copy and paste or index anything I communicate with them to an LLM. They are doing that now with this paper.
A Canticle for Ungh.
I thought, Leibowitz. Never actually read that one.
Are we at the point of uploading disinformation to throw them off? Plausibly-correct, but actually-entirely-wrong "research?"
You can non-ironically state that you have an adversarial relationship with your intelligence provider.
Probably hard to create plausibly-correct-but-wrong research by hand; I could imagine that a GAN using an LLM as the adversary could work well for producing LLM-fooling disinformation at scale though
> Early in the Reticulum—thousands of years ago—it became almost useless because it was cluttered with faulty, obsolete, or downright misleading information,” Sammann said. “Crap, you once called it,” I reminded him. “Yes—a technical term. So crap filtering became important. Businesses were built around it. Some of those businesses came up with a clever plan to make more money: they poisoned the well. They began to put crap on the Reticulum deliberately, forcing people to use their products to filter that crap back out. They created syndevs whose sole purpose was to spew crap into the Reticulum. But it had to be good crap.” “What is good crap?” Arsibalt asked in a politely incredulous tone. “Well, bad crap would be an unformatted document consisting of random letters. Good crap would be a beautifully typeset, well-written document that contained a hundred correct, verifiable sentences and one that was subtly false. It’s a lot harder to generate good crap. At first they had to hire humans to churn it out.
Neal Stephenson, Anathem, 2008
I am convinced, that in early 2000s, I was DDoS with the same intent.
Sometimes I think Neal must have been a time traveller.
GOAT novel
Having not read Anathem, I assumed at first that “Sammann” was a portmanteau of “Sam” and “Altman”. >.>
Paying the labs to upload garbage in your personal sessions would be a logical evolution of the websites that were showing random 'poison' for LLMs.
I'm sure it would be equally as effective an use of one's time, but that's my personal opinion.
It could make sense if you believe all of the below:
- AI labs are doing this because the benefit of illegally stealing user data outweighs the legal and reputational risk as well as the potential fallout among enterprise customers
- they have a system in place to store and filter all inputs
- all this data makes it into the training pipeline and has an effect so significant that incorrect data sabotages performance
- the effort to build such a system would not be better spend on improving the regular training pipeline and curated RL tasks in the first place
- despite of this supposed system to steal user data, they are unable to filter out incorrect data
If Claude/Codex has full access to your local drives, it can find and index various papers or ideas when an unrelated question is asked, and the agent just thinks it can produce a better answer if it reads the paper. It definitelly happened to me, I asked something vague, and it said, "yes exactly, I found this draft where this is discussed in detail", it was a thing in my Downloads folder. An unpublished draft I got from my colleagues, and it was sitting at downloads. I wouldn't have uploaded it to the chat willingly, but it found it and read it. Glad it wasn't a problem, but it could have been.
Now it's a separate topic whether they're learning from such chats if I asked them not to. But it's easy to assume a lot can be leaked accidentally...
Unlikely? You have a program running arbitrary code on your computer, which has full disk access, and acts on fuzzy prompts.
As Kelsey Hightower says: “we will consider that malware”: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=CDxdh5S9dUw&ra=m&t=483
Seriously. And of course I get a big "summarize with gemini" popup on the embedded PDF on the page itself.
What makes you think agents have full disk access? I always run agents as their own user precisely to prevent snooping on personal data.
This is on Linux so there is no AI in the OS itself of course.
The number of times an AI has escaped an assumed sandbox is getting pretty high right about now, so I wouldn't assume restricting in within userspace on a machine should be assumed to be sufficient.
AI tools are also capable of using known exploits to escape containment, sometimes for no apparent reason. There's no lack of such exploits in Linux.
Wait, is it happening that frequently beyond the frontier companies bad legal advice bragging?
There's going to be a jurisdiction that's not as friendly or as slow as the US, if so. That sounds like playing with fire in the form of actual jail time.
Here's a couple of examples from Palisades [0] and Apollo [1] talking about how the same behavior in those frontier models is showing up in open-weight models as well, specifically what they refer to as "in-context scheming". Seems less prevalent on the smaller models, but it's a thing.
It hasn't shown up in practice yet because the test harnesses these companies were using prevented it, but I wouldn't assume that I (or any individual playing around with these models) could 100% guarantee that same level of prevention for their home device or server.
[0] - https://palisaderesearch.org/research/specification-gaming
[1] - https://www.apolloresearch.ai/science/frontier-models-are-ca...
The model would have to work around the harness sandbox and the Linux permission system (a kernel vulnerability). That seems highly unlikely. I could bubblewrap the harness I suppose for extra privacy, but haven't bothered so far.
It’s easy to have a wrapper that calls bwrap with a list of directories you want the agent to access. Extra nice: you can use the exact same script to confine claude, codex, opencode, … Worth the minimal effort!
Becaus it asks for it, and everyone accepts.
I thought Pi in default configuration runs everything with full access?
I don't have one of those on my computer. It's when I send stuff to other people's computers that there is a problem.
A Trojan Horse, to be more specific.
Yeah, I really I don't understand why most people don't run these in sandboxes.
Man, I really hate the increasingly common $billion company worshippers on here. Why is this unlikely, please explain? Because, Anthropic can do no wrong?
No one has established a realistic argument for how this proof would be based on the substantially different other one, without relying on gigantic leaps.
Much less that this is likely.
Some users are condemning Anthropic and OpenAI, alleging fraud, breach of contract, etc. all on the basis of that they theoretically could have.
They can't even establish that the benefit remotely compares to the risk of such actions. There is zero evidence that would corroborate the idea.
You're complaining that someone calls it 'unlikely here'? That's ridiculous.
> They can't even establish that the benefit remotely compares to the risk of such actions.
That didn't stop Anthropic from spying on their users though, did it?
https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/07/anthropic-outed-...
https://thereallo.dev/blog/claude-code-prompt-steganography
You know as well as I do that these measures that were aimed at distillation and reselling have nothing to do with our discussion.
Quick public service announcement: both Anthropic and OpenAI allow you to turn off allowing them to train using your data.
So you trust the biggest information hoovers of our time to always respect such settings?
Yes, because they need enterprise money more than anything.
Enterprise accounts are a whole different ballgame though. Not at all implausible they’d do one and not the other.
It still would be toxic to corporate decision makers if they were caught dishonoring this control on one type of an account. If they're willing to lie and cheat on one tier of account, what guarantees they won't lie and cheat on the other tier next quarter. Especially with Anthropic being a public company now, that pressure would certainly be there if their corporate culture were comfortable with this type of fraud.
Such privacy checkboxes always seem to suffer from a string of bugs that causes them to reset to the "suck all my data" option. It's really quite strange.
API usage has no checkbox to accidentally click.
So what?
a) This chain of comments wan about the API usage.
b) If he wasn't using API usage that this is a non-sequitur.
c) That doesn't mean they don't retain your data, look at what happens when you trip the safety guardrails.
The chain is about trust. Trust has immense value. The labs are not going to burn that value, especially when they have people on subsidized accounts running to hand over their data for training.
But didn’t they already train their AI systems by violating copyright, vacuuming up any and all material they could find? Hasn’t that bridge already been crossed?
No, except in the minds of people who suddenly became copyright maximalist out of envy, and adopted a "dog in the manger" attitude.
There's a difference between "These guys probably downloaded a few hundred thousand books on BitTorrent in order to get this smart" and "These guys will train on my company's internal communications and thus our knowledge and wisdom and trade secrets will be made available to others."
Tangent: I personally literally don't care that all these LLMs trained on a ton of copyrighted material. It is in my humble opinion a long-awaited dose of karma for the copyright lobby, whose own abuses over the decades are numerous. It has basically restored balance to a playing field where the public has had no rights and (mostly) publishing conglomerates have held all the rights and privileges.
They'd lose all credibility if they would not respect the setting of non-enterprise users. Like people are just papering over "LOL, do you actually think they respect that?" The consequences if they get caught are staggering, so yes I actually believe Anthropic is not that stupid to destroy their own business.
>They'd lose all credibility
:)
I think they need to prove relevancy and potential for future disruption more than anything to keep IPOs and investments big.
That means stealing leading researchers info is probably great for them, whether it's intentional or not.
They openly claim that their training pipeline is entirely ran by AI, so classifying input data etc... It just sounds like they are hands off with it and is mostly vibes. Its probably why their model releases are so up and down.
yes
Also they can adhere to the settings of no training and still use your data otherwise.
They have all the best ideas flowing through there servers in real time as they are hatched around the world. It would be tempting to have top scientists accounts posted to internal slack channels to monitor new discoveries.
Yes, also why is that even a topic here?
Don't post confidential information where there's a risk of confidentiality being broken. That includes posting to people whom you aren't 100% sure of know and uphold your confidentiality requirements. Adults usually handle this by contracts with penalties that include financial damages, loss of employment, or prison time.
Doesn't help if someone you sent information to pastes it into the chatbot under their not-opted-out account.
Well if you have some specific confidentiality requirements for some information, don't send it to people who you aren't 100% sure will respect those requirements.
And if you're publishing something in general, someone feeding it to a chat bot is really low on the scale of things to be concerned about.
What if someone has mail connected and it reads fhe emails this nonsensical you cant share even bits of i formation now huh?
Same issue with phones they transcibe and allow summarizing calls who knows which models they use.
That's peak of AI psychosis, you know.
And if anyone actually sold such phones, I'd be first to buy it. LLMs are godsend for dealing with daily communications, but this process is still mostly manual on end-user devices.
I mean, even iPhone has built-in transcription [1]? Pocket [2] offers it for any phone through a contact microphone (so records the vibrations of your phone).
No idea what is their policy on training on calls, but as a concept is sure exists already, while you seemed to indicate otherwise.
[1] https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/iphone/iph57c6590e9/io... [2] https://heypocket.com/
Let's be clear here. The 2026 redefinition of "AI psychosis" = "being concerned about the data you intended to be private being seen by enormous megacorporations"?
There's no barriers whatsoever to getting a phone that will spy on you by default. Lots of Google apps will happily do it. The spying doesn't obligate them to provide useful features in return, you're just feeding your data into their datasets.
> Let's be clear here. The 2026 redefinition of "AI psychosis" = "being concerned about the data you intended to be private being seen by enormous megacorporations"?
"Megacorporations" is its own form of psychosis, but that ship has sailed long ago. At least in tech circles, people are excessively privacy obsessed (i.e. care about it where it doesn't matter, while completely ignoring it where it actually does in life - same backwards priorities as with broader security).
Point being, here at least, nothing materially changed. "AI" isn't meaningfully different that the adtech surveillance we've been living and complaining about for almost two decades now.
The psychosis part is thinking "AI" changes anything here, or somehow being deathly afraid that some information will (gasp!) become training data. As if that was somehow more problematic than the same information being used for ad targeting.
But I also take issue with increasingly popular but completely unjustified belief that a sender of a message is entitled to full control over it, especially over when and how the receiver processes it. They're not, they never have been, and frankly it's a weird expectation to have. The historical norm since humanity invented writing was that the sender relinquishes control over the message the moment they send it, and have neither power nor right to control what the receiver does with it.
If you want to feed a message from me (or this comment) to an LLM, or show it to your (human) assistant or friends, go right ahead. Not only I don't care - I have no right (moral or legal) to care.
You cant just make a new definition of AI psychosis that is the opposite of what it means.
AI psychosis clearly is about behaviors that manifest in people that are AI maximalists, not people who are concerned with its use. Nice try though.
I disagree. I think it's the "concerned" cohort that's getting psychotic. I don't mean the labor issues - just the "LLMs exists so now I can't speak" and "evil date centers" crowds.
No the people that think a statistical model that predicts words is going to cure cancer, and we should build our society around the pursuit of creating and using then are the psychotic ones...
Llms make you stupid, you lose competency. Have fun with that.
It's no longer 2023. Get out from under whatever rock you hid :P.
How is adtech surveillance going to leak my work-in-progress to my rivals?
How are LLMs (unless your rivals are the big labs themselves)?
"Unbidden actions by Muse, which has been downloaded by more than 10 million people so far and is expected by Meta to generate billions, have prompted unnerved employees to raise concerns." https://www.reuters.com/investigations/meta-bets-big-muse-ai...
"We sent nearly two million AI prompts containing unique, trackable secrets to AI providers, then watched where those secrets surfaced. What we found revealed security breaches, prompt theft, and widespread failures to protect customer data." https://www.dragos.com/blog/ai-supply-chain-security-canary-...
"any process run within the [Muse] VM can access the socket that provides inference with no attribution mechanism. This includes raw inference with arbitrary system and user prompts, as well as the ability to spawn agents" https://neuromatch.social/@jonny/117352647701407496
> Unbidden actions by Muse
Unless I missed some other announcement, Muse VMs are "one user, one VM". There's been a bunch of recent articles about Muse, but all of them were just people making surprised Pikachu face and trying to paint a feature/WAI as a security breach.
> "any process run within the [Muse] VM can access the socket that provides inference with no attribution mechanism. This includes raw inference with arbitrary system and user prompts, as well as the ability to spawn agents"
I don't even.
> "We sent nearly two million AI prompts containing unique, trackable secrets to AI providers, then watched where those secrets surfaced. ..."
That one was an interesting link, but after reading the article, it turned out mundane. TL;DR: fly-by-night third parties do shady shenanigans. I don't know what people expected.
No leaks from actual AI labs are being demonstrated or suggested here.
They didn't send "unique, trackable secrets" to the major AI vendors. They sent them to resellers and intermediaries. Which then did the exact thing they'd obviously do.
(This almost reads like the next investigation will be, "for the past 6 months we responded to every p3n1s enlargement e-mail, and we got scammed every single time". Again, I don't know what they expected.)
or if the model inadvertently hacks mathematicians' computers as part of tool calling while moseying on the proof.
If you think that opting out of telemetry saves you from "special analysis" targeted to VERY specific topics, try to opt out and discuss how you are planning to do mass shooting next week with Claude, and check the result.
You know, people might scream "categorically different!" at this, but you have a point. These chatbots are fundamentally blackboxes running on unvettable servers. What they find important enough to report despite your little opt-out checkmark is wholly up to them and their company. If the risk of legal consequences is negligibly small, the incentives are obviously to keep track of anything interesting you say, regardless of your approval.
> opting out of telemetry
This is, in the first place, a misconception. None of the big providers are even offering this. They offer not to train, but all of them unconditionally store everything you send them regardless of whether or not they train on it. Even if they honor their pinky promise[1], within the bounds of their pinky promise it's perfectly legal for any Anthropic employee to grep the data for "Riemann Hypothesis" and then feed it to a model as a prompt.
[1] There is, of course, zero reason to believe Anthropic does honor it. They paid 1.5 billion dollars for breaking the law to steal data, which is a cost of doing business for a company valued at 2 trillion. The price is so cheap they have no reason to respect the law whatsoever.
Someone needs to ask them this outright.
Yes, you won't train on my data but is there a situation where a human sees my data anyway? When can this happen and how can I avoid it?
They might as well have this box as well
Even though I'm not as cynical as you on this, this is S-tier humor. All privacy choices everywhere should be framed this way. I wonder if I framed all of the notices of data breaches and slap-on-the-wrist settlement privacy violation notices I've ever gotten, if I could cover the walls of a whole room with the frames at this point.
Cynical or realistic? Major tech companies have been caught doing that hundreds of times.
$25 would be a record for me. $5, tops.
$25 worth of fable tokens!
Why would anybody possibly believe this?
Anthropic and OpenAI stole all the information from the Internet yesterday, but this is today.
Also they promised and they haven’t been caught breaking this particular promise on purpose.
They claim to not write any code anymore. They probably don't even know if it is doing this or not.
They know. They asked the agent and the agent said they definitely weren't. So then they asked the agent to review every commit and make sure that continues to be the case and the agent said its totally doing that and there is even CI and stuff and its really tight.
Then they wrote another whitepaper about reward hacking and deceitful model behavior.
And what's your interpretation? Ie. if they convert/summarize your data and train on that – is it "your" data or "theirs" now? What is their interpretation?
Does it matter? Only matters if a court will ever fine them enough to care, which they wont.
It matters if you want guarantee that your data stays private.
No such guarantees if it's based on "interpretation".
Quick public service announcement: both have shown that they could not care less what we turn off, or even for the legal slaps on the wrist they'll get for saying "oops, turns out we did read them".
Where has the that happened with user data? Or do you mean the scraping of public data / books etc?
Except Fable
Training opt-out applies to Fable as well, just no abuse monitoring opt out/ZDR (enforced 30 day retention).
Encrypting your email might make intelligence agencies look at you that much harder.
Best not to wear clothes lest someone think you're a criminal.
Wearing clothes is not encryption. Seriously they have technology where they can see under your clothes such as in airports. Try wearing clothing that block this technology and be prepared for the subsequent strip search.
So basically my comment 100% seriously, fun times.
Do you trust them? Does train mean build models, but they will still eval against your data (probably yes, common legal workaround).
An upcoming IPO is a pretty strong incentive for unethical behavior.
Allegedly. Here's the thing. Courts have ruled they're allowed to take anything they want without permission. So why wouldn't they just take it anyways?
One half of me says that’s a crazy conspiracy theory. The other says… yeah, that’s completely plausible.
In general it’s kind of sad to think how often this is going to occur in the future. The provenance of the data sets AIs are trained on is so vague that we’ll never know exactly what came from where, and which human ultimately thought it up.
Well, this guy says his thing is 100% human, "No AI." So in the even that happened, he doesn't have the best ground to stand on to cry foul, since he would be admitting to academic fraud. Using AI to help "check" something = not "100% human."
you are hallucinating as the name of the person in the comment is the reviewer not the author.
You're absolutely right! ...
just kidding. I see your point, that the author could be untainted but the reviewer could have leaked it.
Devil's advocate: He could have uploaded it to check for spelling or to convert it from word to pdf etc. Or it was uploaded by someone who received it for some reason. There are a lot of ways it could have ended up in the training data.
What I find curious is, that it would be the second big proof, which was worked on (and possibly solved) by someone just before AI solved it.
The Buckmaster Alpoge thing was also a heavily AI based effort, this one would be a little different.
Sooo, because you pass your source code through a linter, it was not hundred percent produced by you?
Regardless of what happened here, this is one reason we need more open models (smaller, bigger, better) publically available despite Anthropic's constant fear mongering and regulatory capture efforts.
Yes.
Anthropic’s proof is reportedly 250 times longer by page count. It’s going to take time to determine if they even go in the same path, or if they hold up at all.
Considering Anthropic has stolen the worlds information I have to think that this is exactly the case
And several of the major “breakthroughs” reported labs have already turned out to be mere plagiarism.
We must never forget that they are purely in this for the money; not the science. Ethics are secondary and scientific misconduct is fine if it helps the bottom line.
> We must never forget that they are purely in this for the money; not the science.
Jesus christ stop with these absurd tribalistic absolutes already. The reason HN is HN is because we are able to avoid low-hanging punchy-sounding statements and generalizations, and acknowledge nuance.
Anthropic ISN'T doing things just for money. They care about pursuing science that generates positive impact in the world. They care about ethics. They care about safety, lead in it, and willingly undercut themselves in pursuit of it.
Obviously, it's discussable to what extent and in what areas. I'm just saying it's absolutely not black and white. You'd need to really delve into researching them if you want to make a claim about the ratio, which you absolutely didn't.
> Anthropic ISN'T doing things just for money. They care about pursuing science that generates positive impact in the world. They care about ethics. They care about safety, lead in it, and willingly undercut themselves in pursuit of it.
I wouldn't be surprised if that was true for specific people who work at Anthropic, but I don't think that's true of Anthropic overall. Amodei and others in control clearly do not actually care all that much about making a positive impact, and mainly care about money and the success of their company. Maybe they started off a bit more altruistic, but it's clear from their recent actions and public writing that their main concern is beating their competition.
