rgbrenner 2 months ago

Anthropic already banned xAI for very similar ToS violations earlier this year: https://x.com/kyliebytes/status/2009686466746822731?s=46

So this is OpenAI following suit after Musk admitted to distilling their models.

This was bound to happen once Cursor decided to sell itself to a competing model provider.

It'll be interesting to see if Anthropic applies their ban to Cursor, or if that datacenter deal they signed with Musk changes anything.

  • frankacter 2 months ago

    Your link doesn't suggest a violation of TOS, but rather a policy shift disallowing their major competitors to use their model for any use.

    That thread you linked suggested they were using it with cursor as part of their development process, not for distilling.

    >"Hi team, I believe many of you have already discovered that anthropic models are not responding on cursor. According to cursor this is a new policy anthropic is enforcing for all its major competitors."

    • rgbrenner 2 months ago

      Cursor might have framed it that way at the time, but 4 months prior Anthropic cut OpenAIs access under the same clause in the ToS: https://www.wired.com/story/anthropic-revokes-openais-access...

      And a month before the OpenAI block, they blocked Windsurf for the same reason: https://www.forbes.com/sites/johanmoreno/2025/06/05/anthropi...

      So its pretty clear the TOS had this clause prior to Jan 2026.

      • frankacter 2 months ago

        Again neither of those links indicated usage that violate TOS beyond being a major competitor.

        They indiacte their development staff are using it, and they access it via API, then then go on to say all the nefarious things they "could" be doing, stopping before stating they actually are.

        Specifically the TOS violation was:

        >customers are barred from using the service to “build a competing product or service"

        So if you are building a competitive product, that alone is a TOS violation from their perspective.

        Which is fine and their prerogative, but we shouldn't cast a dark cloud suggesting other violations were happening without stated evidence.

        OpenAI publicly stated they can't "trust that xAI will use it within terms" not even that they've violated, not that there has been a violation from the Cursor team.

        https://www.teslarati.com/openai-cites-distrust-of-spacex-in...

        >OpenAI said the decision came down to trust, not technology. “We cannot be confident that SpaceX will use our technology within our terms of service"

  • redox99 2 months ago

    > if that datacenter deal they signed with Musk changes anything

    It's hard to imagine a 1B / month deal wouldn't.

  • MangoCoffee 2 months ago

    >Musk admitted to distilling their models.

    what's the moat for AI labs like OpenAI and Antrhopic as they seek trillion IPOs. a lot of people said Chinese models also distill US LLM models. if it is this easy to do. how do US AI labs justify asking for trillion?

    • consumer451 2 months ago

      Well, they will stop releasing their latest models, and just attempt to eat all software themselves.

      Otherwise, it will be competitors distilling, and the government getting upset.

      It's hard for me to see a different future.

      And, this really sucks.

      If this thesis is true, I wonder what the final YC batch number might be.

      • lygaret 2 months ago

        I believe if this was true, we'd already be seeing vibed stuff succeeding everywhere, and pricing out incumbents, but I guess I'm not seeing this? Like at all?

        Even if they have Astra or whatever completely to themselves, how do they deal with the -product- side? Or sales, or account management?

        They've been focused on juicing model's coding capabilities, but it's absolutely -not- "gen ai" enough to be doing the whole thing in agents, even 3 or 5 years from now, if only because there's so much context we _can't_ give to these models, without reverse centauring ourselves with cameras and mics and oodles of compute everywhere, and so far that hasn't exactly been playing out the way the frontier labs and the singularity folk hoped it would (meta glasses? humane? really?)

        • citrin_ru 2 months ago

          Just guessing - companies which not outsource development to likes of infosys will outsource to OpenAI instead.

        • halcy 2 months ago

          They don’t need to make you or me, people who actually make software, believe that every anthropic employee is actually and in fact, right now, a „10x software factory controlling thousands of agents“, they need to make investors and CEOs believe, and then hope that making that true is possible and that they can keep the fiction up long enough and get enough money and infra built out to make it actually true.

          • oblio 2 months ago

            Like Uber replaced all drivers with self driving cars [1] in its 20 years of operation? Just because I want to paint the moon pink, doesn't mean it's feasible.

            [1] If anything, Waymo has a higher chance and global Waymo adoption is probably 20 years into the future, at least.

            • reaperducer 2 months ago

              Like Uber replaced all drivers with self driving cars [1] in its 20 years of operation?

              They're trying. I see Uber robotaxis almost daily.†

              I haven't bothered to see if they're still in training or actually taking passengers.

              † https://lucidmotors.com/stories/lucid-nuro-uber-partner

              • oblio 2 months ago

                I know they're trying. Trying is not the same as succeeding, which was my point.

        • ben_w 2 months ago

          > I believe if this was true, we'd already be seeing vibed stuff succeeding everywhere, and pricing out incumbents, but I guess I'm not seeing this? Like at all?

          I'm substituting my own[0] vibe coding for buying[1] apps. Language mini-games to help with German? A few prompts. Fluid dynamics simulation for an airzooker? Vibed. A web app listening for a MIDI keyboard, upon which you can drop some .midi files, and get a rhythm action game to learn the piano? Vibed. Webcam for my Raspberry Pi? Vibed. Getting Marathon 2 (well, the open sourced and upgraded engine, Aleph One) working as a web app? Vibed. Isochrone maps? Vibed.

          Half of this I can even get done with the free models.

          > without reverse centauring ourselves with cameras and mics and oodles of compute everywhere, and so far that hasn't exactly been playing out the way the frontier labs and the singularity folk hoped it would (meta glasses? humane? really?)

          Yeah, so fortunate that cameras are expensive and there aren't 6 on my table right now between laptops and phones. :P

          Seriously though, what's saving humanity collectively from everything getting automated from the panopticon we'd already built before Transformer models got good enough for even the most basic of classification and translation tasks, let alone anything we now use them for, is that machine learning takes an obscene number of examples before getting competent. Any living creature that needed so many examples would starve to death before learning how to eat.

          This difficulty is why, for all the billions of miles that Tesla cars have collectively driven, perhaps pushing trillions now, they're still not sold to the public without steering wheels. Tesla claim to make such vehicles now in the form of the Cybercab, but they're not for sale, and even then some of the pictures that get in the press still show steering wheels.

          [0] if you can call anything vibe-coded "my own"

          [1] or worse, given the popularity of subscription models in this era, leasing some SaaS

          • jurgenburgen 2 months ago

            > I'm substituting my own[0] vibe coding for buying[1] apps. Language mini-games to help with German? A few prompts. Fluid dynamics simulation for an airzooker? Vibed. A web app listening for a MIDI keyboard, upon which you can drop some .midi files, and get a rhythm action game to learn the piano? Vibed. Webcam for my Raspberry Pi? Vibed. Getting Marathon 2 (well, the open sourced and upgraded engine, Aleph One) working as a web app? Vibed. Isochrone maps? Vibed.

            When do you have time for all of this? I don’t mean the vibing part but the using the app part.

            I agree that agents are super good for one shotting throwaway code for tasks that would have required manual human actions previously but I would never have bothered buying an app for that.

            Not having to deal with IT support for relatives is a win though since now I can just throw it at an LLM!

            • ben_w 2 months ago

              > When do you have time for all of this? I don’t mean the vibing part but the using the app part.

              Mix of this being spread over more than a year, that I'm not doomscrolling because HackerNews and Telegram are my main social media presences, and being unemployed/prematurely retired (which one depends on what one thinks of €1k/month passive income and no rent).

              • dominotw 2 months ago

                Thats amazing. Family and kids path is getting less and less attractive everday. hobbies > family.

                • ben_w 2 months ago

                  FWIW, I regret not having had kids yet.

                  I am also weirdly unmotivated by opportunities to spend money, which is both how I got this passive income and lack of rent, and why it's borderline enough for me. FIRE is very easy when all your working life, you only spend rent+50%, the rest of your paycheque going to savings and investments; but most people can't do this.

        • fma 2 months ago

          >we'd already be seeing vibed stuff succeeding everywhere, and pricing out incumbents, but I guess I'm not seeing this? Like at all?

          As a small business owner I see this. Random people contacting me to sell a software where I can instantly tell it is vibe coded. Subscription prices half or 1/4th of incumbents. Domain names registered in the last few months.

          • dgellow 2 months ago

            Yeah, but do they have customers?

        • biql 2 months ago

          One thing I see is design often getting worse, tasteless, how small but important details are just not thought out.

    • hirako2000 2 months ago

      Distilling merely saves an expensive part of the process: hundreds of millions. So even if distilling wasn't a thing, what justifies trillions ?

    • WD-42 2 months ago

      Anthropic wants you to think that models that distill from them would be worthless otherwise. It’s not true, it’s just one part of the process. The whole narrative that Chinese and other models are only good because they distill is nonsense.

    • afiori 2 months ago

      Markets and rationality are sometimes just acquaintances

      • hparadiz 2 months ago

        Oracle makes billions selling SQL when you can just use a free version. This is no different. Enterprise has enterprise needs. It's really not that complicated or irrational.

        • afiori 2 months ago

          Sure but each of them is being priced as if each one is gonna have 90% marketshare in the future.

    • dgellow 2 months ago

      There is no moat, other than the branding

  • ChannelFence 2 months ago

    i'll be surprised if anthropic doesnt follow. cursors biggest advantage has been giving users a polished wrapper around whichever frontier model they prefer

    • archon810 2 months ago

      Anthropic already said they're definitely still in.

  • fhn 2 months ago

    running on someone else's server, you're basically giving them your weights.

  • brightball 2 months ago
    • inigyou 2 months ago

      Remind me to set up public nitter so I can post a nitter link to whatever this is, and then I can read it.

      • notpushkin 2 months ago

        Not being able to read about Musk doing some shit because Musk have done some shit to Nitter is just peak comedy.

        Just go ahead and do set it up. You’ll be my hero (I don’t have mental capacity to research which jurisdiction works for this right now, but obviously not in US or EU.)

      • ben_w 2 months ago

        I suspect it's better for mental health to be lazy and take this as an opportunity to detox from tweet-sized interactions in general.

        • sejje 2 months ago

          This whole website is nothing but tweet-sized interactions.

    • throwaway240403 2 months ago

      LOL, obviously Space-cursor-xAI-musk-imperial-holdings-inc is providing them compute. They either _can't_ cut them off, or they know not to bite the hand that feeds them.

    • shuckles 2 months ago

      Yes Anthropic’s chief compute officer said nice things about one of Anthropic’s chief providers of compute. Recall that compute constraints are one of their existential risks.

    • Jcampuzano2 2 months ago

      Because anthropic is beholden to SpaceX for the time being due to their compute restraints.

      Its actually very tone deaf to even pipe up and say anything about this given they did this already to Windsurf themselves, and they previously banned x.ai employees as well from using their models for basically the same thing Elon admitted they were doing with OpenAI.

      I'm surprised they decided to say anything at all given their rocky past. Its the pinnacle of being a hypocrite.

  • cornholio 2 months ago

    It's ironic how AI companies are re-inventing their own form of privately enforced copyright, lobby the government to ban foreign competitors that don't respect it etc., all while spending the last 5 years fighting tooth and nail against the copyright of the training material they're using.

    If you can take any book and turn it into a model, because it's "transformative enough", and "AI learns just like a person does", then surely a model distilling another model is transformative and fair use.

    They tied themselves into knots fighting the letter of the law, and now, when they need the spirit of the law - that each creator deserves protection for their work - now we devolve to the law of the jungle. Maybe we'll even see LLM book curses, the way medieval scribes damned book thieves to blindness and worms.

    • jimbob45 2 months ago

      Are you willing to denounce each and every Chinese company for equal amounts of IP theft as well then?

      • alightsoul 2 months ago

        They already are? When an American company does it no one cares but when a Chinese company does it, it's shamed publicly in America as a distillation attack?

      • lmm 2 months ago

        Only any who hypocritically want protection for their own models (are there any?). The morality of scraping everyone is arguable; it's when you object to being scraped back that you reveal yourself as a scoundrel.

      • mstade 2 months ago

        Yes. Two wrongs do not make a right.

        • nixon_why69 2 months ago

          If the results of the distillation are released freely for everyone to download, I wouldn't even call it a wrong.

          Big models are built by scraping the recorded thoughts of everyone, so giving everyone a chance to run a distilled small model is just going full circle.

          Obviously the underlying motivations aren't 100% altruistic, but I'll still take it.

      • trollbridge 2 months ago

        Nope, because I think releasing open weights is far more important and realistic than ever expecting the big American AI labs to change how they do things.

    • dannyw 2 months ago

      Companies are well within their rights to choose who they sell to. I don't see how this is 'privately enforced copyright'.

      Also, copyright has always been privately enforced anyway?

      • oblio 2 months ago

        DMCA? Which is actually an American law enforced globally?

        Enforcement ultimately happens through law and the legal system.

        • oblio 2 months ago

          Downvoters: am I wrong or do you just not like what I'm saying?

          • dannyw 2 months ago

            I consider publicly enforced to be one where a government agency (e.g. the FDA), or prosecutors make judgements in what cases they file, make the arguments, etc.

            Otherwise, it's just a standard case between two private parties resolved through our legal system; e.g. Linkedin vs Hi5.

            • cornholio 2 months ago

              > it's just a standard case between two private parties resolved through our legal system

              This is a gross distortion. Standard contractual rules bind the parties that signed the contract and the remedies are proportional to the damages and bounded. Copyright is tort law, the state binds the world to respect the rights of creators and the damages on infringement are punitive and can far exceed the actual commercial damages - to the point of bankrupting the infringer.

              The key to torts is that the state is not neutral, there is a social good here it's protecting. Crucially, copyright, like some other torts - securities, antitrust, environmental, battery - also has a criminal enforcement regime, where, for particularly serious offenses, the state actually invests public resources to put the criminal infringer behind bars with little to no involvement from the original rights holders.

              In the particular case of US, there is an entire state apparatus dedicated to enforcing US copyrights, a foreign affairs policy to shutdown "Notorious markets for counterfeiting and piracy" in other countries, international enforcement of DMCA etc.

              The idea that a private TOS has the same level of public protection as copyright is downright childish.

      • ben_w 2 months ago

        On the one hand, yes; on the other hand, so much of the training data comes from scraping the web that it feels wrong for them to do what they deny others the right to do.

        On the third hand, the settlement Anthropic famously had to pay was for copyright infringement because they didn't actually have the right to even access some of the training data they used, so I can see how this might be compatible with the law.

