eyeat 1 day ago

This is just a continuation of the circular financing that has plagued Nvidia for the past 5 years. If the last earnings call was any guidance, their plan to renegotiate their current usage deals with neoclouds is going to severely shoot themselves in the foot.

Now, if you believe the entire market hinges on NVDA, this will absolutely heighten our current correction.

  • toomuchtodo 23 hours ago

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/live-blog/2026-11-20/markets-...

    > The cost to protect against default on Nvidia bonds has jumped to a fresh all-time high. It’s been moving up all week and jumped by the most since July this afternoon.

    https://www.bloomberg.com/news/live-blog/2026-11-20/markets-...

    > Goldman Sachs Group Inc.’s panic gauge climbed near its maximum level as US stocks tumbled Friday, signaling that another substantial wave of selling will follow over the coming weeks. Goldman’s trading desk said the selloff spread across the so-called systemic investors, projecting that commodity trading advisers could offload another $65.8 billion in a flat market, $28.6 billion if stocks rise and as much as $80.6 billion if equities continue to decline.

    (no paywall bypass for live page, so link and copy paste must do, mea culpa)

    • smallmancontrov 23 hours ago

      ...and US10Y barely dipped below 5% and is now pushing back up.

      We live in interesting times.

      • eyeat 22 hours ago

        I mean, it's certainly an attractive offer. I bought some 10Y when it was touching 4.5 because I couldn't imagine it going any higher, and yet here we are.

  • boringg 22 hours ago

    I mean isn't circular financing how the economy works as a whole? Its just what level we tolerate before people think its risky. Economies are circular in nature.

    • eyeat 22 hours ago

      Yes, money exchanges hands. Wow, we engage in a society.

      The issue lies within the entire market being concentrated on 7 companies... and then 5... and now 3... and with these companies being so high up on stilts, their relative risk is heightened.

      I am certainly not buying $NVDA right now

      • rileymat2 22 hours ago

        I thought the issue with NVIDIA is at times money was not changing hands, but they were getting investments in companies that needed GPU's at unsustainable markups? Or am I misunderstanding the controversy? If money was changing hands, this would not be an issue?

      • icedchai 21 hours ago

        The market has a tendency to overreact in both directions. I'm not buying NVDA yet, but it's certainly on my watch list. I think it will be below $100 again, soon.

    • wmf 22 hours ago

      The real implication is that Nvidia is providing financing so customers can buy GPUs that they do not want or need. It's closer to channel stuffing.

      I'm not saying I believe this, but I think this is the real concern for many skeptics.

      • lokar 22 hours ago

        Also providing financing at a substantial discount compared to what an independent lender would charge for that risk.

        This then has the effect of artificially raising profits (you are providing a subsidy, but not counting it as an expense).

        • martinald 21 hours ago

          But literally every car company does this. If you take out a lease or a loan with eg Ford Credit they will offer incentives that no bank will.

          While I think eg taking equity is one thing, providing finance incentives is pretty standard in "traditional" industries

          • lokar 20 hours ago

            As long as you account for it correctly.

            • dcrazy 20 hours ago

              This is why so many companies keep coming up with newer, even more “inventive” extensions of EBITDA: to draw attention away from the numbers which reflect customer acquisition costs as expenses.

              • JumpCrisscross 19 hours ago

                Ebitda is non-GAAP.

                • dcrazy 18 hours ago

                  Yes, my point was that EBITDA isn’t enough nowadays. You wind up with truly crazy numbers like WeWork’s “Community Adjusted EBITDA.”

                  • JumpCrisscross 18 hours ago

                    > You wind up with truly crazy numbers like WeWork’s “Community Adjusted EBITDA"

                    That one must reach back to a 2019 aborted IPO probably indicates that we didn't "wind up" with this.

                    Anthropic went public with audited financials showing GAAP figures. While it did also have management numbers in its prospectus, as is expected, the market seemed to fixate on price to revenues. Again, entirely GAAP figures.

          • watwut 3 hours ago

            This argument keeps popping up, but no, car companies are not doing the same thing. The money lending company is different org then the car making one - per law.

        • JumpCrisscross 19 hours ago

          > providing financing at a substantial discount compared to what an independent lender would charge for that risk

          This is standard vendor financing and it’s fine. The weird part with Nvidia is the taking of equity in its customers. (Also sleeping with customers.)

          • throwup238 16 hours ago

            > (Also sleeping with customers.)

            Perks of the job. CEOs don’t just get free snacks like the rest of us.