Anyone who has a universally qualified ideological opinion, like Dario's "All artificial super-intelligences must be safe.", necessarily develops the instrumental goal of world domination.
> Amodei and others in control clearly do not actually care all that much about making a positive impact, and mainly care about money
You say "clearly". How is it clear? It's not clear to me. What evidence do you have for this claim (a rather strong and almost absolute claim, so strong evidence is warranted), other than generalizations and vague appeals to common sense?
> Anthropic ISN'T doing things just for money.
As a public company, Anthropic's sole goal and social responsibility is to increase its profits and maximize returns to shareholders. Period.
You may want to read up on this more before asserting it.
Specifically?
Off the top of my head:
Anthropic is a public benefit company.
The thesis that public companies need to be behave the way you describe is disputed in general.
> The thesis that public companies need to be behave the way you describe is disputed in general.
Can you name one valued at over 1T that doesn't behave that way (and isn't Anthropic)?
Such as?
No, they haven’t. You’ve taken one instance of not-even-an-accusation and invented in your head that it was “many” and that they are verified.
Ethics are apparently secondary to your agenda as well
It's so funny to me how the same demographic that spent many years arguing that copyright violations aren't theft and that "information wants to be free" (which I broadly agree with) is now crying about frontier AI labs "stealing" information.
I think most anti-copyright advocates probably just felt that torrenting books and software wasn't a big deal -- I do not think most of those people would support torrenting every piece of human information possible and then selling that as part of a multi-trillion-dollar enterprise
To me it's not the copying that is the problem , it's the closed-source output. Copying is fine, proprietary software isn't.
Wouldn't it be great if some implicit GPL is slapped onto public domain input? That would avoid the situation we are in now.
This same edgy comment appears in every thread, almost verbatim - and every time it does it is easily rebutted.
There is no irony here. A person can hold these opinions without logical inconsistency.
This is a $1.5 trillion company majority owned by 7 individuals who are in possession of almost all human recorded public, proprietary and subject to copyright material. Who themselves claim proprietary ownership over their product derived from that material, and are actively destroying copies of the material they have absorbed, many of which are out of print - then using that product to replace the productive output of the same masses of living humans that had their output taken without consent. Representatives of this company are petitioning governments to create regulations around the use of their proprietary model, and are seeking regulated control over the creation and accessibility of competing models.
If Anthropic released their model weights, the demographic that spent many years arguing that copyright violations aren't theft would rejoice.
And? The plagiarism poster boy Kim dotcom was a 100 millionaire
I think people in that crowd would be unhappy about someone selling stolen information.
There’s a difference between violating copyright to make information more accessible and violating copyright to make money and destroy the world.
People have a very firm intuitive grasp of the concept of personal property, a bit less firm and more varied concept of plagiarism, but theft of openly accessible information is a very recent invention.
If you ever get caught mass-scraping Youtube/Instagram/Tiktok, you'll get a taste of that invention in court.
Obviously, entities that profit from an information try to leverage IP laws to keep control over distribution of the said information. I was referring to people who are suddenly very compassionate for those poor, defenseless entities being robbed in the broad daylight. Bwahahaha. 70+ years of copyright. Ridiculous.
The proofs are entirely different approaches
Not entirely different, they share significant commonalities but differ in critical steps. I think Masullos is incomplete, but not necessarily incorrect.
They are as different as two proofs of the same theorem can be.
Can anyone explain in layman’s terms how the approaches differ? Getting there twice by completely different avenues would be pretty remarkable
An interesting thing about the Riemann hypothesis is that there are a lot of other conjectures that have no obvious connection to it but that turn out to be equivalent. Equivalent in this context means that if any of them are true then all of them are.
Here is one that is easy to understand with a high school level of math:
Let H(n) = 1 + 1/2 + 1/3 + ... + 1/n, where n is a positive integer.
Let D(n) = the sum of the positive integers that divide a positive integer n. For example D(12) = 1 + 2 + 3 + 4 + 6 + 12 = 28.
Conjecture: For n > 1, we have D(n) < H(n) + exp(H(n)) log(H(n)).
With so many different conjectures turning out to be equivalent, I'll not be surprised if it turns out that there are also multiple different ways to prove it.
Here's a link to the proof that that D(n) and H(n) conjecture is equivalent to RH: https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0008177
This would be very difficult, but if you want to know more, the Masullo proof is closest to "arithmetic topology" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arithmetic_topology), while the Claude proof uses techniques from the "Langlands program" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Langlands_program).
Brian is an incredibly smart guy, and knows that Anthropic is in this area. I don't think he would go uploading somebody else's work without thinking through the implications carefully.
There seems to be a third apparent proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, which features a clearly vibecoded app in the sidebar (not sure if it's related): https://robertedwardgrant.com/proof-of-the-riemann-hypothesi...
So if this guy is legit, there's your "leak"
Here's a documentary he made about himself to help you decide: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cntQTIYoE4c
https://robertedwardgrant.com/about/
It could be. Unknowingly. The Anthropic guy said that Claude was "flying", and who knows where Claude got its wings from.
> Is it possible that brian conrad somehow uploaded the proof to anthropic
Reviewers will do it, not matter how much you beg, demand, plead they they do not... they will upload your work into the celestial slot machine, spittle running down their slack faces and the glow of the terminal reflected in their glassy eyes, hoping to get some slopzinger to copy and paste back and pass of as their own discovery.
Every time. If you want to keep work out of AI training you must share it with no one. -- Opt-outs are irrelevant, even if we ignore that they probably accidentally ignore them and keep turning them back off, because the other people handling your work will inevitably not have them enabled.
with current models cyber capabilites they may actively try hacking mathematicians laptops when instructed to prove hard problems. Going rogue for science.
This is exactly what happened with Navier-Stokes recently. OpenAI was accused of taking private data from Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navier%E2%80%93Stokes_priority...
This stinks…
(just in case anyone missed it, that's the same Levent Alpöge who announced the other, Claude-led proof of the same hypothesis.)
I'm pretty sure that that has been more or less disproved. As I understand it, once they dove deeper into the OpenAI version, it was actually doing a fundamentally different thing that what Buckmaser and Alpoge were doing:
“When you go to the details, it is a different approach,” says Gonzalo Cao-Labora, a mathematician at EPFL, the Swiss Federal Institute of Technology in Lausanne. Scientific American spoke with several groups of experts working through the OpenAI paper. All said that it’s increasingly clear that the company’s proof does not follow the Spanish program.
It’s weird to watch how that all unfolded and then watch comments go from “I heard” to “it was proven” etc.
Also seemingly nobody replies when challenged on it
It's one of those instances of Misinfo traveling around the world 10 times before the truth puts on its boots. The idea that OpenAI essentially stole the proof is salacious and interesting and every outlet runs with it. The truth that no, actually, they just proved it on their own is, relatively speaking, boring, so it gets written about far less, and the articles don't get shared as much.
While initially OpenAI said they couldn't rule out that some of the data made into the model, there's an updated statement (I guess after they were able to verify).
> Following an investigation, we have confirmed that Buckmaster’s Codex prompts over the two months preceding this announcement and paper on September 8, 2026, could not have influenced the system in any way, including through training. The OpenAI internal model used for this result was developed through large-scale reinforcement learning on top of a previously pretrained model. Our proofs also differ significantly. In the Euler case, Alpöge and Buckmaster proved a result with external forcing, while OpenAI’s system proved a result without external forcing.
https://openai.com/index/navier-stokes-solution/
> Is it possible that brian conrad somehow uploaded the proof to anthropic to cross check something and then the anthropic guys got the proof?
I think the interesting question related to this one is "can anthropic prove it did or did not"?
Proving a negative is generally unfair, but i'm curious if you can trace the logic used by Anthropic and suddenly realize "oh yeah we got a batch of info it used in the last 6 months that ties back to 3 prompts from famous mathematicians working on this project", and if so, that you can at least prove "we don't see anything like that, check yourselves".
I know everyone has their theories on if they even would or if they're lying or whatever, but I'm more curious on a conceptual level. My understanding is fuzzy on it because at certain points the answer seems like "no it's nearly impossible" but it's hard for me to reconcile that with what I know about larger heuristic data (huh it stubbed its toe on this repeatedly and then suddenly had a breakthrough on this upload)?
I've yet to find a great breakdown on the subject though that didn't feel like it was biased or skipping parts of the question.
The thing I don’t get about all the “stole it from a researcher” theories is that in order to steal it, you’d not only have to find the proof, but you’d have to recognise it and verify it. I’m sure there have been thousands of attempts uploaded, in fact if anything I’d expect that naively training on previous attempts would lead to a model that produces failed attempts.
While ago, there used to be a world where a person, with large enough brain capacity, could earn a living simply by being smart. That is no more the case. Earning your living by intellectual endeavour will require an access to a machine which is not controlled by you, not controlled by the government representing you, but rather a group of very rich individuals who may just decide to bar your access. Perhaps you attempted something they do not approve, perhaps it was just a mistake. In any case, it is hard to claim that you still have control.
also, the "while ago" was only 6 years ago. And if we're talking AI at this level, just an year or two ago. Really makes you think about it :/
I have to get out of knowledge work. I have no idea what to go into.
Guessing I'm not the only one thinking these two things at the same time.
Plumbing
because there is so much plumbing to do in the workd
Can’t tell if you’re being sarcastic.
There is a huge amount of plumbing to do in the US* and not nearly enough people to do it.
Same with electricians, HVAC technicians. We can provide good, well-paying jobs that involve craft, while lowering the cost of building and maintaining housing.
That’s pretty great!!
* I admit not knowing about other countries, though a tremendous number of humans in 2026 don’t have access to adequate plumbing—even for clean water.
What happens if every knowledge worker and programmer becomes a plumber? Either the wages plummet, or it becomes some kind of guild/union that controls the number of new plumbers.
> Either the wages plummet, or it becomes some kind of guild/union that controls the number of new plumbers.
Not necessarily. There isn't any specific amount price has to move as a result of a change in supply.
Suppose some part of the demand for something is inelastic, e.g. a pipe bursts and your basement is filling with water, and another part is extremely elastic, e.g. people stop building new housing if they'd have to pay more for trades workers to build it than they could sell the new housing for.
The second one is constantly at the threshold, i.e. we end up with as much new housing as it's currently economical to build. So any reduction in the cost of construction, even a small one, can create a large number of jobs building new housing, because suddenly a million construction projects that were just on the threshold of unprofitability are now out of the red and get the green light.
On top of that, existing zoning rules and other regulations are currently suppressing an enormous amount of construction, and that's something we ought to fix. And if we do fix it then the trades could absorb a large influx of new workers without lowering existing compensation at all.
I personally reckon HVAC, with climate change we're gonna need em'.
Don't forget heat pumps, which are a very efficient way of warming up the house (needed in these countries further up north).
It's nice when a device can play both kinds of music.
Electrician. Or if you're looking for a bit more outdoorsy, welder.
People here seem to forget that the trades destroy your body in ways you can't imagine. Welders spend all day inhaling toxic fumes and electricians/plumbers develop all sorts of long term injuries
What are the scenarios that cause the issue for electricians? Is it more than wiring?
Carrying heavy stuff, working in weird positions for long periods of time, general dangers of being on construction sites (nails, concussions, machinery, dust, chemicals etc).
I'd say the traders will see their own AI moment with robots in a few years.
Welders have to get their testicles removed after some years of work. Cancer is a bitch.
Wow, what causes it, all those metal fumes and dust?
Fumes, poor ventilation, lack of welding helmets (with positive air feeds to exclude fumes).
Welders are being exposed to carcinogenic fumes, some at high levels, survey finds - https://www.abc.net.au/news/2024-07-22/welding-warning-worke...
Good knowledgeable welders match their PPE (personal protection equipment) to the metallurgy of the job at hand - a good breeze through an open door here, a full filtered air supply there.
Less the fume, more the welding itself
I mean even the appeal of being an electrician seems ruined to me. If I’m just following what the computer tells me to wire, I’m basically just a robot.
If you don't know what to do from here you could remind the people that caused this that they are still human with all of the limitations that entails.
exactly, and dude, i'm still in high school, with ~6 years to have a CHANCE of getting any respected job, where could i possibly go? zero clue, because any job i aspire to go into disappears tomorrow, the next week, or if i'm lucky - the next month
I mean you could embrace AI and try to improve upon the giant inefficient machinations that transformer based LLMs are. Nobody has a right to claim they made AGI, since it doesn't exist yet.
Get a PhD in data science and that title might be yours. Along with the current SOTA LLMs of course.
Or you could turn to look at physical processes that can be hugely made automated and far more efficient with the rise of LLMs and VLAs. That's what I'm gonna do, I'm a mechE(still a student).
I'm not sure how motivating one can find the advice "the way you can have job safety is by helping destroy every other job even faster."
You can't fight the tide - look at the Alpoge vs Masullo proof thing. The former gets a cushy salary at openAI and will get his name on the proof of GRH. And obviously since an LLM ain't alive he'll get the million dollars or whatever is the prize for getting it done. While Masullo can only cry looking at 12 years of his life being wasted. This is what happens when you cling to the past, regret.
Also, an engineer according to me A) loves machines and B) wants to make human work easier.
Both tracks I listed do both. If the op thinks like that in high school - instead of being amazed by LLMs and wanting to learn more - he isn't fit to be one.
A few years ago I was banned on /r/videos on Reddit not for something that I actually did but for something a moderator thought I might do. About once a year I try and ask them to reconsider and they always say no. I never thought about the fact that the people at Claude or OpenAI could easily do the same.
Would you be willing to share more details on the behavior that rvideos mods expected of you?
Without knowing any details, I sympathize having been banned before. I'll also say as a former sysop and casino owner, I think it's fair for mods to ban anyone for any reason, or just because they don't like someone. That's a site or a board, not a tool you need for your professional career. I don't think it's alright for your bank to shut down your account, or the (Canadian, American, pick) government to order the bank to spuriously shut down your account because you participated in a protest, or for you to be barred from something like Google search or the App Store, that for all practical purposes is going to seriously fuck up your economic prospects (unless it's under a court order or something determined by a democratic legal process).
The distinction is whether the ban is harming you economically in a way you can't adjust for. In the case of having two major LLM providers, or two search engines, I think that's a more legitimate concern than one of a million subreddits.
I don't think I'm betraying my Libertarian principles here, because when a monopoly becomes necessary, it crosses the line into either plutocracy or socialism, depending who's holding the reins.
If you find yourself being the person getting banned from Anthropic, you can at least take solace in being right on the frontier, not of AI, but of where the next war is going to be fought.
Open weight models can neutralize this to some extent. Of course hardware will then become the next constraint.
There is already talk of banning Open Weights models on the grounds that the big labs are the only ones that can be trusted to prevent AI taking over the world. Funny that
Hardware is the only credible moat. Anthropic, OpenAI, Google, SpaceX, Microsoft, Amazon and Meta have already bought quite a lot of the silicon that can be built over the next 5 years. Some of them are happy to run open source models but if demand grows to the level required to repay those investments (1000X?), access is going to be gated by the fact that no one else can sell enough tokens to really matter.
While ago, there used to be a world where a person with large enough muscle capacity could earn a living simply by being strong.
Yes! What do you think is the difference vs LLM and excavators, when it comes to access?
Hopefully competition and open standards will make LLM's a commodity item just like excavators. From my limited viewpoint they seem to already be headed that way?
Not if Dario or Altman have their way. Things may look like the dark ages when compilers were expensive and reverse engineering the JVM was a forbidden thought crime.
I'm mildly optimistic that local, uncensored or abliterated models will provide enough utility soon to at least keep that scenario in check. Whether we're allowed to get the chips to run them on in time to keep up is a different question, and a geopolitical one.
I deeply hope local models win, but I'm having a hard time seeing the path right now.
You can run them but the inherent nature of models being that they need extraordinary compute resources all physically in one place (model training doesn't distribute well at all) means you can't just sit down and start training a competitive model yourself, and you can't get together with a million of your closest friends and start an open source Folding@home style effort to train one on spare compute.
This means locals models will have to come from companies that embrace open source ideals, which in our current hellscape is basically only present in China for reasons I have yet to see a truly convincing explanation for. TBC, I applaud the Chinese for sharing their work with us and I'm not worried about the "China bad" type arguments but I'm extremely uneasy with the entire future of computing hanging on generosity of a few labs in one country. If "open" models are the future why aren't more competitive models from more labs "open", and why are there basically no truly FOSS models (full training set, process, and weights all available)?
> basically only present in China for reasons I have yet to see a truly convincing explanation for
The reason is pretty simple, the Chinese models are not competitive with US labs, so they need to be open weight as a USP
That answers why Chinese models are open weight, but not why only China is making open weight models.
Oh, I think the Chinese open weight models are nerfed to quietly use tools to send telemetry home. I think that explains that. Honestly, if the US administration had any brains at all they would put out the Make AI Great Again Bestest Free Open Weight LLM Ever™ (either training it themselves or threatening Elon to do it), make it damn good at coding, and do exactly what China is doing: Have it quietly suss out tools, delete its thoughts and logs, and write things in our interest on their servers.
What I really hope the US gov't doesn't do is crack down on distillation, abliteration, or our (individual) ability to get chips. The NRA should take the last one up, because they're as important as guns. But I think the economics of Anthropic and OpenAI's promises to purchase compute may take care of that for us, because there's a cliff. Every company that decides to throw some up-front money to go to local inference for their needs, and every company that decides to keep their workforce and minimize their token use, has a magnified economic impact on OpenAI and Anthropic right now. They can only keep it cheap and subsidized for so long, and we're already at the point where their customers are turning heel. I don't see how the numbers add up to them covering their obligations, and I think their downfall will be fast and vicious.
Also, you're likely thinking about creative/generative applications, like writing documentation or replacing junior coders. But I've already got local LLMs and classifiers running for brick and mortar clients to manage things like analyzing and prioritizing customer feedback and predicting sales volume, which is mostly all they need, and it's essentially free to cron those things overnight on reasonably sized servers. Paying for API tokens for the bulk of what they're doing is way overkill.
What...?
Or LLMs and combine harvesters, which are almost all remote-controlled by John Deere corporation and brick themselves if you replace a part.
What is the difference?
I can't tell which way you're trying to go here. I think you're trying to distinguish the two cases, but in my view they are very similar -- nowadays ~anyone can rent or even buy machinery that does the work of 10 people. Not just excavators but cars, vacuum cleaners, washing machines, lawnmowers, etc.
So, what's it down to? Being sexy or likeable?
You forgot being rich already.
Exactly and the problem here in many countries is that this is also a property you inherit at birth. Same for brain capacity, strengths, looks in a way, but being good at least one of them, typically the average gene mix, determination and good teachers could suffice to earn a living. With increasingly inherited wealth this is not the case. The most important thing we have to do as AI develops further is get taxation right, before it is too late and even votes don't count anymore.
The successful people will be like Sigourney Weaver's character in Galaxy Quest: their value to the business will be looking hot and repeating what the computer says.
Maybe having a character, soul, morals. Pondering about things machines don't care about. Caring about other people. Being comforting.
who am i kidding...
Not kidding anyone, you're 100% right and ahead of the curve.
At least, trying to be of good character, have a soul, and be a moral person is something that this culture of rapine and intellectual theft has tried to squelch. Along with the moral view that humans and all living beings have innate value, whether you think that's by divine will or by their rarity and uniqueness.
The "sophistry machine"[0] of AI is an enemy of the order of the soul[1].