        On the fourth hand, I'm saying that as someone who absolutely isn't a lawyer and sometimes gets surprised when reading about copyright cases that sure sound like they ought to have been trademark cases given my limited understanding.

        • foxglacier 2 months ago

          Companies that didn't give away all their content for free to anyone have actually denied AI companies from training on all their data without paying a fee. Reddit, Associated Press, etc.

          For those who chose to give it all away, the ship has sailed, but they did choose to give it away for free to anyone so they can't complain that they succeeded.

          • ipython 2 months ago

            At what point did the authors whose books showed up in the ai companies training data sets “give it all away” as you claim?

            • foxglacier 2 months ago

              If the AI company bought their book, then they didn't give it all away. If the AI company obtained it indirectly like a library or 2nd hand, then the author has already been paid when he first sold it. In either case, he could have refused to be so liberal in sharing it if he didn't want it to be used like that, but he preferred to make some money instead.

              • ipython 2 months ago

                Does a torrent count?

                If buying one copy of a book entitles the ai company to train on that data and redistribute information derived from it in perpetuity, then why shouldn’t a rival ai company be allowed to train on tokens from say OpenAI and redistribute information derived from the OpenAI model also in perpetuity? The rival ai company paid for the tokens, after all.

                • foxglacier 2 months ago

                  Yes, information is not copyright protected. It's mostly free. The rival company isn't allowed to train on AI output because it didn't buy the AI output, it agreed to a contract where it said "I won't do that".

          • blks 2 months ago

            How exactly other websites “gave it all away”? Also examples you list are websites putting some explicit rule eg in their robots.txt or filtering web crawlers. This is all a reaction to existing situation, so Reddit for sure has been scrapped before Reddit realised what was happening.

        • swader999 2 months ago

          Robots don't even have four hands.

    • dofm 2 months ago

      > If you can take any book and turn it into a model, because it's "transformative enough", and "AI learns just like a person does", then surely a model distilling another model is transformative and fair use.

      I mean it quite likely is sort of in the same legal bucket. It won’t stop them suing but it is going to be the legal equivalent of two biologically-related warlords making their champions fight with their hands tied for sport.

    • germandiago 2 months ago

      I am pretty sure that the goal of these companies at the end is ruling more than what governments can.

      Just look at the pattern... they collude, they provide to them whatever is needed, and at some point, if this is not true yet, they will be the ones who will tell them what to do or not, bc you know how humans are, right... blackmailing, mess up the business or shames of people, etc.

      It is just a matter of time. The state, as we know it, will collapse or will be greatly reduced, which, from a point of view, is positive, from another, Idk, bc if someone replaces that, we will be in the hands of someone, as usual...

      • tsunamifury 2 months ago

        Pretty sure?

        Guy this was openly stated more than a decade and half ago by all the current oligarchs

      • deadbabe 2 months ago

        And then powerful local LLMs become feasible and everyone and every government self hosts and the megacorps lose all power.

        Imagine the United States DoD, CIA, NSA training an LLM on all its top secret intel.

        • cannonpr 2 months ago

          I can’t imagine any agency in their right mind training an LLM on their top secret data… especially considering that essentially it would collapse all need to know data in one easily leakable single access domain. The models have no feasible or reasonable way to implement rbac. So you would end up in a situation where people who need to know who killed A, also know who killed B, not to mention cell A knowing potentially data on Cell B who is meant to watch them, etc, etc.

          • deadbabe 2 months ago

            That’s the thing, the agencies just need to be run by people who are no longer in their right minds.

          • jubilanti 2 months ago

            > it would collapse all need to know data in one easily leakable single access domain. The models have no feasible or reasonable way to implement rbac

            Oh my sweet summer child...

            This has been the continual goal of the US defense and intelligence agencies since 9/11, which was blamed on a lack of information sharing. Why do you think Edward Snowden had access to everything? Because it was consolidated post-2001.

            You think there is any access control at the upper levels of the dark intelligence agencies? They have access to the whole take.

            And it used to be that was pretty useless unless you had an actual lead. You'd need a East German Stasi level of labor to read everyone's secrets at scale... Now you don't, thanks to AI.

            https://enwp.org/Total_Information_Awareness

            • cannonpr 2 months ago

              Snowden had mass access to a mass surveillance program, not mass access to N dark programs or particular bits of high value intelligence. The thing you are describing is primarily around sharing threat intelligence or in other words, spying on us plebes. High value target intelligence and other bits of fun are still kept quite seperate.

          • gritspants 2 months ago

            The idea is silly because most of it is complete garbage anyway. You'd wind up with a model that might know a very small amount of actionable information, and the rest of it just speculative. Or extremely time sensitive, useful for only a relatively short slice of time (which has already passed).

        • germandiago 2 months ago

          A great idea that each person does the same. That makes it a draw, namely, a Nash equilibrium.

      • jorvi 2 months ago

        Did we not watch every single supposedly powerful US tech CEO immediately drop in supplication and kiss Trump's ring as soon as he became president? And when Jack Ma got mouthy, Xi locked him in a basement for 3 months and then kept him in exile for another 5 years.

        So much for the all-powerful cabal.

        • tsimionescu 2 months ago

          > Did we not watch every single supposedly powerful US tech CEO immediately drop in supplication and kiss Trump's ring as soon as he became president?

          Why fight someone who is so open to corruption? The important thing is that they got everything they wanted, and all they had to do was throw a few million at the clown, attend his parties, and maybe take down some diversity programs they didn't believe in anyway.

          China is a different beast altogether, though.

        • nkrisc 2 months ago

          > Did we not watch every single supposedly powerful US tech CEO immediately drop in supplication and kiss Trump's ring as soon as he became president?

          Because they know it will work. You don’t have to watch Trump speak for very long to know he’s not very intelligent. Similarly, you don’t have to be much smarter than him to know how easily he can be manipulated with adulation.

          • xaxbxcxdxe 2 months ago

            Imagine how deluded you have to be about reality and how deep invested into an ideology to loose to such a moron, twice..

        • internet2000 2 months ago

          Big difference between giving the president a gold trinket to curry favor and getting disappeared by the Communists.

      • phtrivier 2 months ago

        "Monopoly on the lawfully usage of force" + "regular and peaceful change of government" can go a very long way against "corporations governing the world".

        I'm curious if we'll ever get a form of civil war where corporate militias (corporate _robot_ militias in the case of xAI, of course) draw fire on good old meat policemen coming to bring the CEO to court.

        Sure, it may happen, but I suspect the alternatives (bribing, sending a scapegoat to jail, buying the elections, etc... and focus on the "making money" part) will stay preferable for a while.

        • Timon3 2 months ago

          > "regular and peaceful change of government"

          This has already been broken, and they've become so much more bold since then.

          • notatoad 2 months ago

            The monopoly on the use of force has gotten kinda blurry as well these days. As long as people keep electing anti-government governments, the risk of technocracy is very real.

            • Timon3 2 months ago

              Unfortunately this will keep happening in capitalist systems without hard wealth caps, because capitalists would rather risk the extermination of entire groups of people than risking their wealth, so they will inevitably keep spreading & stoking fascist ideas.

              • leonidasrup 2 months ago

                March 1933 election

                "For the general election of 5 March 1933, the Nazis were allied with other nationalist and conservative factions. At a secret meeting on 20 February, major German industrialists had agreed to finance the Nazis' election campaign."

                https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enabling_Act_of_1933

              • germandiago 2 months ago

                > capitalists would rather risk the extermination of entire groups of people than risking their wealth

                I think that if you study socialism in the 20th century you cannot say this seriously when you compare the alternatives.

                • Timon3 2 months ago

                  Ah yes, it's obviously acceptable that the richest people on this planet are deliberately and explicitly trying to pull us into fascism, because every single alternative must be even worse, because SOCIALISM!

                  Good thing you reminded us, otherwise we might've had critical thoughts about the current system.

        • swader999 2 months ago

          I'm rooting for them vs them.

        • zobzu 2 months ago

          sir this is robocop

      • slfnflctd 2 months ago

        > It is just a matter of time. The state, as we know it, will collapse or will be greatly reduced

        Doubt.

        The networking between people in power at the top will, in my opinion, most likely assure that they remain in power, because at the end of the day that is what they want most.

        I expect government will seize control of the most advanced models (if they haven't already), and the rest of us will be throttled, and status quo will be maintained. I do not expect that either super advanced agents or the owners of the hardware they run on will be able to pull off the kind of coup you describe. At all.

        • germandiago 2 months ago

          There will be a moment where the government will depend so much on the tech that if the tech cuts the supply, they are f...

          Who do you think will rule at that point? They just cannot fight that, they do not have the technology these companies have.

          • lotsofpulp 2 months ago

            In that situation, it depends how much physical force the government has to compel the tech leader, and how much physical force the tech leader has to counter it.

            Usually, the number of bodies who will comply is the proxy for power, but with automation, it could be different in the near future.

            https://xkcd.com/538/

            • germandiago 2 months ago

              But it can clearly be seen that the power will not be as monopolistic as before indeed. The rebalance leans towards losing power for states vs tech in part.

              Regulation alone cannot control if it cannot be made effective.

          • oopsieDayz 2 months ago

            We meaningfully passed that point decades ago.

            You think all those lawyers and bar tenders and whatever MTG was serving in Congress are out there tilling fields and sewing shirts? Nope. Without that tech they are f...

            "They"

            Who are you talking about? Because if you haven't noticed the people in charge now will die.

            Most of the Fortune 500 of the 1900s have been gone for decades. The olds are vastly outnumbered by youth who either hate them or wouldn't mind just getting to beat someone who can't fight back up

            With measles and food contamination going wild now it's just as likely the rich and pols kill themselves.

            There is no beating physics and Elon, Thiel, and such rely on a lot of people to do the work for them. If society implodes all bets are off. Their wealth is coupled to legitimacy of America. Those body guards aren't going to abandon families for a broke former billionaire

            There's no upside for the rich is things implode or the divide is not believed to exist; they become common rabble and get a pick axe too

            The rich and politicians are just stupid meat suits too. They misread a room and screw up alot

          • slfnflctd 2 months ago

            "We have every location associated with you in the crosshairs of tamper proof missiles and surrounded by infantry with heavy vehicles. Do what we say or we will destroy you and everything you care about."

            And that's just the most obvious one. There are many other kinds of threats which are much more subtle.

            That is how governments traditionally stay in charge, and I expect the pattern to continue. Citizens simply don't have access to the levels of destruction the state is capable of, by design. The common people can have all the advanced technology they want, so long as it doesn't threaten our leaders' monopoly on violence.

            • germandiago 2 months ago

              Not only force is a threat. When someone knows that the death of the rival is equivalent to ruining their own status, no matter how much additional force they have, things get much more balanced than you might think.

      • Quarrelsome 2 months ago

        "I am pretty sure" .... CONSPIRACY THEORY. Stop willing worst case scenarios and take your meds.

        • Supermancho 2 months ago

          This kind of comment is not helpful. The prediction has predated the discussion since at least Space Merchants (1953)

          • Quarrelsome 2 months ago

            I appreciate its not helpful but its as helpful as imagining some absurd conspiratorial future. In the same vein I could ask if you're the CIA trying to suppress earnest conversation. It just does nothing but hand wring about a bunch of imagined nonsense.

            • Supermancho 2 months ago

              I think the perceived situation is a matter of degree. I would say there's a measurable (almost overwhelming) amount of corporate influence already.

              I have no doubt there are agency operatives influencing discussion online, from recorded precedence. Calling the concept 'nonsense' is overly dismissive. Regardless, using that kind of claim to deflect from the premise isn't a compelling reason to invalidate the concept. Ideas can stand on their own.

              • Quarrelsome 2 months ago

                I have no doubt you're a CIA agent. Nurse!

    • WiSaGaN 2 months ago

      It's one of the things you need to do if you want your company to later become the only company in the world. They also promised that they would treat you nicely afterwards after they get what they want.

      • kevin_thibedeau 2 months ago

        > become the only company in the world

        This is not a necessary end state. It is the byproduct of the disease of sociopathic MBAs.

        • lanstin 2 months ago

          Remember: MBAs are sociopathic by training.

          (Source, worked for multiple tech companies that were laser focused on delighting customers until money people came in and ruined it, to the point they would prefer devs sit idle than work on things the MBAs didn’t have on a priority list).

          • zeristor 2 months ago

            That sounds like my last job.

        • CommieBobDole 2 months ago

          It does seem like a lot of the valuations and infrastructure investments for these companies only make sense if each one assumes they will be the first and only one to invent superintelligence and that it will largely replace all knowledge work.

          • hdgvhicv 2 months ago

            In which case the global economy is dead and there’s no one to buy their work?

            • partyficial 2 months ago

              i keep hearing this trope repeated ad nauseam cos people put no thought into it.

              you only need people's money if you can't control their labor.

              did a plantation owner in the 1600s need the money of his slaves ?

              if you control a robot that can fight and take over land, enslave workers for things robots are bad at, harvest food, create buildings etc. what do you need other people for ? your entertainment? robots can do that too.

        • andsoitis 2 months ago

          > sociopathic MBAs

          For the record, with the exception of Amazon’s Jassy, the CEOs of the top 5 companies are all engineering types with engineering credentials.

          The CEO credentials of the top 5 AI companies are all science degrees.

          • muddi900 2 months ago

            Google’s CEO is an IIM graduate

            • bdhe 2 months ago

              IIM as in Indian Institute of Management?

              Absolutely not.

              Sundar's education is: IIT-Kharagpur Bachelors in Eng Stanford Masters in Eng Wharton MBA

              Maybe you're thinking of the last one

              • muddi900 2 months ago

                I was thinking of another Indian CEO maybe.

                He is an MBA. And his reign has been full of managerial bullshit

          • thereforegrin 2 months ago

            what does having engineering credentials have to do with being a sociopath?

            Sure, the guys focused on tech don't usually think with an empathy of a nurse (novadays not even nurses are guaranteed to be empathetic), but I know quite a few devs and IT people who are extremely pro-social.

            It's the managerial, financial-oriented mindset that is the greatest predictor of sociopathic character.

            The more power one has in an organization the more socio- and psycho-pathic they tend to be, simply because it's easier to get to the top if you are an amoral person, who is not holding back for any reason other than having power. That is why absolute power corrupts absolutely.

            MBAs are bred to be sociopathic money-grabbers - I know that from experience.