            • JumpCrisscross 7 hours ago

              > Perks of the job

              This is being repeated by people who seem to believe this. But the firings of the CEOs of McDonald's, Intel and HP for this exact misbehavior indicates what actually happens when this is uncovered (to anyone other than Elon Musk).

      • jaredklewis 22 hours ago

        > GPUs that they do not want or need.

        Wait what? Which customers specifically are you referring to? All of the financing I have heard about has been for customers I definitely believe are using them: CoreWeave, Nscale, Crusoe, Firmus, Nebius, etc... Not sure how to evaluate if those companies "want" or "need" them, but I also can't imagine how they wouldn't, seeing their whole business model is selling access to these chips.

        • eek2121 21 hours ago

          Correct, however, NVIDIA has massive amounts of reserved wafer allocations at TSMC with no product/customer match. Those companies are also buying at their own pace, not at the pace NVIDIA needs them to. I would be REALLY surprised if NVIDIA pulls through this nonsense. They are profitable on paper, however, based on everything I've read, they are actually in a ton of trouble unless they can renegotiate everything. Like..."Bear Sterns" trouble.

          EDIT: One small thing I wanted to mention, is that while I compared this to the downfall of Bear Sterns, NVIDIA is actually lower risk than the infamous investment banking company. There is a lot of room for things to go right. TSMC knows they'll have a ton of demand, regardless, so they could negotiate down allocations with NVIDIA. NVIDIA could also use their free cash flow and make more inventory, even without buyers, and sell it for smaller margins or a slight loss. They can even use those allocations for future gaming chips and other stuff. That second path will cost them big time. Hopefully, they can negotiate deals with TSMC.

          • aeonik 21 hours ago

            Weird, I've been dying to purchase a new computer but I can't justify the latest prices so I've been holding off.

            Customers are there I think...

            • dannyw 19 hours ago

              Would you pay 10k USD for a 5090 though? No? If it was just 2k, then think about all the margin compression…

              • mrgordon 16 hours ago

                Since when did the misinformation on here get to be as bad as WallStreetBets

                NVIDIA never raised the price of a 5090 Founders Edition. They are still $2k although you won't find one.

                Resellers charge $6k (NOT $10k) and NVIDIA does not get more than they did before so there is no margin compression for NVIDIA if they charge $2k in the future.

                • PeterStuer 12 hours ago

                  "you won't find one" carries a lot of the weight here.

                • jjav 10 hours ago

                  > They are still $2k although you won't find one.

                  In other words, they are not $2k then.

                  • s1artibartfast 3 hours ago

                    If you're following the thread, this is about what shows up on Nvidia balance sheet. Revenue is 2K for them

            • seanmcdirmid 18 hours ago

              Not if DRAM is the limiting factor rather than GPUs.

          • etempleton 17 hours ago

            Nvidia is not just profitable on paper, they are wildly profitable on paper. 70% + margins on 115 Billion a quarter revenue with even more projected for Q4.

            I doubt Nvidia would have trouble finding a buyer for their chips in the medium term. Demand is incredibly high and most of the demand is actually originating from the big tech companies - SpaceX, Microsoft, Google, Oracle, Amazon, etc.

        • anon291 20 hours ago

          If these GPUs were not needed, then GPU rental price should be going down as all these neoclouds attempt to sell capacity, but GPU rental prices are going up.

      • missedthecue 21 hours ago

        Do not want or need? There is a 12-18 month backlog right now and the bosses of OpenAI just said yesterday they needed compute wherever they could find it.

        Maybe everyone's lying to the point of committing felonies, but I'd need more proof than conspiracy theory posting. Could I buy a few racks of vera rubin right now?

      • SilasX 20 hours ago

        GPUs are an extremely hot commodity right now and the bottleneck for a lot of high-demand production. It's very hard to imagine there being sales that are artificial, or companies buying overpriced units that they don't need, given the manifest extreme demand for them.

        • hyperadvanced 19 hours ago

          Isn’t the whole point of this that demand is being artificially exaggerated by NVDA subsidizing consumption? I.e. the extreme demand emanates from NVDA loaning everyone money and then turning around and saying “wow, you guys sure want these chips huh!??” Of course demand is extreme when you hold all of the resource and then juice demand!

        • ifwinterco 10 hours ago

          The issue is it's reflexive in both directions, feast can turn to famine very quickly

      • malnourish 20 hours ago

        My neighbor told me a few months ago that Nvidia contacted him and offered a program where he could finance GPUs and then immediately lease their usage back through an intermediary.