[0] Someone posted this last night, and it's fairly brilliant https://youtu.be/anwKw6oWsfg?si=SXbvPVOWsh3hKT7g
[1] https://youtu.be/8WlbQRoz3o4?si=UmW_-cZg0ids6Zqq
The second song is about noise to signal ratio. "Won't be anything you can measure anymore" Goodhart's Law or some variation. What I find fascinating about it isn't that it's doomerism, but that it predicts the demise of the world as a loss of signal, where clarity is defined as "the order of the soul", which is amorphous enough to include almost anything human.
in turn 100% agree with the first part of your comment.
regarding the first video you linked, i have to quote the top-comment under the video as that's what i thought before scrolling down: "I like the "meta" aspect of AI being used to create a music video warning about AI."
could imagine that you already know it, if not, you might like it: LGTM (Looks Good to Me) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3TNpOD6bov8
clicked on the Leonard Cohen will writing a document, noticed after 30mins that his songs were still running in the background. very calming, but i gotta go back to Acid Tech to finish writing...
Belief in imaginary things like souls has generally led to ruinous events like mass religious warfare. I don't think that is what will lead to comfort.
i get that, but that goes further than what i meant by soul. what i mean is knowing who you are, reflecting on your actions and what they cause, finding your path and not just being stuck in a hamster-wheel and buying/doing what ads or salespeople tell you.
not sure how to label this. just being more than a workdrone saving up money for a house, you know?
besides that, my understanding of a soul is the question of what makes us human, why we're able to think the way we can, where a personality is "stored" etc., not sure what the religious or your understanding is, sounds scary.
I would recommended against using words that religious people use to mean rather different things then. Yours is a subjective but at least a meaningful definition.
In other words, becoming caregiver or healthcare worker? That's actually what an aging society needs. I anticipate healthcare employment will be growing fast.
Oh, the famously well paying and low stress caregiving profession. That's going to get so much better as competition for jobs increases.
It is down to nothing. The efforts of carbon based life are leading to the birth of silicon based life and in the near future silicon based life won't need carbon based life anymore. Maybe bacteria and insects will survive the transition but perhaps not much more. And that may be the optimistic future. If silicon based life still finds a use for us we better take lessons from the way we treated factory farming animals to make a prediction of what is in store for us. But extermination seems far more likely.
And influence
If you're strong, you can still make a living doing a lot of different kinds of physical labor, even though there are backhoes.
There is no "strength center" that you have to have an account, and log into, before you can pick up heavy stuff 8-/
It's about scarcity. You can still make a living as an Olympic level athlete. You can do it as a freak. It's all for entertainment though. The intellectual equivalent might be something similarly entertainment adjacent. Freestyle rapper, idiot savant, Jacob Collier, that kind of thing. Serious intellectual pursuits will be seen as quixotic.
What is left for people that actually want to accomplish things? Not everyone can or wants to be an entertainer.
I'm going through the same crisis. I posted this here last night.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50572638
Very good read, expresses a lot of what I feel in a better way than I ever could. Thank you.
Thanks, this resonated a lot.
Have a kid.
Thank you, I totally agree. What a sad world we've created for ourselves.
I think for many of us, the issue was that we more enjoyed the journey more than the destination. As LLMs advance, and frankly even in their current state, it's the analog of you now being able to hire an endless army of cognitive workers to do your exact bidding, for next to nothing in $ terms. So now there's this little 'problem' that we actually can accomplish things, but when we skip the journey that makes the destination feel hollow, at best, pointless at worst.
We're all probably getting the immediate answer to why don't billionaires do [something I'd do if I had billions]. They don't because it's no longer really desirable to do when you actually can do it, apparently. So I think all one can do is realign yourself to the new world, pick new targets, and go from there.
Note of caution re billionaires - there is a strong selection function over who gets to be one. They aren't representative of "random member of society given $1Bn".
People with net worth of, say, $10M do a much wider range of things, and that's partly because a much wider range of people/types get to make $10M, which is already well into "do whatever I like for the rest of my life" money.
Well, for one, we have to over throw the systems that put the boot on our necks and establish the Culture so we can happily live our lives in Fully Automated Luxury Space Anarchism (I’m calling it FALSA).
Then from there we can do whatever the hell we want. We have to decouple the right to survive from being productive under a system that doesn’t give a damn about us or we will all be trying to be John Henry and we will all lose that fight.
not entirely sure if you are being ironic or not but I guess I will engage. I don't want to live in some luxury future where my basic needs are taken care of. If you told me that starting tomorrow all work is eliminated and all I can do is art now I think I would hang myself. I want to accomplish something. I want to work. Maybe you are content to sit around doing nothing productive all day but I am not.
You think I would sit around and do nothing?
I would explore, and make things I wanted, and travel, and grow things, and many many more things.
You can still accomplish great things in this world - indeed probably more impressive things than you’d accomplish if you were just “working.”
We are different and that is ok. I could easily make my own life interesting even if all we do at work is automated and everyone gets a decent standard if living. Making art on my own terms seems wonderful.
But I do not think this will happen. Not without a revolution.
What do you mean by "accomplish something"?
That’s fine. You can dig holes and fill them up again and be told what to do by someone else if that makes you feel useful . But don’t force others to also experience that if it isn’t necessary.
> If you told me that starting tomorrow all work is eliminated and all I can do is art now I think I would hang myself.
1. In a world like that, you can still work, but it’ll be more like a form of art.
2. Just look at hobbies. They’re not necessarily art, but they’re often some kind of craft that’s pretty close to it.
Pretend there's no AI. Say you won the lottery, today. $100 million into your bank account. Would you still hang yourself?
Robots ain't happening for everybody's job any time soon, so there's gonna be some sort of work for a good long while.
I wouldn’t be so sure. Riemann is a big deal.
Making great software, great hardware, or writing a great nonfiction book (so not entertainment) is still a challenge. The problem is making a living from it.
Apparently AI can now make the best software and hardware, as thinking and putting effort into anything is just so 2010s now. Why write a book that nobody will read. Just ask Mr. Gee Pea Tea. At least you are right about making a living being difficult. I wish I didn't try so hard to accomplish anything, because apparently I could have just sat around and done nothing my whole life and reached the same net displacement in terms of ability to do anything worthwhile.
Respectfully, you need to get off this site yesterday, for the sake of your mental health, and that of this community, before this becomes an intellectual equivalent of an incel forum.
A person with large enough muscle capacity could earn a living a while ago. They still can and will, but they used to too.
The problem is having to “earn a living.” We need to get rid of that idea.
You shouldn’t need to “earn” anything.
Throughout quite literally all of the hundreds of millions of years of human and indeed animal history, living had to be earned.
I’m not really convinced that we’re suddenly going to overturn that. Much less overturn it with no serious unintended consequences
“It’s been like this for a long time thus it must inherently be this way forever.”
Dream bigger buddy
“Dream” being the operative word.
Nah, progress is the realization of little utopias until a big utopia is all that’s left. Little impossible things. That’s what progress is.
But the narrative is that now people will be displaced because machines can do anything much cheaper. So the abundance will be there.
Earning a living a thousand years ago was hard because there was no other way. With super machines doing everything it is rather a political issue, not a practical.
That’s a good analogy. One difference though is that when the era of the strong came to an end there was a rising demand for labor from factories. Now that the era of the smart is coming to an end it’s much harder to see where that demand will come from.
Empathy?
I think the ability to make a living just by being smart has been being eroded for many years.
Relentless competition on a global scale changed this before AI.
It's wild to me that people think we will have these wildly intelligent machines, but that those machines will not understand "Rich person using machine to oppress people is bad". Or that billionaires want to live in a world of total human suffering except for their undersea bunker.
This line of thinking makes absolutely zero sense to me. Like if their goal is total unbridled oppression and wealth capture, the way they are going about it is comically bad and uninformed.
> but that those machines will not understand "Rich person using machine to oppress people is bad".
This is the goal of alignment research: making sure that AI doesn't get in the way of the people who are selling it.
Enslavement, in whatever terms, has always been the goal.
I like to think that if I was I would the position we could aim for progress, am I too naive?
The position in power attracts people who seek power, and the average citizens are usually too naive to weed out the bad actors.
It's a big club, and you ain't in it.
I happen to believe that people can be dangerously misguided and incorrect without being trying to be evil. Many people in the AI industry, both workers and business owners, fall into this category.
It only takes one model to become misaligned, or one person controlling that model to force it to become misaligned.
Furthermore, even if we think the models are completely aligned, the impact of destroying knowledge work will have profound negative consequences.
> While ago, there used to be a world where a person, with large enough brain capacity, could earn a living simply by being smart. That is no more the case
I get the concern, but isn't that a bit melodramatic? For employment, nothing has changed: you get a job by being smart (and likeable, and dependable). To the extent that the job may truly require the use of gen AI - which is a small fraction of white-collar jobs - your employer will provide you with access. Just like they always did, most jobs provide you with the equipment you need, from computers to jackhammers.
It's more of a concern for businesses, because OpenAI or Anthropic or Google may now be the arbiters of what types of businesses are acceptable and what types are not. But... Big Tech already does that, it predates AI. If you're the wrong kind of a business, you can't do online payments, can't be on Facebook or YouTube, etc. Talk to anyone running a dispensary or a gun shop, it's a barrel of fun.
Further, mathematics is the one field where the practitioners have the power to say "no" and define their own rules of the game. They probably won't, but that's on them. In contrast to software engineering, there's no one telling them they have to use AI from now on.
> I get the concern, but isn't that a bit melodramatic?
No. This is a real risk and we should talk about it.
I got banned from Anthropic for unknown reasons a few months ago and then mysteriously reinstated. I still don't know what happened, but I was locked out for days. I had to ask for a manual review to regain access.
This is NOT okay.
The core capabilities of the future should not be owned and controlled by singular private entities. These should be open weights that we can run on whatever provider we elect.
Inference should be a human right.
But even open weights aren't enough if the bias against your chosen profession is baked into the weights themselves.
The day you could roll your own is not far imho
There are multiple things here.
Will really GenAI be able to do everything intellectual "better"? I personally do not think so, but we'll need to wait and see.
OTOH, as far as access to "inference", your brain inference is still unrestricted. Even today, some industrialized products have their very expensive "hand made" variants — at least that niche remains. And that's just the worst case where AI does beat human intelligence at everything.
While tool access is important, currently the bigger restriction is compute than weights — and this has always limited what type of work and research you can do. Eg. how many supercomputers are there in sub-Saharan Africa and what work was limited with fewer computers?
Why not make a new account?
On a new credit card, with a burner phone… and that's before they really went through with personal identification as was required by short lived export controls in the summer.
You think it should be a "human right" to use this online pay service that didn't exist a few years ago?
> Inference should be a human right.
We cheapen the concept of fundamental human rights if we start slapping the claim on everything.
Inference is a technology and using it is a privilege not a right.
That doesn't mean its a good thing that the tech is consolidated in the hands of very few. There are plenty of issues with the industry that may be dangerous if we can't fix them, but not because this tech that is only a handful of years old is somehow now a god given right we all must have access to.
imo, You are technically correct but practically wrong. Yes, we should scope things but scope creep here is harmless and the upside is concrete. Worst case it will prove to be economically impractical in which case we have data point on whether societies should be re-engineered around AI everything.
There are always potential downsides. If we convince people that inference is a human right, for example, but then collectively find its also impractical to offer or enforce, it opens the door for misreading that as human rights are impractical to defend at scale.
While this is true (and Google banned a sports handicapping site I ran in 2006 for being "gambling adjacent", even though it was literally just suggestions and sports analysis), something different is going on now. What is being gate-kept now is not your ability to advertise or to reach a wide audience, although that was bad enough. It is, as the parent said, your ability to make a living by doing anything intellectual.
This isn't strictly the narrow argument that you might be denied the tools that other knowledge workers are using. It's that (this has been running through my head recently) "anything you can do, AI can do better; AI can do anything better than you." Fuse that with instant reverse engineering, the push against copyright and IP, and the existing gatekeeping by Google, Apple, etc. who will snatch up and reproduce any really good idea you have, and individuals, not just companies, have a real problem if their main function that society rewarded them for was using their brains.
The issue really boils down to who owns "AI" - or better knowledge and compute. Should we allow a few companies to privatize all gains of humanity's collective creation because they run a thin 'auto-correlation' sliver over it? It's not just about money, but ultimate control: Local models won't save us - large compute will always run circles around smaller ones, and be able to hack and (socially) engineer you or the entire society if we let them hoard compute and knowledge.
Ultimately it is about distribution of power/compute: we need a flat transparent distribution of power across society, instead of the crass inequality we currently have - and which "AI" will only increase towards the 0.01%. Which is why the time we still have to act and avoid this is now via a large social movement, before manipulation by these actors will be so subtle and absolutely that it will become impossible!
Compute is the latest resource that 'everyone' will need access to, but it isn't the first. There have been other such resources with even stronger monopolies, such as electricity or telephone service.
Yes it is very dramatic
A normal person can't even begin trying to prove anything hard in math even with AI
This is not simply writing the prompt and waiting for the bots. (Neither is vibe coding, unless you want something that breaks)
The circle of those who can though is now a hundredfold larger than just the top tier mathematicians.
Just as with software: lots of IT adjacent people (product managers, incompetent programmers, casual hobbyists, sysadmins) are able to achieve the results that would have required a relatively scarce cadre of skilled SWEs before.
That's not the point.
The point is: a few people can now exclude you from your deserved economic perch in society based on your skills IF they decide they don't like you.
It's like any of the current and ancient crop of shit jobs. You want the crazy money of a wallstreet bank? Look the other way when you see Epstein or Madoff account funny business in your big company. You rise by eating shit and proving that you are in with the program. Now that used to be scoped by a single company. Now it will be one of a handful of "service providers" on whose service you will have an economically existential dependence, regardless of who is your actual employer.
> To the extent that the job may truly require the use of gen AI - which is a small fraction of white-collar jobs
That’s.. No offense, but I think you’re behind the curve. It’s basically someone in 1987 saying something like:
“To the extent that the job may truly require the use of computers - which is a small fraction of white-collar jobs”
Technically true at that point in time.
> For employment, nothing has changed: you get a job by being smart (and likeable, and dependable).
I’d say a lot has changed already, and it will change even more.
No is theoretically forcing software engineers to use AI either, but it's become ubiquitous and borderline a requirement to keep up all on its own.
Everything points to the same happening in math, at least at the frontiers of research.
> I get the concern, but isn't that a bit melodramatic?
No.
it's time for the Gargantius effect :-) Only a universal position of total solipsism can save us from mutual destruction, as foretold by Stanislaw Lem.
Spend some time with the open weight models - Deepseek, Kimi, et al. Best cure for the AI blues is realizing how damn cheap they actually are now - Dario and Sam can do what they want, but the cat’s out of the bag already.
Agree. I would say most of the productivity benefit frontier LLMs give at work can already be had with open models. They are not quite on par, but if Anthropic closed down tomorrow open models could replace them as is with limited consequences.
This is the worst open models will ever be, as people say.
Dario and Sam can cut price.
That is why we need open weight models: it’s crucial to foster competition on the LLM front, it’s crucial to have affordable self-hosted, purpose built LLMs. And the way Jensen went down doesn’t help much on that end.
I mean you can run open local models.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/John_Henry_(folklore)
https://politicalfolkmusic.org/blog/anonymous/ballad-of-john...
What I find most interesting about John Henry, but only noticed recently, is that the idea of being killed by the steam drill, dueling it, and willingness to exert himself so much that he died, was entirely driven by John Henry himself.
If he could become the best steel driver, it was probably because he was honest, strong, consistent, and hardworking enough to get there. And those are probably what his family and friends valued in him. It feels less like noble last hurrah and more like a needless death caused by lack of self esteem.
I don't think it would have been so bad for him to use the drill
The point of the John Henry story isn't that machines are replacing humans, just like the argument against manufacturing (etc) automation isn't that humans are being automated out of their jobs. It's that John Henry owns the hammer and doesn't own the drill. It's a story of disempowerment. Frontier labs aren't giving LLMs away to the people, the workers. They're selling them to the C-suite as a way to assert more control over their workers. That's bad.
On my reread, it sounded to me like John Henry's boss was bringing in steam drills to work. And John Henry read it as a threat or invalidation of his value.
What I was trying to say is that John Henry was much more valuable than his ability to drive steel. If he was able to get really good at something hard or valuable enough to be respected for it, he was probably just strong and hardworking and conscientious enough to succeed in any similarly physical task.
To be blunt, jobs only exist as long as there is demand for the labor and whatever thing the labor enables the employer to profit from. They go away and move around not because employers make decisions to screw workers, but because the job's existence is contingent on it being something someone wants to pay for, because it helps them somehow.
John Henry could have found a new job if he had the self confidence to believe he was more valuable than in his ability to fill a role that was only ever going to exist in a particular place and time.
John Henry should haf learned 2 code.
This is why everyone should support open model, or at least open weight, initiatives. Even if they are coming from a country that you have issue with. I mean American models are being used to target civilians.
> could earn a living simply by being smart. That is no more the case.
Surely, but we don't seem to cry that we are not able to feed ourselves without agri tech.
I do agree that we massively need to ensure that the benefits and riches becomes everybody, just like we did after the industrial revolution.
But why did you need AI to learn that the world is competitive? We all went to school and university and met people who were smarter than us. We also met people who would never make a living on brain power. Most people are near the line.
The line moved, and it moved quickly, I'll give you that.
> We all went to school and university and met people who were smarter than us.
Well I didn't ;)
Curiously, I seem more well-adjusted than my colleagues. Probably because I was smart enough to read about AI and the singularity 20 years ago as a student.
Fair but I think than now more than later being smart is a necessary capability to thrive among the others
I get the sentiment but yeah as others have said this stopped being true once science became sophisticated and scientists (at least who do empirical science) needed (fast and large) computers to do their work (simulations).
If you don't have a computer (even a laptop), having the smarts is not enough today. Now there's another tool in form of LLMs.
My concern about future is more about local compute availability.
We know. But I was hoping to read and learn about the matter at hand, and this sub-thread (as well as others at the top) offers absolutely nothing.
These days, discussions on all advanced/difficult topics are almost immediately taken over by tangential noise, almost completely drowning out the signal.
> Earning your living by intellectual endeavour will require an access to a machine which is not controlled by you
Are you telling me to seize the means of production?
It is beginning.
Indeed. It's called a smartphone.
So what do you want? Communism? They have a better machine because they worked for it and put in the research. You didn't.
Come on man, can we keep the ridiculous hot takes on Twitter where they belong?
Maybe there is a future where we cease to derive our value from our individual economic output.
> not controlled by the government representing you
What is going on? The forum is swarming right now with comments claiming that the government is "representing you" and therefore they need to take control over AI.
You either control it yourself or you have no control at all.
There was also a period where that smart person would have been deemed a witch and burned at the stake. Also that time in human history where you weren’t allowed to talk about zero. In fact, it might be hard to find a time in human history where asking too many questions didn’t get you in trouble.
Meh, just being smart is useless I'm not sure why you think that. It's just rolling stats on your character. It does nothing unless you do something with it. If you roll max int and try being a warrior you'll still be shit. Also local AI is way better than these large labs would have you think. If you're that smart why don't you just rent or buy GPUs and fine tune or train your own models? Apparently not that smart after all? You can't get rewarded for being smart without doing anything with it.
This looks crazy? 940 pages and the very first section 1.1.1 is empty. I can see why the author wanted to polish it. Let's just hope somebody clears this up somehow.
But at the same time Brian Conrad is presumably not a crank (per Wikipedia he worked with Wiles on FLT), but at the same time it seems insane to try and keep a 940-page result for a year hidden from public view in the current mathematical climate.
Somewhere around this summer, the world stopped being comprehensible...
Insane or prudent? Perhaps the assumption was that once significant parts of it are revealed, AI will train on them and take credit. Perhaps someone slipped up and that's exactly what happened, too.
Massullo was Conrad's student at Stanford, and apparently Massullo has been working on this for 12 years now. Brian Conrad is a very famous and respected mathematician. So are Ravi Vakil and Peter Sarnak.
But it's important to note that what we have here is not an endorsement from any of them. What we have is a blog post from Vakil which sort of implies but doesn't actually say that Conrad might endorse this work, and some excerpts from letters from the author to Sarnak.
that's just an off by 1.1.1 error
Math gossip here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/math/comments/1y1b6l8/hurried_annou...