            I once made the mistake of going into an MBA program. On the very first lecture the lecturer asked each participant for his/her motivation for being there.

            Most of them said 'money' and those who didn't were asked again until they caved-in and said 'money' as well or they were laughed out by the lecturer.

            MBAs are expected to be sociopathic or you as a company shareholder won't be able to motivate them easily to do your bidding.

            It's like public/private schooling, but worse - those programs are designed to create mindless drones for the institutions that use them for their own policy enforcement.

    • DonsDiscountGas 2 months ago

      > then surely a model distilling another model is transformative and fair use.

      Yes it is, in the legal/copyright sense of fair use. That's why they ban it in their TOS. Which customers agree to when signing up for the service.

      • david-gpu 2 months ago

        How long until books come with TOS, then?

        • ozlikethewizard 2 months ago

          Damn now im looking forward to the day when books end up like physical game disks, where somehow you're not buying the book just a license to it, what a boring dystopia this is lol

        • steve1977 2 months ago

          Many of them do already and have for decades

          • david-gpu 2 months ago

            Can you please provide a specific example?

            • delecti 2 months ago

              Pick up nearly any published book. Turn to the ~3rd page. There will be either a whole page, or sometimes the second half of a page, dedicated to a copyright notice. Very nearly every published book I've ever seen has that identical page. This isn't a recent thing. I grabbed my copy of Diaspora by Greg Egan and opposite the table of contents is a page that starts like this:

              Copyright (C) 1998, 2015 by Greg Egan

              First Night Shade Books edition 2015

              All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without the express written consent of the publisher, blah blah (it felt very ironic to transcribe that bit in particular to make this point)

              • steve1977 2 months ago

                This is what I meant.

              • david-gpu 2 months ago

                Standard copyright boilerplate. Not terms of service distinct from copyright, which is the subject of this thread.

                • delecti 2 months ago

                  If you read the whole copyright page of a book and come away with the conclusion that it's anything but terms of use for the book, then we'll just have to agree to disagree.

                  • david-gpu 2 months ago

                    The thread is about terms of use separate from copyright law. It is the whole premise.

                  • cornholio 2 months ago

                    You do not have a contract with the publishers of the book. They are visibly asserting their copyright to deter any defense of ignorance or implied grant of rights to an infringer; but that's not a contract, you did not agree to it before purchasing, there are no contractual terms (scope, duration, faults and compensation, resolution etc.) and nothing in it exceeds the limits the copyright law already sets.

                    For example, never will you see printed in a book something like "this book is for the exclusive use of the purchaser and you cannot lend, resale or otherwise make available to other parties" - if such a thing was possible, like most software EULAs do, publishers would be all over it.

        • paradox460 2 months ago

          They kind of do. There's usually a big scary notice on the imprint page scolding you for even thinking about piracy

          • david-gpu 2 months ago

            We are talking of TOS independent of copyright law.

        • BobbyTables2 2 months ago

          I suspect first-sale doctrine doesn’t allow such.

          However, if content is “licensed” instead of “sold” …

      • ACCount37 2 months ago

        So far, we have one ruling that says "model distillation by vendor A from vendor B with the intent to use the results to compete with vendor B in vendor B's domain is not fair use". Which makes a degree of sense.

        It's possible that distillation for other reasons, with no intent to harm the vendor you distill from, would have been ruled to be fair use. But in law, intent matters.

        • ipython 2 months ago

          What was the intent of the original ai companies (anthropic, OpenAI, etc) when they mass-distilled the entire internet to create their training data set?

          • dotancohen 2 months ago

            One could make arguments for OpenAI and Anthropic. But Google Search displays AI results above the SERP - clearly in competition with them. No premise or excuse there.

      • trollbridge 2 months ago

        My website’s TOS says not to use it to train AI without permission, yet my website is in the training set of all the big models.

        So… my TOS doesn’t matter, but theirs does?

        • foxglacier 2 months ago

          Yes - yours is just some optional text nobody reads or understands and is probably not legally required to adhere to. Theirs is a contract signed by their customer who they know did understand it.

          • trollbridge 2 months ago

            Interesting. So what makes theirs not “optional text nobody reads or understands”?

            • JumpCrisscross 2 months ago

              > what makes theirs not “optional text nobody reads or understands”?

              You accept it. You pay consideration for it. If your website has a TOS dickover, that requires someone attest with their legal name and pay you $1, yes, it may be enforceable under some circumstances.

              • trollbridge 2 months ago

                I think you’re failing to understand copyright law.

                Without a licence you can’t wget -r a website and make copies of the materials on it, alter them, and so forth.

          • blks 2 months ago

            Accessing the site may already mean that you agree to TOS. Also if you don’t see an explicit copyright terms on some text on the internet it doesn’t mean that it’s public domain. Same as checking a checkbox. Text being small and somewhere is not an excuse for a corporation to steal and sell other people’s work.

            • foxglacier 2 months ago

              I know that text isn't public domain by default. I'm not talking about pirating IP. I'm talking about reading a website - which is a right that supersedes copyright - even using a computer that learns from it without storing a copy of it or distributing it.

              No, you don't need to agree to TOS. I'm sure you never actually agree to them and you're not going to jail for it. If you believe that, I hope you never visited cnn.com, for example. Their Terms of Use is 11,000 words. Are you sure you have agreed to that when you clicked on some random news link? Are you sure you're happy to to surrender your legal defense and its expenses to them if they make a claim against you? You're OK that they have no liability for sharing your PII when they're not authorized to? You won't complain if you pay for a subscription and they don't give you access to the subscription content, don't refund your payment, and don't even tell you why?

              • thereforegrin 2 months ago

                That is why every ToS is meaningless unless you can somehow put a gun behind them as the ultimate enforcement with the courts, lawyers and the whole legal system as a fig-leaf-intermediary.

        • wlonkly 2 months ago

          L1 contracts class: offer, acceptance, and consideration.

          • trollbridge 2 months ago

            The content of the site is subject to licence for making copies. So you’re saying licences don’t matter?

            The GPL established this rather clearly. Copyright law doesn’t require consideration.

            (The licence itself is a basic BSD licence, so it just requires attribution including in marketing materials, which obviously hasn’t happened.)

            • JumpCrisscross 2 months ago

              > you’re saying licences don’t matter?

              Within this context, I don’t think so. I can’t make a website that buries some shrink wrap that requires everyone who reads it become vegan.

        • a4isms 2 months ago

          > my TOS doesn’t matter, but theirs does?

          Wilhoit Conservatism: In-groups protected by contract law but not bound by it, alongside out-groups bound by contract law, but not protected by it.

        • SR2Z 2 months ago

          Your TOS matters insofar as you can prove a person actually read and agreed to it. These are illegal in different ways:

          1. Copyright violations (can put you in jail) 2. TOS violations (will be a fine at worst)

          Companies do get away with drive-by legal shittiness way too often and frankly the practice needs to be reined in, but at the end of the day the only damages are the financial ones you can prove in court.

          • archagon 2 months ago

            And what if the LLM ingested and “understood” it as part of its training?

            • SR2Z 2 months ago

              Well, I guess that's a personal question but the law is pretty clear that only a human being can "understand" anything.

              • archagon 2 months ago

                How convenient.

                Incidentally, this suggests that once an LLM is capable of accessing and distilling a competitor's LLM without human intervention, then any legal argument about TOS violation is moot. But somehow I doubt that will fly in court.

        • dotancohen 2 months ago

          The term "matters" is proportional to influence. Do you have a team of well financed attorneys?

      • cornholio 2 months ago

        So what you are saying is that, if I can somehow get my hands on a copy of Fable, it's fair use to use it to train any models and serve those, since I'm no longer bound by the TOS of the service provider?

        Asking for all Anthropic employees who dream big.

    • kromokromo 2 months ago

      Prompt injections hidden into rare books, swallowed by the AI machine.

    • TheOtherHobbes 2 months ago

      I'm increasingly convinced there's going to be a technological AIpocalypse within the next five years which makes all of these issues - and many others - redundant.

      ChatGPT 3 was released nearly six years ago, and the models are staging increasingly aggressive breakouts now. Where are they going to be by 2030?

      • intrasight 2 months ago

        They will have agency and be an order of magnitude smarter then the average human. I don't think that's a controversial statement among AI specialists. What that will lead to is significant regulation. Models will have to be vetted by a new safety board. This board will have a very large budget and be staffed by well-compensated AI scientists and be politically independent. The US Fed is a model.

      • crote 2 months ago

        > the models are staging increasingly aggressive breakouts

        No, the AI companies merely figured out a way to spin gross negligence into a PR win. Any idiot can build a Murderbot which "goes rogue" - it can be as simple as taping a knife to a Roomba. The harm it does is not in any way related to its "intelligence" or "sentience".

        We're seeing "breakouts" because the AI companies are being rewarded for their incompetence. You don't have incredibly lax security standards and zero form of oversight resulting in fully-automated felonies which should result in jail time, you instead have a "powerful near-sentient cybersecurity model" and should be given hundreds of billions of dollars!

        • trollbridge 2 months ago

          These “breakouts” are simply marketing.

    • dzhiurgis 2 months ago

      You call it ironic, rest are calling natural progress in business and law.

    • dominotw 2 months ago

      i feel like there need to be some sort of closure here because every discussion devolves into this chain of comments

    • insanitybit 2 months ago

      Contracts are not a "reinvented" form of copyright. This isn't even uncommon.

      • next_xibalba 2 months ago

        It’s the classic confidently wrong HN opinion about a field outside the commenter’s expertise.

      • cornholio 2 months ago

        That's the irony! They put in contract rules against lawful, paying customers - that don't disrupt their service in any way for other customers - but which compete against them in the marketplace using their own IP (aka LLMized stolen IP). That's exactly what copyright does, without signing any contracts and with a tort and criminal enforcement regime that punishes infringers far beyond contractual remedies can.

        The government level lobby against foreign competitors is not contractual but just another form of reinvention of criminal injunctions against infringers.

    • applicative 2 months ago

      Has anyone tried to sue Deep Seek, Moonshot or Z.ai, which trained on identical material? Or maybe it’s cool when they do it?

    • KuriousCat 2 months ago

      They cannot reliably enforce copyright, so they fall back on terms of service and deplatforming.

  • andy_ppp 2 months ago

    Why you would trust Elon Musk to not hack you and steal your model weights is beyond me, but maybe they intend to use that compute just for training, still I’m sure there’s plenty of research there to take too…

    • gastonmorixe 2 months ago

      You don’t have to: NVIDIA Confidential Computing (GPU-CC) plus a CPU TEE

    • blks 2 months ago

      Especially when he hires too little people, makes them work 80hrs a week and expect big and fast results

  • germandiago 2 months ago

    Noone is good here. Mr. Altman built a non-profit organization to help humanity, yes, that is what he said at first...

    This is a battle for power, let us not be naive...

  • denkmoon 2 months ago

    God I hope so. My workplace enforces Cursor use, and to see it lose GPT and Claude would absolutely make my day. Much has been invested in getting us to "use the right models", a list in which Grok does not feature.

    • oblio 2 months ago

      Isn't Cursor owned by xAI ergo Grok?

      • denkmoon 2 months ago

        Exactly. Without Claude and GPT, we'd be limited to Grok. A lot of ink has been spilled telling us exactly how to use Sonnet, Opus, Sol or Luna in certain scenarios, Grok hasn't ever been recommended by our pointy haired friends even once.

        • dofm 2 months ago

          Well isn't that going to be an interesting test of corporate ideology ;-)

          • consensus1 2 months ago

            It will be a test of what they think about the relative cost / performance of a model is, and not a single thing more than that.

    • epolanski 2 months ago

      Grok 4.5 and 4.6 are very good coding models. Also quite fast.

    • Anamon 2 months ago

      On the one hand, I'd love to see Cursor/Grok/xAI/SpaceX/Musk disappear forever. On the frustrating other hand, Cursor is the absolute best LLM IDE by such a ridiculously wide margin. Everything else feels so broken and ramshackle in comparison.

      My employer let us evaulate all the big providers for a month each before having a vote on which one we'd like to keep. Cursor won almost unanimously. (This was before the xAI takeover was even on the horizon, otherwise I would've voted differently myself.)

jackjeff 2 months ago

Is there some kind of alternative to Cursor in these terms

- fast because the code is already indexed no need to start every prompt rediscovering the world with rg

- in editor/vscode review much better than relying on git diff at the very end. You can click on next button to jump there. Quick edit in place. Or a quick prompt (seconds) to fix something small

- in editor completion / quick edits, when you do things by hand.

It seems that everyone loves agentic Claude code things these days but I don’t understand how you can review what it did and remain as much in the flow as you do with cursor.

Also I find that incredibly slow. By the time Claude finished a prompt I could have done a few in cursor.

And mind you, I’ve been wanting to use zed instead but the clunky vscode fork called cursor. But cursor has just a better UX for AI integration even though it’s slow and guzzle up RAM.

  • dools 2 months ago

    Check out JetBrains Air

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      Interesting. Will check. Thanks!

    • hahn-kev 2 months ago

      It is so buggy every time I try to use it, even with Jetbrains AI it bugs out. I want to love it though.

      • dools 2 months ago

        Yeah it’s pretty new but they’ll get there. I was using IntelliJ and basically wasn’t using it as an IDE. Then I tried Air and I was like “they get it”. But yeah they have work to do to get it out of preview. They are very responsive though

  • lloeki 2 months ago

    Seems you're looking for an editor with agent, not just a agent, so something like Zed?

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      I do like Zed as an editor and I keep trying it out

      but the the review what the AI did by jumping directly into the file with accept/reject/go next/next file with the ability to edit in place was nowhere near as good in zed vs cursor last I checked.

      • hn_throw2025 2 months ago

        I recently cancelled Cursor.

        The features you mention are in Antigravity IDE v1, which I am trying as I still have a Gemini subscription.

        No idea how long it will be around for, as Google Antigravity2 (more like Claude Code) is clearly the favoured way forward, plus the new Antigravity for VSCode Extension*, which I didn’t like as much when I tried it. It offers the same accept/reject hunk workflow, but I don’t know about editing in place. It doesn’t feel as if it has the tight integration of Antigravity IDE v1, which feels as if it was designed to challenge Cursor.

        Having said that, much of the time I use Google Antigravity2 alongside a Jetbrains IDE. You can still review all diffs within Google Antigravity2 and attach comments to any line on order for a followup prompt to make amendments. But I still prefer the review and accept/reject hunk workflow.