        It was slightly more complicated than that, but he claims NVidia was practically telling him it was free money. He is a natural salesman/ entrepreneur and thus prone to some exaggerating, but he's not what I'd call a liar.

      • TwoNineFive 16 hours ago

        > GPUs that they do not want or need

        > I'm not saying I believe this

        Saying things you don't believe is called "lying". You are lying.

      • sl0wbrainRot 14 hours ago

        This is/was most def going on

        In 2024 I received an email to an address setup for a side hustle

        Email was from a neo cloud with H100s for around 23% the cost of the usual suspects

        Immediately wondered why a no-name neo cloud has such a fancy discount for a nothing side hustle with no traction

        Emailed back hypothesizing channel stuffing. Reply was a simple

        "You might be onto something ;)"

        Since then been no question this all been a too big to fail push to make big deals and expect a bailout or the entire economy collapses

    • cmiles8 22 hours ago

      Legitimate vendor financing is a thing and generally accepted as OK. For example a car company giving loans to credit-worthy folks to buy a car. Or leasing cars to folks via similar mechanisms. If the risk is managed properly it’s a nice profit center since now you get car revenue plus loan interest.

      What Nvidia has been doing is closer to a car company finding a bunch of broke folks that will require a small miracle to pay back the loan, and financing cars for all them, then telling the market demand for cars if off the charts. If magically somehow these folks can generate cash to pay for it one gets away with it. If not, then you have a mini-2008 financial crisis unfolding on your balance sheet.

      • missedthecue 21 hours ago

        That second paragraph is basically how the aircraft leasing business works, and has worked for a very long time. Lend planes on credit to buyers intending to monetize and pay them back.

        Boeing Capitals whole purpose is to provide financing to cash strapped airlines hoping to monetize the airframe.

        I don't see a reason to be especially cynical about this business model because it has been proven to work in concept. I think the only thing left to answer is how profitable inference actually is, and how easy it is to use GPUs as collateral (it's very easy with a Boeing 777). We have 80 years of airline data and about 1-2 years of neocloud data.

        • cmiles8 21 hours ago

          Ha. Yes. Hence the phrase how do you become a millionaire in the airline business? Be a billionaire and found an airline.

          • missedthecue 21 hours ago

            Well yes running an airline is a famously difficult business. But my point is that financing airlines has been fantastically profitable.

            If GPUs turn out to be highly analogous to airplanes, (in the sense that they are monetizable capital goods offered on credit), then the neoclouds might suffer just like airlines over the long run while Nvidia and other creditors do handsomely.

            • delis-thumbs-7e 20 hours ago

              > If GPUs turn out to be highly analogous to airplanes

              That’s some hefty if you got there. I don’t know much about aircraft financing, but I know that if you default on your airline company I paid for, I have a fledt of very very expensive planes ready to make money next 20-30 years. I also know they will have demand since people need to fly and demand is linked to GDP. Also, did not Boeing amputate it’s financing portfolio years ago precisely because it is so dangerous, whereas Nvidia takes money from left pocket, gives to neocloud to receive it back and puts it in his right pocket?

              If CoreWeave defaults you got bunch of GPU’s deprecating as we speak and being out of demand in 5-6 years. Also you have AI demand of which everyone say is off the roof, but the numbers on the board don’t seem to add up. Basically it is almost like throwing trillions of dollars to Wright -brothers after their first flight.

              I think the fundamentals will be there one day, but it doesn’t look they are there now.

              • missedthecue 19 hours ago

                So there are a couple of things here.

                First, in the limited period of time we have had to observe inference economics, it's clear that these chips have an economically useful life that is longer than their accounting depreciation schedule. A100s sold in 2020 are still running 24 hours a day earning money. This is also true of airliners. United is still flying planes built in 1991. That has long long been depreciated and is still earning profit every day.

                Second and far more important; Yes, an airliner lasts longer than a GPU, but the economic payback is also way way longer. A 737 can take generally 15 years to economically recoup the investment. Meanwhile they're saying a Blackwell is what, 9 months payback? And a Vera Rubin even faster.

        • cmiles8 19 hours ago

          Except only around 1% of Boeing sales are vendor financed. Leasing aircraft is popular by airlines but that balance sheet risk is carried by separate leasing companies. And there is a very strong market for second hand aircraft including those decades old. So it’s a totally different market setup than GPUs.

      • bigbuppo 21 hours ago

        I know someone that works at a high credit risk used car lot. Their motto is literally, "We sell to sell again" and that's kind of a joke. It's not uncommon for them to resell a vehicle that has been reposessed several times before it finally ends up somewhere permanent or is beyond economic repair.