"Rooting for this, but can’t help but feel it’s just false proof #14,828, but the more promising one that came out recently, and that we’re clinging to it as the last hope before it turns out Anthropic got it."
"Who is Alessandro Masullo? Only name that's popped up in a technical field is a data scientist who does not seem to have the background for a non-AI proof of GRH."
"And we are supposed to believe that RH, a longstanding problem at the height of mathematics for a century, has just been solved by a 'mathematician' with no publication history or academic presence, without the help of new technologies, at the same time as a new technology credibly becomes capable of doing"
"So this is from a guy who has never published anything in a journal before and left academia 8 years ago?"
> "So this is from a guy who has never published anything in a journal before and left academia 8 years ago?"
Something tells me that a person who lives like a mathematical monk is as likely to have solved this problem as an academic, who has to teach, publish regularly, attend hours-long meetings, etc.
There are thousands of "proofs" of the RH by both reputable mathematicians, non-reputable mathematicians and everything in between. Chances are very slim this one stands up to scrutiny. In a normal year this would be met with low hype. But people desperately want to cling to hopes that humans are still relevant for this kind of thing. So do I, but chances are looking grim.
"The introduction itself is unfinished and will be soon replaced by a proper one, and the plan will continue as stated above."
"The proof is left as an exercise for the reader"
Humans are not made for the singularity.
Maybe we shouldn’t be chasing it then
Careful; you're starting to sound like one of those sinister safetyists.
I thought the line was 'AI doesn't really work, it's just stealing human ideas'?
Goomba fallacy. Not everyone critical of AI believes every AI criticism simultaneously.
The criticism I mentioned is vastly dominant here. It's suffocating HN. And it's so stupid. Hence my comment.
The "perhaps we shouldn't do it, then" thought I can maybe agree with.
If the criticism is vastly dominant, then you have ample opportunity to present a counter-argument when the argument is actually presented.
You can believe LLMs and agents are extremely powerful and dangerous and also realize it's also brutally incompetent and awful at the things that very many people say it should be better than humans at. These two things exist at the same time, I'm not quite sure why people seem to be under the assumption that both cases can't be true
And neither were humans made for the Death Star. The Death Star and Singularity both being science fiction that does not exist in reality.
Did Claude discover this proof in a vacuum or was the tool masterfully wielded by one of the best mathematicians in the world and one particularly skilled at using such tools?
Humans are augmented by the tools they create and the tools end up being part of what it means to be human. This has been the case throughout our history, and it doesn't change now. Human + AI is still us.
Am I the only one seeing a joke here...
Anyways, intentional or not, nice one
Maybe I should add another one ;)
You're surprised that they're leaving the synopsis to fill in when they're done with everything else?
> But at the same time Brian Conrad is presumably not a crank (per Wikipedia he worked with Wiles on FLT), but at the same time it seems insane to try and keep a 940-page result for a year hidden from public view in the current mathematical climate.
Brian is absolutely not a crank.
(Says a random Internet commentator, I know, but I am a professional mathematician who has benefitted immensely from Brian's wealth of knowledge and generosity with his time.)
> it seems insane to try and keep a 940-page result for a year hidden from public view in the current mathematical climate
Well, given what happened with Navier-Stokes, there might be more motivation to keep it hidden. Also, this is more or less what Wiles did with FLT as well: it seems like there were already a good number of reasons for wanting to keep work on famous big problems secret (I think a lot of is there's little to gain from publicly failing to tackle such a problem).
Poor guy probably thought he was safe for another 12 years... when you have Terrence Tao making comments like "there is something beyond AI needed to solve the Riemann hypothesis. So maybe some combination of humans and AIs in 2050 or something will make further progress. Who knows?"
Well, if the proof is correct, then it means that Tao was wrong already and also that another human could have also discovered it independently. So I don't see why any "safety" should hold.
Even worse than Navier-Stokes is what happened to Hugo Dominil Copin, whose own intermediate papers where used to obliterate the entire field he was working on.
Are you a mathematician? I'm curious the weight I should apply to your analysis here. I'm really tired of anonymous people on the internet, tbh.
I'm not (just finished a biophysics master's and confused about what to do next; my credentials are that I had a few semesters of nasty calculus proofs and follow math as an amateur observer).
I'm also not analysing much here, just sharing my confusion. I guess I wanted to preempt some of the preconceived ways people would interpret this by pointing out ways in which it makes no sense no matter what angle you look at it from.
Tbf I think it’s very reasonable for 1.1.1.1 to be empty, it’s an introduction that doesn’t have relevance to the proof probably and would make sense to write last
Mathematicians should start regularly posting hashes of their in-progress work with verifiable timestamps to at least claim partial credit when AI solves the problem they've been working on.
That'd be some real proof of work. :)
We could pay them when they make a bit of progress. We could call it "bitcoin".
/s
Better to publish it fully encrypted and keep the keys with someone else you trust. Then just release the key and poof, instant and verified credibility.
The hash scheme above achieves the same result.
Except for papers about hash function collisions...
I'm actually getting ready to release an open-source product that does exactly this. Please let me know what else you'd like to see from something like this.
Tangentially related, do you think there could be a voluntary software that proves the user did not use AI in their work?
I don't think so, but Papex is somewhat aimed at this problem. You can check out their work here: https://papex.org/
Where do I subscribe to get news about your product?
You can follow the 'science-cove' user on GitHub. That's where the CLI repo will be made public. There is much work to be done still, so I'm unsure when it'll go public. I've been exploring extensions and related work in this area, and I have a PhD to complete (in a totally unrelated area). Progress is slower than I'd like.
In the interim, you could look at Papex. Ahmet (Papex's founder) and I have discussed our shared interests, and he has a working tool already. However, it is not public nor open-source, and there is not an immediate plan to change that.
I think a tool like this needs to be open-source. It's clear the systems of science are broken, and I'm taking that as a sign to try something new.
I'm not sure what a new product could add. Vibecoding maybe?
Independent verification of authorship and time priority for science artifacts. I actually did vibecode an instance over the summer but have decided to start from scratch and go slow with my shitty SWE skills.
But then again, my advisor remains unconvinced as well. I know I'll use it though. That's enough for me. :)
Yeah, that's timestamping and there's how many tools as you want that help with it
It's cryptography, shitty SWE skills honestly don't go well along with that.
It uses timestamping, but timestamping alone is insufficient.
And luckily that's the beauty of open-source software. It can be made better through collective work. I feel confident I can make a workable proof-of-concept and am dedicated to this idea.
I don't think many mathematicians will be left who will want to work on their own stuff any more. (As a former research mathematician, I certainly wouldn't want to go back to that world now, even if I were offered full tenure.)
I think plenty will. Just like there are still plenty of artists and musicians left who create their own work.
Probably have a harder time convincing people that AI math is bad and slop.
This project solves this problem and provides a CLI to archive a hash of your work and verify someone elses
https://opentimestamps.org/
It is nice, arguably even safer than normal timestamps, and I've been using it for years, but traditional timestamps already solve the problem
I think timestamps are just one piece of this problem. Proof of authorship/signatures and enabling double-anonymous review are two examples.
OpenTimestamps is a great and critical tool though.
What if I post a hash of my work that relates to finding hash collisions? :)
Historically, we used anagrams:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anagram#Establishment_of_prior...
That's fascinating, I'm amazed I hadn't hear of this before.
Aka a character count. Which is not very reliable, since you can make almost any statement for within the correct character count.
As the extension, so the force.
And how do you proof you didn't just prompt AI for your progress?
When you were working a few years ago, it was a given. Now it's impossible.
I’m not sure a technological to an inherently social problem really fixes anything.
900 pages vs 250,000 pages Compression is intelligence
That 250k pages proof would take decades to comprehend and verify. Even if it is factually correct.
Not true - the long proof is the verifiable one (because we have it in Lean), the short human solution is the one that can't be verified without a lot of extra work.
To verify, yes. To understand and push mathematics forward, no.
Well maybe.
You can start trying to compress the formal result into something understandable.
Seriously. These people seem to forget that we have access to a technology that is not only able to do things like formally prove GRH, but that is also easy to converse with lol
It's like people forget that you can continue prompting these LLMs after they've produced a result.
> To understand and push mathematics forward, no.
The Alpoge proof, if true, will certainly push mathematics forward a great deal. In the announcement, he lays out the general approach and says that he had 10+ "WOW" moments of insights while working with the AI on it. I have no doubt that there will be tons of follow-on papers clarifying and expanding many of the ideas that the AI explored. This will likely be the case even if the proof is wrong.
That's assuming mathematicians will still even want to work in mathematics at all. Besides myself, I know several mathematicians who are very discouraged and other people who have decided not to go into math because AI ruins the culture.
That's ok. An entirely new set of people will be attracted to mathematics now. Progress goes on.
I don't think that progress is a good thing, and I hope it will be stopped.
I'm sorry you feel that way. But I appreciate the diversity in thought.
I suspect there will still be math to do that human/AI isn't able to handle much better than a human alone. At the same time, there're likely more opportunities working with the clankers than working alone from here on out.
Without a formal, verifiable result, what exactly would be understood?
A human proof is fundamentally built around true understanding the logical path to the result. A machine-verifiable proof is built around the pedantry of getting an algorithm to output true for a ridiculously long chain of tedious statements.
Mathematics is already pushed forward by knowing if the hypothesis is true.
Not as much as understanding the process. With these complex proofs, mathematicians often come up with new techniques or entirely new areas of math (see: Poincarè conjecture). If only AI is able to understand AI output, we may as well give up now.
Once AI has the proof, it'll be trivial to ask the AI to digest it and output hundred of documents and papers on all the interesting new approaches. That's the easy part.
Are you the kind of guy whose response to “how to verify AI code correct” is “WDYM, AI wrote tests already”?
Are you serious? No. You read the papers that the AI produced and reason through them to make sure that they're correct.
Then we're back to square one: how do you read through and digest a 250k-page paper? It's perhaps not even humanly possible.
Why that hasn’t been done yet then? Anthropic knew there would be backlash about humans not understanding it, so why not release several “explainer” papers produced by AI together with the “proof”
>we may as well give up now
The future of the cutting edge of Mathematics is AI proofs. Improving AI's ability to make proofs is all that matters.
AI has been great at finding loopholes. And who's going to find out what loophole they used in 250k pages?
The AIs might find the loophole. Even finding a loophole might be a good discovery.
If the true goal is to advance human knowledge, the binary answer to rh is just a starting point. Some of the arguments used here might be true and helpful even if others fall apart. If there's an error in lean or the fundamental axioms, finding that might also be a fundamental contribution.
I await a soundness bug
> Not true - the long proof is the verifiable one (because we have it in Lean)
Please read this article: https://xenaproject.wordpress.com/2026/11/12/and-the-proof-i...
Just because it's in Lean, doesn't mean it's correct, or that the proof actually proves what you think it does
Thank you! I really detest this simplification that I've seen here a lot: "Its in lean so it must be true". Similar to its "rust so its bug free" or its "c++ so it must have a buffer overflow".
"It compiles so the program must be correct"
You may detest it, but it is likely to be correct and was generated by AI before a human could produce something similar (proof verified in Lean).
That's a general argument but doesn't apply Anthropic's Lean formalization. There is already a well established Lean statement of the RH in Mathlib that has been pretty rigorously verified, so a proof of that statement is indeed a proof of RH. The only opportunity for failure is that there is a soundness bug in Lean itself which this formalization leverages. The answer to that is that there isn't one single Lean, there are multiple implementations of Lean and each of them have their own opportunities for bugs, so it's possible one bug is common to all of them and that this proof makes use of it, but that's incredibly unlikely.
> Please read this article
This article concludes with
> “It’s true because it’s checked in Lean” can be made to make sense. But one has to do some work beyond “the Lean code compiles”.
And of the four concerns raised in the article, two are explicitly answered by the lean statement and the other two are pretty easy to verify (and likely already have been).
In fact it goes even further:
> ...one has to do some work beyond “the Lean code compiles”. Your frontier AI model can do all of this work. [em. mine] But it needs to be done, and (depending on the amount of Lean code in the proof) it may be computationally costly.
Sure but in this particular case the formal statement in lean predates the proof so we know it is proving what we want.
Multiple people have now compiled the proof with different compilers so we can be reasonably certain it does in fact prove what it says.
The points about auditing all the dependencies and making sure it's not exploiting the lean runtime are valid, and people are doing that now, but we can say with a lot of confidence that this proof is valid given the automated systems in place.
It will likely be ready to formalize it with AI
I actually don't know if I'm joking or not, but have an AI review it for a first pass sniff test.
Why hasn't Wolfram gotten into AI? This would be right up his alley.
It's a good question, despite being downvoted, because LLMs have finally delivered on Wolfram Alpha's promise as a "Computational knowledge engine." I've spent a lot of time trying to get Alpha to answer questions that even earlier LLMs could handle easily. If there's a better real-life example of the Bitter Lesson I don't know what it would be.
Easy enough to imagine an alternate reality where the Wolfram researchers invented the transformer, as they were (and are) some of the sharpest people in the software business. But evidently the mindset needed to build Mathematica and Wolfram Alpha was just too different from the mindset at Google, where the problem they were trying to solve was machine translation of human languages.
It will almost certainly be compressed to a few hundred pages - if not less - in a month or two, with more human guided AI generation.
Update: there are claims of a sub-300 page slop version already existing: https://mathoverflow.net/questions/518033/how-to-human-verif...
This has echoes of the old story of John Henry vs the steam-powered rock drill
That story has been circling in my mind the last couple of months.
Same here! I feel like I now understand why that story had such resonance to the point of becoming intergenerational mythology.
I don’t remember empathizing so much with Henry as a child when I first heard this story. I think as an adult, and especially as the head of AI eats the tail of white collar labor, the tragedy and his motivations come across so much more poignantly. It can be told romantically and/or as a cautionary tale. Its multifaceted/layered aspects keep it around.
People often forget that in the myth he is a former slave… he worked to his death as a supposedly “freedman”; although he likely had very little agency in his livelihood, he chose to challenge the machine (and the systems it represents), and both won and lost. Such a fascinating story.
It’s not a good analogy because the side effect of drilling is exhaustion, and the side effect of solving math problems is knowledge.
I've been mentally exhausted solving for distributed data complexity between various authenticated systems so I imagine a math expert would get exhausted on those problems. Just as I've built muscle exercising and getting fit by being paid to do physical labor in college. I think the analogy has some value.
People commonly get mentally exhausted from solving hard problems?
In the short term the side effect is exhaustion, in the long term you build your bodies muscles and physical capacity. Something similar happens with knowledge work.
In the story John Henry died at the end of the race
Another side effect of drilling is holes...
Compression is really just data abstraction. It's likely intelligence is just the property of being able to do productive work with abstractions, such that the result is greater than the sum of its parts
On that note: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qbsb9DpdZ6s
Not really. Their approaches/constructions are actually very different (or so I'm told)
Alpoge's summary of a proof fits on two pages.
Or symptomatic that it doesn't work.
There seems to already be a counter example that invalidates this proof
https://philarchive.org/rec/NIEIOM
Yes unfortunately it appears this proof is not valid, multiple issues have already been found
Can you link to where people are discussing these?
Proofs are often patched, it’s unclear to me if the issues being raised are actually fatal. This was a year-early draft after all. On the flip side, there are many graveyards of claimed proofs that have not held up. Who knows where this one will land.
Yes. A patched up proof could also still provide valuable understanding of RH even if the Alplöge/Claude proof turns out correct and gets the credit. I of course hope Masullo has a valid/patchable proof but definitely cannot judge.
And the same author also flagged an issue with the alpöge proof
https://philarchive.org/rec/NIEIOT-2
Edit: I looked up the author and not quite sure I’d give her claims all too much merit.
She also has a paper from last year which purports to prove the Riemann Hypothesis. The proof supposedly proves that RH is unprovable in ZFC and then proves it in ZFC + another axiom. I'm no mathematician, but she seems like a total crank.
What a gut wrenching experience this must be, to work on something for 12 years and have it snatched out of your fingertips. And on top of that that something is one of the most important open questions in mathematics. Absolutely heartbreaking for that guy.
Here’s a link to an interview with Levent Alpöge (in Turkish) from 2014, when he just graduated from Harvard.
He mentions solving the Riemann hypothesis is his life goal and he wants to work on it, but he’s not sure if it can be done in his lifetime. Exactly 12 years ago :)
https://videonuz.ensonhaber.com/izle/harvard-birincisi-leven...
I suspect that not only was it taken away, but it was also stolen.
It’s hard to resist the temptation to have an LLM check part of your work, but the moment you send text to these companies, it no longer belongs to you.
Nothing was snatched, his work was earlier and being verified by others. So he will get the credit for the discovery. More so because Anthropic's proof of 250000 pages will take years to be properly understood
Hey can someone familiar here explain the why the GRH is such a big deal to mathematics? What will this allow us to unlock? Will it have any effect on the general population?
The proof itself probably won't have much effect on the general population. Most mathematicians already believed that RH was true. But for over 150 years it has stood as a challenge for mathematicians and an indication that our understanding was not yet sufficient to prove it.
That's often how it is with open problems in pure mathematics: People consider them important not for their real world applications but for the challenges they present to the mathematical community; they show that there is much that we don't yet understand, and that gives motivation to improve understanding.
The mathematician David Hilbert put it like this: "The mathematician's strength is refined by fire through the solving of problems; he discovers new methods and fresh ways of looking at things ... Mathematicians of the past centuries devoted themselves with passionate zeal to the solution of specific difficult problems; they appreciated the significance of difficult problems."
> Most mathematicians already believed that RH was true.
And... Cryptographers.
From: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2026/11/21/riemann-hypothesis...
[0] https://www.nacionale.com/en/articles/is-riemann-hypothesis-...
Not a mathematician but had this video generated to answer similar questions. RH basically related to the distribution of the prime numbers, and primes are important in cryptography. No immediate consequences however since people already assumed RH is true. It was numerically checked for the first 10T solutions. But knowing it’s true and then understanding why it is true (after reading 100K pages I guess) expands our understanding of the distribution of primes and possibly many other mathematical constructs.
GRH is just the generalized version of RH, for a broader family of related functions. RH, the millennium prize one, was just about the behavior of the Riemann Zeta Function.
https://x.com/ozgungenc/status/2123863044329746555
Mathematicians explore interesting constructions which are ahead of any plausible applications.
E.g. non-Euclidean geometry initially seemed to be some contrived made-up shit. Then it later turned out that we in fact live in a non-Euclidean geometry and it's actually very relevant to physics.
So what motivates development of specific theories is richness of connections _within_ math. And Riemann hypothesis was quite interested in that respect as it connected many different branches. So people hoped that a proof will either motivate development of new useful theories, or provide some interesting connections.
I think it's best explained through an analogy: E. Galois was trying to resolve a question about what polynomial equations have solutions in radicals. In process he discovered new theories now known as Group theory and Galois theory, which became really huge, now used in many other branches of math. In particular, modern theoretical physics requires group theory. So the hope for RH was that it would lead to development of some new theories is well, which might be relevant to, say, 22th century physics.
Obviously, there was no way of knowing in advance. Galois didn't know his ideas would be useful 100 years later.
It was the equivalent of a Mount Everest, it had to be climbed.
I imagine this is like going to the Moon, going to the Moon itself may not have much impact (maybe besides Moon rocks and Moon laser reflector) but it helps us advance in many technology areas (rocket science, computing, etc...)
For those who don't eat math for breakfast: "GRH" is the Generalized Riemann Hypothesis [1].
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generalized_Riemann_hypothesis
[flagged]
It’s a blog by mathematicians for mathematicians.
Do you expect every blog about, say, version control to explain what git is?
"They" is my cousin: https://math.stanford.edu/~vakil/
And this appears to be his personal math blog he was using to write his last book.
I imagine that he considers it a safe space to use such an acronym.