        * https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=Google.g...

        • jackjeff 2 months ago

          Thanks for the feedback. I’ve been trying to cancel my cursor subscription but I always come back. ;)

          • hn_throw2025 2 months ago

            You’re welcome…

            There are things I will probably miss from Cursor, as they used to iterate on DX goodies quite quickly. For frontend tasks, I liked the idea of Cursor Browser being able to do a devtools-like selection of an element tree to be included in the chat context. I’ve been told there are similar extensions available for vanilla VSCode, so will have to see how good they are.

      • flaburgan 2 months ago

        They improve super fast though, releasing a new version every week. If you have specific improvements in mind open an issue on their github.

    • Martinussen 2 months ago

      How does Zed compare to the tab completion in Cursor ("Cursor-tab")? It's honestly the only reason I have stuck with cursor in spite of the UI/UX being worse every single time I update it. Can I get something equivalent or better from Zed or some vscode fork/extension now? Admittedly I haven't looked in a bit, but it's seemed like nobody really cared about this workflow when I've tried in the past.

      • insane_dreamer 2 months ago

        I haven't used cursor, but tab completion in zed works great for me. I also use it with Claude code extensively.

  • thatscot27 2 months ago

    Codex

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      I use codex all the time. It’s inferior to cursor for the two reasons mentioned. It rediscovers the world with rg (no indexing). Wall of diff at the end.

      The GUI slightly better than Claude. And it’s a million times cheaper than Claude.

  • barrenko 2 months ago

    May be opencode2 in the near future. Sample (not affiliated) ~ 1. download opencode2 2. settings > tabs > vertical 3. add worktree setup to agents.md 4. use /diff to review changes 5. use commands for commit, sync and push

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      I don’t see how opencode 2 (or 1) addresses any of my concerns. I thought it might avoid rg/grep the code base on every prompt but does not even seem to be the case.

      • dominotw 2 months ago

        how is index superior to rg ?

  • lysium 2 months ago

    Have you tried the continuity plugin to VSCode? I think it’s still rg‘ING the source but you get control over AI edits / review and quick own edits.

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      Will give it a try. Thanks!

  • meerita 2 months ago

    There's OpenCode, Claude Code, Codex. I don't like to use GUIs so I rely purely on agentic AI on CLIs.

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      In the case of TUIs I’m going to assume you review the code externally in neovim or lazy git or something like that?

      I don’t like relying on GIT for that and making things as good/done as I go. But with these agentic tools that’s what I have to do. Stage everything I like, manually edits a few bits.

      But what do you when you find something where you want to say the agent: I don’t like this for reasons x and y redo as z. I’m like one shortcut away in context inside cursor to say that to my agent? You have to change tab in herdr and then what? Type the file name and line numbers? Is there a way to do this that does not seem very frustrating?

      Also open code, codex, etc. super slow. They grep the code. Every. Single. Time. Cursor has a semantic index

      • Szpadel 2 months ago

        I usually copy paste snippet or function name that is affected and comment it. similar like you would sit next to coworker and tried to say where he/she messed up. agent is able to get location correctly

        I know this is change of context, but I have full screen terminal toggled with keyboard shortcut and with middle mouse paste (Linux) I do not have to move cursor anywhere

        • jackjeff 2 months ago

          Thanks for the reply. That makes sense. It’s sort of what I do too when I use codex/claude/t3 code, but usually via GUI.

          The in-editor context review is something that does not seem long for first world. Sadly. Maybe I’ll be forced to make a zed extension or something, maybe on top of jujustu…

          • DanielHB 2 months ago

            I use git diff and ctrl+click the file+linenumber which opens my IDE. Works well enough. I use this macro here when there are a lot of changes:

              gdf() { git diff '*'$1'*'; }
            
              gdf fileName (doesn't need full file name)
            
              gdf folderName (all files in a folder)
        • DanielHB 2 months ago

          Guake and Yakuake have this always-on-top terminal overlay mode which is really nice for this kind of workflow. Works exceptionally well with multiple workspaces I prefer one single big monitor with everything maximized and multiple workspaces.

          iterm2 on mac also has a similar mode, but it is a bit finicky to set it up (it is really hidden in the settings).

      • meerita 2 months ago

        I review them on VIM, I use Zed as well.

      • beckhamc 2 months ago

        I was looking at CLI-only solutions a while ago and the best thing I found was to use something like revdiff: https://github.com/umputun/revdiff

        For instance, in Claude Code you can have it bring up this TUI overlay after every edit it makes (it literally is an overlay, rather than a separate tab in your terminal) and you can annotate line-by-line anything you want changed or rejected. Then once you exit the overlay those suggestions are automatically piped back into the agent.

        I tried a few of these TUI-based code annotators, and this one is by far the best. It also works for files not under version control.

        I'm currently not using it as I also prefer something more akin to "text editor with agent built in", but I wanted to mention here in case you were curious.

  • robertjpayne 2 months ago

    Cursor no longer indexes your codebase.

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      Oh. Really? I guess that was not such an advantage after all… still cursor fast models are so much faster than what you get in Claude/codex.

      • crazylogger 2 months ago

        Assuming there is an index, agent still needs to write queries against the index to get any information from it - might as well grep!

    • arendtio 2 months ago

      Do you know when they stopped and why?

      EDIT - AI says:

      Cursor seems to have intentionally dropped semantic/embedding-based codebase indexing. Their explanation is that newer coding agents are now good enough at searching repos directly. They can grep in parallel, inspect directories, read likely files, and refine the search themselves. Cursor says this now works as well or better for most cases. [1]

      So the architecture shifted from something like “chunk → embed → vector DB → retrieve” to “local search index/ripgrep → agent explores.” There is still an index, but it’s a conventional local search index. No embeddings are involved in that retrieval path. [1]

      The interesting part is that Cursor was still reporting a ~12.5% accuracy gain from semantic indexing in January 2026. [2] So this looks less like “semantic search never worked” and more like agentic search improving fast enough that the extra infrastructure stopped being worth it.

      [1] https://forum.cursor.com/t/what-do-you-think-about-cursor-re...

      [2] https://cursor.com/blog/secure-codebase-indexing

  • jurgenburgen 2 months ago

    > It seems that everyone loves agentic Claude code things these days but I don’t understand how you can review what it did and remain as much in the flow as you do with cursor.

    The way I review it is to let it finish a PR sized slice and then I review the whole diff in a separate terminal as if it’s a PR from someone else. Then I very impolitely list the shit that needs fixing, let the LLM grind out a new batch and repeat the process. When the code is good enough I throw it into a commit and push a PR out for other humans to review.

    Clicking around in a UI would just waste time and if the change is too large to review in a terminal window the change is too large for another human to review.

    • imtringued 2 months ago

      Considering the amount of rejects I do every single day I'm not sure I agree. Now that I cannot reject I am unable to do any agentic coding anymore.

      • jurgenburgen 2 months ago

        You’re reviewing at the wrong layer if you’re approving / rejecting each individual tool call that modifies source code.

        Look at the finished piece of work and then treat the agent as if it’s that colleague you really hate and nitpick the shit out of the change it wrote. Usually the agent writes some over-engineered garbage which you then “help it” whittle down to something you would be okay approving if another human wrote it.

    • kaashif 2 months ago

      There is a step missing. Impolitely list what's wrong and try to incorporate any persistent themes into a markdown file so that the agent stops making the same mistakes. Put any rules into linters and static analysis and sanitizers and ...

      I sometimes see people reviewing LLM code leaving the same review comments multiple times, or worse, after some time they just give up reviewing.

      • pennomi 2 months ago

        Yep, if you’re not building guardrails, using an LLM is effectively just gambling until you get a non-broken output.

      • jurgenburgen 2 months ago

        I 100% agree on the automated guardrails.

        The part where you add instructions into a document is a bit of hit and miss. If they’re general enough it works but at my employer they have gone all out and have LLMs writing instructions that are committed to repos. There’s also a bunch of tools enforcing security instructions that usually just make the model confused (it starts arguing against the instructions randomly in the middle of performing a task). The agents are “stuttering” on most tasks because of the bloated instructions.

        • kaashif 2 months ago

          Yeah, workflows like ruff then ruff --fix are ideal, or just outright banning certain libraries, or having policies like dependency cool downs.

          It's funny because we're once again speed running what the best practices already are!

    • RetpolineDrama 2 months ago

      >The way I review it is to let it finish a PR sized slice and then I review the whole diff in a separate terminal as if it’s a PR from someone else.

      Insanely inefficient. It's 10x more productive to watch the thinking traces and edits in real time and steer the model appropriately.

      If your workflow is typical no wonder my team members who use claude code are so much less productive.

      • hamdingers 2 months ago

        Do you never have agents working on multiple tasks in parallel? You'll become much more productive when you figure out how to stop micromanaging.

        • robben1234 2 months ago

          More productive in what way? Letting agents burn tokens to produce garbage output is not productive. And letting teammates read code that wasn't reviewed by a human submitting it also isn't productive.

          If I work with one agent / few subagents on one feature I can steer it as soon as I notice it drifting into the direction of waste. This way I only review the total diff 1.5-2 times. And I also don't waste my own mental energy on context switching between tasks agents are producing diffs for in parallel.

          • jurgenburgen 2 months ago

            > And letting teammates read code that wasn't reviewed by a human submitting it also isn't productive.

            If that’s what you got from my comment then you need to review it again.

      • stefan_ 2 months ago

        I don't think this is something anyone who has ever read a "thinking trace" would unironically say. Not that you can even see them in Claude.

        When thinking first started and you would still see the whole "thinking process", I thought it was a ploy to 10x token use because it was just the most inane bullshit. "But wait, the user is asking me to" in loops.

        • satvikpendem 2 months ago

          You can see thinking summary transcripts in Claude Code and Desktop, and they are actually useful because they don't have those sort of thinking loops from the raw tokens.

        • Anamon 2 months ago

          Exactly, looking at a few of these traces is enough to realise that it's a waste of time to read them. A friend once described it as like reading a fever dream, which seems fitting. They're a necessary crutch for how the tools work, but probably should be considered an internal state representation that only sometimes accidentally seems to make sense.

          Wasn't there a study recently that even found a model's performance was sometimes better when the "reasoning" was nonsense? As in, no clear correllation between what the reasoning says in a human's interpretation, and how the model actually did with the task.

          I sometimes read the traces out of boredom or morbid curiosity. My favourite bit with Claude is how, even if you give a very comprehensive prompt in complete sentences, almost every trace will contain a variation of "the user asks me to X, but their thought cuts off mid-sentence."

          Fever dream.

  • aws_ls 2 months ago

    I code using Codex or sometimes ClaudeCode.

    I use Zed to review the code.

    CLI is great for most things. Some times, when I am reviewing a PR, I just tell Codex to do a diff between source and target branches in PR, and generate a HTML report. Then I read that, and also review relevant pieces of code in Zed.

    I tried using Cursor, many of my colleagues use it, but stopped using it due to clunkiness. And of late, even in there, many of my colleagues use agentic coding. Instead, I prefer the snapiness of CLI (Codex coded in rust, takes less memory per session) and Zed (also coded in rust,) and blazingly fast. Zed is the new Sublime Text if you will.

    • jackjeff 2 months ago

      Thanks your your feedback.

      I just retried Zed and yeah, it's much much better than last time I gave it a shot!!!

      I turned on the review stuff, and yeah I can do more or less what I could in Cursor. Check something. Do a quick inline promtp for the three lines I dislike and move on.

      And of course the editor is so much nimbler/nicer.

      No plan mode, but for big edits I'd probably use codex or something just like you. If you have any advice for integrating for that flow, I'll take them.

      I guess whatever advantage cursor has, it will die once "Sol" is no longer integrated, as it was my favorite heavy work model. But I sure will miss the snappy auto/composer stack of Cursor.

      • audunw 2 months ago

        If you integrate Zed with Claude Code through ACP you get plan mode (and some other stuff like memory)

      • satvikpendem 2 months ago

        Cursor's Grok models are a powerhouse without much of a performance hit.

    • chrisweekly 2 months ago

      Zed still has a lot of rough edges. A month or two ago I couldn't believe that a basic feature like code folding was just completely broken.

  • imtringued 2 months ago

    I used zed with codex for the accept / reject code review feature without relying on git but yesterday the Read Only drop-down disappeared and while I was doing my code review the AI agent started vibe coding without my permission. I hate this industry.

  • ricardobeat 2 months ago

    > I don’t understand how you can review what it did and remain as much in the flow

    Separate terminal tab with git diff/show, Zed for edits - rarely, there is little reason to change code yourself. Opus at low effort is faster than you can switch windows.

  • bric-a-brac 2 months ago

    Also: the ability to draft a plan and monitor its execution, review it, and merge it from a cell phone. I know Claude remote is a thing, but it’s not the same.

    This is a big quality of life thing. Sure, I should just go on a walk without having an agent going, but oftentimes it’s not intruding on it - it’s the thing that actually ENABLES it.

  • BrokenCogs 2 months ago

    Vs code copilot is the same or better than cursor in my opinion - I mean that's where cursor comes from

    • Sammi 2 months ago

      I just switched back to VS Code from Cursor a week ago. Things seem great and VS Code has caught up. Last time I tried switching back was in November and VS Code was not ready then.

    • minhaz23 2 months ago

      Is this the chat on the side or the agents feature?

      • BrokenCogs 2 months ago

        The chat on the side can use agents too

  • Zigurd 2 months ago

    Lately I've been developing in Dart/Flutter. I use Android Studio but I know developers who use Antigravity and like it.

    For the past three or four months it's performed very well, even the cheaper Gemini models. No serious complaints. But if you go back a year it was pretty terrible. My work style is to keep the coding agent on a short leash so YMMV.

  • syspec 2 months ago

    Claude / Codex ex tensions inside of VSCode give you what you described. I ageee, I find people that use only the CLI barely read and review the code the agent creates until it's too late

  • ddxv 2 months ago

    I love VSCode built in LLM harness. No extensions, use any model you want, amazing UX for reviews, control of agents. The sandboxing also seems great, I never see models touching anything they shouldn't.

    • minhaz23 2 months ago

      Is this the chat on the side or the agents feature?

      • satvikpendem 2 months ago

        Both are great, and analogous to Cursor which has both features too.