        I'm sure nvidia's plan is/was to take over the neoclouds that failed, and then sell turnkey solutions (pre-racked systems or whole datacenters) to other hopeful neoclouds.

      • Woodi 7 hours ago

        > Legitimate vendor financing is a thing and generally accepted as OK

        > What Nvidia has been doing is closer to a car company finding a bunch of broke folks that will require a small miracle to pay back the loan

        Did you noticed Nvidia being no.1 on Wall Street or something like that? They was doing it at global economy scale Not some random individual wanting to get car worth maybe 3 x DGX Sparks.

        And do you know what is worth ~5 Sparks ? Commercial bakery furnance with 60 years warranty for heating elements (German steel, German welding ;) and maybe 3 days of work of building it in bakery.

        That computer things are way overvalued and they keep pumping it - just one company ordered 40% of global RAM production without even having builded computer room. And that company do not even plan to be profitable so from where they had money to pay for order of global 40% of RAM ?

    • anon291 20 hours ago

      Yes, when a bank makes a loan, suddenly, that's a new asset and this is the fundamental force of money creation in any economy.

      • janderson215 8 hours ago

        A loan is a liabilities, not an asset.

    • gessha 18 hours ago

      Circular financing has a very specific meaning with respect to supplier and consumer and generalizing it for the whole economy is either naive or trollish.

      • joshribakoff 16 hours ago

        And if there is an intermediate party between the supplier and consumer to add indirection? Its a spectrum.

  • darksim905 21 hours ago

    plagued Nvidia?

    You mean uplifted and made Nvidia king and is by design?

  • dmitriy_ko 15 hours ago

    Nvidia's investment in neoclouds was an alternative to building their own GPU cloud. Jensen "didn't want to compete with his customers". If Nvidia used their cash to build their own data centers and then rent them out, would it be still considered a "circular financing"?

    • runeks 11 hours ago

      Isn't this alleged "circular financing" simply Nvidia offering a line of credit to its customers?

      • seunosewa 11 hours ago

        Yep. Nvidia's PR dropped the ball in making this clear.

        • ksec 9 hours ago

          Glad to see sanity prevails on HN.

          What Nvidia doing isn't new for any industry. But they could have explained themselves using submarines PRs. On the other hand, it is clear to me the whole thing isn't just about "circular financing" but someone wants to bring down Nvidia.

ralph84 1 day ago

If the board thought there were accounting issues why did they make the CFO the interim CEO?

  • feverzsj 1 day ago

    As a scapegoat.

    • lazide 1 day ago

      Kicking out Jensen using office affairs as an excuse is perfect for this too.

  • baggachipz 23 hours ago

    Classic Glass Cliff scenario.

    • cogman10 20 hours ago

      My thoughts exactly. She's there because Nvidia is about to have some very bad news while she's in charge. Including her making some very unpopular decisions (Layoffs, benefits cuts, etc)

      Once those all land, she'll be fired and I'd not be shocked if Jensen is brought back. And, of course, none of the changes she's made will be reversed. This sort of play has happened a bunch of times.

      • adrian_b 10 hours ago

        She has already declared a couple of days ago that she has started to "reexamine" the financing deals with the NVIDIA customers, whatever that means.

  • dgellow 23 hours ago

    If there is no issues, why hasn’t the Q-10 been reported?

    • chollida1 21 hours ago

      > If there is no issues, why hasn’t the Q-10 been reported?

      because its due in a few weeks.

      They last one was from August 26th so 3 months would bring them to near the end of November.

      And pedantic side note, its called a 10-Q

  • willis936 23 hours ago

    Because the CFO is the only C suite on record opposing circular financing and calling it out by name. If anyone internal would give them deniability it's her.

    • lenerdenator 22 hours ago

      She's also the person who is best-equipped to answer questions about their books.

    • ralph84 22 hours ago

      Disagreeing on business strategy is one thing, accounting fraud is a completely different thing. After SOX, no CFO is going to sign off on accounting they don't agree with.

      • coolestguy 21 hours ago

        Ah yes - we've made it illegal so now it wont happen

        • ralph84 21 hours ago

          We've made it so that if it happens, the CFO is definitely in on it.