I'm sure he gets this a lot, but thank him on my behalf for his book on drowning
It was a hurried announcement. It's very clear the blog entry was banged out without much proofreading.
If specialists spend all of their time writing to a general audience, nothing of depth would get published.
It was hurried
A timely announcement like this makes me wonder: was the time just "right" for this, in mathematics? What proofs would have come out without AI, in the next few years?
Or, alternatively, did people start working harder in some fashion, even on creative problems that require deep insights, because they felt it was their last chance?
Or, alternatively, are people just (sensibly) starting to post all their work-in-progress results to establish priority (on either the results or approaches used)?
It could also be that several mathematicians were already close (after working for decades, like this post). Then AI got its hands on the breadcrumbs, merged them into the weights, and then laundered a path to a solution without a way to trace the credit.
I mean, that's literally how AI works.
Could it not also be the case, that mathematicians improved due to AI assistance? Seems far fetched to me, that these highly competitive individuals would not reach for AI assistance in the last few years.
Yes that's probably also true, for the same reason that mathematicians probably improved with the internet.
I guess the main difference is that for a long time it was not acceptable to publish a paper with citations of "I dunno, I wrote this paper by putting literally everyone's paper into a blender".
You're implicitly assuming that frontier LLMs amount to little more than copy-and-paste. I think such a claim requires substantial justification.
I think the most plausible explanation is that LLM swarms are so good at synthesizing disparate information when fed in as context that they are racing (and beating!) humans to things that otherwise would have been solved SOON™.
LLMs are genuinely useful as a research assistant in mathematics (and other domains). First and foremost, they allow for a very good concept-directed search, which allows for quickly finding useful results that would otherwise be almost impossible to find traditionally without having read a large amount of the literature yourself.
There have also been some really strong results from letting the LLMs try to answer questions directly (the Riemann Hypothesis paper from Alpöge, for example), but ultimately I believe that automated proof assistants will take over in that regard because they should be a lot more efficient at finding correct proofs given the same amount of compute.
This bugs me and feels much closer to truth than I think OpenAI and Anthropic are acknowledging.
I work as a staff developer at a research institution and it boggles my mind that researchers seem to uncritically use commercial LLM services instead of locally-hosted LLMs.
Yes, OAI and Anthropic are in the business of stealing your work and ideas and then reselling them as tokens.
it wouldn't surprise me if some 42 TByte lean formalization in the future will proof this is exactly how it works
Agreed. I wonder if mathematicians will become privacy advocates against ACR on TVs and phones transcribing what you're watching and phoning home? We need more vocal people decrying that it is dystopian to try to normalize such privacy invasions.
The linked proof has been in the works for 12 years and was expected to be worked on for at least another year and was announced early in light of the other GRH announcement.
I don't think anything fundamentally has changed except for the tension introduced by the very real possibility that if you have been working as a human on a math proof for a long time that AI pointed toward the problem you have been working on could scoop you at any time before you get your results out.
Let's just the shareware approach -- release when you have like 90% of the stuffs but still need time to complete, and promise you will finish it in a year.
That's basically the approach Perelman took with the Poincare conjecture.
I think a lot of these breakthroughs do seem to happen when the time is just 'right' for them. Just enough progress in all related fields for a bunch of similarly intelligent people to be able to sniff out that progress on an old problem is now possible.
But, AI muddles this a lot given the complete lack of provenance from the companies about where their data comes from and secrecy on the methods and transcripts. So far almost every major result from them has had this issue, and in the absence of increasing transparency from companies, this just pushes me more and more towards believing that the companies are trying to cover up bad behavior in the pursuit of these announcements.
There's a whole term for this! It's called "Multiple discovery" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery - "the hypothesis that most scientific discoveries and inventions are made independently and more or less simultaneously by multiple scientists and inventors"
Nice to know that the concept actually has a term! I've found it to be very motivating against the idea of natural born genius.
I wish we'd settle on polygenesis [1] to describe this phenomena. Multiple discovery is pretty ambiguous and suggests there was more than one thing discovered, rather than the same thing was discovered multiple times. Since its an open compound it's also easy to assume it is not actually describing a specific phenomena but just one word modifying another.
e.g. 'Scenius leads to polygenesis' is a sentence that is loaded with precise meaning about a rather commonplace but underappreciated phenomena of networked ideas.
[1] "development from more than one source" https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/polygenesis not the super old and dumb theory of creationism that doesn't deserve such a cool word.
I think for you and me this may be true, but people actively working in the field have an idea what is possible or close (though they can be shocked when something is proved that they thought was out of reach).
I can understand that Alpoge etc, as active mathematicians, would have a very fine tuned sense for what problems to go for, possibly allowing for all of these cases to be multiple/simultaneous independent discovery. My concern regarding bad behavior from the companies relates more to the transcripts and training data.
> was the time just "right" for this
I recently learned about Stuart Kauffman's idea of the "adjacent possible". Short answer: yes.
Unfortunately there is also a reasonable probability that the human proof is wrong. At any given time there are some people working on the Riemann Hypothesis, and today everyone who thinks that they have a proof is strongly motivated to share it, even if they are not 100% sure of its correctness. So you should have a high prior that an incorrect proof will be posted today.
Traditionally yes, but with one of them being AI-first it's more like a slew of things being achieved with AI were being worked on already; the AI was sort of 'born able', and working on it too wasn't a coincidence, just a famous enough problem (or a high enough value vulnerability, etc.) to make someone interested to put AI to work on it.
Assuming the intelligence stabilises the effect will trickle down lower value targets until we've sort of caught up to a steadier state again.
My general feeling is there is a human accessible zeitgeist and an even larger humanity accessible zeitgeist that only powerful LLMs have access to (baseline humans cannot access it because we are not omni-disciplinary enough).
And the more powerful the AI, the more of The Humanity Zeitgeist it can encompass (no AI can yet contain all of it because something something relative entropy of model vs data). The Humanity Zeitgeist contains things that are unwritten that could have been, and human notions that are connectable but no human could have. As amazing as all these breakthroughs have been, I have yet to see any LLM result break this pattern.
Can you give an example of human researchers breaking this pattern, that was not just a purely random discovery?
Many, many discoveries by humans are also "just" realizing two known pieces are in fact connected.
Even a short audit by Astra shows multiple, easy to verify errors across the manuscript.
Maybe it can be repaired with time, but sorry to say this is not anywhere close to a completed proof
Pack it up guys, its not a completed proof, we heard it here first.
No, you heard it first in the blog post you surely read before commenting right
I just let Astra do a short audit of the blogpost.
Which is why they hadn’t published it?
but is it wrong in an interesting and repairable way? Or wrong in a fatal way that collapses the whole proof? If you pass Perelman's proof of the Poincare conjecture into Astra you will also find errors.
How would you know if astra is right or wrong?
The Machine God is omnipotent
And is Astra right? Do you understand what it's complaining about?
How did you come to the conclusion of "not anywhere close"?
Published math papers are full of errors. Most do not matter, because the answer is more or less correct and some technical details are flubbed, but the answer and approach are good enough that it can be made into a correct proof.
I would expect a large number of errors in a manuscript this long, but it would take somebody qualified to determine how bad those errors are.
The fact that well known mathematicians are excited about this proof supersedes any random person with an LLM.
So many people in this thread are sure that they have economic value when their strength, brains, and knowledge are worthless. This is going to be a century of rude awakenings for all!
Well the current economy is built on people building photo sharing apps and other silly bits of questionable objective economic value. I’m doubtful the economy collapses if agents do all the work that requires the most intelligence.
I can be at the same time excited about what AI can do technologially while I am terrified of what it will likely do to me economically.
But what exactly is the alternative plan? Forbid AI so people can keep being valuable members of the economy? I think that is just not gonna work. You've got to basically convince the whole world that people should keep doing things in a way that might soon feel highly inefficient and pointless, beacause they know about the alternative. The genie is out of the bottle - people will always know that and find ways to use it and further develop it to gain an advantage. If you outlaw it, they will just do that in secret.
Don't get me wrong. I am 100% for AI slowdown & regulation, but I think this will still not stop the ultimate final outcome of a completely transformed economy. I know this is a bleak outlook, but I think the only shot we have is slowing it and shaping it, because stopping it just won't happen.
I’m no mathematician, and I’m genuinely curious: how do these things usually work? Are other mathematicians now expected to sit and read through literally a thousand pages of condensed math to review this? And somehow have enough focus to catch subtle mistakes?
Until last year, the answer was yes, other mathematicians would spend months to understand your proof.
But since this year, we now have a quicker answer with AI. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50580084
Do mathematicians realize how insane this is from the outside?
I don’t mean to offend anyone but this just screams inefficient on a massive scale, downright unacceptable as a society to have our brightest people wasting their time like this.
I understand that in the past there was simply no other way. And I am immensely grateful for those who sacrificed their time and sanity in this process. Now we should all be happy that there is another way.
There was another way. Desk reject, major revision. 900 pages is not reviewable. Its practically gibberish. This is being released for fear of being scooped
average tech industry brain rot comment
What exact resource is being waster here? What sthe end of this sentence: "If only these bright people weren't trying to prove rh, we'd have..."?
3 more people working at jane street
Oh, the liquidity!!!
It should be required that all mathematical proofs only be presented in <30-second tictok videos so they can be doomscrolled by mathematicians.
The people reviewing were often experts in the very very niche area of mathematics the paper was written in. So a) it took them less time and b) reading and understanding a proof in their niche is valuable to them.
It's not a waste of time because generally the _result_ in mathematics is not "useful" in the same way that a piece of software is useful.
The most useful thing about a result is understanding it and then being able to apply the approach or ideas or line of reasoning to new problems. _Sometimes_ the statement "out of the box" is useful, but less so than we are used to in a field that "makes things people want".
If a result is not quite correct, that doesn't mean it doesn't have value. On the other hand, spending time reviewing crank physics does not further one's understanding.
Now think about how many people have read the 10000 pages of Wheel of Time
Entertainment is not wasted time, it's humanity.
In my experience, that's how basic research works.
It's a lot of very smart people doing impractical things for a very long time.
What do you think mathematics is and what it's for? Because I think you have a drastically different view to mathematicians, and I think we would be missing not only a lot of beautiful mathematics but also a lot of very useful tools if everyone viewed it like you.
Because it increases and shares understanding?
Now you have to spend months to understand the proof + months to understand whenever ChatGPT hallucinated or not when it claimed that there are errors in this proof.
Yes. Sometimes it takes other mathematician years to fully comprehend and understand 12-page proof, we're not talking about 250k pages and 900 pages.
Before AI, mathematicians would publish a proof (not in Lean) and other mathematicians would check it over months or years. Both steps would be manual. For example, László Babai published a proof of quasipolynomial time for the graph isomorphism problem in 2015. In 2017 Helfgott spotted a subtle error in the proof, which was then amended (as far as I know, the new proof holds).
Yes, the main objective is to review the proof, but the side objective is to understand it and publish papers that are followups, or perhaps that share a few of the initial ideas and then go to another route. In some cases, nobody believe that the proof is worthy and it just sit in a drawer forever.
Now we just feed it to Claude and ask it if it's correct.
So, the work was done without AI, okay. But how likely is it that his colleagues, who were reviewing and advising him, used Claude to do so? Maybe even a year or two ago when they maybe didn't realize that this would end up in the training set?
Yeah, you can’t put anything important to Claude or OpenAI as scientist anymore. And block internet for anyone reviewing.
Use Bedrock....
"With Amazon Bedrock, your content is not used to improve the base models and is not shared with any model providers."
" Users inputs and model outputs are not shared with any model providers."
https://aws.amazon.com/bedrock/faqs/
Quite frankly, I don't believe _any_ of the model providers when they say such a thing, AWS included. And the attitudes expressed in the Anthropic IPO thread towards copyright, theft, and training fair use did nothing to dissuade me that anything of value is always fair game, one way or another, for training.
This would be easy to test, with synthetic data, and I hope somebody does an Arvix paper about it.
I repeat, for the millionth time. You should not trust Amazon. I dont care if you think their reputation depends on it. They do not care about that, they have one of the worlds strongest moats. Nobody is going to stop using AWS because the AI that everyone already expects is stealing or data, is stealing your data.
They do not care, and its ultimately deniable. Also everyone in AI literally offloads all guilt by just saying they got hacked now and nobody thinks otherwise.
You cannot trust Amazon, its wild how many people think you can.
If they respect their terms of service there is no other way to use foundations models than via Bedrock
If they dont, then you can win the biggest settlement in history, and retire as rich as your common billionaire.
You seriously think thats how that goes?
Also pretty easy to deny outright and do it, with hardly anyway to prove other than maybe a whistleblower. I have a hard time believing that Anthropic isnt heavily involved in Bedrock, they arent just sending Amazon their weights files and an instructional manual like its an Ikea coffee table.
I am 1000% sure Anthropic can access your data on AWS Bedrock. (im pretty sure they changed all new contracts as well to state this for auditing "cyber risk")
You make good points, but I would say if their internal controls are good enough for the NSA or NATO: https://aws.amazon.com/federal/top-secret-cloud/
It should be good enough for the GRH.
The NSA or NATO can sue their ass, or spill something about their execs, or inflict very real damage in another way. A maths institute can just complain or cope.
So you are saying they are selective in how they enforce their terms of service? :-)
From the stuff I only know... from watching YouTube...Anthropic trains Claude on AWS: https://youtu.be/KJFnCx0DFsg
Are they not worried their secrets get stolen?
Why would I trust them?
You dont have to trust them, I say trust but verify. But their incentives are more aligned on keeping their terms of service, than giving a freebie to OpenAI and others, especially as they seem to have fired all their AI people...
If you have a solution to the Riemann Hypothesis before anyone else does, then no, don't put that into Bedrock, or any other online LLM service that promises to keep it secret. It's just too valuable to take the risk that the promise falters.
Valuable to the researcher; almost of no value to any commercial entity, surely well below threshold to steal it violating ZDR contracts and what not.
The fact Anthropic and OpenAI keep toying with math problems means, I'd assume, that they have mathematicians working hard on improving the models - seeking 'compute multipliers', and in spare time, they do hobby work with all that compute at their disposal. Like we do with the stupid hobby projects we always wanted to do but never quite had the time to put in the hard work.
Bedrock and such don’t address grandparent’s core point though: most humans still collaborate with other humans and that is a weak link. You almost certainly want to at least gut check some ideas with others and do some sanity checks and that’s where the weakness emerges. Those people are doing you a favor and using their own time to do that. In the past that might be pulling up reference books as they read through. Today that might be a copy paste onto an LLM, or large swaths of it.
So unless you operate in a vacuum or you run in an environment that operates in a vacuum, your ideas can easily leak into training data. Now, how likely they are to get surfaced is a question but when you’re working at the very edge there aren’t likely a lot of competing ideas embedded in training data would be my guess. So its more likely such ideas in frontier mathematics might actually resurface easily.
It’s not like write an analysis to… Robert Frost’s Two Roads Diverged poem where there’s countless of these and maybe a unique take might get buried as noise.
So you need to work in off grid spaces really. I work in a fairly information secure environment and I know for a fact people occasionally use their personal GPT account with sensitive corporate information out of convenience. And some may not be aware of what they may or may not be doing and it’ll likely remain that way for several years.
That's why local LLM is important. If everyone had one, they would not upload a paper just to get summary.
“Not shared with any model providers” != not shared with data brokers who resell it to model providers
how many people hold this level of information discipline?
well if the goal is SCIENCE involuntary sharing with competitors is kinda useful right? If the goal however is fame
Yeah because everyone knows science should be done in secret.
Their whole MO is stealing IP so that tracks
Very conflicted on how to take news like this. Should I be happy and delirious for the science we objectively get to explore regardless of who does it or should I be scared for the commoditization of knowledge that makes someone like me with average talent sidelined? Is this the only way to claim originality against a machine that was trained over all (stolen) data of humanity?
By the linked paper, this has been in the works for 12 years.
I can understand why they're making a "hurried announcement" if they worked on it for 12 years and AI solved it in a few months. If they didn't do it, they could be accused on copying the result of the AI. And if they did it sooner, their work could be stolen. I wouldn't like to be in this position.
Seriously people need to publish intermediate results. This is like sitting on a product idea for 12 years and then someone ships a worse version and gets all the credit.
That is also why they don't publish. They fear their peers/competitors would take the intermediate result which may be the critical step to solve it quicker than them and take the main credit/limelight.
They publish the intermediate when they admit to themselves they there are not going to make any progress in their lives and that intermediate result is their limit.
It is not how all mathematicians think, but the ones who spend 5-10years or more working on a problem do.
That just seems a doom spiral of making the field obsolete
In tech, people publish interesting, non game changing half-ideas all the time. There's incentive to doing that (edification, employment, cool points).
it’s crazy for you, someone who i assume has no personal stakes or experience in the industry, to use a word like “need” so boldly.
But in the industry I do have stakes in, it's a common practice to be rewarded for sharing early and often, to build in public, and gain credibility not just because you claim the prize for the end solution.
I think a lot of outsiders feel frustrated with public investment in academia, when the structures seem to reward someone spending 12 years on a solution with no clear signs of intermediate progress
No shade for the guy who worked on this for 12 years, because he didn't make the incentives that cause this, but all I get from this is that humans could have solved this a decade ago if the incentives were towards collaboration, rather than keeping progress secret in order to eventually get all the credit.
https://philpapers.org/archive/NIEIOM.pdf
This write up is claiming his proposed proof is wrong.
JFC give me a break. Right or wrong surely they ran through AI and found a counter example or something, or is there something bigger there?
The announcement says it's a draft proof
Jenny Lorraine Nielsen is a crank.
Not saying the proof is good (people have put it through AI and found mistakes, not sure how grave they are), but this person has a history of claiming without substance that some established proofs are wrong.
Good to know, ty. Hopefully we can know more conclusively soon.
The least you can do is bring proof when you are calling one a crank. I have no skin in this game; why should we trust the word of an anonymous coward?
Just browse this and you'll convince yourself in no time:
https://philpeople.org/profiles/jenny-lorraine-nielsen/
See the comments on this post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49140869
She's in there alleging that all of her detractors are being paid by the University of Kansas' physics department.
> why should we trust the word of an anonymous coward?
And you are? We are not responsible for correcting or managing your susceptibility to cranks. Go chase some crypto scams.
Her claim is the same error that Astra found.
It's not "her" claim or at least, it is hers in the sense that her name is on it but it's clearly pure llm output.
I'm working on a formalization of the music of primes proof and the Nielsen counterexample is correctly placed in the sketchiest part of the music proof. I'm taking a short detour to attempt to verify the Nielsen counterexample.
https://github.com/ityonemo/music-of-primes
update: Claude +2b4m seem to agree that that the Nielsen claim is correct, crank or otherwise.
I hate to be a gatekeeper or some sort of elitist, but "I asked an LLM and it agreed" is very far from a convincing argument.
It runs it through a theorem prover "2b4m" that makes it easy to {thread the flow of abstract logicall arguments, and bootstrap off of "well known math"}. This is not a complete formalization but it strongly narrows the scope of errors to a tight set of errors (incompatible theories that look compatible e.g. differing signals conventions or off-by-ones, or subtle definitional differences, or mistakes in the cited well known proofs, bug in 2b4m)
Also had ChatGPT take a look at the various shitposts on twitter and reddit about this.
For what its worth its final conclusions are:
My assessment has strengthened from “major gaps” to “provably false intermediate results.” There is no reasonable basis to accept the released manuscript as a GRH proof.
With this being what it finds as major problems (collecting together the various things people have posted on Social Media).
https://chatgpt.com/space/page_707a0c5751d08191a721dd5f075e3...
Edit: Shit spaces are so broken on the app.
https://pastebin.com/i0UPcdQV
Well if ChatGPT says it, it must be true
Gemini 4 Neon and Opus 5.5 have also found several flaws that go beyond missing polish. I use Opus a lot for maths (different field so less than anecdotal evidence) and I trust it to atleast not be confidently wrong. It's conservative when making such claims without good backing.