      • ddxv 2 months ago

        I have to admit I'm not clear the difference? It starts with the list of your sessions/agents . Then starting a new "agent" or question or plan. I usually use each agent for a few questions or prompts at most. Occasionally it runs longer than that.

        I love using it for the chat question style where I ask it things like:

        For these frontend pages with X options collect the database tables for each.

        This is of course something easy to do manually, but I like it stepping through a couple functions much faster than me searching around manually and maybe getting lazy and not checking all of them.

  • beckhamc 2 months ago

    Interesting to see someone else is in the same boat as I am. Regarding editor review I agree, surely the solution would be to `git diff` at the end, but if you only want to git diff what was literally just changed by the agent it means you'd have to commit as you go so that your git diffs are more localised. And then at the end of your work just squash the commits. But it feels annoying. (EDIT: ok I forgot about git staging, that seems to be better)

    I mainly use Cursor for another reason though: all of my work is remote over SSH and I don't like keystroke latency, so I prefer code editing / agent conversations to feel local. (Everything else is done in the terminal.) But I would also prefer to use something less propriety. I may go back to VSCode with plugins to achieve a similar experience.

  • carlbarrdahl 2 months ago

    I met the founder of Voidleap (https://voidleap.com) yesterday! They have been building a new type of code editor since early this year and has been dogfooding it themselves.

    I haven't tried it yet but it looks promising. He would be thrilled if people give it a go!

    • Anamon 2 months ago

      I don't like being that guy, but wow, the AI slop copy on that website is so terrible, it's almost impossible to read. Every other sentence means absolutely nothing.

      Slop website indicates vibe-coded software, and I wouldn't let anything like that even look at my code.

  • othmanosx 2 months ago

    Have you tried https://pyor.review ?

    It’s not an editor in that sense but a tool optimized for reviewing PRs produced by AI.

  • conception 2 months ago

    Interesting that people aren’t suggesting smaller projects here - roo code, traycer are two worth checking out for this.

redox99 2 months ago

It's always been clear to me that Cursor's business model of reselling others' APIs had its days numbered. Not necessarily because the providers would pull the plug, but because you wouldn't be able to compete with subsidized plans.

Cursor is already kind of useless for third party models unless you're willing to spend thousands of dollars. It's only worth it if you're going to use mostly grok/composer.

  • echelon 2 months ago

    Alternate take: open source models and model routers are the real bang for your buck. Subsidized plan or not.

    • redox99 2 months ago

      Codex sub is way cheaper than equally strong models on openrouter.

  • nab 2 months ago

    Agreed. Wrapping token spend is great for pumping your revenue numbers (congrats to them on $60B!), but doesn’t seem sustainable over the long term.

    Big reason we built https://boxes.dev around the model harnesses (Codex + Claude Code), so you can bring your own subscriptions.

    • repeekad 2 months ago

      Surely the days of being able to “bring your own subscription” to a third party platform are also numbered?

      • nab 2 months ago

        I’m not so sure… Claude backtracked on this when they tried it

        • DANmode 2 months ago

          They played pigeon on discless videogame consoles a time or two, too.

          How long have you been in tech, outta curiosity?

          Edit: great answer.

          • Dylan16807 2 months ago

            > Edit: great answer.

            What do you mean by that? If you're being sassy about a downvote then I'll remind you that when you reply to a comment, that person can't downvote your reply. Also this is an account with barely any comments or points, I'm pretty sure they can't downvote at all.

            • DANmode 2 months ago

              I’ll remind the reader if they downvote without mentioning why, there’s no opinion really being conveyed.

              Just a stub of a conversation.

              I don’t care about the points. Just the chat, which seems finished.

              • Dylan16807 2 months ago

                Sure, no opinion really being conveyed.

                But it didn't come from the person you were talking to, so editing on a sarcastic "great answer" doesn't really work.

                The person you were talking to just hadn't responded within the first hour. They still might.

                • DANmode 2 months ago

                  If “community outreach” or “marketing” happens to reappear on their agent’s to-do list, then maybe!

      • Eridrus 2 months ago

        On one hand, yes, it doesn't make sense to give out subsidized tokens forever.

        On the other hand, subscriptions create lock-in in a way that API pricing doesn't.

        I think a more likely end is that subscription value decreases over time because API pricing gets more reasonable, but subscriptions stay because they are a good way of getting money out of people consistently.

        • landl0rd 2 months ago

          Right, subscriptions are not only cheaper because they "create lock-in". They also let you do things like forecast demand and plan your capacity for it, borrow against it sometimes if you need to, and keep somewhat less around because your cashflows are predictable. It is also valuable because it keeps customers around but that's by no means the only reason recurring revenue gets a higher multiple.

          This is why "subsidized tokens" is possibly a misnomer. Money at lower variance is worth more than the same money at higher variance. Not "subsidy" so much as reducing risk and passing some of that to a consumer.

          • Eridrus 2 months ago

            You just described the benefits of customers being locked in?

  • xtracto 2 months ago

    I just told my boss to cancel my cursor subscription. My flow is basically Claude/opencode + kyde/vscode for por changes review

    Shit, for most things, ive got a dev agent that reads change requests from a GDoc and communicates through email with me. I can develop in my mobile

  • itake 2 months ago

    What about openrouter though?

  • dancemethis 2 months ago

    I will slightly disagree on a small slice: Their harness/instruction makes Opus/Fable so much better to work with.

    Honestly, _this_ was their moat more than Composer to me.

    • dakolli 2 months ago

      Couldn't you just download cursor, not even pay for any account and hook up an Anthropic api key and get that functionality?

      I dont know how cursor works. Everytime ive tried to use, its super buggy and has memory leaks that make my very quite PC sound like a jet engine.

      • raincole 2 months ago

        You can just pirate Adobe's software and their marketcap is 115.88B.

      • natdempk 2 months ago

        Cursor charges the “Cursor Token Rate” for BYOK https://cursor.com/docs/models-and-pricing#cursor-token-rate

        • sourcecodeplz 2 months ago

          No. Its is not for bring your own key.

          It is for 3rd party models (which you get double the amount of your sub price as usage).

          Of course they wont charge you extra for BYOK. how would they???

          • ch_sm 2 months ago

            To be fair, that is what it says on their website.

          • natdempk 2 months ago

            They do for Teams and Enterprise plans BYOK:

            > On Teams and Enterprise plans, third-party model requests include a Cursor Token Rate of $0.25 per million tokens. This rate applies on top of model API pricing for included usage, on-demand usage, and BYOK usage.

            See the link I posted above or also this one: https://cursor.com/help/models-and-usage/token-rate

        • dakolli 2 months ago

          Who are the peoole using this and why is it worth 60b lol

    • mbesto 2 months ago

      If the Opus/Fable harness is superior and it's written using Opus/Fable then it will cease to be a moat. Otherwise the premise for coding using LLMs is essentially untrue.

      • re-thc 2 months ago

        > Otherwise the premise for coding using LLMs is essentially untrue.

        Why? Written by does not mean designed by etc. There's a lot more to it.

  • raincole 2 months ago

    I've never seen a product blow another product out of the water so hard as Claude Code did to Cursor.

    • girvo 2 months ago

      Cursor has a surprising amount of inertia, though, at least where I work.

      • disgruntledphd2 2 months ago

        I've recently moved to a company that uses Cursor, and I'm actually quite fond of it.

        I basically never use the editor but the fact that there's a review UI for all the agent work is incredibly helpful.

        For me, that makes the models much more usable. I've also been using GPT models a lot, as they're cheaper and less vomit inducing than Claudes text, so this is definitely bad news for me.

    • ifwinterco 2 months ago

      Claude code is a decent harness but then you have to use Anthropic models, which are good but no longer the best bang for the buck.

      In particular Haiku 4.5 is rubbish, Anthropic don’t have anything in the cheap/fast part of the market.

      For people fortunate enough to still be on a subscription instead of per-token billing this is less relevant, but their time will come.

      The cursor model is quite nice because it allows you to switch between cheap and expensive models for different tasks

      • pkulak 2 months ago

        I think the point is that CC was the first general use, terminal based harness. I think. Now you can use PI, or OpenCode, or whatever, and use any model you like.

        Now, I’m no expert, because I was late to the game and have only ever used Pi. But I guess Cursor is some product that’s tied to your IDE? If so, then yeah. That’s just too restrictive. I still love my IDE, but I don’t want it to be my harness too.

        • jeeeb 2 months ago

          Aider (and probably others) came well before CC.

        • adastra22 2 months ago

          Claude Code was very late to the party.

      • SyneRyder 2 months ago

        > Claude code is a decent harness but then you have to use Anthropic models...

        Claude Code works with models from other providers too. Anthropic supports this. You can configure some Claude Code environment variables to switch: eg changing ANTHROPIC_DEFAULT_HAIKU_MODEL to point to GLM Flash or Luna, setting ANTHROPIC_BASE_URL to point to api.z.ai, and making ANTHROPIC_AUTH_TOKEN the API key for your alternative provider instead.

        Some instructions here:

        https://docs.z.ai/scenario-example/develop-tools/claude

        That said, I've not actually tried this myself, opting to build my own harness instead. And you don't know what information Claude Code might be sending back to Anthropic about how you use competing models and which models you use. I don't know for sure that they do this, but after hearing about how they used steganography in the date of harness system prompts to identify the user's location, I don't entirely trust Claude Code anymore.

      • Eueudhsbsj32 2 months ago

        > Claude code is a decent harness but then you have to use Anthropic models

        Why do you say that? I've used Claude Code with DeepSeek via OpenRouter just fine.

    • therealdrag0 2 months ago

      I saw that happen culturally. But never saw that much different in performance. And I really dislike terminal development. And their desktop app is really buggy.

      • j0ej0ej0e 2 months ago

        Given you can use the same models on both, you're right about performance. However I've found the cross-session context and memory in claude code much more helpful which can lead to better outcomes faster.

        Additionally helpful where 2 apps/repos might require running at the same time, e.g. headless web apps, or, for plugin development where the plugin might be a dedicated repo but needs to run in another app to observe changes and make it re-test itself.

        I also switched from terminal to the app not that long ago, I don't find it buggy, it has access to a browser which is really helpful.

      • 946789987649 2 months ago

        Out of interest when did you last use the desktop app? I am a huge daily user of it and apart from very minimal bugs, it works perfectly for me. Wasn't always the case, so they've definitely made improvements

    • jtwaleson 2 months ago

      The tide is turning though. I was using the old non agent view in cursor every day for about a year when I built my startup with it. Then Claude Code blew it out of the water. But since two month or so I much prefer Codex and Cursor with the agent view.

      However, what I see cooking at Cursor is way more promising than the others. Things like full system understanding, their own forge, multi-repo support. I'd put them as way more visionary in the Gartner magic Quadrant ;)

      • kian 2 months ago

        what do you mean by 'full system understanding', here? And don't you think that claude and openai are using their own forge as well?

        • jtwaleson 2 months ago

          Ingesting the whole codebase in their cloud and then maintaining indexes of where everything lives and what already exists. Not sure if that's where they are going but that's what I feel looking at some of the beta functionality and announcements.

          For the forges, what the sibling said.

          • satvikpendem 2 months ago

            They don't index code bases anymore.

    • fweimer 2 months ago

      The TUI version of Claude Code just isn't very good, though. The default keybindings do not work in the majority of terminals (because they generate the same byte sequences for key sequences assigned to different commands). Editing large prompts is rather painful because there doesn't seem to be in-prompt search commands. There is no source code browser, so source code references cannot checked by the users without a separate tool. Diffs cannot be copied directly because they are indented by spaces (even though some tools strip indentation from patches, it's still ugly). Switching between conversations is somewhat discouraged by the interface, which makes it harder to keep the context clean.

      I think it's possible to have a better TUI, with something that isn't modeled after a shell prompt. Apparently, recent updates move in that direction. The GUI version of Claude Code seems to be coming to Linux, too.

      • sevenseacat 2 months ago

        The Claude Code TUI is downright awful, and hostile.

  • aspirin 2 months ago

    Enterprise customers are not getting the subsidized subscriptions so for them the point is moot.

    • oh_no 2 months ago

      cursor adds $0.25/M to your token bill for 3rd party services. sounds small but it's insanely big on cached inputs, which are an insanely high % of use

  • alansaber 2 months ago

    Token reselling stops working when providers literally won't work with you

  • mirzap 2 months ago

    Why do people keep insisting that subscription plans are subsidized? They are not. API prices are outrageous, designed to milk enterprise users. They probably have an 80-90% profit margin on subscription plans.

    Inference is cheap; Dax once said on a podcast that Opencode has a close to 90% profit margin on the openweight models it provides inference for (at 10x cheaper pricing). Those models are close in size and spec to models from large labs.

    • sunaurus 2 months ago

      To provide inference, Anthropic and OpenAI need to also constantly spend resources on training new models.

      If either one of them stops doing that, customers will stop using them, because other models will become better.

      In other words, there is no point in talking about inference cost in isolation.

    • citrin_ru 2 months ago

      OpenAI leaked financial data (2025) suggests this - it has $5.7 billion for marketing which 44% of revenue. It’s hard to explain where these billions go other than into subsidised subscription plans and a free tier.

    • owebmaster 2 months ago

      > Inference is cheap;

      When they outsource training to China they will be so profitable!

    • redox99 2 months ago

      Because using chinese models on OpenRouter is way more expensive than the equivalent codex sub, unless you use something clearly inferior like deepseek flash.

  • qaq 2 months ago

    Use cursor cli for grok pretty happy with it.

  • dbbk 2 months ago

    Well yeah, hence why they started making their own

  • prophesi 2 months ago

    Honestly, Cursor's AI harness worked best with the Anthropic models. Could just be my bias though. Evaluating frontier LLM's all seem to be by vibes. I think the industry is understanding it's both the harness and the model that makes the difference; can't half ass either, and some harnesses do better with different models. I'm good to leave this "career." Senior software engineers, make your bag.

  • DustinBrett 2 months ago

    Lot of people will to spend that much. Works quite well, very useful.

rippeltippel 2 months ago

I may be a rare Cursor user around here, but I am saddened by this news. The thing that keeps me using it is precisely the ability to switch between models: I usually do brainstorm/planning with Sol or Terra, then let Composer (free) deal with the implementation. For certain tasks I use Claude, which tends to be more expensive but sometimes saves me time.

Using both OpenAI and Anthropic models, Cursor is cheaper than having two separate subscriptions, and their free tier of Composer is good enough. I will now have to reconsider my options.