          • coolestguy 21 hours ago

            Not the same as saying that it can't happen now because of SOX

            • ralph84 19 hours ago

              Whether a CFO agrees with the accounting is not the same as whether the accounting is fraudulent. The point is after SOX a CFO can't use the excuse of "the CEO made me do it." The CFO has to certify under penalty of prison that they personally reviewed the accounting and agree with it.

leovander 16 hours ago

For those thinking how could it be possible that CFO didn't know, well companies this large, public or not, will have in-house counsel they pay for, for advice (sure, in-house counsel will farm out to third parties). If the counsel tells the C-suite they shouldn't do a specific thing, the C-suite is more than welcome to ignore counsel. Counsel is giving its legal opinion and C-suite can override their counsel's advice.

A more fun way to look at it, search Better Call Saul, Kim Wexler talking to Kevin Wachtell giving him a mouthful.[0]

[0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KjnNV2JLMX0

danielovichdk 23 hours ago

I guess that guy on youtube, Ned Citron was right after all.

  • toomuchtodo 23 hours ago

    How accurate have Ed Zitron's AI skeptic predictions been? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49526069 - September 2026 (1056 comments)

    Good comment by yousif_123123 in that thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49534777 (imho)

    • dgellow 23 hours ago

      The predictions are irrelevant. It’s about the thesis and information he publishes. He has been directionally correct from that point of view

      • toomuchtodo 23 hours ago

        > He has been directionally correct from that point of view

        I agree, he was just early.

      • ipsum2 22 hours ago

        "The parts he's absolutely wrong about are not important". Okay buddy.

      • tclancy 19 hours ago

        Can you clarify what “directionally correct” means?

        • anon7725 18 hours ago

          “There’s something fishy going on with all of these AI financing deals and when/if it comes to light the market will tank”

        • jcranmer 18 hours ago

          It sounds like a polite way of saying "right in the outcome, wrong about all of the details."

          A good historical example of this is Billy Mitchell, saying in the 1920s that bombers made battleships obsolete, which sounds like what would happen by the end of WW2, but on closer inspection, he was betting very heavily on the wrong kind of aircraft development (and would have sabotaged the right kinds of aircraft!) that listening to him would have left you with a lot of dead pilots and a battleship still bearing down on you.

          • nixon_why69 13 hours ago

            I think we can be a little kinder than that to Zitron, he called out the circular financing in some detail but didn't perfectly nail the timing of the collapse or the political and infidelity angles. Still directionally correct on the big picture.

          • ashkankiani 9 hours ago

            No one can predict the exact breaking point when people wake up from a bubble, and so "directionally correct" is the best one can do when pointing out the dogshit fundamentals of a company's offering.

    • hashmap 23 hours ago

      Aged poorly, that article. Paints a picture of Ed Zitron standing on the beach, saying, "Later on, the water will be higher," and the author looking at his watch 30 minutes later and proclaiming, "What a fool! The water is lower than it was when he made his prediction!"

      The comment is good. Ed Zitron's loudest critics are the people who under no circumstances will accept that his central point is one of physics ineluctable, and that the AI trade is going to be drawn in.

      • lesuorac 21 hours ago

        More like quotes Ed on saying “No later than 30 minutes will the water be above the lifeguard stand” and then 30 minutes later its low tide.

        Ed Zitron is like Freud where everybody who believes in him doesn’t actually listen to the exact words. Of course when you substitute the words its correct. The danluu article uses exact quotes.

        • toomuchtodo 21 hours ago

          How could Ed know when Jensen’s affairs being made public were going to pop the bubble?

          • gruez 21 hours ago

            Maybe he didn't know anything and just happened to be directionally correct? In other words the "justified true belief" concept in epistemics.

        • delis-thumbs-7e 20 hours ago

          Yet he was reporting about Nvidia’s chips ending up in China and the mysterious Chinese lady Jensen was often seen with back in March:

          > Things get a lot weirder as Bloomberg digs in, including a woman called “Huang” that may or may not be both the CEO of Megaspeed and an associated company called “Shanghai Hexi,” which is also owned by the Yangtze River Delta project… who was also photographed sitting next to Jensen Huang at an event in Taipei in 2024.(Long article, Nvidua ar very bottom: https://www.wheresyoured.at/the-ai-industry-is-lying-to-you/)

          Most of this stuff has been out in the open for a long time, if you just care to look for it. He is just reporting same stuff Bloomberg, Reuters, FT, WSJ.

          • sph 16 hours ago

            Holy shit nice catch

          • lesuorac 44 minutes ago

            This is almost exactly Dan's exact point. Ed has written a lot of articles and a lot of words in the articles.

            And the thing you've chosen to show how Ed is right is him regurgitating somebody else's work! Lets just go up a paragraph to where Ed highly implies Supermicro is also selling to China; is Supermicro indicted? How long until they aren't indicted will you agree Ed is wrong?