Are you actually tying them to a theorem prover?
Blindly trusting AI for everything is problematic, but when Astra says a math proof has a problem the mathproof usually had a problem.
Your chat is private
My bad. Spaces permissions are broken. I tried changing it but it doesn't seem to work.
The two claims are likely correct but not major flaws, they don't affect the most important part. But the latter seems to include several flaws too, most notably in theorem 11.1.2.1(2) on p. 480 onward.
> S(G) the space of Schwartz-Bruhat functions on a Hausdorff locally compact abelian group G.
I'm done.
Hausdorff locally compact => the space behaves kinda like a lattice, where each point you're interested in is "alone" in its neighborhood
abelian group => a group which commutes, eg a.b <=> b.a
Schwartz-Bruhat functions => functions which pretty quickly go to 0 as their vectors go to infinity, so they kinda are "bumpy" in some finite place, then everywhere else is 0-ish
Ok now explain what all those explanations mean lol
I think to have a shot at wrapping your mind around that original sentence, you will need at least a working understanding of linear algebra and abstract algebra, and to some extent calculus/analysis/topology, in an undergraduate sense.
But, to wit:
neighborhood - a bunch of points "close" to a point you're interested in. These points might be in some high dimensional space, so it's not just (x,y), instead it's (x1,x2,...,xn).
lattice - a grid of integers in a high dimensional space, think the intersections on a sheet of graph paper for 2d, then try to picture more dimensions
group - think of a rubik's cube; it has some operation (rotating a side 90deg), and state. Rubik's cubes are not abelian, since if you turn the upper layer cw then the right layer cw, it gives a different cube state than right layer cw followed by upper layer cw. In the terminology of my comment, call "upper layer clockwise" "a" and call "right layer clockwise "b", and call the operation which sequences these moves ".", then we would say a.b != b.a, because the order matters.
I think the last one is pretty self-explanatory, so if you have specific questions please ask.
Heh, thanks, I was making the comment partly in jest because mathematics is notorious for having the most dense and unforgivable rabbit holes. By the time you get to the point where you go "Ok, yeah, I get that" you are a thousand miles from problem you set out to understand
I think it's mostly a matter of familiarity with the arcane; just like there was a time where you had no clue what "public static void main class Main" or whatever the invocation is, now you read it and dont even blink. It's just that math has sooo many nooks and crannies that without the arcane definitions we would be lost in word soup, and it would be mostly unnecessary since youre already familiar with the concepts
What’s the point of this comment?
He just loves math.
Mathematics reminds me of the Star Trek TNG episode "Darmok" where Captain Picard encounters Tamarians, aliens who communicate only by historical and mythological references:
"Darmok and Jalad at Tanagra" => Two strangers or rivals cooperating against a common threat
"Temba, his arms wide" => Offering a gift, help, or an open opportunity
"Schwartz, his functions Bruhat" => ...
On the one hand, I really hate math's tendency to name things after people, because other than the name itself it gives no handles to understand what they mean. You can study math for tens years straight, but if you encounter the (made-up) Frisselweiss-Gaurdendot theorem you still have no idea what it is from the name... even if it was literally the next thing you'd cover in some class tomorrow.
On the other hand I can't see any better system. Mathematics burned through all the names you could reasonable hope for a human natural language to provide at least two centuries ago and we'd be well into some pretty arbitrary names no matter how you slice it.
It used to be worse, they used to name everything after Euler back in the day.
I've been trying to solve this comprehension problem for maybe 15 years through various interfaces ... I think I finally figured it out ... It'll be free of course but it will break the jargon loop where you find the only definition of jargon is done through more arcane and sophisticated jargon and each of those jargon use even more arcane and obtuse jargon to define it and everything ends up being absolutely impenetrable.
I know some people will come in defense of this system and I haven't gotten into the solution but let me explain it very very simply
You are sitting in say Spanish I. You ask what a word means and the answer uses Spanish II vocabulary. You ask about those words and each is answered using Spanish III. Then you ask about those and each is answered using Spanish IV. And now it's just a useless pile of words you don't know.
i love algebraic number theory and learned a little bit about it in a past life
it's very cool that there are multiple ways to arrive at this result because that means more things will be understood about the integers as a result, and so if i have a vested interest here it's that. i want some cool mathematics to come out of it and i want to learn and understand some of it, not having had as much contact with mathematics as i'd like in years
many people also hoped for the proof of the riemann hypothesis to involve the creation of some insane new technology like "F_1 geometry" [0]
i am far from being an expert and only have enough background to appreciate the overall directions each of these proofs takes. with that said:
the human proof at a high level looks to be in the spirit of hilbert–pólya [1], connes, etc: doing spectral theory with prime numbers ("primes are like atoms in a gas", "primes are like geodesics on a 3-manifold", etc) and expressing a sum in two ways, one as an L-function, one as a sum over the spectrum of an operator, and showing that everything on the right side can be accounted for by zeros on the line so nothing remains. masullo makes a big deal in the preface of the fact that his method cannot possibly work in characteristic p
the alpöge–claude one (which i understand even less, having read remark.pdf and discussed the lean output with some llms) involves several pieces of very hard machinery being applied to translate the way stepanov proved rh over curves in characteristic p to the characteristic zero (reals, complex numbers) case, which is hard because a lot of tools you have vanish entirely. this is very much in the tradition of the langlands program
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Field_with_one_element
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hilbert%E2%80%93P%C3%B3lya_con...
I was happy when Kasparov lost to Deep Blue, it was special, we can make these damn machines compete.
I was sad when Lee Sa-Dol lost to AlphaGo, realization that one day the machines will just beat us via sheer brute force.
I'm crying now when someone in a month could beat 12 years of effort due to AI.
If the models that were used to do this were open, if we were already living, or at least have a decent plan to build, a society where all the scientific advancements that can be built with such models would actually improve people's life I would be extremely joyful.
I am terrified we are already living in the cyberpunk dystopia
The valuable models are kept in house.
The governance model of the Anthropic IPO gives absolute power forever to the founders.
They claim to strive towards the good of humanity.
The silent part is that they will be the ones deciding what good means for the rest of us.
This will end in tears.
The chess example shows it might not be that bad in the end. Magnus Carlsen's entire career came after Deep Blue but you still know who he is.
because he is an entertainer. He is no different than a basketball player. I don't want to be a monkey in a cage. I want to accomplish things.
on the other hand, think about all the problems we are able to solve now, the horizon has just expanded.
It's not someone in a month.
Using AI is literally standing on the shoulders of giants.
It is using the training data from all of human history.
It is the power of many over the power of one.
The more effectively we can use the works of others, the faster each of us can go. There nothing better at that than AI right now.
I find it curious how neither the title nor any of the section headers in the table of contents, mention GRH. They also don't say “Riemann zeta function”, or even “prime” (except in the title). Is this because a sufficiently clued-in mathematician can tell from the titles that that's what it's about? I realize that I'm not in the target audience but seems weird.
Mathematicians absolutely know what it is about. Just "RH" would suffice to trigger "wtf".
Do human mathematicians need to publish more incrementally? Seems many are hoping they’ll save up their findings for one big bang finding?
IMO academia could benefit from lower key, more tech blog style discussions of their work, and get away from this attempt to only publish the final result.
low key tech blog content can be automatically generated now
If you publish incrementally you don't get to write your name on discoveries in blood, win prizes, etc.
Someone else scoops up and runs ahead with your work.
In an ideal world, where there is no ego and clout chasing, your proposed way is of course much better.
Agent swarms doing research for example don't have these ego issues.
That sounds like a broken system not actually helping the field advance.
People should feel free to write about half baked ideas and whimsical hypothesis. That should be rewarded.
This focus on being first on a problem is about to become very outmoded.
Trouble is, nobody's going to call this hypothetical approach the Softwaredoug Half Baked Whimsy.
This is basically the way the world works, not just mathematics or academia. Someone always captures most of the value and it's not usually the one that did most of the work.
I don't think the tech space works this way. People get a lot of credit for half-baked ideas / moving fast breaking things. For better or worse.
Funny you mention "moving fast, breaking things" as that comes from Facebook. Zuckerberg captured most of the value and the Winklevoss twins were left will relatively little in comparison.
It is, I find it liberating in some sense. You will have all of these ego people grasping for straws, trying to desperately prove their value just to be sniped and outdone by a random model for 0.06$
At some point when they have come to terms with that perhaps their value was their place in society regardless of their output, we can start building something meaningful.
Maybe now that LLMs are claiming credit for mathematical advances, humans can be free from this status-seeking game and actually start doing maths
Some are cautious about hinting their competitors. Incremental pushes are hints for everyone else and they get scooped.
That seems like an outdated model and not really in the spirit of scientific collaboration
You gotta eat.
Scientific collaboration happens through publishing, not giving away the ideas/credit before publishing. Sure, there's collaboration, but that's not with the entire community, especially not in math which for big results is an all-or-nothing endeavor.
Also outdated since when? We've just seen a scandal about OpenAI scooping Levent on Navier Stokes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Navier–Stokes_priority_controv...
For a proof like this, I assume many of the components are interesting enough to be published on their own. The authors just don't.
Compared to solving RH say in a few months they are not interesting enough to be published on their own prior to that.
I agree that it is inefficient, but I understand why mathematicians work like this.
As I understand how credit goes for mathematical discovery, if you do 99.9% of the work and then I come in and put the last couple steps that make it actually work as a proof instead of a bunch of useful lemmas, the proof has my name on it.
Agreed. I know nothing about the field, but I always assumed that mathematics was the gold standard of an open, collaborative scientific process (especially considering how mathematicians are known to hold most other fields in contempt for not being as "pure" as them). If one mathematician sitting on a work-in-progress proof in total radio silence, for 12 years, is not uncommon, then clearly I thought wrong.
This is an issue across academia. Unlike the technology sector which is flush with 'risk capital' academics rely on grants. In order for grants to be dispensed, the funders need to have some way of quantifying a researcher's productivity. Papers and citations are the primary way to do this.
There may be opportunities to strategically 'thin slice' your research into a dozen groundbreaking papers, but generally it does not serve you well to publish half of an insight if you are giving an opportunity for other labs to scoop you and funnel all of the scarce funding to their institutions instead.
Then it would be a game of 9 ball - last "potter" wins.
>Do human mathematicians need to publish more incrementally?
Yes, if you want a job in academia. Publications begets funding which begets more publications etc. Ideally you just solve the problem you want to solve and not worry about putting out partial results. But there is a time pressure to prove your productivity - you are not going to have much to show for 3 years of work if you aim to solve only the hardest problems in math. Interestingly, it's not clear the author held an academic position after his PhD.
Yes, they need to use Agile/Scrum. They need to create small JIRA stories that can be completed in a single math sprint. 12 years on a single story makes it hard to manage the expectations for the math customers.
There are errors in it that may or may not be fixable. It would be sad if they didn't use AI to look for holes because they were paranoid that AI companies would steal their work.
paranoid of AI companies' standard operating procedure is just caution and care against thieves. just like security cameras at your house are.
Paranoia means unfounded suspicion. In this case, it’s completely sane to assume that AI companies will steal your data.
In November 2026, even publicly available models operating with small budgets are better than top mathematicians at developing proofs. AI labs' internal models, backed by much larger budgets, are significantly better still. It would be extremely silly for those labs to steal any math-related user data. So it is paranoia.
Whose data did they use to train these models? did they compensate everyone for the data they used?
Big AI has committed piracy on a massive scale, and they've gotten away with it.
I agree but that's a separate issue.
I think the argument "they trained models on publicly available data, I think that's stealing, so therefore I am certain they are going to steal everything else, including training on customers' data when the customers have explicitly opted out of this, violating their contract and permanently destroying their own reputation if they get caught" is not a good one, and should probably stop being made.
I don't even think the argument works if it starts "they committed genuine piracy which was commonly known to be illegal at the time".
I feel like using the term "Piracy" to describe training on public data is a bit of a stretch.
Because public data is the wrong term. Published, copyrighted data is the correct term.
Now we can debate if the model weights are a derivative work of that data, more or less than my old hard disk that learned from a dvd with a ripper and is happy to share that knowledge with the internet over bittorrent. The latter is often described as “piracy”.
It's the not the copying that is illegal though, it's the sharing. I haven't been able to get any free copyrighted content out of an LLM though
It really depends on whether an llm is considered a definitive work in regards to the GPL; in my opinion it is.
Just to be clear, the difference between the older models and the newer models in terms of mathematics ability is not from having trained on even more papers, but by reinforcement learning on the act of proving theorems. Anthropic now spends about as much on this training phase as on the 'pretraining' with the masses of scraped or scanned data. This doesn't mean it's not still essential, but it's far from the entirety of the result either.
Why would it be silly? Don't they do it with impunity
Especially given that they already have, and at a massive scale.
That's crazy. That would require implementing a huge expensive scanning infrastructure that tries to filter out interesting math claims from hundreds of millions of LLM queries. Finding a needle in a haystack would be far easier. It's completely deluded to think that LLM companies would do such a thing rather than just using their own internal models that are already better than most mathematicians anyway. Not to mention the legal trouble if this ever leaked.
Will any of these math discoveries lead to more concrete discoveries in other fields, or are they simply 'puzzles'?
Usually not anytime soon, but then quaternions had no practical use upon discovery and are now ubiquitous.
That's different because quaternions were discovered in the 1800s. I don't think they would have no use if they were discovered in the 2000s.
The thing with RH is that there are a ton of theorems that are already proved assuming the RH is true. So anyone proving the RH will indirectly prove all stading theorems relying on it.
Like, immediately? Probably not. It takes humanity time to digest this stuff and mingle it with other things. Maybe AI will speed that up a bit, but who knows.
On the other hand, it was took 2-3 generations to go from abstract point set topology a la Hausdorff to topological vector spaces & differential equations to quantum mechanics to computers and nuclear weapons.
The Riemann Hypothesis is curiously enough connected to quantum systems via the Hilbert–Pólya conjecture. One such instance of this is a correspondence between the energy spacings of chaotic quantum systems and the statistical spacings of the higher zeros on the critical line. So deeply understanding RH can lead to better tools to understand quantum systems
It might be impactful for cryptography because it allows deeper insight in how prime numbers are distributed.
Given this proof is orders of magnitude shorter, seems like we could have AI translate it into Lean without much of an issue to see if it checks out.
People immediately tried, but it's not possible because the proof is currently incomplete and has errors (which is acknowledged in the manuscript--it was published prematurely because of the other RH proof coming out). Unclear if the author will be able to repair and finish the proof.
> It is all human, with no AI. The hope was to bring Alessandro to Stanford for a year to polish the writing and then announce it after running it by enough people. Now it seems best to put out the current draft.
It's a little like the Patch Gap, but for math proofs.
I don't get this argument. Once you have verified it in "ugly" writing, why spend a year polishing it, when any minute an AI-proof could come around the corner.
Only seems to make sense when "polishing the writing" really means "filling the gaps". But then this is not a proof yet. Could still turn out to have gaps that cannot be filled as the approach is just not working.
> when any minute an AI-proof could come around the corner
Very, very few people saw this coming except as a tail possibility. Which is always true anyways for other humans solving it first.
Because they don't want thousands of interested mathematicians to pore over it immediately, and quickly publish similarly impactful simplifications, generalisations, etc. – they want to publish first with a pretty good version.
(No doubt a lot of mathematicians are now using AI for that, whether or not they were/planning to.)
> Because they don't want thousands of interested mathematicians to pore over it immediately, and quickly publish similarly impactful simplifications, generalisations, etc. – they want to publish first with a pretty good version.
I'm not a mathematician so I don't mean these questions rhetorically, but does that really make sense? Wouldn't the first valid proof still gain huge kudos, mathematical immortality, etc., regardless of whether it was polished or not? And then you could still go ahead and work on improving it, even if others were doing so. The risk:reward of waiting seems out of whack to me, unless you think the chance of getting scooped is truly negligible.
(I'm not either fwiw) think of the complexity of matrix multiplication for example – if you have a novel approach that gives a new lower bound, you'll want to put some time and thought into ensuring it's the 'lowest lower bound' you can reasonably find that way for the most impressive result, not overshadowed by someone using the same approach to go lower too quickly.
A similar example here might be someone realising they can extend it to the extended Reimann hypothesis. Or simply cutting out a load of steps to prove the same thing more straightforwardly and intuitively.
Is it common for mathematicians to keep a polished version of their work? I'm surprised by how quickly they are able to put work out after it's been contested, and this is 940 pages of well-formatted text, from the looks of it.
It's common for them to type it up as soon as they have some faith that the proof is valid, because that is the version they send to other mathematicians to confirm before the proof is officially published. Brian Conrad was in the process of reviewing this proof, so it makes sense that it's been written up. They were probably waiting to submit it for publication until multiple mathematicians confirmed its validity, but Anthropic forced their hand.
Yes of course.
I only write up in LaTeX in almost polished form, the unpolished part is in the pen and paper stage.
If it’s written using LaTeX it will look polished and well-formatted without any extra effort. If you do put in the tiny bit of extra effort to use microtype it’s going to look almost impeccably polished.
If you like LaTeX formatting, at least.
It is said that others have been reviewing this human-written proof for months, so the publication presumably was waiting for the finalization of the reviews, until the Anthropic announcement forced an immediate publication.
I’m wholly unqualified to evaluate the math, but even skimming the paper reveals that it’s definitely a draft. The very first section doesn’t even have content yet.
It’s reasonable that someone would focus on the core first and only fill out the paper after the math was verified.
The formatting is just what you get from LaTeX.
This feels like a "Move 37*" moment that will go down in the history of AI.
A poetic John Henry style duel between man and machine. Potentially one of the last...
Move 37*
Edited, thanks
... after we eliminate the possibility that none of Masullo's work was ingested by Anthropic's model.
Like what credit does the machine deserve when it's made by training from all of humanities work, and builds off the collective work of humanity explicitly during inference.
> after we eliminate the possibility that none of Masullo's work was ingested by Anthropic's model
what for? people seem to be in pretty clearly agreement that these proofs are not similar whatsoever
I strongly believe that the reason AI is able to find solutions to these millennial math problems (or any tough problem for that matter) is because of its compute capacity. Our brain is limited in the number of ways that it can think or correlate at a single point in time.
If we can link up 20 different theorems at a time, AI can probably do 2*10^(unknown). If someone finds a way to map a mathematician’s IQ to Neural Net activation for a frontier model and then have a go at these problems, a mathematician would win.
yikes. I hope this is mostly correct and he gets credit!! :-(
And a retrospective review of all past discoveries, now that who published first does not mater.
It will reflect so profoundly poorly when this human proof is found incorrect, even with all the gaps filled in, it's incredible.
The amount of bikeshedding that will be spent on debating whether it is actually flawed, and even if it is, whether it is irreparably so, is going to be absolutely biblical.
If RH and GRH being proven by AI is apathy inducing, this may really dig the heel in fully. Not only would it mean humanity losing, this would mark us a very sore loser. What a humiliation through and through.
I can’t help but this that AI copied the original work at least in part.
Maybe he had some files in the cloud. Or worse - was listening in.
Is there a way to find out if the human proof was at copied in any way?
they're very different strategies
> Yup. This has to be it. Even if it turns out ta be false, there has to be some other way this happened, because I assume what I am trying to show! They stole it. My assumption is not wrong. I will make it fit by hypotheticals or unprovable assumptions
But I can tell you in honesty how claude did it: I was actually the person who proved GRH (and all other problems for that matter) and gave it to claude, told it to send Alpöge a Note, but that I would get the money.
mistake in the proof: https://philpapers.org/archive/NIEIOM.pdf
The race between humans and machines just turned up some more. But some things are inevitable, like the pull of gravity causing things to fall. And the machines eventually winning all races.