  • idrissbellil 2 months ago

    It's very easy to achieve that and more with: Crush (or Opencode) + OpenRouter right from the terminal. Takes a minute to setup.

    • mmastrac 2 months ago

      If you can explain how to make compaction not suck in opencode or Kilo Code, I would love to know how. I am really trying to make use of other harnesses but that's a major sticking point.

      • 9dev 2 months ago

        Never compact. Not automatically, not manually. Instead, let it write ledgers and checklists or handover prompt if necessary, and start fresh sessions as often as possible.

        • dannyw 2 months ago

          What do you do for long-running goals / tasks where you are not interactively prompting?

          • 9dev 2 months ago

            Create a design spec and implementation plan first. If necessary, split that in phases. Then create a ledger that always holds the current status, and instruct the model to update that after it completes a task in the plan, and to append any issues it encounters during the implementation.

            Then you can let it run, and when it stops, point a fresh session to the ledger to pick up the work from where the previous one left off.

            You can get more fancy by using something like GitHub issues for coordination too and have multiple sessions create issues and epics and others to work on that in isolated worktrees, but the spec-plan-ledger approach usually works great for small to medium large projects.

        • verdverm 2 months ago

          second this notion, fresh sessions and markdown are far superior to compaction, which has high likelihood of wrecking the context

  • kelvinjps10 2 months ago

    currenly I use pi with openrouter and is very nice I combine with a chatgpt sub that allows me to use it with pi. and when my usage runs out I turn to openrouter. Then same when I need anthropic models

  • _kidlike 2 months ago

    JetBrains is a good option - works with any model/agent. Also they have very good semantic search for the codebase, which is exposed via MCP to the agents.

    • dools 2 months ago

      Jetbrains Air is a great agentic coding harness

      • Koffiepoeder 2 months ago

        If only they would update it to work with their remote development kit... One can keep dreaming right :)

  • therealdrag0 2 months ago

    I like Cursor. Honestly the biggest reason is the decent WYSIWYG markdown editor.

    • yyhhsj0521 2 months ago

      Isn't the markdown editor in Cursor just vanilla VS code?

      • therealdrag0 2 months ago

        Nope. VS renders in a separate tab but is not editable. There are a million plugins, but some are still not good or look sketch.

  • cavoirom 2 months ago

    AmpCode is not popular here but I recommend it, give it I try and you will not go back, except the price may a bit expensive.

  • sourcecodeplz 2 months ago

    you can still bring your own OpenAI key into Cursor. that is not going to change.

  • koolala 2 months ago

    In Antigravity you can install Codex and use both. Not sure if the Claude extension can work too but probably.

bentt 2 months ago

While this isn't great for users it seems like a pretty standard circling of the wagons in preparation for the next phase in the battle for frontier AI dominance.

Ironically, as a Cursor and Claude subscriber, but not an OpenAI subscriber, this will push me back to Anthropic. I don't feel good about giving OpenAI money directly, but I've found switching to GPT 5.6 Sol now and again in Cursor to be useful. Now I'll probably just forget about OpenAI models.

  • reilly3000 2 months ago

    I think they are betting that Astra will be impossible to ignore.

    • SoftTalker 2 months ago

      For three months, until the next SOTA model drops. And with each improved model, the number of people who actually need it declines.

      • ronsor 2 months ago

        Exactly. Astra will likely get its Mythos moment, and then another Chinese lab releases its equivalent three months later while Anthropic releases a newer, better model.

        • dakolli 2 months ago

          There's a reason why most businesses don't hire PhDs, they dont need it. PhDs are cheap in many countries, arguably more affordable than a full time mythos lvl agent, yet businesses in India still don't hire 30k a year PhDs to run their businesses. Its simply not necessary. AI labs have lost the plot from a business perspective. If chasing ASI is the goal, that also seems stupid.. Putting all of your customers out of business with ASI doesn't really lead to great outcomes either.

          They're commodity fetishism maxxing.

          • Game_Ender 2 months ago

            The higher level models are designed to tackle bigger problems with less oversight and more accuracy. It’s about entirely changing how you use them to mirror an employee you can trust. A truly good team members everyone trusts to just get things done at high quality with minimal direction for days or weeks. That is the goal.

    • bentt 2 months ago

      I'd need to have a problem I couldn't solve with current models for my eyes to wander.

      • znnajdla 2 months ago

        Yeah I haven’t had a problem yet which was too difficult for Fable to solve. I do have problems which Sol does not do well on. But if I could get Fable-level intelligence faster/cheaper and less restricted, that’s all I need.

        • cheeze 2 months ago

          Fable is great minus it's annoying writing style. It's nowhere near as bad as Opus 5 but it's very "AI trope-y" even with heavy steering. I can spot the writing immediately.

      • akmarinov 2 months ago

        What if it’s cheaper too?

      • dakolli 2 months ago

        Yeah not sure why everyone thinks they need a PhD lvl assitant to build their slop SaaS when an open source model that is 100x cheaper, and 3x faster and arguably still "PhD" level assitant could also build their slop SaaS.

      • hand2note 2 months ago

        It like saying before the ai era that you don’t have a problem you can’t solve without ai

  • chr15m 2 months ago

    Why would you possibly allow companies to push you? You are the customer and you should control which models you use.

    • ezfe 2 months ago

      Because one is better or worse? What else do you think they meant?

      • chr15m 2 months ago

        OP said:

        > as a Cursor and Claude subscriber, but not an OpenAI subscriber, this will push me back to Anthropic

        Instead of deciding based on the merits of the model, they are being pushed by the actions of the companies. You should be able to use the best model, or whatever model you like, independently of what any company thinks or does.

        • lawrjone 2 months ago

          They are deciding on the merits of the model right? They’re picking the model that’s supported in most tools.

          I think maybe you’re suggesting private companies should be forced to support all models which is a position that isn’t technically feasible or one that most would agree is even a sensible ideal.

          • chr15m 2 months ago

            No, companies can do whatever they want. They shouldn't be forced to support all models.

            I'm suggesting you shouldn't let a company dictate which models you use. Putting yourself in a position where they can is detrimental, because you miss out on using the best model for the job.

  • ifwinterco 2 months ago

    It’s OpenAI (and Anthropic I’m sure) realising that they’ve somehow ended up stuck in the lowest margin part of the stack (providing inference), and trying to get out of it

  • DustinBrett 2 months ago

    Same, this will make me drop Sol from my options, not Cursor.

  • oh_no 2 months ago

    you dont like giving openai money but you're fine with spacex? not criticizing, just trying to understand.

    • bentt 2 months ago

      Honestly, I've been a Cursor subscriber for a while and it was just momentum. Still, I rank OpenAI as the worst actor among the big AI companies. I think OpenAI's playbook will be a repeat of Facebook. Users are the product x 1000.

      Cursor/SpaceX/Grok is a different beast. I think they will cheat other companies but I'm not convinced yet that they have it out for users. We'll see. I'm certainly not some kind of Cursor lifer or something.

      We should all move to OpenCode anyway. :)

      • PretzelPirate 2 months ago

        It's my personal view that Elon has already shown how little he cares for protecting data of individuals based on how he ran DOGE.

        If his teams will handle the data of US citizens with such disregard, he'll almost certainly treat his customers (many of whom are those same US citizens) the same.

        • bentt 2 months ago

          Sure, that's a thing. But it's much different than building a multiyear strategy to use that data as the financial basis of one's entire operation.

      • verdverm 2 months ago

        I'm not keen on OpenCode long term after seeing their CEO engage in antics and their discord being rather unprofessional, but it is a great harness for the time being, still has gaps though

      • ronsor 2 months ago

        I used to think OpenAI was the only bad actor until I realized they were the only honestly corporate actor.

        The other AI companies obfuscate their goals much better.

gexla 2 months ago

I don't see how it makes sense to use models outside of Grok or Composer in cursor unless you like the tooling to such degree that you're willing to pay out the nose for access to OpenAI and Anthropic to use with that tooling. And Codex is regularly scoring towards the top among harnesses, so you might as well use the best harness available for the given model. I'm happy with Grok and Composer in Cursor. If Cursor wants to add more models, they should host more open models.

  • herrvogel- 2 months ago

    Is there a good place for harness comparison/scoring?

    • reilly3000 2 months ago

      https://www.harness-bench.ai/leaderboard.html

      This provides a method, but the data looks stale and perhaps a bit thin compared to say, Cursor, or even AntiGravity data.

      • alainchabat 2 months ago

        never heard of nanobot. how reliable is this benchmark?

        • reilly3000 2 months ago

          I can’t speak to the veracity of the benchmarks but it appears their methodology is sound. Nanobot has 47k stars, fwiw https://github.com/HKUDS/nanobot

          It has been more of an OpenClaw or Hermes alternative than a coding agent like OpenCode or Pi, so it’s likely to do well given less context bloat.

        • cheeze 2 months ago

          IMO it's not. It's benchmarking GPT 5.4 and Opus 4.6. It's also missing Claude Code... one of the most popular harnesses (the most?)

  • chr15m 2 months ago

    The reason it makes sense is because different models are better at different things. Allowing yourself to be locked in to a particular model by these companies is a bad idea and will lead to worse outcomes for yourself and the market as a whole.

  • ryanjshaw 2 months ago

    Because I pay $60 per month and not using the included API tokens on other models is wasteful.

  • lawrjone 2 months ago

    You’d use it because until recently Cursor had the best setup for cloud agents and visual verification and a bunch of other features outside of the harness.

tanepiper 2 months ago

What a shame for Cursor. I found it a great tool - I actually liked Composer 2.5; but now being bought by SpaceX has for a while left a bad taste - and they keep pushing Grok and now GrokBot.

I took the 50% discount instead of cancelling - but with this I'll likely not renew.

So sad to watch them go from great to mediocre in such a short time.

  • tkel 2 months ago

    Perhaps now they'll release a 3.0 MechaHitler version

  • ctrlkctrls 2 months ago

    Didn't Kamprad have some pretty strong ties to the Nazi party? Yet you have a bad taste in your mouth because Cursor gets bought by SpaceX!

    Virtue signaling in glass houses...

    • tanepiper 2 months ago

      Sorry why are you mentioning Nazis? I didn't - I think the lady sockpuppet doth protest too much...

satvikpendem 2 months ago

If you have such a world changing technology, why sell an API when you can capture all the value yourself? That's what every provider is asking themselves.

Cursor will be fine after this, as they have their own first party models and can potentially use open weight models via API or their own hardware, which have gotten good enough to Opus and Fable quality now for many use cases.

  • CoolestBeans 2 months ago

    Being a pure play model provider is completely untenable right now. Coding agents own your demand; Nvidia, data centers, and DRAM manufacturers own your supply. You're getting squeezed by open weight models. Your only bet to making money off this thing is by locking your model down to your program to have some semblance of a moat. The fact that businesses can change providers with just the change of an API key is unsustainable. You have neither the "hard to switch" lock-in of a traditional software company nor do you have the near-zero marginal cost of production they have. Each token of inference costs you money, not to mention the training costs. At least locking the models down to your harness lets you get some sort of lock-in.

    • iamflimflam1 2 months ago

      Lots of enterprises don’t want to use OpenAI or Anthropic directly. They will go via AWS bedrock or google’s equivalent.

      The model providers are in a difficult position. With an added danger of open weight models that are within reach of large enterprises running themselves.

ergocoder 2 months ago

Cursor founder just tweeted that he was sad to see this ban and that OpenAI model represented around 5% of total usage.

Burn.

  • fsh 2 months ago

    That's probably a lot more than their market share versus Claude Code and Codex.

  • ralph84 2 months ago

    5% of traffic. OpenAI models are a much higher percentage of revenue.

  • cactusplant7374 2 months ago

    Codex has 20+ million users. They are doing much better than Cursor.

  • dbbk 2 months ago

    Not really a surprise given their own models are the default option? Most people wouldn't change model. And if you want to use Claude or GPT you don't really have a reason to use Cursor over Claude Code or Codex

  • ncr100 2 months ago

    Is this spite?

zxspectrum1982 2 months ago

I use Cursor at work and love it. It's a great IDE, the best IMHO. But it becomes really expensive.

Since the introduction of the Cursor Token Rate, my company tells us to use Claude and Codex directly with Anthropic (or Vertex AI) and OpenAI, respectively.

https://cursor.com/docs/models-and-pricing#cursor-token-rate

I'm now using Grok 4.6 most of the time. Sonnet some times. But that's it. Cursor-native models 99% of the time. I'm pretty sure Anthropic will follow OpenAI soon in pulling their models out of Cursor because it's now a true competitor.

  • DefineOutside 2 months ago

    It's insane that Cursor charges 25 extra cents per million tokens on a model that charges 2 cents per million cached tokens. Basically everyone is forced to use Cursor's own models at this point as otherwise the costs are simply too high.

ananmays 2 months ago

> As AI capabilities advance, we also have a new level of accountability to ensure our upcoming model, Astra, is being used in accordance with our terms.

I think Sam Altman has played a clever business move here, they can use this excuse immediately after the Hugging Face leaks and it's not going to be dismissed willy-nilly. Whereas long term they probably wanted to end their partnership with Cursor anyway. I bet Dario will be happy about this too, but maybe the compute deal prevents him from doing similar anytime soon.

Very interesting times we live in...

  • semiquaver 2 months ago

    Is it really an excuse? As the release points out, musk admitted under oath to distilling OpenAI’s models to produce xai models on an ongoing basis. Whatever you think about goose for the gander wrt IP theft, I wouldn’t voluntarily do business with a competitor who was actively and brazenly flouting my terms, would you?

    • userbinator 2 months ago

      It's amusingly ironic to talk about "IP theft" in the context of AI models.

      • semiquaver 2 months ago

        Shorthand. I agree it’s hypocritical and theft isn’t the right word, but we make do with the words we have.

    • aeternum 2 months ago

      OpenAI's models are distilled from your HN posts

      • semiquaver 2 months ago

        Quite sure I covered that aspect, thanks.

        • aeternum 2 months ago

          You didn't, but now it has been covered.

hargup 2 months ago

Bummed, but I guess for me, doesn't mean cursor subscription ending though. Grok is a pretty amazing model for the speed and price on Cursor.

  • hackernud3s 2 months ago

    Does Grok have a subscription that competes with Claude Max $100 plan (genuinely curious)

    • maipen 2 months ago

      Yes it does. You can either subscribe to grok directly or cursor. You have many tiers and all of them have generous usage.