            > He is just reporting same stuff Bloomberg, Reuters, FT, WSJ.

            He's not though. He copy-pastes their stuff and then adds his own predictions that just end up being wrong.

            Look, I agree that there are fundamental issues (amount of electricity, amount of financing, etc) that are going to cause issues with this AI full speed. However, I'm not going to tell you the bubble will end tomorrow. Ed might; and that's where he becomes wrong.

    • ftchd 23 hours ago

      Clearly he's wrong

treebeard901 19 hours ago

Colette Kress the acting CEO of nVidia has been with the company since 2013 as Chief Financial Officer. It's difficult to believe the CFO was unaware of what could be years of blackmarket chip sales. It would ultimately be the financial department that has to manage that revenue on the books.

If the several investigations into this end up drawing her in, then nVidia might need another acting CEO in the not too distant future.

nVidia also has an issue where many of the C level people at the company have ties to a specific foriegn country that I will leave unnamed. It will be interesting to see who replaces her and if they bring in someone from the outside.

The stock continues to fall as well so who knows what will happen next.

  • motionlessveloc 18 hours ago

    > many of the C level people at the company have ties to a specific foriegn country

    Genuinely unsure what you're hinting at here. Even Israel doesn't seem to check out (none born, studied or worked there).

    Colette Kress, Interim Chief Executive Officer (CEO); Executive Vice President & Chief Financial Officer (CFO)

    Nick Parker, Chief Commercial Officer (CCO) / EVP, Worldwide Field Operations

    Debora Shoquist, Executive Vice President, Operations Tim Teter, Executive Vice President, General Counsel and Secretary

    Chris A. Malachowsky, Founder & NVIDIA Fellow Alison Wagonfeld, Chief Marketing Officer (CMO)

    Bruce Andrews, Chief External Affairs Officer

    Scott Gawel, Vice President & Chief Accounting Officer (CAO)

    Bill Dally, Chief Scientist & Senior Vice President of Research

    • Melatonic 17 hours ago

      They all certainly have ties to California - now the worlds 4th largest economy !

      I have no idea what they're getting at either in all seriousness though

EmX_3000 22 hours ago

Isn't everybody implicated? The stock-for-discounted-chips deals, huge numbers of dark GPUs held by shady companies (or just gone), it's all so shady that it boggles the mind.

jjcm 1 day ago

They're now down nearly 50% since their high 6 weeks ago. Absolutely crazy.

TheAlchemist 20 hours ago

IF the bubble is finally popping, just be careful guys - because no matter how cheap things look, they can always get a lot cheaper !

If what many people think is right, ie, that the whole business of AI is unprofitable and pretty much only exist for now because Nvidia & co is directly or indirectly financing their own demand, this whole house of card will collapse really quickly. As a reminder - before the 'boom' Nvidia was making a 3B profit, in a good year.

  • topspin 19 hours ago

    Rather nice not having to wade through all the bubble denier mental gymnastics today.

  • oefrha 19 hours ago

    The whole business of AI can’t be unprofitable, open models like DeepSeek are clearly being served profitably and if it turns out GPU, HBM, etc. should be cheaper than they currently are, serving them will only become more profitable. Given that, the frontier closed models with a pretty big price premium must be very profitable to serve as well, even if you don’t take their word for it. Training can stop today and the existing models (open ones at least) are still very useful and aren’t going anywhere. A valuation pop may drag down some companies, but the .net pop didn’t mean the whole business of internet is unprofitable.

    • zamalek 18 hours ago

      > Training can stop today and the existing models (open ones at least) are still very useful and aren’t going anywhere.

      Unless your competitor keeps training, then you'll be starved for customers. The idea that R&D can stop is absurd.

      • oefrha 18 hours ago

        There are already plenty of inference-only providers in the business that are not training at all.

    • bayarearefugee 17 hours ago

      > The whole business of AI can’t be unprofitable

      Offering compute is likely to remain profitable.

      But unless someone suddenly pulls a moat of out of their butt, the layer of AI on top of that compute could very possibly end up being a minimally profitable business, like say VPS hosting.

      Sure, you can make a few bucks doing that, but not what you want to try to build companies with trillion dollar valuations off of.

      • oefrha 12 hours ago

        I believe inference as an industry will be as big or bigger than pre-AI AWS, just with current model capabilities, bubble popping or not. In fact if you add up this year’s AI revenue from all the big names, that should already be close to or surpass AWS’s 2024 revenue of $108B? Will it support multiple trillion dollar companies? No idea. But it’s not a few bucks either.