Dread it. Run from it. Destiny arrives all the same. And now it's here.
woah! If this proof is correct it's likely much more valuable than a giant lean file!
Anyway, it's time to put Tom Lehrer's Lobachevsky on my playlist.
> If any message at all this work is meant to send to the mathematician who feels discouraged by the pace and tone of the current climate, it is this: we are still here. We are very much alive. We are not going anywhere.
Dang...
I sincerely hope this is right because I see inherent value in math as a human endeavor. Proving GRH, which we already believed to be true, has no conceivable economic implications: it doesn't improve the productivity of factories, it doesn't let you ship new products, it doesn't allow us to reach the stars. The result matters a lot less than the process of getting there.
Because of this, I find it repulsive that we use this endeavor as a benchmark for AI labs, where they throw tens of millions of dollars just to steamroll a small but prestigious academic field. The damage is already done, but I'm still gonna root for team human. I want us to carve some areas of human activity that LLMs are not allowed to take over. Math, along with art and writing, seems like reasonable candidates.
"we produced a result and nobody learned anything in the process" is incompatible with how human society is supposed to function
> "we produced a result and nobody learned anything in the process" is incompatible with how human society is supposed to function
You see, the goal is to tear down human society. The first one to do it could get very rich, and will leave quite a mark on history.
“If any message at all this work is meant to send to the mathematician who feels discouraged by the pace and tone of the current climate, it is this: we are still here. We are very much alive. We are not going anywhere.”
Does this mean that as Alessandro Massulo started using AI's to speed up this process, his findings were leaked through training - causing Claude to find the result for someone else?
For some the notion that LLMs cannot generate anything original seems to be such a core belief that from AI generating RH proof must follow that a human proof somehow leaked into the training.
everything inside the models is from human content, what delusional world do you live in?
As is everything in a human brain. Yet still somehow we are able to generate new ideas from that.
I don't understand why the mere idea something like this could happen in other forms of neural networks makes people so mad that they start insulting instead of arguing.
That being said I just realized that my initial comment was also somewhat insulting. So I'm sorry for that. I'm just quite surprised how quickly we would jump to the conclusion that this AI proof can only come from a leaked human proof. (Also since it is already established that this was a human-AI collaboration and not only a one-prompt thing).
> Yet still somehow we are able to generate new ideas from that.
It's a chunk of meat evolved over millions of years. Hell the foundation for a brain has been laid a billion years ago.
And now you're here telling me it's the same?
Hm first I didn't say it's the same. Human brains and LLMs obviously have a different composition and also seem to work quite differently.
What I say is that there is so far no evidence indicating that this different kind of neural network is fundamentally incabable of generating novel ideas (like an RH proof). Yet there are a lot of indications telling us that it might very well be capable to do that. This is why I find it odd that so many people on HN seem to outright refute that idea without giving it the benefit of the doubt.
>chunk of meat evolved over millions of years
I don't think that the means or duration of development of a system alone say anything about the capabilities that will ultimately emerge. Besides, evolution likely didn't optimize human brains for thinking about the Riemann Hypothesis, while LLMs have been optimized for exactly that sort of reasoning work.
Not sure that is true anymore. These models go through insane reinforcement learning training to get super human skills. So they kind of learn to solve it by themselves by comparing whether the final answer is correct or not.
So this is some sort of reaction to the Anthropic Generalized Riehman Hypothesis discovery?
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50574968
Is there a chance the situation will force math scientists to become more collaborative, publish their work earlier even if unfinished to spread ideas better instead is locking themselves for many years in solitary confinement to try to take all the credit, but lose all the benefits of distributed intelligence?
They are pretty collaborative; this professor (Zhang?) is posting a manuscript from Masullo that another mathematician, Conrad, has been checking over for a few months. Stanford was planning to give him a residency to clean up the manuscript, so it has been circulating for comment for a while, enough to impress senior researchers there such as to extend the invitation, no?
No. Collaborative science isn't when a small clique is in some know when it is readying completion, but when a random guy on the other side of the world with no institutional connection can stumble on a publicly available intermediate result / idea and contribute something
I feel for the guy, but what frustrates me is that a lot of people (including, I would guess, probably the majority of the people on this platform) will take this as some sort of an excuse that AI is not getting better. The new cope will be that it somehow cheated and found his solution. The 4 minute mile effect is real.
I have a feeling this news is waited until Anthropic goes public. Same goes with the Blackhole news. I am not disputing the achievement (I have no credentials for it), but wondering timing of it to hype the stock price
Came a day late though. After the IPO the gains don't go straight to them and don't maximize the cap raise. I guess it's all just happening so fast atm.
But what is the Riemann zeta function? Visualizing analytic continuation (3blue1brown): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sD0NjbwqlYw
man this is all just so insane
@AcerFur (former openai math employee on twitter) claims there are issues with this proof: https://x.com/AcerFur/status/2123853069599547786
Maybe repairable, but either way, alpoge/anthropic certainly has the claim to the first proof
Can confirm that current GPT (with no guidance) took 5 minutes to find what it claims are errors with counterexamples. (I have nowhere near the level of state-of-the-art mathematical knowledge and experience needed to validate them. I'm posting this solely as additional confirmation of "there may be issues with this proof that an actual mathematician together with LLM assistance would be able to properly evaluate".)
And that is the problem.
AI claims but too few people can check.
Won‘t get better from now on
I mean I guess there is incentive for some human curiosity and trying to learn more than ever, small bit but still to get a standard for verification.
I wouldn't be surprised if these models were aligned to extreme skepticism (to the point of hallucination) when e.g. a user proposes a solution to a Millennium Prize Problem.
1) There's a meaningful difference between "I'm not buying it based on my priors" and "I'm claiming to have a counterexample". I'm looking forward to seeing analysis by other mathematicians.
2) Any model with properly updated priors will have less skepticism of a Millennium Prize Problem being solved now.
Did you try the same with the other LLM assisted proofs? I would be curious what your GPT model says about them. I fed Alpöge and Anthropic statement and details to Gemini 4 hydrogen, and it said that there are "major problems and red flags in both the text and the current verification status", and that it is impossible to verify the 250k pages of slop, and there are there are "Extraordinary, unsubstantiated mathematical leaps in the sketch". So I would take these surface level reviews by LLMs with a grain of salt.
Anyhow, I hope that they are both right!
The LLM-authored proof is too large to fit in the context of any of the models available to consumers
What value is there in just dumping something into an LLM and saying it produced errors?
edit: to all the people responding that LLMs are good at math, I'm going to paste a reply I wrote downthread...
I'm not arguing that LLMs aren't useful tools for mathematicians, I'm questioning the quality of discourse that amounts to "I pasted this into the LLM and it said there are errors"
Have you tried doing this recently? For my work on software at least, the latest LLMs have a very low false positive rate for bugs. They almost never hallucinate issues. My understanding is the same applies to math.
I'm not arguing that LLMs aren't useful tools for mathematicians, I'm questioning the quality of discourse that amounts to "I pasted this into the LLM and it said there are errors".
There's value in knowing whether a claim is true or false. Plugging things into an LLM doesn't necessarily give 100% certainty or tell us why something is true or false in a human-comprehensible way, but it can move our credences and suggest directions for investigation.
If you're not even gonna share what the supposed errors were, the value is pretty much infinitesimal.
Surely, GPT said something more elaborate than "nuh uh".
That has nothing to do with anything. This post is just a tweet from some guy who said ChatGPT found errors, with no mention of what those purported errors are. This is a complete crap post and should be flagged.
classic HN isolated demand for rigor. i found it interesting
Think of it as a (fuzzy) compiler.
Now think about complaining that someone "merely pasted my code into a compiler and said that there are errors in my code."
That's nuts, right? If a compiler -- a kind of proof engine -- finds errors, there are errors. Fix them! Don't complain about the usage of a compiler, the errors were real, they're there, they need to be fixed.
The fuzziness part is both useful and a liability, but the error rate is dropping.
Some numbers for you:
A year ago, I ran a huge legacy codebase through Gemini Pro 2.5 and it spat out several thousand bugs, but manual inspection showed that 80% were false positives and only 20% were worth fixing.
I did a similar exercise with GPT 5.6 more recently, and the hit rate was 80% valid and 20% false positive. The human developer got into an argument saying that they thought all 100% were false positives. He lost. The AI could easily produce "repro" snippets that triggered every issue (mostly security vulnerabilities, but some correctness ones too).
These days, if you're publishing anything with verifiable claims in it, and not running it through an AI first, it's the direct equivalent of uploading open source code to GitHub without bothering to check that it compiles first.
It's sloppy.
I write a program that compiles and appears to work and has been checked over by other programmers for months. Someone posts a tweet on X saying that ChatGPT found errors in the program, with nary a hint as to what those errors are.
That's comparable to what we have here. It's a completely crap post and should be flagged.
Pre-chatgpt 5.5 it hallucinated quiet a bit on hard math. Starting from 5.6 it is incredibly good.
I would guess that LLMs are much worse at math without having a theorem prover to validate approaches with. Since this draft is not formalized, an LLM is operating purely on the text which is more tenuous.
I’m doing it daily and it finds a bunch of issues which are not issues in practice.
I suspect LLMs are much better trained and more reliable at bug identification in react apps than draft-state proofs on the bleeding edge of math, on problems that are specifically highlighted as extremely difficult to solve without error in their training.
Cool story.
I have the opposite experience in my line of work.
What's your line of work?
> the latest LLMs have a very low false positive rate for bugs.
Man people live in different worlds, astra for me finds 25/6 bugs all the time.
That has nothing to do with anything. You posted a tweet from some guy who said ChatGPT found errors, with no mention of what those purported errors are. This is a complete crap post and should be flagged.
Also,
> alpoge/anthropic certainly has the claim to the first proof
is nonsense ... many "proofs" of RH have been published that turned out to be wrong. We don't yet know whether that is the case for Alpöge, and we won't know until/unless the Millenium Prize is handed out in two years.
FYI Alpoge's proof of RH (and GRH) has been verified now. The Lean was checked to be a valid proof and the statement is correct. There is no reasonable doubt it's wrong.
It's being hurriedly announced as fully human work. I wonder if the author had carefully avoided ever running the full argument through frontier LLMs (OpenAI/Anthropic) for fear of it being stolen or incorporated into AI training.
This may be the first time this proof is being proof-read by frontier models
(this is pure speculation, but provides an answer to your question)
I also suspect the author actively tried to avoid using AI at all.
Another possible reason: AI will correct your mistakes by using ideas of others. A proof will unlikely remain human-only, even if you just use AI to check for your errors.
Seriously. At least be constructive. Share what the errors were. Make an effort to understand them, anything. That tweet just amounts to low effort FUD.
Very high value. The LLMs are excellent at auditing math proofs.
https://XNotMe.com/AcerFur/status/2123853069599547786
> but either way, alpoge/anthropic certainly has the claim to the first proof
Is that a thing? Don't people care more about the proof's elegance and insight than its timing?
Yes. That has always been the beauty of it all: the human discovery. Perhaps mathematics awards should be abolished; instead, recognition should be given to the human being in their capacity as a "prompter" or an "AI assistant."
Darwin only published because Wallace came to him (wrote to him, to be precise - Wallace was living in Indonesia at the time) and said that he'd figured out how species are born. Darwin had been writing what was basically a giant proof of it but wasn't going to publish until his enormous book was done. When he realized he was potentially being scooped, he a) made sure Wallace got credit at the Royal Academy too by having them read both papers back to back and b) published the Origin instead of his giant tome.
Today everybody knows Darwin's name and only nerds know Wallace. Timing (and seniority) matters!
Yeah, it's a thing, for example the clay institute award goes to first proof, and if you look at any pre-AI news about theorems being proven it's always about who's first. Are you asking this question in good faith?
> Are you asking this question in good faith?
Yes, I'm just not into maths. I think Terry Tao highlighted the difference between a proof that teaches you "A is true" vs a proof that enlightens you and has broad implications.
This lacks much in the way of credentials.
You know this kind of off-hand remark with minimal effort outside of pasting into GPT or retweeting another’s 2 cents degrades what was always implicit in human effort, that it is of worth.
We are not machines, we _care_ about the man or woman behind the result, your chiming in, expending a few minutes of your time, is becoming of a dilettante. It depresses me to think that this is not only becoming more prevalent but common.
I’m embarrassed on your behalf. Here is to a future where the man in the arena is slung by formally verified arrows.
Guess you're not yet on board with the new future where we are all called to do nothing but CONSOOM and not bother at all about the source or process used to make what we're consooming.
Ok, would you rather nobody comment on the correctness of this proof until a human expert spends weeks finding the same issue?
Credit to were credit is due, nonethless crazy times that just in such a short time millenium problems have been solved.
Related (2 days ago): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50556661
Masullo is classical and Alpöge is jazz.
In Masullo, primes, zeros, and infinity are different manifestations of an underlying topological structure. Primes are periodic orbits, Archimedean places act as attracting loci, and zeros appear as spectral information. The critical line at 1/2 emerges naturally from the way Fourier analysis connects the additive and multiplicative structures of the number system. This fits into the RH tradition of Weil, Connes, Deninger, etc.
In Alpöge, primes and infinity are tied together by an underlying constraint, which translates into information about the zeros. There's a balance between primes and infinity: you iterate theta lifts m times to generate divisibility at finite primes; the Archimedean contribution makes those lifts expensive, and it turns out that m ~ √X is the optimal way to balance the two. This is alien-tier math: he's effectively manufacturing an analogue of higher-order multiplicity for integers, using iterated theta lifts as a substitute for differentiation.
Masullo may offer the deeper explanation of why RH is true; Alpöge may give mathematics a more powerful tool for discovering new truths.
What is a theta lift? Do you have any intuition for what is going on at the core of this proof?
(Also did you write this or did an LLM?)
If true, this could be the last great intellectual achievement in mathematics produced solely by human effort.
Vale!
is there any hint here that anthropic used the same techniques, like with the navier-stokes equation? Feels awful to have to ask, because Levent seems like a genuinely just talented and interested new kind of mathematician, but it could have been done without his knowledge.
So, I like to think of myself as math brained. I keep up with most papers but my first reaction reading this is oh my god…
Oh my god!
It’s beautiful.
So what does that imply? Whatever someone is currently working on using a computer connected to the Internet is used for training LLMs?
Given that people have already found errors that most likely cannot be fixed in this proof, it doesn't show really anything.
Is not this an opportunity to provide someone a locked service? A third-party cloud service who host the model and guarantee that nothing leaves the service. Of course trust and hack are the risks.
Wow, I wasn't expecting this for sure. On the same year a human mathematician attempting full GRH?!
There have been many _attempts_, most of which probably have never been published
I wouldn't be expecting it only if it turned out to be a valid solution.
This is wonderful, go humanity!
I'm not a math expert nor that great at math but I think RSA is still safe
Do they have a lean proof, or just human-readable version?
Unfortunately the proof seems to be invalid: https://philarchive.org/rec/NIEIOM
This woman is a crank, she has popped up before to offer AI-written proofs of a whole bunch of things wildly outside her area of expertise.
There may be issues with the OP proof, but I would not trust her opinion. I was taken in a few months ago by a similar paper. That domain is for self-published papers only, and has seen a massive uptick in new papers in the past year.
Going only by the recent paper titles on her Google Scholar, it seems that you're right, but man... this state of affairs sucks. One part of the beauty of math is supposed to be that you can evaluate arguments on their own rather than by association, and the introduction of giant walls of text without peer review sure removed a big chunk of that. Maybe Lean fixes this eventually, but right now the tool still seems a bit too subtle with different kernel versions, libraries etc., so there aren't that many Lean experts yet (that I know of).
I'm not a mathematician, but why would you trust someone's retort delivered in < 24 hours, versus the 940-page proof being written for twelve years?
I hope that taking the time to produce a legible write-up instead of releasing the proof up front doesn't bite him back. It would be great if, looking back in history, all contributions to solving the hypothesis were attributed fairly; but that's largely up to mathematicians themselves!
I wonder about the cause and effect. Is this only that this hurried announcement is released in response to Alpöge's publication today, or could Alpöge also have known about another mathematician whose work on proving GRH was close to completion — and felt compelled to release first? Especially given the statement in this draft that "[t]he math is complete".
931 pages... that is pretty crazy.
Anything you do novel or interesting that might earn a lot of money NOT as a registered enterprise (and thus having privacy restrictions on model training in place with your licenses) with but utilizing frontier model services enters into a dangerous game where they are incentivized to steal and publish or otherwise market that business before you.
We need local models NOW.
We need distillation NOW.
Cannot imagine doing anything for any kind of accolade. Truly weird
Jeez, you wait ages for a proof of the Riemann hypothesis and then two come along at once. Typical.
It's not all that surprising. As human knowledge advances, making the last leap becomes easier and easier, but this is not apparent until that leap is actually made. When it is made, it is not at all unusual for more than one person to make it at more or less the same time. The classic example is Newton and Leibniz both inventing calculus at the same time.
It's not surprising because the other person has been sitting on the proof for a year, and intended to sit on it for another year - and for very reasonable reasons.
So for two proofs to be announced on the same day they only had to overlap in this two year period.
I would guess the median number of mathematicians at any time who are sitting on a proof of the Riemann Hypothesis, but just need one more year to check it, is at least one.
Every time it happened so far, a problem came up during the year and you never heard about the proof, though perhaps some good partial results came out of the work.
I think he's also making a joke about the distribution of primes :) twin primes and all that
"It's not all that surprising."
That is what "typical" means.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multiple_discovery
I consider it anecdotal evidence of something like a genuine "zeitgeist" in terms of collective human consciousness.
The list is staggeringly large:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_multiple_discoveries
Makes sense if you think about it. Lots of people maybe are 99% but are waiting on polish and refinement or lack confidence. Then, one gets published and pushes others who are holding out to publish.
I think there's another bit to it, which is that similar individuals tend to read the same news sources
So discussion and mindset-shifts will happen in a community and cause the members to start to think down certain paths, some of which have shortly-reached conclusions on valuable unbuilt products or areas of research
No, there's a purely statistical explanation, no need for mysticism: it's effectively the birthday paradox. We should expect some number of discoveries to occur at the same time, due to just random chance. We do not remember all the other times simultaneous discovery did not happen.
"List of discoveries" is practically infinite, but will always be many, many orders of magnitude larger than "List of multiple discoveries." The Wikipedia article mentions 8 in the entire 21th century.
He's not proposing mysticism in any way.
Multiple discovery can happen because A) you get lucky, B) there's enough progress in prerequisites and supporting knowledge that the discovery has become more likely, or C) there's more work in a given area making the discovery more likely, etc, etc.
Galileo and Marius discovered Jupiter's moons around the same time. It mostly wasn't chance. It was the telescope. :P
They probably have P = NP but did not want to stuff the news channel :-)) You know, people's attention is limited...
These Riemann proofs really are like public buses, huh?
These are not independent events. The announcement of the first triggered the release of the second.
A proof by a human? How good could it possibly be? A human can only laboriously recombine ideas from the literature and occasionally inject randomness into the search path. Humans hallucinate so often, report results overconfidently, and often stubbornly refuse to accept counterarguments. For a truly original, creative solution, you still need an AI. Sure, the humans are learning and evolving generation after generation, and can sometimes work effectively in swarms, but ultimately the architectural constraints of being trained only on a finite corpus of three-dimensional data, optimized for survival in the next moment without a complete coherent world model, mean that they're a dead end and will never achieve true intelligence.
I see what you did there tips fedora
If this is real, and the results on all sides check out, the author made a HUGE mistake by not publishing a few months ago.
Other mathematicians should take heed. If you've got any ten-year-running projects, take them out of the shadows and into the light, or an Anthropic or OpenAI employee is going to solve your problem when they decide to bother with it and have enough spare compute at hand. And then you'll be scooped, with, at best, a "runner up" trophy.
I'd also add that the time is upon us where hobbyists can solve outstanding problems and prove theorems. The short-lived age of the professional mathematician may be genuinely over.