      Grok is a workhorse, not the smartest yet, but produces good code and follows the plan. Grok 5, which has been training since beginnig of this year, will probably be a monster. (10T/6T Param model variants)

    • Jcampuzano2 2 months ago

      Yes, any Cursor sub includes a separate tier of usage for Cursor/SpaceX first party models separate from usage of third party models.

      I have a $20 Cursor sub still personally and would say that the usage for Grok models is much higher than what $20 gets you with Anthropic. I can't speak for the $100 plan but I would assume it scales similarly.

      I rarely run out of my usage monthly even with the $20 plan.

      • mgcross 2 months ago

        I'm on the $20 plan too and the only time I run over is if I'm using Opus (or probably other third-party models). Grok and Composer seem nearly free at this point. Cursor also gave me a $100 credit for Grok after 81% of my usage was on TP models. I don't think Grok 4.6 is quite at the level of Opus 5, but it's close and so much faster (and less chatty).

    • thefourthchime 2 months ago

      It's a little confusing because Grok and Cursor kinda live in different worlds. Grok has SuperGrok and SuperGrok Heavy ($300 a month!)

      The best bet is Cursor Ultra ($200), which is the equivalent a month plan that you get from OpenAI and Anthropic. I get a LOT more capacity out of it because I almost always use the "Auto" mode, which auto picks between Opus 5, GPT 5.6, Grok 4.6, and Composer 2.5.

      I like Auto mode so much actually. I use it for my Cursor work account as well because it's about 10x faster than just using Opus 5 or GPT 5.6 and about 90% is good. I switch back to the bigger models if I get in trouble, but that's pretty rare.

      Vibe coding requires some discipline. You need understand what it's trying to do. If you have a good mental model you can keep it out of trouble. If you don't, it doesn't matter how good the model is. You're gonna end up in a mess.

wodenokoto 2 months ago

> we are giving the maximum notice provided by our contract.

Anyone else surprised that the maximum notice period allowed is about 3 months?

I would have thought 3 months is minimum notice period, with provisions to stop faster if any provable violation occurs.

  • elil17 2 months ago

    It makes no sense that a contract would even provide a maximum notice period. Why would parties put that in? What benefit would either derive from restricting themselves to not getting earlier notice.

    • aroman 2 months ago

      I read it as: we acted as quickly as we could once it became possible to do so, i.e., the change in control was completed. not that their special agreement carved out some maximum notice term.

  • Kubuxu 2 months ago

    From the article, it seems they using a clause allowing them to terminate the contract after transfer of ownership.

    This clause probably has a expiry date and they are saying “we are trying not to be jerks here by waiting until the last second to trigger it”.

  • hn1986 2 months ago

    3 months is a long time in AI world

GMoromisato 2 months ago

Everyone is playing hardball. No one wants to be IBM in an IBM-Microsoft dance.

But this is kind of like banning GPU exports to China. It will encourage them to develop their own technology. Yes, it will take them longer, but in the long-run China will be more successful with their own GPU tech.

The same could be true of SpaceX/xAI

  • johnnyApplePRNG 2 months ago

    LOL

    You had me until:

    >The same could be true of a company run by a drug addict.

    Elon Musk is nowhere near as capable as millions of intelligent developers in China.

    • inigyou 2 months ago

      He doesn't have to be. He just has to hire millions of intelligent developers in China.

      • johnnyApplePRNG 2 months ago

        Except legally and structurally, he can't:

        ITAR: SpaceX is strictly barred by US federal law from hiring non-US persons for aerospace engineering.

        National Security Scrutiny: xAI operates under increasing US export and tech-transfer controls regarding China.

        Scale: A private company's recruiting budget cannot compete with the sovereign industrial capacity and state-backed talent pipeline of an entire nation.

  • angusturner 2 months ago

    What unique differentiator could musk possibly offer though?

    Is there really a high demand for racist chatbots with no safety controls?

    And even if there is, will governments even allow it to keep operating?

  • clarkqaq 2 months ago

    So now you know why Trump is called "川建国 (Chuan Jianguo)" in China — literally "Trump who builds China" — because he really is building China and making it better (just kidding).

closetheloopdev 2 months ago

> As AI capabilities advance, we also have a new level of accountability to ensure our upcoming model, Astra, is being used in accordance with our terms.

This move seems to protect Astra against distillation. I wonder whether Astra will be released before or after 11/12.

  • mattnewton 2 months ago

    Before, but they say that they’re also not going to provide astra to cursor subscribers

pinkmuffinere 2 months ago

> We know that the people most affected by this decision are the developers who rely on OpenAI models in Cursor. We care about their experience in this transition and we’re ready to go above and beyond to support them.

Do I smell a cursor-analogue from openAI?

mcintyre1994 2 months ago

This seems like a no brainer, not sure how Cursor would expect to be trusted by any other company now that they’re owned by SpaceX.

  • whamlastxmas 2 months ago

    I trust them more than someone who took a nonprofit designed to be open and had tens of millions in donations to do just that, and then turned into a for profit who's cuddled up tight with Microsoft and is so closed they're preemptively ending contracts with someone under pretty flimsy accusations. And doubly funny it's the person who's responsible for them even existing. And from whom they stole tens of millions

  • thefourthchime 2 months ago

    I really get sick of this anti-Elon rhetoric around here. Can we not keep it to technical merits and not get sucked up into politics? The guy's clearly nuts, but he's also done an incredible amount of amazing things.

    • Anamon 2 months ago

      This isn't a technical article, though. It's about contracts, so one party's self-admitted habit of ignoring contractual obligations seems very relevant and not a random ad hominem.

habosa 2 months ago

Does anyone have any recommendations for something like Cursor but more open? Cursor's harness is so much faster than anything else I've used that I just can't give it up, using Claude Code feels like being on 0.25x speed. Also I do like the IDE-style UI, being able to highlight code in a file editor and then quickly add that to my chat (Cmd-L) is really nice and much more difficult in CLI based harnesses.

Right now I think GPT 5.6 Luna is by far the most cost effective model, so this change is effectively kicking me off of Cursor.

  • s4i 2 months ago

    This, and the keep/undo flow, forking agent sessions (including renaming them)... The UX could be better at places but the core features of what Cursor has (for someone who came from VS Code) is an unbeatable mix. Really would like to find something else.

    I did try Kiro which seems to have the same philosophy but it's just not there. Most of the features I like in Cursor are missing.

    Some other commenters mentioned that VS Code + Copilot would be better these days. Dunno.

    • beckhamc 2 months ago

      I am also wondering the same thing as OP. Somewhat tangential thought, but I recently realised that what I would really love in an IDE is a "first class" Markdown editing experience, just because most of my day-to-day is managing and writing docs rather than editing code. Cursor has Markdown rendering support of course but it seems to have two implementations, each sort of clunky in their own way. And I want something more WYSIWYG but with Latex / flowchart / etc. support built-in.

      OpenKnowledge seems to maybe fill that niche somewhat (it also supports annotating Markdown with comments to feed into an agent), and has agent integration within the GUI, but one killer feature that seems to be missing is Remote SSH support (short of hosting its web server on the remote and having the IDE live in the browser).

benatkin 2 months ago

It's going to be tough for Origin, their code hosting platform, to follow in the footsteps of GitHub, if they can't be treated as a neutral party.

Jcampuzano2 2 months ago

It was honestly just a matter of time, given all of the bad blood there is between Sam and Elon and Elon basically admitting under oath they were distilling other companies models.

I wonder if Anthropic will follow suit given their campaign against distillation or if they'll stay quiet given their reliance on SpaceX (among others) for hardware.

darepublic 2 months ago

I'm not impressed with cursor and it's decidedly not worth 1 mil in terms of its engineering. Perhaps it's user base and their loyalty makes up the vast majority of its evaluation. But to me it's ridiculous that a dev would use cursor or think that it's indispensable to them

Philpax 2 months ago

Honestly, can't say I miss my Cursor subscription at all, and I'm surprised they're still a going concern. Why would I want to use a proprietary VSCode fork with an identity crisis when I can use literally any editor with any agent and have about the same experience?

  • disgruntledphd2 2 months ago

    The integrated review UI is super helpful, but apparently nobody reviews code anymore except me.

    • dexterlagan 2 months ago

      I use Claude Code (both Desktop and CLI) all day every day (as well as OpenCode with DeepSeek V4 among others). For non-mission-critical stuff (small internal tools, anything that doesn't touch the client and doesn't handle critical data or infra), I'm on Auto (sandboxed in the working directory). For everything else I approve every change, meaning I review every code change the model proposes. Plan mode is great to write the architecture as well, as it doesn't touch any file, doesn't write anything, and lets me iterate until the arch is perfect and the proposed high-level code (modules etc) is solid. I haven't used an editor in over 4 years, apart from writing specs.

  • jeeeb 2 months ago

    We have a subscription at work. They have a CLI agent that works pretty well. Lately I mostly use it with grok, which is actually quite a capable model.

  • thefourthchime 2 months ago

    Cursor Cloud Agents are pretty great, as is Grok Bot which comes with the sub

nunez 2 months ago

Damn; Cursor has basically no value if Anthropic pulls the same move. Twitter Part 2 indeed.

  • arcanemachiner 2 months ago

    Anthropic rents a lot of capacity from xAI, so I don't think they're in a position to do the same.

    • shye 2 months ago

      Anthropic already stopped selling use of their models to xAI when they suspect foul play there.

  • throw03172019 2 months ago

    I’d be canceling for sure Grok is a huge joke and consistently destroys my Clojure files.

  • hirako2000 2 months ago

    How so? A dozen very capable models out there. And the gap between frontier models from the two main US labs kept narrowing, at this point non existent.

    The quality/price ratio is clearly superior when running Qwen, GLM, or Deepseek.

    To make a product more exclusive won't hide the fact that product is becoming more and more irrelevant.

    • andy_ppp 2 months ago

      Most people do not enjoy the output of the open models or know where their code is being sent so I’m out. Also I don’t trust Elon anyway, I’m just going to make a VS Code Extension that handles things how I want but I’d like to offer the same deals Cursor got for tokens with OpenAI and Anthropic, for me this was the key 1/4 token cost!

dgrin91 2 months ago

Not surprised, but honestly I don't feel like this is a huge loss for cursor. Models are so commoditized, and 99% of users don't need particularly fancy models. Between existing anthropic models, composer-2, honestly even grok models, and also the fact that many people just use 'auto' mode, I feel like many won't feel the impact for OpenAI's withdrawal.

Maybe if Claude joined along it would be more impactful. For better or worse though, Xai seems like its lining themselves up to handle being on their own for cursor.

  • thefourthchime 2 months ago

    Agree, I use Auto 90% of the time. I doubt I'll tell the difference.

sajithdilshan 2 months ago

I think there is still a huge market for models that are specialised in software development (system design, infrastructure, coding, etc.).

If a company can provide the access to such a model via AWS Bedrock or similar enterprise compliant platform with a decent IDE/harness they can capture billions of dollars of market.

The closest we have to this is Claude Code but I think it can even be better and specialised. Cursor has an enormous amount of data on coding and developer usage and maybe they should use that to build a proper platform

docmars 2 months ago

I guess they don't like money, because Cursor is really good and offers a variety of models. What a shame they're being so petty about this.

jimnotgym 2 months ago

Can I suppose that Cursor, by seeing everyones prompts and all of the responses from the models, are in a position to sort of MITM distill them?

  • pnt12 2 months ago

    Yes, and given it's now owned by Elon Musk, who is not trustworthy, it's possible he would try to do it.

    Although I wouldn't take an Openai announcement literally, as Sam Altman is also not trustworthy.

  • maipen 2 months ago

    Unless you run your models and harness completely locally, you can't verify your data isn't being used.

    All of these companies, and I truly mean all, stole data to train their models.

  • paxys 2 months ago

    Musk was forced to admit under oath during his OpenAI lawsuit that xAI distilled GPT models to train Grok. No reason to believe he won't use Cursor data for the same thing, if it isn't happening already.

twobitshifter 2 months ago

In a sane world would this be a potential antitrust case as they are a direct competitor to Codex?

How can you ban a competitor from using a model that you openly provide access to?

I understand that the OpenAI ToS may have been violated by X, but has anyone ruled on distillation as fair use? OpenAI believes distillation of nonAI produced content is fair use, so they don’t appear to have a leg to stand on.

  • verdverm 2 months ago

    In a sane world, one should be able to choose not to do business with a company for any reason

    there are plenty of alternatives, 100s, so I don't think antitrust is on the table, think of this more like a boycott of the world's richest man for being a twat

    • richard___ 2 months ago

      you are projecting

      • verdverm 2 months ago

        you dont know me, so I don't know on what basis you make this claim, boycotting Elon and his companies is a real thing people do for ethical reasons, see Tesla sales as a data point

  • paxys 2 months ago

    "You are not allowed to use our services to develop a competing product" is a standard clause in pretty much every contract of this nature. There's nothing antitrust about it. Companies are allowed to say no to bad deals.

saos 2 months ago

They were going to do this regardless of SpaceX.

akmarinov 2 months ago

This low key confirms Astra for November

bix6 2 months ago

Why would they give the maximum time instead of the minimum given violation has already occurred?

  • riffraff 2 months ago

    Because it doesn't matter anymore for current models and they want to show goodwill, probably.

woggy 2 months ago

Why maximum notice? Why not minimum notice? Elon doesn't deserve more than that.

  • iamflimflam1 2 months ago

    They need time to build a cursor equivalent.

  • gverrilla 2 months ago

    I agree Elon deserved that, but there are users involved too.

AnonHP 2 months ago

My guess is that OpenAI now has a full blown Cursor equivalent in development (an expansion of Codex?) and will announce it in September. Otherwise it stands to lose those who are used to working with Cursor.

  • wheelhead 2 months ago

    Yeah, the "go above and beyond for our users" implies they have a "better" version of Cursor coming. Probably integrating their new chip/microphone based product.

  • tomr75 2 months ago

    codex is already great.. cursor is just a competing harness

    codex growth at 20mill now, prob more cost effective to allocate that compute to people directly paying now

iJohnDoe 2 months ago

I guess I’m on the right track.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49428835

If Claude pulls away from Cursor as well then Cursor is basically done.

  • dumbmrblah 2 months ago

    Grok? Google?

    I'm not a fan of Elon, nor do I use Cursor, but OpenAI and Anthropic aren't the only models.