  • aurareturn 16 hours ago

    When Nvidia was making 3B in profit, we thought we might never solve Riemann Hypothesis and all of us were writing code word by word like cavemen.

ashkankiani 1 day ago

Let's summarize:

- nvidia stopped reporting revenue via singapore->china, and last year the revenue from china was >20% . they are now under strong scrutiny and likely can't sell to china nearly as much or at all

- in their earnings call they announced 2 major things: $150 billion of stock buy backs (very big vote of confidence /s), and tighter constraints on circular financing for neoclouds

- lost the leader who organized the china revenue and most of the current financial deals

- is now officially under investigation

- datacenters have more pushback and regulation is likely to increase once democrats go into office (not a guarantee), reducing demand which was already artificially increased (see below)

- was pressuring companies to buy gpus and warehouse them to pump their numbers, despite the inability of companies to actually build the datacenters in time

- and we don't know the full extent of their financial commitments or how much of it was loaned against their stock as equity

Yes this is very much a buy from me :thumbsup: Everyone put on your knife proof gloves and buy the dip

  • thaumasiotes 23 hours ago

    > Everyone put on your knife proof gloves

    I like to call them gauntlets. :D

  • laurels-marts 22 hours ago

    Over the last few days I actually started averaging down by buying in staggered increments. I still have 3 GTCs left with limits set in advance. I’m amused to see where this is going.

    • hrncn 21 hours ago

      The problem is that the hit jobs keep coming and I have no idea what Jensen did (or didn't do), but clearly it's open season now. As much as I want to buy more, it clearly is not over yet, and it feels like gambling right now.

      • laurels-marts 21 hours ago

        I will not be surprised if the stock bottoms out below 100, but how much below I have no idea.

  • TheBigSalad 18 hours ago

    Buy opportunities like this come only once every few years.

  • ashkankiani 4 hours ago

    I missed one, competitors like goog and amzn have started selling their own chips, digging into some of their sales profits.

cmiles8 22 hours ago

Nvidia appears to have dug itself a hole it’s not going to be able to get out of. The vendor financing games work until they don’t, then they backfire spectacularly.

They know if they show a quarterly decline, or even just a big growth slowdown, the AI valuation boom will implode and everyone will return to regularly scheduled programming. Valuations of all these AI gems, including Anthropic, would then see an 70-80+% haircut with standard valuations for growth companies.

So to avoid that they’ve been signing increasingly questionable funding deals and allegedly pushing folks to take delivery of chips they don’t need because data center construction is hitting massive snags. Hence too the reports of GPUs sitting in warehouses collecting dust. It appears this is now all coming to a head and the next 12 months will be very interesting.

Early moves such as all the “Jensen was actually kinda not a nice guy” articles hitting the press today suggest the strategy may be throw Jensen under the bus and use that to try and clean up this mess and reset the company. Get your popcorn ready. Some are already calling this “Jenron.”

  • aurareturn 16 hours ago

    None of this stuff matters.

    The only thing that matters is AI demand.

voidfunc 1 day ago

Didn't have nvidia being Enron 2.0 on my bingo card.

  • lazide 1 day ago

    Notably, Enron financial impact was about $40-60 bln depending on how you count it.

    Nvidia has lost at least $2trln in market cap almost instantly with this going on.

    This is the titanic to Enron’s little dinghy.

  • kovacs 23 hours ago

    Funny you should make that comparison... Nvidia replaced Enron in the S&P

  • hoppp 23 hours ago

    They could definitely pop and of course everything will get more expensive.

    AMD is the clear winner in this market. They will own the graphics market and will create the best next gen AI chips from now on.

    • beambot 23 hours ago

      There are a lot of rumors going around that AMD was doing the same shenanigans re:China...

    • captainbland 21 hours ago

      I'm not sure, it seems like everyone and their mother has a decently capable TPU design at this point or is in the process of designing one. I think the moat isn't as big as it was for GPUs.

      • eecc 21 hours ago

        Exactly, and that explains Jensen’s strategy.

        Nvidia’s got a time-limited (crumbling) moat and it needs to capitalize it to death before it goes away, replaced by competing stacks.

        If the US datacenter industry can’t absorb their max capacity, its only option is to throw its momentum towards building clouds on their own stack, wherever they can. Asia.

        Next step would’ve been boostrap their own AI lab on OSS models, and fork.