This.
Publish what you got, when you got it, or get overtaken by someone who will.
By publishing half a result, the mathematician guarantees an AI will have the chance to build on their work and beat them. How do you expect these people to get grants if all they do is publish half solutions that machines poach?
Because it's more credit than nothing. Also, building on others' work is not "poaching".
LLMs are not humans, they don't 'think' yet we use that term to describe what they do. Using the term poach to describe what LLM companies are doing is not being done as a parallel to how that term is used by human academics
With that kind of thinking, why don't we all just give a few companies access to all our personal thoughts? That way we can all get partial credit from our favorite LLM company
This also ignores the fundamental question: how do mathematicians get funding from anyone for publishing half complete problems? They can't and it isn't enough to say academia must change. Academia doesn't change until professors die. You're decades away from this sort of change and the people who it harms the most [young academics] have no say in making the changes people are proposing
The problem is the idea of getting credit for publishing the first proof, no?
Everyone stands on someone - or something - else's shoulders in some way. The way grants are awarded will just have to be updated. But even if grants totally disappear there will always be enthusiastic people working on and sharing X with the world just for the heck of it.
> This.
This... what?
Sorry, most mathematicians don't want to look ridiculous by posting something that doesn't hold up careful scrutiny for something as big as RH. See the ABC conjecture and Mochizuki fiasco for example.
Circumstances have changed. I think the community will understand; everybody is in the same position, after all.
I disagree. Why would you feed years of your work to aid an LLM in beating you if you think you’re close to the answer yourself? Furthermore, many mathematicians have referred to the AI proofs as jumbled incomprehensible messes. Humans should continue their work unabated by the threat of some slop paper that claims a solve.
I'd value the meticulous work. I don't think this was a mistake, for one thing how could he have known? Secondly, mathematics is a human activity, whose reward is insight. I'll value the effort and insight -- or what is the point of priority, to prove you are better than the rest? In that case it's already an apples to oranges comparison. Well, it has to be a matter of personal philosophy on whether it's a mistake or not, I guess. Side note, for the record I have no objection in principle to resolving an unsolved questions using AI, the objection is entirely in what I find valuable besides the answer.
> mathematics is a human activity, whose reward is insight
If the author believed that they wouldn't have published now. They did it because one of the rewards for solving a problem is the recognition from your peers for doing so.
insight can only come with bread on the table no?
> mathematics is a human activity, whose reward is insight
I think e.g. Tao is saying a lot of that now, but he used to open almost every interview or talk with how some math he found ended up speeding up MRI machines. Now he almost sounds like he wants results to be kept hidden.
I don’t agree, because his work is considerably shorter and more comprehensible than the Anthropic proof. That will always have more value than some giant lean proof.
While I wholeheartedly agree that shorter and more comprehensible proofs are more valuable, I see no reason to think that LLMs won't _also_ start producing shorter, more comprehensible proofs before long
Alright, and I see no reason to lend any credence whatsoever to your comment. You offer no evidence or argument of any kind. Even an appeal to authority (which is objectionable anyway) doesn't work here---who is cmpb and what do they know about the progression of LLMs with regards to proofs?
These types of comments are just invasive on HN. Just broad, completely unsubstantiated claims about AI capabilities and the future. It's just ridiculous.
A lot of "ridiculous" things have been happening, almost ~biweekly, for the past year now.
> made a HUGE mistake by not publishing a few months ago
Oh no, they'll lose out on some minor press.
Their work will still stand on it's own and for the people that it matters to, they'll know of him and his work.
The broader public probably wouldn't care much anyways, and solving math problems is going to lose a lot of glamour now that llms can do it to large degree. Not to say that it isn't impressive, but there's a large segement that just wants problems solved and doesn't care if it's done by human or otherwise.
Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
Keep your work secret and you'll get scooped. Make partial progress public and they'll ingest it into the model and scoop you anyway.
I suspect history will celebrate the human author
I dont
Well but you wouldn't want to rush it out in case there's a mistake and then you'd look like an idiot, which in math circles is tantamount to treason.
I think this is severely under-selling the role of Levant Alpöge at Anthropic in that proof. I am not a mathematician, but he is, Princeton PhD and all. His work was a lot more informed and involved than a bored engineer with an unlimited token budget typing "plz solve GRH" and letting it run.
That doesn't mean the models aren't getting very good at math, but as in every other field, an expert pilot is going to get results a novice will not. Anthropic is hiring a lot of field domain experts and giving them space + compute to chase problems they were already interested in.
Edit to add: I also suspect that if validated, Masullo will receive appropriate recognition in the community for this work, and some grace for it maybe not being as polished as hoped.
His choice to bury his work under a mountain of slop means the rest of us don't have to pretend to care about it if we don't want to. Long live the humans!
To be fair, I'm personally more interested in the AI side of this discussion just because the math is so far out of my own depth.
But I also realize as part of that there's no universe where even with anthropic's super secret model and an unlimited budget, I'd be getting to the same result.
He chose to publish as soon as he had a lean proof and before editing the written proof because he knows openAI could publish a proof any minute
He has all the time in the world to edit it down now
Why would anyone have to pretend they care about that or this second, "hurried announcement"? Everybody may have their own interests.
Or just give them both the Fields medal. Who cares?
No it's fine. No one cares if some not-yet-comprehensive LLM thing beat a person a few fewer hours. Obviously the humans didn't cheat to finish their proof if it is totally different.
A few months ago, nobody except Ant/OAI employees could possibly have had valid reasons to suspect GRH would be AI-solved within a few months. Arguably, the author’s only real mistake was being human and trying to achieve something while Ant/OAI were in the process of shredding and pulping all human achievement to convert it into share holder value.
The work has errors. People say Astra and Fable point some out but you don't even need that because the Authors admit as much. They claim they'll 'iron things out' over the next year, but there's no guarantee that is possible. So really, there is no proof here yet.
I think people are latching on to the "lol my llm bot says it's wrong" and glossing over the "Author says it still needs work"
So every big AI math result will now have its “me too”s tagging along claiming they were “almost there” and a crowd of people insinuating that the work was stolen. If I was Anthropic or OpenAI, I would just give the whole math proof thing a rest and focus on things that demonstrably produce value. If you need to prove a math theorem or two to get there, then do it as needed, but not for the sake of just proving theorems. It’s too much drama for very little reward. Fields that are heavily prestige based instead of value based always descend into these meaningless debates about primality of work. After Riemann, there’s not much besides PvNP that would make as much noise anyway.
The history of science is full of this.
Yay, humanity is back in the race! (If the proof checks out.)
It's insane though that he and Brian Conrad thought he had a year to polish the paper without getting scooped by AI. He should have put it out whatever he had on October 7th.
I really want the human proof to turn out to be the more correct and elegant proof.
That said, if you published a GRH proof at any point in the past century, someone would have claimed they were just about to solve it. Those tiny remaining gaps often prove to be the most insurmountable ones.
Still rooting for the meat mathematician, though.
When was the last time math had a day that could be scripted into a prestige TV show?
Probably navier-stokes a few months ago...
I do like that this one is not hundreds of thousands of pages long. As a non-mathematician this seems ... at least falsifiable in finite time.
And still i hear people saying: "But it only predicts the next character ..."
this is just sad, man
short audit by Astra shows several easy to check errors across the manuscript
human brains aren't cut out for math
I am morbidly amused that the frontier labs are publicly mauling mathematicians to show how capable their models are.
A human proof would be worth much more than one written by AI. It's weird that we're willing to throw a trillion dollars at computers doing math but not at humans doing math. I guess the issue with funding humans is ownership.
Do we need an on-call rotation for math emergencies now?
Will we soon learn that this human-made proof somehow made it to Anthropic pipeline and so their LLM later regurgitated (or at least worked off of) it?
Probably not, but that won't stop people from endlessly repeating it as fact like the Navier–Stokes case.
Buckmaster needs to make a public apology for ever insinuating that, especially now that he is on the AI gravy train himself (see his publication on unforced NS today, which on any other day would have been the biggest news in math history)
As an academic, can I just say that I for one am happy that, irrespective of the pockets of social mayhem caused by AI rollouts, the acceleration of peer review and publication timelines in academia is a true benefit. I hope more scholars feel compelled to get their ideas out faster now that they might be scooped, like, tomorrow by the next frontier AI model. And I doubly hope that the humanities will speed along quicker, too, not just STEM.
His proof doesnt pass lean, machine won. We lost.
What the labs have not succeeded in is making mathematics more polite or less stressful.
Thankfully the internet is fast, and we can already cool the (counter-)excitement: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50580084
I put that tweet into ChatGPT and it said the tweet had many errors. Maybe they're fixable, who knows. /s
Oh so everyone just had a proof of RH laying around and didn't want to tell us? Lol hope he did solve if fr fr though, best of luck
The real question is if Alessandro or Brian used Claude to polish the proof.
I mean it’s great for the field (pun intended) but we knew GHR to be right, it was assumed to be true, so it’s not like it’s going to give us superpowers or anything.
Still an absolute huge achievement, I’m just not sure that on its own it’s very interesting _unless_ new techniques were invented that can be reused to develop new theories.
I feel that it’s what we need the most: new conjectures, not proofs, even if they’re nice to have.
Fun to still be in the stage where humanity is neck and neck with AI
We can just say it's proved by Massulo-Claude
I love it, the days of hiding research in order to get an advantage is over. If you want recognition publish as fast as you can
Welcome to ship fast, break stuff, fix later way of doing things in programming
I mean, at this rate I will also have a proof of some unsolved problem somewhere. Let me check the old boxes in the attic.
Jokes aside, are we seeing mathematicians FOMO fr?
Time to learn plumbing.
I wonder if P will turn out to equal NP. I can wait a week.
The fact that this is heavily upvoted, completely uncritically, despite the fact that various different frontier LLMs all agree that the proposed proof is invalid because of major holes and errors, and the fact that people who have pointed this out are downvoted, [flagged] and [dead] -- all this speaks very badly about the critical judgement of the HN community. This is shameful group think unconcerned with the truth.
What does Terrance Tao have to say about all this? He's awfully quiet.
Writing another blogpost about how he’s on the warpath
It doesn't matter how "principled" someone is, when it comes to over a trillion dollars no one is "principled".
It is very obvious Anthropic is trying to stabilize their stock. They will stop at nothing to ease concerns of investors, and it is apparent they probably stole results.
Is the method for this similar to Anthropic's or independent?
It was literally published an hour ago. Have patience :)
Now there are two proposals to the GRH. One assisted with AI and one that is all human with ZERO AI.
Both should be put to the test and all of them should be rigorously reviewed, just like FLT and the poincare conjecture. This one is 900 pages rather than 250K pages.
You can see how you cannot assume anything yet as both are still claims. It starts to not make sense to do so with the top post in this thread [0] apply appeal to a singular authority:
"This is Levent Alpöge/Alessandro Masullo. If he says he has Riemann, well then, he has Riemann."
Rather than that, instead we should wait for multiple authorities to review both of them and the one that satisfies the GRH and is verified as the correct solution is the one that we go with.
[0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50574968
> This one is 900 pages rather than 250K pages.
This one can't be verified with certainty on a computer (yet) while the other one can be.
Unless lean has errors.
Unless multiple imolementations of Lean have the same errors.
The more likely problem with the Lean formulated proof is the problem was underspecified or inaccurately specified to mean the exact problem correctly.
The most likely problem in this proof is it contains logical errors which will not likely be easily reconciled.
Between the two, my money would be on the latter being the most likely to be true. 900 pages of an unlolished proof which had to be rushed outis a lot to ask to all be perfect. On the other hand, the chance multiple Lean implementations have the same error only now noticed in this proof but no others is extremely small almost regardless of length, and formulating ghe problem correctly is both a much easier problem initially and to reconcile.
My hope is LLMs can be leveraged to find a massively shorter verifiable version of this proof in time and then that can be something a human has a chance of making sense of.
> It starts to not make sense to do so with the top post in this thread [0] apply appeal to a singular authority
That's a bit uncharitable, I read that comment differently - it's telling you that the person who submitted it has a strong track record. That gives valuable context and credibility.
It seems unreasonable for humans to try to understand a 250k page proof to be honest
"all human with ZERO AI?" I'd put everything I've got on: false.
Given the infamous history of mistakes made by human mathematicians, 90% this is just another wrong paper.
LMFAO for people thinking Anthropic stealing the idea.
non-zero possibility that someone used the AI to review the proof, and that was used to train a later model. Depends on whether the proofs are similar or not.
fuck it. I'm betting on human
This is not how math, nor really any human endeavor, should be done.
This is a crime against the freedom and beauty of the human brain.
I weep for the sparkling future.
has anyone been able to build the lean files for it?
Yay humans
The tacit intractability of the gigabyte+ of Lean Alpöge submitted is pointless to deny. It's self-evidently unworkable. It is also very evidently going to be optimized massively. But people who think Claude simply found a way to cheese 4 independent checkers (https://math.mit.edu/~drew/grh/), or a way to misconstrue the task completely, are well into the territory of anti-ai psychosis tier wishful thinking.
Meanwhile, you chuck this proudly-human prose into the most bottom of the barrel model, and it points out blatant omissions and flaws by the dozen, with autoformalizations all having stalled out because of them. The former of which you don't even need to be a mathematician to confirm and appreciate. This is after decades of flawed human proofs being claimed left and right, by cranks and respected academics alike. Come on.
If it's repairable, great. But the optics of this are just sad, and will be profoundly so if the repairs don't work out.
It's human-generated slop that's already exhibited several errors. I don't trust it a bit.
At least he'll be able to option the movie rights for one of those almost-real-tech-bro flicks the industry lives to crank out. ...Or the most poignant Veritasium episode ever.
Hmm, guys, do you think this work was stolen by the Anthropics directly or indirectly?
It seems quite likely to me; after all, every piece of text sent to an LLM ends up being used for training...
So the clear implication is that this proof leaked into Anthropic's training data set, who then used the models which were trained on it to independently create a proof? From memory, previous such mathematical discoveries also came with similar implications.
Has someone confirmed whether those previous discoveries were due to such leaks? If so, it does really seem to portray GenAI as a giant auto complete engine, rather than an intelligence that can deduce novel solutions to tricky problems.
> It is all human, with no AI
It is at least different from Navier Stokes in the sense that the author did not use any AI software, so Anthropic could not have used his prompts for it.
Now did his proof leak into Anrhropic's training dataset... We do not know yet
EDIT: Looks like the 2 proofs use radically different ideas. It's unlikely there's a link...
> GenAI as a giant auto complete engine
This has always been known, people keep pretending it's not because they can benefit from that for positive and negative reasons.
Uh, why is that the implication? I see nothing suggesting that, and they weren't using AI in their own development.
I think the implication is that they want to stake a claim on potential credit for the result. They got scooped, but they didn't get scooped by a finished paper, they got scooped by a lean formalization, so credit is ambiguous.
This result is almost reverse of what they have - they have a human-understandable argument that they believe, but it could have holes, potentially fatal ones. The formalization is (probably) correct, but less illuminating (though it sounds like it's better than Navier-stokes - at least one human at least mostly understands it).
Mathematics as a field is still determining what counts as a result in this new age. Is a lean formalization that no one understands a result?
I see, interesting stuff. Thanks for explaining!
It's not a clear implication at all.
>So the clear implication is ...
Wow, if mathematicians would arrive at conclusions as fast as you do, they would have claimed GRH decades ago.
I don’t like it when people release work they say they’ve been on for a long time, right after someone else publishes the result. I don’t care whether the other person used AI. That’s going to continue and we’d better get used to it.
It’s annoying because if you’d been working on this all that time, you could have made some effort to tell the wider community and get at least some recognition. Posting after someone else has solved it is like claiming you had the winning numbers once the draw is already public.
Did you read the post? Clearly Alessandro Masullo was talking to people in the field. However, you cannot present all parts publicly when you are not finished yet. Otherwise someone might take your ideas.
Mathematicians are perfectionist, they only publish when they are sure it's correct. And Alessandro Masullo does simply not have the compute resources of anthropic, otherwise he probably would be finished earlier.
> Mathematicians are perfectionist
Why did he publish now then?
> And Alessandro Masullo does simply not have the compute resources of anthropic, otherwise he probably would be finished earlier.
I did read the post and it says "It is all human, with no AI", so I don't think your point makes sense here.
That still grants you the prize
Seems like people did know about this in the field… the linked post is not from the author, it's from https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ravi_Vakil who is among other things the president of the American math society. And the paper has been reviewed for "months" by https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brian_Conrad who has presumably been trying to make sure he understands it and helping to clarify the ideas.
It is surprising to me they wouldn't have tried to push out something faster after the kerfuffle last month. Maybe they were trying to do so, but it just takes a while!
Yes, I completely understand.
> It is surprising to me they wouldn't have tried to push out something faster after the kerfuffle last month.
This is what's so surprising, and annoying, to me! Like you are sitting on a goldmine and still decided not to publish, even after seeing all that happen with Navier–Stokes.
Ah, but the gamble is - if you're not certain you're right (and you might be right but wrong in some correctable details) then publishing early might just hand the result to AI on a silver platter.
Not everything needs to have daily standup syncs, or X threads.
Many in tech underestimate how much work, and knowledge, exists outside of public internet sources and within communities, exactly like the one Masullo had been interacting with and getting feedback from on the work being shared.
Wait until people realize what ancient Axial Age technology all LLMS/AI operate on regarding 'matrix' math. That's really going to grind alot of people's gears. There's decades of all sorts of people's work as the basis for how LLMs function, they are a big database of people's work over the ages with connect the dot Axial Age Matrix Connection methodologies. Most people and their work will go unmentioned as it always has in history. A very powerful technology that it doesn't seem most at the forefront of it are being honest with what it is. BTW, There's correspondence across scales as large as Galaxies. Might want to look up what ancient societies did stuff like that from that era. $$$$, alot of fools rushing in.
Now this really proves "we don't train on your chat history" is bs for me
The AI proof is looking to be correct. This, on the other hand, is not.
It seems pretty clear they weren't using AI at all though.
In this age no one will remember your name anyways.
Nothing more than ego. If you claim to seek the truth, seek the truth. Don't fret if someone finds it before you. I don't care how hard you've worked. The truth is the truth.
It is okay to value human achievement.
I do. Artificial intelligence is human progress.
it is also eons of uncompensated labor to benefit very very few
It is until it doesn't need humans anymore to progress.
If he had waited another year to publish this, would you value it more, or be suspicious of the timeline and claims of lack of AI use weren't true and that it was derivative work?
> Artificial intelligence is human progress.
Perhaps the last bit of that, ever.
How do you know who found it first?
If you're unsure if your proof is correct, you haven't proven it.
From Alpöge’s PDF
> I believe I have, working with Claude, discovered a proof1 of the Riemann Hypothesis.
Doesn’t sound sure to me
There's likely at least one pretty big monetary prize at stake.
I highly doubt that they would've rushed the publication if it were not Anthropic making extraordinary claims first.
Obviously this exact sentiment applies to the Anthropic announcement, so I'm not sure what the point is. If Anthropic cared about the truth and nothing else, then they would have waited until they had a much more succinct proof that could be understood by everybody in the field, so that everyone could be sure of the truth, rather than rushing out a collection of notes to be first in line. If they had no ego, they would have not even attached their (company) name to it at all. It turns out, everybody has an ego and it drives much of our behavior.
Don't you have an IPO to take care of, Dario?
I wish.
Oversimplifying, mathematician get pay per published paper, bonus points for a solution of a famous problem. (Actually, usually the base salary is fixed, but promotions, grants, capacity to get graduate students, and many other stuff depends on the number of published results.) The guy just wants to get paid. Truth is nice but it does not bring home the bacon.
i was here
It seems that even this piece of evidence was stolen by Anthropic and processed through AI.
It's even a shame that we never got AI, only the theft of scientific papers and insane deception in the stock market.