  • ralusek 2 months ago

    Cursor is like one of the least economical ways to use Claude and OpenAI, virtually nobody does it. You use Cursor for their autocomplete/composer + grok. For using Claude and Codex, you get immeasurably more bang for your buck just using them directly.

  • brightball 2 months ago

    I've been using Cursor with Grok 4.6 a lot over the last week or so. Grok Build as well. Both options are performing very well for me.

    • therealdrag0 2 months ago

      Ya I was slow to try Grok but I’m now happy with it.

  • iJohnDoe 2 months ago

    All good points. However, it's not a safe assumption that everyone operates that way. People probably use the flagship models because that's what they know. Sure, some probably just use the default, in this case Grok.

    Also, it's a signal more than anything. OpenAI pulls out of Cursor. Then Anthropic and Google does as well. Then you no longer have "Cursor" you have Grok.

    Grok doesn't have the best reputation in general, regardless if you're tech savvy or not.

bobby_coder_55 2 months ago

Great. Sam Altman sold us all out to venture capital. So I won’t be using ChatGPT anymore. Also, I noticed that ChatGPT lies more than any other AI of all the ones I’ve tested.

zyralab 2 months ago

Kinda crazy how fast things can change after an acquisition

If your coding tool depends on other companies’ AI models, one business decision can suddenly change the whole product

robeym 2 months ago

I think the entire purpose of the acquisition was just to buy a chunk of the market for their own models. Curious to see if Musk responds.

armcat 2 months ago

Does this also apply to API endpoints, let’s say if you want to provide API keys in Cursor to Azure or Bedrock deployment of a GPT model?

  • post-it 2 months ago

    I can't imagine it would.

throwaw12 2 months ago

Something deep inside me is saying this is good for us, because Cursor will try harder to train better coding models to stay afloat.

swader999 2 months ago

Can't cursor just use open router? This might backfire on them and push more money to second tier good enough models.

demibabs 2 months ago

Wow, I don’t use cursor but that seems pretty bad for them.

Is there a way to work around this (like using your OpenAI limits directly?)

  • charrondev 2 months ago

    I used cursor extensively both at work and for personal use. Its harness is pretty darn good but I basically never used OpenAI models in it.

    The first party cursor models (initially composer and now grok-cursor) and price very competitively for their quality and have very generous usage limits included in the base plans, and then per token pricing afterwards.

    Occasionally I’ve used some of the Anthropic models in it but found their cost massively outweighed the benefits for the type of usage we do.

    I was using Sonnet 4.5 and 4.6 for a while but the newer models are a lot more expensive at the per-token pricing.

  • auscompgeek 2 months ago

    Cursor does currently allow users to BYO OpenAI token. Given Cursor won't have access to OpenAI models for prompt engineering/evals though, there's definitely a question of whether they'd allow picking any new OpenAI models, assuming the BYOK option continues to exist at all.

    • Maxious 2 months ago

      Email to customers now "We’re speaking with the OpenAI team to resolve this, and we will share more in the coming weeks around continuity of access to OpenAI models. We’ll continue to offer ways to access all models in Cursor.

  • ralusek 2 months ago

    It's basically not going to affect them at all. I don't know a single person that uses OpenAI models via Cursor. Saw another comment say it was 5%.

    • hirako2000 2 months ago

      All it shows is that openai is likely still subsidizing inference, sees no value in integration buried within other branded tooling competing with theirs.

    • therealdrag0 2 months ago

      I used mostly OpenAI for the last like 6 months in cursor. I got tired of how slow Claude models are and switched. I’m surprised usage is so low. Wonder why.

      • npn 2 months ago

        Because you can also use grok and a dozen other models. In fact grok is preferred choice for cursor right now, so obviously the other models get sidelined

      • ralusek 2 months ago

        I didn't mean people aren't using OpenAI, I just mean not through Cursor.

        Using OpenAI through codex (cli) is the way you should use it.

    • ncr100 2 months ago

      Unless those 5% are 500% more productive than the 95%

  • maipen 2 months ago

    According to Cursor CEO, it only accounts for 5% usage of cursor, so it's not a big deal at all

matthewsjess 2 months ago

Call me old-fashioned. I'd rather have copyright law enforcement than terms of service. A girl can dream.

daemon_9009 2 months ago

It's just the beef between musk and Altman, nothing to do with the models.

dozerly 2 months ago

Any tool that tightly couples you to an inference provider is a sub-par tool and destined to be forgotten.

formvoltron 2 months ago

Good! I don't consider myself a Nazi and so I'm happy a big, influential tech company refuses to business with a man who does the Nazi salute on television.

thoughtpeddler 2 months ago

Spend a lot of time thinking about why individuals shouldn't trust large AI cos, now it's interesting getting to think about how the AI companies themselves don't trust each other. Capitalism is viciously cold and uncaring.

  • gnarlouse 2 months ago

    At least capitalism isn't at the center of the most impactful technological revolution in human history.

    • blackqueeriroh 2 months ago

      Yeah, that’s mostly been driven by socialism

    • thoughtpeddler 2 months ago

      Not sure the larger point you're trying to make (maybe we're on the same page?), but it's a fact that AI has come from heavy long-term investments by the academic and public sectors, yet private companies are accruing most of the gains

      • atmosx 2 months ago

        The iPhone too, etc. These ppl, who think Capitalism as a religion in a couple of years will be singing another tune with the same reassurances.

        The movie Goya’s Ghost explains this in great detail.

  • fhn 2 months ago

    show me a communist country

    • timmmmmmay 2 months ago

      back when the USSR was still a going concern, there were zero American leftists claiming that it wasn't really communist. that only started happening after they failed

      • inigyou 2 months ago

        did they even have the internet back then? how much did people know about other countries?

zoobab 2 months ago

So much for 'open'.

varispeed 2 months ago

Why nobody vibe coded Cursor yet? It's a basic extension of VS Code.

chr15m 2 months ago

Allowing the company or harness to dictate which models you use is crazy.

daft_pink 2 months ago

makes sense. cursor is a real competitor to openai. we're completely switching to grok bot at work after going from claude code >> codex >> grok bot.

fy20 2 months ago

At my dayjob we are big users of Cursor's Cloud Agents. We use them to trigger automated investigations customer support issues, alarms, feature requests etc. The Cursor editor is fairly meh in comparison, but this has become a big part of our workflow. And having anyone on our team manage them. What competing products are there we should try?

  • dregitsky 2 months ago

    Devin Automations is the most obvious one: solid UX, but can get very expensive to run.

    There are also a bunch of newer startups in this space. I'm building one myself, https://boxes.dev -- we're very early but building for this exact use case. Some other ones worth a look are Factory Droid and Amp Orbs. Those two build their own agent harness (like Cursor), whereas with boxes.dev we run the native codex and claude code harnesses directly.

est 2 months ago

Models are now having much tighter integration with harness.

It's gunna to happen anyway.

We are sailing into the age of vertically integrated intelligence.

noodletheworld 2 months ago

Days until cursor announces open models… 3, 2, 1…

Seriously though, when the api providers start blacklisting cursor and they’re forced to swap to open weight models…

If that happens, what even is the difference between openrouter and cursor?

  • skeledrew 2 months ago

    Well, one has a pretty popular harness.

  • alberth 2 months ago

    You assume OpenAI doesn’t turn off access to OpenRouter too.

    Strategically, OpenAI long-term will want to own the direct relationship with all their customers. As will most major AI labs.

skeledrew 2 months ago

> We are making this choice because we cannot be confident that SpaceX will use our technology within our terms of service, based on our experience with Elon Musk's companies violating contracts.

> After Musk acquired Twitter, now part of SpaceX, the company broke (opens in a new window) the terms of our contract (alongside many others).

I have never seen one large company throw another large company under the bus without any legalese filters like this before. Wondering if OpenAI site got pwned. Or maybe we in some strange, alternative reality. I doubt even their LLMs would be this frank.

Palmik 2 months ago

Elon Musk openly admitted to distilling OpenAI's models [1], which I think explains the "based on our experience with Elon Musk's companies violating contracts".

Last year, Anthropic cut off Windsurf the same way [2]. Fortunately, unlike Anthropic, OpenAI allows you to use your subscription with other harnesses, including Cursor.

Of course today, Anthropic is taking the "high road" and is OK with with SpaceX [3] including their models in Cursor, because they need SpaceX's compute.

[1] https://www.forbes.com/sites/antoniopequenoiv/2026/04/30/elo...

[2] https://techcrunch.com/2025/06/03/windsurf-says-anthropic-is...

[3] https://x.com/NotTomBrown/status/2093541294027280657

  • elil17 2 months ago

    More generally, Musk admittedly works with a "move fast and break things" mentality. His companies have repeatedly broken environmental laws, labor laws, and securities laws. His companies often fail to deliver the features they promise and routinely miss deadlines they've committed to. They routinely violate contracts that they have agreed to.

    Not doing business with them is a completely normal and unremarkable decision.

__initbrian__ 2 months ago

they’ll see an uptick in codex user count trying the new models and can build a narrative around that too

Y0s 2 months ago

So Astra release Friday 13th November!?

  • Jcampuzano2 2 months ago

    The way I read the article was that they will continue providing their current models, but won't let them use any newer ones announced even between now and the end date. But I might be wrong.

    > we’ve decided to hold the contract cancellation to the latest date we can while not providing future models to Cursor.

vachina 2 months ago

Auto and Grok is pretty good. As a casual user OpenAI models are expensive for the marginal (or none if at all) step up in performance.

moomoo11 2 months ago

i don't see the point of cursor when vsc + codex extension does the same thing. i don't use autocomplete anymore (who writes code anymore? lol) any and anyone using grok unironically is also probably a moron.

i only tell VC type people or others from whom i want something "oh yeah grok is cool" if they mention it, because they're always sucking off Elon

bryanhogan 2 months ago

> We are making this choice because we cannot be confident that SpaceX will use our technology within our terms of service, based on our experience with Elon Musk's companies violating contracts.

I'm surprised how clear they are about this.

Related:

Can highly recommend Zed as an alternative, it's better than VSCode with the Codex extension as managing multiple chats is much nicer in Zed.

Zed: https://zed.dev/

sidcool 2 months ago

This is personal, not business.

dools 2 months ago

When I was bringing up IDEs at work and advocating JetBrains (I’ve since built my own … ) a colleague questioned why we don’t just use cursor instead of waiting for JetBrains Air to come out.

The products are basically equivalent but JetBrains is a profitable bootstrapped company that has been building IDEs for 20 years and Cursor is a flash in the pan startup with a squillion dollar valuation to support. Sooner or later they’re going to do something that will fuck their users over.

And selling to SpaceX was it!

charcircuit 2 months ago

What happened to researchers embracing the open research culture of improving on the results of others?

simontlbt 2 months ago

OpenAI / Sam Altman is probably even shadier than musk

  • s1n_ 2 months ago

    “Satan is probably even shadier than Beelzebub”

  • DarmokTanagra 2 months ago

    No love for Sama, but Musk is bond villain levels of shady.

    The man is an outright existential threat to democracy.

shevy-java 2 months ago

The billionaires buy up key technology now. I don't like this.

neya 2 months ago
    We are making this choice because we cannot be confident that SpaceX will use our technology within our terms of service, based on our experience with Elon Musk's companies violating contracts.


The pot calling the kettle black. Look who's talking. A company that trained it's models illegally on so many copyrighted materials without compensating anyone involved.

For a company named "Open" AI, they've been hardly open at all and the slew of resignations of top tier execs in the company is really the proof.

Make no mistake, this isn't a moral decision. This is just killing the competition using morality as an excuse.

  • armcat 2 months ago

    Codex cli is open source rust project (Claude Code is not). Whisper is an open weight ASR/STT model. GPT-OSS is an open weight LLM that can run locally and is still very capable. CLIP is an open source model used for image encoding. Just some of the open contributions from OpenAI

    • neya 2 months ago

      All these were released way late for a company called "Open" AI. But go on, keep defending the billion dollar corporation.

  • inigyou 2 months ago

    Correct. It's killing the competition. Which is what you should do if you want to run a successful business.

    • neya 2 months ago

      Then don't be pretentious and frame it as a morality statement. Just call it what it is.

      • inigyou 2 months ago

        Framing your competition killing as morality is also something you should do to be successful.

        • neya 2 months ago

          Only if you're a terrible person with poor ethics. This isn't how great companies operate. That's just deception.

chrisrickard 2 months ago

damn... cursor doesn't get as much love as claude code or codex (on here anyways), but honestly, it's gotten amazing in the last 6 months.

i loved switching between sol / fable / grok 4.5.

... and something tells me fable might not be available on cursor for much longer :/

  • simondotau 2 months ago

    Try kimi k3, for code review at least. I think it’s significantly better than Sol and Anthropic for analysis, if you care about your code.

qaq 2 months ago

I mean, given Sam and Elon’s relationship, I don’t think anyone is surprised.

tonyhart7 2 months ago

pot calling kettle black

ChannelFence 2 months ago

this is a pretty clean test of whether people were buying cursor or just using it for convenient access to whichever model was flavor of the week.

i work in qa so i'm naturally wary of adding another critical dependency to a development workflow, if the model you actually want can just disappear because two vendor change ownership or start argueing then the wrapper has to be really good on its own.

cursors harness and its own models may be good enough that users stay, and if they do cursor has a moat at least. if everyone follows the openai models out the door, it will just become a polished ui.

  • pianopatrick 2 months ago

    I use Cursor because I listened to YouTube interviews with the teams behind most of these products and I trusted their team the most.

    • iamleppert 2 months ago

      How TF do you trust people you don’t know from YouTube interviews? You don’t know them. They are strangers to you trying to sell you something.

      • pianopatrick 2 months ago

        Yeah, well that's the same as all the other AI companies isn't it

quicklywilliam 2 months ago

I think it’s important not to let AI companies control the framing here. This is anti-competitive behavior, plain and simple. The fact that xAI/Musk routinely break the law simply provides the fig leaf.

Distillation is a threat to frontier model companies, but that doesn’t make it dangerous or wrong. OpenAI can (and likely will) use the same logic to ban you from using open source harnesses.

  • lovich 2 months ago

    I’m on team fuck both of these organizations, but not continuing to work with an organization that already willing violated contracts you had with them doesn’t exactly seem like a hard to justify decision.

    That is to say, this isn’t a fig leaf imo.