        All this, without getting caught “entering their clients’ businesses”, American clouds and American ai labs

  • Espressosaurus 23 hours ago

    I thought they were selling shovels for the longest time, not selling CDSs. Guess I’m the fool here!

  • throwawaypty 23 hours ago

    NVIDIA is shipping products. Enron was entirely grift.

    • MaxHoppersGhost 23 hours ago

      Enron was an actual energy company. The pieces of Enron still operate today under different names.

      • missedthecue 21 hours ago

        Correct. EOG Resources for example is a Fortune 500 that will do $30B of sales this year.

        EOG stands for Enron Oil & Gas.

  • almog 23 hours ago

    The irony (if it turns out to be anything similar) is that Nvidia replaced Enron in the S&P 500 index.

feverzsj 1 day ago

Just as predicted, the AI market collapses right after midterm.

  • lostmsu 23 hours ago

    This is the second collapse since the midterm already (so far).

  • andrekandre 18 hours ago

    i'm not caught up on the thinking, but why was a prediction?

cbg0 1 day ago

Are we expecting more than a slap on the wrist with the current US administration?

  • 2OEH8eoCRo0 1 day ago

    The current admin started the investigation. Maybe?

    • 233mhz 22 hours ago

      Trump already said the US is a country of "second chances" while talking about the topic. They care more about big numbers getting bigger than anything else

      • bubblethink 22 hours ago

        There is no "they" now. The admin is schizophrenic. Lutnick and Bessent are feuding, Rubio is a useful tool, and Trump is sundowning. It's anyone's guess where the chips will fall.

        • undersuit 16 hours ago

          > It's anyone's guess where the chips will fall.

          Maybe a gold bar, a Rolex or a 747 shows up too.

  • stevenwoo 23 hours ago

    US taxpayers now own ten percent of Intel through current federal government’s actions. Now maybe taxpayers will have to own part of NVidia when the dust settles. Who knows what the Trump family and other insiders are trading but I bet they benefit from final outcome and each step of the way.

    • ericmay 22 hours ago

      Well many on the left have been clamoring for government to own these companies and more so it seems like they’re getting what they wanted at least

  • TheBigSalad 18 hours ago

    I'm sure it will be a record breaking 1 BILLION dollar fine that nobody will notice.

  • browningstreet 16 hours ago

    Another extraction round, like that china sales tariff

LogicFailsMe 1 day ago

So where my cheap Blackwell GPUs at? My stochastic parrots want crackers!

lenerdenator 22 hours ago

It'll be interesting to see what they find. My read as a guy who read about Enron but doesn't do much investing of my own is that the SEC is the lifeguard blowing the whistle asking you to turn your music down at the public pool, while the DOJ is the actual cop who slams your head into the hood of his squad car while yelling "STOP RESISTING!". If the lifeguard also notices you have a huge bag of drugs right next to the stereo, you're screwed because they'll pass that info along to the officer.

If they find the proverbial bag of drugs, well, mark this down as another instance of poor board leadership allowing the cult of the founder to take hold at Nvidia and the rest of us paying the price.

zergrush 21 hours ago

if you are hoping for an enron type of accounting scandal you are going to be massively disappointed. they are way too smart for that. what's probably under scrutiny are whether they followed accounting rules but even there ton of specialized lawyers that can stretch what the boundaries are, there's no real case here other than just a nice headline from what I understand.

  • rcr-anti 21 hours ago

    Wasn't part of the reason Enron worked for as long as it did that they were seen as too smart for that?

    • zergrush 13 hours ago

      Enron outright committed fraud by recording profits that didn't exist that wasn't very smart.

      What NVIDIA is doing isn't illegal and they are far too wise to do something brazen like Enron did which seems to be what a lot of the misinformed users are hoping for

  • notaharvardmba 21 hours ago

    It’s like distributed Enron, the SPVs are held by the datacenter and hyperscaler people. So it’s arms length but that doesn’t make the whole thing any less susceptible to a big repricing. End of the day, higher interest rates, borrowing money, stretching depreciation, using SPVs, all of this is really reminiscent of Enron except instead of one company it’s the entire AI sector. ORCL being the most egregious example since they are also in the middle of an AOL/Time Warner style deal pledged with overvalued shares. High yield spreads are really taking off again and the bottom line is the market is out of money. You also have boomers hitting peak RMD, geopolitical stuff hitting energy and commodities. We have a long way to drop, the question is will it be fast or slow. But it’s healthy, prices were too high, people were speculating. Risk off now.

  • small_model 19 hours ago

    You could say then Nvidia are the smartest guys in the room?